2 Samuel Chapter 17 Read as one passage
2 Samuel 17:24–29
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
24Then David went to Mahanaim, and Absalom crossed the Jordan with all the men of Israel. 25Absalom had appointed Amasa over the army in place of Joab. Amasa was the son of a man named Ithra, the Ishmaelite who had married Abigail, the daughter of Nahash and sister of Zeruiah the mother of Joab. 26So the Israelites and Absalom camped in the land of Gilead. 27When David came to Mahanaim, he was met by Shobi son of Nahash from Rabbah of the Ammonites, Machir son of Ammiel from Lo-debar, and Barzillai the Gileadite from Rogelim. 28They brought beds, basins, and earthen vessels, as well as wheat, barley, flour, roasted grain, beans, lentils, 29honey, curds, sheep, and cheese from the herd for David and his people to eat. For they said, “The people have become hungry, exhausted, and thirsty in the wilderness.”
What the first hearers heard
For the first hearers this verse was a hinge in the story of Absalom's revolt, with three effects:
- It showed God working through human advice. The narrator has just said outright that "the LORD had ordained to defeat the good counsel of Ahithophel, in order to bring disaster on Absalom" (17:14), and that Ahithophel saw it and hanged himself (17:23). This verse shows that hidden purpose at work in ordinary troop movements. Absalom does exactly what Hushai suggested. God is not mentioned in the verse, but the story has taught the listener to see him behind it.
- It set up the battle. David is in a fortified town with supplies and loyal allies; Absalom has left his base and crossed into Gilead's forests at the head of a large but untrained levy. Listeners who knew the land would sense that the advantage had shifted. "The forest devoured more people that day than the sword" (18:8).
- It sharpened the tragedy. Father and son are set side by side in the Hebrew, mirror images on either side of the river. Absalom's personal presence, a point of pride in Hushai's flattery, is what will put him in the oak tree and under Joab's darts. The scene also brings back older memories: Mahanaim, where Saul's son had ruled in exile, and where Jacob camped in fear of a hostile brother. The king is now a refugee in a place tied to fallen dynasties and family conflict.
The verse also prepares for what comes after the battle. The 'Israel' that crossed with Absalom will later argue with 'Judah' over who should bring the king back (19:9–15, 41–43), and the tribes will split again under Sheba (20:1–2).
From the study of 2 Samuel 17:24.
Verse by verse
-
24Then David went to Mahanaim, and Absalom crossed the Jordan with all the men of Israel.
Full study →David, for his part, had already reached Mahanaim, "the Camps", the walled town east of the Jordan in Gilead. Absalom, meanwhile, crossed over the Jordan: he himself, and every fighting man of Israel with him.
The Hebrew sets the two movements side by side, like two scenes cut together. Each half of the verse opens with a name instead of the usual "and then…" verb, so the reader sees father and son taking up positions at the same moment, not one event leading to the next. David is settled at a fortified town: once the capital of Saul's son, and the place where Jacob, fearing his brother, met "God's camp." Absalom is on the move, making the same river crossing David made in flight the night before, but now as the hunter.
The last words carry the point. Absalom is there in person, with the whole tribal levy, which is exactly what Hushai had advised (17:11) and the opposite of Ahithophel's plan for a quick strike without him. Readers have just been told that the LORD had determined to defeat Ahithophel's good advice (17:14), and in the verse before this one Ahithophel goes home and hangs himself. Here they see that advice defeated in full: the slow, massive muster gave David the night he needed, and it brings Absalom himself across the river toward the battle that will kill him.
-
25Absalom had appointed Amasa over the army in place of Joab. Amasa was the son of a man named Ithra, the Ishmaelite who had married Abigail, the daughter of Nahash and sister of Zeruiah the mother of Joab.
Full study →The verse pauses the war story to fill in a piece of background: "Now as for Amasa: Absalom had put him over the army in Joab's place." The Hebrew puts Amasa first and uses a verb that looks back to an earlier event. The narrator is stopping the action to say who is leading the rebel force that has just crossed the Jordan.
Then comes his family line, in the standard formula for introducing someone: "Amasa was the son of a man named Ithra (or Jether), the Israelite (or, as Chronicles has it, the Ishmaelite), who had gone in to Abigail." "Gone in to" is the Hebrew way of saying he slept with her, which here means he fathered a child by her and most likely married her. Abigail was the daughter of Nahash and the sister of Zeruiah, Joab's mother.
