Ezra Chapter 3 Read as one passage

Ezra 3:10–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10When the builders had laid the foundation of the temple of the LORD, the priests in their apparel with trumpets, and the Levites (the sons of Asaph) with cymbals, took their positions to praise the LORD, as David king of Israel had prescribed. 11And they sang responsively with praise and thanksgiving to the LORD: “For He is good; for His loving devotion to Israel endures forever.” Then all the people gave a great shout of praise to the LORD, because the foundation of the house of the LORD had been laid. 12But many of the older priests, Levites, and family heads who had seen the first temple wept loudly when they saw the foundation of this temple. Still, many others shouted joyfully. 13The people could not distinguish the shouts of joy from the sound of weeping, because the people were making so much noise. And the sound was heard from afar.

What the first hearers heard

For the returnees and the first readers of Ezra–Nehemiah, probably in the later Persian period, this verse said that legitimate worship had been restored, without a break, from Israel's founding king.

  • Continuity over novelty. Everything is done "according to David". The vested priests, the silver trumpets, Asaph's guild and the cymbals are the old order, not an innovation. For a community whose temple had been burned and whose monarchy was gone, this was reassurance that nothing essential had been lost.
  • God's house before human politics. The heikhal is YHWH's palace. With no Davidic king on the throne, the community's centre is the house of the divine King, and David's authority survives in how worship is arranged.
  • Proper order and legitimacy. The text names the builders, the priests and the Levites separately, each in its role. Ezra 2 had just checked who could serve as priest (2:61-63). The ceremony shows the purified community acting correctly.
  • Echo of the First Temple's dedication. Hearers who knew the Chronicler's account (2 Chr 5:12-13) would hear the dedication repeated. This prepares for v. 11's song of YHWH's lasting hesed (loyal covenant love) toward Israel. Israel's story had not ended in exile.
  • Mixed emotion ahead. The ceremony leads into the shouts of the young and the weeping of the old who remembered the first house (3:12-13). The verse opens a scene that is both joyful and painful.

From the study of Ezra 3:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10When the builders had laid the foundation of the temple of the LORD, the priests in their apparel with trumpets, and the Levites (the sons of Asaph) with cymbals, took their positions to praise the LORD, as David king of Israel had prescribed.

    When the workmen had re-founded the palace of YHWH, setting the house of Israel's divine King back on its ruined base, the leaders stationed the priests at their posts. The priests wore their sacred vestments, garments the returning families had just donated, and carried the long silver signal-trumpets that only priests could blow. Beside them stood the Levite singers of the hereditary guild of Asaph, with their pairs of bronze cymbals. All of them were placed there to raise loud, public acclaim to YHWH, arranged exactly as David, king of Israel, had once set things in order for the worship of his God.

    Several things in the verse carry more weight than the English shows:

    • "Founded" is not a groundbreaking. The builders were working on the ruins of Solomon's temple, destroyed about fifty years earlier. The verb names the formal re-establishment of the building on its old footing.
    • "Temple" is literally "palace." The building was the royal residence of the God being praised.
    • The priests are "clothed" in the passive form, "vested." That is, ritually equipped for office.
    • "Upon the hands of David" is an idiom for David's own arrangements.

    The whole scene deliberately re-enacts the dedication of the First Temple (2 Chr 5:12-13): the same instruments, the same two orders of clergy, and in the next verse the same song. In a province with no king, "David king of Israel" is the authority under which worship begins again.

    Full study →
  2. 11And they sang responsively with praise and thanksgiving to the LORD: “For He is good; for His loving devotion to Israel endures forever.” Then all the people gave a great shout of praise to the LORD, because the foundation of the house of the LORD had been laid.

    Two choirs of Levites sang back and forth to Yahweh, praising him out loud and openly declaring what he had done. One side sang, "For he is good!" and the other answered, "For his loyal, covenant-keeping love lasts on and on, resting over Israel!"

    These were the very words Israel had sung when Solomon's temple was dedicated. Jeremiah had promised they would be heard again in the ruined city. Now the returned exiles sang them over the bare site of the temple, and they added the words "over Israel": this small, poor community was claiming that God's loyalty to his people had outlasted the exile.

