Exodus Chapter 21 Read as one passage

Exodus 21:33–36

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

33If a man opens or digs a pit and fails to cover it, and an ox or a donkey falls into it, 34the owner of the pit shall make restitution; he must pay its owner, and the dead animal will be his. 35If a man’s ox injures his neighbor’s ox and it dies, they must sell the live one and divide the proceeds; they also must divide the dead animal. 36But if it was known that the ox had a habit of goring, yet its owner failed to restrain it, he shall pay full compensation, ox for ox, and the dead animal will be his.

What the first hearers heard

To Israelite farmers and herders, this was a familiar and practical scenario. Cisterns were everywhere, animals grazed freely, and an open cistern could cost a neighbor his ox. The law taught several things.

  • Responsibility follows the hazard. Whoever opens or digs a pit becomes its "owner" in the legal sense (v. 34, ba'al ha-bor, "master of the pit") and answers for what it does.
  • Fault lies in neglect, not intent. No one meant to kill the animal. The wrong is failing to take a simple precaution ("and does not cover it").
  • The remedy is restoration, not punishment. The ruling in v. 34 is compensation in silver, and the negligent party keeps the carcass. The aim is to make the injured neighbor whole without destroying the one at fault.

This fits the wider concern of the Book of the Covenant that life within a community bound to God includes care for a neighbor's livelihood. Compare 23:4–5, which tells an Israelite to return even an enemy's straying ox or donkey and to help with his fallen donkey.

From the study of Exodus 21:33.

Verse by verse

  1. 33If a man opens or digs a pit and fails to cover it, and an ox or a donkey falls into it,

    "Suppose someone uncovers a pit, or someone digs a new one, and leaves it open with no lid over it. And suppose a head of cattle or a donkey wanders over and falls down into it…"

    The verse sets up a legal case, and the ruling comes in the next verse (21:34): the person responsible for the pit pays the animal's owner in silver and keeps the dead animal. The "pit" is most likely a cistern, a narrow-mouthed, bell-shaped chamber cut into rock to store rainwater. Every village needed them, and an animal that fell into one was usually killed or lost. The two verbs, "opens" and "digs," cover both ways of creating the danger: exposing an old pit or excavating a new one. "A man" here simply means "anyone." The decisive words are "and does not cover it." The law does not blame anyone for having a cistern. It blames them for leaving it open when a simple stone or lid would have prevented the loss. "Ox or donkey" names the two working animals every farming household depended on, and they stand for valuable livestock generally.

    Full study →
  2. 34the owner of the pit shall make restitution; he must pay its owner, and the dead animal will be his.

    If someone opens up a pit or digs a new one and leaves it uncovered, and a neighbour's ox or donkey falls in and dies (v. 33), then the one responsible for the pit must make the loss whole. He pays it back in silver, weighed out to the value of the animal, to the animal's owner. The word for 'owner' is the same in both places: one ba'al answers to another. The carcass then becomes his, the pit owner's, so the meat, hide and horn he takes over count toward what he has paid. The law sets no punishment, only full compensation. The goal is that the injured neighbour is left whole and the careless one bears the cost of his carelessness. (An old Jewish reading takes 'his' to mean the animal's owner instead: he keeps the carcass, and the pit owner pays the difference. Either way, the neighbour ends up made whole.)

    Full study →
  3. 35If a man’s ox injures his neighbor’s ox and it dies, they must sell the live one and divide the proceeds; they also must divide the dead animal.

    "And if one man's ox butts another man's ox, and the struck animal dies, then the two owners together shall sell the surviving ox and split its silver exactly in half. And the dead ox too, its carcass and whatever it is worth, they shall split in half."

    This is a case of an accident with no one to blame. Two animals belonging to two members of the community fight, and one is killed. Nobody knew the surviving ox was dangerous; that situation is covered separately in the next verse. So the law does not ask who pays whom. It treats the loss as something the two households share. Both animals are turned into value that can be shared: the living ox is sold for weighed silver, and the dead ox still has meat, hide and horn. Then everything is cut down the middle. If the oxen were worth about the same, each owner ends up with half a live ox's price plus half a carcass, so each bears half the loss.

