Zechariah Chapter 11 Read as one passage

Zechariah 11:7–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

7So I pastured the flock marked for slaughter, especially the afflicted of the flock. Then I took for myself two staffs, calling one Favor and the other Union, and I pastured the flock. 8And in one month I dismissed three shepherds. My soul grew impatient with the flock, and their souls also detested me. 9Then I said, “I will no longer shepherd you. Let the dying die, and the perishing perish; and let those who remain devour one another’s flesh.” 10Next I took my staff called Favor and cut it in two, revoking the covenant I had made with all the nations. 11It was revoked on that day, and so the afflicted of the flock who were watching me knew that it was the word of the LORD.

What the first hearers heard

To Judeans living under foreign rule and through local leaders, this verse showed what God's shepherding should look like. Someone finally takes charge of the flock that everyone else is exploiting, especially its weakest members. He brings two gifts, named so no one can miss them: Favor, God's gracious protection holding back the nations around them, and Binders, the unity that keeps God's people one family.

But the verse sits inside a story the audience heard to the end. Within a month the shepherd grows impatient with the flock and they come to detest him (v.8). He breaks Favor (v.10), is paid off with a contemptuous thirty pieces of silver (vv.12–13), and breaks Binders (v.14). Then God raises up a "worthless shepherd" (vv.15–17). So the passage worked as a warning and an indictment. The people's suffering is not because God offered no good shepherd. When one was offered, the flock and its dealers rejected him, and the protection and unity he brought were taken away. For hearers steeped in Ezekiel 34 and 37, it showed that hopes of restoration under one shepherd were real but could be lost through faithlessness.

From the study of Zechariah 11:7.

Verse by verse

  1. 7So I pastured the flock marked for slaughter, especially the afflicted of the flock. Then I took for myself two staffs, calling one Favor and the other Union, and I pastured the flock.

    "So I took up the shepherd's work over the flock destined for the butcher, and so, the most downtrodden sheep of that flock [or, following the ancient Greek: for the sheep-dealers]. I took two shepherd's sticks for myself. One I named Favor, the kindness and goodwill that make life sweet. The other I named Binders, the cords that tie the flock together as one. And I shepherded the flock."

    The prophet is carrying out a command (v.4): to act as ruler-shepherd over a people whose buyers treat them as meat and whose own shepherds have no pity on them (v.5). The verse opens and closes with the same verb, I shepherded, so the act is real and complete: he did the job. The two staffs are signs. Their names spell out what a good shepherd gives a flock: God's gracious protection, here guarding them from the surrounding nations (v.10), and a unity that binds Judah and Israel together as brothers (v.14). Hearers who knew Ezekiel 37 would remember two sticks joined into one as a promise of restored unity. In Zechariah the named staffs are introduced only to be broken a few verses later, when the flock rejects its shepherd and he rejects them (vv.8–14). The calm, orderly verse is the quiet before that breach.

    Full study →
  2. 8And in one month I dismissed three shepherds. My soul grew impatient with the flock, and their souls also detested me.

    In one single month I wiped out the three shepherds, the known leaders who had been feeding on the flock instead of feeding it. "Wiped out" is the word used when God blots out nations; it means more than removing them from office. But the trouble did not end with the leaders. My patience with them ran out. Literally, "my self became short with them": the endurance that had kept me caring for this doomed flock was used up. "Them" could be the shepherds, but it most naturally means the flock I am about to address. And the feeling ran both ways: they, for their part, were sick of me. Their whole selves recoiled from me in disgust.

    The verse is the hinge of the prophet's acted-out parable. He has taken up the shepherd's job for a "flock marked for slaughter" (v.7). He clears away its bad leaders quickly, yet the flock does not welcome him; it loathes him. One person's exhausted patience meets the other side's revulsion, and the shepherding relationship collapses. The next verse follows directly: "I will no longer shepherd you."

    Full study →
  3. 9Then I said, “I will no longer shepherd you. Let the dying die, and the perishing perish; and let those who remain devour one another’s flesh.”

