Exodus Chapter 16 Read as one passage

Exodus 16:31–36

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

31Now the house of Israel called the bread manna. It was white like coriander seed and tasted like wafers made with honey. 32Moses said, “This is what the LORD has commanded: ‘Keep an omer of manna for the generations to come, so that they may see the bread I fed you in the wilderness when I brought you out of the land of Egypt.’” 33So Moses told Aaron, “Take a jar and fill it with an omer of manna. Then place it before the LORD to be preserved for the generations to come.” 34And Aaron placed it in front of the Testimony, to be preserved just as the LORD had commanded Moses. 35The Israelites ate manna forty years, until they came to a land where they could settle; they ate manna until they reached the border of Canaan. 36(Now an omer is a tenth of an ephah.)

What the first hearers heard

For the first hearers, the verse did three things:

  • It explained a name. "Man" kept alive the moment their ancestors stood over the ground asking "What is it?" (v. 15). The name was itself a reminder that Israel had been fed by something it did not grow, make or understand.
  • It made the food visible to people who would never eat it. The next verse orders a jar of manna kept "so that they may see the bread I fed you in the wilderness." This verse does the same thing in words. Later generations living off the land in Canaan, where the manna had stopped (Josh 5:12), could picture it: white grains the size of coriander seed, tasting like a honey cake.
  • It answered the complaint. The chapter begins with the people longing for Egypt's bread (v. 3). The description stresses that God's provision was not a meagre substitute but sweet and fine. Later tradition dwells on this. Psalm 78:24–25 calls it "grain of heaven" and the "bread of the mighty ones." Deuteronomy 8:3, 16 explains it as a lesson that a person lives "by every word that comes from the mouth of the LORD." That makes the later complaint in Numbers 11:6, "we see nothing but this manna", look all the more ungrateful.

From the study of Exodus 16:31.

Verse by verse

  1. 31Now the house of Israel called the bread manna. It was white like coriander seed and tasted like wafers made with honey.

    The whole family of Israel gave the strange food a name. They called it "Man", which echoes the question they asked when they first saw it on the ground (v. 15): "Man hu?", "What is it?" The food God gave them was named after their own bewilderment, and every later generation that said the word repeated that first question.

    Then comes a description for people who had never seen it. In size and shape it was like coriander seed: small, round grains about the size of a peppercorn, scattered over the ground. In colour it was white. (Coriander seed itself is tan, so the comparison is about shape, and the white belongs to the manna.) Its taste was like a flat cake made with honey: something like a thin homemade pancake or fried cake, sweetened with honey or rich fruit syrup.

    To a people who had just complained that in Egypt they at least had bread to the full (v. 3), the point was clear. The food that came from heaven was not grim survival rations. It was mysterious, pure white, and tasted like a treat.

    Full study →
  2. 32Moses said, “This is what the LORD has commanded: ‘Keep an omer of manna for the generations to come, so that they may see the bread I fed you in the wilderness when I brought you out of the land of Egypt.’”

    Moses passes on a fresh order from Israel's God: “This is the word the LORD has commanded: a full omer of it is to be set aside under guard for all your generations to come, so that they can see with their own eyes the food I put in your mouths in the wilderness when I led you out of the land of Egypt.”

    Several things are packed in:

    • A full omer is not a token pinch. It is exactly the daily portion each person gathered (vv. 16–18), the amount God gave to each person, always enough and never too much.
    • “Under guard” / “for safekeeping” uses the same word as v. 23, where manna was set aside overnight for the Sabbath. Ordinary leftover manna rotted by morning (v. 20). This portion is to last for generations, so its survival is part of the sign.
    • “They may see”: the speech shifts from “you,” the generation that ate it, to “they,” descendants who never stood in the wilderness. Memory is not left to stories alone. There is something to look at.
    • “The bread I fed you” means the food God himself “caused you to eat,” like a parent feeding children, in a place where no field could grow grain.
    • The feeding is joined to the rescue from Egypt in a single breath. The God who fed them is the God who freed them, and the jar testifies to both.
    Full study →
  3. 33So Moses told Aaron, “Take a jar and fill it with an omer of manna. Then place it before the LORD to be preserved for the generations to come.”

