Joshua Chapter 21 Read as one passage

Joshua 21:4–5

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

4The first lot came out for the Kohathite clans. The Levites who were descendants of Aaron the priest received thirteen cities by lot from the tribes of Judah, Simeon, and Benjamin. 5The remaining descendants of Kohath received ten cities by lot from the tribes of Ephraim, Dan, and the half-tribe of Manasseh.

What the first hearers heard

To its first hearers this verse was a record of the land being settled in order, and of a promise being kept. Several points would have stood out:

  • God commanded it and the tribes gave it. The towns came 'out of their own inheritance' (v. 3), so the landed tribes supported the landless priests. That is the system Numbers and Deuteronomy laid out, and here it is carried out in practice.
  • Nobody could accuse the priests of a land grab. The lot is mentioned twice. The priests ended up in valuable southern towns, including Hebron, the old patriarchal centre, because the lot put them there and not by their own choice.
  • Priests and Levites are distinguished. 'Sons of Aaron the priest, from the Levites' states the arrangement of the priestly laws: all priests are Levites, but only Aaron's line serves at the altar, and it is housed separately.
  • The priests are tied to a region. For readers in the time of the kings, the priestly towns in Judah and Benjamin explained where priestly families such as those of Anathoth came from, and why they were close to Jerusalem and its temple.
  • Every tribe has a place in the land. Even Levi, with no territory, has somewhere to live. The list of chapter 21 ends with the statement that 'not one word… failed' (21:45).

From the study of Joshua 21:4.

Verse by verse

  1. 4The first lot came out for the Kohathite clans. The Levites who were descendants of Aaron the priest received thirteen cities by lot from the tribes of Judah, Simeon, and Benjamin.

    Then the lot was drawn, and it fell to the clans descended from Kohath, Levi's son. Within that branch, the priestly line, the descendants of Aaron the priest (who were Levites, but a distinct group among them), were assigned thirteen towns. These came out of the land already allotted to the tribe of Judah, to the Simeonites (whose towns lay inside Judah), and to the tribe of Benjamin. The lot settled it, and Israelites understood a decision by lot as God's decision, not chance. The 'cities' were small, settled towns. The priests did not own the tribes' territory; they received places to live and the open pastureland around each town for their animals (v. 3). The tribes with land gave these out of their own inheritance, as God had commanded through Moses (Num 35). The result put Israel's priests in the south, in the hill country around Hebron and on the Judah–Benjamin border, the region where Israel's central place of worship would later stand.

    Full study →
  2. 5The remaining descendants of Kohath received ten cities by lot from the tribes of Ephraim, Dan, and the half-tribe of Manasseh.

    And to the other clans of Kohath, the Levite clans that were not Aaron's priestly line, ten towns were assigned by God's lot. The towns were taken from land the clans of Ephraim already held, from the tribe of Dan, and from the western half of Manasseh.

    The verse continues a ledger. Verse 4 had just given thirteen towns, out of Judah, Simeon and Benjamin, to the priests descended from Aaron, near where Jerusalem and its sanctuary would later stand. 'The remaining' Kohathites are their relatives who were not priests. These were the clans that carried the ark and the holy furniture in the wilderness (Numbers 4). They are settled in the next band of territory to the north and west, in the central hill country and its western slopes.

    The Hebrew sentence has no verb. It reads like an entry in a register: to whom, from whom, by what means, how many. The number 'ten' comes last for emphasis. 'By the lot' tells the first hearers that this arrangement came from God and was not a political bargain. The 'cities' were mostly modest walled towns with grazing land around them. They were places to live inside other tribes' land, not a territory of the Levites' own.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v4

    lot

    gôrāl

    What we hear
    A random draw, a matter of chance or luck, like a raffle.
    What they heard
    A means of getting God's decision. The outcome was understood to come from the LORD (Prov 16:33), and the drawing was done 'before the LORD' at the sanctuary.
  • in v4

