Luke Chapter 11 Read as one passage
Luke 11:39–41
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
39Then the Lord said, “Now you Pharisees clean the outside of the cup and dish, but inside you are full of greed and wickedness. 40You fools! Did not the One who made the outside make the inside as well? 41But give as alms the things that are within you, and behold, everything will be clean for you.
What the first hearers heard
In the scene. For the host and his guests, cup purity was a real expression of devotion: making ordinary life holy. Jesus does not argue that purity is meaningless. He argues that it is aimed at the wrong surface. A man careful about the outer rim of his cup while his household runs on what was squeezed from others has purified the part of the vessel that matters least. The plural "you Pharisees" makes it a charge against the movement's priorities, said to their faces in the place where purity was most practised: the table.
For Luke's readers. Luke's audience was a mixed community of Jewish and Gentile believers, many of them not keeping Jewish purity rules. They would hear several things:
- The question "what makes a person clean?" is moved from vessels and hands to how one holds and uses possessions. This is one of Luke's main themes (12:13–34; 16:1–31; 19:8).
- The cure is concrete. In verse 41, "give as alms the things within, and look, everything is clean for you", the inside full of plunder is emptied by giving. For Luke, generosity to the poor is itself a form of purification.
- This verse opens a series of six "woes" (11:42–52). It sets the theme for the rest of the chapter: outward precision combined with neglect of "justice and the love of God" (11:42).
The prophetic echo. Jewish hearers would recognise the prophets' complaint that worship and ritual were offered by hands holding the goods of the poor (Isa 1:10–17; 3:14; Amos 5:21–24). Jesus speaks as a prophet at a dinner party.
From the study of Luke 11:39.
Verse by verse
-
39Then the Lord said, “Now you Pharisees clean the outside of the cup and dish, but inside you are full of greed and wickedness.
Full study →Jesus answers his host's silent disapproval. Luke, the narrator, calls him "the Lord". Jesus has just sat down to eat without first washing, and the Pharisee was taken aback. Jesus replies with a pointed, almost ironic "Well now":
"You Pharisees, of all people, are scrupulous about making the outside of the cup and the serving platter ritually pure. But the inside of you is loaded to the brim with what you have seized from others, and with malice."
The picture comes from the table in front of them. Purity law really did distinguish a vessel's outer surface from its inside, and pious people took care that their tableware was fit to use. Jesus speaks in exactly those terms, then changes the subject mid-sentence. You expect "but the inside of the cup", and you hear "but the inside of you". The Pharisees themselves are the vessels.
What fills them is not simply "greed" as a private feeling. The Greek word is harpagē: plunder, robbery, extortion, the loot of grasping. Its partner is ponēria: active wickedness and ill will. The word for "full" is the one used for a ship loaded with cargo. The point is that the vessel is pure on the surface and packed with stolen goods.
The next two verses show this is not a dismissal of outward practice. The God who made the outside made the inside too (v. 40). The cure for an inside full of plunder is outward and concrete: give it away as alms (v. 41).
-
40You fools! Did not the One who made the outside make the inside as well?
Full study →"You senseless people! The God who made the outside — did he not make the inside too? Of course he did."
Jesus is eating at a Pharisee's table. His host has been surprised that he skipped the ritual washing before the meal (11:38). Jesus answers with an image from the kitchen: you scrub the outside of the cup and the plate, but inside, you are full of plunder and wickedness (11:39). Then comes this verse, a short question in the style of Israel's wisdom books, framed to expect "yes."
The opening word does not mean "idiots." It is the word Proverbs and the Psalms use for the person who lives as if God does not really see. Learned and careful as they are, these men are acting like the "fool" of Psalm 14. "The one who made" is the Creator, described by what he did, in language that echoes "God made" in Genesis 1. The same verb is used twice, so the sentence balances: made the outside / made the inside. One maker, one claim over both.
