1 John Chapter 4 Read as one passage

1 John 4:5–6

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

5They are of the world. That is why they speak from the world’s perspective, and the world listens to them. 6We are from God. Whoever knows God listens to us; whoever is not from God does not listen to us. That is how we know the Spirit of truth and the spirit of deception.

What the first hearers heard

For readers left behind after the split, this verse was reassurance and diagnosis together.

  • Reassurance: The departed teachers were persuasive and popular. John explains why. They and their audience share the same origin, so of course the world listens to them. Their success does not show they have the Spirit. It shows they belong to the world. This matches what Jesus had said: "If you were of the world, the world would love you as its own" (John 15:19).
  • Diagnosis: Verses 4–6 give a way to tell the two spirits apart. Ask where a message comes from (what does it confess about Jesus come in the flesh?) and who welcomes it. Like hears like. Those from God hear the apostolic witness (v. 6). Those from the world hear the world's spokesmen.
  • Identity: The emphatic "you… they… we" drew a clear line around the community. The readers were "from God" and had already "overcome" these teachers (v. 4), because the one in them is greater than the one in the world. Verse 5 describes the other side of that line so the readers would not be drawn across it.

The verse did not tell them to withdraw from society, and it did not define worldliness as habits. It warned them about religious voices whose message, however spiritual it sounded, came from the world rather than from God.

From the study of 1 John 4:5.

Verse by verse

  1. 5They are of the world. That is why they speak from the world’s perspective, and the world listens to them.

    These people (the false prophets who carry the antichrist spirit) come from the world and belong to it. That is why their message comes out of the world as its source: the world's outlook, assumptions and voice. And the world recognises its own voice in them and keeps giving them a ready, accepting hearing.

    The sentence is built on "world" three times in a row: they are from the world → they speak from the world → the world hears them. This is a closed loop. The world produces these speakers, their words carry the world's voice, and the world welcomes them. "From" (Greek ek) is about origin and kinship, not topic. They do not talk about worldly things. Their talk comes from the world, the way a child's family likeness comes from its parents.

    "World" here does not mean the planet or "secular culture." It means human society organised apart from God and in opposition to him, the order John says "lies in the power of the evil one" (5:19). The surprise is that these "worldly" speakers are religious. They are prophets who claim the Spirit (4:1). The verse comes between "you are from God" (v. 4) and "we are from God" (v. 6), so its stress falls on "they": you belong to one source, they belong to another, and you can tell which by whose voice each audience accepts. For John's readers, the opponents' popularity was not a reason to doubt themselves. It showed which family the opponents belonged to.

    Full study →
  2. 6We are from God. Whoever knows God listens to us; whoever is not from God does not listen to us. That is how we know the Spirit of truth and the spirit of deception.

    We, emphatically we, set against "them" in the previous verse, have our origin in God and belong to him. The person who is truly, and still, coming to know God gives us a real hearing: he takes our message to heart and responds to it. The person who does not have his source in God will not give us that hearing, whatever words reach his ears. This is how we tell the two spirits apart: the Spirit who carries God's truth, and the spirit that leads people off the road.

    The verse mirrors 4:5 line for line. They come from the world, so they talk the world's language and the world listens to them. We come from God, so those who know God listen to us. Where a person comes from shows in what they respond to, the way children of one household recognize their father's voice (compare John 10:27, "my sheep hear my voice").

    The "we" are the people who hold to the message about Jesus as it was "heard from the beginning" (1:1–3; 2:24). That message is the confession that Jesus Christ has come in the flesh (4:2). The test is not loyalty to a personality. It is how people respond to that original testimony, and in the very next verse (4:7) whether they love.

    "Truth" here means God's reality made known in Jesus. Its opposite is not an innocent mistake but planē: wandering, deception, an influence that draws people astray.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v5

    they are of the world / they are from the world

    ek tou kosmou eisin

    What we hear
    They are "worldly": secular people, or Christians with loose lifestyle habits such as entertainment, drink or fashion.
    What they heard
    Their origin and belonging is the God-opposed human order. In context these are religious teachers and prophets claiming the Spirit, not irreligious outsiders. The issue is source and allegiance, shown in a false confession about Jesus (4:2–3), not lifestyle.
  • in v5

    speak of the world (KJV, WEB)

    ek tou kosmou lalousin

    What we hear
    They talk about worldly subjects: money, politics, pleasures.
    What they heard
    Their speech comes out of the world as its source. Its outlook and inspiration are the world's, whatever the topic, and their topic was religious.
  • in v6

    the spirit of error

    to pneuma tēs planēs

    What we hear
    An outlook that gets some facts wrong; an honest mistake in doctrine.
    What they heard
    The spirit of wandering off course and of leading others astray: an active, deceiving influence (compare 2:26, "those trying to lead you astray").
  • in v6

    he that knoweth God / whoever knows God

    ho ginōskōn ton theon

    What we hear
    Someone who knows things about God or believes God exists.
    What they heard
    Someone in an ongoing, personal relationship with God. In this letter that relationship shows itself in keeping God's commands and loving one another (2:3–4; 4:7–8).
  • in v6

    heareth us

    akouei hēmōn

    What we hear
    Physically hears the words spoken.
    What they heard
    Heeds us, receives and accepts what we say. The opposing side hears the same words and refuses them.
Every word
  1. αὐτοὶ

    autoi · G0846

    they, they themselves · v5

    Placed first for emphasis: "*they*, for their part." It points back to the "them" the readers have overcome in v. 4, meaning the false prophets of 4:1 who carry the spirit of the antichrist (4:3). It sets up a three-way contrast: "you" are from God (v. 4), "they" are from the world (v. 5), "we" are from God (v. 6).

