Jonah Chapter 4 Read as one passage
Jonah 4:10–11
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
10But the LORD said, “You cared about the plant, which you neither tended nor made grow. It sprang up in a night and perished in a night. 11So should I not care about the great city of Nineveh, which has more than 120,000 people who cannot tell their right hand from their left, and many cattle as well?”
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse is the first half of the book's last move, and it turns the story back on them. Jonah has quoted Israel's own creed (4:2, "gracious and compassionate, slow to anger, abounding in steadfast love," from Exod 34:6) as his complaint against God. He has just said his anger is justified "to the point of death." God does not answer with a rebuke. He answers with a comparison taken from Jonah's own feelings: you grieved over something you did not make, did not work for, and had for one night.
The hearers would have picked up several things:
- The creator's claim. Jonah has no claim on the plant. Yahweh made both the plant and Nineveh. Whether they are spared or destroyed is for the one who "made them grow" to decide.
- Deuteronomy turned around. Israel had been told that its eye must not ḥus (pity, spare) the nations under the ban (Deut 7:16). Here the same God says that he does ḥus an enemy capital. Compassion toward Gentiles who repent is shown to be part of Yahweh's character, not a lapse in his justice.
- Values out of proportion. Jonah wept over a plant and wanted a city full of people and animals to perish. The verse sets up that imbalance so v. 11 can state it outright.
- A question left open. Jonah never answers. The hearers, many of whom shared Jonah's feelings about Assyria, are left to answer for themselves.
From the study of Jonah 4:10.
Verse by verse
-
10But the LORD said, “You cared about the plant, which you neither tended nor made grow. It sprang up in a night and perished in a night.
Full study →Then Yahweh answered Jonah's claim that he was "angry enough to die": "You, you grieved over that plant. You felt the protective sorrow that would have spared it from destruction. Yet you never wore yourself out working for it, and you never raised it the way someone raises a child. It was one night old when it came to be, and one night old when it perished."
The words are pointed. You is stressed, setting up the reply that comes next: "And I, should I not feel that same sparing pity for Nineveh?" (v. 11). The verb God uses for Jonah's feeling is the very verb he will use for his own feeling toward Nineveh. The comparison runs from the small case to the large one. If grief over a plant that cost Jonah nothing makes sense, then compassion for a great city God has been raising makes far more sense. "You did not make it grow" quietly picks up the book's favourite word, great: God is the one who makes things great, including "the great city." The closing word, perished, is the word every frightened character in the book has prayed to escape: sailors, captain and king. In the whole story only one thing perishes, a shade plant, and Jonah is the only one who weeps over it.
There is gentle irony in God's description, too. Jonah's "pity" for the plant was largely about the shade he lost (4:6–8). God treats even that self-centred grief as a real, small example of compassion, so that it can teach Jonah about a much larger one.
-
11So should I not care about the great city of Nineveh, which has more than 120,000 people who cannot tell their right hand from their left, and many cattle as well?”
Full study →"You felt for that plant," God has just said, "which you never worked for and never grew. It came up in a night and was gone in a night." Then comes the closing line:
"And I — am I not to feel for Nineveh, that great city, and spare it? There are more than twelve times ten thousand human beings in it who do not know their right hand from their left. And animals, a great many of them."
The verse depends on its pairings. You felt for a plant; I, shall I not feel for a city? The verb is the same both times. It means a pained concern that holds back from destroying, a pity that stops a raised hand. Jonah's concern was for something he had not made and that lasted one night, and part of what he mourned was his own shade. God's concern is for what he did make: more than 120,000 people, counted one by one, and their herds and flocks.
God describes these people as unable to tell right from left. They cannot steer themselves. They may be very young children, or adults who have never been taught the way. They are not the arrogant enemy Jonah wanted to see burn. The book then stops on a question, and Jonah never answers it. The question is left with the reader.
Where the English drifted
-
in v10
gourd (KJV, YLT)
qiqayon
- What we hear
- A pumpkin, squash or dried decorative gourd: a fruit lying on the ground.
- What they heard
- A tall, fast-growing leafy shade plant, most likely the castor-oil plant. What matters is its shade, not any fruit.
-
in v10
pity / had pity
ḥus
- What we hear
- Feeling sorry for something in a detached or condescending way, with no action implied.
- What they heard
- A protective grief that would spare its object from destruction. It is the same verb God uses for his own compassion toward Nineveh in v. 11.
-
in v11
pity (ESV, YLT); feel sorry for (NLT)
khus
- What we hear
- A detached or even condescending sympathy, a feeling that need not lead to any action.
- What they heard
- A pained concern at the sight of something about to be lost, which moves a person to spare it. In judgment texts it is exactly what stops destruction.
