John Chapter 8 Read as one passage

John 8:48–49

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

48The Jews answered Him, “Are we not right to say that You are a Samaritan and You have a demon?” 49“I do not have a demon,” Jesus replied, “but I honor My Father, and you dishonor Me.

What the first hearers heard

To readers of John's Gospel, many of them Jewish believers in Jesus, the verse showed how a claim to be Abraham's true family could be turned around against Jesus. His opponents call him a Samaritan, the classic false claimant to Israel's heritage, and someone driven by a demon. These are the same two moves John's Gospel records repeatedly: rejecting Jesus' origin ("where is he from?", 7:27, 41–42, 52; 8:14) and rejecting the source of his words (7:20; 10:20).

John's readers would have heard irony in it. They knew that Jesus had in fact gone to Samaritans and been welcomed by them as "the Saviour of the world" (4:39–42). The label meant as contempt pointed, without the speakers knowing it, to his mission to outsiders. The demon charge also reverses who belongs to the devil: in John's account Jesus speaks what he has heard from the Father (8:38), and those who reject him are acting out another parentage (8:44).

Some scholars think readers also saw their own situation here. The Gospel speaks of followers of Jesus being put out of the synagogue (9:22; 16:2). If so, the verse would have read as the kind of insult believers themselves had faced: outsider, heretic, deluded. The scene steps up toward 8:52 ("Now we know you have a demon") and the attempted stoning in 8:59. It shows public hostility hardening into violence.

From the study of John 8:48.

Verse by verse

  1. 48The Jews answered Him, “Are we not right to say that You are a Samaritan and You have a demon?”

    The Judeans arguing with him fired back: "So we were right all along, weren't we, when we kept saying it? You are the Samaritan here. You are the outsider with a counterfeit pedigree and a false religion, not a true child of Abraham. And you have a demon in you. You are possessed, out of your mind."

    The verse answers what Jesus has just said. He told this crowd that they were not really Abraham's children, that they did not belong to God, and that their father was the devil (8:39–47). They return each blow:

    • "Samaritan" throws his charge about false descent back at him. To a Jerusalem crowd the Samaritans were the standard example of people who claimed Abraham and Moses but were, in their eyes, mixed-blood heretics. The name may also have hinted at sorcery.
    • "You have a demon" answers "your father is the devil." He calls them children of the devil; they call him demon-possessed and mad.

    The question is built to expect "Yes, of course," and the emphatic "we… you" draws the line between insiders and outsider. This is a public exchange of honour and shame in the temple courts at the Festival of Tabernacles. Jesus picks up exactly that language in the next verse: "I honour my Father, and you dishonour me." Notably, he denies having a demon but does not bother to deny being a Samaritan.

    Full study →
  2. 49“I do not have a demon,” Jesus replied, “but I honor My Father, and you dishonor Me.

    Jesus answered them, matching their emphatic insult with emphatic words of his own: "I am not the one with a demon. I am not mad, and I am not driven by some evil spirit, as you claim. What drives me is the opposite: I keep honoring my Father. Everything I say and do gives him the public recognition and obedience a true son owes. You, on the other hand, are right now heaping public shame on me."

    The verse is built on a balanced contrast: I… you, honor… dishonor. Jesus does not trade insults back. He corrects the record and then turns the charge around. In the honor-and-shame world of the temple courts, the accusers had tried to shame him with two labels: "Samaritan", meaning an outsider and heretic, and "demon-possessed", meaning a madman or sorcerer. Jesus rejects the second outright. He leaves the first unanswered. He then names what they are doing: dishonoring him. Since John has already said that whoever fails to honor the Son fails to honor the Father who sent him (5:23), the implication is pointed. The question of whose father is whose has run through the whole argument (8:39–44). The one they call demon-possessed is the son honoring God, and the people defending God's honor are the ones insulting God's agent.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v48

    the Jews

    hoi Ioudaioi

    What we hear
    The Jewish people as a whole, or Judaism as a religion, opposing Jesus.
    What they heard
    A particular group of Judeans in the temple courts: the hearers of 8:31 who had 'believed him' and are now hostile. Jesus, his disciples and the gospel writer are all Jews.
  • in v48