The logic is simple and pointed. Care for outward purity is not wrong; Jesus says in 11:42 that such things should not be neglected. But it makes no sense to tend carefully to the surface for God's sake while ignoring the part of yourself he also made and actually examines. The "inside" in view is not vague spirituality. It is what verse 39 named, greed and grabbing, and verse 41 gives the remedy: give what is within as alms to the poor.
-
41But give as alms the things that are within you, and behold, everything will be clean for you.
Full study →"Instead, take what is inside (inside those carefully washed cups and dishes, and inside you) and give it away as an act of mercy to the poor. Look: then everything is clean for you."
Jesus is reclining at a Pharisee's table. His host has just been surprised that Jesus did not perform the ritual washing before eating (v. 38). Jesus answers with a picture: you scrub the outside of the cup and the plate, but the inside is "full of plunder and wickedness" (v. 39). The God who made the outside made the inside too (v. 40), so purity cannot stop at the outer surface.
Then comes the twist. The word "rather" swings away from washing altogether. "What is inside" first means the literal contents, the food and wine on the table. Verse 39 hints that these were gained by grasping, and Luke elsewhere calls the Pharisees "lovers of money" (16:14). But the phrase also reaches the inner person that the same verse describes as full of greed. Jesus' cure works on both levels at once: hand the contents over. What greed gathered in, mercy gives out.
The word for the gift, eleēmosynē, is literally "mercy-deed". It is the standard Jewish term for charity, which pious Jews ranked with prayer and fasting, and which books like Tobit and Sirach said could purge sin. "Give" is a command for a concrete act, not a mood.
"Look!" signals the surprise: purity comes through giving, not through scrubbing. "Everything is clean" is in the present tense and means ritual cleanness, the fitness to share a holy table, not hygiene. It is not a future reward. It describes the state you are in once mercy flows outward. "Everything" (vessel, food, diner) is clean "for you": the anxious question of which surface of a cup is defiled stops being your problem.
The next verse ("you should have done these without neglecting the others") shows Jesus is not mocking purity or tithing as such. He is putting first things first.
Where the English drifted
-
in v39
clean
katharizō
- What we hear
- Washing off dirt; hygiene.
- What they heard
- Making a vessel ritually pure, fit for use under the purity laws. This is a religious status, not a matter of dirt.
-
in v39
greed
harpagē
- What we hear
- An inner wanting-more; a feeling or attitude.
- What they heard
- Robbery, plunder, extortion, or the loot itself: the act and the fruit of seizing what belongs to others.
-
in v39
Pharisees
Pharisaioi
- What we hear
- Self-righteous hypocrites; 'a pharisee' as an insult.
- What they heard
- A respected, popular Jewish movement devoted to exact keeping of the Law and to purity in everyday life, including meals. Jesus is eating at one of their tables.
-
in v40
You fools! / Ye fools
aphrones
- What we hear
- You idiots, a put-down aimed at someone's intelligence, which can sound like plain name-calling and even seem to clash with Jesus' warning against calling anyone 'fool' (Matthew 5:22).
- What they heard
- 'You senseless ones': the wisdom literature's word for people who lack moral good sense and live as if God sees only the surface. It is a prophetic verdict on how they live, not a comment on their brains, and it is a different word from the mōros/'raka' of Matthew 5:22, which concerns contemptuous abuse spoken in anger.
-
in v41
alms
eleēmosynē
- What we hear
- A small, old-fashioned handout to a beggar. Optional, a bit condescending, and spiritually minor.
- What they heard
- A 'mercy-deed': a gift to the poor that Jews of the time counted as a central act of righteousness. It was so central that the word stood in for 'righteousness' (*tsedaqah*) itself, and it was linked to the removal of sin.
-
in v41
clean
katharos
- What we hear
- Physically clean, hygienic, washed of dirt or germs. Or simply 'morally good'.
- What they heard
- Ritually pure: fit to approach God and share a holy meal, in the purity system of Leviticus as practised by the Pharisees. The issue at this table was religious status, not dirt.
-
in v41
the things that are within you (BSB); what is inside you (NIV)
ta enonta
- What we hear
- Your feelings, heart attitudes, inner spirituality, as opposed to outward actions.
