Job Chapter 23 Read as one passage
Job 23:4–7
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
4I would plead my case before Him and fill my mouth with arguments. 5I would learn how He would answer, and consider what He would say. 6Would He contend with me in His great power? No, He would certainly take note of me. 7Then an upright man could reason with Him, and I would be delivered forever from my Judge.
What the first hearers heard
To ancient Israelite readers of a wisdom book, this verse would have sounded daring. The traditional wisdom represented by Job's friends held that suffering is God's tôkaḥat, his correction, and that the right response is to accept it (5:17; compare Prov 3:11–12). Job turns that around. He does not want to receive correction. He wants a courtroom where he can present his own proofs before God.
Readers would have recognized the setting at once: elders at the gate, a plaintiff setting out his claim in order, and the demand that the accused party appear. The scandal of the speech is that the "other party" is God, and the problem is that God does not appear. The verse therefore expresses both Job's confidence that he is in the right and his anguish at God's hiddenness.
The book does not simply approve or condemn the wish. God rebukes Job for darkening counsel (38:2) and for putting God in the wrong to justify himself (40:8). Yet in the end God tells the friends they have not spoken of him "what is right, as my servant Job has" (42:7). Ancient readers were left to hold both judgments together.
From the study of Job 23:4.
Verse by verse
-
4I would plead my case before Him and fill my mouth with arguments.
Full study →"If only I knew where to find him and could reach his seat of judgment (v. 3), I would draw up my case and lay it out point by point, right in front of his face. I would fill my mouth with every plea, proof and rebuttal I have, the kind of arguments that show where the other party has gone wrong."
The picture comes from the law court. Job does not imagine pouring out his feelings in private. He pictures a formal hearing where a plaintiff stands before the judge with a carefully arranged brief. The verb for "lay out" is the one used for drawing soldiers up in battle lines and for arranging an offering on an altar. His "case" is the same Hebrew word as "justice," so Job is bringing his claim to justice itself before God. His "arguments" are the kind of proving, correcting speech that Proverbs usually has God aiming at human beings. Here Job imagines himself holding them, though the next verses show he also expects to listen to God's reply (v. 5). The verse is a wish, not a plan. It depends on the "If only" of verse 3, and its force comes from the fact that God has not shown up to the hearing.
-
5I would learn how He would answer, and consider what He would say.
Full study →Job is daydreaming about a court hearing. He has just said, "Oh that I knew where I might find him, that I might come to his seat! I would lay out my case before him and fill my mouth with arguments" (vv. 3–4). Then he goes on:
"I would get to know the very words he would answer me with, and I would grasp what he would say to me."
Both verbs are wishes and resolves ("let me know… let me understand"), not plain statements. The two halves of the line say the same thing twice, which is how Hebrew poetry adds weight: words / what and answer me / say to me. "Answer" belongs to the courtroom. It is the reply of the other party once Job has made his case. Job is not asking for comfort or an explanation from a friend. He wants God to show up and reply in person, in his own words, addressed to Job. He has had enough of the friends' words about God. And Job does not only want to hear the reply. He wants to understand it, believing that if God would speak, the meaning of his suffering would finally be plain.
The verse is shaped by the book around it. Job's wish for God to "answer" is granted in 38:1, where the same verb is used: "the LORD answered Job out of the whirlwind." But the answer does not come in the courtroom terms Job imagines here.
-
6Would He contend with me in His great power? No, He would certainly take note of me.
Full study →"Would he come against me in court with the full weight of his overwhelming might, winning by force alone? No! He himself would surely turn his mind to me. He would give me his attention and hear my case."
Job is picturing a trial (vv. 3–7). In earlier speeches he was afraid that no fair hearing with God was possible: God's sheer power would terrify him into silence, whatever the truth (9:19, 9:34–35, 13:21). Here, for a moment, he answers his own fear. If he could only find where God sits in judgment, God would not use his strength to crush him. The same God would personally (the Hebrew adds an emphatic "he himself") listen. Hebrew leaves the object of "he would set" unspoken. The most natural sense is the familiar idiom "set his heart on", meaning pay attention. The next verse draws the conclusion: in such a court an honest man could argue it out with God and be acquitted for good.