    Samaritan

    Samaritēs

    What we hear
    A good-hearted helper, from the 'Good Samaritan' parable, or just a regional label.
    What they heard
    A slur: a schismatic, mixed-race heretic with a false temple and a false claim to Abraham, possibly with overtones of sorcery.
  • in v48

    hast a devil (KJV)

    daimonion echeis

    What we hear
    You have Satan in you; you are in league with the devil himself.
    What they heard
    You are possessed by a demon, a lesser evil spirit. In practice: you are mad. This is a different word from 'the devil' (diabolos) in 8:44.
  • in v49

    devil (KJV: "I have not a devil")

    daimonion

    What we hear
    The Devil, Satan himself, as though Jesus were denying that he is Satan or has Satan inside him.
    What they heard
    A lesser evil spirit, one of many. 'To have a demon' was the everyday way of calling someone possessed or out of his mind (compare 10:20). It is different from *diabolos*, 'the devil', which John uses in 8:44.
  • in v49

    honor / dishonor

    timaō / atimazō

    What we hear
    An inner attitude of respect or polite regard. 'Dishonor' sounds like a mild lack of courtesy.
    What they heard
    Public granting or stripping of a person's standing and worth. Honoring a father meant obeying and faithfully representing him. Dishonoring someone meant actively shaming them before others, as their slur had just done.
Every word
  1. Ἀπεκρίθησαν

    Apekrithēsan · G0611

    answered · v48, v49

    They respond. It is a reply to Jesus' charge in 8:44–47 that they are not from God and that their father is the devil. This is a counter-attack, not a neutral answer.

  2. οἱ

    hoi · G3588

    the · v48, v49

    The article marks a known group, the same opponents Jesus has been debating since 8:31.

  3. Ἰουδαῖοι

    Ioudaioi · G2453

    Jews / Judeans · v48

    In this chapter the word names the specific crowd in the temple courts who are arguing with Jesus, people introduced in 8:31 as having 'believed him'. It does not stand for the Jewish people as a whole. Jesus, his disciples and the narrator are all Jews too.

  4. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v48, v49

    Links 'answered' and 'said' in a common Semitic-flavoured double verb of speaking.

  5. εἶπαν

    eipan · G2036

    said · v48

    An aorist form, a simple past act of speaking. It introduces their words.

  6. αὐτῷ

    autō · G0846

    to him · v48

    Addressed straight to Jesus. This is a face-to-face insult, not talk behind his back.

  7. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v48, v49

    Opening a question with οὐ signals that the speaker expects the answer 'yes'. The sense is 'Surely we are right…, aren't we?'

  8. καλῶς

    kalōs · G2573

    well, rightly · v48

    'Aptly, accurately, fittingly.' They claim their label for Jesus has now been proved true.

  9. λέγομεν

    legomen · G3004

    we say · v48

    Present tense. It suggests something they have been saying for some time ('we keep saying'), so this insult already circulated about him.

  10. ἡμεῖς

    hēmeis · G3165

    we · v48, v49

    Greek does not need this pronoun, so including it adds emphasis: 'we', as opposed to you. They set themselves up as the true insiders.

  11. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that · v48

    Introduces what they say: the two charges.

  12. Σαμαρίτης

    Samaritēs · G4541

    Samaritan · v48

    A slur, not a description of where he was born (they know he is from Galilee, 7:41, 52). It brands him a schismatic outsider with no real claim to Abraham, and perhaps also a sorcerer.

  13. εἶ

    ei · G1510

    you are · v48

    A flat statement of identity: this is what you are.

  14. σὺ

    su · G4771

    you · v48, v49

    Another emphatic pronoun, set against the 'we' above. You are the outsider, not us.

  15. δαιμόνιον

    daimonion · G1140

    demon · v48, v49

    An evil spirit, a lesser spiritual being. It is not 'the devil' (diabolos, 8:44). The word plays back on Jesus' claim that their father is the devil.