    Moses said to Aaron, the man who would serve as priest: "Take a single storage jar and put into it a full omer of manna, exactly one person's daily share. Then lay it to rest in the LORD's presence, in the sanctuary, as something to be guarded and kept for your descendants, generation after generation."

    The wording looks back to the Sabbath. Earlier in the chapter, any manna kept overnight bred worms and stank (v. 20). Only the Sabbath portion, which Moses told the people to "lay up to be kept until morning" (v. 23), stayed fresh. Moses now uses exactly the same words, "lay it up … to be kept", but the keeping lasts for generations instead of one night. The food that normally could not survive a day becomes a lasting memorial.

    The "it" set before the LORD points grammatically to the manna, not the jar. What the children are meant to see (v. 32) is the bread itself. The Hebrew says nothing about the jar being gold or about it going inside the ark. It is placed "before the LORD", and v. 34 adds "before the Testimony", next to the covenant tablets, much as Aaron's staff would later be kept "as a sign" (Num 17:10).

    Full study →
  4. 34And Aaron placed it in front of the Testimony, to be preserved just as the LORD had commanded Moses.

    Exactly as Yahweh had commanded Moses, so it was done. Aaron set the omer of manna down and left it there for good, in front of "the Testimony". That is the stone tablets of the covenant, the written and witnessed terms of God's agreement with Israel, kept in his presence (in v. 33 the same spot is simply "before Yahweh"). There the manna was held in guarded custody, a sacred trust passed down for generations who would never gather it from the ground themselves.

    The wording links back to the start of the chapter. Manna kept overnight normally bred worms and stank (v. 20). Only for the Sabbath had Moses said, "set it down to be kept until morning" (v. 23), and then it stayed sound. Here the same two words come back, "set down" and "for keeping". Bread that would not keep for a day is laid up to keep for ages.

    The verse also gets ahead of its own story. The tablets, the ark and Aaron's priesthood all come later in Exodus. The narrator is telling the reader where this jar ended up: beside the covenant document in the sanctuary, a permanent witness that the God of the covenant fed his people in the wilderness.

    Full study →
  5. 35The Israelites ate manna forty years, until they came to a land where they could settle; they ate manna until they reached the border of Canaan.

    The Israelites, all Jacob's descendants as one family-nation, lived on the manna, the 'What-is-it?' food that fell daily in the desert. They ate it for the whole forty years of the wilderness generation, until they reached country that was settled and lived in, where bread grows from fields instead of falling from the sky. The narrator then repeats the point with emphasis: the manna, that was what they ate, right up to the moment they reached the very edge of the land of Canaan.

    The verse looks back over the whole journey as a completed story. Its two halves mirror each other ('they ate the manna... until they came / the manna they ate... until they came'), and the second half narrows 'a settled land' to 'the edge of Canaan', the promised goal. It explains why Aaron's jar of manna (16:33–34) mattered: later generations who had never seen manna were to know that their ancestors were fed this way for an entire lifetime, and that the feeding stopped only at the threshold of the promise (Joshua 5:10–12).

    Full study →
  6. 36(Now an omer is a tenth of an ephah.)

    "And the omer, the one you have been hearing about all through this story, is a tenth of an ephah."

    This is a narrator's footnote. The manna story kept using the word omer: each person gathered an omer a day (v. 16), two omers on the sixth day (v. 22), and an omer of manna was put in a jar and kept before the LORD for later generations (vv. 32–33). By the time the story was being told, the omer was no longer a measure people used. So the narrator steps out of the story and converts it into the unit everyone did know, the ephah, the standard grain measure of market and temple. A tenth of an ephah was also a very familiar amount, because it was the standard portion of flour in many grain offerings. In modern terms that is roughly two litres, a little over two quarts, though the ancient measures cannot be fixed exactly. The point for the hearer is concrete: this is how much bread God gave each person every day in the wilderness, and how much was kept in that jar.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v31

    honey

    devash

    What we hear
    Bees' honey from a hive.
    What they heard
    Any rich sweet syrup. It could be bees' honey, but often meant syrup boiled from dates or grapes, which was common in the Levant. Here the point is simply 'sweet'.
  • in v31

    wafers

    tsappichit

    What we hear
    A crisp, light factory biscuit, or a thin communion wafer.
    What they heard
    A homemade thin flat cake or pancake, possibly fried, made with honey. The word appears only here, so the exact form is uncertain.
  • in v32

