1 Chronicles Chapter 21 Read as one passage

1 Chronicles 21:10–12

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10“Go and tell David that this is what the LORD says: ‘I am offering you three options. Choose one of them, and I will carry it out against you.’” 11So Gad went and said to David, “This is what the LORD says: ‘You must choose 12between three years of famine, three months of being swept away before your enemies and overtaken by their swords, or three days of the sword of the LORD—days of plague upon the land, with the angel of the LORD ravaging every part of Israel.’ Now then, decide how I should reply to Him who sent me.”

What the first hearers heard

The Chronicler wrote for the Judean community after the exile, in the Persian period, who were gathered around the rebuilt temple in Jerusalem. For them this verse was not mainly about David's personal failure. It was a step in explaining how the temple site came to exist. They would have heard several things:

  • God's word through a prophet is final. The messenger formula shows that the judgment comes from the LORD himself, not from human enemies or bad luck.
  • Confession does not erase consequence, but the outcome is still open. David has confessed, and God answers with a fixed penalty, yet he lets David choose its form. This prepares for David's appeal to God's "very great mercies" (21:13) and for God relenting (21:15).
  • The king answers for the people. A community that had lost its monarchy saw how a ruler's act could bring disaster on everyone, and how intercession and sacrifice could turn it away.
  • The threat leads to the altar. What God "stretches out over" David (v. 10) becomes the angel's outstretched sword (v. 16). It is put back in its sheath only when sacrifice is offered on Ornan's threshing floor (vv. 26–27). The temple where they worshipped stood on the spot where judgment was stopped.

From the study of 1 Chronicles 21:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10“Go and tell David that this is what the LORD says: ‘I am offering you three options. Choose one of them, and I will carry it out against you.’”

    God tells his prophet: "Go and say to David, as my messenger, These are the words of the LORD: Three blows I am holding out over you, already raised. Pick one of them for yourself, and I myself will bring it down on you."

    The verse speaks with royal formality. Gad does not give advice. He delivers a sentence in God's own first-person voice, the way an ancient envoy spoke for his king. The number "three" comes first for emphasis, and the three "things" are left unnamed for now. The listener hears only that three judgments are suspended over the king. The verb is often translated "offer", but it pictures something stretched out over a person, the same verb used a few verses later for the angel's sword "stretched out over Jerusalem" (21:16). So this is not a generous menu. The penalty is certain. The only thing left to David is which form it takes, and the weight of that choice falls on him personally ("choose for yourself"). God does not hide behind circumstances: "I will do it to you."

    Full study →
  2. 11So Gad went and said to David, “This is what the LORD says: ‘You must choose

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 12between three years of famine, three months of being swept away before your enemies and overtaken by their swords, or three days of the sword of the LORD—days of plague upon the land, with the angel of the LORD ravaging every part of Israel.’ Now then, decide how I should reply to Him who sent me.”

    Gad, David's seer, gives the king God's terms like a herald: Either three years of famine, or three months in which you keep being swept off the field in front of the people who have you hemmed in, while your enemies' sword runs you down, or three days of YHWH's own sword, which means epidemic sweeping through the land, with YHWH's envoy, the Destroyer, cutting his way across every part of Israel's territory. So now, look hard at this and decide what answer I am to carry back to the One who is sending me.

    The options are built with care. The number three stays fixed while the span shrinks from years to months to days, so each option is shorter and more concentrated than the last. The penalties move from nature (famine), to human hands (the enemy's sword), to God's direct hand (God's sword, explained as pestilence). The two 'swords' are placed side by side on purpose, because David's answer turns on whose hand holds the blade (v.13). 'Destroying' recalls the Destroyer of the Passover night. Gad also calls himself someone 'sent', a messenger who speaks alongside the heavenly messenger who will strike. The last word of the verse, 'a word', makes the point that the king has to give an answer, and that his choice will decide how all Israel suffers.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    I offer you / I am offering you three options