    The prophet has been playing the part of a shepherd. God appointed him over a flock already marked for slaughter (v. 4), and he got rid of the bad shepherds who were exploiting it (v. 8). Now he and the flock have come to loathe each other, and he quits: "I will not shepherd you any longer." To shepherd meant more than giving out food. It meant leading the flock, guarding it from wolves, searching for strays, nursing the sick. In Israel and its neighbours it was also the standard picture of a king ruling his people. Then he names the sheep a good shepherd would have saved, and leaves each one to its fate. "The one that is dying — let it die. The one that is going missing, vanishing — let it vanish." Each verb is said twice, which makes the words sound like a sentence being passed: what is failing is left to finish failing. The word for 'vanishing' is the same one he used a verse earlier for wiping out the three bad shepherds. The fate he gave the corrupt leaders now falls on the flock he leaves behind. "And the ones left over — let them eat, each one the flesh of her companion." The sheep are female in the Hebrew ('each ewe... her fellow'). The survivors, whom the prophets usually hoped would be God's restored remnant, become meat-eaters and turn on their own companions. The picture is unnatural on purpose. It recalls the darkest covenant curse, people eating human flesh in a siege, and it also suggests a community destroying itself from within. The verbs can be read as a decree ('let them') or as a prediction ('they will'). In either case the point is the same: once the shepherd withdraws, death, loss and self-destruction follow on their own.

    Full study →
  4. 10Next I took my staff called Favor and cut it in two, revoking the covenant I had made with all the nations.

    "Then I took my shepherd's staff, the one I had named Graciousness, and hacked it through, to cancel the covenant, my binding sworn arrangement, that I had cut with all the peoples."

    The prophet has been playing the part of a shepherd over "the flock doomed to slaughter" (v. 4). He carried two staffs: one named Favor/Graciousness (no'am, the pleasant, kindly goodwill of a good ruler) and one named Union (literally "Bonds"). The flock and its leaders despised him, so he has just resigned: "I will no longer shepherd you" (v. 9). Now he acts out that resignation. He does not simply drop the staff of graciousness. He chops it, with a word Hebrew uses for hewing down idols and cutting off strength. The act is deliberate and final.

    The stated purpose is to annul a covenant. The verb is the one Israel's Scriptures use when Israel breaks God's covenant, and the one God had promised never to apply to himself (Lev 26:44; Judg 2:1). There is also a grim play on words. Covenants in Hebrew are "cut," so what had been cut into being is now cut apart.

    The covenant is "with all the peoples," most naturally the surrounding nations. The picture is of God having held the nations in check by a sworn arrangement so that they could not devour his flock. With the staff of favor gone, that restraint is lifted, and the flock is left to the hands of neighbors and kings (v. 6). The voice of "my covenant" belongs to the prophet in his role, but it merges with God's own voice. This is God withdrawing his protective favor from a people who rejected the shepherd he gave them.

    Full study →
  5. 11It was revoked on that day, and so the afflicted of the flock who were watching me knew that it was the word of the LORD.

    "And it, the covenant, was declared void on that very day. And so the downtrodden members of the flock, the ones who had been watching me closely, recognized that this was a message from the LORD himself."

    The verse picks up immediately after the prophet, acting the part of a shepherd at God's command, snaps his staff called Favor (v.10). The first verb is not about the stick but about what it stood for. The protective covenant "with all the peoples" is legally annulled (the same verb used for breaking a treaty or a vow), and it happens that day, at the moment of the act. The sign does not just illustrate the change. It brings it about.

    Then comes the audience. The Hebrew text as handed down names them "the afflicted of the flock": the exploited sheep of 11:4–5, bought and slaughtered by handlers who thank God for their profits. They have been watching the shepherd. The verb describes a steady, close gaze, and from what they saw they knew. The closing words, "that the word of the LORD it was," repeat almost exactly Jeremiah's words after a sign confirmed his prophecy ("Then I knew that this was the word of the LORD," Jer 32:8). Like Jeremiah's, this scene moves straight to silver being weighed out (v.12).

    One important uncertainty runs through the verse. The oldest Greek translation read the same Hebrew letters as "the traders of the flock," and many scholars and some English versions follow it. On that reading, the people who realize God is speaking are the dealers who hired the shepherd, and their response is to pay him off with thirty pieces of silver. Either way, the point stays the same: the shepherd's dramatic action was confirmed as God's own word, and the covenant that had held back disaster was truly gone.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v7

    Bands (KJV, YLT)

    ḥōvəlîm

    What we hear
    A musical group, or a strip of fabric or metal.
    What they heard
    Binding cords or ties: the bonds that hold a people together, specifically the brotherhood of Judah and Israel (v.14).
  • in v7

    Beauty (KJV)

    nōʿam

    What we hear
    Physical attractiveness or good looks.
    What they heard
    Pleasantness, graciousness, favor: goodwill that makes life sweet. Here it stands for God's protective covenant care for his flock (v.10).
  • in v8

    my soul … their souls

    nafshi … nafsham (nefesh)