    bread

    lechem

    What we hear
    A baked loaf from a bakery.
    What they heard
    Staple food or sustenance in general. Manna came as flakes, which were then baked or boiled (v. 23). “The bread I fed you” means “what I kept you alive on.”
  • in v32

    wilderness

    midbar

    What we hear
    Either untouched forest and wild nature, or endless sand dunes.
    What they heard
    Dry, uncultivated steppe and pasture land, rocky and sparse, good for grazing flocks but impossible to farm. The point is that no bread could be grown there.
  • in v33

    pot (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    ṣinṣenet

    What we hear
    A cooking pot or a clay flowerpot.
    What they heard
    A storage jar or container. Its exact shape is unknown because the word appears only once. Its purpose was keeping and displaying, not cooking.
  • in v33

    before the LORD

    lifnê YHWH

    What we hear
    In God's sight, a spiritual or moral sense of living before God.
    What they heard
    Physically in the sanctuary, in front of the place of God's presence. Verse 34 specifies 'before the Testimony', next to the covenant tablets.
  • in v34

    the Testimony

    ha'edut

    What we hear
    A personal account of faith ('sharing my testimony') or a witness's spoken evidence in court.
    What they heard
    A physical object: the stone tablets with the covenant terms on them (and by extension the ark holding them), kept as a standing witness to the covenant between Yahweh and Israel.
  • in v35

    children of Israel

    bnei yisra'el

    What we hear
    Young people, or a childlike group.
    What they heard
    The descendants of Jacob-Israel, the whole nation of every age, named as one family.
  • in v35

    manna

    man

    What we hear
    An idiom for any sudden windfall or welcome surprise ('manna from heaven'), or a vague 'spiritual food'.
    What they heard
    A specific physical food, named from the question 'What is it?'. It was gathered every morning, rationed by household, doubled before the Sabbath, and it stopped when farm produce became available.
  • in v36

    omer

    ʿōmer

    What we hear
    Readers who know the Jewish practice of 'Counting the Omer' (the 49 days from Passover to Shavuot) may assume this is the same omer, a sheaf of barley.
    What they heard
    Here it is a dry measure of volume, a tenth of an ephah (about two litres), used for the daily manna ration. The 'omer' of the counting comes from Leviticus 23:10–15, where the word means a sheaf of grain waved as an offering. Lexicons treat the two as separate words, or at least separate senses.
Every word
  1. וַיִּקְרְא֧וּ

    vayyiqre'u · H7121

    to call, name · v31

    With 'name' as its object, this is the ordinary Hebrew way of saying 'they named it'. The verb is plural even though 'house' is singular: the whole people, acting together, gave the name.

  2. בֵֽית־

    veit- · H1004

    house, household, family · v31

    'House' here means a family line, not a building. 'The house of Israel' is the whole family descended from Jacob/Israel. In the books of Moses this phrase is unusual (the usual one is 'sons of Israel'), which gives the naming the feel of a family remembering something together.

  3. יִשְׂרָאֵ֛ל

    Yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v31, v35

    The ancestor's name, which here stands for the whole people sprung from him.

  4. אֶת־

    'et- · H853

    (object marker) · v31, v32, v33, v35

    A grammatical marker with no English equivalent. It shows that 'its name' is what was called.

  5. שְׁמ֖וֹ

    shemo · H8034

    name · v31

    'Its name'. In the ancient Near East, giving something a name captured what it was or how it was first met. This name keeps the people's first reaction to the food (v. 15).

  6. מָ֑ן

    man · H4478

    manna · v31, v33, v35

    The name itself. The story connects it with the people's question in v. 15, 'man hu?', 'What is it?' So the food is named after their own confusion. The major pause in the verse falls on this word.

  7. וְה֗וּא

    vehu · H1931

    and it (he) · v31, v36

    'And it'. This begins the description. There is no verb 'was'; Hebrew lets this kind of description stand without one.

  8. כְּזֶ֤רַע

    kezera' · H2233

    seed · v31

    'Like the seed of'. This compares size and shape: small, round grains spread on the ground.

