Luke Chapter 7 Read as one passage

Luke 7:24–25

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

24After John’s messengers had left, Jesus began to speak to the crowds about John: “What did you go out into the wilderness to see? A reed swaying in the wind? 25Otherwise, what did you go out to see? A man dressed in fine clothes? Look, those who wear elegant clothing and live in luxury are found in palaces.

What the first hearers heard

For the Galilean crowds this was a pointed reminder of their own experience. Many had walked out to the Jordan, heard John's fierce preaching (3:7–14), and been baptized. Jesus makes them ask why they went. The silly first answer, "to look at reeds," clears the way for the true one. Their own trip showed they had recognized in John something greater than any ordinary sight.

The verse also did three things in that moment:

  • It defended John. After John's question from prison, Jesus publicly denied that John was a vacillating man. In Scripture's terms, John was like the righteous one who "will not be shaken" (Ps 16:8 LXX), not the "broken reed" one cannot lean on (Isa 36:6).
  • It set up a contrast with power. Together with v. 25 (fine clothes, palaces), the image sets the rough wilderness prophet against the comfortable, pliable court of Antipas, the very ruler who had imprisoned him. Hearers who knew Antipas's coinage may have caught a sharper jab.
  • It opened a climax. The three questions (vv. 24, 25, 26) build to "a prophet, and more than a prophet," and then to the identification of John as the messenger of Malachi 3:1 (v. 27). That placed John, and so Jesus, inside Israel's expectation that God was about to act.

From the study of Luke 7:24.

Verse by verse

  1. 24After John’s messengers had left, Jesus began to speak to the crowds about John: “What did you go out into the wilderness to see? A reed swaying in the wind?

    Once John's two disciples were gone, so that none of this could look like flattery meant for the prison, Jesus turned to the crowds and started talking about John himself. He made them remember their own trip: "When you left your towns and went out into that empty country by the Jordan, the place where Israel's prophets and its hopes of a new exodus belonged, what sight did you think you were going to watch? A reed, bending back and forth in the wind?"

    The question is meant to sound faintly ridiculous. Reeds lined the Jordan by the thousand, and nobody makes a pilgrimage to look at one. In Israel's Scriptures, though, a reed was also the standard picture of something flimsy and unreliable, pushed whichever way the wind blows. John had just sent word from prison asking whether Jesus really was "the one who is to come," so someone might suspect John was wavering. Jesus rules that out: whatever drew you to John, it was not a man who bends with every pressure. Some listeners may also have heard a dig at Herod Antipas, the ruler who had John in chains, whose coins appear to have shown a reed. The next verse, about soft clothing and palaces, points even more plainly at a royal court. This verse opens a set of three rising questions (vv. 24–26), and they lead to the real answer: John was a prophet, and more than a prophet.

    Full study →
  2. 25Otherwise, what did you go out to see? A man dressed in fine clothes? Look, those who wear elegant clothing and live in luxury are found in palaces.

    Jesus has just asked the crowds what they went into the wilderness to see, and suggested a reed bending in the wind. Now he offers a second, equally absurd answer: "No? Then what did you go out there to look at? A man wrapped in soft, fine fabrics, the costly cloth of the rich? Look, people who wear clothing that advertises their rank, and who live a life of pampered luxury, are found in kings' palaces."

    The answer is obvious, and that is the point. Nobody walks out into the desert by the Jordan to find a courtier. That kind of person lives in royal residences, where the clothing is "glorious" (it displays honor) and life is soft and plentiful. John was the opposite. He wore the rough garment of the old prophets, ate desert food, and drank no wine (7:33). He was neither a reed that bends to every wind nor a well-dressed man who bends to a king. Galileans would think of the court of Herod Antipas, the king John had denounced, and Luke's readers know (3:19–20) that John is now in that king's custody. The man the crowds went out to see is not at court. He is in a king's prison because he refused to be the kind of man courts are full of. The next verse gives the real answer: a prophet, and more than a prophet.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v24

    wilderness / desert

    erēmos

    What we hear
    A barren expanse of sand, a place of mere emptiness or scenery (especially where older translations say "desert").
    What they heard
    Uninhabited country away from towns, here the Jordan valley where reeds grew along the river. To a Jewish hearer it was a place full of memory: the exodus, testing, and Isaiah's promised voice preparing the way of the Lord.
  • in v25

    soft raiment / soft clothing (KJV, WEB, ESV)

    malakois himatiois

    What we hear
    Comfortable clothes: cozy, casual, gentle on the skin.
    What they heard
    Fine, smooth, costly fabrics that only the wealthy and the court could afford, and that visibly marked a person as rich and of high rank.
  • in v25

    live delicately (KJV, WEB)

    tryphē hyparchontes

    What we hear
    Living gently or fragilely, sheltered or refined in a quiet way.
    What they heard
    Living in luxury and indulgence: lavish food, comfort and pleasure, the showy abundance of a royal court.
Every word
  1. Ἀπελθόντων

