Jeremiah Chapter 4 Read as one passage
Jeremiah 4:23–26
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
23I looked at the earth, and it was formless and void; I looked to the heavens, and they had no light. 24I looked at the mountains, and behold, they were quaking; all the hills were swaying. 25I looked, and no man was left; all the birds of the air had fled. 26I looked, and the fruitful land was a desert. All its cities were torn down before the LORD, before His fierce anger.
What the first hearers heard
To Judeans in Jerusalem before the Babylonian invasions, this was a shocking image. They knew the story that their God had turned empty waste and darkness into a livable world, and that he had given them a good, fruitful land within it. Jeremiah tells them that because they "do not know" God (v. 22), that gift is about to be undone. Their land will become tohu wavohu again: empty of people, birds and harvests, its cities rubble, its sky black.
The vision worked in several ways:
- As warning. The disaster was not random. It was the Creator's response to covenant unfaithfulness, and therefore a call to turn back (compare 4:1–4, 14).
- As lament. Spoken right after the prophet's cry of pain (4:19–21), it gives words to grief beyond normal language.
- As theology of creation. The God who orders the world can also withdraw that order. Israel's security rested not on the land itself but on its relationship with him.
- With a limit. Verse 27 ("yet I will not make a full end") kept a thread of hope: judgment, not annihilation.
After 587 BC, when Jerusalem and the Temple were destroyed, those who survived would have read these lines as fulfilled.
From the study of Jeremiah 4:23.
Verse by verse
-
23I looked at the earth, and it was formless and void; I looked to the heavens, and they had no light.
Full study →"I looked at the land, the whole earth, and there it was: waste and emptiness, tohu and bohu, the very words of the world before creation. I looked up to the sky, and its light was gone."
The prophet is seeing a vision. In it he stands where the people of Judah live and finds it turned back into an uninhabitable wilderness: no fields, no towns, no life (the next verses add that the mountains shake, no human being is left, the birds have fled and the cities lie in ruins). The rhyming pair tohu wavohu ("waste and void") occurs only here and in Genesis 1:2, so anyone who knew the creation story would hear it at once. Then the sky goes dark, cancelling God's first word, "Let there be light."
The point is not that the planet dissolves into shapeless matter. The point is that God's judgment on his faithless people (v. 22) will be so complete that it will feel like creation running in reverse, as though the world returned to its state before God made it a home. "The earth" here is both Judah's own land and, in the poet's picture, the whole cosmos.
-
24I looked at the mountains, and behold, they were quaking; all the hills were swaying.
Full study →"I looked at the mountains, and there they were, quaking: heaving as in an earthquake, and still heaving as I watched. And every last one of the hills was being tossed back and forth, lurching as if it weighed nothing at all."
This is the second of four vision reports (vv. 23-26), each beginning "I looked". The first showed the earth turned back into the empty chaos of before creation ("formless and void", the tohu wabohu of Genesis 1:2) and the sky with its light gone. Now the prophet looks at what ancient people took to be the most permanent things in the world, the mountains and hills that seemed rooted in the earth's foundations, and sees them unstable. The quaking is the earthquake that traditionally marks the LORD's arrival as a warrior (Judges 5:4; Nahum 1:5). It is also the ground trembling under the horses of the invader from the north whom Jeremiah has been describing all through the chapter. The hills "shaking themselves to and fro" uses a rare doubled verb whose sound itself rocks back and forth. Its root means "light, weightless": the heaviest things in the landscape are tossed about like chaff. The point is not geology. It is that when the LORD comes in "fierce anger" against Judah (v. 26), nothing that seemed fixed will hold.
-
25I looked, and no man was left; all the birds of the air had fled.
Full study →"I looked — and there it was: not a human being anywhere. And every bird of the sky had fluttered off and was gone."