  2. ἐκ

    ek · G1537

    out of, from · v5, v6

    Origin and belonging: where someone comes from and what they draw their life from. John uses the same pattern in "from God" (v. 4, v. 6), so the question is which source a person's life flows from.

  3. τοῦ

    tou · G3588

    the · v5, v6

    The article goes with "world": the familiar Johannine "world," a known quantity to the readers.

  4. κόσμου

    kosmou · G2889

    world · v5

    Not the planet or nature. It means human society as it is organised apart from God and against him, the sphere that "lies in the power of the evil one" (5:19).

  5. εἰσίν·

    eisin · G1510

    they are · v5, v6

    A present-tense statement about what they are and where they belong. It describes what they are, not just something they did once.

  6. διὰ

    dia · G1223

    because of, on account of · v5

    With "this" it means "for this reason, that is why." Their speech follows from their origin.

  7. τοῦτο

    touto · G3778

    this · v5, v6

    Points back to the statement just made, that they are from the world.

  8. λαλοῦσιν

    lalousin · G2980

    they speak · v5

    Present tense, so it describes their ongoing talk and teaching. In John's Gospel Jesus speaks what he has heard from the Father (John 8:26, 38). These prophets also pass on a source, but theirs is the world.

  9. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v5, v6

    Adds the result. Speech that comes from the world finds a ready audience in the world.

  10. ἀκούει.

    akouei · G0191

    hears, listens to · v5, v6

    More than hearing sounds. It means listening receptively and accepting what is said, which is the Johannine sense of "hearing" a voice (John 10:27; 18:37). Present tense: the world keeps listening to them.

  11. ἡμεῖς

    hēmeis · G3165

    we · v6

    Emphatic, since Greek verbs already carry their subject: "we, as opposed to them." It answers "they" (autoi) in 4:5 and stands next to "you" in 4:4.

  12. θεοῦ

    theou · G2316

    God · v6

    The God of Israel, whom Jesus made known (1:2–3). He is the source the true community comes from.

  13. γινώσκων

    ginōskōn · G1097

    knowing · v6

    A present participle: the one who is knowing God, an ongoing and personal acquaintance. In this letter that knowing shows in obedience and love (2:3–4; 4:7–8).

  14. ὃς

    hos · G3739

    who, whoever · v6

    Opens the negative half of the statement: "whoever…".

  15. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v6

    A flat factual "not": this person simply is not from God.

  16. πνεῦμα

    pneuma · G4151

    spirit · v6

    The power or influence that drives a speaker. Here it is the divine Spirit who carries truth (compare John 14:17).

  17. ἀληθείας

    alētheias · G0225

    truth · v6

    The genitive means "the spirit marked by, producing and belonging to the truth." In John's writings truth is God's reality made known in Jesus, not merely correct statements.

  18. πλάνης.

    planēs · G4106

    wandering, deception · v6

    Leading off the right road. This is an active force that misleads people, not an honest slip. It ties to "those who are trying to lead you astray" (2:26).

The world behind it

A community split. First John was written (traditionally from Ephesus, late first century) to churches shaken by a departure: "They went out from us, but they did not really belong to us" (2:19). The people who left kept teaching, apparently as Spirit-inspired prophets (4:1). They denied that "Jesus Christ has come in the flesh" (4:2–3) and claimed to know God while ignoring his commandments and love for the fellow believer (2:4, 9–11). John calls them "antichrists" (2:18, 22), and in 4:1–6 he gives the readers a way to "test the spirits."

Travelling prophets and testing. Early churches were visited by wandering teachers who claimed to speak by the Spirit. The Didache, an early Christian manual of church practice (late first to early second century), also tells churches to test prophets and to judge them by whether they live "the ways of the Lord" (Did. 11). Testing a prophet by his message goes back to Deuteronomy 13:1–5 and 18:20–22.

Two spirits, two families. Jews of the period often described the world as divided between two spirits or two camps. The Dead Sea Scrolls' Community Rule speaks of "the spirits of truth and of deceit/injustice" that rule "sons of light" and "sons of darkness" (1QS 3:13–4:26). The Testament of Judah 20:1 speaks of "the spirit of truth and the spirit of error," which is the exact Greek pair John uses in v. 6 (though the Testaments' present form has Christian additions). John's readers would have recognised this frame. What is new in 1 John is the test: the deciding question is what a person confesses about Jesus come in the flesh, and whose voice they accept.

