Joshua Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Joshua 5:2–6
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
2At that time the LORD said to Joshua, “Make flint knives and circumcise the sons of Israel once again.” 3So Joshua made flint knives and circumcised the sons of Israel at Gibeath-haaraloth. 4Now this is why Joshua circumcised them: All those who came out of Egypt—all the men of war—had died on the journey in the wilderness after they had left Egypt. 5Though all who had come out were circumcised, none of those born in the wilderness on the journey from Egypt had been circumcised. 6For the Israelites had wandered in the wilderness forty years, until all the nation’s men of war who had come out of Egypt had died, since they did not obey the LORD. So the LORD vowed never to let them see the land He had sworn to their fathers to give us, a land flowing with milk and honey.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelites who heard this story, Gilgal was a founding scene. The verse said several things at once:
- Identity before conquest. The first thing Israel does in the land is not to fight but to be marked as the covenant people. Possession of the land rests on God's promise to Abraham, and the sign of that promise comes before the sword.
- A new generation, fully included. The children of the wilderness generation, whose parents died under judgment (Num 14; Josh 5:6), are not second-class Israelites. They receive the same sign "a second time", as the Exodus generation once did. The reproach of the past is "rolled away" (5:9, a play on the name Gilgal).
- Trust shown in the body. Disabling every fighting man in enemy country only made sense if God was their defence. Placed right after the enemy's collapse (5:1), the command shows Israel's safety as God's doing.
- Getting ready to worship. The circumcision makes possible the Passover (5:10), the end of the manna and the first meal of the land's produce (5:11–12). The story moves from the wilderness to settled life in the land.
- Sacred tradition. The flint knives mark this as a rite with deep roots, not a medical procedure. The Greek tradition later remembered the knives as relics buried with Joshua.
From the study of Joshua 5:2.
Verse by verse
-
2At that time the LORD said to Joshua, “Make flint knives and circumcise the sons of Israel once again.”
Full study →At that very moment (just after the waters of the Jordan stopped and Canaan's kings went weak with fear, 5:1), the LORD, the God bound to Israel by covenant, gave Joshua a direct order: "Make yourself blades of flint, and do it again: circumcise the men of Israel a second time."
The word used for the "knives" is the ordinary Hebrew word for sword. In a book about to be full of swords, the first blade lifted after the crossing is turned on Israel's own men, not on the enemy. The blades are to be flint, stone knives, though metal was available. That makes this a deliberately old, sacred rite. It recalls Zipporah's flint at the start of the Exodus story (Exod 4:25) and the covenant sign first given to Abraham, alongside the promise that his offspring would own this very land (Gen 17:8–11).
"Again… a second time" does not mean anyone is cut twice. As the next verses explain, the men born during the forty years in the wilderness had never been circumcised. "A second time" refers to the nation: Israel was marked once as the people who came out of Egypt, and now the new generation is marked as the people entering the land. The order of events matters. Before any battle, and before the Passover four days later (which only circumcised men could eat), Israel had to be made, in the flesh, the covenant people again. That meant several days of weakness in enemy country, and it was safe only because God had already filled the enemy with terror.
-
3So Joshua made flint knives and circumcised the sons of Israel at Gibeath-haaraloth.
Full study →"So Joshua made himself flint blades, just as he was told, and circumcised the men of Israel, the whole generation born in the wilderness, at the place that ever afterwards was called 'Foreskin Hill'."
The verse is a point-for-point report that God's command in v.2 was obeyed. "Make for yourself flint knives… and circumcise" becomes "he made for himself flint knives… and he circumcised". The blades are literally "swords of rocks": hand knives knapped from flint. They are the same kind of stone edge Zipporah used in Exodus 4:25, an old, ritually fitting tool rather than a bronze or iron one.
"Sons of Israel" here means the males of the nation, and specifically the men and boys born during the forty years in the wilderness who had never received the covenant mark (vv.5–7). These were the army that had just crossed the Jordan. Circumcising them all at once in enemy country, within sight of Jericho, left the whole camp disabled for days (v.8).
The place name rounds off the scene with an earthy, unforgettable label. Gibeath-haaraloth means "the Hill of the Foreskins", the mound where the cut foreskins were left. It became a landmark that kept the event in public memory: here Israel took on Abraham's covenant sign before keeping its first Passover in the promised land (v.10).
-
4Now this is why Joshua circumcised them: All those who came out of Egypt—all the men of war—had died on the journey in the wilderness after they had left Egypt.