This is the third frame of a four-part vision (vv. 23–26). Each frame opens with the same jolt: "I looked, and look!" The prophet's eyes move down through the world as Genesis built it. Earth and sky have gone back to "formless and empty" and the light has gone out (v. 23). The mountains shake (v. 24). Now he looks for the living creatures, and they are gone. First, and most starkly, he finds no humans. The Hebrew does not say people are dying or fleeing. It says there are none. The phrase almost repeats Genesis 2:5, which describes the world before humans existed: "there was no human." The word is the general word for humankind, the creature made last and highest in Genesis 1.
Then the birds. "Birds of the heavens" is the creation phrase for the creatures of the sky. In Jeremiah's other warnings the birds come to feed on Judah's unburied dead (7:33). Here even they have flown off in alarm. The verb's tense shows it has already happened: the sky is silent. The picture is emptier than a battlefield. It is a land with nothing alive in it, as if creation had been run backwards.
The context makes clear what land this is. The cities of v. 26 are torn down "before the LORD, before his fierce anger", and the surrounding verses are about Judah and Jerusalem facing the invader from the north. Jeremiah is seeing what his own country will look like when the judgment has finished its work.
-
26I looked, and the fruitful land was a desert. All its cities were torn down before the LORD, before His fierce anger.
Full study →"I looked, and there it was: the garden-land had become the wilderness. Every one of its towns had been pulled down, collapsing at the advance of Yahweh, before the blaze of his anger."
This is the last of four "I looked" visions (vv. 23–26). Each one takes away another layer of the world. Verse 23 removes light and form ("formless and empty", the words of Genesis 1:2), verse 24 shakes the mountains, and verse 25 takes away people and birds. Now the last two marks of human life go: the farmed land and the cities.
The "fruitful land" is the karmel: terraced vineyards, olive groves and orchards. Jeremiah had already used this word for the land God gave Israel ("I brought you into the land of the karmel", 2:7). The "desert" is the midbar: scrubby, unfarmed steppe, and the same "wilderness" Israel had wandered in before that gift (2:2, 6). So the garden turns back into the wilderness, and Israel's story runs backwards.
The cities are "pulled down", which is the very verb God used when he called Jeremiah "to tear down" (1:10). The cause is said twice in matching lines. They fall "from the face of Yahweh", the way things give way before an advancing warrior, and "from the face of the burning of his nose", the Hebrew picture of anger as heat flaring in the nostrils. In the prophet's vision the past tense presents a disaster still to come as if it had already happened.
Where the English drifted
-
in v23
formless / without form
tohu
- What we hear
- Shapeless, unstructured raw material, as if the earth were turning into a featureless blob.
- What they heard
- A desolate, uninhabitable waste like a desert, with no life, people or cultivation. The opposite of a place 'formed to be inhabited' (Isa 45:18).
-
in v23
the earth
ha'arets
- What we hear
- The planet as a whole.
- What they heard
- The land: in this chapter, Judah's own land under threat of invasion. It is also heard against 'heavens and earth' in Genesis 1, so the local disaster is pictured on a cosmic scale.
-
in v24
moved lightly (KJV); moved themselves lightly (YLT)
hitqalqalu
- What we hear
- The hills shifted slightly or gently, a soft, minor movement.
- What they heard
- The hills were tossed violently back and forth again and again, lurching as if weightless. It is earthquake motion, not a gentle sway.
-
in v25
birds of the heavens (KJV, NASB)
of hashamayim
- What we hear
- Birds connected with 'heaven', the spiritual realm or afterlife.
- What they heard
- Simply the wild birds of the sky. *Shamayim* here is the visible sky where birds fly.
-
in v26
desert
midbar
- What we hear
- A sandy, lifeless waste like the Sahara.
- What they heard
- Unfarmed, thinly settled steppe and scrubland, often used as seasonal pasture. It is also the 'wilderness' of Israel's wandering before it entered the land.
-
in v26
before the LORD
mippenei YHWH
- What we hear
- In front of the LORD or in his sight, as if God were watching the cities fall.