    Then the whole crowd raised a great cry, the same kind of ritual cheer Israel once gave when the ark of God arrived or a king was hailed. That cheer was itself praise to Yahweh, because the house of Yahweh had now been founded. The work was only begun, not finished. The love "rests upon" Israel, and the shout "rests upon" the founding of the house; the same small Hebrew word ties the two halves of the verse together.

    Full study →
  3. 12But many of the older priests, Levites, and family heads who had seen the first temple wept loudly when they saw the foundation of this temple. Still, many others shouted joyfully.

    Many of the priests, the Levites and the heads of the ancestral clans were old men. They had seen the first house of God, Solomon's temple, standing on its foundations before the Babylonians burned it. Now this new house lay in front of them, both in plain sight and as they weighed it in their minds, and they kept on weeping aloud. This was not quiet tears but full-voiced wailing, as loud as any lament.

    Beside them, many others raised the ringing acclamation. This was the same festival shout Israel gave when the ark came into the camp or a king was hailed, now lifted up to the LORD, full of feast-day joy, their voices rising high.

    The verse is built as a pair: 'many' and 'many', a 'great voice' of weeping and a lifted 'voice' of joy. It does not rank them or rebuke either group. Grief for what had been lost and joy at what was beginning go up together from the same ceremony, and the next verse says nobody could tell the two sounds apart.

    Full study →
  4. 13The people could not distinguish the shouts of joy from the sound of weeping, because the people were making so much noise. And the sound was heard from afar.

    All through the ceremony the people could not tell the ringing shout of festival joy apart from the sound of the people weeping. The whole assembly kept raising a great shout: the same acclamation Israel had always raised for the ark and for its King, with the priests' trumpets and the Levites' cymbals sounding. The weeping was just as loud: old priests, Levites and clan heads who remembered Solomon's temple, destroyed some fifty years before, were lamenting aloud. The narrator does not split the crowd into happy young people and sad old people. Both are 'the people', and the verse says so three times. Joy and grief are each given the same word, 'sound'. Then they merge into a single 'sound' that carried a great way off, beyond the ruined city, far enough for neighbours (and, in the next verse, enemies) to hear. The foundation of the LORD's house was greeted with one voice made of thanksgiving and mourning together, and Israel itself could not separate the two.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    laid the foundation

    yissedu (yasad)

    What we hear
    Digging and pouring a brand-new foundation on an empty site, the first construction step.
    What they heard
    Formally founding or re-establishing the house on its old site, probably clearing and restoring the ruined platform and foundation courses of Solomon's temple, marked by a ceremony. Several biblical texts date the 'founding' to different moments.
  • in v10

    trumpets

    chatsotserot

    What we hear
    Brass trumpets as in a band or orchestra, or loosely any horn, including the shofar.
    What they heard
    Straight hammered-silver signal trumpets reserved for priests, sounded at sacred occasions 'as a remembrance before God' (Num 10:10). They are distinct from the ram's-horn shofar.
  • in v11

    his mercy endureth for ever (KJV)

    chesed

    What we hear
    God's pity or leniency toward people who deserve punishment.
    What they heard
    Yahweh's loyal, committed love toward the people he is bound to by covenant. It is faithfulness shown in action, and it often goes beyond what is owed. Here it is shown in bringing Israel home and letting the temple be rebuilt.
  • in v12

    ancient men (KJV)

    zəqēnîm

    What we hear
    Men from antiquity, or men of an earlier age.
    What they heard
    Old men: the aged members of these leading groups, old enough to remember Solomon's temple.
  • in v12

    chief of the fathers (KJV)

    rāʾšê hāʾābôt

    What we hear
    Leading patriarchs, or senior fathers in a family sense.
    What they heard
    Heads of the 'fathers' houses', the extended ancestral clans that were the basic units of the returning community. These were recognised clan leaders.
  • in v12