    What we hear
    The immortal, spiritual part of a person, separate from body and feelings, as if the verse were about souls in a religious sense.
    What they heard
    The whole living self as the seat of desire, endurance and emotion. "My nefesh grew short" is an everyday idiom for "I lost patience", and "their nefesh loathed me" means "they were thoroughly sick of me".
  • in v9

    I will not feed you (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    lo' 'er'eh

    What we hear
    I will stop providing you with food.
    What they heard
    I will no longer act as your shepherd: guide, protect, rescue and rule you. The word was a standard picture of kingship.
  • in v9

    that that is to be cut off, let it be cut off (KJV, WEB)

    hannikhchedet tikkached

    What we hear
    Readers who know Leviticus hear 'cut off' as the formal penalty of being excluded from God's people (karet).
    What they heard
    The one that is vanishing or going missing and about to be lost, left to disappear entirely. It is a different verb (kachad), about disappearing or being wiped out, not formal exclusion.
  • in v10

    Beauty (KJV)

    no'am

    What we hear
    Physical attractiveness, a staff that is good to look at.
    What they heard
    Graciousness, pleasantness, favor: the kindly goodwill and care of the shepherd-ruler toward the flock.
  • in v10

    break my covenant

    lehafer et-beriti

    What we hear
    Violating or failing to keep an agreement, which would suggest God being unfaithful.
    What they heard
    Deliberately annulling or voiding an arrangement by the one with authority over it, as a husband or father could void a vow (Num 30). Here it is a judicial withdrawal in response to the flock's rejection of the shepherd.
  • in v10

    all the people (KJV)

    kol-ha'ammim

    What we hear
    The whole population of Israel.
    What they heard
    A plural, "all the peoples," which in Zechariah 9–14 normally means the surrounding nations.
  • in v11

    waited upon me (KJV)

    hashshōmrîm ʾōtî

    What we hear
    Served me, attended me as servants, or waited for me.
    What they heard
    Were watching me closely, observing what I did.
  • in v11

    the word of the LORD

    dĕvar-YHWH

    What we hear
    The Bible, the written Scriptures.
    What they heard
    A specific message from God delivered through a prophet. Here it was delivered through an action (breaking a staff), which the watchers recognized as God's message.
Every word
  1. וָֽאֶרְעֶה֙

    va'erʿeh · H7462B

    to shepherd, pasture · v7, v8, v9

    'And I shepherded.' This is the standard Hebrew narrative past: the prophet reports that he did what he was told in v.4 ('Shepherd the flock of slaughter'). The verb covers the whole job of a shepherd: feeding, guiding, protecting. In the ancient Near East it was also ordinary language for ruling a people.

  2. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v7, v8, v9, v10, v11

    An untranslated marker showing that 'the flock' is the object of the shepherding.

  3. צֹ֣אן

    tsōn · H6629G

    flock (sheep and goats) · v7, v11

    A collective word for small livestock, sheep and goats together. Here, as across Zechariah 9–11, it stands for the people of God.

  4. הַֽהֲרֵגָ֔ה

    ha-hărēgāh · H2028H

    slaughter, killing · v7

    'The slaughter.' The flock is defined by what is going to happen to it: animals kept to be sold and butchered, not cared for (v.5: 'their buyers slay them and go unpunished').

  5. לָכֵ֖ן

    lākhēn · H3651C

    therefore, so · v7, v11

    Normally 'therefore', but that sense sits awkwardly here. Translators render it 'especially', 'hence' or 'indeed'. Some read these letters together with the next word as 'traders' (see textual notes).

  6. עֲנִיֵּ֣י

    ʿăniyyê · H6041

    afflicted, poor, downtrodden · v7, v11

    'The afflicted ones of…' This word means people pressed down by poverty or oppression, often the ones God is said to defend. In the standard Hebrew text these are the weakest sheep of a flock that is already doomed.

  7. וָאֶקַּֽח־

    va'eqqaḥ- · H3947G

    to take · v7, v10

    'And I took.' The start of a symbolic act. The prophet picks up objects that will carry meaning, much like Ezekiel's sticks in Ezekiel 37.

  8. לִ֞י

    lî · H9030

    for me · v7, v8

    'For myself.' The staffs become the shepherd's own equipment for the job.

  9. שְׁנֵ֣י

    shənê · H8147

    two · v7

    'Two.' The number matters: each staff will stand for a different bond, and each is broken separately (vv.10, 14).

  10. מַקְל֗וֹת

    maqlôt · H4731

    stick, rod, staff · v7, v10

    'Staffs' or 'sticks.' A wooden rod of the kind a shepherd or traveller carried (Gen 32:10; 1 Sam 17:40). Here they are ordinary tools turned into signs.