The last link is the point. Amasa and Joab are first cousins, sons of two sisters, and according to 1 Chronicles 2:16 those sisters are David's own sisters or half-sisters. So Absalom has replaced David's nephew with another of David's nephews, his own cousin, to fight David. The verse begins and ends with Joab's name. One reading is that Absalom chose a man whose family claim matched Joab's, hoping to keep the Judahite clan loyal. This is a civil war inside one household, and the reader who knows what comes next will feel the shadow of it. David will later offer Amasa Joab's post (19:13), and Joab will kill his cousin with a hidden blade while greeting him (20:9–10).
-
26So the Israelites and Absalom camped in the land of Gilead.
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
27When David came to Mahanaim, he was met by Shobi son of Nahash from Rabbah of the Ammonites, Machir son of Ammiel from Lo-debar, and Barzillai the Gileadite from Rogelim.
Full study →Now it happened that, as David arrived at Mahanaim, "Two Camps", the walled town across the Jordan where Saul's son had once reigned as a king in difficulty, three men came forward. The first was Shobi, son of Nahash the Ammonite king, from Rabbah, the Ammonite capital David himself had recently conquered: a foreign prince of a defeated house. The second was Machir son of Ammiel, from Lo-debar, a town whose name sounded like "no thing": the same man who had once sheltered Saul's grandson, so a man from the circle of the old royal house. The third was Barzillai the Gileadite, from Rogelim, an aged and very wealthy landowner of Gilead itself, the region where Absalom's army was now camped.
The Hebrew sentence is deliberately left hanging. Verse 27 lists the givers, verse 28 and most of verse 29 pile up the gifts (beds, basins, pottery, wheat, barley, flour, roasted grain, beans, lentils, honey, curds, sheep, cheese), and only then does the verb come: they "brought them near to David and to the people with him, to eat." The effect is a growing stream of help, arriving at the moment when David, betrayed by his own son, has nothing.
-
28They brought beds, basins, and earthen vessels, as well as wheat, barley, flour, roasted grain, beans, lentils,
Full study →Verse 28 is the middle of one long sentence. Verse 27 names the givers: Shobi the Ammonite prince, Machir of Lo-debar and old Barzillai of Gilead. Verse 28 and the start of verse 29 heap up what they gave, and only then does the verb arrive: they brought (it) near to David and the people with him to eat (v. 29). In Hebrew the list simply starts with no verb, one item after another, each joined by "and." The effect is a wagon-train of supplies rolling into camp.
A full rendering:
[They brought] bedding to sleep on, basins, and the potter's clay ware; wheat and barley, ground flour and roasted grain; beans and lentils, and roasted grain, honey and curds, sheep, and cheese from the herd, for David and the people with him to eat. For they said, "The people are hungry and worn out and thirsty in the wilderness."
The order follows what refugees need first. People who fled Jerusalem with nothing need somewhere to lie down and something to cook and drink from. Next comes grain at every stage of preparation: whole wheat (the better grain) and barley (the everyday grain) for later, flour ready to bake today, and roasted grain to eat right now. Then come beans and lentils, the protein of ordinary meals. The givers thought about the sequence of hunger: food for this hour, for tonight, and for the weeks ahead. The repeated "roasted grain" at the end is probably a scribe's double copy, though some readers take it as a second roasted food such as parched beans.
-
29honey, curds, sheep, and cheese from the herd for David and his people to eat. For they said, “The people have become hungry, exhausted, and thirsty in the wilderness.”
Full study →Three men from east of the Jordan (an Ammonite prince, the man who had once sheltered Saul's grandson, and a rich old landowner of Gilead) set before David and the people with him, as hosts serve guests, a feast from herding country: honey (bees' honey or thick date syrup, quick strength for drained men), curds (thickened soured milk, a filling herders' staple, not churned butter), live sheep and goats to slaughter, and cheese from the cattle herds. That last phrase is a rare word, and some ancient translators took it as 'fat calves'. All of this came on top of the beds, bowls, grain, beans and lentils of the verse before. They gave not on request but because they had looked at David's company and judged for themselves: "The people are famished, drained to the point of collapse, and parched, out there in the wilderness." The three words hunger, faintness and thirst, set 'in the wilderness', echo Israel's old wilderness journey, when a worn-out people had to be fed by someone else. Bringing a fugitive king food in the middle of Absalom's revolt was also an open act of loyalty: these men were choosing a side.