- What they heard
- 'The things inside', with no 'you' in the Greek. First of all this means the contents of the cups and dishes just mentioned, with a play on the inner person 'full of plunder'. The command is to give those contents away: a concrete, outward act of generosity.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v39
This verse doesn't set inner spirituality against outward religion
- What's often taught
- This verse is often taught as Jesus saying that God cares about the heart, not outward religious acts: ritual and visible practice are empty, and only inner spirituality matters.
- What the text supports
Part of this is right: Jesus does expose a careful outward piety that hides corruption. But the passage does not set the inner against the outer.
- What fills the 'inside' is not bad spirituality but harpagē: plunder, extortion, the goods taken from others. It is an inside filled by outward actions.
- In the very next verse Jesus says that God made both the outside and the inside (v. 40). The outer side is not worthless.
- The cure is an outward act: 'give as alms the things that are within, and everything is clean for you' (v. 41).
- In verse 42 Jesus tells the Pharisees they should practise justice and the love of God 'without neglecting the others', meaning their careful tithing.
The contrast is between a pure surface and a household stocked by exploitation. It is not a contrast between ritual and feelings.
- Where the English feeds it
- Rendering *harpagē* as 'greed' (BSB, NIV, ESV) turns stolen goods into a private attitude. That makes it easy to hear the verse as being about inner disposition rather than what has been taken from others. 'Clean' suggests hygiene rather than purity, which blurs the real practice Jesus is engaging.
Every word
-
Εἶπεν
Eipen · G2036
said · v39
A simple past-tense 'said'. It introduces Jesus' reply to the host, who had been silently surprised (v. 38). Jesus answers a thought the man never spoke aloud.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
and, but, then · v39
A light connective that moves the story on: 'then'.
-
ὁ
ho · G3588
the · v39, v40, v41
Article with 'Lord'.
-
κύριος
kyrios · G2962
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
to, toward · v39
Marks who is addressed: Jesus speaks directly to his host.
-
αὐτόν·
auton · G0846
him · v39
The Pharisee who invited Jesus to the meal (v. 37). Jesus speaks to one man but at once widens it to 'you Pharisees'.
-
νῦν
nyn · G3568
now · v39
Probably not 'at this moment' but a pointed 'Well now' or 'So then', which gives the line an ironic edge. Some scholars think it reflects an Aramaic particle with that sense (see debates).
-
ὑμεῖς
hymeis · G4771
you (plural) · v39, v41
The pronoun is spelled out, which Greek does not need, so it is emphatic: 'you, of all people'. The address is now plural: the whole group, not just the host.
-
Φαρισαῖοι
Pharisaioi · G5330
Pharisees · v39
Members of a respected Jewish movement known for exact interpretation of the Law. They tried to bring priestly purity into ordinary homes and meals. The name is a group label here, not yet the English insult 'pharisee'.
-
ἔξωθεν
exōthen · G1855
outside, from outside · v39, v40
The outer surface of the vessel. Purity rules in fact distinguished a vessel's outside from its inside (see setting), so the word comes straight from that technical discussion.
-
ποτηρίου
potēriou · G4221
cup · v39
An ordinary drinking cup on the table in front of them. Jesus takes his picture from the meal they are sitting at.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v39, v40, v41
Joins cup and platter as the vessels of the meal.
-
πίνακος
pinakos · G4094
platter, flat dish · v39
A broad serving plate or board, the same word as the 'platter' for John the Baptist's head (Mark 6:25). Matthew's parallel uses a different word (paropsis). Cup and platter together stand for all the tableware.
-
καθαρίζετε,
katharizete · G2511
you cleanse, make clean · v39
Present tense, describing a regular practice: you routinely purify. The sense is ritual purity, making a vessel fit for use under the purity laws. It is not about washing off dirt.
-
ἔσωθεν
esōthen · G2081
inside, within · v39, v40
The partner word to 'outside'. The sentence sets you up to expect 'the inside of the cup', but it says 'the inside of you'.