    Apelthontōn · G0565

    to go away, depart · v24

    "When they had gone away." The form sets the timing: Jesus waits until John's men have left before he praises John, so this is not flattery meant to be carried back to the prison.

  2. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, then, but · v24

    A light connective that moves the story on: "then." It marks a shift from Jesus' reply to John to Jesus' speech about John.

  3. τῶν

    tōn · G3588

    the · v24, v25

    Points to the specific messengers already met in 7:18–20, the two disciples John sent.

  4. ἀγγέλων

    angelōn · G0032

    messenger; angel · v24

    Human envoys, John's own disciples (7:18–19). The word's basic meaning is "one who carries a message"; it means "angel" only when the context is heavenly. Luke may also be preparing for 7:27, where John himself is called God's "messenger" (angelos).

  5. Ἰωάννου

    Iōannou · G2491

    John · v24

    John the Baptizer, now in prison under Herod Antipas (Luke 3:19–20).

  6. ἤρξατο

    ērxato · G0757

    to begin (middle voice); to rule (active) · v24

    "He began." Luke often uses "began to speak" simply to open a speech. Here it starts a longer address that runs to 7:35.

  7. λέγειν

    legein · G3004

    to say, speak · v24

    "To speak." Together with the previous word it means "he started telling."

  8. πρὸς

    pros · G4314

    to, toward · v24

    Marks who is being spoken to: the speech is aimed at the crowds.

  9. ὄχλους

    ochlous · G3793

    crowd, throng · v24

    Plural, "the crowds": ordinary people, many of whom (or their neighbours) had once made the trip out to John at the Jordan (Luke 3:7, 10).

  10. περὶ

    peri · G4012

    about, concerning · v24

    "About John." John is the subject of the speech, not only the one it is addressed to.

  11. τί

    ti · G5101

    what? (also: why?) · v24, v25

    "What?" It is the object of "to gaze at": what sight were you expecting? The same question is repeated in 7:25 and 7:26, building up to the real answer.

  12. ἐξήλθατε

    exēlthate · G1831

    to go out, come out · v24, v25

    "Did you go out," a single past event. It recalls the crowds' actual trek out of the towns to the Jordan to hear John (Luke 3:7). Jesus makes them remember what drew them.

  13. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, to · v24

    Direction of the trip: out into the open country.

  14. ἔρημον

    erēmon · G2048

    deserted; (as noun) wilderness, uninhabited land · v24

    Uninhabited land: here the Jordan rift and the edge of the Judean steppe, not a sea of sand. It also calls to mind Israel's exodus and the voice "crying in the wilderness" of Isaiah 40:3, which Luke has already applied to John (3:4).

  15. θεάσασθαι;

    theasasthai · G2300

    to look at, gaze on, behold (as a spectacle) · v24

    "To gaze at, to take in a sight." The word is related to "theatre" and has a sightseer's tone: what spectacle did you walk all that way to watch?

  16. κάλαμον

    kalamon · G2563

    reed, cane; staff; reed-pen · v24

    A reed or cane, the tall plant that grew thickly along the Jordan. Reeds were everywhere there, so nobody would travel to see one. The word also suggests something flimsy that bends with any pressure.

  17. ὑπὸ

    hypo · G5259

    by (agent); under · v24

    Names the force acting on the reed: "by" the wind.

  18. ἀνέμου

    anemou · G0417

    wind · v24

    Wind, the ordinary breeze of the Jordan valley. In the picture it stands for whatever pressure pushes a person one way and then another.

  19. σαλευόμενον;

    saleuomenon · G4531

    to shake, cause to sway, unsettle · v24

    "Being shaken." The present tense pictures continual swaying, and the passive shows the reed is moved by something else. The question expects the answer "No": John was not a man pushed around by every pressure.

  20. ἀλλὰ

    alla · G0235

    but · v25

    After the previous question ("a reed swaying in the wind?") has been left hanging with an implied "no", alla means "well then" or "no? then...", moving on to the next possible answer. BSB's "Otherwise" captures this.