Full study →"And here is the account of why Joshua circumcised them. Every male of the people who came out of Egypt, every man old enough to be counted for war, died in the wilderness. They died on the road, while they were still on their way out of Egypt."
The verse is the narrator stepping aside to explain verse 3. Israel has just crossed the Jordan. Now, inside enemy territory, Joshua circumcises the whole adult male population with flint knives. Why would a nation descended from Abraham need this? Because the men who had borne the covenant sign were gone. "Men of war" does not mean professional soldiers. It means the census-counted men aged twenty and over (Numbers 1:3), the very group God swore at Kadesh would die in the wilderness for refusing to enter the land (Numbers 14:29–35). The verse names them in a widening-then-narrowing sweep: "all the people… the males… all the men of war." The double "from Egypt" frames the line like an epitaph: they came out of Egypt, and they died still coming out of Egypt, on the road and short of the goal. Verse 5 completes the thought. Those men had been circumcised, but the sons born on the journey had not. So the sign had to be given again to a new generation before it could keep the Passover (5:10) and take up the promise.
-
5Though all who had come out were circumcised, none of those born in the wilderness on the journey from Egypt had been circumcised.
Full study →Here is the reason: every man of the generation that marched out of Egypt, the "Goers-Out," bore the mark of the covenant in his body. But their sons, the ones born out in the dry grazing country while the long road out of Egypt was still being walked, had never been given it. No one had circumcised them.
The verse is built like a balanced pair. It opens with "circumcised" and closes with "not circumcised," and the middle repeats "all the people... and all the people." The point: both groups are fully Israel, the same kin and the same covenant family, but one carries the sign and the other does not. The phrase "on the way, in their going out from Egypt" treats the whole forty years as part of the exodus, which is only now ending at Gilgal. The last verb is active and has no stated subject ("they did not circumcise"). It records something left undone during the wandering without saying who was responsible. Verse 6 points to the reason in the background: the wandering itself was the sentence on a disobedient generation. The verse explains why Joshua had to circumcise an entire army on enemy soil, right before Passover. No uncircumcised male could eat it (Exod 12:48).
-
6For the Israelites had wandered in the wilderness forty years, until all the nation’s men of war who had come out of Egypt had died, since they did not obey the LORD. So the LORD vowed never to let them see the land He had sworn to their fathers to give us, a land flowing with milk and honey.
Full study →For forty years the Israelites travelled through the wilderness steppe, until the whole nation, that is, every fighting man who had marched out of Egypt, had come to a complete end. They were the ones who did not listen to the LORD's voice, and the LORD swore an oath against them that he would not even let them lay eyes on the land. That was the land the LORD had sworn to their ancestors to give to us: a land running with milk and honey.
The verse explains why the generation standing at Gilgal had never been circumcised: the wilderness years were a sentence, and they had just ended. Every phrase points back to the scene at Kadesh (Numbers 13–14). There the spies reported a land 'flowing with milk and honey', the men of fighting age refused God's command to go up, and God swore they would die in the wilderness 'until your corpses are finished'.
Joshua uses that same verb, 'finished', and the reader is meant to feel the account being closed. It also links to the chapters around it. 'The whole nation' that came to an end in the wilderness stands opposite 'the whole nation' that has just 'finished' crossing the Jordan (3:17) and will 'finish' being circumcised (5:8).
The Hebrew says 'swore' twice in a row. God's oath of judgment against one generation and his oath of promise to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob were both kept. The rebels were refused even the sight of the land, the thing God granted Moses from Mount Nebo. At the end the narrator says 'to give us'. The storyteller stands with the generation that received the gift and speaks Israel's own confession: the land was promised long ago, and we are the ones who received it.
Where the English drifted
-
in v2, v3
sharp knives (KJV)
ḥarbôt ṣurîm
- What we hear
- Ordinary sharp knives, presumably metal, such as any kitchen or tradesman's blade.
- What they heard
- Blades of flint: stone knives chosen for a sacred rite even though metal tools existed, recalling Zipporah's flint (Exod 4:25).
-
in v2
circumcise again… the second time
wəšûb mōl… šēnît
- What we hear
- The same men were being circumcised a second time, or an earlier circumcision had to be redone.
- What they heard
- A second circumcision of the nation. The wilderness-born men had never been circumcised (vv. 4–7). The nation was marked once in the time of the Exodus and is now marked again as it enters the land.