  16. ἔχεις

    echeis · G2192

    you have · v48, v49

    'To have a demon' was the normal idiom for being possessed. In practice it meant 'you're mad / out of your mind' (compare 10:20).

  17. Ἰησοῦς

    Iēsous · G2424

    Jesus · v49

    The Greek form of Yeshua/Joshua. He is named as the one speaking in reply to the group's insult.

  18. ἐγὼ

    egō · G1473

    I · v49

    Greek does not need this pronoun, because the verb already shows who is speaking, so including it adds emphasis: 'I, for my part'. It sets up a deliberate contrast with 'you yourselves' later in the verse.

  19. ἀλλὰ

    alla · G0235

    but, on the contrary · v49

    A strong 'on the contrary'. It replaces the false charge with the truth: what drives him is not a demon but devotion to his Father.

  20. τιμῶ

    timō · G5091

    I honor · v49

    To give someone the public recognition and worth they are owed, shown in conduct and not only felt inside. The present tense describes his steady pattern: his whole activity honors the Father.

  21. πατέρα

    patera · G3962

    father · v49

    God as Jesus' Father. Coming right after the argument over who is whose father (8:38–44: Abraham, God, the devil), the word is pointed.

  22. ἀτιμάζετέ

    atimazete · G0818

    you dishonor, shame · v49

    The direct opposite of timaō: to strip someone of honor, to insult or humiliate them in public. Their slur ('Samaritan, demon-possessed') is exactly such an act, and the present tense says they are doing it right now.

The world behind it

Where and when. John 7–8 takes place in the Jerusalem temple during the Festival of Tabernacles (Sukkot), the crowded autumn pilgrimage feast. By 8:20 Jesus is teaching near the treasury. The argument in 8:31–59 begins with people who "had believed him" and ends with them picking up stones (8:59).

Why "Samaritan" stung. Judeans and Samaritans had centuries of hostility behind them:

  • Judeans traced the Samaritans to the foreign settlers whom Assyria brought into the northern kingdom (2 Kings 17:24–41). Samaritans said they were the true descendants of Joseph who had kept the faith pure.
  • The Samaritans worshipped on Mount Gerizim instead of Jerusalem (compare John 4:20). The Judean ruler John Hyrcanus destroyed their temple there in the late 2nd century BC.
  • In Jesus' own lifetime, according to Josephus, Samaritans scattered human bones in the Jerusalem temple at Passover (around AD 6–9).
  • Ben Sira calls them "the foolish people that live in Shechem" (Sirach 50:26), and later rabbinic law treated their food as unclean.

Calling a fellow Jew a "Samaritan" therefore meant: you are a fake Israelite, a heretic, an enemy of the true temple. It came straight after Jesus questioned their descent from Abraham. Samaria was also linked with magicians such as Simon (Acts 8:9–11), which may tie the label to the demon charge.

"Having a demon." In first-century Jewish thinking, strange speech, extravagant claims or erratic behaviour could be explained as possession by an evil spirit. "He has a demon" was close to "he's insane" (John 10:20: "He has a demon and is raving mad"). It also served to discredit a teacher: if his words came from a demon, they need not be heard.

Honour and shame. In Mediterranean public life, an insult given in public had to be answered or the person lost face. Jesus had made serious claims about who his hearers' "father" was. They answer with the strongest labels for an outsider that they have. Jesus' reply in 8:49 is framed in exactly those terms: honour and dishonour.

From the study of John 8:48.

Where scholars differ

in v48

Who exactly are 'hoi Ioudaioi' in this verse, and how should the word be translated?

  • The same crowd of 8:31, Jews who had 'believed him' and turned hostile once he questioned their descent from Abraham.

    The scene continues without a break from 8:31 to 8:59, and the same addressees are in view throughout (8:33, 39, 48, 52, 57).

  • Mainly the Judean religious authorities and their followers, as often in John.

    Passages such as 1:19, 7:13, 9:22 and 19:38 use Ioudaioi for the people in power whom others fear. Scholars such as U. C. von Wahlde argue that the 'hostile' uses are mostly about authorities.