    šālôš ʾănî nōṭeh ʿālêkā

    What we hear
    A generous or neutral offer, like being handed a selection to pick from at your leisure.
    What they heard
    'Three I am stretching out over you': three judgments held poised above the king, the same image as the sword 'stretched out over Jerusalem' in 21:16. There is a real choice, but it is a choice between blows.
  • in v12

    coasts (KJV: 'throughout all the coasts of Israel')

    gevul

    What we hear
    Seashores or coastlines.
    What they heard
    Borders, and by extension the whole territory inside them: 'every region of Israel'.
  • in v12

    angel

    mal'akh

    What we hear
    A gentle, winged guardian or comforter.
    What they heard
    An envoy or agent sent to do a task. Here he is an armed executioner of a divine sentence, with a drawn sword over Jerusalem (v.16).
  • in v12

    advise thyself (KJV)

    re'eh

    What we hear
    Give advice to someone, or ask for advice.
    What they heard
    'See!', meaning 'consider carefully and decide for yourself'.
Every word
  1. לֵךְ

    lēk · H1980

    go, walk · v10

    A short command that sends the prophet off. Gad is being sent as a messenger from God to the king.

  2. וְדִבַּרְתָּ

    wədibbartā · H1696

    speak · v10

    Literally 'and you shall speak'. Following a command, this form carries the force of a second command: 'go and speak'. YLT's 'thou hast spoken' copies the verb's form but misses how it works here.

  3. אֶל־

    ʾel · H413

    to, toward · v10

    Marks David as the one the message is addressed to.

  4. דָּוִיד

    dāwîd · H1732

    David · v10

    The king, who has just confessed the sin of the census (21:8). He gets the message as king, the one whose act brought guilt on the whole nation.

  5. לֵאמֹר

    lēʾmōr · H559

    saying · v10

    The standard marker that a quotation is about to start, much like opening quotation marks.

  6. כֹּה

    kōh · H3541

    thus, so · v10

    Opens the formula 'Thus says…', which signals that the words that follow belong to the sender, not to the messenger.

  7. יְהוָה

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD (Yahweh) · v10, v12

    The personal name of Israel's God, whom David has offended by the census. By custom English prints it as 'the LORD'.

  8. שָׁלוֹשׁ

    šālôš · H7969

    three · v10, v12

    Stands first in its clause for emphasis: 'Three, I am holding over you.' The 'things' is not in the Hebrew and is left unspecified until verse 12: three years of famine, three months of defeat, three days of plague.

  9. אֲנִי

    ʾănî · H589

    I · v10

    An explicit pronoun, which the verb does not need, so it stresses God as the one acting. The parallel in 2 Samuel 24:12 uses the older form ʾānōkî. Chronicles uses the shorter form, as later Hebrew tends to.

  10. נֹטֶה

    nōṭeh · H5186

    stretch out, extend, hold out · v10

    A present participle, 'I am stretching out': something happening now or about to happen. Followed by 'over you', it pictures something held out above David, like a hand or weapon raised to strike. It is more than a neutral 'offer'.

  11. עָלֶיךָ

    ʿālêkā · H5921

    upon, over, against (you) · v10

    'Over you' or 'against you'. The three options hang over David as threats. They are not set before him as gifts.

  12. בְּחַר־

    bəḥar · H977

    choose · v10

    A command: 'choose!' The judgment itself is fixed. Only its form is left to David.

  13. לְךָ

    ləkā · H9031

    for yourself · v10

    'For yourself.' This adds personal weight: the choice, and the responsibility for it, belong to David. KJV 'choose thee' keeps it.

  14. אַחַת

    ʾaḥat · H259

    one · v10

    Feminine 'one', agreeing with the unnamed 'things'. Exactly one of the three will fall.

  15. מֵהֵנָּה

    mēhēnnāh · H9039

    from them · v10

    'Of them', meaning out of the three.

