Proverbs Chapter 3 Read as one passage

Proverbs 3:27–28

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

27Do not withhold good from the deserving when it is within your power to act. 28Do not tell your neighbor, “Come back tomorrow and I will provide”—when you already have the means.

What the first hearers heard

For a young man about to run a household, this was a concrete rule of fair dealing.

  • Pay what you owe, and pay it now. Wages, debts, pledges and the poor's share are already other people's. Holding them back, even for a night, is a kind of taking. Verse 28 makes the time point explicit: delay when you have the means is itself withholding.
  • Ability creates obligation. The same phrase the prophet Micah used for the powerful who do harm "because it is in the power of their hand" (Mic 2:1) is used here the other way round. Power is to be used to hand over what is due.
  • The wise imitate God. Israel praised YHWH as the one who "does not withhold good" (Ps 84:11). The household that fears YHWH (Prov 3:7, 9) acts in the same way.
  • Social health. In a village where everyone depended on everyone else, unpaid wages and unreturned pledges damaged relationships with a neighbour, the theme of vv. 28–30. Prompt dealing protected those bonds.

From the study of Proverbs 3:27.

Verse by verse

  1. 27Do not withhold good from the deserving when it is within your power to act.

    "Do not hold back a good thing from the people it belongs to, whenever it lies within the strength of your hand to do it."

    The Hebrew pictures something good, such as money, goods, wages or help, that already belongs to someone else. You are the one holding it. The word for the recipients is baʿal, the ordinary word for an owner. So the verse is not mainly saying "be generous when you feel like it." It says: don't keep back what is theirs. "Withhold" implies the good was on its way to them and you are the obstacle.

    The condition, "when it is in the power of your hand," uses a fixed Hebrew idiom for ability. The duty is scaled to what you can actually do. It asks nothing impossible, but it also leaves no room for delay once you are able. The next verse closes that loophole: don't say "come back tomorrow" when you have it with you now.

    The phrase "withhold good" also echoes Israel's praise of God, who "withholds no good thing from those who walk uprightly" (Ps 84:11). The wise person is to treat their neighbour the way God treats the faithful.

    Full study →
  2. 28Do not tell your neighbor, “Come back tomorrow and I will provide”—when you already have the means.

    Don't say to your fellow, the person you live among, deal with and who trusts you, "Off you go; come back later; tomorrow I'll give it," when it is right there with you.

    The verse catches the actual words of a brush-off. Two clipped commands ("go… come back") send the person away. Then comes a promise in the first person ("tomorrow I will give") that costs the speaker nothing today. The final clause turns it around: and there is, with you. What is asked for already exists and is already in your hands. The fault is not poverty. Verse 27 has already limited the duty to "when it is in the power of your hand to do it". The fault is holding back something you could give now and making the other person carry the cost of waiting: the extra trip, the lost day, perhaps a night without food or a cloak.

    The verse leaves open what is being asked for. In its setting this probably includes what is owed: a worker's wage, a loan repayment, a pledged cloak to be returned. Verse 27 speaks of withholding good from "its owners", those it rightly belongs to. It reaches just as naturally to help a neighbor asks for and you are able to give. "Tomorrow" is not a safe promise, since no one knows what a day will bring (Prov 27:1). In the world of this verse, delay itself is a way of withholding.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v27

    the deserving (BSB); those who deserve it (NLT)

    bəʿālāyw ("its owners")

    What we hear
    People who have earned your help by their good character, as in the moral test of "the deserving poor."
    What they heard
    The people the good belongs to: those with a rightful claim on it. The word is property language, not a judgement of their worth.
  • in v27

    when thy hand is toward God (YLT)

    ləʾēl yādəkā

    What we hear
    Something to do with God, or with lifting your hand to God.
    What they heard
    A fixed idiom for "when you are able," literally "in the power of your hand."
  • in v28

    neighbor

    rea'

    What we hear
    The person in the next house or apartment, often someone you hardly know and have no dealings with.
    What they heard
    Anyone in your circle of dealings: fellow villager, companion, friend, business partner, the other party in a transaction. Often someone who has a real claim on you or relies on you.
Every word
  1. אַל־

    ʾal · H0408

    not, do not · v27, v28

    This is the negative Hebrew uses for a direct, immediate prohibition ("don't!"), not a general rule stated in the abstract. It opens the first of five "do not" commands in verses 27–31 about how to treat a neighbour.