    The wording repeats the point. "Halve" opens and closes the ruling, and the final verb has an older, fuller ending that gives the last word weight: the dead one, too, they shall halve. The "living" ox and the "dead" ox are set side by side so that nothing is left out of the reckoning. The verb for the blow is a broad "strike/butt", not the specific "gore" of the surrounding verses. It is the same word ancient Babylonian lawyers used for this exact case.

    Full study →
  4. 36But if it was known that the ox had a habit of goring, yet its owner failed to restrain it, he shall pay full compensation, ox for ox, and the dead animal will be his.

    "Or suppose it was already common knowledge that this ox was a gorer, and had been for some time, and yet its owner did not keep it penned or watched. Then he must pay, and pay in full: a live ox to replace the ox that died. The carcass then belongs to him."

    This verse is the second half of a pair. Verse 35 covers an ox that kills a neighbour's ox with no warning. Nobody could have seen it coming, so the two households split the loss: they sell the live ox, share the price, and share the carcass. Verse 36 changes one fact. The animal was a known gorer (the Hebrew word itself describes a habit, not a single act), its behaviour was public knowledge "from yesterday and the day before", and the owner did nothing. That turns misfortune into negligence. The doubled Hebrew verb ("paying, he shall pay") makes the full payment non-negotiable. The verb's root is the root of shalom: the payment makes the neighbour whole again. "Ox in place of the ox" uses the same substitution word as "eye for eye" a few verses earlier, and here it plainly means a like-for-like replacement or its value. The negligent owner, having paid for a whole live animal, keeps what is left of the dead one. That way the injured neighbour is restored exactly and does not end up with more than he lost.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v33

    pit

    bor

    What we hear
    A rough hole or ditch in the ground.
    What they heard
    Usually a rock-cut, plastered water cistern (or storage pit), deep and narrow-mouthed, a normal and necessary part of village life that was normally kept covered with a stone.
  • in v33

    ox

    shor

    What we hear
    Specifically a castrated draft bull.
    What they heard
    Any single head of cattle: bull, cow or ox. It was a household's most valuable working animal.
  • in v33

    a man

    'ish

    What we hear
    A male person specifically.
    What they heard
    In case law, 'anyone, a person', whoever is responsible.
  • in v34

    money (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    kesef

    What we hear
    Coins or currency handed over as payment.
    What they heard
    Silver weighed out on scales by the shekel (a unit of weight). No coins existed in Israel when this law was framed or applied.
  • in v35

    neighbor's ox

    šôr rēʿēhû

    What we hear
    The ox belonging to the person who lives next door.
    What they heard
    'His fellow's ox', meaning simply another person's ox. 'A man… his fellow' is the Hebrew idiom for 'one… another', with the added sense of a fellow member of the community.
  • in v35

    divide the money of it

    wəḥāṣû ʾet-kaspô

    What we hear
    Split the cash, i.e. currency from the sale.
    What they heard
    'Halve its silver': split exactly in two the weighed silver paid for the live ox. There was no coinage in Israel when this law took shape.
  • in v35

    ox

    šôr

    What we hear
    A castrated draft steer.
    What they heard
    Any single head of cattle. Here the animal is most likely a bull, since bulls are the ones that typically fight to the death.
  • in v36

    ox

    shôr

    What we hear
    A castrated male draft animal, as distinct from a bull or cow.
    What they heard
    Any single head of cattle: bull, cow, steer or ox. Hebrew does not mark gender or castration in this word. A goring animal in a herd was quite likely an uncastrated bull.
  • in v36

    used to push (KJV)

    naggāḥ

    What we hear
    Shoving or nudging, something minor.
    What they heard
    Habitually goring with the horns, a deadly behaviour.
Every word
  1. וְכִֽי־

    vekhi · H3588A

    and if, when · v33, v35, v36

    Opens a new case in the law code: 'And if / when such-and-such happens…'. Here it does not mean 'for' or 'because'; it sets up a hypothetical situation that the next verse will rule on.

  2. יִפְתַּ֨ח

    yiftach · H6605A

    to open · v33

    To open up or uncover. The picture is someone removing the cover from a pit that already exists, such as a cistern, and leaving it open.