-
in v3
children of Israel (KJV)
bənê yiśrāʾēl
- What we hear
- Young boys or kids.
- What they heard
- The male descendants of Israel. Here that means the adult and teenage men born in the wilderness, the nation's fighting force.
-
in v4
men of war
ʾanšê hammilḥāmâ
- What we hear
- Professional soldiers or warriors
- What they heard
- All adult Israelite males aged twenty and over, registered for the tribal muster (Numbers 1:3), i.e. the whole adult male generation
-
in v4
All the people that came out of Egypt… died
kol-hāʿām hayyōṣēʾ… hazzekārîm
- What we hear
- The entire population that left Egypt, men, women and children, died in the wilderness
- What they heard
- The verse at once narrows 'all the people' to 'the males… the men of war', the group sentenced in Numbers 14:29. Those who were children at the Exodus survived. So did Joshua and Caleb, and the uncounted Levites probably did too.
-
in v5
wilderness
midbār
- What we hear
- Forest or untouched nature, or else an empty sand desert.
- What they heard
- Semi-arid steppe and scrub outside farmland, often used for grazing flocks. Sparse and harsh, but not lifeless, and in Israel's story the place of both testing and God's care.
-
in v6
wandered (BSB, NLT)
halekhu (from halakh)
- What we hear
- They were lost, going in aimless circles because they couldn't find their way.
- What they heard
- 'They walked / went about': a neutral verb of travel. The forty years were a sentence of time to be served until a generation died off, not a navigation failure. Elsewhere the Bible does say God 'made them wander' (Num 32:13, a different verb) and that they 'circled Mount Seir' (Deut 2:1–3), so the idea of wandering is biblical. It just isn't in this word.
-
in v6
were consumed (KJV, WEB, YLT)
tom (from tamam)
- What we hear
- Destroyed suddenly, devoured or burned up.
- What they heard
- 'Came to an end, were used up, finished': a whole generation dying off over decades until none was left, carrying out the sentence of Numbers 14:33–35.
-
in v6
a land flowing with milk and honey
ʾerets zavat chalav udevash
- What we hear
- A paradise of luxury and effortless wealth.
- What they heard
- A land rich in pasture (goat and sheep milk) and natural sweetness (wild honey and the syrup of dates, figs and grapes). It praises the land's fertility for herders and farmers. It does not promise a life free of work.
Every word
-
בָּעֵ֣ת
ba'ēt · H6256
at the time · v2
'At the time', a particular moment and not a general age. It ties God's command to the situation just described: the crossing of the Jordan, and the Canaanite kings losing heart (5:1).
-
הַהִ֗יא
hahî' · H1931
that · v2
'That' points back to the moment in verse 1. The timing matters: Israel's enemies are frozen with fear, so the army can safely be put out of action for a few days.
-
אָמַ֤ר
'āmar · H0559
said · v2
A plain past-tense 'said'. The rite starts with a direct order from God, not with Joshua's own plan.
-
יְהוָה֙
YHWH · H3068
the LORD (Yahweh) · v2, v6
Israel's God, called by his covenant name, the name tied to his binding promises to Israel. Fitting here, because the command restores the sign of that covenant.
-
אֶל־
'el · H0413
to · v2, v3
Marks who is spoken to: the command is aimed at Joshua as leader.
-
יְהוֹשֻׁ֔עַ
yəhôšua' · H3091
Joshua · v2, v3, v4
Moses' successor. In the story, the leader who brings the people into the land now carries out the rite that marks them as Abraham's covenant offspring.
-
עֲשֵׂ֥ה
'ăśēh · H6213
make · v2, v3
A command, 'make'. Joshua is to make (or have made) the tools on the spot. These knives are produced for this one rite.
-
לְךָ֖
ləkā
for yourself · v2
'For yourself.' Hebrew often adds this after a command to keep the action close to the person told to do it (cf. Gen 12:1, 'go for yourself'). It does not mean the knives are for Joshua's private use. Most modern versions drop it; KJV's 'make thee' and YLT's 'for thee' keep it.
-
חַֽרְב֣וֹת
ḥarbôt · H2719
blades, knives (usually 'swords') · v2, v3
The normal word for 'sword', here used of cutting blades in general, so 'knives'. Any reader of Joshua would notice that a book full of swords begins its conquest with blades turned on Israel's own men.