  11. לְאַחַ֞ד

    lə'eḥād · H0259

    one · v7, v8

    'To one [of them].' The first staff.

  12. קָרָ֤אתִי

    qārāʾtî · H7121H

    to call, name · v7

    'I called / I named.' In Hebrew thought, naming something defines what it is. The names tell the hearers what each staff means.

  13. נֹ֙עַם֙

    nōʿam · H5278

    pleasantness, delight, favor · v7, v10

    'Pleasantness / Favor.' The kindness and goodwill that make life sweet, used of 'the favor of the LORD' (Ps 90:17). In v.10 breaking this staff cancels a protective covenant with 'all the peoples'.

  14. חֹֽבְלִ֔ים

    ḥōvəlîm · H2256C

    bonds, cords, union · v7

    'Binders' or 'Cords.' It comes from a root meaning 'to bind with rope'. The staff stands for what ties the people together. In v.14 breaking it ends the brotherhood between Judah and Israel.

  15. וָאַכְחִ֛ד

    va'akhḥid · H3582

    and I effaced / cut off · v8, v9

    This form of the verb means to make something disappear: wipe out, blot out, destroy. The same root comes back twice in v.9 and once in v.16, so the word ties the leaders' removal to the flock's own fate. It means much more than "dismissed".

  16. שְׁלֹ֥שֶׁת

    sheloshet · H7969

    three (of) · v8

    "The three of the shepherds." With the article on the noun that follows, it reads like a group the hearers already knew. The text never says who they were.

  17. בְּיֶ֣רַח

    beyeraḥ · H3391

    in a month · v8

    A lunar month, named after the moon (yareaḥ). It sets a strikingly short span of time.

  18. וַתִּקְצַ֤ר

    vattiqtsar · H7114A

    and it became short · v8

    Part of an idiom, "my self became short," which means "I ran out of patience" or "I could bear it no longer." Hebrew calls a patient person "long of nostrils" and an impatient one "short of spirit".

  19. נַפְשִׁי֙

    nafshi · H5315I

    my self / my soul · v8

    The shepherd's whole inner self: his desire, endurance and life-energy. Together with the verb it means "I lost all patience." It does not point to an immortal part of him.

  20. בָּהֶ֔ם

    bahem · H9038

    with them · v8

    "With them," literally "in them." The Hebrew does not say whether "them" means the three shepherds or the flock. Verse 9 is spoken to the flock, which tips many readers (and the BSB) toward the flock.

  21. וְגַם־

    vegam- · H1571

    and also · v8

    "And they too." It makes the rejection mutual: his patience ran out, and they on their side felt disgust for him.

  22. בָּחֲלָ֥ה

    baḥalah · H0973A

    loathed, felt disgust · v8

    A very rare verb, found clearly only here in the Bible, meaning to feel revulsion or weariness toward someone. They were not merely uninterested. They were sick of him.

  23. וָאֹמַ֕ר

    va'omar · H0559

    and I said · v9

    The prophet, still acting out the shepherd role God gave him in v. 4, reports his own decision. The 'and' form carries the story on from v. 8, where he and the flock came to loathe each other.

  24. לֹ֥א

    lo' · H3808

    not · v9

    A flat negative. It cancels the job he was given: 'Shepherd the flock doomed to slaughter' (v. 4).

  25. הַמֵּתָ֣ה

    hammetah · H4191

    the dying one · v9

    A present participle, 'the one dying', in the feminine because 'flock' (tso'n) is feminine in Hebrew. The picture is a sick or failing ewe, the very animal a good shepherd would nurse.

  26. וְהַ֨נִּשְׁאָר֔וֹת

    vehannish'arot · H7604

    and the ones remaining · v9

    'Those left over' (feminine plural), meaning the survivors. Prophets usually speak of the survivors as the remnant God will restore. Here they are the ones who turn on each other.

  27. תֹּאכַ֕לְנָה

    to'khalnah · H0398

    let them eat / they will eat · v9

    'Let them eat' or 'they will eat', the ordinary word for eating. With 'flesh' it means devouring. Sheep graze, so sheep eating flesh is a deliberately unnatural picture.

  28. אִשָּׁ֖ה

    'ishah · H0802I

    woman; (idiom) each one · v9

    Literally 'a woman'. With 're'utah' it forms the Hebrew idiom for 'each one... another' when the subject is feminine, here the ewes of the flock. It does not mean actual women.