    the foundation of this house was laid

    yāsad

    What we hear
    A groundbreaking on an empty site, with new footings poured from scratch.
    What they heard
    The founding or refounding of the temple. This may have included restoring and building on the surviving Solomonic platform and foundations, and it was marked as a formal ceremony.
  • in v13

    the shout of joy / so much noise

    teru'ah

    What we hear
    Spontaneous cheering, a happy crowd yelling.
    What they heard
    The recognised communal acclamation of Israel, the same cry raised for the ark, for a king's enthronement, in holy war and with trumpets. Here it greets the LORD's house, sounding with the priests' trumpets.
  • in v13

    noise (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    qol

    What we hear
    Unwanted racket or din, as if the scene were chaotic.
    What they heard
    Simply 'sound' or 'voice', with no negative tone. It is the same word as in the prophetic promise 'the sound of joy and the sound of gladness' (Jer 33:11).
Every word
  1. וְיִסְּד֥וּ

    veyissedu · H3245

    and they founded · v10, v11, v12

    An intensive-stem verb (Piel) meaning to found, establish, or set a building on its base. Here it marks the official 'founding' of the rebuilt temple. It probably means restoring and re-laying the platform of the destroyed building, not breaking new ground. The unusual verb form with 'and' works as a time clause: 'when the builders founded…'.

  2. הַבֹּנִ֖ים

    habbonim · H1129

    the builders · v10

    An active participle used as a noun, 'those who build'. It means the hired masons and carpenters of 3:7, who were paid in money, food and oil. The text keeps the workmen's role separate from the priests' and Levites' liturgy that follows.

  3. אֶת־

    et- · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v10, v12

    An untranslatable particle that marks 'the temple of YHWH' as the thing being founded.

  4. הֵיכַ֣ל

    heikhal · H1964

    palace, temple · v10

    A very old word that came through Akkadian ekallu from Sumerian é-gal, 'great house'. It means a king's palace or a god's palace. It presents the temple as the royal residence of Israel's divine King, not simply a meeting hall.

  5. יְהוָ֑ה

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh (LORD) · v10, v11

    The personal name of Israel's God, which English Bibles conventionally write as 'the LORD'. The palace belongs to this named God, the one who brought the exiles back.

  6. וַיַּעֲמִידוּ֩

    vayya'amidu · H5975

    and they stationed / appointed · v10

    The causative form of 'stand': to set someone in position or assign them to a post. As written, an unnamed 'they' (the leaders) stationed the priests and Levites at their posts. Ancient versions read it as 'they stood'.

  7. הַכֹּהֲנִ֨ים

    hakkohanim · H3548

    the priests · v10, v12

    The hereditary Aaronic priests, who were in charge of the altar and the sacred trumpets. Their genealogy had just been checked (2:36-39, 61-63).

  8. מְלֻבָּשִׁ֜ים

    melubbashim · H3847

    clothed, vested · v10

    A passive participle, literally 'having been clothed'. In context it means dressed in the official priestly garments. Those garments had just been donated: 2:69 lists 100 priestly tunics given by the families.

  9. בַּחֲצֹֽצְר֗וֹת

    bachatsotserot · H2689

    with the trumpets · v10

    The straight metal trumpets, usually silver, that the priests blew (Num 10:1-10). They are not the ram's-horn shofar. Their blast signalled a sacred occasion and served as a 'remembrance before God'.

  10. וְהַלְוִיִּ֤ם

    vehalviyyim · H3881

    and the Levites · v10, v12

    Members of the tribe of Levi who were not priests and served in the temple. Here it means specifically the singers' guild.

  11. בְּנֵֽי־

    benei- · H1121

    sons of · v10

    Means members of a hereditary guild or clan, not necessarily literal sons. Ezra 2:41 counts 128 'sons of Asaph', the singers.

  12. אָסָף֙

    Asaf · H623

    Asaph · v10

    The Levite whom David appointed as chief musician (1 Chr 16:4-7). His name is attached to Psalms 50 and 73–83. His guild carried on the Davidic musical tradition.