-
7Then an upright man could reason with Him, and I would be delivered forever from my Judge.
Full study →"There, in his very courtroom, a straight and honest man could argue his case out face to face with him, and the truth would come out. And I would get clean away, once and for all, from the one who is judging me."
Job has just wished he knew where to find God's "seat" (v. 3), so that he could lay out his case and fill his mouth with arguments (v. 4). In v. 6 he decides that God would not crush him with sheer power but would actually pay attention. This verse is the outcome he pictures:
- "There" means at God's seat of judgment, the place Job cannot find (vv. 8–9).
- "An upright man" is a straight-dealing, honest person. Job means himself, and it is the very word God used of him in chapter 1, though Job does not know that.
- "Reason with him" is a courtroom word. It means arguing a case until it is clear who is in the right. It can even mean "be shown to be in the right".
- "I would be delivered" pictures a fugitive getting safely clear. Here it means being acquitted, with the charge lifted.
- "Forever" means for good, with the case closed and never reopened. It is about a final verdict, not the afterlife.
- "From my judge" is the paradox. The judge Job wants to get free from is God, and the only way out is to stand before God. Job trusts God's fairness over God's apparent hostility.
An ancient reading, found in the Greek and Latin versions, ends the line differently: "and I would bring my case through to victory." Either way, the line expresses confidence that a fair hearing would end in complete vindication.
Where the English drifted
-
in v4
cause (KJV "order my cause"; WEB "set my cause in order")
mišpāṭ
- What we hear
- A reason or motive, or a movement someone campaigns for ("a good cause").
- What they heard
- A legal case or claim brought before a judge. This older English sense of "cause" survives in phrases like "show cause."
-
in v4
arguments
tôkāḥôt
- What we hear
- Quarrels or heated exchanges, or simply debating points.
- What they heard
- Formal pleas and proofs in a dispute, meant to show the other side is in the wrong. The same word means "reproof" or "correction" elsewhere.
-
in v5
answer
ʿānāh
- What we hear
- A conversational reply, as in God answering a prayer or responding to a question.
- What they heard
- Here it is the reply of the opposing party in a legal hearing, the response to the case Job has just laid out (v. 4). It is the same verb used for giving testimony in court.
-
in v6
plead against me (KJV)
yārîv ʿimmādî
- What we hear
- To beg or implore. That makes God sound like the one pleading with Job, which is odd and the reverse of the sense.
- What they heard
- To argue a legal case against someone as the opposing party: 'Would he contest my case against me?'
-
in v7
delivered forever
waʾăpallǝṭāh lāneṣaḥ
- What we hear
- Saved eternally, as in salvation from sin and its eternal consequences.
- What they heard
- Got safely clear, for good, of a legal charge: acquitted with the case permanently closed.
-
in v7
the righteous (KJV)
yāshār
- What we hear
- A person with right standing before God, declared just.
- What they heard
- A straight, honest person whose conduct has no crookedness. Here Job means himself.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v4
"Fill my mouth with arguments" was a courtroom wish, not a method of prayer
- What's often taught
- This verse is often taught as a model for prayer. The believer should come before God with arguments drawn from his promises and character, and plead them persistently, the way Job "filled his mouth with arguments."
- What the text supports
The teaching gets something right. The Bible does show people reasoning with God (Abraham in Gen 18, Moses in Ex 32, the lament psalms), and Job's longing for God's presence is real.
But the verse itself is something else. It is a wish that depends on "If only I knew where to find him" (v. 3). It is spoken in a legal setting: ʿārak mišpāṭ means drawing up a case for court (compare 13:18). Job's tôkāḥôt are not God's promises pleaded back to him. They are proofs of Job's innocence and rebuttals of how God has treated him, the same word Proverbs uses for reproof. Job never gets to deliver them. When God answers, he uses the same root against Job, "Let him who argues with God answer" (40:2), and Job covers his mouth (40:4).