  29. בְּשַׂ֥ר

    besar · H1320

    flesh of · v9

    'Flesh, meat, body.' 'Flesh of' a neighbour recalls the covenant curse of eating human flesh in a siege (Lev 26:29; Deut 28:53–57; Jer 19:9).

  30. רְעוּתָֽהּ׃

    re'utah · H7468

    her companion / fellow · v9

    'Her fellow, her companion' (feminine), finishing the 'each... another' idiom. In sound, though not in root, it echoes the word for shepherding (ra'ah) that opens the verse: once the shepherd quits, the flock's companions become its predators.

  31. וָאֶגְדַּ֖ע

    va'egda' · H1438

    hew, hack off, cut down · v10

    A violent word for chopping, used elsewhere of cutting down sacred poles (Deut 7:5) and hacking off horns or arms (Lam 2:3; 1 Sam 2:31). The staff is chopped through, not just snapped.

  32. לְהָפֵיר֙

    lehafer · H6565

    to break, annul, make void · v10, v11

    "In order to annul." This states the purpose of the sign: chopping the staff acts out, and puts into effect, the cancelling of a covenant. The verb is the standard one for breaking or voiding a covenant or a vow.

  33. בְּרִיתִ֔י

    beriti · H1285

    covenant, binding agreement · v10

    "My covenant": a solemn, binding arrangement backed by oath. The speaker is the prophet acting as God's shepherd, but the voice slides into God's own (compare v. 13), so this is in effect God's covenant.

  34. אֲשֶׁ֥ר

    asher · H0834

    which, that · v10

    Introduces the relative clause that says which covenant is meant.

  35. כָּרַ֖תִּי

    karatti · H3772

    I cut (a covenant), made · v10

    Literally "I cut," the normal Hebrew idiom for making a covenant. Here it has the sense "I had made." It makes a grim echo with the chopping of the staff: what was "cut" into being is now cut apart.

  36. אֶת־

    et- · H0854

    with · v10

    This is the preposition "with," not the object marker. It names the other party to the covenant.

  37. כָּל־

    kol- · H3605

    all · v10

    "All." The covenant covered every one of the peoples in view, not just one.

  38. הָעַמִּֽים׃

    ha'ammim · H5971

    the peoples · v10

    Plural, "the peoples." In the prophets this usually means the surrounding nations, though it can sometimes mean the tribes of Israel. Who exactly is meant is the verse's main interpretive question (see debates).

  39. בַּיּוֹם

    bayyôm · H3117G

    day · v11

    "On the day": ties the annulment to the moment of the symbolic act itself. The breaking of the staff and the breaking of the covenant happen at the same time.

  40. הַהוּא

    hahûʾ · H1931

    that · v11

    "That (day)": points back to the day of the staff-breaking. Here it is a plain time marker, not the end-of-days formula "on that day" that fills Zechariah 12–14.

  41. וַיֵּדְעוּ

    vayyēdʿû · H3045

    to know · v11

    "And they knew / recognized": they understood what they had seen, so that it brought them to a conclusion. The prophet's action was understood as a message.

  42. הַשֹּׁמְרִים

    hashshōmrîm · H8104I

    to watch, keep, observe · v11

    "The ones watching": an ongoing participle. They were keeping their eyes on the prophet as he acted. It means close observation, not serving him or waiting for him.

  43. כִּי

    kî · H3588A

    that, for · v11

    "That": introduces what they came to know.

  44. דְבַר־

    dĕvar- · H1697G

    word, matter, thing · v11

    "Word of": a message or decree spoken by God. Dāvār can also mean "matter, event," which fits here: an action carried the message.

  45. יְהוָה

    YHWH · H3068G

    the LORD (divine name) · v11

    Israel's God by his personal name. The point is that the shepherd's action was not his own idea. It came from YHWH, who commanded it in 11:4.

The world behind it

An acted prophecy. Zechariah 11:4–17 is a symbolic act, a type familiar from Jeremiah (the ruined loincloth, the smashed jar) and Ezekiel (the brick siege, the two joined sticks). The prophet plays a role, and objects and actions carry God's message. Whether he physically herded sheep or reports a visionary or literary performance is debated. Either way, the hearers would understand it as a message about their rulers and their future.

Shepherds as rulers. Throughout the ancient Near East, kings were "shepherds" of their peoples. Ezekiel 34 had already put Israel's leaders on trial as shepherds who fed themselves and not the sheep. Zechariah 10:2–3 and 11:3–5 continue that charge: the flock is "doomed to slaughter" because its shepherds have no pity, its buyers kill it, and its sellers say "Blessed be the LORD, I am rich."