Where the English drifted
-
in v24
all the men of Israel
kol-ʾîš Yiśrāʾēl
- What we hear
- The whole nation of Israel, every Israelite, sided with Absalom.
- What they heard
- The Israelite men called up for war: the tribal army Absalom had summoned on Hushai's advice. In this part of 2 Samuel, 'Israel' is also a political term that is often set apart from Judah.
-
in v25
went in to (KJV, WEB, YLT)
ba el
- What we hear
- Simply entered a place or went to see someone.
- What they heard
- Had sex with her, here meaning he fathered a child by her and most likely married her. This is the standard Hebrew idiom for that.
-
in v25
captain of the host (KJV)
ʿal-hatsava
- What we hear
- A middle-ranking officer of some group, with 'host' heard as someone who entertains guests.
- What they heard
- Commander-in-chief of the army. This is the same office Joab held under David.
-
in v27
the children of Ammon (KJV, WEB)
benei ammon
- What we hear
- Young people, or literal offspring, of a man called Ammon.
- What they heard
- The standard name of the Ammonite nation, 'the Ammonites'. 'Sons of X' is a normal Hebrew way to name a people group, with no reference to age.
-
in v28
parched corn (KJV)
qālî
- What we hear
- Roasted maize (American 'corn').
- What they heard
- Toasted wheat or barley kernels, eaten without cooking. Maize was unknown in the ancient world.
-
in v28
beds
mishkāv
- What we hear
- Framed furniture with mattresses.
- What they heard
- Bedding in general, mostly sleeping mats, rugs or pallets for refugees in a camp. Framed beds and couches were luxury items.
-
in v29
butter (KJV, WEB, YLT)
chem'ah
- What we hear
- A solid yellow fat spread on bread or used in cooking, a minor extra.
- What they heard
- Soured, thickened milk: curds or a yogurt-like food that was eaten or drunk as a main source of nourishment.
-
in v29
sheep
tson
- What we hear
- Only sheep.
- What they heard
- The 'flock' of small livestock, meaning sheep and goats together, usually herded as one flock.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v27
Lo-debar wasn't the wasteland of the sermons
- What's often taught
- Lo-debar means 'no pasture' or 'no word', so it was a barren, desolate place. Mephibosheth living there (2 Sam 9) is a picture of a broken life in a land of nothing.
- What the text supports
The Bible never describes Lo-debar as barren. The name's form and meaning are uncertain: it is spelled several ways (lo' devar, lo devar, lidvir), and the 'not/no' sound may be a pun rather than its original meaning. Amos 6:13 uses that pun to mock a military victory, not to describe the land. Gilead was known as good grazing and farm country. And in this verse the man from Lo-debar, Machir, is wealthy enough to have kept a royal heir in his household and now to help supply David's whole company (vv. 28–29). The sermon picture gets one thing right: the name could be heard as 'no thing', and Israelites did play on it. But the text presents Lo-debar as the home of a man of means.
- Where the English feeds it
- English Bibles transliterate the name, so readers depend on popular explanations of what it means. These often present one uncertain etymology as fact.
Every word
-
וְדָוִ֖ד
wəDāwid · H1732
and David · v24, v27, v29
The sentence opens with David's name rather than with the verb. Hebrew stories normally move forward with the verb first, so this break in the pattern stops the forward motion and points the camera at David's position as a separate scene.
-
בָּ֣א
bāʾ · H0935G
come, go in, arrive · v24, v25, v27
A completed action: David had arrived and was now in place at Mahanaim. With the subject placed first, it can be read as background ('David had reached Mahanaim') to what Absalom does next.
-
מַחֲנָ֑יְמָה
Maḥănáymāh · H4266
Mahanaim ("two camps") · v24, v27
The town in Gilead east of the Jordan, with the Hebrew ending -āh meaning 'toward/to'. A walled town with a gate (18:24), once the capital of Saul's son Ish-bosheth, and the place Jacob named 'two camps' (Genesis 32:2).
-
וְאַבְשָׁלֹ֗ם
wəʾAbšālōm · H0053
and Absalom ("my father is peace") · v24, v25
Again the name comes first, matching 'and David' at the start of the verse. The two men, father and son, are set side by side as rival forces taking their positions.
-
עָבַר֙
ʿābar · H5674A
-
אֶת־
ʾet- · H0853
[direct-object marker] · v24, v25
Marks 'the Jordan' as what was crossed. It is not translated.
