Numbers Chapter 31 Read as one passage
Numbers 31:15–18
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
15“Have you spared all the women?” he asked them. 16“Look, these women caused the sons of Israel, through the counsel of Balaam, to turn unfaithfully against the LORD at Peor, so that the plague struck the congregation of the LORD. 17So now, kill all the boys, as well as every woman who has had relations with a man, 18but spare for yourselves every girl who has never had relations with a man.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse is the turning point in the last campaign of Moses' life. The army comes home having done what a successful army did: men killed, women and children brought back as plunder. Moses' outraged question reframes that success as a failure.
The point for the first audience, made explicit in v.16, concerns the danger of being led into unfaithfulness to the LORD. In the story's logic, the women of Midian were not bystanders. They were the means by which Israel had "broken faith" (maʿal, a word for sacrilege, a betrayal of what belongs to God) at Peor, and that betrayal cost thousands of lives. Keeping them alive inside the camp meant keeping the source of that danger at its centre. The chapter goes on to deal with corpse-impurity and purification of people and metal (vv.19–24), and with dividing the plunder, including a share for the sanctuary (vv.25–47). This shows the campaign was viewed through priestly concerns: holiness, purity, and what belongs to God.
The text does not soften the harshness, and it does not criticise Moses. It presents his order as authoritative. The sparing of the young girls in v.18 rests on the idea that they had no part in Peor. Many interpreters also see the passage as speaking to the community's lasting worry about marriage with foreign women and the worship of other gods (compare Num 25; Deut 7:3–4; Ezra 9–10). Readers of different schools agree on that theme, whatever they conclude about the historical event.
From the study of Numbers 31:15.
Verse by verse
-
15“Have you spared all the women?” he asked them.
Full study →Moses has just come out of the camp to meet the returning army and is angry at its commanders (v.14). Turning to them, he demands: "You let every female live?!"
The form of the sentence is an outraged question, not a request for facts. The captives are standing in front of him. The verb is the one Hebrew uses in war accounts for leaving people alive when they could have been killed. The word for those spared is not "women" in the social sense but "female," the counterpart of "male." It is the same pair the narrator used a few verses earlier: the army "killed every male" (v.7). So Moses is saying: you finished off every male, but every female, of every age, you kept alive.
The next verse gives his reason. In his eyes these were the very people who, "through the counsel of Balaam," led Israel into unfaithfulness to the LORD at Peor, which brought the deadly plague (v.16; Num 25). Because the word covers girls as well as women, the verses that follow go on to sort the captives. That sorting leads to the order to kill the boys and every woman who had lain with a man, and to keep alive only the young girls (vv.17–18).
-
16“Look, these women caused the sons of Israel, through the counsel of Balaam, to turn unfaithfully against the LORD at Peor, so that the plague struck the congregation of the LORD.
Full study →Moses is furious that the officers returning from the war against Midian have spared the women (v.15). He points at the captives: "Look at them! These are the very women who, acting on Balaam's word, became Israel's means of betraying YHWH in the Peor affair, and so the deadly blow fell on YHWH's own assembly."
Several things in the Hebrew are worth bringing out:
- "These, they": the emphatic pronoun singles out these women as the ones responsible. Hebrew does not say they "caused" Israel; it says they were, for Israel, the instrument of the betrayal. The Israelite men are not excused: they were the ones who did it.
- "By the word of Balaam": Balaam had insisted again and again that he could speak only the word God gave him (Num 22–24). Now his own word turns out to lie behind the Peor disaster. The same Hebrew noun then names "the affair of Peor", so one man's word becomes a whole affair.
- "Breach of faith against YHWH": not a minor "trespass" but ma'al, the language of sacrilege and of a wife's unfaithfulness. Joining the feasts of Baal of Peor and sleeping with the women who invited them (Num 25:1–3) was, in this frame, Israel being unfaithful to its covenant God.
- "The striking": the remembered blow of Num 25:9 that left 24,000 dead, stopped only by Phinehas. The text names the blow, not a disease.
- "YHWH's assembly": the people struck were God's own gathered community camped around his sanctuary, which shows how serious the betrayal was.
The verse is Moses' justification for the order that follows in v.17. In the logic of the text, the women who had taken part in the seduction at Peor still carried that danger into Israel's camp.
-
17So now, kill all the boys, as well as every woman who has had relations with a man,
Full study →"So now, because of what these women did at Peor: kill every boy among the captured children. And every woman who has had sex with a man, every one who has lain with a male: kill her."