-
צֻרִ֑ים
ṣurîm · H6697
rocks; flint · v2, v3
'Of rocks', meaning flint, the hard stone that flakes into a razor edge. 'Blades of flint' are stone knives, not metal ones.
-
וְשׁ֛וּב
wəšûb · H7725
and return / again · v2
Literally 'and turn back'. When joined to another verb, as here, šûb means 'do it again'. So 'return, circumcise' means 'circumcise again'. YLT's 'turn back' is too literal.
-
מֹ֥ל
mōl · H4135
circumcise · v2, v3, v4, v5
A command, 'circumcise': cut away the foreskin, the bodily sign of the covenant God made with Abraham (Gen 17:10–14).
-
אֶת־
'et · H0853
[direct object marker] · v2, v3, v6
A grammar word that cannot be translated. It marks 'the sons of Israel' as the ones being circumcised.
-
בְּנֵֽי־
bənê · H1121
sons of · v2, v3, v6
'Sons of' Israel. Often this phrase simply means 'Israelites', but here it really is the males, because only males were circumcised. 'Sons' is accurate.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל
yiśrā'ēl · H3478
Israel · v2, v3, v6
The people descended from Jacob-Israel, here the generation born in the wilderness (vv. 4–7).
-
שֵׁנִֽית׃
šēnît · H8145
a second time · v2
'A second time.' It goes with 'again' (šûb) to make the point twice. As verses 4–7 explain, this is the nation's second mass circumcision, not a second circumcision of the same men.
-
ל֥וֹ
lô · H9033
for himself · v3
Literally 'for him'. It repeats the 'for yourself' of v.2, so Joshua makes the blades for his own use in this job. KJV's 'made him' is old English for 'made himself'. Most modern versions drop the word because it adds little in English.
-
גִּבְעַ֖ת
gibʿat · H1389
hill of · v3
A low hill or mound, here the first part of a place name near Gilgal.
-
הָעֲרָלֽוֹת׃
hāʿărālôt · H6190
the foreskins · v3
With the article: 'the foreskins'. The place name means 'Hill of the Foreskins'. It reads naturally as a name taken from this very event, the spot where the removed foreskins were left or buried.
-
וְזֶ֥ה
wezeh · H2088
and this · v4
Points forward to the explanation that follows. The narrator pauses the action of verse 3 to account for it.
-
הַדָּבָ֖ר
haddābār · H1697
word, matter, thing; reason · v4
'The matter' or 'the account': the reason behind what happened. The supplied gloss 'because' captures the function here, but the word itself is a noun, 'thing / affair'.
-
אֲשֶׁר־
ʾăšer · H834
which, that · v4, v6
Links 'the matter' to Joshua's act: 'the matter for which / that' Joshua circumcised, which English renders as 'why'.
-
כָּל־
kol · H3605
all · v4, v5, v6
'All', the first of two sweeping 'alls' that stress that none of that generation was left.
-
הָעָ֣ם
hāʿām · H5971
people · v4, v5
'The people', the kin-community of Israel. At once the narrator narrows it to the adult males (next words).
-
הַיֹּצֵא֩
hayyōṣēʾ · H3318
go out, come out · v4, v5, v6
'The one coming out': a singular participle ('-ing' form) agreeing with 'people' as a collective. It calls up the Exodus itself, the defining 'going out'.
-
מִמִּצְרַ֨יִם
mimmiṣrayim · H4714
from Egypt · v4, v5, v6
Names the place of slavery. With the repeated phrase at the end of the verse it brackets the whole statement.
-
הַזְּכָרִ֜ים
hazzekārîm · H2145
male(s) · v4
'The males'. The narrator narrows 'all the people' to the males, because they are the ones circumcision concerns and the ones counted for war.
-
אַנְשֵׁ֣י
ʾanšê · H582
men of · v4, v6
'Men of…', joined to the next word. In practice the plural of ʾîš, 'man'. Strong's files this plural form under H582.
-
הַמִּלְחָמָ֗ה
hammilḥāmâ · H4421
battle, war · v4, v6
'Men of the war': the fighting-age males counted in the census, twenty years and older (Numbers 1:3). These were not professional soldiers.
-
מֵ֤תוּ
mētû · H4191
to die · v4
'Died' (completed action). This is the verdict of Numbers 14 carried out: that generation's bodies would fall in the wilderness.