  13. בַּֽמְצִלְתַּ֔יִם

    bamtsiltayim · H4700

    with the cymbals · v10

    The form is dual, meaning a pair of clashing bronze cymbals. Asaph himself played them (1 Chr 16:5). They probably marked the start of the singing and the breaks in it, rather than keeping a running beat.

  14. לְהַלֵּל֙

    lehallel · H1984

    to praise · v10, v11

    An infinitive meaning 'in order to praise'. Hallel is loud, public acclaim of someone's greatness, the root of 'hallelujah'. Verse 11 says what was sung: 'For he is good; his loyal love toward Israel is forever.'

  15. עַל־

    al- · H5921

    upon, according to · v10, v11

    Together with 'hands' it forms the idiom 'according to the direction of' or 'under the arrangement of'.

  16. יְדֵ֖י

    yedei · H3027

    hands of · v10

    'Upon the hands of David' is an idiom for David's arrangements or appointments. It is the same phrase used when David organises the singers in 1 Chr 25:2, 6. It does not mean David physically played.

  17. דָּוִ֥יד

    David · H1732

    David · v10

    The founding king, remembered as the one who organised temple music. By the time of this ceremony he had been dead for about 450 years.

  18. מֶֽלֶךְ־

    melekh- · H4428

    king of · v10

    A pointed title. Judah now had no king and was a Persian province, yet worship is ordered by the authority of Israel's king.

  19. יִשְׂרָאֵֽל׃

    Yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v10, v11

    The whole covenant people. The returnees, though mostly from Judah and Benjamin, see themselves as the continuation of all Israel.

  20. וַֽיַּעֲנוּ

    wayya'anu · H6030C

    to sing / answer · v11

    Narrative past: 'and they sang in response.' The verb normally means 'answer'. Here it describes the Levite choirs singing back and forth, one group calling and the other replying.

  21. וּבְהוֹדֹת

    uvehodot · H3034

    to give thanks · v11

    'And with giving thanks.' This is thanks given out loud by saying what God has done, in front of others. It pairs with hallel to make the standard phrase for temple song.

  22. כִּי

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v11, v13

    Opens the words of the song itself. It works either as 'for' (giving the reason for praise) or as a marker that a quotation begins.

  23. טוֹב

    tov · H2896A

    good · v11

    '[He is] good.' The Hebrew has no 'he is'. Readers supply it, almost always with Yahweh as the subject. Tov covers good, beneficial, pleasant and generous.

  24. לְעוֹלָם

    le'olam · H5769G

    forever, to the age · v11

    'For ever', 'to the age': lasting into a future you cannot see the end of. Coming right after the exile, it claims that God's loyalty outlasted the disaster.

  25. חַסְדּוֹ

    chasdo · H2617A

    loyal love, kindness · v11

    'His loyal love.' This is committed, faithful kindness inside a relationship, here the covenant bond between Yahweh and Israel. It is the key word of the refrain.

  26. וְכָל־

    vekhol · H3605

    and all · v11

    'And all.' Shifts the focus from the trained Levite singers to the whole crowd.

  27. הָעָם

    ha'am · H5971A

    the people · v11, v13

    'The people': the gathered community as a single body, as opposed to the clergy.

  28. הֵרִיעוּ

    heri'u · H7321

    to shout, raise a cry · v11, v13

    'They shouted.' This is the verb for a mass cry: a war shout, a cheer for a king, or the cry when the ark of God arrived.

  29. תְרוּעָה

    teru'ah · H8643

    shout, blast, acclamation · v11, v12, v13

    'A shout', from the same root as the verb before it ('they shouted a shout'), which adds emphasis. A teru'ah is the loud cry a crowd raises to greet a king or God.

  30. גְדוֹלָה

    gedolah · H1419A

    great, loud · v11, v12, v13

    'Great', meaning loud and big. Verse 13 says it was heard far away.

  31. בֵּית־

    beit · H1004Q

    house · v11, v12

    'House of.' The standard word for the temple as God's household and dwelling place.

  32. וְרַבִּ֡ים

    wərabbîm · H7227

    many · v12

    "And many". After verse 11's 'all the people' shouting, this picks out a large group within the crowd. It is matched by the second 'and many' later in the verse, which sets up two crowds side by side.