- What they heard
- 'From the face of' means 'because of, at the approach of'. The cities collapse as God advances, the way things give way before a charging warrior.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v23
Jeremiah 4:23 doesn't describe a world before Adam
- What's often taught
- Because Jeremiah uses the same words as Genesis 1:2 ('without form and void') to describe a judgment, Genesis 1:2 must describe an earlier world that God judged and ruined, often linked to Satan's fall. On this view the six days of Genesis are a re-creation after a long 'gap'.
- What the text supports
The judgment in Jeremiah 4 is clearly identified, and it comes after Adam, not before. It is the coming invasion of Judah by 'evil from the north' (4:6–7), because 'my people… have not known Me' (4:22). The vision includes cities torn down and fruitful land made desert (4:26), and v. 27 names its object: 'the whole land shall be a desolation.' Nothing in the passage looks back to a world before humanity, to angels, or to Satan.
The borrowing runs the other way. Jeremiah takes the familiar language of the world before God made it livable and applies it to Judah's future, to say that judgment will undo creation. Using Genesis vocabulary to describe a judgment does not make the original Genesis scene a judgment, just as Isaiah's use of tohu and bohu for ruined Edom (Isa 34:11) says nothing about Genesis.
What the reading gets right: the link between the two verses is real and intended, and tohu wavohu does describe an empty, unlivable state. The step the text does not support is making that state the result of a judgment before Adam.
- Where the English feeds it
- Identical English wording in Genesis 1:2 and Jeremiah 4:23 ('without form, and void' in the KJV) makes the verses look like a matched pair of events. 'Without form' also adds a 'ruined matter' picture that the Hebrew 'wasteland, emptiness' does not carry.
in v24
Jeremiah's shaking mountains aren't a lost world before Adam
- What's often taught
- Jeremiah 4:23-26, with its formless earth, darkened sky and quaking mountains, is said to describe an earlier world that God judged and destroyed between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2, before the creation of humanity.
- What the text supports
The vision belongs to a poem about Judah's coming invasion (4:5-31). Its wording echoes Genesis 1 to show creation running backward: judgment so complete it can only be described as the world becoming unmade. It does not report an earlier world. The verses around it settle this. The ruined cities are broken down 'before the LORD, before his fierce anger' (v. 26), the next verse speaks of 'the whole land' and promises 'yet I will not make a full end' (v. 27), and the following lines go back to Judah, Zion and the invader's horsemen (vv. 28-31). The quaking (ra'ash) is the earthquake that marks God's warrior arrival (Judg 5:4; Nah 1:5) and the ground shaking under the enemy's cavalry (Jer 8:16). What this reading gets right is the real link with Genesis 1. The link is a literary echo used for a coming judgment, not a historical report of the past.
- Where the English feeds it
- The shared phrase 'formless and void' (KJV 'without form, and void') in both Gen 1:2 and Jer 4:23 makes the connection easy to see in English. The past-tense 'I beheld / I looked' can also suggest Jeremiah is seeing a past event, when it is the normal form for reporting a vision.
in v25
Not a lost world before Adam: Jeremiah is looking at Judah
- What's often taught
- Jeremiah 4:23–26 is often cited as a glimpse of an earlier world, one that existed before Adam and was destroyed when Satan fell. On this reading, the 'no man', the vanished birds and the ruined cities describe a judgment between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2, before the present creation.
- What the text supports
The vision borrows the language of Genesis, but its subject is Jeremiah's own people:
- The surrounding verses identify the land: the invader from the north (4:6–7), Jerusalem (4:14, 16), 'my people are foolish' (4:22), and the daughter of Zion in agony (4:31).
- The cities of v. 26 are torn down 'before the LORD, before his fierce anger'. That is covenant judgment on Judah's sin, the theme of the whole chapter.