-
בַמִּדְבָּר֙
bammidbār · H4057
wilderness, steppe · v4, v5, v6
The dry grazing land and desert between Egypt and Canaan. It was the place of testing, and here the place of the burial of a generation.
-
בַּדֶּ֔רֶךְ
badderek · H1870
way, road, journey · v4, v5
'On the way / en route'. They died while travelling and never reached the goal of the journey.
-
כִּֽי־
kî · H3588A
for, because, indeed · v5, v6
Carries on the explanation begun in verse 4 ("this is the reason Joshua circumcised them"). It means "you see" or "the fact is." BSB's "Though" comes from reading the two halves of the verse as a contrast, not from this word itself.
-
הָי֔וּ
hāyû · H1961
to be · v5
"They were." Paired with the participle it means "they were in the circumcised state," which is why English gives "had been circumcised."
-
הַיִּלֹּדִ֨ים
hayyillōdîm · H3209
born (ones) · v5
A rare word for "the born ones." It names the children who came into the world during the wandering. It is the same uncommon word Pharaoh used in Exodus 1:22 for the newborn sons he wanted killed.
-
לֹא־
lōʾ · H3808
not · v5, v6
Flat negation placed just before the last verb, so the verse ends on an absence.
-
אַרְבָּעִ֣ים
ʾarbaʿim · H0705
forty · v6
The span of one generation. It is also the sentence pronounced in Numbers 14:33–34: one year for each day the spies spent in the land.
-
שָׁנָ֗ה
shanah · H8141
year · v6
Singular in form, as is normal in Hebrew after numbers above ten. It means 'years'.
-
הָלְכ֣וּ
halekhu · H1980I
walk, go · v6
An ordinary verb for walking or travelling: 'they went about'. On its own it does not say 'wander' or 'get lost'. It describes a long journey that is now complete.
-
עַד־
ʿad · H5704
until · v6
Marks the point the forty years were waiting for. The journey's length was tied to the end of a generation, not to the distance.
-
תֹּ֨ם
tom · H8552
be complete, come to an end · v6
Literally 'the finishing of'. The old generation came to a full end. In Joshua 3–5 the same verb describes the new nation 'finishing' its crossing of the Jordan (3:17; 4:1, 11) and 'finishing' its circumcision (5:8).
-
הַגּ֜וֹי
haggoy · H1471A
nation, people · v6
'The nation', used here of Israel itself. The next phrase narrows it down: the whole nation in the sense of its fighting men.
-
שָׁמְע֖וּ
shameʿu · H8085H
hear, listen, obey · v6
'Hear', in the full Hebrew sense: hearing that goes on to act. Not listening was the same as disobeying.
-
בְּק֣וֹל
beqol · H6963A
-
נִשְׁבַּ֤ע
nishbaʿ · H7650
swear (an oath) · v6
'He swore': a solemn oath that cannot be taken back. This first oath is against the Exodus generation (Num 14:21–23, 28–30).
-
לָהֶ֔ם
lahem · H9038
to them · v6
'To them': the oath was declared to the guilty generation itself.
-
לְבִלְתִּ֞י
levilti · H1115
so as not, not to · v6
Negates the infinitive that follows: 'so as not to…'. This states what the oath contained.
-
הַרְאוֹתָ֣ם
harʾotam · H7200G
see; (causative) show · v6
'To cause them to see', that is, to show them. The same form is used when God 'let Moses see' the land from Mount Nebo (Deut 34:4). The rebels were denied even that.
-
הָאָ֗רֶץ
haʾarets · H0776G
land, earth, country · v6
'The land': the specific territory of Canaan promised to Israel, not the earth in general.
-
לַֽאֲבוֹתָם֙
laʾavotam · H0001G
father, ancestor · v6
'To their fathers': the ancestors Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, to whom the land oath was first given.
-
לָ֣תֶת
latet · H5414G
give · v6
'To give': the land is a gift handed over by God, not simply won.
-
לָ֔נוּ
lanu · H9035
-
זָבַ֥ת
zavat · H2100G
flowing, oozing · v6
'Flowing of': the land runs or oozes with richness. The verb is used of liquid that seeps or streams out.
-
חָלָ֖ב
chalav · H2461
milk · v6
Mostly goat and sheep milk. It stands for good pasture and healthy flocks.
-
וּדְבָֽשׁ׃
udevash · H1706
honey; fruit syrup · v6
'And honey': sweet syrup, either wild bee honey or the thick syrup made from dates, figs or grapes. With milk it pictures a land rich in what it gives naturally.