  9. גַּד֙

    gad · H1407

    coriander · v31

    Coriander, the plant whose dried round 'seeds' (really tiny fruits, about 3–5 mm across) were a familiar spice in Egypt and the Levant. The word appears only here and in Numbers 11:7.

  10. לָבָ֔ן

    lavan · H3836

    white · v31

    'White'. It describes the manna, not the coriander. Coriander seed is tan or pale brown, so the comparison is about size and roundness, and 'white' adds the colour (compare Numbers 11:7, 'like bdellium', a pale resin).

  11. וְטַעְמ֖וֹ

    veta'mo · H2940

    taste; good sense, judgment · v31

    'And its taste'. Here it means literal flavour, though the same word can mean good sense or judgment elsewhere.

  12. כְּצַפִּיחִ֥ת

    ketsappichit · H6838

    flat cake, wafer · v31

    'Like a flat cake'. The word occurs only here in the Bible. It probably means a thin flat cake or pancake, perhaps fried. Later Jewish tradition took it as dough fried in honey.

  13. בִּדְבָֽשׁ׃

    bidvash · H1706

    honey; sweet syrup · v31

    'In/with honey'. A cake made with or soaked in honey or sweet syrup. To people whose usual staples were bread, beans and onions, this was the taste of a treat.

  14. וַיֹּאמֶר

    vayyomer · H0559

    and he said · v32, v33

    The usual way Hebrew stories move forward: “and he said.” It opens a fresh speech by Moses after the narrator's description of manna in v. 31.

  15. מֹשֶׁה

    mosheh · H4872

    Moses · v32, v33, v34

    Moses speaks, but as a go-between. What follows is a command from Yahweh that he passes on.

  16. זֶה

    zeh · H2088

    this · v32

    “This is…” points ahead to the instruction about to be given. The same opening formula appears in v. 16 for the first manna rules.

  17. הַדָּבָר

    haddavar · H1697

    word, thing, matter · v32

    Both “word” and “thing/matter.” Here it means the specific instruction Yahweh has spoken: “this is the word (the matter) Yahweh commanded.”

  18. אֲשֶׁר

    asher · H0834

    which, that · v32, v34

    A relative word linking “the word” to “Yahweh commanded.”

  19. צִוָּה

    tsivvah · H6680

    to command · v32, v34

    A completed action: “has commanded.” This is a binding order from Israel's divine king, not a suggestion. The supplied gloss “commands” reflects KJV-style English. The Hebrew form presents the command as already given.

  20. יְהוָה

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh, the LORD · v32, v33, v34

    The personal name of Israel's God, written “the LORD” in most English Bibles. The God who rescued Israel from Egypt is the one giving the order.

  21. מְלֹא

    melo · H4393

    fullness, full amount · v32, v33

    “The fullness of”: a full measure, filled to the brim. The ancient Greek and Latin translators read the same consonants as the command “fill!”

  22. הָעֹמֶר

    ha'omer · H6016

    omer (dry measure) · v32, v33, v36

    “The omer” is the measure already mentioned in vv. 16–18: one person's daily ration of manna, about two litres. The jar is to hold exactly what God gave one person for one day.

  23. מִמֶּנּוּ

    mimmennu · H4480

    from it · v32

    “From it” means some of the manna just described in v. 31. BSB and NIV supply the word “manna” to make this clear.

  24. לְמִשְׁמֶרֶת

    lemishmeret · H4931

    keeping, guard, charge · v32, v33, v34

    “For safekeeping, as something under guard.” This is the same word used in v. 23 for manna set aside overnight for the Sabbath, but now the keeping lasts for centuries.

  25. לְדֹרֹתֵיכֶם

    ledoroteikhem · H1755

    generation · v32, v33

    “For your generations”: down the line of your descendants. The wording is the same as in lasting rules like Passover (Exod 12:14).

  26. לְמַעַן

    lema'an · H4616

    so that, for the sake of · v32

    Introduces the purpose: the jar exists so that future people will see.

  27. יִרְאוּ

    yir'u · H7200

    to see · v32

    “They may see.” Note the switch from “you” to “they”: the future generations, who were not there, are to see with their own eyes.

  28. הַלֶּחֶם

    hallechem · H3899

    bread, food · v32

    “The bread,” meaning staple food in general rather than a baked loaf. It echoes Moses' words in v. 15: “This is the bread the LORD has given you to eat.”