-
γέμει
gemei · G1073
is full, is laden · v39
'Crammed, loaded to the brim', used of containers and ships carrying cargo. It fits the vessel picture: the inside is full, but of the wrong things.
-
ἁρπαγῆς
harpagēs · G0724
plunder, robbery, rapacity · v39
Seizing what belongs to others: robbery and extortion, or the loot itself. It is more concrete and active than the English 'greed'.
-
πονηρίας.
ponērias · G4189
-
ἄφρονες
aphrones · G878
foolish, senseless · v40
A plural address: 'you senseless ones!' This is the wisdom literature's word for people who lack practical moral understanding and live as if God does not see. It is not a jab at their intelligence.
-
οὐχ
ouch · G3756
not · v40
Opening a question with this negative expects the answer 'yes': 'Surely he did, didn't he?' The point is treated as obvious, which is exactly why missing it is 'senseless.'
-
ποιήσας
poiēsas · G4160
to make, do · v40
'Having made.' The past (aorist) tense looks back on one completed act of making, and it echoes the Greek creation account ('God made,' Genesis 1). The maker of the outside is identified first.
-
πλὴν
plēn · G4133
but, rather, nevertheless · v41
A strong turn, one of Luke's favourite words: 'instead of all that washing, do this.' It sets the remedy against the problem in verses 39–40, where the outside of the cup is scrubbed while the inside is full of greed.
-
ἐνόντα
enonta · G1751
to be in, be inside · v41
'What is inside'. In context this most naturally means the contents of the cups and dishes just mentioned (v. 39), with a deliberate double meaning that also takes in the inner person, which v. 39 says is 'full of plunder and wickedness'. In ordinary Greek the same phrase could also mean 'what you have' or 'what is possible', which is where the KJV's 'such things as ye have' comes from.
-
δότε
dote · G1325
give · v41
An aorist imperative (a command for one decisive act): 'Give!' The cure Jesus prescribes is an outward, material act of handing something over, not just an inner change of attitude.
-
ἐλεημοσύνην
eleēmosynēn · G1654
alms, charitable gift, act of mercy · v41
'As a mercy-gift'. It comes from eleos, 'mercy', and refers to giving to the poor, which Jews of the time counted as one of the central acts of righteousness. With 'the things inside', it forms a double object: give the contents away as charity.
-
ἰδοὺ
idou · G2400
look! behold! · v41
A Hebrew-flavoured call to attention that announces a surprising result: 'look, you'll see.' The startling claim is that purity comes from giving, not from washing.
-
πάντα
panta · G3956
all, everything · v41
'Everything': cups, dishes, food, and the people eating it. It is a sweeping claim that answers the narrow concern with one vessel's surfaces.
-
καθαρὰ
kathara · G2513
clean, pure · v41
'Clean' in the religious sense of ritual purity, the state needed to approach God and share a holy table. It does not mean hygienically clean. It answers the Pharisee's surprise in v. 38 that Jesus did not wash before the meal.
-
ἐστιν
estin · G1510
is · v41
Present tense, singular because Greek uses a singular verb with neuter plural subjects. Literally 'everything is clean', not 'will be'. The result is stated as an immediate state rather than a later reward.
The world behind it
A meal at a Pharisee's house. Luke 11:37–54 takes place at an ariston, a late-morning or midday meal, in a Pharisee's home. Sharing a table in that world was a statement about belonging and honour. Insulting your host at his own table was a serious breach. The sharpness of Jesus' words is meant to be felt.
Washing before eating. Verse 38 says Jesus "did not first wash" (literally "was not immersed/dipped", ebaptisthē), probably meaning a ritual rinsing of the hands. The Law of Moses required handwashing of priests, not of ordinary people at ordinary meals. Pharisees, however, aimed to eat everyday food in a state of purity close to that of priests, and Mark 7:3–4 describes their washing of hands, cups, pots and bronze vessels as "the tradition of the elders". How widely this was practised in the first century is debated. Its presence among Pharisees is not.