The world behind it
Where and when. Israel has just crossed the Jordan on the tenth day of the first month (4:19) and camped at Gilgal, near Jericho, inside Canaan. Passover falls on the fourteenth (5:10). That leaves a few days between entering the land and the first festival held there.
Why the timing is striking. Adult circumcision left men unable to fight for several days. Genesis 34 tells how Simeon and Levi attacked Shechem "on the third day, when they were in pain". Ordering it for the whole fighting force inside enemy territory would have been reckless by any military standard. Verse 1 is placed just before this command to explain why it was possible: the Amorite and Canaanite kings' "hearts melted", and they had no fight left.
Why circumcision, and why now.
- Covenant sign: In Genesis 17 circumcision is the "sign of the covenant" for Abraham's descendants. The same chapter promises them "all the land of Canaan" (17:8). Standing in that land for the first time, Israel takes up the sign of the promise being fulfilled.
- Passover requirement: Exod 12:43–49 bars any uncircumcised male from eating the Passover. Without this rite, the first Passover in Canaan (5:10–11) could not have been kept.
- The wilderness gap: Verses 4–7 explain that the men who left Egypt were circumcised but died in the wilderness. Their sons, born on the journey, were not.
Circumcision in the ancient world. Israel was not the only people to circumcise. Egyptian reliefs show the practice (the tomb of Ankhmahor at Saqqara). Jeremiah lists Egypt, Edom, Ammon and Moab as circumcising (Jer 9:25–26). Herodotus (2.104) says the peoples of Syria-Palestine did it too. For Israel, what mattered was not the cut itself but what it meant: belonging to the covenant with Abraham's God.
Flint. By the time this story was told, metal blades were common. Using stone for sacred acts is a well-known form of ritual conservatism, keeping to the older tools for holy things. Compare the ban on cutting altar stones with an iron tool (Exod 20:25; Deut 27:5; Josh 8:31).
From the study of Joshua 5:2.
Where scholars differ
in v2
What does 'again… a second time' refer to?
-
A second mass circumcision of the nation, the first having been in the time of the Exodus.
Verses 4–7 say that all who came out of Egypt had been circumcised, but those born in the wilderness had not. Exod 12:48 required circumcision before Passover. The 'first time' is the Exodus generation, the 'second' is Gilgal. This is the view of most modern commentators (e.g. Butler, Hess, Nelson).
-
A second stage of the cut on men already circumcised (rabbinic periʿah).
The Babylonian Talmud (Yevamot 71b) and medieval commentators such as Rashi connect 'a second time' with periʿah, uncovering, a second step added to make a circumcision complete. This reads later rabbinic practice into the scene. It is not supported by vv. 4–7, which describe men never circumcised at all.
-
The repetition markers belong to how the text developed and reflect editorial harmonisation.
The Greek's different wording ('sit down') and its different version of vv. 4–6 suggest the passage grew over time. Some critical scholars think 'again' and 'a second time' were added to link the scene with the Exodus circumcision. This is a hypothesis about how the text grew and does not change what the finished text means.
-
A contrast with an Egyptian-style partial circumcision ('the reproach of Egypt', v. 9).
Some have suggested that Israelites in Egypt practised an Egyptian form of cutting that was later felt to be inadequate. Evidence for differing Egyptian techniques exists but is debated, and the Hebrew text itself points to non-circumcision in the wilderness, not a flawed earlier cut. This view is speculative.
in v2
Why flint knives?
-
Ritual conservatism: sacred acts keep to old tools.
Metal tools existed. Zipporah used flint (Exod 4:25). Israel avoided iron tools on altar stones (Exod 20:25; Deut 27:5; Josh 8:31). Many ancient cultures kept older materials for holy rites.
-
Practical reasons: flint is very sharp and was easy to get.
Knapped flint (stone chipped into shape) gives an extremely fine edge, and flint tools stayed in everyday use well into the Iron Age. The two explanations can be combined.
in v3
What does the 'second time' of the command in v.2 imply about the circumcision carried out in v.3?
-
A second national circumcision: the nation as a whole was circumcised once before (in Egypt or at the exodus) and now again, for the new generation.
The explanation in the Hebrew of vv.4–7 says everyone who left Egypt had been circumcised, but those born in the wilderness had not. 'Again' therefore refers to the nation, not to individuals being cut twice.
-
A completion of an earlier, partial circumcision.