    cities

    'ārîm

    What we hear
    Large urban centres governed by their residents.
    What they heard
    Small settled towns, often walled, where the priests had the right to live, plus surrounding pastureland. Fields and villages could stay with the host tribe (Josh 21:12).
  • in v4

    families (KJV, WEB)

    mishpĕḥōt

    What we hear
    Nuclear households: parents and their children.
    What they heard
    Clans: large kin groups within a tribe, each made of many extended households.
  • in v5

    families (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    mishpechot

    What we hear
    Individual households: parents and children.
    What they heard
    Clans: large kin groups within a tribe, each made up of many extended households and often linked to a district.
  • in v5

    cities

    arim

    What we hear
    Large urban centres.
    What they heard
    Permanent, usually walled settlements, mostly small towns of a few acres, with surrounding pastureland for the Levites' flocks.
Every word
  1. וַיֵּצֵא

    wayyētsē' · H3318

    to go out, come out · v4

    The usual phrase for a lot being drawn or thrown out of its container: the result 'came out.' It is the narrative 'and then' verb form, carrying the account forward from v. 3.

  2. הַגּוֹרָל

    haggôrāl · H1486

    lot · v4, v5

    The marked stone or token used to get a decision. Here it is the means by which God was understood to assign each Levite group its towns (compare 'before the LORD' in Josh 18:6, 10).

  3. לְמִשְׁפְּחֹת

    lĕmishpĕḥōt · H4940

    clan, kin group · v4, v5

    'For the clans of.' A mishpachah is the level between tribe and household: a large kin group made of many extended families. The plural shows that the Kohathites were several clans.

  4. הַקְּהָתִי

    haqqĕhātî · H6956

    Kohathite · v4

    A singular group-name, 'the Kohathite,' standing for the whole group descended from Kohath, Levi's second son (Exod 6:16–18). Aaron's line belonged to this branch.

  5. וַיְהִי

    wayhî · H1961

    to be, happen · v4

    'And there was (for),' the ordinary Hebrew way of saying 'they got' or 'it belonged to.' Hebrew has no verb 'to have.'

  6. לִבְנֵי

    livnê · H1121

    son, descendant · v4, v5

    'To the sons of,' meaning Aaron's descendants as a hereditary line, not only his literal sons. By now Aaron is dead (Num 20:28) and his son Eleazar is high priest (Josh 21:1).

  7. אַהֲרֹן

    'ahărōn · H175

    Aaron · v4

    Moses' brother, the first high priest. His name marks out the priestly families from the other Kohathites.

  8. הַכֹּהֵן

    hakkōhēn · H3548

    priest · v4

    'The priest,' Aaron's title. It names the sanctuary office of offering sacrifice and handling holy things, which in Israel's law only Aaron's line could hold.

  9. מִן־

    min- · H4480

    from, of · v4

    Here it singles out part of a group: the Aaronites are one part of the Levites.

  10. הַלְוִיִּם

    halwiyyim · H3881

    Levites · v4

    The tribe of Levi as a whole. The phrase makes clear that priests are Levites, but not every Levite is a priest.

  11. מִמַּטֵּה

    mimmaṭṭēh · H4294

    staff; tribe · v4, v5

    'From the tribe of.' Matteh means a staff or rod, and by extension the tribe that the staff stood for (compare the tribal staffs in Num 17). The towns come out of Judah's own share.

  12. יְהוּדָה

    yĕhûdāh · H3063

    Judah · v4

    The large southern tribe whose land included Hebron, the most important city on the priestly list (v. 11).

  13. הַשִּׁמְעֹנִי

    hashshim'ōnî · H8099

    Simeonite · v4

    Literally 'the Simeonite,' the same kind of group-name as 'the Kohathite.' Simeon's towns lay inside Judah's territory (Josh 19:1, 9), so Judah and Simeon are counted together in v. 16.

  14. בִנְיָמִן

    vinyāmin · H1144

    Benjamin · v4

    The small tribe just north of Judah. It gives four towns (vv. 17–18), among them Gibeon and Anathoth.