  33. וְרָאשֵׁ֨י

    wərāʾšê · H7218

    head · v12

    "And the heads of". The recognised leaders of each extended family. This is a social office, not a title of honour only.

  34. הָאָב֜וֹת

    hāʾābôt · H1

    father · v12

    "The fathers". Short for 'fathers' houses', the ancestral clans that organised the returning community. 'Heads of the fathers' means clan chiefs, not patriarchs.

  35. הַזְּקֵנִ֗ים

    hazzəqēnîm · H2205

    old; elder · v12

    "The old ones". It narrows the group: the aged men among these priests, Levites and clan heads. Their age matters because the next clause says they remember the first temple.

  36. אֲשֶׁ֨ר

    ʾăšer · H834

    who, which · v12

    "Who". It introduces what sets these old men apart: they are eyewitnesses.

  37. רָא֜וּ

    rāʾû · H7200

    see · v12

    "They had seen". A completed action in the past. This is personal eyewitness memory of Solomon's temple from before 587/586 BC, not something they had heard about.

  38. הָֽרִאשׁוֹן֙

    hāriʾšôn · H7223

    first, former · v12

    "The first". Solomon's temple, burned by the Babylonians about fifty years earlier. 'First' already assumes a second one is now being built.

  39. זֶ֤ה

    zeh · H2088

    this · v12

    "This". It points at the house in front of them, set against 'the first' house.

  40. בְּעֵ֣ינֵיהֶ֔ם

    bəʿênêhem · H5869

    eye · v12

    "In their eyes". Literally 'before their eyes', but in Hebrew the phrase also often means 'in their judgment'. Haggai 2:3 uses the same phrase of this temple: 'Is it not as nothing in your eyes?'

  41. בֹּכִ֖ים

    bōkîm · H1058

    weep · v12

    "Weeping". The verb form describes an ongoing action: they kept on weeping while the ceremony went on. In Hebrew this is audible, public crying.

  42. בְּק֣וֹל

    bəqôl · H6963

    voice, sound · v12, v13

    "With a voice". The first of the verse's two 'voices'. The weeping is described as sound, to be set beside the shout.

  43. בְשִׂמְחָ֖ה

    bəśimḥâ · H8057

    joy, gladness · v12, v13

    "With joy". The joy of a festival: public celebration that people express out loud, not a private feeling.

  44. לְהָרִ֥ים

    ləhārîm · H7311

    raise, lift up · v12

    "To lift up". They raised their voices high. The word suits shouting and also hints at exalting, which fits praise.

  45. וְאֵ֣ין

    ve'ein · H0369

    and there is not · v13

    Negates the whole participle clause that follows: 'and the people were not (able to be) distinguishing.' It describes a state that lasted for a while, not a single moment.

  46. מַכִּירִים֙

    makkirim · H5234A

    recognizing, distinguishing · v13

    The 'recognize' verb, used here with 'from' (le-) to mean telling one thing apart from another. The form shows ongoing action: all through the ceremony no one could tell the two sounds apart.

  47. בְּכִ֣י

    bekhi · H1065

    weeping · v13

    'The weeping of'. Audible crying. Verse 12 says the elders wept 'with a great voice', so this is loud public lamenting, not quiet tears.

  48. נִשְׁמַ֖ע

    nishma' · H8085G

    was heard · v13

    A passive form, 'was heard', with no hearer named. The next chapter opens with the same verb: 'the adversaries of Judah and Benjamin heard' (4:1).

  49. עַד־

    'ad · H5704

    until, as far as · v13

    'As far as'. It begins a phrase about how far the sound carried.

  50. לְמֵרָחֽוֹק

    lemerachoq · H7350

    far, distant · v13

    Literally 'to from-afar'. Three prepositions are stacked together ('as far as to from a distance'), a pattern of late biblical Hebrew. It means 'a great way off'.