  2. תִּמְנַע־

    timnaʿ · H4513

    to withhold, hold back, refuse · v27

    "You hold back." The verb pictures keeping back something that would otherwise go to someone. It is about refusing or delaying, not about failing to think of it.

  3. ט֥וֹב

    ṭôv · H2896B

    good, good thing, benefit · v27

    Here it means a concrete "good thing": money, goods, wages, help or any benefit. It is not an abstract moral quality. The word is broad enough to cover both a debt and a kindness.

  4. מִבְּעָלָ֑יו

    mibbəʿālāyw · H1167I

    owner, master, possessor · v27

    Literally "from its owners." The "its" refers back to the good. The good is described as already belonging to these people, so holding it back means keeping what is rightfully theirs. In this possessive phrase the plural form often has a singular sense ("its owner").

  5. בִּהְי֨וֹת

    bihyôt · H1961

    to be · v27

    "When it is / while it is." It sets the condition of the command: the duty applies at the moment you are able.

  6. לְאֵ֖ל

    ləʾēl · H0410L

    power, strength · v27

    "To/in the power of." This is part of a fixed idiom, "it is in the power of my hand" (Gen 31:29; Mic 2:1). The word is spelled like ʾēl "God," but in this idiom it means ability, not deity.

  7. יָדְךָ֣

    yādəkā · H3027H

    hand; power, control · v27

    "Your hand." The hand is both the image of power and the hand that would actually give. The written consonants have "your hands," but the reading tradition says "your hand."

  8. לַעֲשֽׂוֹת׃

    laʿăśôt · H6213A

    to do, make, act · v27

    "To do [it]." No object is stated, so it means "to do the good" or "to act." The stress falls on actually carrying it out.

  9. תֹּ֘אמַ֤ר

    tomar · H0559

    to say · v28

    'You say', in the form used for wishes and prohibitions. With 'al it means 'don't say'. The wrong here is done with words: a brush-off spoken to someone's face.

  10. לְרֵֽעֲךָ֨

    le-re'akha · H7453

    neighbor, fellow, friend · v28

    'To your fellow': anyone you live alongside and deal with, whether a fellow villager, companion, business contact or friend. It is not only the person in the next house. Verse 29 shows this person lives near you and trusts you.

  11. לֵ֣ךְ

    lekh · H1980

    go, walk · v28

    A blunt command: 'Go.' It sends the person away. The KJV, WEB and ESV keep it. The BSB leaves it out.

  12. וָ֭שׁוּב

    va-shuv · H7725

    return, come back · v28

    'And come back.' Together with 'go' it makes a quick, offhand formula: 'Off you go, come back later.' The person is made to walk away empty-handed and make a second trip. Here the verb means a physical return. It has nothing to do with repentance.

  13. וּמָחָ֥ר

    u-machar · H4279

    tomorrow · v28

    'And tomorrow.' The usual word for the next day, and often a vague 'later'. Proverbs elsewhere warns that tomorrow is not yours to count on (27:1).

  14. אֶתֵּ֗ן

    etten · H5414

    give · v28

    'I will give.' A first-person promise with no object stated: 'I'll give (it).' What is asked for is left open. It could be wages, a loan, a returned pledge or plain help.

  15. וְיֵ֣שׁ

    ve-yesh · H3426

    there is, existence · v28

    'And there is.' A particle that simply states that something exists. Here it opens a clause describing the circumstances: 'while it is there.' That is the sting: what is asked for already exists.