  29. הֶאֱכַלְתִּי

    he'ekhalti · H0398

    to cause to eat, feed · v32, v35

    Literally “I caused you to eat,” spoken by Yahweh. It is the picture of a parent or host putting food in front of dependants. Deuteronomy 8:3, 16 uses the same verb for the manna.

  30. בַּמִּדְבָּר

    bammidbar · H4057

    wilderness, steppe · v32

    “In the wilderness,” the dry grazing land where no farming was possible. The point is that bread there could only come from God.

  31. בְּהוֹצִיאִי

    behotsi'i · H3318

    to bring out · v32

    Literally “in my bringing out,” meaning when I brought you out. Yahweh is the one who acts. The supplied gloss “send” is weak here: the form means “cause to go out” or “lead out.”

  32. מֵאֶרֶץ

    me'erets · H0776

    land, country · v32, v35

    “From the land of”: a territory, not the planet.

  33. מִצְרָיִם

    mitsrayim · H4714

    Egypt · v32

    Egypt, the land of slavery and also of the “pots of meat” the people longed for in v. 3. The feeding is tied to the rescue from it.

  34. אֶל־

    el- · H0413

    to, toward · v33, v34, v35

    Marks who is being spoken to: Aaron.

  35. אַהֲרֹן

    ahărōn · H0175

    Aaron · v33, v34

    Aaron is the future high priest. Setting something down 'before the LORD' is priestly work, so the job goes to him.

  36. קַח

    qaḥ · H3947

    take · v33

    A command, 'take'. It opens a short run of three commands: take, put, deposit.

  37. צִנְצֶנֶת

    ṣinṣenet · H6803

    jar · v33

    A container for storing things. The word appears only here in the Hebrew Bible, so we don't know its exact shape or material. It was not a cooking pot.

  38. אַחַת

    aḥat · H0259

    one · v33

    'One jar', a single container. It also fits the story's point that each person gathered one omer a day.

  39. וְתֶן־

    wəten- · H5414

    and put · v33

    A plain command, 'put'. The supplied gloss 'if only' comes from a separate idiom (mî yittēn, 'who will give'), which is not used here.

  40. שָׁמָּה

    shāmmāh · H8033

    there, thither · v33

    'There' with an ending that marks direction: into the jar.

  41. וְהַנַּח

    wəhannaḥ · H5117

    and cause to rest, deposit · v33, v34

    'Set it down to rest' or 'deposit it'. This is the same verb used in v. 23 for laying up the Sabbath portion overnight, which then did not rot.

  42. לִפְנֵי

    lifnê · H6440

    before, in front of · v33, v34

    Literally 'to the face of'. With YHWH it is a worship term for the place where God is present, not a vague 'in God's sight'.

  43. הָעֵדֻ֖ת

    ha'edut · H5715

    testimony, solemn charge, covenant document · v34

    'The Testimony.' In Exodus this is the standard name for the stone tablets of the covenant, and by extension the chest (ark) that holds them (25:16, 22; 31:18). It is the written, witnessed statement of the covenant terms. It is not a personal account of faith.

  44. וּבְנֵי

    uvnei · H1121

    and sons of · v35

    'Sons of' in a kinship phrase means the descendants or people of someone. 'Sons of Israel' is the whole people descended from Jacob-Israel: men, women and children, not young people only.

  45. אַרְבָּעִים

    arba'im · H0705

    forty · v35

    Forty, the span of the wilderness generation (Num 14:33–34). It is a real count in round figures, since the manna began a month after the Exodus.

  46. שָׁנָה

    shanah · H8141

    year · v35

    Singular in form. Hebrew normally uses the singular after numbers above ten, so it means 'forty years'.

  47. עַד־

    'ad · H5704

    until · v35

    Marks where the manna period ended. The verse is defined by this end point, and the word 'until' comes twice.

  48. בֹּאָם

    bo'am · H0935

    their coming · v35

    A verbal noun with 'their' attached: 'until their coming'. The point is arriving at a destination, not wandering.

  49. נוֹשָׁבֶת

    noshavet · H3427

    inhabited · v35

    A passive form of 'to dwell', meaning 'being dwelt in' or 'inhabited'. It describes settled country with towns, fields and crops, the opposite of empty desert.

