John Chapter 7 Read as one passage

John 7:12–13

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

12Many in the crowds were whispering about Him. Some said, “He is a good man.” But others replied, “No, He deceives the people.” 13Yet no one would speak publicly about Him for fear of the Jews.

What the first hearers heard

For John's first readers, this verse shows a people unable to make up its mind under pressure. The festival crowds can see that Jesus is not an ordinary rabbi. They cannot agree whether he is genuinely good or a seducer of Israel, and they are too afraid of their leaders to argue it out in the open.

Several things would have struck those readers:

  • The wilderness echo. "Murmuring" is the word for Israel's grumbling in the desert. John 6 has just linked Jesus to the manna. Here God's people mutter again in the presence of what God has provided.
  • The legal danger. "He leads the people astray" is the language of Deuteronomy 13. From early on, Jesus' opponents described him in exactly these terms (Matt 27:63; Justin, Dialogue 69). Readers would recognise the charge that would bring Jesus to his death.
  • Neither verdict is enough. John's Gospel is written so that readers "may believe that Jesus is the Christ, the Son of God" (20:31). "He is good" is kinder than "he leads astray," but it falls far short of the question the chapter keeps raising: is he the Prophet, is he the Christ (7:26, 31, 40–42)? The division in v. 12 looks ahead to the explicit "division (schisma) among the crowd" in 7:43.
  • Fear of speaking. For readers who may themselves have faced pressure from synagogue or civic authorities over Jesus, the crowd's whispering "for fear" (v. 13) was a familiar and pointed picture. It quietly asks whether they too will speak "openly" (parrēsia).

From the study of John 7:12.

Verse by verse

  1. 12Many in the crowds were whispering about Him. Some said, “He is a good man.” But others replied, “No, He deceives the people.”

    All through the packed festival crowds there was a steady, hushed muttering about Jesus. It was talk kept low, under the breath, because people were afraid of the authorities (v. 13). The crowd was split, and the argument kept going round. Some kept saying, "He is good": genuine, honest, someone you can trust. Others kept answering, "No! He's leading the people astray." In other words, he is a seducer who draws simple folk away from the right path, the kind of false teacher the Law of Moses warned Israel about and condemned to death.

    The word for the muttering is the same one the Greek Old Testament uses for Israel grumbling in the wilderness. Both "were saying" verbs describe repeated, ongoing talk, not a single remark. "Good" is weighed against "leads astray," so the real question is not whether Jesus is nice. It is whether he is an honest messenger of God or a dangerous impostor.

    Full study →
  2. 13Yet no one would speak publicly about Him for fear of the Jews.

    "For all that buzz, though, nobody was saying anything about him out loud. People talked under their breath, but no one spoke freely and in the open, because they were afraid of the Judean authorities."

    The verse completes a picture. Verse 12 describes a crowd seething with muttered argument: he's a good man; no, he leads the people astray. Verse 13 adds that all of it stays in whispers. The word for 'openly' carries the sense of frank, public, unafraid speech, the kind a free person has the right to use. At this festival nobody used it where Jesus was concerned. The verb is in a tense that describes a continuing state ("no one was speaking"), so this was the atmosphere all through the feast, not one tense moment.

    The people they feared are called "the Jews". But the frightened crowds are themselves Jews, gathered at a Jewish festival in the Jewish temple. As often in John, the phrase here means the religious power-holders of Jerusalem: the "rulers" and "chief priests and Pharisees" the chapter goes on to name (7:26, 32, 48). These were the people already trying to kill Jesus (7:1) and already searching for him at the feast (7:11). The danger was concrete. John later says these authorities had agreed to expel from the synagogue anyone who confessed Jesus as Messiah (9:22).