  16. אִתָּֽךְ׃

    ittakh · H0854

    with · v28

    'With you', in your possession or at hand. Hebrew grammar marks this as the final word of the verse. The verse ends on the plain fact that the thing is with you now.

The world behind it

Father-to-son instruction. Proverbs 1–9 is written as a father teaching his son. The son is expected to inherit a household: land, workers, money to lend and goods to manage. Verses 27–31 are a group of five "do not" commands about dealing with a neighbour: don't withhold, don't delay (v. 28), don't plot harm (v. 29), don't quarrel without cause (v. 30), and don't envy the violent man (v. 31).

What "good" could be owed. In Israel's economy several things were described as already belonging to someone else:

  • A day labourer's wage. It had to be paid before sundown (Lev 19:13; Deut 24:14–15) because the worker "has set his heart on it."
  • A pledge. A poor man's cloak taken as security had to be returned by nightfall (Exod 22:26–27; Deut 24:12–13).
  • The poor's share of the harvest. The edges of the field and the forgotten sheaves were set aside for the poor, the foreigner, the orphan and the widow (Lev 19:9–10; Deut 24:19–21).
  • Debts and deposits. Repaying a loan or returning something left in your care.

When a hearer was told not to withhold good "from its owners," these familiar cases would have come to mind. Holding a worker's pay overnight, or keeping a pledged cloak, was keeping someone else's property.

From the study of Proverbs 3:27.

Where scholars differ

in v27

Who are "its owners," the people the good is to go to?

  • Those with a concrete legal claim: workers awaiting wages, creditors, people whose pledges or deposits you hold.

    *Baʿal* is property language. Verse 28 is about putting off someone who comes to collect. The Torah has explicit same-day rules for wages and pledges (Lev 19:13; Deut 24:12–15).

  • Anyone in need whom you are able to help. Their need gives them a moral claim on your goods.

    The Septuagint renders "the needy." Elsewhere Proverbs treats giving to the poor as a duty tied to honouring God (14:31; 19:17; 22:9). The Torah frames the poor's share of the harvest as already theirs. Many commentators (e.g. Waltke) read the term broadly.

  • Both. The ownership language deliberately gives the claims of the needy the same force as debts.

    "Good" is a broad word, and the verse names no specific transaction. Israel's law already blurred the line between charity and obligation (gleaning laws, the release of debts).

in v27

Why does the idiom "in the power of the hand" use ʾēl, the word spelled like "God"?

  • It is a separate noun meaning "power, strength," a homonym of ʾēl "God."

    BDB and HALOT list it separately. It appears only in this fixed expression (Gen 31:29; Deut 28:32; Neh 5:5; Mic 2:1).

  • It is the same word as "god/mighty one," used in an old phrase that had faded into a stock idiom meaning "my hand has might."

    ʾēl is linked with ideas of might. Compare Hab 1:11, where a man's own strength is "his god." Either way, the meaning in use is simply "ability."

in v28

Is the verse about paying what is owed, or about generosity to anyone who asks?

  • Mainly what is owed: wages, debts, returning pledges.

    Verse 27 forbids withholding good 'from its owners' (mibbe'alav), those it rightly belongs to. Israel's laws on same-day wages and returning pledges (Lev 19:13; Deut 24:12–15) fit the 'come back tomorrow' scenario closely, and the verb natan is used there for paying wages.

  • Broader: any good or help a neighbor asks for that you are able to give.

    Verse 28 does not say what is asked for. The Greek and Latin translations read the pair as being about doing good to the needy, and Sirach 4:3 applies the idea to gifts for the poor. Some commentators argue 'its owners' includes people with a moral claim through their need, not only a legal one.

in v28

Is the speaker lying or just procrastinating?

  • A dishonest put-off: a promise made to get rid of the person.

    'Go, and come back' is a dismissal. The speaker has the thing in hand, so 'tomorrow' covers an unwillingness to give.

  • Simple postponement, which is still wrong.

    The text does not say the promise is insincere. Its point is the circumstance ('and it is with you'): when you could give now, delay alone harms the one who has to wait.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).