  15. עָרִים

    'ārîm · H5892

    city, town · v4, v5

    'Towns.' An 'ir was any lasting settlement, usually small and often walled. Verse 3 adds their 'pasturelands,' the open ground around them for grazing animals.

  16. שְׁלֹשׁ

    shĕlōsh · H7969

    three · v4

    The first half of 'thirteen' (literally 'three-ten').

  17. עֶשְׂרֵה

    'esrēh · H6240

    -teen (ten, in compounds) · v4

    Completes 'thirteen': 9 towns from Judah and Simeon (v. 16) plus 4 from Benjamin (v. 18). The ס after it is a scribal mark for a paragraph break.

  18. קְהָ֜ת

    Qehat · H6955

    Kohath · v5

    Kohath was the second son of Levi (Exod 6:16–18). His line included Aaron's priestly house. It also included the other Kohathite clans, who carried the most holy objects of the sanctuary (Num 4:1–15).

  19. הַנּוֹתָרִ֗ים

    ha-notarim · H3498

    the ones remaining · v5

    'The remaining ones', a passive participle meaning 'those left over'. It refers to the Kohathites who were not descendants of Aaron. Aaron's descendants had already received their thirteen cities in verse 4. It does not mean survivors.

  20. אֶ֠פְרַיִם

    Efrayim · H669

    Ephraim · v5

    Ephraim was the Joseph tribe in the central hill country. The four cities it gave included Shechem, a city of refuge (Josh 21:20–22).

  21. דָ֞ן

    Dan · H1835

    Dan · v5

    This is Dan's first allotment, west of Benjamin toward the coastal plain (Josh 19:40–46). Its cities were Eltekeh, Gibbethon, Aijalon and Gath-rimmon (21:23–24).

  22. וּמֵחֲצִ֨י

    u-me-chatsi · H2677

    and from half of · v5

    'And from half of'. Manasseh's territory was split across the Jordan. This half is the western one, west of the river.

  23. מְנַשֶּׁ֛ה

    Menasheh · H4519

    Manasseh · v5

    Western Manasseh gave Taanach and Gath-rimmon (21:25). The parallel in 1 Chronicles 6:70 reads Aner and Bileam. Eastern Manasseh's cities in Bashan go to the Gershonites in verse 6.

  24. עָֽשֶׂר׃

    eser · H6235

    ten · v5

    'Ten'. The total placed last for emphasis, as in every entry of this list. Verses 20–26 list the ten by name.

The world behind it

Why Levites needed towns. Levi was the one tribe without territory of its own (Num 18:20–24; Deut 18:1–2; Josh 13:14, 33). The Levites lived on tithes and offerings, and 'the LORD is their inheritance.' To give them somewhere to live, Numbers 35:1–8 ordered the other tribes to give 48 towns with pastureland. Joshua 21 carries out that order. Genesis 49:7 had said Levi would be 'scattered in Israel.' Here that scattering takes an ordered form: Levites live throughout the land among all the tribes.

The three branches of Levi. Levi had three sons, Gershon, Kohath and Merari (Exod 6:16). Each line received towns by lot (Josh 21:4–7). Aaron came from Kohath's line through Amram (Exod 6:18–20). The Kohathites had carried the most holy objects of the tabernacle (Num 4:4–15), so it fits that their lot comes first even though Gershon was the firstborn. The Kohathite allotment is split in two: the priestly Aaronites get 13 towns (this verse) and the other Kohathite clans get 10 (v. 5).

Where the priestly towns were. Verses 13–18 list Hebron, Libnah, Jattir, Eshtemoa, Holon, Debir, Ain, Juttah and Beth-shemesh from Judah and Simeon, then Gibeon, Geba, Anathoth and Almon from Benjamin. Jeremiah later came 'from the priests who were in Anathoth' (Jer 1:1), and Solomon banished the priest Abiathar to Anathoth (1 Kgs 2:26). At the time of this story Jerusalem was still Jebusite, but readers in the monarchy period would have noticed that the priests' towns ring the area around it.