-
הַיַּרְדֵּ֔ן
hayYardēn · H3383
the Jordan · v24
The river that divides the hill country west of it from Gilead. Here it is the line between Absalom's newly taken kingdom and the territory where David has taken refuge.
-
ה֕וּא
hûʾ · H1931
he · v24
'He' is repeated so that a second subject ('and all the men of Israel') can be added. The repetition is partly just grammar, but it keeps Absalom himself in view. He is in the field in person, exactly as Hushai advised (17:11).
-
וְכָל־
wəkol- · H3605
and all, every · v24
'And all/every'. It stresses how large and complete the muster was, which is just what Hushai had told Absalom to gather (17:11–12).
-
אִ֥ישׁ
ʾîš · H0376G
man · v24, v25
The Hebrew is singular ('every man of Israel') but it means a group: the Israelite men called up to fight. This is the army, not the whole population.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל
Yiśrāʾēl · H3478
-
עִמּֽוֹ׃
ʿimmô · H5973A
with him · v24
'With him'. The army is with Absalom, under his personal command, so he and they are bound together for the battle that follows.
-
עֲמָשָׂ֗א
ʿamasa · H6021
Amasa · v25
Amasa is the new commander. The name probably comes from the root 'to carry a load' and may be a short form of Amasiah, meaning 'the LORD has carried'.
-
שָׂ֧ם
sam · H7760
put, set, appoint · v25
The perfect verb placed after its object gives the sense 'had appointed'. The appointment happened earlier and is filled in here as background.
-
תַּ֥חַת
taḥat · H8478
under; in place of · v25
It means 'instead of'. Amasa takes the post Joab held under David, so Absalom builds a rival command that mirrors David's.
-
יוֹאָ֖ב
yoʾav · H3097
Joab · v25
Joab is David's long-serving commander. His name means 'the LORD is father'.
-
עַל־
ʿal · H5921
upon, over · v25
'Over' in the sense of authority: in command of.
-
הַצָּבָ֑א
hatsava · H6635
army, host · v25
The fighting force, here the tribal levy that Absalom has gathered from 'all Israel'. This is the 'host' of the KJV.
-
בֶן־
ven · H1121
son (of) · v25, v27
'Son of'. This begins the family-line formula.
-
וּשְׁמוֹ֙
ushmo · H8034
and his name · v25
Literally 'and his name [was]'. It continues the introduction.
-
יִתְרָ֣א
yitra · H3501
Ithra · v25
Amasa's father, called Jether elsewhere (1 Chronicles 2:17; 1 Kings 2:5). The name comes from a root meaning 'abundance' or 'what is left over'.
-
הַיִּשְׂרְאֵלִ֔י
hayyisreʾeli · H3481
the Israelite · v25
The Hebrew as it stands says 'the Israelite'. 1 Chronicles 2:17 reads 'the Ishmaelite', and many scholars think that is the original. Calling an Israelite 'the Israelite' in Israel's own story would be an oddly pointless label (see textual notes).
-
אֲשֶׁר־
asher · H0834
who, which · v25, v29
'Who', referring back to Ithra.
-
אֶל־
el · H0413
to, toward · v25
'To' (her). This completes the idiom 'went in to'.
-
אֲבִיגַ֣ל
avigal · H0026
Abigail · v25
Amasa's mother. The name means 'my father is joy'. 1 Chronicles 2:16 makes her a sister of David. She is not David's wife Abigail of Carmel (1 Samuel 25).
-
בַּת־
bat · H1323
daughter (of) · v25
'Daughter of'.
-
נָחָ֔שׁ
naḥash · H5176
Nahash · v25, v27
The name means 'serpent'. It is a puzzle: Chronicles makes Abigail and Zeruiah daughters of Jesse, David's father, not of a Nahash (see debates).
-
אֲח֥וֹת
aḥot · H0269
sister (of) · v25
'Sister of'. In Hebrew this can also mean a half-sister.
-
צְרוּיָ֖ה
tseruyah · H6870
Zeruiah · v25
The mother of Joab, Abishai and Asahel. Her sons are regularly called 'the sons of Zeruiah', named after their mother, which is unusual. The meaning of her name is uncertain.
-
אֵ֥ם
em · H0517
mother (of) · v25
'Mother of'.