Inside and outside of vessels. Leviticus 11:32–33 and 15:12 say that vessels can become impure and must be purified or broken. Later Jewish legal discussion, collected in the Mishnah around AD 200 but drawing on earlier debates, treats a vessel's outer side and inside as separate zones that could differ in purity (m. Kelim 25). It also records disputes between the schools of Shammai and Hillel, two rival first-century schools of Pharisees, about the order of washing cups and hands at a meal (m. Berakhot 8:2). Jesus' image of cleaning "the outside of the cup" used the vocabulary of a live discussion his hearers knew well.
Plunder and the purse. Luke elsewhere calls the Pharisees "lovers of money" (16:14) and warns against those who "devour widows' houses" (20:47). The prophets had accused Jerusalem's leaders in the same terms: "the plunder of the poor is in your houses" (Isa 3:14, Greek version). An accusation of harpagē places Jesus in that prophetic tradition of charging the respectable with economic exploitation.
From the study of Luke 11:39.
Where scholars differ
in v39
What does 'now' (nyn) mean at the start of Jesus' reply?
-
It is logical or ironic: 'Well now, you Pharisees...', a rhetorical opener rather than a time marker.
Nothing in the context contrasts 'now' with an earlier time. Greek *nyn* can carry the sense 'as things stand / so then'. Several major commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer, Marshall) note that it may reflect an Aramaic particle meaning roughly 'well then' or 'look'.
-
It is temporal: 'Nowadays you Pharisees...', meaning the present state of things as opposed to how it should be or once was.
This is the normal meaning of *nyn*, and translations such as the KJV ('Now do ye...') keep the word without spelling out its force. On this view the line contrasts current practice with God's intention.
in v39
Is Jesus engaging a real legal debate about vessel purity, or only using a metaphor?
-
The saying reflects a real Pharisaic debate about whether a vessel's outer surface and inside affect each other's purity, and it takes a side in it.
Jacob Neusner ('First Cleanse the Inside', New Testament Studies 1976) linked it to early disputes between the schools of Shammai and Hillel preserved in the Mishnah (Kelim 25; Berakhot 8:2), where inside and outside are distinct zones of purity.
-
The purity language is mainly a vivid image drawn from the table. The point is moral, not a ruling on how to wash vessels.
Others (e.g. Hyam Maccoby, JSNT 1982) argued that the rabbinic evidence does not match the saying closely. Luke's own wording quickly drops the vessel ('the inside of you'), and verse 41 resolves the matter with almsgiving rather than a purity rule.
in v40
Who is 'the one who made' the outside and the inside?
-
God the Creator (the majority view).
'The one who made' (ho poiēsas) is standard biblical language for the Creator (Septuagint Psalm 94:6; Acts 4:24; 14:15). The verse sits between a description of the Pharisees' inner life (v. 39) and a call to give alms from within (v. 41), so the 'inside' is the human heart, which only God made. Commentators such as Fitzmyer, Marshall and Bock take this view.
-
The craftsman who made the vessel, used as an analogy.
The immediate image is a cup and a dish. Whoever makes a cup makes its inside along with its outside, so it is absurd to treat only the outside as needing to be clean. On this reading the argument still points to God, but by analogy from the potter rather than by naming the Creator directly.
in v40
Does ποιέω here mean 'make' or 'do / attend to'?
-
'Made' (create). Followed by nearly all translations.
Poieō is the usual Septuagint verb for God's creating, and the rhetorical question expects agreement with an obvious truth about creation.
-
'Do / attend to': 'Shouldn't whoever takes care of the outside also take care of the inside?'
Poieō commonly means 'do' or 'deal with,' and this sense fits the cleaning action of verse 39. Some commentators (Marshall, for example, discusses the option) treat it as possible. It is less natural with the Creator echo and the participle-plus-finite-verb pattern, and few adopt it.
in v41
What does 'the things inside' (ta enonta) refer to?