  • 'Judeans' is better than 'Jews,' as a regional and temple-centred label.

    Ioudaios comes from Judea. John contrasts Judea with Galilee (7:1) and Samaria (4:9). Some social-science commentators (e.g. Malina and Rohrbaugh) prefer 'Judeans.' Critics reply that by the first century the word was already a religious-ethnic name used for diaspora Jews too.

  • A representative, symbolic use: Ioudaioi stand for 'the world' that rejects the revealer.

    Bultmann and others note that John often uses 'the Jews' and 'the world' in parallel ways. Critics warn that this reading makes it easy to turn a narrative group into a whole people.

in v48

Why do they call Jesus a 'Samaritan'?

  • A counter-charge about false descent: Jesus denied they were Abraham's children, so they call him a member of the people whose claim to Abraham Judeans rejected.

    It comes straight after 8:39–44. Samaritans claimed patriarchal descent (John 4:12, 'our father Jacob') which Judeans disputed (2 Kings 17; Josephus Ant. 9.288–291; 11.340–341).

  • It hints at sorcery and false prophecy, which fits 'you have a demon.'

    Samaria was associated with magicians such as Simon (Acts 8:9–11; Justin, 1 Apology 26). Samaritan prophetic figures stirred unrest (Josephus Ant. 18.85–87). The two charges are joined by 'and.'

  • A reference to his known contact with Samaritans or to doubts about his origins.

    John 4 tells of his stay in Sychar. John 7:27, 41–52 shows that his origins were disputed. This is speculative, since the crowd knows he is from Galilee.

in v49

Why does Jesus deny having a demon but say nothing about being called a 'Samaritan'?

  • His silence is deliberate. He refuses to treat 'Samaritan' as shameful, which fits John's positive portrait of Samaritans.

    John 4:39–42, where Samaritans confess him as 'Savior of the world'; compare Luke 10:33 and 17:16. Many church fathers (e.g., Augustine, Tractates on John 43.2) read the silence this way.

  • The two charges amount to one: 'Samaritan' here implies sorcery or demonic power, so denying the demon answers both.

    Samaritans were linked with magic (Simon Magus, Acts 8:9–11; Justin, 1 Apology 26). The two labels are joined by 'and' in 8:48, and the follow-up in 8:52 repeats only 'you have a demon'. Several modern commentators (e.g., Brown, Keener) mention this possibility.

  • The silence carries no special meaning. Jesus answers the charge that mattered, because a possessed man's testimony would be invalid, and lets an ethnic slur go.

    The argument hangs on whether his testimony can be trusted (8:13–18). Only the demon charge directly undermines that. Commentators who take this view warn against reading too much into the silence.

Sources
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., John 8:48 apparatus
  • BDAG s.v. δαιμόνιον, Ἰουδαῖος, Σαμαρίτης, καλῶς
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. δαιμόνιον
  • Josephus, Antiquities 9.288–291; 11.340–347; 13.254–256; 18.29–30; 18.85–87; 20.118–136
  • Sirach 50:25–26
  • Mishnah Shevi'it 8:10
  • Justin Martyr, 1 Apology 26
  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 43.2
  • Vulgate, John 8:48
  • R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • B. J. Malina & R. L. Rohrbaugh, Social-Science Commentary on the Gospel of John
  • U. C. von Wahlde, 'The Johannine "Jews": A Critical Survey', NTS 28 (1982)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 4:9 and 8:48
  • BDAG s.v. δαιμόνιον, τιμάω, ἀτιμάζω
  • Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • Bruce J. Malina & Richard L. Rohrbaugh, Social-Science Commentary on the Gospel of John
  • Jerome H. Neyrey, The Gospel of John in Cultural and Rhetorical Perspective
  • Mishnah Berakhot 5:5 (agent principle)
  • Josephus, Jewish War 7.185
  • Augustine, Tractates on the Gospel of John 43
  • Septuagint: Exod 20:12; Mal 1:6; Deut 32:17

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).