The world behind it

Where this happens in history. In 539 BC Cyrus of Persia took Babylon, and soon after (538 BC) he let exiled Judeans return and rebuild their temple (Ezra 1). The returnees set up the altar first, on the old site, in the seventh month (3:1-6). Work on the building itself began in "the second month of the second year" after arriving (3:8). That date echoes Solomon, who began the First Temple in the second month (1 Kgs 6:1; 2 Chr 3:2). Judah was now a small Persian province ("Yehud"), with a Davidic governor-figure (Zerubbabel) and a high priest (Jeshua) but no king.

A ruin, not an empty lot. The Babylonians burned Solomon's temple in 587/586 BC (2 Kgs 25:9). Its platform and lower courses still stood on the mount. In the ancient Near East, rebuilding a god's house on exactly the old spot and plan mattered a great deal. Mesopotamian kings boast of finding the original foundation outline before rebuilding. Founding ceremonies there combined lament for the ruined house with rejoicing over the new one, which may shed light on the mixed weeping and shouting in Ezra 3:12-13.

Instruments and personnel. By the post-exilic period the roles were fixed. Priests (descendants of Aaron) blew the silver trumpets. Levites, organised into singers' guilds traced to David's appointees Asaph, Heman and Jeduthun (1 Chr 15–16; 25), sang and played cymbals, harps and lyres. The returnee list includes 128 singers, "sons of Asaph" (Ezra 2:41), and the families had donated priestly garments (2:69). The verse shows those resources being put to use.

The deliberate echo. The Chronicler's account of Solomon's dedication (2 Chr 5:12-13) has Levitical singers with cymbals, priests with trumpets, and the refrain "for he is good, for his hesed endures forever". Ezra 3:10-11 repeats every element. First hearers would recognise the claim: this is the same worship, resumed.

From the study of Ezra 3:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

When was the Second Temple 'founded', and what event does Ezra 3:10 describe?

  • Two-stage history: work began soon after the return (c. 537/536 BC) under Zerubbabel and Jeshua, was halted by opposition (4:1-5, 24), and resumed in 520 BC under the prompting of Haggai and Zechariah.

    This is the straightforward sequence of Ezra 3–6, and 4:24 explicitly records a stoppage. It is held by more harmonising commentators such as Kidner and Fensham.

  • The narrator has telescoped events: Ezra 3:8-13 draws on the 520 BC founding (Hag 2:18; Zech 4:9) and places it earlier for theological reasons, to show continuous faithfulness from the return onward.

    Haggai 1–2 speaks as if nothing had been built and dates the founding to the 24th of the 9th month of Darius's 2nd year. Zechariah 4:9 credits Zerubbabel. This view is argued in various forms by critical commentators such as Williamson and Blenkinsopp.

  • Yasad here means 'restore' or 're-found' rather than 'lay new foundations', so several 'foundings' (Sheshbazzar in Ezra 5:16, Zerubbabel in Ezra 3 and Haggai–Zechariah) can describe phases of restoring the old structure.

    A. Gelston, VT 16 (1966), points to the verb's broader range, for example 2 Chr 24:27. Mesopotamian 're-founding' rituals and parallels in building inscriptions are also cited, e.g. Petersen, CBQ 1974.

in v10

Who is the subject of 'stationed', and did the priests stand on their own or were they set in place?

  • The Hebrew text's causative 'they stationed' is original. The leaders (Zerubbabel, Jeshua, the overseers of 3:8-9) assigned the clergy to their posts.

    This is the vowel-pointing of the Hebrew text, followed by KJV, WEB and YLT, and it fits Ezra's emphasis on proper appointment.

  • The original read 'the priests stood', a simple verb with the priests as subject.

    1 Esdras 5:59 and the Vulgate (steterunt) support it, and probably the Septuagint (ἔστησαν). It is followed by BSB, NIV and others.

in v11

Does wayya'anu mean 'they answered (antiphonally)' or simply 'they sang'?

  • Responsive or antiphonal singing

    The usual sense of 'anah is 'answer'. Neh 12:24 describes Levite choirs 'watch opposite watch'. Ps 136 is built as call and response. The Septuagint has apekrithēsan, 'they answered'. ESV, BSB, WEB and KJV ('by course') follow this.