The verse can illustrate boldness before God. As a pattern for prayer, though, it describes an argument the book itself questions.
- Where the English feeds it
- The soft English word "arguments" can sound like persuasive reasons offered in prayer. "Plead" (BSB) can sound like devout petition. The Hebrew points to a lawsuit, with legal proofs and reproofs aimed at the opposing party.
Every word
-
אֶעֶרְכָ֣ה
ʾeʿerkāh · H6186A
to arrange, set in order · v4
"Let me lay out" or "I would lay out." The verb is used for drawing up troops in battle lines, setting a table, or stacking wood on an altar. Here it means preparing a legal case and setting it out point by point. The ending -āh makes it a wish ("let me"). After the "If only..." of verse 3, it describes what Job would do if he ever got his hearing.
-
לְפָנָ֣יו
lᵉpānāyw · H6440G
before, in the presence of (lit. 'to his face') · v4
"Before him": literally "to his face." Job wants to stand face to face with God, the way a litigant stands in front of the judge. His complaint is that God is hidden (23:8–9) and will not show up.
-
מִשְׁפָּ֑ט
mišpāṭ · H4941H
justice, judgment, legal case · v4
"A case." This is the word for justice and for a judge's verdict. Here it names the matter brought to court, Job's side of the dispute. It comes last in its line for emphasis. Job's question about justice becomes an actual lawsuit.
-
וּ֝פִ֗י
ûpî · H6310G
and my mouth · v4
"And my mouth." It is placed first in the second line for emphasis. The mouth is the means of pleading. Ironically, when God finally speaks, this same Job lays his hand over his mouth (40:4).
-
אֲמַלֵּ֥א
ʾămallēʾ · H4390
to fill · v4
"I would fill." The form is intensive, picturing a mouth packed full with nothing held back. It carries on the wish of the first line: once in court, Job would bring out every argument he has.
-
תוֹכָחֽוֹת׃
tôkāḥôt · H8433B
argument, rebuttal, reproof · v4
"Arguments": legal counter-pleas, proofs, and charges that show where the other side is wrong. The word comes from the root used for settling a dispute and for correcting or reproving someone. It is the word Proverbs uses for the correction God gives people (Prov 3:11). Here Job would turn these arguments toward God's treatment of him.
-
אֵ֭דְעָה
ʾēdʿāh · H3045
to know · v5
The -ah ending turns the verb into a wish or resolve: "I would get to know, let me find out." It picks up the opening of the speech in v. 3 ("Oh that I knew where to find him"). The thing Job wishes he knew there was where God is. Here it is what God would say.
-
מִלִּ֣ים
millîm · H4405
words, speech · v5
The actual words God would speak, his spoken reply in the case. This poetic word for speech runs all through Job, where the friends' speeches are constantly called "words." Here Job wants God's own words in place of theirs.
-
יַעֲנֵ֑נִי
yaʿănēnî · H6030B
to answer · v5
"He would answer me." The setting is a hearing, so this is a reply from the other side of a case and not small talk. The clause works as "the words [that] he would answer me," with no word for "that." Hebrew poetry often leaves it out.
-
וְ֝אָבִ֗ינָה
wəʾābînāh · H0995
to understand, discern · v5
"And I would understand / make sense of." This is also a wish form. Job wants more than to hear the reply. He wants to grasp it and see what it means for him.
-
מַה־
mah- · H4100
what? · v5
"What" in the sense of "whatever." It matches "words" in the first half of the line: the content of God's reply.
-
יֹּ֥אמַר
yōʾmar · H0559
to say · v5
"He would say." It pairs with "answer" in the first half, the ordinary verb of speaking set beside the courtroom verb.
-
לִֽי׃
lî · H9030
to me · v5, v6
"To me." The reply is addressed to Job himself. He wants God to speak to him directly, not to have God's mind explained by others.