-
in v11
cannot tell their right hand from their left
lo' yada' bein yemino lismolo
- What we hear
- A joking way of calling someone dim, clumsy or easily confused.
- What they heard
- People without the knowledge to direct themselves, whether young children or people with no moral or religious instruction. The phrase lowers their guilt. It is not mockery.
-
in v11
cattle (KJV, BSB, ESV)
behemah
- What we hear
- Cows.
- What they heard
- Domestic livestock of all kinds: herds and flocks, sheep and goats as well as oxen (compare 'herd and flock' in 3:7).
Every word
-
וַיֹּ֣אמֶר
vayyomer · H0559
and he said · v10
The ordinary narrative verb for speech, carrying the story forward. God now gives his reply to Jonah's outburst in 4:9 ("I am angry enough to die").
-
יְהוָ֔ה
YHWH · H3068
Yahweh, the LORD · v10
Israel's personal divine name. In 4:7–9 the narrator says "God" (Elohim) when the worm and the scorching wind are sent and when God asks his question. Here the covenant name returns for the closing argument, the same name Jonah used in his complaint in 4:2.
-
אַתָּ֥ה
attah · H0859
you (masculine singular) · v10
The Hebrew verb already contains "you," so writing the pronoun out adds stress: "YOU, you pitied..." It sets up a contrast with "And I..." (va'ani), the first word of v. 11.
-
חַ֙סְתָּ֙
ḥasta · H2347
to pity, spare, feel sorry for · v10, v11
To feel for something so that you would spare it from destruction, or to grieve when it is lost. God credits Jonah with this feeling for the plant. Read against 4:6–9 the description is partly ironic, because what Jonah mourned was mostly his own lost shade.
-
עַל־
ʿal · H5921
upon, over, concerning · v10, v11
Marks what the pity is directed at: "(feel pity) over / about." The same pairing, 'pity over', is used of Nineveh in v. 11.
-
הַקִּ֣יקָי֔וֹן
haqqiqayon · H7021
a plant (probably the castor-oil plant) · v10
The fast-growing leafy plant God "appointed" in 4:6 to shade Jonah. The word appears only in this chapter of the Bible. Its exact species is debated (see studies).
-
אֲשֶׁ֛ר
ʾasher · H0834
which, that · v10, v11
Introduces the description of the plant that follows: what Jonah did not do for it.
-
לֹא־
loʾ · H3808
not · v10, v11
Plain negation. Jonah put no labour into the plant.
-
עָמַ֥לְתָּ
ʿamalta · H5998
to toil, labour wearisomely · v10
Hard, tiring work. Jonah did not dig, plant or water. The plant cost him nothing.
-
בּ֖וֹ
bo
in/on it · v10
"Over it": the plant was not the object of any work by Jonah.
-
גִדַּלְתּ֑וֹ
giddalto · H1431
-
שֶׁבִּן־
shebbin · H1121
which/that + son of · v10
The short relative particle she- ("which") joined to ben, "son of," begins the Hebrew idiom for age or lifespan: "which was a son of a night."
-
לַ֥יְלָה
laylah · H3915
night · v10
"A son of a night" means one night old: the plant's whole existence fits inside a single night.
-
הָיָ֖ה
hayah · H1961
to be, come to be · v10
"It came into being." It sprang up overnight.
-
אָבָֽד׃
ʾavad · H0006
-
וַֽאֲנִי֙
va'ani · H0589
and I · v11
An emphatic pronoun Hebrew does not need grammatically. It answers the 'you' (attah) that opened verse 10: 'You pitied the plant… and I, shall I not pity Nineveh?' The whole argument hangs on this contrast between Jonah and God.
-
נִינְוֵ֖ה
ninveh · H5210
Nineveh · v11
The great Assyrian city on the Tigris (opposite modern Mosul). Assyria was the empire that crushed and deported the northern kingdom of Israel, so for Israelite hearers the name meant the enemy.
-
הָעִ֣יר
ha'ir · H5892B
city · v11
'The city.' Set in apposition to the name ('Nineveh, the city, the great one'), repeating the book's refrain.
-
הַגְּדוֹלָ֑ה
haggedolah · H1419A
-
יֶשׁ־
yesh · H3426
there is · v11
The word for existence: 'there are in it.' It points to the actual living beings present.
-
בָּ֡הּ
bah · H9034
in her/it · v11
'In it,' literally 'in her.' Cities are grammatically feminine in Hebrew.
-
הַרְבֵּה֩
harbeh · H7235A
much, many · v11
A verb form (hiphil infinitive absolute of 'to be many') used as an adverb, 'abundantly.' Joined with the next word it means 'many more than'.