- Ein ha'adam ('there was no human') echoes Genesis 2:5's description of the world before humans to say that Judah will be emptied as if it had never been inhabited. It does not describe a previous human-less age with cities.
- V. 27 ('the whole land will be a desolation, yet I will not make a full end') and v. 28 (the earth mourning) continue the same prophecy about the coming disaster. They are in the future and about Judah, not a past age.
The pre-Adamic reading is right to notice the strong Genesis echoes. But the passage uses them to describe a future reversal of creation on Jeremiah's land, not to reveal a past one.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'Earth' in v. 23 (KJV and others), where *erets* can equally mean 'land', and 'there was no man' make the scene sound global and primeval. Renderings like 'land' and 'no people' make the local reference clearer.
in v26
These torn-down cities are Judah's, not a lost world before Adam
- What's often taught
- Jeremiah 4:23–26 is a look back at the original earth's ruin between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2, after Lucifer's fall. 'Formless and empty' echoes Genesis 1:2, and the 'cities' in v. 26 show that a civilization before Adam was destroyed by God's anger.
- What the text supports
The passage does echo Genesis 1 on purpose, and that much of the reading is right. But Jeremiah uses creation language to describe the coming ruin of Judah, not a prehistoric world:
- "Its cities" belong to hakkarmel, the garden-land, which Jeremiah has already named as the land God gave Israel (2:7: "I brought you into the land of the karmel").
- The surrounding verses name the setting: Judah and Jerusalem (4:3–5), an invader "from the north" (4:6), horsemen and archers emptying "every city" (4:29), and "daughter Zion" crying out (4:31).
- "Torn down" (nittetsu) is the verb of Jeremiah's own commission "to tear down" nations (1:10). It also describes the Babylonians tearing down Jerusalem's walls (39:8; 52:14).
- The "fierce anger" (charon af) is the one v. 8 says "has not turned back from us", meaning Judah.
- V. 27 gives the verdict: "the whole land will be desolate, yet I will not make a complete end." That is judgment with a remnant left, not a world wiped out before Adam.
The past tense ("I looked") is the normal way a prophet reports a vision. It does not show the events had already happened in history.
- Where the English feeds it
- The KJV's "the earth was without form, and void" in v. 23 matches Genesis 1:2 word for word, and "earth" sounds like the whole planet. In both places the Hebrew *erets* can mean "land", and in Jeremiah it most naturally means the land of Judah. Reading "earth" as global makes the cities of v. 26 look like a worldwide civilization.
Every word
-
רָאִ֙יתִי֙
ra'iti · H7200G
I saw, I looked · v23, v24, v25, v26
First person, completed action: the prophet reports what he saw in a vision. The word opens each of the four lines of vv. 23–26 ('I looked… I looked… I looked… I looked'), giving the vision a drumbeat.
-
אֶת־
'et- · H0853
(marks the direct object) · v23
Untranslatable grammar word marking 'the earth' as what was seen.
-
הָאָ֔רֶץ
ha'arets · H0776G
the earth; the land · v23
Can mean the whole earth or the land of Judah. Paired with 'the heavens' it sounds cosmic, as in Genesis 1:1. In the chapter around it, though, ha'arets keeps meaning Judah's land (4:5, 7, 20, 27). Both meanings are working at once.
-
וְהִנֵּה־
wehinneh · H2009
and look!, and behold · v23, v24, v25, v26
A word that points: it puts the hearer inside the prophet's eyes at the moment of shock. 'And there it was…'
-
תֹ֖הוּ
tohu · H8414
waste, wasteland, emptiness · v23
An empty, unlivable place like a trackless desert. In this verse it is the land with all its life, order and people gone. It is not a description of shapeless matter.
-
וָבֹ֑הוּ
wavohu · H0922
and emptiness · v23
A rhyming partner to tohu that strengthens it: 'waste-and-void'. The rhyming pair appears together only here and in Genesis 1:2, so anyone who knew the creation account would hear it at once.