-
הַבְּרָב־
ha-bə-rāv · H7230
abundance, greatness · v6
This one Hebrew word is three pieces: a question marker (ha-), 'with/by' (bə-), and 'abundance of' (rov). It opens the verse as a real question: 'Is it with sheer abundance of...?' Putting the 'how' first stresses the manner: would God fight with an overwhelming amount of force?
-
כֹּ֭חַ
kōaḥ · H3581
strength, power, might · v6
Raw strength or force. Joined to the word before it, 'abundance of strength' means overwhelming might. The same phrase appears in Job 30:18, where Job describes God's 'great force' twisting his clothing. In this verse it is the power Job had feared would crush him in any trial.
-
יָרִ֣יב
yārîv · H7378
to contend, argue a case, bring a lawsuit · v6
A courtroom verb: to argue one's side in a legal dispute. The verb form describes an imagined future, so it reads as 'would he argue his case against me?' The picture is of two parties before a judge, not a brawl.
-
עִמָּדִ֑י
ʿimmādî · H5978
with me · v6
A longer, poetic form of 'with me.' After a verb of disputing it means 'against me' or 'with me as the opposing party.'
-
לֹ֥א
lōʾ · H3808
no, not · v6
Here it stands alone as Job's answer to his own question: 'No!' The Hebrew accent marks give it a pause of its own.
-
אַךְ־
ʾak · H389
surely, only, but · v6
A small word that both contrasts and affirms: 'rather, surely.' It turns from what God would not do to what he certainly would.
-
ה֝֗וּא
hûʾ · H1931
he · v6
The verb already includes 'he', so the separate pronoun adds emphasis: 'he himself.' The same God whose power Job feared would personally attend to him.
-
יָשִׂ֥ם
yāśim · H7760
to put, set, place · v6
Literally 'he would set/put.' The object is left unsaid. Most interpreters take it as a shortened form of the common phrase 'set the heart/mind on' (pay attention to, take note of). Others supply 'strength' (KJV) or 'a charge'. See the debate below. The word is spelled without its usual middle vowel letter (yāśim for yāśîm), which is a spelling variant, not a different word.
-
שָׁ֗ם
shām · H8033
there · v7
Points back to God's 'seat' or 'dwelling' in v. 3 ('Oh that I knew where I might find him, that I might come to his seat'). 'There' means in that courtroom, in his presence. Some translations (BSB) take it as 'then', which Hebrew sham can sometimes mean, but the place sense fits Job's search for where God is (vv. 3, 8–9).
-
יָ֭שָׁר
yāshār · H3477
-
נוֹכָ֣ח
nôkāḥ · H3198
argue, reason, be proved right · v7
A courtroom verb: to argue a case out face to face, so that who is in the right becomes clear. The form can mean 'argue with each other' (Isa 1:18, 'come, let us reason together') or 'be shown to be in the right' (Gen 20:16). Both senses suit Job: a fair hearing in which the honest man's innocence comes out.
-
עִמּ֑וֹ
ʿimmô · H5973
with him · v7
With God, face to face. This is the opposite of what Job feared earlier (9:32–35): that he and God could never meet as two parties in a case.
-
וַאֲפַלְּטָ֥ה
waʾăpallǝṭāh · H6403
escape, get safely away, rescue · v7
'And I would get safely away.' The form expresses the result Job wants and longs for. The root is used for fugitives and survivors getting clear of danger. Here the danger is a hostile verdict, and getting away means being let off, acquitted.
-
לָ֝נֶ֗צַח
lāneṣaḥ · H5331
perpetuity, for good · v7
'For good, once and for all.' The case would be closed and never reopened. It describes a final verdict, not life after death.
-
מִשֹּׁפְטִֽי׃
mishshōpṭî · H8199
from my judge · v7
'From the one judging me.' This is almost certainly God himself, who at present seems to be treating Job as guilty. The paradox: Job hopes to escape God-as-accuser by appealing to God-as-fair-judge.