  50. קְצֵה

    qetseh · H7097

    edge, end, border · v35

    The outer edge or extremity of something. Here it is the edge of Canaan, the threshold of the promised land: Gilgal, just across the Jordan (Josh 5:10–12).

  51. כְּנָעַן

    kena'an · H3667

    Canaan · v35

    The land west of the Jordan promised to the patriarchs (Gen 12:7; 17:8). The verse ends on the promise's goal.

  52. עֲשִׂרִ֥ית

    ʿăśirît · H6224

    tenth (part) of · v36

    The feminine form of the ordinal 'tenth', used as a noun meaning 'a tenth part'. It is tied grammatically to the next word: 'the tenth of the ephah'. Here it is spelled without one of its usual vowel letters, which is common and makes no difference to the meaning.

  53. הָאֵיפָ֖ה

    hāʾêpâ · H374

    the ephah · v36

    The standard Israelite dry measure for grain, used in markets, in offerings, and in the laws about honest weights. 'The' marks it as the familiar unit everyone knew. That is why it can be used to explain the unfamiliar omer.

The world behind it

Where and when. The story places this in the Wilderness of Sin, between Elim and Sinai, one month after leaving Egypt (16:1). The people had complained that they would starve. God promised "bread from heaven" (16:4), which appeared each morning with the dew. It came with rules: gather only a day's portion, collect double on the sixth day, none falls on the Sabbath, and anything kept over goes bad (16:16–30). The verse right before this one tells us that the people rested on the seventh day. Our verse then pauses the action to name and describe the food. The next verse orders a jar of it kept "for your generations."

How people described food. A desert people had no word for this substance, so they described it by comparison with the most familiar things they knew: a common kitchen spice (coriander, well known in Egypt) and the sweetest baked food they knew (a honey cake). Sweet things were a luxury. The everyday diet in Egypt that the people remembered was bread, fish, leeks, onions and garlic (Num 11:5).

The Sinai "manna" of today. In parts of Sinai, small insects feeding on tamarisk shrubs leave behind sweet droplets. These harden into small whitish-yellow grains in the cool of early morning. Bedouin call them mann and gather them before the ants and the sun take them (F. S. Bodenheimer, 1947). Many scholars think this natural sweet resembles the description here, and possibly gave the food its name. The biblical account, however, presents a supply large enough to feed the whole people every day for forty years (16:35; Josh 5:12). It doubles on the sixth day, stops on the Sabbath, and rots if hoarded. That is far beyond the small seasonal yield of the tamarisk, and the text treats the food as a direct act of God.

From the study of Exodus 16:31.

Where scholars differ

in v31

Where does the name 'man' come from?

  • It is a play on the Israelites' question 'What is it?' (man hu), as the text itself presents it.

    Exod 16:15 explicitly links the two: 'they said to one another, "man hu?" because they did not know what it was.' A form *mn* meaning 'what/who' is found in related Semitic languages, so it may be an old or regional Hebrew form.

  • The name came from an existing word for a known desert sweet, and the 'What is it?' story is a wordplay on it.

    Arabic *mann* names the sweet tamarisk exudate in Sinai. Standard Hebrew for 'what' is *mah*, not *man*. Biblical name explanations are often wordplays rather than technical etymologies.

in v31

Is the biblical manna related to the natural tamarisk 'manna' of Sinai?

  • The description reflects a real natural phenomenon, which the tradition has magnified or framed as divine provision.

    Insect honeydew on tamarisks forms small, sweet, whitish grains at dawn and melts in the sun (compare 16:21). Bedouin call it *mann* (Bodenheimer 1947).

  • The text describes a unique miraculous provision that cannot be reduced to the natural sweet.

    The tamarisk yield is small and seasonal. The biblical food feeds the whole people daily for forty years, doubles on the sixth day, stops on the Sabbath, rots overnight, and ceases on entering Canaan (16:20–26, 35; Josh 5:12). It is also boiled and baked (16:23; Num 11:8), which honeydew is not suited to.

in v31

Did manna taste of honey (Exod 16:31) or of oil (Num 11:8)?

  • The two descriptions come from different strands of tradition that described the food differently.

    Many critical scholars assign Exod 16 and Num 11 to different literary sources. The comparisons (a honey cake versus 'cakes of oil' or 'cream of oil') differ.