    The silence also sets up a contrast. Jesus has come to Jerusalem 'not openly but as in secret' (7:10), and the people are speaking only in secret. A verse later Jesus walks into the temple courts and teaches, and the Jerusalemites marvel that "he is speaking openly, and they say nothing to him" (7:26). He speaks in the open while everyone else holds back.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v12

    He deceives the people

    planā ton ochlon

    What we hear
    He's a liar or a con man; he tells untruths.
    What they heard
    He leads the people off the right path: the specific Jewish charge against a false prophet or enticer who draws Israel away from God (Deut 13), a capital offence.
  • in v12

    He is a good man

    agathos estin

    What we hear
    A pleasant compliment: he's a decent, nice person (often heard as "just a good moral teacher").
    What they heard
    "He is good": genuine and trustworthy, the opposite of a seducer of Israel. It is one side of a verdict on whether he is an honest messenger or a dangerous impostor. "Man" is not in the Greek.
  • in v13

    for fear of the Jews

    dia ton phobon tōn Ioudaiōn

    What we hear
    The Jewish people as a whole, an ethnic or religious group distinct from Jesus and his followers, were the threat.
    What they heard
    Fear of the Judean religious authorities in Jerusalem. The people who are afraid are themselves Jews, as are Jesus and his disciples. John uses 'the Jews' here as shorthand for the leadership that is seeking Jesus' death (7:1, 11) and that the chapter goes on to call 'the rulers' and 'the chief priests and Pharisees' (7:26, 32, 45–48).
Every word
  1. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v12

    A simple link that carries on the scene from v. 11, where the authorities are searching for Jesus at the feast. John often joins his narrative with plain "and."

  2. γογγυσμὸς

    gongysmos · G1112

    murmuring, muttering · v12

    Low, hushed talk passed among people who don't dare speak openly (v. 13). It is not all complaint: some of the muttering is in Jesus' favour. Still, the word recalls Israel's grumbling in the wilderness.

  3. περὶ

    peri · G4012

    about, concerning · v12, v13

    Jesus is the subject of the talk. Everyone is discussing him, though he has not yet appeared at the feast.

  4. αὐτοῦ

    autou · G0846

    him · v12, v13

    Jesus, the one the authorities are asking after in v. 11 ("Where is that man?").

  5. ἦν

    ēn · G1510

    was · v12

    The imperfect tense (a past tense for ongoing action) shows a state that continued: the muttering went on and on through the festival crowds.

  6. πολὺς

    polys · G4183

    much, great · v12

    There was a lot of this hushed talk and it was widespread. Jesus is the talk of the festival.

  7. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in, among · v12

    The muttering happens inside and through the crowds.

  8. τοῖς

    tois · G3588

    the · v12, v13

    Definite article with "crowds."

  9. ὄχλοις

    ochlois · G3793

    crowds · v12

    The plural is rare: the many groups of pilgrims packed into Jerusalem for the Feast of Tabernacles. In John these ordinary people are kept apart from "the Jews" (vv. 11, 13), meaning the Judean authorities whom the crowds fear.

  10. μὲν

    men · G3303

    on the one hand · v12

    Sets up a balanced contrast with δέ that follows: "some... others..." The crowd is split down the middle.

  11. ἔλεγον

    elegon · G3004

    were saying · v12

    Imperfect tense again: they kept saying this. People were repeating these opinions over and over, not making a single statement.

  12. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754

    that (introducing speech) · v12

    Here it works like opening quotation marks and leaves no word in translation.

  13. ἀγαθός

    agathos · G0018

    good · v12

    "He is good." The Greek has no word for "man." In a contrast with "he leads people astray," it means he is genuine, honest, a teacher you can trust, not a fraud.

  14. ἄλλοι

    alloi · G0243

    others · v12

    The other half of the divided crowd.

  15. δὲ

    de · G1161

    but, on the other hand · v12

    Completes the contrast begun by μέν.

  16. οὔ

    ou · G3756

    no · v12

    A flat denial of the first group's claim: "No, he isn't."

  17. ἀλλὰ

    alla · G0235

    but rather · v12

    A strong "on the contrary" that puts the opposite verdict in place of the first.