Moses is speaking to angry, returning army officers who had brought back the Midianite women and children alive (31:9, 14–15). "So now" makes the order follow directly from verse 16, where he blames the Midianite women for leading Israel into unfaithfulness to the LORD at Peor, on Balaam's advice. In Hebrew the sentence opens and closes with the same blunt command, "kill." That frames the two groups being condemned and gives the order a hard, final ring.
The first group is "every male among the little ones": the boys of the households already taken captive. The adult men were already dead (31:7). The second group is defined by state, not by guilt for a particular act: every woman "knowing a man by the lying of a male." The Hebrew uses its usual idiom for sex ("to know") and then spells it out ("by the lying of a male") so nothing is left unclear.
The verse cannot be read apart from the next one. The girls who had not had sex with a man were to be kept alive "for yourselves" (31:18). The line Moses draws runs between who might carry Midian's lineage and Peor's influence forward (the boys and the sexually experienced women) and who could be absorbed into Israelite households (the young virgin girls).
-
18but spare for yourselves every girl who has never had relations with a man.
Full study →"But every one of the young dependents among the females, the ones who have never had sex with a male, you are to keep alive. They are yours."
The verse narrows a command. Verse 17 has just ordered the death of every Midianite boy and every woman who has "known the lying of a male", that is, who has had sex with a man. Verse 18 then names the one group exempt from that order: the taf, the not-yet-adult dependents, "among the women" who are still virgins. The verb (haḥayu, "keep alive") is the same one Moses used angrily in verse 15 when he found the officers had "kept alive every female." Now he limits the sparing to these girls.
"Little ones" in older English sounds like small children. The Hebrew word covers every dependent child not yet counted as an adult. In a world where girls were usually married soon after puberty, the deciding test (no prior sexual contact with a man) took in adolescent girls as well as small children. "For yourselves" is plural and spoken to the army as Israel's representatives. The girls become part of the human spoil that the rest of the chapter counts (32,000) and divides between the fighters, the people and the sanctuary. The verse does not say in what role they were kept. Parallel texts point to absorption into Israelite households, as servants and, for those old enough, as wives (compare Deut 21:10–14 and Judges 21:11–12).
Where the English drifted
-
in v15
all the women
kol-nəqēvâ
- What we hear
- The adult women among the captives.
- What they heard
- Every female, of any age: the whole female half of the captive group, girls included. It matches 'every male' (v.7) and makes the sorting of vv.17–18 necessary.
-
in v16
commit trespass (KJV, WEB); trespass (NASB)
ma'al
- What we hear
- Walking onto someone's property, or a minor wrong in general.
- What they heard
- Treacherous breach of faith against the holy God: sacrilege, covenant-breaking, the same word used for a wife's infidelity (Num 5:12).
-
in v16
plague
maggēpāh
- What we hear
- A contagious epidemic disease such as bubonic plague.
- What they heard
- A striking or blow: a deadly stroke from God on the people. The text does not say how they died.
-
in v16
congregation of the LORD
'ădat YHWH
- What we hear
- A local church gathering.
- What they heard
- The whole tribal people of Israel assembled as YHWH's community around his sanctuary, worshippers and warriors alike.
-
in v17
known man (KJV, WEB)
yoda'at 'ish
- What we hear
- A modern reader may take "known" as "was acquainted with" and miss the sense, or find the phrase vague.
- What they heard
- Had sexual intercourse with a man. The Hebrew removes any doubt by adding "by the lying of a male."
-
in v18
little ones / women children / girls
taf
- What we hear
- Small children: toddlers and young girls, much as 'little ones' sounds today.
- What they heard
- All dependent, not-yet-adult members of the household. Here it is narrowed by the virginity test, so it would include adolescent girls of marriageable age as well as small children.
-
in v18
keep alive for yourselves
haḥayu lakhem
- What we hear
- Each soldier picks a girl for his own private use.
- What they heard
- A plural command to the army as Israel's representatives: spare these girls as Israel's spoil. The rest of the chapter counts them and divides them between fighters, community and sanctuary (vv.25–47). Their role in the households they entered (servant, later wife, or both) is not stated in this verse.
Every word
-
וַיֹּ֥אמֶר
wayyōʾmer · H0559
and he said · v15
The standard narrative verb form that moves the story forward. It follows directly from v.14 ("Moses was angry"), so what he says is the anger put into words.
-
אֲלֵיהֶ֖ם
ʾălêhem · H0413
to them · v15
"Them" means the officers named in v.14, the commanders of thousands and of hundreds coming back from the campaign. The rebuke is aimed at the leaders responsible for the decision, not at the ranks.