  3. אִ֜ישׁ

    'ish · H0376I

    man, anyone · v33, v35

    In case law this means 'a person, anyone', the person responsible. It does not single out males as the only people who could be liable.

  4. בּ֗וֹר

    bor · H0953A

    pit, cistern · v33, v34

    A pit dug or cut into the ground. In Israel this was usually a water cistern cut into rock, sometimes a storage pit. It was deep and steep-sided, and an animal that fell in usually died.

  5. א֠וֹ

    'o · H0176A

    or · v33, v36

    Brings in the second way the hazard can come about.

  6. יִכְרֶ֥ה

    yikhreh · H3738B

    to dig · v33

    To dig or excavate. This is the second scenario: making a new pit rather than uncovering an old one. The dictionary listing 'pierce' comes from other passages. Here the sense is plainly 'dig'.

  7. וְלֹ֣א

    velo' · H3808

    and not · v33, v36

    'And does not…'. This negative is where the fault lies. Liability comes from leaving the pit open, not from digging it.

  8. יְכַסֶּ֑נּוּ

    yekhassennu · H3680

    to cover · v33

    'He covers it', meaning he closes off the opening with a stone, boards or some other lid. Failing to take this ordinary precaution is the negligence.

  9. וְנָֽפַל־

    venafal · H5307G

    to fall · v33

    'And it falls'. This is the harmful result that makes the case.

  10. שָׁ֥מָּה

    shammah · H8033G

    there, thither · v33

    'There' with an ending that shows direction: 'into there', down into the pit.

  11. שּׁ֖וֹר

    shor · H7794

    ox, head of cattle · v33, v35, v36

    A single head of cattle, male or female, bull, cow or draft ox. It was the most valuable farm animal, used for ploughing and threshing.

  12. חֲמֽוֹר׃

    chamor · H2543

    donkey · v33

    The donkey, the ordinary pack and riding animal. 'Ox or donkey' is a standard pair in this law code (compare 22:4, 22:9; 23:4–5) and stands for valuable livestock in general.

  13. בַּ֤עַל

    ba'al · H1167

    owner, master, lord, husband · v34, v36

    'The owner of', the person who holds the pit. In this law it means the one responsible for it, the man who opened or dug it in v. 33, and not necessarily who owns the land.

  14. יְשַׁלֵּ֔ם

    yeshallem · H7999

    (piel) make whole, repay, compensate · v34, v36

    'He shall make it whole', meaning he must pay back the loss so the injured owner is left complete again. This is the standard word for compensation all through the damage laws that follow (21:36–22:15).

  15. כֶּ֖סֶף

    kesef · H3701

    silver, money · v34, v35

    'Silver', put first in its clause for emphasis. He pays in silver measured by weight, not by handing over a live animal of his own (compare 21:36, 'ox for ox').

  16. יָשִׁ֣יב

    yashiv · H7725

    (hiphil) bring back, return, give back · v34

    'He shall give back': the silver goes back to the injured party to restore what the negligence took from him.

  17. וְהַמֵּ֖ת

    vehammet · H4191

    to die; (participle) the dead one · v34, v35, v36

    'And the dead [animal]': the carcass of the ox or donkey. It still had value as meat, hide and horn.

  18. יִֽהְיֶה־

    yihyeh- · H1961

    to be, become · v34, v36

    'Shall be / shall become [belonging to]'. With 'to him' that follows, it is the ordinary Hebrew way of saying who owns something.

  19. לּֽוֹ

    lo · H9033

    to him, his · v34, v36

    'His'. Grammatically it most naturally means the pit owner, the subject of the verbs before it. But it could refer back to the nearer noun 'its owner', and classical Jewish interpretation took it that way (see Debates). A closed-paragraph marker (ס, setumah) follows in the Hebrew text.

  20. יִגֹּ֧ף

    yiggōp · H5062

    to strike, push, butt · v35

    The ox 'strikes' or 'butts' the other ox. It is a broad verb for striking a blow, not the specific 'gore' verb (nāgaḥ) used in vv. 28–32. It matches the Akkadian verb used in the equivalent Babylonian-era law.

  21. אֶת־

    ʾet · H0853

    (object marker) · v35

    Untranslatable marker that tells you the next noun, the neighbor's ox, is the one being struck.