  18. πλανᾷ

    plana · G4105

    leads astray, deceives · v12

    "He leads people astray." Literally, he makes them wander off the road. In Jewish usage this was the charge against a false prophet or false teacher who draws Israel away from God (Deut 13), and it carried a death penalty.

  19. οὐδεὶς

    oudeis · G3762

    no one, nobody · v13

    An absolute 'no one'. It sweeps across the divided crowds of verse 12. Whatever people thought of Jesus, nobody said it out loud.

  20. μέντοι

    mentoi · G3305

    however, yet, nevertheless · v13

    A contrast word that John is fond of (also 4:27; 12:42; 20:5; 21:4). It sets the whispering just described against the lack of any open speech: there was a lot of talk, *but* it was all under the breath.

  21. παρρησίᾳ

    parrēsia · G3954

    openness, frankness, boldness of speech; publicly · v13

    A noun used here as an adverb: 'with openness', meaning out loud, in public, without holding back. It picks up a thread that runs through the chapter: the brothers urge Jesus to act 'in the open' (7:4), and Jesus soon teaches 'openly' (7:26) while everyone else is muffled.

  22. ἐλάλει

    elalei · G2980

    to speak, talk · v13

    The imperfect tense, describing an ongoing state: this was how things stood throughout the festival, not a single moment. 'Nobody was talking about him openly.'

  23. διὰ

    dia · G1223

    through; (+ accusative) because of, on account of · v13

    With the accusative it gives the cause: the silence happened because of the fear. YLT's 'through fear' keeps the older sense of the English but means the same.

  24. φόβον

    phobon · G5401

    fear, dread; also reverence · v13

    Plain fear of consequences: being reported, shamed, or excluded from the community. It is not awe or reverence here.

  25. Ἰουδαίων

    Ioudaiōn · G2453

    Jew, Judean · v13

    The genitive names who the fear is directed at. The people who are afraid are themselves Jewish festival pilgrims and Jerusalemites, so the word cannot mean the Jewish people as a whole. It refers to the Jerusalem religious authorities, the 'rulers and Pharisees' of 7:26, 32 and 48, who were already seeking Jesus' death (7:1).

The world behind it

The Feast of Tabernacles (Sukkot). The scene takes place at the autumn pilgrimage festival (John 7:2). It was one of the three feasts when Jewish men were expected to go up to Jerusalem, and it was probably the most crowded and joyful of them. Pilgrims from Galilee, Judea and the wider Jewish world filled the city and lived in temporary booths. That explains the unusual plural "crowds": many separate pilgrim groups, all talking.

A man under threat. John has already said that "the Jews were seeking to kill him" (7:1), and Jesus went up to the feast "not publicly but in secret" (7:10). In v. 11 the authorities are scanning the festival for him ("Where is that man?"). In v. 13 no one speaks openly "for fear of the Jews." The crowd members are themselves Jews, so in this passage "the Jews" means the Judean religious leadership in Jerusalem, not the Jewish people as a whole.

The charge of "leading astray." Deuteronomy 13 commands Israel to reject and put to death any prophet, dreamer or relative who entices the people to follow other gods, even if he performs signs. Later Jewish law developed this into the categories of the "enticer" (mesit) and "one who leads astray" (maddiah). To say that a wonder-working teacher "leads the people astray" was to say he fit that pattern. It was a charge with legal teeth, and it explains the whispering.

From the study of John 7:12.

Where scholars differ

in v12

Does "he leads the people astray" reflect the formal Deuteronomy 13 charge, or just general disapproval?

  • It reflects the formal legal-religious charge against a false prophet or enticer.

    The Septuagint uses πλανάω for leading Israel into apostasy (Deut 13:5). John 7 is full of talk about killing Jesus (7:1, 19, 25) and asks whether he is a true prophet (7:40, 52). Matt 27:63 ("that deceiver"), Justin's *Dialogue* 69 ("deceiver of the people") and the later b. Sanhedrin 43a ("led Israel astray") all use the same category. J. Louis Martyn (*History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel*) and others have argued that John 7 deliberately follows this charge.