  21. ἰδεῖν

    idein · G1492

    to see · v25

    "To see, to look at". In v. 24 Luke used the stronger theasasthai ("to gaze at, to view as a spectacle"). Here it is the plain word: what did you expect to find when you got there?

  22. ἄνθρωπον

    anthrōpon · G0444

    a human being, a man · v25

    "A man". A generic person, set against the specific class of people ("those in palaces") who are named in the answer.

  23. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v25

    "In". Here it means being wrapped in or dressed in something.

  24. μαλακοῖς

    malakois · G3120

    soft · v25

    "Soft". Here it describes fabric: fine, smooth, costly cloth, the opposite of the rough hair or wool a desert prophet wore. It may also hint at a pampered, unhardened life, but the concrete meaning is about cloth.

  25. ἱματίοις

    himatiois · G2440

    garment, clothing · v25

    "Garments". The ordinary word for clothes, especially the outer cloak. With malakois it means luxury fabrics.

  26. ἠμφιεσμένον

    ēmphiesmenon · G0294

    to clothe, dress · v25

    "Having been dressed, clothed". The perfect participle describes a settled state: a man who goes about wrapped in such clothes. The verb literally means "to put around", so the picture is of being swathed in fine cloth.

  27. ἰδοὺ

    idou · G2400

    look! behold! · v25

    "Look!" A word that grabs attention, common in Semitic-flavored Greek. It introduces the obvious answer: you know where such people live.

  28. ἱματισμῷ

    himatismō · G2441

    clothing, apparel · v25

    "Apparel, attire". A collective noun for a whole wardrobe or outfit, slightly more formal than himation. Luke uses it again for the dazzling clothing of the transfigured Jesus (9:29).

  29. ἐνδόξῳ

    endoxō · G1741

    honored, glorious, splendid · v25

    "Splendid, glorious". Literally "in-glory" (doxa): clothing that displays honor and rank. In this world, clothes were a public statement of status.

  30. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v25

    "And". It joins the outward display (clothing) to the way of life (luxury).

  31. τρυφῇ

    tryphē · G5172

    luxury, indulgence · v25

    "Luxury, soft living". A life of comfort, abundance and pleasure. Moralists of the day criticized it, and Hellenistic royal courts showed it off as a sign of their wealth and power.

  32. ὑπάρχοντες

    hyparchontes · G5225

    to be, exist · v25

    "Being, living", one of Luke's favorite words for "to be". Those who are in fine clothes and luxury: it is their ordinary condition, not a special occasion.

  33. βασιλείοις

    basileiois · G0933

    royal; (plural) palace · v25

    "Royal palaces". The neuter plural ta basileia was the standard Greek expression for a king's residence. Matthew's parallel has "the houses of kings". Listeners in Galilee would think of the Herodian palaces, Herod Antipas's included.

  34. εἰσίν

    eisin · G1510

    are · v25

    "Are (to be found)". The point is put flatly: that is where such people are, and they are not in the desert.

The world behind it

John in prison. Luke has already reported that Herod Antipas, ruler of Galilee and Perea, locked John up (3:19–20). Josephus says John was held and executed at Machaerus, a desert fortress east of the Dead Sea, because Antipas feared his influence over the crowds (Antiquities 18.116–119). From there John sent two disciples to ask Jesus, "Are you the one who is to come, or should we look for another?" (7:19). Jesus answered with what he was doing (7:22–23). In an honour-conscious culture, a public question like John's could look like doubt or weakness, and Jesus now defends John's standing in front of the same crowds.

The wilderness and the Jordan. John worked in the erēmos, the uninhabited Jordan valley and the dry country beside it (Luke 3:2–3). The riverbanks were thick with tall reeds and canes, so "a reed shaken by the wind" was the most ordinary sight there. Going out to the wilderness also carried meaning. It recalled the exodus, and Isaiah 40:3 had promised a voice crying in the wilderness. In the first century, crowds following a prophet into the wilderness could worry rulers, as Josephus's accounts of later wilderness prophets show.

Herod's reed? When Antipas founded his new capital Tiberias (around AD 19/20), his first coins showed a plant that numismatists such as Ya'akov Meshorer identify as a reed. Gerd Theissen has argued that Galileans would therefore have heard "a reed shaken by the wind" as a sly reference to Antipas himself. That fits the following verse, about men "in soft clothing… in palaces." The suggestion is plausible but not proven (see debates).

From the study of Luke 7:24.