Two sticks. A Palestinian shepherd might carry a club and a crook (compare "your rod and your staff", Ps 23:4). Here, though, the two staffs are mainly symbols. Their closest model is Ezekiel 37:15–22, where sticks inscribed "Judah" and "Joseph" become one in the prophet's hand, a promise of a reunited people under one shepherd-king. Zechariah takes up the same picture and reverses it: the staff "Binders" is snapped, and the brotherhood of Judah and Israel is broken (v.14).

Date and audience. Chapters 9–14 are often dated to the Persian period (late 6th–5th century BC) or later, among a small Judean community ruled through local leaders under foreign empire. Exactly which events lie behind the passage is uncertain (see debates).

From the study of Zechariah 11:7.

Where scholars differ

in v7

Does the verse refer to 'the afflicted of the flock' or 'the sheep traders'?

  • Keep the Masoretic text: the shepherd cares for the flock, especially or therefore its afflicted members.

    This is the transmitted Hebrew text, and 'afflicted' (ʿānî) fits the prophets' concern for the oppressed (cf. Zech 7:10; 9:9). BSB, NIV, NASB and KJV follow it.

  • Follow the Septuagint: read 'for the traders of the flock'.

    The Greek 'Canaan/Canaanites' in vv.7 and 11 points to kənaʿănî, 'merchant'. This reading explains the people in v.11 who 'watched' the shepherd and paid him in v.12, and the buyers and sellers of v.5. It requires only rejoining the same letters. NRSV and ESV, and many commentators, follow it.

in v7

Whom does the prophet represent when he acts as shepherd?

  • He represents God's own shepherding of Israel.

    The breaking of 'Favor' annuls 'my covenant' (v.10), and the shepherd's wages are thrown to 'the LORD's house' (v.13). The prophet speaks and acts for God.

  • He represents a human leader, or the line of rulers God appointed.

    The shepherd language echoes royal imagery (2 Sam 5:2; Ezek 34:23; 37:24). The contrast with the 'worthless shepherd' (vv.15–17), clearly a human ruler, suggests a human office.

  • The roles overlap: the prophet enacts God's rule exercised through an appointed shepherd.

    The prophetic tradition often blends the two (Ezek 34 has God shepherding and appointing 'my servant David'), and the text does not cleanly separate them.

in v7

What historical situation lies behind the 'flock of slaughter' and the broken staffs?

  • Persian-period Judah, under local leaders and foreign overlords.

    This fits the general dating of Zechariah 9–14 and the concerns of Ezra–Nehemiah and Malachi about exploitative leadership.

  • A later, Hellenistic setting, such as the conflicts among high priests or the Samaritan schism.

    Some connect the breaking of the brotherhood between Judah and Israel (v.14) with the Judean–Samaritan split, and the 'three shepherds' (v.8) with known rulers. Over forty identifications have been proposed for the three shepherds, with no consensus.

  • A theological reading of Israel's history rather than a single event.

    The passage reworks earlier prophecy (Jer 23; Ezek 34; 37) into a pattern of rejected leadership and lost unity, and may not point to one datable episode.

in v8

Who are "the three shepherds"?

  • Three short-lived kings of the northern kingdom: Zechariah, Shallum and Menahem's rise

    2 Kgs 15:8–14: Zechariah reigned six months and was murdered by Shallum, who reigned "one full month" before Menahem killed him. That gives a cluster of three rulers and literally "one month". Objection: it is centuries before the likely date of Zech 9–14.

  • Priestly or civic leaders of the Persian or Hellenistic period (e.g. the high priests Jason, Menelaus and Lysimachus of 2 Macc 4)

    Fits a later date for the collection and the turmoil around the temple leadership. Objection: no clear source puts three removals in one month, and the Maccabean dating is a minority view.

  • Three offices or classes of leader (kings, priests, prophets) rather than individuals

    The Bible often groups leaders this way (Jer 2:8, 26; 18:18), and Zech 13:2–6 foresees the end of prophets. On this view "one month" stands for a short time.

  • Moses, Aaron and Miriam (early rabbinic reading)

    Babylonian Talmud Ta'anit 9a reads the verse this way. It then notes that they did not die in the same month and concludes that it means the gifts given for their sakes (manna, the cloud, the well) ended together. This is a later interpretation, not the historical setting.

  • Deliberately unidentifiable or symbolic

    The article shows the first audience knew who was meant, but nothing in the text names them. Many modern commentators conclude that the identity cannot be recovered and that the point is how quickly and decisively bad leadership was removed.

in v8

Who is "them" in "my patience ran short with them"?