-
וְאֶל־
we'el · H0413
and to(ward) · v23
'And [I looked] toward': the verb 'I looked' is understood and not repeated. The prophet's gaze moves from the ground to the sky.
-
הַשָּׁמַ֖יִם
hashamayim · H8064
the heavens, the sky · v23, v25
The visible sky, where the lights hang. With 'the earth' it makes the Genesis 1:1 pair 'heavens and earth', the whole ordered world.
-
וְאֵ֥ין
we'en · H0369
and there is not · v23, v25
Hebrew's word for 'non-existence', stating flatly that something is absent: there simply is no light.
-
אוֹרָֽם׃
'oram · H0216
their light · v23
The light that belongs to the heavens (sun, moon, stars, daylight). Its absence undoes the first act of creation, 'Let there be light' (Gen 1:3).
-
הֶֽהָרִ֔ים
heharim · H2022G
the mountains · v24
The mountains, which to an ancient Israelite were the most fixed and ancient things in the world, the 'everlasting mountains' rooted in the earth's foundations. Showing them as unstable means the world's frame itself is giving way.
-
רֹעֲשִׁ֑ים
ro'ashim · H7493
quaking, shaking · v24
An earthquake word. The related noun ra'ash is 'the earthquake' of Amos 1:1. The participle form shows the shaking still going on as he watches; it is not a single jolt.
-
וְכָל־
wekhol · H3605
-
הַגְּבָע֖וֹת
haggeva'ot · H1389I
the hills · v24
The hills, the usual poetic partner of 'mountains'. Together the pair stands for the whole raised landscape of the land.
-
הִתְקַלְקָֽלוּ׃
hitqalqalu · H7043
they shook to and fro, were set swaying · v24
A rare doubled, reflexive form of the root meaning 'be light'. The doubling shows repeated back-and-forth motion: the hills rock and lurch as if they had no weight, like arrows being shaken in a quiver (Ezek 21:21). It is violent, not gentle.
-
הָאָדָ֑ם
ha'adam · H120
the human, humankind · v25
Human beings as a kind, not males in particular. With 'the', it means humanity as a whole, the same word used for the creature made last and highest in Genesis 1:26–27.
-
ע֥וֹף
of · H5775
flying creatures, birds · v25
A collective word for winged creatures. Here, as part of the fixed phrase 'birds of the heavens', it means the birds of the sky.
-
נָדָֽדוּ׃
nadadu · H5074
fled, flitted away, wandered off · v25
The tense describes something already finished: the birds have flown off and are gone. The verb is used elsewhere for birds fluttering or straying from the nest, so the picture is a sky left empty.
-
הַכַּרְמֶ֖ל
hakkarmel · H3759
garden-land, orchard, plantation · v26
Land under cultivation: vineyards, olive groves and orchards. Jeremiah 2:7 calls the land God gave Israel 'the land of the karmel', so this is Israel's promised garden.
-
הַמִּדְבָּ֑ר
hammidbar · H4057B
wilderness, steppe, open grazing land · v26
Land that is not farmed and not lived in. The two nouns are set side by side with no verb: 'the garden-land: the wilderness.' One has turned into the other.
-
עָרָ֗יו
'arav · H5892B
its cities · v26
'Its' (masculine) points back to the garden-land. These are the walled towns of Judah's farm country, the places people lived and took refuge.
-
נִתְּצוּ֙
nittetsu · H5422
were pulled down, demolished · v26
A passive verb for tearing down buildings, walls and altars. It is the same verb as 'to break down' in Jeremiah's call (1:10), so the prophet is watching his own commission carried out.
-
מִפְּנֵ֣י
mippenei · H6440G
from the face of; because of · v26
Literally 'from the face of'. It gives the cause: the cities fall as Yahweh comes on, the way things collapse in front of an advancing army.