-
מֹשֶׁ֑ה
mōšeh · H4872
Moses · v15
The speaker is Moses himself. Here he is not passing on a 'Thus says the LORD' speech. The narrator still presents him as the community's authorised leader, and his order in vv.17–18 is carried out without comment.
-
הַֽחִיִּיתֶ֖ם
haḥiyyîtem · H2421
have you kept alive / let live? · v15, v18
The prefix ha- turns the sentence into a question, and the verb is the intensive form of 'live' that means 'keep alive, leave alive, let live.' A question formed this way voices indignation more than it asks for information: 'You let them live?!' This is the same verb used in war accounts for sparing or not sparing a population (Deut 20:16; 1 Sam 27:9, 11).
-
כָּל־
kol- · H3605
all, every · v15, v17, v18
With a singular noun it means 'every single one': no female was killed. It mirrors v.7, where the army 'killed every male' (kol-zākhār).
-
נְקֵבָֽה׃
nəqēvâ · H5347
female · v15
A word for biological sex, not 'woman' (ʾishshāh). It is the partner of zākhār, 'male' (as in Gen 1:27, 'male and female'). It covers females of every age, girls and women alike. That is why Moses then has to sort them in vv.17–18: women who have lain with a man, and young girls who have not.
-
הֵ֣ן
hēn · H2005
look!, behold · v16
A word that points at something: Moses directs the officers' eyes to the captive women standing in front of them. It opens his accusation with force, roughly 'Look at them!'
-
הֵ֜נָּה
hēnnāh · H2007
they (feminine plural) · v16
An emphatic 'they', feminine plural. It points back to 'every female' the soldiers spared in v.15. The stress falls on 'these very women'.
-
הָי֨וּ
hāyû · H1961
to be, become · v16
'They were' or 'they became'. Together with the following 'for the sons of Israel' plus an infinitive, it means they served as the means of something for Israel. Hebrew uses no 'caused' verb here; English translations add that.
-
לִבְנֵ֤י
livnê · H1121G
sons, descendants · v16
'For / to the sons of'. 'Sons of Israel' is the usual name for the people as a family descended from Jacob, here especially the men who took part at Peor.
-
יִשְׂרָאֵל֙
yiśrā'ēl · H3478
Israel · v16
The people as a whole, the tribal family bound to YHWH by covenant.
-
בִּדְבַ֣ר
bidvar · H1697G
word, speech, counsel · v16
'By the word of': at Balaam's instruction or advice. The phrase echoes Numbers 22–24, where Balaam keeps saying he can speak only 'the word' YHWH gives him. Here his own 'word' leads Israel astray.
-
בִּלְעָ֔ם
bil'ām · H1109A
-
לִמְסָר־
limsor · H4560
to hand over, deliver; to commit · v16
The verb normally means 'hand over, supply' (as in 31:5). Joined to ma'al it seems to mean 'to give over into / commit' a breach of faith. The wording is unusual and may be a copying slip for the common phrase 'to commit ma'al' (see textual notes).
-
מַ֥עַל
ma'al · H4604
breach of faith, sacrilege · v16
A betrayal of what belongs to God: violating holy things, or breaking faith with the covenant. The same word describes a wife's unfaithfulness in Num 5:12. Here it names Israel's defection to Baal of Peor.
-
בַּיהוָ֖ה
baYHWH · H3068G
YHWH, the LORD · v16
'Against YHWH'. The preposition marks whom the betrayal was aimed at: Israel's own covenant God, called by his personal name.
-
עַל־
'al · H5921A
upon, over, concerning · v16
'Over' or 'in the matter of': it gives the occasion or affair in which the betrayal happened.
-
פְּע֑וֹר
pə'ôr · H6465
Peor · v16
A mountain or site in Moab where a local Baal was worshipped ('Baal of Peor'). There Israel joined in that god's sacrificial feasts and sexual liaisons (Num 25:1–3).
-
הַמַּגֵּפָ֖ה
hammaggēpāh · H4046
plague, blow, striking · v16
'The striking': the deadly blow from God remembered in Num 25:8–9, which killed 24,000. The definite article ('the') marks it as the plague everyone remembers.
-
בַּעֲדַ֥ת
ba'ădat · H5712
congregation, assembly, community · v16
'Among the community of'. The 'edah is the whole assembled people of Israel, the body that worships and also fights, organised around the sanctuary.