  22. רֵעֵ֖הוּ

    rēʿēhû · H7453

    fellow, companion, neighbor, another · v35

    'His fellow', meaning another member of the community. With 'a man' it means simply 'another person's ox', with no suggestion that the two live next door.

  23. וּמָ֨כְר֜וּ

    ûmākərû · H4376

    to sell · v35

    'Then they shall sell'. 'They' is plural: both owners act together. The verb form marks the start of the ruling.

  24. הַחַי֙

    haḥay · H2416A

    living, alive · v35

    'The living one'. This sets it against 'the dead one' at the end of the verse. Both animals are dealt with.

  25. וְחָצ֣וּ

    wəḥāṣû · H2673

    to divide in half · v35

    'And they shall halve'. Not just 'share out' but split into two equal halves, one for each owner.

  26. וְגַ֥ם

    wəgam · H1571

    and also · v35

    'And also'. This adds the second asset. The dead animal is not forgotten, because its meat and hide still had value.

  27. נוֹדַ֗ע

    nôdaʿ · H3045

    to know; (passive) be known · v36

    A passive form, 'it had become known': the animal's habit was common knowledge. It does not require the formal warning mentioned in v. 29, only that the owner could not honestly say he was unaware.

  28. נַגָּ֥ח

    naggāḥ · H5056

    given to goring · v36

    An adjective built on a pattern that marks a habit or trait: 'a gorer', an animal known for it. The word itself carries the idea of habit, so 'had a habit of goring' is accurate.

  29. הוּא֙

    hûʾ · H1931

    he, she, it · v36

    'It (was)': with no verb, this pronoun links the subject to its description, 'that the ox was a gorer.'

  30. מִתְּמ֣וֹל

    mittemôl · H8543

    yesterday, formerly · v36

    'From yesterday'. It is the first half of a fixed idiom meaning 'in the past, before now.'

  31. שִׁלְשֹׁ֔ם

    shilshōm · H8032

    three days ago, previously · v36

    'The day before yesterday'. With the previous word it means 'previously, already before this'. It is not a count of three incidents in the plain sense, though the rabbis later read it that way.

  32. יִשְׁמְרֶ֖נּוּ

    yishmərennû · H8104I

    keep, guard, watch over · v36

    'He did not guard it': he did not pen it, tether it or watch it. The same verb is used for keeping a garden, a flock or a commandment. Here it means the owner's duty of active control.

  33. תַּ֣חַת

    taḥat · H8478H

    under; in place of · v36

    'In place of'. This is the same word as in 'eye for eye' (v. 24) and means one-for-one substitution.

The world behind it

Where the verse sits. Exodus 21:33 belongs to the "Book of the Covenant" (Exod 20:22–23:33), the first collection of laws given after the Ten Commandments. Most of it is case law: "If X happens, then Y is the ruling." This verse is the "if" half, and verse 34 gives the "then."

A block about animals and damage. Verses 28–36 deal with harm involving cattle: an ox that gores a person (28–32), an animal falling into a pit (33–34), and one ox goring another (35–36). Other ancient Near Eastern codes also set out goring-ox cases, notably the Laws of Eshnunna (about 1800 BC) §§53–55 and the Laws of Hammurabi §§250–252. That shows this was a recognized type of legal problem across the region. Those codes have no close parallel to the pit case itself, though Hammurabi has similar rules on negligence, such as a man who fails to maintain his dike and floods a neighbor's field (§§53–56).

Cisterns. Israel's hill country had few springs. From the Iron Age (about 1200 BC on), people cut cisterns into the limestone and plastered them to catch winter rain. They were deep, with a narrow neck and a wide chamber, and were normally sealed with a stone. Joseph was thrown into such a bor (Gen 37:24), and so was Jeremiah (Jer 38:6). A dry cistern made a ready-made prison because no one could climb out. An ox or donkey grazing across open ground could easily step into an uncovered one.

The value of the animals. An ox ploughed and threshed, and a donkey carried loads and people. Losing either could threaten a family's harvest and income. So the ruling in verse 34 restores the owner's economic position with a payment in silver. The pit owner receives the carcass, which still had value (the hide, for instance).