Rabbinic tradition (Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 71b) explains 'the second time' as adding *periʿah*, the fuller uncovering of the glans, to an earlier, incomplete cut. Some modern writers instead suggest a contrast with a less complete Egyptian-style practice. The text itself does not describe any such difference.
-
The Greek version's account: some men from the exodus generation were also uncircumcised.
The Greek of vv.4–5 differs from the Hebrew and seems to explain the rite as covering both exodus-born and wilderness-born men who lacked it.
in v3
Did the hill take its name from this event, or was an existing name reinterpreted?
-
The name comes from the event: the foreskins were heaped or buried there.
This is the plain reading of the narrative. Joshua 4–5 has several other names and monuments explained by events (Gilgal in 5:9, the twelve stones in ch. 4).
-
An older local name has been attached to the story.
Some critical scholars treat Joshua's explanations of names as stories that later accounted for existing places. There is no independent evidence of an earlier name, so this remains a theory.
in v4
Why had the wilderness-born sons not been circumcised?
-
The covenant relationship was suspended for the condemned generation after Kadesh, so the sign was not given until the new generation entered the land.
Verse 6 links the matter to the generation's disobedience. Verse 9 ('today I have rolled away the reproach of Egypt') marks a restored status. Numbers 14:34 speaks of God's 'opposition' or 'displeasure' for forty years.
-
It was a practical omission: constant travel and wilderness conditions made the eighth-day rite hard to keep.
The text says only that they 'were not circumcised… on the way' (v. 5). Some later Jewish tradition (e.g. Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 71b–72a) explains it through the hardships and dangers of the journey.
-
The parents' unfaithfulness included neglecting the sign, and the narrator simply records the neglect.
Verse 6 says they 'did not listen to the voice of the LORD'. Elsewhere neglecting the covenant sign brings danger (Exodus 4:24–26).
in v4
Which form of the account is older, the Hebrew (Masoretic) or the Greek (Septuagint)?
-
The Septuagint reflects an earlier Hebrew text that the Masoretic tradition later reworked.
Differences extend over several verses, consistently and in ways that read like a different underlying text, not random error. Some text-critics argue this for Joshua's Greek more generally.
-
The Septuagint translator or its source harmonised a difficult text.
The Greek removes the awkward implication that a whole generation was uncircumcised and fits better with 'a second time' in verse 2. Smoothing of that kind is typical of secondary readings.
in v5
Why were the children born in the wilderness not circumcised?
-
The covenant sign was suspended as part of the judgment on the rebellious generation (Num 14).
Verse 6 ties the wandering to the fathers' disobedience and God's oath. Verse 9 speaks of a "reproach" removed. Calvin and many modern commentators take the lapse as part of the wilderness sentence, lifted once the land is entered.
-
It was put off for practical or health reasons during constant travel.
The Babylonian Talmud (Yevamot 71b–72a) explains that they did not circumcise because of the exhaustion of the journey, or because "the north wind did not blow" (it was thought to aid healing), so the operation was dangerous. Numbers 9:15–23 describes moves at unpredictable times, which would leave no safe time to heal.
-
The people simply neglected it, one more sign of the wilderness generation's unfaithfulness.
The active verb with no subject ("they did not circumcise") can be read as quietly blaming the parents. Elsewhere the wilderness story stresses Israel's failures.
-
The text does not say, and any answer goes beyond it.
Verses 4–7 explain only what happened (one generation died, the next was uncircumcised). They never give a reason for the lapse. Many commentators stress that the narrator leaves this unexplained.
in v5
Was the whole exodus generation circumcised?
-
Yes, as the Hebrew text says.
The Masoretic Text of verse 5 says so outright. Exodus 12:48–50 assumes the Israelites kept Passover in Egypt, which required circumcision.
-
No, some were not, as the Greek tradition suggests.
The LXX of 5:4–6 speaks of uncircumcised men among those who left Egypt. Exodus 4:24–26 (Moses' own son uncircumcised) and Joshua 24:14 (idolatry in Egypt) show that observance in Egypt may have been uneven. Some scholars think the LXX preserves an older Hebrew wording.
in v6
Why were the sons born in the wilderness not circumcised along the way?
-
Practical hardship: travel conditions made circumcision dangerous or impractical.
The Babylonian Talmud (Yevamot 71b–72a) suggests the exhaustion of the journey, and lack of a healthy north wind, as reasons. Verse 7 says only that they 'had not circumcised them on the way'.