-
וַיְהִ֕י
vayhi · H1961
and it was / and it happened · v27
The standard Hebrew storytelling opener that marks a new scene. It carries no weight of its own beyond 'now it happened that…', which is why most English versions drop it.
-
וְשֹׁבִ֨י
veshovi · H7629
and Shobi · v27
The first of three supporters. Named only here; the meaning of the name is uncertain. The 'and' begins a long list of subjects whose verb does not arrive until the end of v. 29 ('brought near').
-
מֵרַבַּ֣ת
merabbat · H7237
from Rabbah (of) · v27
'From' + 'Rabbah' ('the Great [city]'), the Ammonite capital, modern Amman. David's army had captured it not long before (12:26–31).
-
עַמּ֗וֹן
ammon · H5983
Ammon · v27
The nation east of Gilead, traditionally descended from Lot (Gen 19:38), a frequent enemy of Israel and recently conquered by David.
-
וּמָכִ֤יר
umakhir · H4353
and Machir · v27
The second supporter: the man who had sheltered Saul's grandson Mephibosheth in his house (9:4–5), so a man once tied to Saul's family.
-
עַמִּיאֵל֙
ammi'el · H5988
Ammiel · v27
A name meaning roughly 'God is my kinsman' (or 'my people is God'). Machir's father, known only by name.
-
מִלֹּ֣א
millo' · H3810
from Lo-(debar) · v27
'From' + the first half of the town name Lo-debar; written here with lo' ('not'), which makes the name sound like 'no thing'.
-
וּבַרְזִלַּ֥י
uvarzillai · H1271
and Barzillai · v27
The third supporter, a very old and very rich Gileadite (19:32). The name probably comes from barzel, 'iron'.
-
הַגִּלְעָדִ֖י
haggil'adi · H1569
the Gileadite · v27
A man of Gilead, the Israelite highland east of the Jordan. He represents the local Israelite landowners of the very region where Absalom had just camped (v. 26).
-
מֵרֹגְלִֽים׃
merogelim · H7274
from Rogelim · v27
'From' + Rogelim, Barzillai's home town in Gilead, site unknown. The name may mean 'fullers' or 'treaders' (from regel, 'foot').
-
מִשְׁכָּ֤ב
mishkāv · H4904
bed, place of lying · v28
A singular noun used for a whole category: bedding, sleeping mats, things to lie on. The verse begins abruptly with it, because the verb ('they brought near') does not come until verse 29.
-
וְסַפּוֹת֙
wesappôt · H5592A
basin, bowl · v28
Bowls or basins for liquids: water for washing and drinking, or milk and broth. These are camp essentials for people who fled with nothing.
-
וּכְלִ֣י
ûkhlî · H3627
vessel, article, utensil · v28
A general word for any container or implement. Joined to the next word it means 'vessel(s) of a potter', so pottery: cooking pots, jars, dishes.
-
יוֹצֵ֔ר
yôṣēr · H3335H
potter (lit. 'one who shapes') · v28
From the verb 'to form, shape.' Here it simply says what the vessels are made of: everyday clay ware, as opposed to metal.
-
וְחִטִּ֥ים
weḥiṭṭîm · H2406
wheat · v28
Plural, meaning wheat as harvested grain (kernels). Wheat was the better, more valuable bread grain.
-
וּשְׂעֹרִ֖ים
ûśʿōrîm · H8184
barley · v28
Barley grain, cheaper and hardier than wheat. It was the common bread of ordinary people and also fodder for animals.
-
וְקֶ֣מַח
weqemaḥ · H7058
flour, meal · v28
Grain already ground into meal and ready to bake. This saves the hours of hand-grinding that whole grain would need.
-
וְקָלִ֑י
weqālî · H7039
roasted (parched) grain · v28
Grain toasted over a fire and eaten as it is, with no cooking. It was the standard snack of harvesters and the ration of soldiers in the field.
-
וּפ֥וֹל
ûpôl · H6321
bean(s) · v28
Broad or fava beans, a staple protein of the region, used here as a collective singular.
-
וַעֲדָשִׁ֖ים
waʿădāshîm · H5742
lentils · v28
Lentils, the legume of Jacob's red stew (Genesis 25:34). They cook fast and fill you up.
-
וּדְבַ֣שׁ
u-devash · H1706
and honey · v29
A sweet, thick food: bees' honey or a syrup boiled down from dates or other fruit. It is a rich, energy-dense food, fitting for exhausted men.