  • A separate verb meaning 'sing'

    BDB and HALOT list a distinct 'anah, 'sing' (Exod 15:21; 32:18; Num 21:17). The supplied data tags it H6030C, 'to sing'. NIV and NASB render just 'sang'. Even on this view, the refrain's structure suggests performance in alternation.

in v11

When was the temple 'founded', and what does husad describe?

  • A real founding in about 537/536 BCE, with work then halted until 520

    Ezra 3:8 dates it to the second year after the return. Ezra 4:1–5, 24 reports opposition that stopped the work. Ezra 5:16 credits Sheshbazzar with the foundations.

  • The narrator has compressed events; the main founding was in 520 BCE

    Hag 1–2 and Zech 4:9; 8:9 date the founding to Darius's second year and imply no earlier progress. Some scholars (e.g. Williamson, Blenkinsopp, in different ways) think Ezra 3 groups events by theme rather than strict order.

  • Yasad here means a ceremonial start or restoration, not a full new foundation

    The verb has a range that includes 'establish, restore' (compare 2 Chr 24:27). Ancient Near Eastern foundation rites could mark the restart of work on an old site, and that might satisfy both Ezra 3 and Haggai.

in v11

In 'ki tov', who or what is 'good'?

  • Yahweh: 'for he is good'

    The majority view and nearly all translations. The parallel line 'his chesed' has Yahweh as subject. Compare Ps 136:1.

  • The act of praise: 'for it is good [to praise]'

    The Hebrew has no subject, and Pss 92:1 and 147:1 use tov of praising itself. YLT leaves it open ('for good'). This is a minority reading for the fixed refrain.

in v12

Why did the old men weep?

  • Grief at the contrast: the new temple looked poor beside Solomon's.

    The verse itself sets 'the first house' against 'this house in their eyes'. Haggai 2:3 says of the same project, to those 'who saw this house in its former glory', that it is 'as nothing in your eyes'. Zechariah 4:10 speaks of people despising 'the day of small things'. This is the majority view (e.g., Williamson, Blenkinsopp).

  • Mixed or overwhelmed emotion: tears of relief and memory as well as sorrow.

    The Hebrew verb bākâ is used for joyful reunion (Gen 33:4; 45:14–15) as well as lament. The text gives no reason. Verse 13 says the weeping and the joyful shout could not be told apart, which suggests the two were not opposed so much as blended.

  • Ritual lament belonging to a temple-refounding ceremony.

    Mesopotamian building texts describe lament-priests singing laments when an old temple's foundations were disturbed and a new building begun, to soothe the deity (see Ellis, Foundation Deposits in Ancient Mesopotamia). Some scholars have suggested Ezra 3 reflects a similar custom. Against this: Ezra gives no rubric for lament, and it singles out the weepers as those who personally remembered the first house, which points to real memory rather than a set role.

in v12

What exactly was 'founded', and when?

  • New foundations were laid around 537/536 BC under Zerubbabel and Jeshua, as Ezra 3:8 dates it.

    This is the plain sequence of Ezra 3 ('second year of their coming'). Ezra 5:16 also says foundations were laid early, under Sheshbazzar.

  • Yāsad here means formally beginning to restore or rebuild on the surviving Solomonic foundations.

    The verb and its related noun can mean 'establish' or 'restore' (2 Chr 24:27; 1 Chr 9:22). Gelston (Vetus Testamentum 1966) argued for 'restore, repair' in these texts. The temple platform very likely survived the burning of 587 BC.

  • The scene compresses or anticipates the refounding of 520 BC under Haggai and Zechariah.

    Haggai 2:18 and Zechariah 4:9; 8:9 date a foundation to 520 BC, and Haggai 2:3 contains the same comparison with the first house. Ezra 1–6 is arranged by theme in places (e.g., 4:6–23 jumps ahead to later reigns), so the narrator may be drawing on 520 BC events here.

in v13

Why did the elders weep?

  • Disappointment at the contrast with Solomon's temple.

    Verse 12 links the weeping directly to those 'who had seen the first house'. Haggai 2:3 says the new house seemed 'as nothing' to such people. This is the majority reading.