From the study of Exodus 21:33.

Where scholars differ

in v33

What exactly is the difference between 'opens' and 'digs' a pit?

  • Two acts: uncovering an existing cistern versus excavating a new one. Both create liability.

    The ordinary meanings of patach ('open, uncover') and karah ('dig'). Rabbinic interpretation (Mekhilta, Bava Kamma) takes it this way. NIV's 'uncovers' reflects this view.

  • A stylistic pairing meaning in effect 'makes or leaves open a pit by any means', without a sharp legal distinction.

    Hebrew law often pairs near-synonyms to cover a whole range of situations. The ruling in v. 34 is the same for both.

in v33

Who is the 'owner of the pit' (v. 34) who pays: the digger or the landowner?

  • Whoever opened or dug it and left it uncovered, even in a public place.

    V. 33 makes 'anyone' who opens or digs the subject, and v. 34 calls him ba'al ha-bor. The Mishnah treats the classic case as a pit dug in the public domain (m. Bava Kamma 3:1; 5:5).

  • The person who controls the property where the pit is.

    Ba'al ordinarily means 'owner, master', and cisterns usually belonged to households. The text does not discuss pits on private land, and later law had to fill in that case.

in v34

Whose is 'the dead animal'? Who keeps the carcass, and how is payment calculated?

  • The pit owner (the payer) keeps the carcass after paying the animal's full value.

    The subject of the verbs before it ('shall make whole', 'shall give back') is the pit owner, so 'to him' most naturally points to him. Compare the parallel structure in 21:36, where the one who pays 'ox for ox' gets the dead ox. Most modern translations (e.g. NLT explicitly) and many modern commentaries (e.g. Sarna, Propp) read it this way.

  • The injured owner keeps the carcass, and the pit owner pays only the difference between the live animal's value and the carcass's value.

    Rabbinic interpretation (Mekhilta, Nezikin; Babylonian Talmud Bava Kamma 10b; followed by Rashi on this verse) takes 'his' to mean the injured party, the nearer noun 'its owner'. The carcass is valued and counted toward the payment. Economically the outcome is nearly the same as the first view: the injured owner is made whole either way. The difference is who bears the trouble of disposing of or selling the carcass.

in v35

How is Exodus 21:35 related to Laws of Eshnunna §53?

  • Shared legal tradition: Israel and Mesopotamia drew on a common body of customary 'case law' or scribal legal teaching, so neither copied the other directly.

    The goring-ox case appears across several collections (Eshnunna, Hammurabi, Exodus) with variations. Eshnunna's text is about a millennium older and geographically distant (Westbrook; Finkelstein, 'The Ox That Gored'; Yaron).

  • Literary dependence: the Covenant Code's authors knew Mesopotamian law texts, especially Hammurabi, and reworked them.

    The order and wording of the goring-ox sequence follow Mesopotamian models closely, and Hammurabi was copied widely in scribal schools for centuries (D. P. Wright, Inventing God's Law). The ox-vs-ox case itself, though, is found only in Eshnunna, which complicates any direct-copying model.

in v35

Does the rule mean 'pool and halve both animals' or 'pay half the damage'?

  • Literal pooling: the live ox is sold and the price and carcass are split equally, whatever each animal was worth.

    This is the plain sense of the Hebrew and the identical Eshnunna wording. It is a simple, enforceable village remedy that works best when the animals are of similar value.

  • Half damages: the owner of the striking ox compensates half the loss.

    Rabbinic reading (Mishnah Bava Qamma), which notes that pooling unequal animals could be unjust. It gives the same result as literal pooling when the oxen are of equal value.

in v36

Who gets the dead animal: the negligent owner who pays, or the injured neighbour?

  • The negligent owner who pays keeps the carcass.

    In the pit case just before (21:34), the same phrase, 'and the dead shall be his', most naturally refers to the one who pays. Having paid for a whole live ox, he takes the remains, and the injured party is restored exactly. The Vulgate's 'wholly his', most modern commentators (e.g. Sarna, Propp) and NIV/NLT-style renderings follow this.

  • The injured neighbour keeps the carcass, and the negligent owner pays the difference.