  • The flock

    Verse 9 is addressed to the flock ("I will not shepherd you"), and "their soul loathed me" fits the flock rejecting its new shepherd, which leads to the insulting wage of v.12. BSB, NIV and NLT take this view.

  • The three shepherds

    They are the nearest plural noun in the verse. On this reading the impatience explains why they were removed, and WEB's added "for" takes it this way. Objection: the shepherds had already been wiped out, so their ongoing loathing of him is awkward.

in v9

Is the shepherd decreeing the flock's fate or describing the result of his leaving?

  • A decree of judgment: 'let it die'. The shepherd, acting for God, hands the flock over to its fate.

    The LXX and Vulgate both read it this way, as do almost all modern translations. The doubled-verb formula resembles Jer 15:2, a judgment oracle, and the next verse breaks the staff Favor, a deliberate act of revoking.

  • A statement of what follows: 'what is dying will die'. Without a shepherd these things happen on their own.

    The verbs are imperfects in form. In v. 16 the bad shepherd's sin is that he does not look after 'the vanishing ones', so the harm comes from neglect. The two readings are not exclusive: the withdrawal can be the judgment.

in v9

Is the 'eating of flesh' literal or figurative?

  • Literal: the cannibalism of siege famine, as in the covenant curses.

    Lev 26:29, Deut 28:53–57, Jer 19:9 (nearly the same wording), 2 Kgs 6:28–29, Lam 4:10.

  • Figurative: civil strife, factions, and the strong exploiting the weak within the community.

    The whole passage is a picture of sheep and shepherds, and sheep literally eating flesh makes sense only as an image. Compare Isa 9:19–20 (factions devouring each other) and Mic 3:3 (leaders eating the people's flesh). The neighbouring verses are about owners and shepherds exploiting the flock (vv. 5–6).

in v9

Who is the flock, and when does this happen?

  • Post-exilic Judah under Persian or Hellenistic rule, with corrupt local leadership (priests, governors or tax-farmers).

    The flock's owners grow rich by selling it (v. 5). Scholars have proposed dozens of historical identities for the 'three shepherds' (v. 8), and none has won agreement. Major commentators (Meyers & Meyers, Petersen, Boda) treat the passage as a symbolic critique of leadership, with uncertain dating.

  • A prophetic or eschatological pattern that later Christian readers connected with the rejection of Jesus and the fall of Jerusalem in AD 70.

    Matthew applies vv. 12–13 to Judas' payment. Some Christian interpreters from Jerome onward extended v. 9 to the siege of AD 70, pointing to Josephus' account of a woman who ate her child during the famine (Jewish War 6.201–213). This is a later application. The NT itself does not make it for v. 9.

in v10

Who are "all the peoples" with whom the covenant was made?

  • The surrounding nations. God had imposed a covenant of restraint on them for Israel's protection, and revoking it lets them loose on the flock.

    In Zechariah 9–14, 'ammim regularly means foreign nations (12:2–6; 14:2, 12). Verse 6 threatens handing the people over to neighbors and kings. There are parallels in God making protective covenants with outside forces on Israel's behalf (Hos 2:18; Ezek 34:25; compare Job 5:23). Most modern commentators hold this view (e.g. Smith, WBC; Meyers & Meyers, Anchor Bible; Boda, NICOT).

  • The tribes or clans of Israel. This is God's own covenant with his people, now cancelled.

    The plural 'ammim sometimes means Israel's tribes (Gen 28:3; 48:4; Deut 33:3, 19). "My covenant" sounds like God's covenant with Israel. The whole allegory concerns the flock, that is, Israel.

  • A coded reference to a specific historical arrangement, such as a Persian-era or Hellenistic political settlement whose collapse left Judah exposed.

    The undated, allegorical style of chapters 9–14 invites historical decoding, but no proposed identification has won agreement, and the text gives few concrete clues.

in v10

Whose covenant is "my covenant," the prophet's or God's?

  • God's. The prophet speaks in God's person throughout the sign-act.

    A prophet has no covenant of his own with the nations. In v. 13 the voice merges with God's ("the magnificent price at which I was valued by them"). Covenant-making with peoples is God's prerogative.

  • The prophet's, in the role of a ruler-shepherd within the allegory, standing for a human leader's arrangements.

    The narrative is in the first person throughout and casts the prophet as a shepherd who hires, quits and is paid wages. Some read the shepherd as a figure for a particular leader or office.

in v11

Who watched the prophet: "the afflicted of the flock" or "the sheep traders"?