  • Grief and memory: mourning the destruction, the exile and the dead, set off by seeing the site re-founded.

    Lament for Jerusalem's fall was an established communal practice (Lamentations; Zech 7:3–5 mentions fasts kept for decades). The text does not say the weeping was about size alone.

  • Overwhelming emotion, tears of joy and grief mixed.

    Verse 13 says the sounds could not be told apart and calls both 'of the people'. Some commentators think the line between the groups was not sharp.

  • A ritual lament belonging to the foundation ceremony itself (a minority view).

    Mesopotamian temple-restoration texts call for lament-singers when an old temple is pulled down and a new foundation laid. Critics note that Ezra explicitly ties the weeping to memories of the first house, not to a prescribed rite.

in v13

When, and by whom, was this foundation laid?

  • About 537/536 BC under Zerubbabel and Jeshua, as Ezra 3 presents it. Work then stalled (4:24) and resumed in 520.

    Ezra 3:8. Ezra 5:16 says the foundation was laid in Cyrus's time, though it credits Sheshbazzar, who may have been Zerubbabel's predecessor or overlapped with him.

  • Ezra 3 compresses events, and the main foundation ceremony belongs to 520 BC under Darius.

    Haggai 2:15–18 and Zechariah 4:9; 8:9 speak as if the foundation is laid in 520. Some scholars think the narrator has gathered the founding into one representative scene.

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. יסד, היכל, חֲצֹצְרָה, מְצִלְתַּיִם
  • BDB s.v. יָסַד; יָד (idiom עַל־יְדֵי)
  • A. Gelston, 'The Foundations of the Second Temple', Vetus Testamentum 16 (1966) 232–235
  • H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16, 1985)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library, 1988)
  • F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT, 1982)
  • D. L. Petersen, 'Zerubbabel and Jerusalem Temple Reconstruction', CBQ 36 (1974)
  • R. S. Ellis, Foundation Deposits in Ancient Mesopotamia (1968)
  • J. Montagu, Musical Instruments of the Bible (2002)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 3.291 (silver trumpets)
  • 1 Esdras 5:57–59 (Greek parallel); Vulgate Ezra 3:10
  • BDB s.v. עָנָה (I 'answer'; IV 'sing'), חֶסֶד, תְּרוּעָה, יָסַד
  • HALOT s.v. ענה IV, חֶסֶד, תְּרוּעָה, יסד
  • N. Glueck, Hesed in the Bible (1927; ET 1967)
  • K. D. Sakenfeld, The Meaning of Hesed in the Hebrew Bible (1978)
  • H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
  • F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT)
  • Rahlfs-Hanhart Septuaginta, 2 Esdras 3:11; 1 Esdras 5
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezra 3
  • Supplied STEP/TAHOT word-by-word data
  • BDB (Brown-Driver-Briggs Hebrew and English Lexicon) s.v. יָסַד, בָּכָה, תְּרוּעָה, שִׂמְחָה, זָקֵן
  • HALOT (Koehler-Baumgartner, Hebrew and Aramaic Lexicon of the Old Testament) s.v. יסד, תְּרוּעָה
  • A. Gelston, 'The Foundations of the Second Temple,' Vetus Testamentum 16 (1966)
  • Septuagint, 2 Esdras 3:12; 1 Esdras 5
  • Vulgate, Ezra 3:12
  • Haggai 2:3, 18; Zechariah 4:9–10; Jeremiah 33:10–11; Psalm 137:1
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. תְּרוּעָה, רוּעַ, נכר (hiphil), בְּכִי, שִׂמְחָה, קוֹל
  • P. Humbert, La 'Terou'a': analyse d'un rite biblique (1946)
  • H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary, 1985)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (OTL, 1988)
  • R. S. Ellis, Foundation Deposits in Ancient Mesopotamia (1968), on temple-founding rituals
  • Septuagint, 2 Esdras 3:13; 1 Esdras 5
  • Jeremiah 33:10–11; Haggai 2:3–9; Zechariah 4:10; Nehemiah 12:43

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).