-
מִֽשְׁתֵּים־
mishteim · H8147
two · v11
The prefix mi- ('than') makes a comparison: 'more than two-and-ten.' 'Twelve' here is feminine in form.
-
עֶשְׂרֵ֨ה
'esreh · H6240
ten (in teen numbers) · v11
Completes 'twelve.'
-
רִבּ֜וֹ
ribbo · H7239
ten thousand, myriad · v11
A late Hebrew word for 'myriad' (10,000). 'Twelve myriads' gives 120,000, a large, round figure that was believable for a great royal city.
-
אָדָ֗ם
'adam · H0120G
human being(s), humankind · v11
A collective 'human beings.' It is not 'men' as opposed to women, and not 'Israelites': these are simply people, the same word as Adam, humanity as God made it.
-
יָדַע֙
yada' · H3045
to know · v11
Singular verb with a collective subject: 'who does not know,' each one of them. In the phrase 'know between X and Y' it means 'to tell apart, discern.' The past form speaks of a lasting condition: they have never known.
-
בֵּין־
bein · H0996G
between · v11
'Between… and…', the language of making distinctions.
-
יְמִינ֣וֹ
yemino · H3225G
right hand · v11
'His right (hand).' In Hebrew thought the right hand stood for skill, strength and the proper way, and the right/left pair was also used for moral direction ('turn neither to the right nor the left', Deut 5:32).
-
לִשְׂמֹאל֔וֹ
lismolo · H8040G
left (hand) · v11
'And his left' (literally 'to his left', a usual way to finish a 'between' phrase). The whole phrase pictures people with no means of telling one way from the other: helpless, unknowing, unable to steer themselves.
-
וּבְהֵמָ֖ה
uvehemah · H0929
beast, livestock · v11
'And animals,' meaning domestic livestock in general (oxen, sheep, goats, donkeys), the same animals that wore sackcloth and fasted in 3:7–8. The book's last thought turns to them.
-
רַבָּֽה׃
rabbah · H7227A
much, many · v11
'Much, a great many.' It echoes the 'many' (harbeh) earlier in the verse, and the book of Jonah ends on this word: a great deal of living things God has made.
The world behind it
Jonah's position. Jonah had left Nineveh after preaching its overthrow. He built a shelter (sukkah) east of the city and sat waiting to see whether God would destroy it (4:5). Nineveh was a leading city of Assyria, and Assyria was the empire that later destroyed the northern kingdom of Israel (722 BC) and was remembered for its brutality (compare Nahum). In 2 Kings 14:25 Jonah son of Amittai is a prophet in the time of Jeroboam II (8th century BC). For any Israelite hearer, Assyria was the obvious enemy who deserved to perish.
The plant and the heat. God "appointed" a fast-growing plant to shade Jonah's head. At dawn he appointed a worm to strike it, and then a scorching east wind, the hot desert wind of the region (4:6–8). A castor-oil plant, the most common identification, really can grow very fast, gives broad shade, and can be stripped quickly by larvae. To an ancient hearer the plant was a familiar kind of thing behaving in an unusually quick and pointed way.
The kind of argument. Verses 10–11 reason from the lesser case to the greater, which later rabbis called qal va-ḥomer ("light and heavy"). The book ends on God's unanswered question and gives no reply from Jonah, so the question is left with the hearer.
From the study of Jonah 4:10.
Where scholars differ
in v10
What plant is the qiqayon?
-
The castor-oil plant (Ricinus communis).
The name resembles Egyptian and Greek kiki, which Herodotus (2.94) identifies as castor. The Mishnah and Talmud (m. Shabbat 2:1; b. Shabbat 21a) link qiq oil to Jonah's plant. The castor plant grows fast, has large leaves and is vulnerable to larvae.
-
A gourd or other climbing cucurbit (bottle gourd).
The LXX's kolokynthē and the Old Latin cucurbita. Gourds are grown over shelters for shade in the Near East.
-
The species is unrecoverable or deliberately unusual, because the plant is a 'appointed' miracle.
The word appears only here. Jerome described a shrub with no Latin name. Its overnight growth is presented as God's direct act (4:6).
in v10
Did Jonah really 'pity' the plant, or is God being ironic?
-
Ironic or generous description: Jonah grieved his own lost comfort, and God names it 'pity' to build the argument.
4:6 says the plant was to deliver Jonah 'from his evil/discomfort'. Jonah's 'great joy' (4:6) and his death-wish (4:8–9) are about his own condition.
-
Real feeling for the plant: Jonah did grieve its loss, and ḥus can mean regret over losing something (Gen 45:20).