-
וְעַתָּ֕ה
ve'attah · H6258
and now · v17
Marks a conclusion drawn from what came just before: "so then, given this." It ties the order straight to verse 16, where the Midianite women are blamed for Israel's unfaithfulness at Peor.
-
הִרְג֥וּ
hirgu · H2026
kill, slay · v17
A plural command addressed to the army officers Moses is rebuking (31:14). Harag is the everyday verb for violent killing, used of war, murder and execution. It is not a ritual word.
-
זָכָ֖ר
zakhar · H2145
male · v17, v18
A word for biological sex, the same one used in Genesis 1:27 and in the laws on offerings and circumcision. The army had already killed the adult males (31:7), so the males left here are the boys.
-
בַּטָּ֑ף
battaf · H2945
little ones, dependents · v17, v18
"Among the little ones": the young children of the households captured in 31:9. Together with "male" it means the boys.
-
אִשָּׁ֗ה
'ishah · H802
woman, wife · v17, v18
A woman of any age or marital status. The next phrase narrows the group.
-
יֹדַ֥עַת
yoda'at · H3045
to know · v17, v18
A participle (a verb used like a description), literally "knowing." Here it is the familiar Hebrew way of saying someone has had sex, as in "Adam knew Eve" (Gen 4:1). It describes the woman's state: she is sexually experienced.
-
אִ֛ישׁ
'ish · H376
man, husband · v17
"A man": any man, not only a husband. The group is defined by sexual experience, not by marriage.
-
לְמִשְׁכַּ֥ב
le-mishkav · H4904
bed, a lying down · v17, v18
"By the lying of." From shakhav, "to lie down," which also means to have sex. It spells out the sexual sense of "knowing" so nothing is left unclear.
-
אֲשֶׁ֥ר
asher · H0834A
who, which · v18
Introduces the condition that defines the group. In the end the deciding test is not age as such but the clause that follows.
-
לֹא־
lo · H3808
not · v18
A plain negative. It turns the wording of verse 17 ('every woman who has known a man') around: these are the ones who have not.
-
לָכֶֽם׃
lakhem · H9036
for you (plural) · v18
'For you' / 'for yourselves', a plural that addresses the army and, through it, Israel. It marks the girls as Israel's to keep, part of the human spoil that vv.25–47 count and divide. It does not by itself say in what role they were kept.
The world behind it
The background is Peor. In Numbers 25, Israelite men camped at Shittim took part in sexual relations and sacrificial meals with Moabite women, and through them worshipped "the Baal of Peor." A plague followed that killed 24,000. The case that stood for it all involved a Midianite noblewoman, Cozbi, whom the priest Phinehas killed together with an Israelite man (25:6–15). God then ordered: "Be hostile to the Midianites and strike them, for they were hostile to you with their schemes … in the matter of Peor and Cozbi" (25:16–18).
Numbers 31 carries out that order. It is framed as "the LORD's vengeance on Midian" (31:3) and is Moses' last act before his death (31:2). The army is a token one, a thousand from each tribe, led by Phinehas with the holy vessels and the signal trumpets (31:6). The war is presented as sacred action, not an ordinary raid. The army kills the men, the five kings of Midian and Balaam, and burns the settlements. They bring back as plunder "the women of Midian and their little ones" along with livestock and goods (31:9–12).
What the officers did was normal practice. In the ancient Near East, the women and children of a defeated enemy were usually taken as captives, for labour, marriage or sale, rather than killed. Deuteronomy itself allows this for distant enemies: "the women, the little ones, the livestock … you may take as plunder" (Deut 20:14), and it regulates marrying a captive woman (Deut 21:10–14). Total destruction of all living things was reserved for special cases (Deut 20:16–18). By ordinary standards the commanders had done nothing unusual. Moses' anger treats Midian as a special case because of Peor.
Only v.16 explains the link with Balaam. Numbers 22–24 portrays Balaam as a prophet who ends up blessing Israel. Only here (31:8, 16) is he blamed for advising the scheme at Peor. Later Jewish and Christian tradition built on this verse (Rev 2:14: Balaam "taught Balak to put a stumbling block before the Israelites"; cf. Josephus, Antiquities 4.126–130).
A tension readers have long noticed: Moses' own wife Zipporah was a Midianite, the daughter of a Midianite priest (Exod 2:16–21; 18:1). Midian is also presented as still strong generations later (Judges 6–8). Both facts bear on the debates below about the character of this chapter.
From the study of Numbers 31:15.
Where scholars differ
in v15
What kind of account is Numbers 31: a historical battle report, or a later, idealised priestly narrative?