  • The descriptions are compatible: one describes the raw grains, the other the food after preparation.

    Num 11:8 explicitly describes the manna after it was ground, boiled and made into cakes. Rashi and other traditional commentators also harmonise them, and later tradition said it tasted different to different eaters.

in v32

Should מלא be read as a noun (“a full omer”) or as a command (“fill the omer”)?

  • Noun “fullness of,” as in the Masoretic vowels: “a full omer of it [is to be kept].”

    The Masoretic Text points it as a noun in the construct form. A parallel noun phrase appears in v. 33 (*melo ha'omer man*, “a full omer of manna”), where it is clearly a noun after the verb “put.”

  • Command “Fill!”, as in the ancient versions.

    The Septuagint (*Plēsate*) and the Vulgate (*Imple*) both read a command, as do KJV and YLT. The unvowelled consonants allow it, and a command fits the sense of “this is what the LORD commanded.”

in v32

Why does the passage mention keeping the jar “before the Testimony” (v. 34) before the tabernacle and tablets exist?

  • An intentional look ahead: the narrator gathers the whole history of the manna at its first appearance.

    Verse 35 likewise jumps forward forty years to the entry into Canaan, and v. 36 explains the omer for later readers. The section plainly looks back from a later time.

  • Evidence that vv. 32–34 come from a later priestly layer of the book.

    Many critical scholars (e.g. Childs, Propp) link the vocabulary of “Testimony,” Aaron's role and *mishmeret* with priestly material elsewhere in Exodus and Numbers (e.g. Num 17:10).

in v33

How can Aaron place the jar 'before the Testimony' (v. 34) when the tablets and the ark have not been made yet in the story?

  • The narrator reports a later event early, to finish the manna topic: the command was carried out once the tabernacle existed.

    Medieval Jewish commentators (Rashi, Ibn Ezra) take it this way. Verse 35 also looks far ahead ('forty years… until they came to the border of Canaan'), which shows these closing verses are a summary written from a later point of view.

  • Verses 32–34 come from a priestly strand of tradition concerned with the sanctuary and were arranged by topic, not by time.

    Critical commentators (e.g., Childs, Propp) point to priestly vocabulary such as 'Testimony', 'before the LORD' and 'mishmeret', and to the similar Aaron's-staff passage in Num 17.

in v33

Was the jar inside the ark or in front of it?

  • In front of it, as the Hebrew says.

    Exod 16:33-34 says 'before the LORD' / 'before the Testimony', and Num 17:10 says the same of Aaron's staff. 1 Kings 8:9 (and 2 Chr 5:10) says that in Solomon's day the ark held nothing but the two tablets.

  • Inside the ark, at least at some period.

    Hebrews 9:4 lists 'the golden jar of manna, Aaron's staff that budded, and the tablets' in connection with the ark. Some read this as a Second Temple tradition. Others read it as describing the Most Holy Place as a whole, or as reflecting a time before Solomon. The Hebrew of Exodus itself does not say 'inside'.

in v34

How can Aaron place the manna 'before the Testimony' when the tablets and ark do not yet exist?

  • The narrator reports in advance an act that was carried out later, once the tabernacle was built.

    Rashi and Ibn Ezra ad loc.; v. 35 likewise summarises the forty years of manna in advance; the phrase 'just as Yahweh commanded' links the act to the tabernacle instructions. Most modern commentators (Sarna, Propp) agree.

  • Source-critical: vv. 32–34 come from the priestly writer, who assumes the sanctuary and its objects and has placed this material within the manna story.

    Priestly vocabulary (edut, mishmeret, 'for your generations', the obedience phrase) and Aaron's priestly role; see Childs and Propp on Exod 16. This explains how the text came to be, and is compatible with the first view as a reading of the finished text.

in v34

Was the manna jar inside the ark or in front of it?

  • In front of the ark, beside it rather than inside.

    Hebrew lifnei means 'before, in front of'. 1 Kgs 8:9 says the ark held only the two tablets. Num 17:10 places Aaron's staff 'before the Testimony' in the same way.

  • Inside the ark, at least in some period or tradition.