The world behind it
The courtroom frame of Job. From chapter 9 onward Job keeps talking about his suffering in the language of a lawsuit (Hebrew rîb). He wants to "argue" with God (13:3). He has "prepared his case" (13:18). He laments that there is no arbiter between them (9:33). He finally signs his written complaint and demands an answer (31:35). In ancient Israel, disputes were heard in public, usually at the city gate before elders or a judge. Each side stated its claim, called witnesses, and tried to show the other side was in the wrong. A man of Job's standing had once sat at that gate as a judge himself (29:7–17).
Verses 3–5 as a unit. Verse 3 opens with mî yittēn, literally "who will give?", the usual Hebrew way of saying "if only!". Verse 4 describes how Job would present his side. Verse 5 says he would then listen to God's answer. Verses 6–7 voice his confidence that an upright person could reason with God there and be acquitted. Verses 8–9 then fall back on reality: Job cannot find God anywhere.
How the book answers. God does speak from the whirlwind (chs. 38–41). He uses Job's own legal words in reply: "Will the one who contends with the Almighty correct him? Let him who argues with God (môkîaḥ, same root as tôkāḥôt) answer" (40:2). He also asks, "Will you annul my mišpāṭ?" (40:8). Job, who wanted to fill his mouth, puts his hand over it (40:4).
From the study of Job 23:4.
Where scholars differ
in v4
Are Job's tôkāḥôt self-defence or accusations against God?
-
Mainly defensive pleading: proofs of Job's innocence.
The parallel phrase "set out a case" (13:18) is followed by "I know that I shall be vindicated." In 23:7 Job expects to be acquitted, and the oath of innocence in ch. 31 is a defence.
-
They also carry counter-charges against God's justice.
Elsewhere *tôkaḥat* regularly means reproof. The Septuagint and Vulgate render it as "reproofs" or "rebukes." Job has openly accused God of injustice (9:22–24; 19:6–7). God's reply in 40:2 calls Job one who "argues with/reproves God" (*môkîaḥ*), and 40:8 accuses him of condemning God to justify himself. In a lawsuit, proving one's innocence often meant proving the other party wrong.
in v4
Does the book approve of Job's desire to litigate with God?
-
It is presented as bold integrity that God ultimately honours.
In 42:7–8 God says Job, unlike the friends, spoke "what is right" about him. God does finally appear and address Job directly, which is the hearing Job asked for.
-
It is presented as a stance Job must give up.
In 38:2 Job "darkens counsel by words without knowledge." In 40:2 and 40:8 God rebukes him for contending. In 40:4–5 and 42:6 Job lays his hand on his mouth and withdraws or repents.
-
Both: the book refuses to resolve the tension neatly.
The divine speeches and the closing verdict sit side by side. Many commentators (e.g. Habel, Clines) read the lawsuit as a theme the book deliberately keeps open.
in v5
Is Job hopeful here, or is this a wistful wish he does not expect to come true?
-
In this moment Job is unusually confident that a fair hearing would go his way.
Verses 6–7 go on to say God would not crush him with power but would "pay attention" to him, and that "there an upright man could reason with him, and I would be acquitted forever." This contrasts with 9:14–20, where Job feared he could not answer God at all.
-
The confidence is real but hypothetical, and the next verses undercut it.
The whole passage hangs on the unreal wish "Oh that I knew" (v. 3). Straight after it come God's absence (vv. 8–9) and Job's terror (vv. 15–16, "I am terrified at his presence"). Commentators such as Clines and Hartley stress that the hope swings back and forth.
in v5
What would God's "answer" be: a statement of the charges, or a reply and verdict?
-
Job wants to hear the specific charge against him.
This fits his repeated demands to be told his offence: 10:2 ("let me know why you contend with me"), 13:23 ("make me know my transgression"), and 31:35 ("the indictment written by my adversary").
-
Job pictures God as the opposing party replying to the arguments Job has just made (v. 4), and so effectively ruling on the case.
The order of vv. 4–7 is: Job sets out his case, God answers, and then Job is acquitted (v. 7). Studies of the lawsuit pattern in Job (e.g. Habel, Scholnick) read v. 5 as the reply stage of a trial. The two views overlap, and many interpreters hold both.
in v6
What is the unstated object of 'he would set ... on me' (yāśim bî)?