-
A judgment status: while the rejected generation lived out its sentence, the covenant sign was not given to the next generation.
The passage ties the omission directly to the Kadesh sentence (vv. 6–7). Circumcision resumes only once that generation is 'finished'. Verse 9 also speaks of a 'reproach' being rolled away.
-
The text does not say. Its interest is literary and theological: Gilgal as a fresh covenant start before Passover.
Verses 4–7 explain who was uncircumcised, not why. The narrative then moves straight to circumcision, Passover and the end of the manna (5:8–12), marking a new beginning.
in v6
What is the 'honey' (devash) of 'milk and honey'?
-
Bee honey, chiefly wild.
Judges 14:8 (honey in a lion's carcass) and 1 Samuel 14:25–27 (honey in the forest) clearly mean bee honey. Beekeeping is attested archaeologically at Tel Rehov (Iron Age, about 10th–9th century BC).
-
Mainly fruit syrup (date, fig or grape), like the Arabic *dibs*.
2 Chronicles 31:5 lists *devash* among farm produce tithed alongside grain, wine and oil. Fruit syrup was a staple sweetener in the region. Later rabbinic writers often took the 'honey' of the formula to be date honey.
-
The word covered both, and the formula pictures natural sweetness in general.
*devash* is a general word for sticky sweet syrup. The formula is poetic praise of the land's natural riches rather than a list of products.
in v6
Who is the 'us' in 'to give us'?
-
The narrator writes as a member of, or close to, the generation that entered the land.
A first-person slip like this can suggest an eyewitness or early perspective. Compare 'until we had crossed' in some readings of Joshua 5:1, where the written and read traditions of the Hebrew text differ.
-
It is the confessional 'we' of later Israel identifying with the generation that entered.
Deuteronomy uses exactly this voice: 'the land the LORD swore to our fathers to give us' (Deut 26:3, 9) and 'not with our fathers… but with us' (Deut 5:3), across generations.
Sources
- BDB s.v. חֶרֶב, צוּר, מוּל, שׁוּב, שֵׁנִי
- HALOT s.v. צוּר (II, flint), מוּל, שׁוּב
- Septuagint, Joshua 5:2–6; 21:42d; 24:31a
- Vulgate, Josue 5:2
- Targum Jonathan to Joshua 5:2
- Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 71b; Rashi on Joshua 5:2
- Herodotus, Histories 2.104
- Old Kingdom tomb relief of Ankhmahor, Saqqara (circumcision scene)
- T. C. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
- R. D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library)
- R. S. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Joshua 5
- BDB s.v. חֶרֶב, צוּר, מוּל, עׇרְלָה, גִּבְעָה
- HALOT s.v. צוּר (II 'flint, stone knife')
- Septuagint, Joshua 5:2–5; 21:42d; 24:30–31a (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Josue 5:3
- Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 71b
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Joshua 5:2–9
- Richard S. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
- Marten H. Woudstra, The Book of Joshua (NICOT)
- Trent C. Butler, Joshua (Word Biblical Commentary)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. מוּל, דָּבָר, מִלְחָמָה, יָצָא
- Numbers 1:3; 14:29–35; 26:64–65; Deuteronomy 2:14–16 (internal parallels)
- Septuagint, Joshua 5:4–6 (Rahlfs edition)
- Vulgate, Joshua 5:4
- Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 71b–72a (on the non-circumcision in the wilderness)
- Herodotus, Histories 2.104 (circumcision among Egyptians and others)
- R. D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library), on 5:2–9 and the Septuagint differences
- BDB s.v. מוּל
- HALOT s.v. מוּל; s.v. יִלּוֹד; s.v. מִדְבָּר
- Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 71b–72a
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Joshua 5:2–9
- Vulgate, Josue 5:5
- Richard D. Nelson, Joshua (Old Testament Library)
- John Calvin, Commentary on Joshua 5
- BDB s.v. תָּמַם, שָׁמַע, שָׁבַע, דְּבַשׁ, גּוֹי
- HALOT s.v. תמם, שׁמע, שׁבע, דְּבַשׁ
- Richard S. Hess, Joshua (Tyndale Old Testament Commentaries)
- Story of Sinuhe (description of the land of Yaa)
- Ugaritic Baal Cycle, KTU 1.6 III
- Septuagint, Joshua 5:4–6
- Numbers 13–14; Deuteronomy 1–2; 26; 34
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).