-
יְהוָ֔ה
YHWH · H3068G
Yahweh (the LORD) · v26
Israel's own covenant God. He is not a foreign god. This is what shocks: the ruin comes from Israel's own God.
-
חֲר֥וֹן
charon · H2740
burning, heat (of anger) · v26
From a root meaning 'to be hot, to burn'. In the Hebrew Bible it is used almost only for God's anger, and it heightens 'anger' into blazing anger.
-
אַפּֽוֹ׃
appo · H0639G
his nose; his anger · v26
Literally 'his nose/nostrils'. Anger was pictured as heat flaring in the nostrils, so 'the burning of his nose' is a vivid body image for fierce anger.
The world behind it
When and why. Jeremiah 4 belongs to Jeremiah's early warnings (late 7th to early 6th century BC) about a destroyer "from the north" (4:6), soon identified as Babylon. The chapter is full of war: trumpets, a lion leaving its thicket "to make your land a waste" (4:7), chariots like a whirlwind (4:13), and the prophet's own anguish at the sound of the alarm (4:19–21). Verse 22 gives the reason: "My people are fools; they have not known Me."
The creation pattern. Verses 23–26 follow the order of creation in reverse:
- earth and heavens: tohu wavohu, no light (Gen 1:1–3)
- mountains and hills quake (the dry land, Gen 1:9–10)
- "there was no man" (the human, adam, Gen 1:26–27)
- "all the birds of the sky had fled" (Gen 1:20)
- the "fruitful land" (karmel, garden-land) is a desert and the cities are torn down (cultivated, civilised life)
For an ancient Israelite, creation meant God bringing order and habitability out of an empty, dark, watery waste, not producing matter from nothing. Reversing it means losing everything that makes life possible. Ancient Near Eastern laments over destroyed cities used similar "the world is undone" language.
Not the final word. Verse 27 immediately limits the vision: "The whole land shall be a desolation, yet I will not make a full end." The cosmic picture describes how real the coming disaster is. It is not a timetable for the end of the universe.
From the study of Jeremiah 4:23.
Where scholars differ
in v23
Is the vision about Judah's land or about the whole cosmos?
-
Local: a poetic picture of Judah devastated by the Babylonian invasion.
The whole chapter is about invasion from the north. 'Erets' consistently means Judah's land in 4:5, 7, 20, 27. Verse 26 mentions cities torn down, and v. 27 says 'the whole land' will be desolate but not finished off.
-
Cosmic: a genuine vision of creation itself being undone.
The 'heavens and earth' pair, the darkened sky, the shaking mountains and the absence of humanity follow the order of Genesis 1 in reverse. Some read the passage as an early step toward later apocalyptic writing.
-
Both: national catastrophe described in deliberately cosmic language.
Old Testament prophets regularly describe historical judgments with cosmic imagery (Isa 13:10, 13 about Babylon; Isa 34:4, 11 about Edom, which also uses tohu and bohu). This is probably the majority view today.
in v23
Did Jeremiah write vv. 23–26, or were they added later?
-
A later, more 'apocalyptic' insertion.
Some older critical scholars felt the cosmic tone and tightly patterned structure stood apart from the surrounding war poetry.
-
Original to Jeremiah's preaching.
The vision fits the context: the prophet's anguish (vv. 19–21), the reason given (v. 22), and the limit set (v. 27). Its vocabulary matches Jeremiah's. M. Fishbane and others showed that it deliberately reuses the creation pattern, as Job 3 also does.
in v23
What does tohu wavohu mean: 'chaos' or 'desolate, uninhabited land'?
-
Primeval chaos, a disordered state opposed to creation.
Comparisons with ancient Near Eastern myths of combat with the sea, and the pairing with darkness and the deep in Genesis 1:2.
-
A desert-like, unproductive, uninhabited state; not a hostile chaos power.