The verb's range includes concern or regret over property. The argument works best if the feeling is real, however small.
in v10
What is the main point of the contrast in vv. 10–11?
-
The creator's right: God labours for and 'raises' what he made, so he may spare it.
The stress on Jonah's lack of toil and of 'making it grow' implies the opposite is true for God and Nineveh.
-
A comparison of value: a one-night plant against 120,000 people and many animals.
The 'son of a night' brevity and the size and population of 'the great city' in v. 11.
-
Both together, in a lesser-to-greater argument.
The same verb ḥus and the paired pronouns 'you... and I' bind the two verses into one comparison.
in v11
Who are the people 'who do not know their right hand from their left'?
-
Young children. On this reading the 120,000 are the infants and toddlers, which implies a much larger total population.
The parallel idiom of 'not yet knowing' a pair of opposites as a mark of early childhood (Deut 1:39; Isa 7:15–16). Rashi and other medieval Jewish commentators read it this way, and a number of older Christian commentators did too. It strengthens the appeal: children are wholly innocent.
-
The whole population, described as morally and religiously untaught: they lack Israel's Torah and cannot tell right from wrong.
Right/left is used for moral direction (Deut 5:32; 28:14; Eccl 10:2). A 120,000 total fits a plausible population for Nineveh, while a population five times larger is hard to fit. Most modern commentators (e.g. Wolff, Sasson, Limburg) lean this way. Read like this, the phrase reduces culpability without denying the city's earlier 'evil' (1:2).
-
A general picture of helplessness and dependence, not precise in either direction.
The phrase sits between the human count and the animals, and the rhetoric stresses vulnerability. The text may not intend to settle the question.
in v11
Is the verse a question or a statement?
-
A rhetorical question expecting 'yes, of course you should spare them.' This is the traditional and majority reading.
The parallel with v10 sets up a lesser-to-greater argument. Every ancient version (LXX, Vulgate, Targum) reads it as a question. Hebrew often asks questions without a marker. It fits God having already relented in 3:10.
-
A statement, 'And I will not have pity on Nineveh', or at least a deliberately open line that stresses God's freedom to act as he chooses.
The Hebrew has no question marker. A minority of scholars (notably Alan Cooper, 1993) argue the book emphasises God's unpredictable freedom, and Nineveh did fall later. Critics answer that this reading strains the parallel with v10 and the narrative of 3:10.
in v11
Is the figure of 120,000 realistic or symbolic?
-
Broadly realistic for a great Assyrian royal city.
Estimates for Sennacherib's walled Nineveh are of roughly this order. Assyrian inscriptions give comparable figures (Ashurnasirpal II's banquet stele, 69,574 guests at Calah).
-
A stylised number (twelve × ten thousand) chosen for rhetorical size and completeness.
The book's storytelling is stylised throughout: a 'three days' walk' city, a great fish, a one-night plant. Twelve is a number of fullness in Israel's tradition. The two views can be held together: a round figure that hearers would also find believable.
Sources
- HALOT s.v. חוס, קִיקָיוֹן, עמל, גדל
- BDB s.v. חוּס, קִיקָיוֹן
- Septuagint, Jonah 4:10
- Vulgate, Jonah 4:10
- Augustine, Epistle 71; Jerome, Epistle 112
- Herodotus, Histories 2.94 (kiki/castor)
- Mishnah Shabbat 2:1; Babylonian Talmud Shabbat 21a
- Jack M. Sasson, Jonah (Anchor Bible, 1990)
- Uriel Simon, Jonah (JPS Bible Commentary, 1999)
- Hans Walter Wolff, Obadiah and Jonah (Continental Commentary)
- Leslie C. Allen, Joel, Obadiah, Jonah and Micah (NICOT)
- BDB s.v. חוּס
- HALOT s.v. חוס
- HALOT s.v. רִבּוֹ
- BDB s.v. בְּהֵמָה
- Jack M. Sasson, Jonah (Anchor Bible 24B, 1990)
- Hans Walter Wolff, Obadiah and Jonah (Continental Commentary, 1986)
- James Limburg, Jonah (Old Testament Library, 1993)
- Leslie C. Allen, Joel, Obadiah, Jonah and Micah (NICOT, 1976)
- Douglas Stuart, Hosea–Jonah (Word Biblical Commentary 31)
- Alan Cooper, 'In Praise of Divine Caprice: The Significance of the Book of Jonah,' in Among the Prophets (JSOTSup 144, 1993)
- Rashi on Jonah 4:11
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jonah 4:10–11
- Vulgate, Jonah 4:10–11
- Ashurnasirpal II Banquet Stele (Nimrud)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jonah 3–4
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).