    Rabbinic interpretation (Mekhilta; Babylonian Talmud Bava Kamma 10b–11a) reads 'his' as the injured party. The damager pays the gap between a live ox and the carcass's value, and any further drop in the carcass's value falls on the injured party. The Hebrew pronoun allows either reading, and in practice the two produce the same financial result.

in v36

How is Exodus 21:35–36 related to the Laws of Eshnunna and Hammurabi?

  • Shared legal tradition

    Ox-goring was a standard 'textbook' case in ancient Near Eastern law, taught and copied in scribal schools. Exodus draws on that common stock of cases and reshapes it (e.g. stoning an ox that kills a human, and extending negligence liability to ox-on-ox cases). J. J. Finkelstein, R. Westbrook and others.

  • Direct literary dependence

    Verse 35 matches Eshnunna §53 almost word for word, and the order and wording of the Covenant Code track Hammurabi's laws closely. D. P. Wright (*Inventing God's Law*) argues the Covenant Code was written using Hammurabi's laws as a direct model. Critics answer that Eshnunna §53 has no counterpart in Hammurabi, so some other route of transmission must be assumed.

in v36

Does 'ox in place of the ox' tell us how 'eye for eye' (v. 24) worked?

  • Yes: the taḥat formula means equivalence, often in money.

    In vv. 34–36 and 22:1, the same 'X in place of Y' wording plainly means replacement or value. Rabbinic law took 'eye for eye' as monetary compensation (Bava Kamma 83b–84a), and the nearby laws allow money in place of a life (21:30).

  • Not necessarily: bodily injury may have been treated differently.

    Property cases naturally call for replacement, while injuries to persons may have kept a literal principle of retaliation, at least in theory. Hammurabi §§196–200 apply literal talion between social equals, and Lev 24:19–20 adds 'as he has done, so shall it be done to him.'

Sources
  • BDB s.v. בּוֹר, כָּרָה, כָּסָה, שׁוֹר
  • HALOT s.v. בּוֹר, שׁוֹר
  • Septuagint, Exodus 21:33
  • Vulgate, Exodus 21:33
  • Mishnah Bava Kamma 1:1; 3:1; 5:5–6
  • Babylonian Talmud Bava Kamma 28b, 54a
  • Laws of Eshnunna §§53–55; Laws of Hammurabi §§53–56, 250–252 (M. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exodus 21
  • N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus
  • BDB s.v. בַּעַל, שָׁלֵם, כֶּסֶף, שׁוּב
  • HALOT s.v. בַּעַל, שׁלם (piel), כֶּסֶף
  • Laws of Eshnunna §53; Laws of Hammurabi §§53–56 (M. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor)
  • Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael, Nezikin
  • Babylonian Talmud, Bava Kamma 10b; Mishnah Bava Kamma 5:5–7
  • Rashi on Exodus 21:34
  • W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 19–40 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Exodus 21:34; Vulgate, Exodus 21:34
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. נָגַף, שׁוֹר, רֵעַ, חָצָה, כֶּסֶף
  • Laws of Eshnunna §§53–55 (M. T. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor)
  • Laws of Hammurabi §§250–252
  • J. J. Finkelstein, The Ox That Gored (1981)
  • R. Westbrook, Studies in Biblical and Cuneiform Law
  • D. P. Wright, Inventing God's Law (2009)
  • R. Yaron, The Laws of Eshnunna
  • Mishnah Bava Qamma 1:4; 3:9
  • Septuagint, Exodus 21:35
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Exod 21:28–36
  • BDB s.v. נַגָּח, שָׁלֵם, תְּמוֹל, שִׁלְשֹׁם
  • HALOT s.v. נַגָּח; שׁלם (piel)
  • Laws of Eshnunna §§53–54 and Code of Hammurabi §§250–252, in M. T. Roth, Law Collections from Mesopotamia and Asia Minor (SBL Writings from the Ancient World)
  • W. H. C. Propp, Exodus 19–40 (Anchor Bible)
  • N. M. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Exodus
  • Mishnah Bava Kamma 1:4; 2:4; Babylonian Talmud Bava Kamma 10b–11a; Mekhilta de-Rabbi Ishmael on Exod 21:36

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).