Where scholars differ

in v24

What does "a reed shaken by the wind" refer to?

  • A metaphor for a fickle or unstable person: John is not a waverer.

    In the Old Testament the reed is a stock image of unreliability (2 Kgs 18:21; Isa 36:6; Ezek 29:6–7; 1 Kgs 14:15), and "not shaken" describes the steadfast righteous (Ps 16:8 LXX). The timing, right after John's question from prison, fits a defence against the charge of wavering. This is the majority reading in commentaries (e.g. Marshall, Nolland, Fitzmyer).

  • A literal, ironic question: no one goes into the wilderness to look at ordinary reeds.

    Reeds were abundant along the Jordan, and the verb θεάομαι suggests going to view a spectacle. The question would then be rhetorical and absurd on purpose, leading to the real answer in v. 26. Many interpreters combine this with the first view.

  • A veiled allusion to Herod Antipas.

    Antipas's early Tiberias coins (c. AD 19/20) bear a plant identified as a reed (Meshorer). Gerd Theissen (The Gospels in Context, 1991) argues Galileans would hear the image as Antipas, a pliable ruler. The next verse on soft clothing and palaces clearly points to royal courts. Critics note that the coin evidence is limited, that the reed may simply have been a local emblem of Tiberias's lakeside setting, and that the saying works without any such reference.

in v25

Is "those in palaces" a pointed reference to Herod Antipas, or a general contrast between prophets and the rich?

  • A veiled reference to Antipas and his court.

    Antipas had imprisoned John (Luke 3:19–20) and held him at his palace-fortress Machaerus (Josephus, *Ant.* 18.116–119). The crowds were Antipas's own subjects. Gerd Theissen argued that the "reed shaken by the wind" in v. 24 alludes to the reed image on Antipas's early coins minted at Tiberias, which would make vv. 24–25 a coded jab at the ruler. Gospel of Thomas 78 explicitly mentions "your kings and your powerful ones".

  • A general, proverbial contrast between a rugged prophet and pampered courtiers, with no specific target.

    The wording is generic ("those", "palaces" in the plural). Contrasts between the rough philosopher or prophet and luxurious courts were common in ancient moral writing. The reed-on-coins theory is debated, and the reed may simply be a stock image of instability. Many commentators allow an Antipas echo without making it the main point.

in v25

Does τί mean "what" or "why"?

  • "What did you go out to see? A man in soft clothing?" (most translations).

    Luke's word order, with ἰδεῖν ("to see") straight after the verb, reads most naturally as "what… to see", and the parallel questions all have an object noun as their answer (a reed, a man, a prophet).

  • "Why did you go out? To see a man in soft clothing?"

    τί often means "why" in Koine Greek. Gospel of Thomas 78 reads "why", and some major manuscripts of Matthew 11:9 have a word order that favors it. The overall sense is almost the same either way.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. κάλαμος, σαλεύω, ἔρημος, θεάομαι, ἄγγελος
  • Septuagint: 2 Kgdms (2 Kgs) 18:21; Isa 36:6; Isa 40:3; Ezek 29:6–7; 3 Kgdms 14:15; Ps 15[16]:8
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.116–119; 20.97–98, 167–172
  • 1QS (Community Rule) 8:13–14
  • Gerd Theissen, The Gospels in Context (1991), chapter on 'The Shaken Reed'
  • Ya'akov Meshorer, A Treasury of Jewish Coins (2001), on coins of Herod Antipas
  • Gospel of Thomas, saying 78
  • J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke I–IX (Anchor Bible)
  • I. H. Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
  • J. Nolland, Luke 1–9:20 (WBC)
  • F. Bovon, Luke 1 (Hermeneia)
  • NA28 apparatus on Luke 7:24
  • BDAG s.v. μαλακός
  • BDAG s.v. ἔνδοξος
  • BDAG s.v. τρυφή
  • BDAG s.v. βασίλειος
  • BDAG s.v. ἀμφιέννυμι
  • LSJ s.v. βασίλειος, τρυφή
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.116–119 (John's imprisonment at Machaerus)
  • Josephus, Life 65–68 (Antipas's palace at Tiberias)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 19.344 (Agrippa I's robe)
  • Septuagint Genesis 3:23–24 ("paradise of tryphē")
  • Gospel of Thomas 78
  • Gerd Theissen, The Gospels in Context (reed and Antipas's coinage)
  • NA28 apparatus on Luke 7:24–26 and Matthew 11:9

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).