-
'His heart/mind': he would pay attention to me, take note of me, listen to me. This is the majority modern view (BSB, WEB, ESV, NASB).
'Set the heart on' is a common idiom, used in Job itself (1:8; 2:3; 34:14). The verb appears with the object left out and the same sense in Job 4:20 and probably 34:23. It fits verse 7, where an upright man reasons with God in a fair hearing.
-
'Strength': he would put strength into me (KJV).
Takes the object from kōaḥ ('strength') in the first half, which makes a neat contrast: instead of using his strength against me, he would give it to me. But Job wants a hearing, not empowerment, and the context (vv. 4–7) is entirely about argument and verdict.
-
'A charge': he would (not) lay a charge on me. This is a legal reading, reflected in renderings like NIV's.
'Set ... on' someone can mean charge them with something: Job 4:18 ('he charges his angels with error') and 24:12. The legal setting supports it. However, it needs 'No' to govern the second clause or a negative to be supplied, while the Hebrew accents and word order most naturally make 'No' the answer to the first question, followed by a positive statement.
in v7
Does nôkāḥ mean 'argue/reason with' or 'be proved right'?
-
'Argue, reason with': a two-sided legal debate.
Isa 1:18 uses the same form for God and Israel 'reasoning together'. Job's repeated wish to argue his case with God (13:3, 13:15) and the 'arguments' of 23:4 fit this sense.
-
'Be vindicated, be shown to be in the right'.
Gen 20:16 uses the same form to mean 'set right, vindicated'. The second half of the verse speaks of the result (acquittal), which suits a vindication sense in the first half. Some modern versions (e.g., NIV) lean this way.
in v7
What is the last phrase: 'forever from my judge' or 'my case to victory'?
-
Keep the Masoretic Text: 'I would get away for good from my judge.'
Makes good sense in context and matches the paradox in Job 9:15. Followed by most English translations.
-
Read mishpāṭî: 'I would bring my case through to victory.'
Supported by the Septuagint and Vulgate. The phrase lāneṣaḥ with mishpāṭ appears in Hab 1:4. The 'victory' sense of neṣaḥ is well attested in later Hebrew and Aramaic.
in v7
Who is 'my judge'?
-
God himself, in his present hostile role.
The whole speech is addressed toward God's tribunal (vv. 3–6), and there is no other judge in view. Job hopes God as fair judge will free him from God as apparent accuser. Most commentators take this view.
-
The accusation or condemnation in general, including the friends' verdict.
The friends act as Job's judges in the dialogue. Fewer interpreters take this view, and the wording points most naturally to God.
Sources
- BDB s.v. עָרַךְ, מִשְׁפָּט, תּוֹכַחַת, יָכַח
- HALOT s.v. ערך, תּוֹכַחַת
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library), on the legal metaphor
- J. E. Hartley, The Book of Job (NICOT)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 23:4; Vulgate Job 23:4
- BDB s.v. עָנָה, מִלָּה, בִּין, יָדַע
- HALOT s.v. עָנה I (legal/testimonial sense), מִלָּה, בִּין
- N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
- S. H. Scholnick, "The Meaning of Mišpāṭ in the Book of Job" / lawsuit studies in Job
- Supplied OSHB/STEP morphology and BSB, KJV, WEB, YLT texts
- BDB s.v. רִיב; שׂוּם; כֹּחַ; אַךְ
- HALOT s.v. רִיב; שׂים
- S. R. Driver & G. B. Gray, Job (International Critical Commentary)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 23:6
- Vulgate Job 23:6
- Supplied source text: Hebrew word-by-word data with lemma, Strong's and morphology
- BDB s.v. יָכַח, פָּלַט, נֵצַח, שָׁפַט
- HALOT s.v. יכח (Niphal: 'to argue with one another; to be proved right'), פלט, נֵצַח
- É. Dhorme, A Commentary on the Book of Job
- Septuagint, Job 23:7
- Vulgate, Job 23:7
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).