-
וְחֶמְאָ֗ה
ve-chem'ah · H2529A
and curds · v29
Soured, thickened milk, something like yogurt or the Middle Eastern laban, not churned butter. A staple herders' food that keeps without refrigeration.
-
וְצֹאן֙
ve-tson · H6629G
and flock · v29
'Small livestock' as a group, meaning sheep and goats together, brought live to be slaughtered for meat.
-
וּשְׁפ֣וֹת
u-shephot · H8194
and cheeses of · v29
A word found only here in the Bible. Tradition takes it as cheese or some solid milk product. Its exact meaning is uncertain.
-
בָּקָ֔ר
baqar · H1241
cattle, herd · v29
Large livestock (cows, oxen). Joined to the previous word: '[cheese] of the herd', meaning made from cow's milk, unless the phrase refers to the animals themselves.
-
הִגִּ֧ישׁוּ
higgishu · H5066H
they brought near · v29
'Brought near, set before', the verb used for serving a meal to someone (Gen 27:25) and for presenting offerings. It is the main verb of the whole two-verse list, held back until here, after the long list of goods.
-
וְלָעָ֥ם
ve-la-'am · H5971A
and for the people · v29
'The people' here means David's followers: his household, officials and fighting men. In military narrative 'am often means the troops.
-
אִתּ֖וֹ
itto · H0854
with him · v29
Those who stayed 'with him'. In this story, being with David or with Absalom is the dividing line of loyalty (compare 15:13–22).
-
לֶאֱכ֑וֹל
le'ekhol · H0398
to eat · v29
The purpose of the gift: food to be eaten now, not a token present.
-
כִּ֣י
ki · H3588A
for, because · v29
Introduces the reason the givers acted.
-
אָמְר֔וּ
amru · H0559
they said · v29
The donors 'said', which can also mean 'thought' or 'reasoned'. It gives their motive: they saw the need for themselves.
-
רָעֵ֛ב
ra'ev · H7457
hungry · v29
Hungry, famished. This is the first of three conditions.
-
וְעָיֵ֥ף
ve-'ayef · H5889
faint, weary · v29
Faint and drained, the kind of exhaustion that comes from hard travel without food or water (compare Gen 25:29–30, Judg 8:4–5).
-
וְצָמֵ֖א
ve-tsame' · H6771
thirsty · v29
Parched. Thirst completes the triad and points to the dry country they had crossed.
-
בַּמִּדְבָּֽר׃
ba-midbar · H4057B
The world behind it
Geography. The Jordan runs through a deep rift valley. West of it lie the hill country of Benjamin, Ephraim and Judah, with Jerusalem. East of it is Gilead, wooded high ground cut by the Jabbok River. David fled Jerusalem eastward over the Mount of Olives, down through the wilderness to the fords of the Jordan, and crossed overnight on Hushai's warning (17:16–22). Gilead put a river between him and the usurper and gave him rough, wooded country for fighting.
Why Mahanaim. It was a walled town with a double gate and a room above the gateway (18:24, 33). It had served as a royal seat before: Abner set up Saul's son Ish-bosheth there after Saul's death (2 Samuel 2:8–9). Local leaders were loyal to David: Shobi son of Nahash from Rabbah of the Ammonites, Machir from Lo-debar (who had once sheltered Mephibosheth), and the wealthy old Barzillai of Rogelim. They supplied him at once with beds, bowls, grain and food (17:27–29). The place where Saul's house had ruled in exile now shelters David in exile.
Two plans of attack. Ahithophel advised a night attack by 12,000 men on a tired David, killing only the king (17:1–3). Hushai, secretly loyal to David, advised a full national muster "from Dan to Beersheba," with Absalom leading it in person (17:7–13). Calling up a tribal levy took time. That time let David cross the river, reach a fortress and organize his veteran troops under Joab, Abishai and Ittai (18:1–2). This verse records the result of Absalom choosing Hushai's plan.
From the study of 2 Samuel 17:24.
Where scholars differ
in v24
Where exactly was Mahanaim?
-
Tell edh-Dhahab el-Gharbi, on the north bank of the Jabbok
The site is a prominent fortified mound in the Jabbok valley. Its twin hill to the east, Tell edh-Dhahab esh-Sharqi, is often identified with Penuel, which fits Genesis 32, where Mahanaim and Penuel are close together. Recent studies of Gilead's geography (e.g. Finkelstein, Koch and Lipschits) take this view.