    Hebrews 9:4 lists the jar and staff with the tablets in connection with the ark ('in which were...'). Some argue Kings describes only Solomon's time, after the other items were gone. Others read Hebrews loosely, as describing what belonged with the ark.

in v34

What is the background of the word edut?

  • From the root 'witness': the tablets are a 'witness' to the covenant.

    Link with 'ed, 'witness', and he'id, 'to testify, warn solemnly'; the Septuagint's martyrion; Deut 31:26, where the law book is placed beside the ark 'as a witness against you'.

  • Related to the ancient Near Eastern treaty term for sworn terms (Aramaic 'dy', Akkadian adê), so it means 'covenant stipulations'.

    Sefire treaty inscriptions (8th c. BC); the treaty-like structure of Israel's covenant texts. The exact etymology is disputed, and the two views are often combined.

in v35

Do 'an inhabited land' and 'the edge of the land of Canaan' name the same place or two stages?

  • They are the same place, said twice. The second clause restates the first more precisely, in the common Hebrew pattern of saying something twice in parallel.

    The mirrored structure of the verse, and Joshua 5:10–12, which places the end of the manna at Gilgal, at the edge of Canaan.

  • They are two stages. The 'inhabited land' is the settled territory east of the Jordan (the kingdoms of Sihon and Og, Num 21), where Israel already had access to settled food. The 'edge of Canaan' is the final end point.

    Israel lived in settled country east of the Jordan before crossing (Num 21:25, 31; 32). Medieval Jewish commentators raised this possibility.

  • Rabbinic harmonisation: the manna stopped falling at one point but stored manna was still eaten until the later point.

    Babylonian Talmud Kiddushin 38a and the Mekhilta: the manna stopped falling when Moses died (7 Adar), and the people lived on what they had stored until 16 Nisan at Gilgal.

in v35

When and from whose viewpoint was this verse written?

  • A later explanatory note, part of the editing of the Pentateuch, written from a time when Israel was already in the land.

    It describes events after Moses' death (Josh 5), mentions 'the Testimony' before the ark is built, and v. 36 has to explain an obsolete measure. Critical scholars usually assign the passage to the Priestly writer or a later editor.

  • Traditional view: Moses wrote it near the end of his life, looking back over almost forty years and forward to the near future, or a later inspired editor added it.

    By the time Moses addressed Israel in Deuteronomy, the people were on the plains of Moab with the manna still falling (Deut 8:3, 16). Jewish and Christian tradition both allowed for small editorial additions such as Deut 34.

in v35

Was the manna a natural phenomenon?

  • The description draws on a known Sinai phenomenon: sweet insect secretions on tamarisk trees (Arabic *mann*), gathered at dawn.

    Similar appearance, timing (morning, melts in the sun) and sweetness. Reported by travellers and naturalists since the 19th century.

  • The text presents something that cannot be reduced to that phenomenon.

    Tamarisk manna is seasonal (early summer), small in quantity, and does not breed worms or follow a six-day/Sabbath pattern. Exodus describes enough for a whole nation, all year, for forty years, doubled on the sixth day and absent on the Sabbath.

in v36

Who added this explanatory note, and when?

  • It is an editorial gloss from a time after the wilderness period, when the omer was no longer in use.

    The verse steps outside the story to explain a unit, as other later glosses do (1 Sam 9:9). Verse 35 already looks back on forty years and the entry into Canaan. The Septuagint's past tense ('was') reads it the same way.

  • It belongs to the Mosaic or early narrative itself and is written for future generations.

    Traditional Jewish commentators such as Rashi and Ibn Ezra treat it as part of the giving of the text. Verses 32–33 explicitly look ahead to later generations seeing the jar, so a note explaining the measure fits that forward-looking frame.

in v36

How large was the ephah, and therefore the omer?

  • About 22 litres for the ephah, so about 2.2 litres for the omer.

    Based on reconstructions of jars inscribed 'bath' (the liquid equal of the ephah, Ezek 45:11) from Lachish and Tell Beit Mirsim. This is the figure most commonly given in reference works.

  • A smaller ephah of about 10–15 litres, so an omer of about 1–1.5 litres.

    The jar reconstructions are fragmentary, and some scholars work from other data such as later rabbinic egg-volume equivalents (an omer = 43⅕ eggs, b. Eruvin 83b). Measures also varied by period and region.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).