  • Keep the Hebrew text: "thus the afflicted of the flock."

    It is the received Hebrew reading and is supported by the Vulgate. kēn ("thus") and ʿānî are ordinary, well-attested words. The idea of a watchful, suffering remnant fits the prophets' concern for the oppressed and the flock's suffering in 11:4–5. The harder or less smooth reading is often the original one.

  • Follow the Septuagint: "the traders (Canaanites) of the flock."

    The Greek reading needs only a different division of identical consonants. "Canaanite" = trader is attested (Prov 31:24; Zeph 1:11; Zech 14:21). It gives a coherent story: the shepherd works for the traders (v.7), they watch him, and in v.12 he says "to them," "give me my wages," which only an employer can do, and they weigh out thirty shekels. The "afflicted" sheep would hardly be the ones paying his wages.

in v11

What was the covenant "with all the peoples" that was annulled?

  • God's restraint on the nations, which had protected Israel.

    Verse 6 threatens to hand the people over "into the hand of his neighbor and into the hand of his king". Removing a protective arrangement fits a staff named "Favor." Compare Hosea 2:18 (Heb 2:20), where God makes a covenant with the animals on Israel's behalf.

  • An arrangement among peoples (for example, the tribes of Israel, or the nations in general), or a reference to a historical treaty situation.

    ʿammîm ("peoples") can sometimes refer to Israel's tribes (Deut 33:3, 19). Some scholars link the passage to specific Persian-period or later political events, but no identification has wide agreement.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. רָעָה, נֹעַם, חֶבֶל, הֲרֵגָה, כְּנַעֲנִי
  • HALOT s.v. חֹבְלִים, כֵּן (לָכֵן), עָנִי, מַקֵּל
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Zechariah 11:7, 11
  • Vulgate Zechariah 11:7
  • Carol L. Meyers & Eric M. Meyers, Zechariah 9–14 (Anchor Bible)
  • David L. Petersen, Zechariah 9–14 and Malachi (Old Testament Library)
  • Mark J. Boda, The Book of Zechariah (NICOT)
  • Joyce G. Baldwin, Haggai, Zechariah, Malachi (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Zechariah 11
  • BDB s.v. כָּחַד, קָצַר, בָּחַל, נֶפֶשׁ
  • HALOT s.v. כחד, בחל I, קצר
  • Jastrow, Dictionary of the Targumim, Talmud Babli and Yerushalmi s.v. בְּחַל
  • Babylonian Talmud, Ta'anit 9a
  • Septuagint, Zechariah 11:8
  • Vulgate, Zacharias 11:8
  • Code of Hammurabi, prologue (royal 'shepherd' title)
  • BDB s.v. רָעָה, כָּחַד, שָׁאַר
  • HALOT s.v. כחד (nif. 'be hidden; be effaced, annihilated')
  • Carol L. Meyers & Eric M. Meyers, Zechariah 9–14 (Anchor Bible, 1993)
  • David L. Petersen, Zechariah 9–14 and Malachi (Old Testament Library, 1995)
  • Mark J. Boda, The Book of Zechariah (NICOT, 2016)
  • Ralph L. Smith, Micah–Malachi (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Septuagint, Zech 11:9
  • Vulgate, Zech 11:9
  • Code of Hammurabi, prologue (king as re'um, 'shepherd')
  • Josephus, Jewish War 6.201–213
  • BDB s.v. נֹעַם, גָּדַע, פָּרַר, בְּרִית, עַם
  • HALOT s.v. נֹעַם; גדע; פרר II (hif. 'break, annul'); כרת
  • Ralph L. Smith, Micah–Malachi (Word Biblical Commentary 32)
  • Carol L. Meyers & Eric M. Meyers, Zechariah 9–14 (Anchor Bible 25C)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Zech 11
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Zech 11:7–11
  • Vulgate, Zech 11:7–10
  • BDB s.v. פָּרַר; HALOT s.v. פרר I (Hiphil/Hophal of annulling a covenant)
  • HALOT s.v. עָנִי; s.v. כְּנַעֲנִי ("trader, merchant")
  • BDB s.v. שָׁמַר ("watch, observe")
  • BDB s.v. דָּבָר
  • Septuagint, Zechariah 11:7, 11 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Zacharias 11:11
  • Jeremiah 32:8–9; 33:20–21; Isaiah 8:10 (parallel usage)
  • Matthew 27:9–10 (later citation of Zech 11:12–13)
  • STEPBible/TAHOT tagged Hebrew text (supplied data)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).