How tohu is used elsewhere (wilderness, empty cities, worthless things), its contrast with 'inhabited' in Isa 45:18, and a related Ugaritic word for 'desert'. In Jer 4:25–26 the emptiness is spelled out as no people, no birds, no crops and no cities (Tsumura).
in v24
What does the shaking of the mountains in vv. 23-26 describe?
-
Poetic, cosmic-scale description of the coming Babylonian devastation of Judah, shown as creation coming undone.
The surrounding poem (4:5-31) is about an invading army from the north; v. 26 names cities ruined 'before the LORD'; v. 27 says 'the whole land shall be a desolation, yet I will not make a full end'; Jeremiah uses ra'ash elsewhere for the land shaking under enemy cavalry (8:16). This is the majority view (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom).
-
A vision of a final, world-ending judgment, of which Judah's fall is a foretaste.
The language goes beyond any single invasion (no light in the heavens, no humans at all), and later apocalyptic writings use the same imagery for the end of the age. Readers holding this view usually also accept the historical reference to Judah as the primary one.
-
A description of a ruined world before Adam, lying between Genesis 1:1 and 1:2 (the 'ruin-reconstruction' or 'gap' reading).
Rests on the shared phrase 'formless and void' with Gen 1:2. Most scholars reject it because the passage is addressed to Judah, mentions cities and the LORD's anger at his people, and is followed by 'yet I will not make a full end' (4:27).
in v24
Are vv. 23-26 original to Jeremiah or a later addition?
-
Original to Jeremiah.
The vocabulary and the 'I looked' vision form fit Jeremiah's style (cf. 1:11-13); the passage is closely woven into the war poems around it. Defended by Holladay and Lundbom.
-
A later addition with an apocalyptic flavour.
Some older critical scholars thought the cosmic scope suited later apocalyptic writing better than Jeremiah's historical warnings. This view has less support today.
in v24
Do the quaking mountains and hills deliberately recall the high places of idolatry?
-
Yes, an intended irony.
Jeremiah has just condemned worship 'on every high hill' (2:20) and called 'the hills... the tumult on the mountains' a delusion (3:23), using the same pair of words.
-
No, simply standard theophany language.
The mountains/hills pair is a stock expression in theophany poetry (Nah 1:5; Hab 3:6; Isa 54:10) and needs no special reference.
in v25
Is Jeremiah describing the end of the whole world, or the devastation of Judah in poetic, cosmic terms?
-
Cosmic or poetic language for a local, historical judgment on Judah.
The Hebrew *erets* (v. 23) commonly means 'land' as well as 'earth'. V. 26 names Carmel (or 'the fruitful land') and 'its cities'. The whole chapter concerns the northern invader and Jerusalem (4:5–7, 14–16, 29–31). Ancient Near Eastern texts regularly describe military catastrophe in world-shaking imagery.
-
A genuinely cosmic vision of creation undone, which goes beyond any single invasion.
*Tohu va-vohu* (v. 23) occurs only here and in Gen 1:2. The sequence light, heavens, mountains, humans, birds follows the creation order. The language is universal ('the heavens', 'humankind'), not 'my people'. Many interpreters see it as anticipating later end-of-world prophecy, while still tied to Judah's crisis.
in v25
Does the vision deliberately echo Genesis 1–2?
-
Yes, it is a deliberate reversal of the creation pattern.
The unique shared phrase *tohu va-vohu*, the parallel order of elements, *ve'adam ayin* (Gen 2:5) beside *ein ha'adam*, and the creation phrase 'birds of the heavens' (Gen 1:26). This is argued by M. Fishbane (VT 1971) and W. Holladay, among others.
-
The parallels come from shared creation vocabulary, not dependence on the written Genesis text.
Many scholars date the Genesis 1 account in its present written form to Jeremiah's time or later, so direct literary borrowing is uncertain. Both texts may draw on common Israelite creation traditions. Either way, the creation imagery is widely recognised.
in v25
How does v. 27 ('yet I will not make a full end') relate to the total emptiness of v. 25?