How lots were cast. Lots were drawn 'before the LORD' at the sanctuary (Josh 18:6–10; 19:51), probably by drawing marked tokens from a jar or shaking them out of a fold of clothing (Prov 16:33). 'Came out' fits a token drawn or shaken out of a container.

From the study of Joshua 21:4.

Where scholars differ

in v4

When does the list of Levitical towns (Josh 21 / 1 Chr 6) come from, and was it ever carried out as written?

  • It reflects an administrative arrangement of the united monarchy under David and Solomon.

    W. F. Albright argued that the spread of the towns, including towns in areas controlled only under David and Solomon, fits that period best. Others connect it with Levites settled as royal officials (compare 1 Chr 26:30–32).

  • It reflects a later reform period, for example Josiah's in the late 7th century BC.

    Albrecht Alt and others pointed to the geography and to the way worship was centralised in the time of the kings. Some towns on the list seem to fit later political borders.

  • It is largely an ideal plan drawn up by priestly writers, based on Numbers 35.

    Some towns appear not to have been occupied in the periods proposed. The tidy figures (48 towns, mostly four per tribe) and the shared material with Chronicles point to a planned scheme. Even so, many scholars think real places and memories lie behind it.

  • It is a record of an allocation made in Joshua's day, as the narrative presents it.

    This is the plain reading of the text, which links the allocation to the command in Numbers 35 and to the lot-casting at Shiloh (Josh 18–19). It is defended by more conservative commentators, who explain archaeological gaps by partial settlement or by identifying the sites differently.

in v4

Were priests and Levites always two separate classes?

  • The distinction between Aaronite priests and other Levites is old and goes back to Israel's early worship.

    Numbers 3–4 and 18 set out the two-level system, and this verse presupposes it.

  • The sharp distinction developed later; earlier, any Levite could serve as priest.

    Deuteronomy speaks of 'the Levitical priests' and of the whole tribe of Levi (Deut 18:1–8), and Ezekiel 44:10–16 demotes some Levites. In the 19th century Julius Wellhausen argued that the priestly writings, which this chapter reflects, came after Deuteronomy.

in v5

When was the Levitical city list (Joshua 21 / 1 Chronicles 6) composed, and does it reflect a real arrangement?

  • An administrative list from the united monarchy (David/Solomon).

    W. F. Albright and B. Mazar noted that towns like Gezer were only firmly Israelite from Solomon's time (1 Kgs 9:16). The list's spread fits royal administration of border and newly won areas.

  • A later, idealised or theological list (late monarchy, Josiah's era, or after the exile).

    A. Alt, and later N. Na'aman and others, point to its tidy pattern (4 towns per tribe, 48 in all), to towns Israel did not hold early, and to its links with priestly writing (Num 35). On this view it is an ideal map more than a record.

  • It preserves an early tradition that was later expanded.

    The differences between the Joshua and Chronicles versions, and the scribal damage in both, suggest a list that was copied and edited over time around an older core.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. גּוֹרָל, מִשְׁפָּחָה, עִיר, מַטֶּה
  • HALOT s.v. גּוֹרָל; מִשְׁפָּחָה; עִיר
  • STEPBible TAHOT (Translators Amalgamated Hebrew OT) morphology and lemma data
  • W. F. Albright, 'The List of Levitic Cities,' Louis Ginzberg Jubilee Volume (1945)
  • R. G. Boling & G. E. Wright, Joshua (Anchor Bible)
  • R. D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library)
  • T. C. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • R. S. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Joshua 21
  • Numbers 35:1–8; Deuteronomy 18:1–2; 1 Chronicles 6:54–60; Proverbs 16:33
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפָּחָה, עִיר, גּוֹרָל, יָתַר
  • Numbers 3:27–31; 4:1–15; 35:1–8; Leviticus 25:32–34
  • 1 Chronicles 6:54–70 (Heb. 6:39–55), parallel list
  • R. G. Boling & G. E. Wright, Joshua (Anchor Bible), on ch. 21
  • N. Na'aman, Borders and Districts in Biblical Historiography (1986)
  • W. F. Albright, 'The List of Levitic Cities' (1945)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).