-
Another site in the Jabbok region (e.g. Tell Hejaj, south of the river)
Some scholars weigh the biblical route descriptions (2 Samuel 2:29; 18) and survey results differently and place Mahanaim at a different mound near the Jabbok.
-
Khirbet Mahneh, north of Ajlun
The modern Arabic name seems to preserve 'Mahanaim', but the site lies farther north than the biblical descriptions suggest, and many scholars think the name moved over time.
in v24
Who are 'all the men of Israel' with Absalom?
-
The whole national levy, Judah included
Hushai urged gathering 'all Israel from Dan to Beersheba' (17:11). The revolt began at Hebron in Judah (15:9–10), and Absalom's commander Amasa was a Judahite relative of David (17:25). Judah's later slowness to bring David back (19:11) suggests it had taken part.
-
Mainly the northern and central tribes, as distinct from Judah
In 2 Samuel 19–20, 'Israel' and 'Judah' appear as rival blocs (19:41–43; 20:1–2), and 'Israel' is shown as having backed Absalom (19:9–10). The phrase may already carry this tribal-political meaning here.
in v25
Was Amasa's father an Israelite or an Ishmaelite?
-
The original read 'Ishmaelite', and 'Israelite' is a copying error.
1 Chronicles 2:17 reads 'Ishmaelite', and so do some Greek manuscripts. The two words differ by one letter. Calling an Israelite 'the Israelite' would be a pointless label.
-
The original read 'Jezreelite', a man from Jezreel in Judah.
The Vaticanus Greek reading. David's wife Ahinoam was a Jezreelite from Judah (1 Samuel 25:43), which shows the label was used in David's circle.
-
'Israelite' is original and meaningful.
It could mean a northerner as opposed to a Judahite, or stress that he was a full member of Israel. Rabbinic tradition (b. Yevamot 77a) harmonises the two readings rather than correcting either.
in v25
Who was Nahash, the father of Abigail and Zeruiah?
-
An earlier husband of David's mother, which makes Abigail and Zeruiah David's half-sisters.
1 Chronicles 2:16 calls them David's sisters but does not call them Jesse's daughters. That fits a shared mother and different fathers.
-
Nahash is another name for Jesse.
Rabbinic tradition (b. Shabbat 55b) identifies the two. There is no other textual support.
-
A copyist's error influenced by 'Shobi son of Nahash' in 17:27.
The name appears two verses later, and copyists' eyes could skip between nearby lines. But no manuscript reads otherwise here.
-
Nahash the Ammonite king, or a member of his house.
This could explain the friendship between Nahash and David (2 Samuel 10:2) and Shobi son of Nahash's support (17:27). It is speculative, and it is not clear how it fits with Chronicles.
in v27
What was Shobi's status, and why did he help David?
-
A client ruler installed by David after Rabbah fell, acting as a loyal ally.
Rabbah was captured and its people put to labor (12:26–31). Hanun, the prince who insulted David, disappears from the story. Shobi is a son of Nahash 'from Rabbah', which fits a replacement ruler.
-
A member of the Ammonite royal house who remembered Nahash's friendship with David, rather than simply a dependent ruler.
2 Sam 10:2 records Nahash's chesed (loyal kindness) to David. The narrative pattern of kindness returned suggests personal loyalty as well as political duty, but the text gives no motive.
in v27
What does Machir's support signify?
-
It shows that part of the old Saulide network in Gilead had accepted David.
Machir sheltered Mephibosheth (9:4–5), and Gilead, especially Jabesh-gilead, had been strongly tied to Saul (1 Sam 11; 31:11–13; 2 Sam 2:4–7).
-
It reflects personal ties more than a party realignment. Some even link Machir to Bathsheba's family.
Bathsheba's father is Eliam (2 Sam 11:3), called Ammiel in 1 Chr 3:5, the same name as Machir's father. This is a speculative link that rests only on the shared name.
in v27
Where was Mahanaim?
-
Tell edh-Dhahab el-Gharbi on the Jabbok river.
Fits the Jabbok setting of Gen 32 and the Transjordan geography of 2 Sam 2 and 17–18; widely favored.
-
Other sites in the Jabbok region (e.g., Tell Hajjaj and others).
The biblical data locate the town only in general terms, and excavation has not settled the question.
in v28
Is the repeated 'roasted grain' at the end of the verse original?