  • In the crowd's mouth it is an informal, general accusation, and reading in a technical legal procedure is going too far.

    Here it is said by members of a divided crowd, not in a trial, and πλανάω is a common word for any deception. The rabbinic legal categories are written down much later than John and may not reflect first-century procedure. Caution is needed in using b. Sanhedrin 43a as historical evidence.

in v13

Whom does John mean by 'the Jews' (hoi Ioudaioi) in this verse?

  • The Jerusalem religious authorities (chief priests, rulers, leading Pharisees).

    The frightened crowds are themselves Jews. The same group is 'seeking to kill him' (7:1) and searching for him (7:11). The chapter names the authorities as 'rulers' and 'chief priests and Pharisees' (7:26, 32, 45–48). In 9:22 'the Jews' make a binding decision, which only a governing body could do. This is the most common view among commentators (e.g. von Wahlde, Brown, Keener).

  • 'Judeans': people of Judea and Jerusalem, as opposed to Galileans.

    Ioudaios originally meant 'Judean'. John 7:1 links the threat with Judea ('he would not walk in Judea because the Ioudaioi sought to kill him'), and the Galilean pilgrims could fear the Jerusalemites (Mason; Esler). Critics reply that John also uses the word for Galileans (6:41, 52) and for Jews generally (4:9, 22).

  • A literary figure for those who reject Jesus, shaped by the late-first-century conflict between synagogue and Jesus-followers.

    The expulsion theme (9:22; 12:42; 16:2) and the uniform hostile use suggest John's own community's experience shows through the story (Martyn; Bultmann read 'the Jews' as standing for the unbelieving 'world'). Others (e.g. Reinhartz) stress that, whatever the intent, the rhetoric pulls the reader toward treating 'the Jews' as a whole as the outsider group.

in v13

Does 'no one' include Jesus' critics, or only his sympathisers?

  • Mainly the sympathisers: those who thought him 'a good man' were the ones with reason to fear.

    Parallels (9:22; 12:42; 19:38) are all about believers or sympathisers hiding their view, and the critics' opinion matched the authorities'.

  • Everyone: until the authorities had ruled, any public stance on Jesus was risky.

    The Greek says 'no one' without qualification. Both opinions in 7:12 are reported as murmuring. People in 7:25–26 wonder whether the rulers have decided he is the Messiah, which suggests the official position was not yet clear and nobody wanted to get ahead of it.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. γογγυσμός, ἀγαθός, πλανάω, ὄχλος
  • LSJ s.v. γογγύζω
  • Septuagint: Exod 16:7–12; Num 14:27; Deut 13:1–11 (LXX 13:2–12)
  • Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 69
  • Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 43a
  • J. Louis Martyn, History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel
  • NA28 critical apparatus at John 7:12
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament
  • C. K. Barrett, The Gospel According to St John
  • Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • BDAG s.v. παρρησία
  • BDAG s.v. Ἰουδαῖος
  • BDAG s.v. φόβος
  • Thayer s.v. μέντοι
  • Louw–Nida 33.90 (speak openly), 25.251 (fear)
  • R. E. Brown, The Gospel According to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
  • C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
  • U. C. von Wahlde, 'The Johannine "Jews": A Critical Survey', NTS 28 (1982)
  • J. L. Martyn, History and Theology in the Fourth Gospel
  • S. Mason, 'Jews, Judaeans, Judaizing, Judaism', JSJ 38 (2007)
  • A. Reinhartz, Cast Out of the Covenant: Jews and Anti-Judaism in the Gospel of John
  • Euripides, Ion 672–675; Hippolytus 421–423
  • Philo, Who Is the Heir 5–29
  • Vulgate, John 7:13

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).