-
The contents of the cups and dishes: give the food and drink (gained by 'plunder', v. 39) to the poor.
The nearest antecedent is the cup and dish of v. 39. BDAG and many commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer, Johnson) take it this way. It fits Luke's strong focus on possessions.
-
The inner person: give yourself, your inner life, in mercy.
Verse 39 says 'your inside' (*to esōthen hymōn*) is full of greed, and v. 40 speaks of God making 'the inside'. BSB and NIV add 'you' along these lines.
-
An idiom for 'what you have' or 'as far as you are able'.
Classical Greek uses *ta enonta* or *ek tōn enontōn* for available resources or 'as far as possible'. KJV and YLT follow this sense, and the Vulgate's *quod superest* is related.
-
A deliberate double meaning combining the first two.
Luke's wording moves fluidly between the cup's inside and the person's inside in vv. 39–40. Many recent commentators (e.g. Green) read the play as intentional.
in v41
Do Luke's 'give alms' and Matthew's 'cleanse' go back to one Aramaic saying?
-
Yes. Aramaic *dakkau* ('cleanse') was misread or reinterpreted as *zakkau* ('give alms').
Proposed by Julius Wellhausen and developed by Matthew Black (*An Aramaic Approach to the Gospels and Acts*). The two Aramaic words look and sound alike, and in later Aramaic *zakki* can mean 'to give alms'.
-
No. Luke's wording reflects his own deliberate emphasis on almsgiving.
Luke stresses alms repeatedly (12:33; Acts 9:36; 10:2–4). The Greek reads naturally as it stands, and the theory requires a misreading that cannot be proven. Many commentators (e.g. Fitzmyer) treat it as possible but unnecessary.
in v41
Is Jesus sincere or ironic?
-
Sincere: almsgiving truly brings purity.
This matches the Jewish tradition in Tobit 12:9 and Sirach 3:30, Luke's consistent positive view of alms, and v. 42's 'these you ought to have done'. It is the majority view.
-
Ironic or rhetorical: 'give alms and then (you suppose) everything is clean'.
A minority view. It reads the line as mocking a mechanical trust in charity. It has little support in Luke's otherwise positive treatment of alms.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἁρπαγή, καθαρίζω, πονηρία, νῦν, γέμω, πίναξ
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἁρπαγή
- Septuagint, Isaiah 3:14; Leviticus 11:32–33; 15:12
- Josephus, Antiquities 13.297–298; 17.42; 18.12–15; Life 12
- Mishnah Kelim 25; Mishnah Berakhot 8:2
- J. Neusner, 'First Cleanse the Inside', New Testament Studies 22 (1976)
- H. Maccoby, 'The Washing of Cups', Journal for the Study of the New Testament 14 (1982)
- J. A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
- I. H. Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
- M. Black, An Aramaic Approach to the Gospels and Acts
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 11:37–41
- BDAG s.v. ἄφρων, ἔξωθεν, ἔσωθεν, ποιέω
- Septuagint: Psalm 13:1 (14:1), Proverbs (passim), Genesis 1:1
- Mishnah Kelim 25:1–8; Mishnah Berakhot 8:2
- J. Neusner, "'First Cleanse the Inside': The 'Halakhic' Background of a Controversy-Saying," NTS 22 (1976)
- D. L. Bock, Luke 9:51–24:53 (BECNT)
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament
- BDAG s.v. ἔνειμι
- BDAG s.v. ἐλεημοσύνη
- BDAG s.v. καθαρός
- Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
- Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
- Luke Timothy Johnson, The Gospel of Luke (Sacra Pagina)
- Matthew Black, An Aramaic Approach to the Gospels and Acts
- Jacob Neusner, "'First Cleanse the Inside'", New Testament Studies 22 (1976)
- Mishnah Kelim 25
- Tobit 4:7–11; 12:8–9; Sirach 3:30; Daniel 4:27 (Theodotion)
- Gary A. Anderson, Charity: The Place of the Poor in the Biblical Tradition
- Vulgate, Luke 11:41
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).