-
It is a copying error (dittography), and the list originally ended with 'beans and lentils.'
The word is absent from the main Greek and Syriac witnesses. Repeating an identical word in a short list is a typical scribal slip. Several modern versions omit it.
-
It is original and names a second roasted food, such as parched beans or lentils.
It stands in the Masoretic text. Medieval Jewish commentators read it as roasted legumes after the beans and lentils, and the KJV's 'parched pulse' follows that tradition. Roasting legumes was a known practice.
in v28
Why does Shobi, an Ammonite prince, support David?
-
After conquering Rabbah, David installed Shobi as his vassal ruler of Ammon, so his gift is a loyal subordinate's duty.
Hanun's house was defeated (2 Samuel 12:26–31). Shobi appears as a son of Nahash with access to great resources only a few years later, in a pro-David role.
-
He acts from a personal or family bond with David that goes back to Nahash.
David speaks of Nahash's earlier 'kindness' (ḥesed) to him (10:2). Shobi may have been honoring his father's alliance, especially if he had opposed his brother Hanun's insult. The text gives no motive.
in v29
What is shephot baqar?
-
Cheese (or a solid milk product) from cattle.
Traditional Jewish interpretation, most modern lexicons, and a possible link to a root meaning 'scrape' or 'skim'. It also fits the dairy items (curds) listed beside it.
-
Young or fattened cattle.
The Vulgate's 'fat calves'. It would parallel 'flock' (tson) with 'herd' (baqar) as live animals for meat.
-
Meaning unknown.
The word occurs only here, and the Septuagint left it untranslated.
in v29
Is devash here bees' honey or fruit syrup?
-
Bees' honey.
Wild honey is clearly meant in Judges 14 and 1 Samuel 14, and it is the usual sense of the word.
-
Date or fruit syrup.
In agricultural lists (2 Chr 31:5) devash appears among cultivated produce, and fruit syrup was a common preserved sweetener in the region. The text does not settle it.
Sources
- BDB s.v. מַחֲנַיִם, מַחֲנֶה
- HALOT s.v. מַחֲנַיִם; s.v. עבר
- Waltke & O'Connor, An Introduction to Biblical Hebrew Syntax, on clauses that put the subject before the verb (background and simultaneous action)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9)
- Robert Alter, The David Story
- I. Finkelstein, I. Koch, O. Lipschits, 'The Biblical Gilead: Observations on Identifications, Geographic Divisions and Territorial History', Ugarit-Forschungen 43 (2011)
- Rahlfs-Hanhart, Septuaginta, 2 Reigns 17:24; Genesis 32:2
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata, 2 Samuel (2 Regum) 17:24
- Supplied source text with Strong's data (2Sam.17.24)
- BDB and HALOT s.v. בּוֹא (idiom 'come in to' a woman)
- HALOT s.v. צָבָא
- HALOT s.v. יִתְרָא / יֶתֶר
- 1 Chronicles 2:13–17; 1 Kings 2:5, 32; 2 Samuel 19:13; 20:9–10
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9), notes on 17:25
- Babylonian Talmud, Shabbat 55b; Yevamot 77a
- Septuagint (Rahlfs; Vaticanus and Lucianic witnesses) at 2 Reigns 17:25
- BDB s.v. מַחֲנַיִם, לֹא דְבָר, בַּרְזִלַּי
- HALOT s.v. מַחֲנַיִם; לֹא דְבָר; רֹגְלִים
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 17:27–29
- A. A. Anderson, 2 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary), on 17:27–29
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Sam 17:27
- Septuagint (2 Kingdoms 17:28)
- Anchor Bible Dictionary, articles 'Mahanaim', 'Lo-debar', 'Barzillai'
- BDB s.v. מִשְׁכָּב, סַף, קָלִי
- HALOT s.v. קָלִי, פּוֹל, עֲדָשָׁה
- S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel (on 2 Sam 17:28)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible), textual notes on 17:27–29
- Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms (2 Samuel) 17:28
- Oded Borowski, Agriculture in Iron Age Israel
- Philip J. King & Lawrence E. Stager, Life in Biblical Israel
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 17:27–29
- BDB s.v. חֶמְאָה, שְׁפוֹת, נָגַשׁ, מִדְבָּר
- HALOT s.v. חֶמְאָה, שְׁפוֹת, עָיֵף
- Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms (2 Samuel) 17:28–29
- Vulgate, 2 Samuel 17:29
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.