-
A historical record of a campaign at the end of the wilderness period, as traditional Jewish and Christian readers have generally taken it.
It is woven into the Numbers narrative (Num 25:16–18 commands it; 31:2 ties it to Moses' death). It names specific kings (31:8; cf. Josh 13:21), and the plunder rules are presented as practical legislation.
-
A largely literary, priestly composition that uses an idealised holy war to teach about purity, plunder and the danger of apostasy (e.g. Levine, Anchor Bible; Niditch, War in the Hebrew Bible).
The figures are schematic: 12,000 soldiers and not one Israelite lost (31:49), 32,000 virgin girls, neat halves and percentages of plunder. The chapter is dominated by priestly concerns (Phinehas, purification, sanctuary shares). Midian appears strong again in Judges 6–8, and Moses' own marriage was Midianite.
in v15
Why does Moses single out the females, and how are the spared girls identified?
-
Women who had lain with men stand for those who took part in the sexual-cultic rites at Peor. Young girls are presumed innocent of it.
v.16 makes the women's role at Peor the stated reason. vv.17–18 divide them precisely by sexual experience ('known a man by lying with a male').
-
Rabbinic tradition read the criterion as marriageable age rather than proven experience.
Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 60b, discusses how the girls were identified, including a tradition that they were passed before the high priest's golden head-plate. This shows early readers were already struggling with the practicality and meaning of the distinction.
in v15
Is Moses acting on God's command, or going beyond it?
-
Moses carries out the divine order of 31:2–3 / 25:17 ('be hostile to the Midianites'), and the narrator endorses him.
There is no word of criticism. The order is carried out, and God's next speech (31:25–30) regulates the division of the captives without objection.
-
Some modern readers note that the specific order to kill the women and boys is spoken by Moses, not quoted from God.
vv.15–18 have no 'the LORD said' formula, unlike 31:1–2 and 31:25. The text itself, however, gives no explicit sign that this distinction is meant to signal disapproval, so this remains an inference.
in v16
Why does Balaam, who blesses Israel in Numbers 22–24, appear here as the instigator of Peor?
-
Different traditions combined: the Balaam chapters (often assigned to older non-priestly sources) portray him positively, while Num 31 (usually treated as a later priestly composition) reflects a hostile view of him.
Num 22–24 contains no hint of a plan to seduce Israel. Num 25 does not mention Balaam. The negative portrait appears only in Num 31:8, 16 and in later texts (Deut 23:4–5; Josh 13:22; Neh 13:2).
-
The narratives fit together: having failed to curse Israel, Balaam advised Moab and Midian to undermine it through seduction and idolatrous feasting, so Israel would bring God's judgment on itself.
Num 24:14 has Balaam 'advise' Balak (often read this way in Jewish interpretation, e.g. Targum Pseudo-Jonathan). Num 31:8 places him among the Midianites. Josephus, Antiquities 4.126–130; Philo, Life of Moses 1.294–299; Rev 2:14.
in v16
Moabite or Midianite women?
-
Two strands are combined in Num 25: Moabite women in vv.1–5 and a Midianite woman in vv.6–18. Num 31 builds on the Midianite strand.
Num 25:1 names 'daughters of Moab'. 25:6, 15, 17–18 focus on Midian and Cozbi. Num 31 targets only Midian.
-
Moab and Midian acted in alliance, so the text treats them together.
Num 22:4, 7 show the elders of Moab and of Midian acting jointly in hiring Balaam.
in v17
Why are the sexually experienced women killed and the virgin girls spared?
-
Punishment for Peor: the women are killed because they were the means of Israel's apostasy.
Verse 16 gives this reason directly, and "so now" (v.17) ties the order to it. One weakness: the category covers every sexually experienced woman, not only those shown to have been at Peor, so guilt is assigned to the whole group.
-
Lineage, purity and assimilation: only girls with no prior sexual tie to Midianite men, and so no uncertain paternity or Midianite household ties, could be absorbed into Israel.
The sorting is done by sexual status (v.17–18) and not by guilt. The boys, who carry the male line, are killed too. Commentators such as Milgrom and Levine stress the concern with purity and a clean break from Midian.
-
The girls were kept as wives, concubines or servants: "keep alive for yourselves" means taking them into Israelite households, possibly under rules like those in Deuteronomy 21:10–14.