-
It is an original qualification: the judgment is devastating but not final.
Jeremiah repeats this limitation elsewhere (5:10, 18; 30:11; 46:28), which suggests it is part of his message.
-
It is a later softening added after the exile.
It sits awkwardly between the absolute vision (vv. 23–26) and the mourning that follows (v. 28). Some commentators judge it an editorial addition reflecting the community that survived.
in v26
Is this a vision of the end of the whole cosmos, or poetic language for the invasion of Judah?
-
Hyperbole about Judah: creation-reversal language applied to a historical military disaster.
The surrounding text is about Judah and the northern invader (4:5–8, 13–17, 29–31). 'Its cities' refers to the karmel of 2:7. V. 27 speaks of 'the whole land' and adds 'I will not make a complete end'. V. 29 has every city abandoned before horsemen and archers. Most commentators (e.g., Holladay, Lundbom) read it this way.
-
A truly cosmic or end-time vision of de-creation, later read as pointing to a final judgment.
The deliberate echo of Genesis 1 ('formless and empty', light, heavens, birds, humans) goes beyond ordinary war reporting. Fishbane showed that the passage follows a creation pattern. Later Jewish and Christian end-time writing used similar language for the end of the age.
in v26
Is hakkarmel 'the garden-land' or 'Mount Carmel'?
-
A common noun, 'the garden-land / orchard country', meaning Judah's fertile land in general.
The article and the pairing with 'the wilderness' make it a general category. Jer 2:7 uses 'land of the karmel' for the whole promised land. Mount Carmel lay in the north, in old Israelite territory, not in Judah.
-
The proper name Carmel, the famously lush headland, standing for all fertile land.
The Septuagint and Vulgate both take it as the name. Carmel serves as a symbol of lushness elsewhere (Isa 35:2; Amos 1:2; Nah 1:4). A wordplay on the name may well be intended either way.
Sources
- BDB s.v. תֹּהוּ, בֹּהוּ, אֶרֶץ
- HALOT s.v. תֹּהוּ
- M. Fishbane, "Jeremiah IV 23–26 and Job III 3–13: A Recovered Use of the Creation Pattern," Vetus Testamentum 21 (1971)
- D. T. Tsumura, Creation and Destruction: A Reappraisal of the Chaoskampf Theory in the Old Testament (2005)
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jeremiah 4:23; Genesis 1:2
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 4:23
- BDB s.v. רָעַשׁ; s.v. קָלַל
- HALOT s.v. רעשׁ; s.v. קלל (hitpalpel 'be shaken, sway')
- W. McKane, Jeremiah I (ICC)
- P. C. Craigie, P. H. Kelley, J. F. Drinkard, Jeremiah 1–25 (WBC)
- M. Fishbane, 'Jeremiah IV 23-26 and Job III 3-13: A Recovered Use of the Creation Pattern', Vetus Testamentum 21 (1971)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 4:23-26
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Jer 4:24; Vulgate Jer 4:24
- BDB s.v. נָדַד
- HALOT s.v. נדד; s.v. אָדָם; s.v. אַיִן
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 4:23–28
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible), on 4:23–26
- Septuagint, Jeremiah 4:25
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 4:25
- BDB s.v. כַּרְמֶל, מִדְבָּר, נָתַץ, חָרוֹן, אַף
- HALOT s.v. כַּרְמֶל, מִדְבָּר, נתץ, חָרוֹן, פָּנִים
- Michael Fishbane, 'Jeremiah IV 23–26 and Job III 3–13: A Recovered Use of the Creation Pattern', Vetus Testamentum 21 (1971)
- William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
- Jack R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
- Shemaryahu Talmon, 'The "Desert Motif" in the Bible and in Qumran Literature'
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament (Walton, Matthews, Chavalas), on Jer 4
- Septuaginta, ed. Rahlfs, Jer 4:26
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Jer 4:26
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).