"The world listens." The context suggests the opponents were doing well and perhaps attracting more followers than John's group. The verse turns that success around. Wide acceptance by "the world" is just what you would expect from speakers whose message comes from the world. Jesus warned of this pattern in the Gospel (John 15:18–19; 17:14).

From the study of 1 John 4:5.

Where scholars differ

in v5

Who exactly are "they" (the false prophets/secessionists), and what did they teach?

  • Early docetists, perhaps connected with Cerinthus, who denied that the divine Christ truly took on flesh or suffered.

    The test in 4:2–3 (confessing "Jesus Christ come in the flesh"), 5:6 ("not by water only but by water and blood"), and Irenaeus' report (Against Heresies 1.26.1; 3.3.4) that John opposed Cerinthus in Ephesus.

  • A wing of the Johannine community that so stressed Jesus' divine origin that his earthly life and death lost saving significance, and with it ethical obedience (R. E. Brown).

    The letter's focus on commandments, love for the fellow believer, and the claim to be sinless (1:8–10; 2:4, 9). The opponents seem to be former insiders using shared Johannine language (2:19).

  • The dispute centred on whether Jesus is the Messiah, possibly a return toward a non-messianic Jewish position.

    2:22 ("who is the liar but the one who denies that Jesus is the Christ?") and 5:1. Most scholars think this does not fully explain the stress on "flesh" in 4:2.

in v5

Does "the world listens to them" mean the opponents were numerically more successful?

  • Yes. The verse answers a real situation in which the secessionists were winning more followers, and John explains their success.

    The present tense describes an ongoing reality. The reassurance "you have overcome them" (v. 4) and the warning tone of 2:18–27 suggest a community under pressure. Brown argues the secessionists may have been the larger group.

  • Not necessarily. It is a statement of principle about kinship (like hears like), not a report on numbers.

    The same principle appears in John 8:47 and 15:19 with no specific situation behind it, and v. 6 states the mirror principle in general terms.

in v6

Who is the emphatic "we" whom those who know God listen to?

  • The apostolic eyewitness circle, the "we" of 1:1–3 who saw and touched the Word of life.

    The "we / you" pattern in 4:4–6 ("you are of God" in 4:4, then "we are of God" in 4:6) suggests a group distinct from the readers. The "we" of 1:1–3 is clearly the eyewitnesses. Many older and evangelical commentators (e.g. Stott, Yarbrough) take this view.

  • The bearers of the community's tradition: the author and the circle of teachers who passed on the Johannine witness, not necessarily eyewitnesses.

    Raymond Brown (Anchor Bible) argues the "we" are the guardians of the tradition "from the beginning" (2:24), set against the secessionist teachers ("they," 4:5).

  • The whole faithful community, as opposed to the secessionists.

    The contrast in 4:5–6 is between two groups, "they" and "we." In 4:7 the "we" plainly includes all the readers ("let us love one another"). The test concerns the community's confession, not a special office.

in v6

Is "the spirit of truth" the Holy Spirit or a human disposition?

  • The Holy Spirit, set against a demonic or antichrist spirit.

    John 14:17; 15:26 and 16:13 use the same title for the promised Spirit. 4:2 speaks of "the Spirit of God," and 4:3 of "the spirit of the antichrist." This is why BSB, NIV, ESV and NLT capitalize it.

  • Two inner tendencies or influences at work in people, as in Jewish "two spirits" teaching.

    In 1QS 3–4 and the Testament of Judah 20 the two spirits are powers operating within human beings. 4:1 tells readers to "test the spirits," plural, which can refer to the inspired speakers themselves. KJV, WEB and YLT keep the lowercase.

  • Both: God's Spirit and the opposing power, each working through human speakers.

    John uses the Jewish two-spirits framework but names its powers in light of Christ. 4:1–3 moves easily between "spirits" and the prophets who speak by them.

in v6

What does "by this" (ek toutou) refer to?

  • Only the listening test just stated: who heeds us and who does not.

    It comes immediately after 4:6a–b, and in 1 John similar phrases often point back to what has just been said.

  • The whole section 4:1–6, both the confession test (4:2–3) and the listening test.

    The verse closes the paragraph that began with "test the spirits" (4:1), and "spirit of truth / spirit of deception" echoes "Spirit of God / spirit of antichrist" in 4:2–3.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. κόσμος
  • BDAG s.v. ἐκ
  • BDAG s.v. ἀκούω
  • BDAG s.v. λαλέω
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Epistles of John (Anchor Bible 30, 1982)
  • Stephen S. Smalley, 1, 2, 3 John (Word Biblical Commentary 51)
  • Robert W. Yarbrough, 1–3 John (Baker Exegetical Commentary on the NT)
  • Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule 1QS 3:13–4:26
  • Testament of Judah 20:1
  • Didache 11
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.26.1; 3.3.4
  • Vulgate, 1 John 4:5
  • BDAG s.v. πλάνη
  • BDAG s.v. γινώσκω
  • Robert W. Yarbrough, 1–3 John (Baker Exegetical Commentary on the New Testament)
  • John R. W. Stott, The Letters of John (Tyndale NT Commentaries)
  • Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.3.4
  • Vulgate, 1 John 4:6

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).