The girls are counted and divided as plunder alongside the livestock (31:32–47), and 32 go as tribute to the sanctuary. Deuteronomy 21 shows that Israelite law expected captive women to be married. Scholars disagree over how far that law protected them, and the text of Numbers 31 itself says nothing about how the girls were treated.
in v17
Is Numbers 31 a record of a historical war or a later literary composition?
-
It preserves the memory of a real conflict with Midianite groups in Transjordan, told in the style and with the numbers of its time.
Midianites are well attested in the region. The chapter names specific Midianite kings (31:8; cf. Josh 13:21), and Israelite tradition elsewhere remembers Peor.
-
It is mainly a late priestly composition that uses a war story to teach law (corpse impurity, division of plunder, tribute for the sanctuary) and to show the cost of Peor.
Midian is a major power again in Judges 6–8. The figures are schematic (12,000 soldiers, no Israelite losses at all in 31:49, very large plunder counts). Much of the chapter is about purity and the rules for dividing plunder. Commentators such as Noth, Levine and Milgrom note these features to varying degrees.
in v18
In what role were the girls kept 'for yourselves'?
-
As future wives or concubines
Virginity is the deciding criterion, which fits marriageability. Judges 21:11–12 uses the same wording and explicitly gives the spared virgins as wives. Deut 21:10–14 regulates marriage to female captives. Rabbi Shimon bar Yoḥai (b. Yevamot 60b) reads the verse as permitting marriage.
-
As household servants or slaves
The chapter treats the girls as spoil: counted, divided by lot-like shares, and taxed for the sanctuary alongside livestock (vv.25–47). The sages in b. Yevamot 60b read lakhem as 'as servants.' Many were children too young for marriage.
-
As both, in the ordinary ancient pattern
In the ancient Near East, captive girls normally entered households as servants and often later became wives or concubines. Deut 21 assumes this path while limiting abuse (a mourning period, no sale after rejection). The verse itself leaves the role open.
in v18
What kind of text is Numbers 31: a war report or a later legal-theological narrative?
-
A record of an actual campaign at the end of the wilderness period
It is set within the Numbers narrative, is tied to Num 25, and names Midianite kings (v.8) who also appear in Josh 13:21.
-
A largely idealised priestly composition about purity and spoil law
Many critical commentators (e.g. Noth, Levine) point to several features. No Israelite soldier is lost (v.49). The numbers are vast (675,000 sheep, 32,000 virgins). Most of the chapter is about purification and dividing spoil. Midian is a major power again in Judges 6–8. On this view the story illustrates law and ideology more than it reports an event.
Sources
- BDB s.v. חָיָה (Piel 'preserve alive, let live')
- HALOT s.v. חיה; s.v. נְקֵבָה
- Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley, Hebrew Grammar §150 (interrogative sentences)
- Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990), on Num 25 and 31
- Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 21–36 (Anchor Bible, 2000)
- Timothy R. Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT, 1993)
- Susan Niditch, War in the Hebrew Bible (1993)
- Septuagint, Numbers 31:15
- Babylonian Talmud, Yevamot 60b
- Josephus, Antiquities 4.126–130; Philo, Life of Moses 1.294–305
- BDB s.v. מָסַר, מַעַל, מַגֵּפָה, עֵדָה
- HALOT s.v. מסר, מַעַל
- Jacob Milgrom, Cult and Conscience (1976), on ma'al as sacrilege
- Jacob Milgrom, JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990)
- Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 21–36 (Anchor Bible)
- G. B. Gray, Numbers (ICC)
- Septuagint, Numbers 31:16
- Vulgate, Numbers 31:16
- Josephus, Antiquities 4.126–130
- Philo, Life of Moses 1.294–299
- Deir 'Alla plaster inscription (Balaam son of Beor)
- Revelation 2:14; 2 Peter 2:15; Jude 11; Joshua 22:16–20
- BDB s.v. הָרַג, טַף, יָדַע, מִשְׁכָּב
- HALOT s.v. טַף, יָדַע, מִשְׁכָּב
- Jacob Milgrom, The JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990), on Num 31
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), lines 14–17, in The Context of Scripture 2.23
- Judges 21:10–12; Deuteronomy 20:13–17; 21:10–14; Numbers 25
- BDB s.v. טַף
- HALOT s.v. טַף; s.v. חיה (hiphil)
- BDB s.v. מִשְׁכָּב
- Mesha Stele (KAI 181), lines 16–17
- Judges 21:10–14; Deuteronomy 20:14–16; 21:10–14; Numbers 25
- J. Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary), on ch. 31
- B. A. Levine, Numbers 21–36 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- T. R. Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT)
- M. Noth, Numbers (OTL)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).