  16. וְאֶעֱשֶׂה־

    wəʾeʿĕśeh · H6213

    do, make, carry out · v10

    'And I will do', which after a command carries purpose: 'so that I may do it'. God says he will carry out the chosen judgment himself.

  17. אִם־

    'im · H0518A

    if, whether · v12

    Starts a list of options: 'either…'. It picks up Gad's command in v.11, 'take for yourself' (choose). With the two 'im clauses that follow, the sentence becomes a formal three-way choice.

  18. שָׁנִ֜ים

    shanim · H8141

    years · v12

    Three full agricultural cycles. In a farming economy that depended on rain, that meant failed harvests one after another.

  19. רָעָ֗ב

    ra'av · H7458

    famine, hunger · v12

    Famine caused by drought or crop failure, slow and wearing. The noun simply stands next to 'three years' with no connecting word: 'three years: famine'.

  20. חֳדָשִׁ֜ים

    chodashim · H2320G

    months · v12

    Months counted by the new moon. Three months is about the length of a military campaign season.

  21. נִסְפֶּ֥ה

    nispeh · H5595

    to be swept away, snatched away · v12

    A passive participle, 'being swept away'. It describes an ongoing state of being carried off and destroyed. It is the same verb as Abraham's 'Will you sweep away the righteous with the wicked?' (Gen 18:23). The parallel in Samuel has 'fleeing' instead.

  22. מִפְּנֵי־

    mippenei · H6440G

    from before, from the face of · v12

    Literally 'from the face of': being driven back in front of the enemy, in sight of them.

  23. צָרֶיךָ֮

    tsareykha · H6862C

    your adversaries · v12

    'Your foes'. The word comes from a root meaning 'narrow, pressing', so these are the people who hem you in. David's answer in v.13 uses the same root: tsar li, 'I am in a tight place'.

  24. וְחֶ֣רֶב

    ve-cherev · H2719

    and the sword of · v12

    The human sword. It sets up a contrast with 'the sword of YHWH' in the third option.

  25. אוֹיְבֶ֣ךָ׀

    'oyivkha · H0341

    your enemies · v12

    A participle, 'those being hostile to you'. It is a second word for enemy, placed alongside tsar for emphasis.

  26. לְמַשֶּׂגֶת֒

    lemasseget · H5381

    to overtake, catch up with · v12

    'Overtaking'. The form is feminine because 'sword' is feminine in Hebrew, so the sword itself is pictured as running the fugitive down. The grammar is unusual ('for overtaking'), but the meaning is clear: there is no escape.

  27. יָ֠מִים

    yamim · H3117G

    days · v12

    Days. The shortest period, but this option comes directly from God.

  28. וְדֶ֙בֶר֙

    ve-dever · H1698

    pestilence · v12

    A deadly epidemic. The 'and' here explains rather than adds: 'the sword of YHWH, that is, pestilence'. God's 'sword' takes the form of disease.

  29. בָּאָ֔רֶץ

    ba'arets · H0776G

    in the land · v12

    In the land of Israel, the land promised in the covenant. That is exactly where the curses of the covenant were said to fall.

  30. וּמַלְאַ֣ךְ

    u-mal'akh · H4397H

    and the messenger/angel of · v12

    'Messenger' or 'agent'. Here it is a heavenly agent carrying out a death sentence, not bringing news. In v.16 David sees him holding a drawn sword over Jerusalem.

  31. מַשְׁחִ֖ית

    mashchit · H7843

    destroying, ruining · v12

    A participle, 'destroying'. It is the same form used for 'the destroyer' at the first Passover (Exod 12:23), so it calls up that memory.

  32. בְּכָל־

    bekhol · H3605

    in all · v12

    'Throughout all': the whole country, with no region spared.

  33. גְּב֣וּל

    gevul · H1366H

    border, territory · v12

    First 'boundary', then the land inside the boundary: 'the whole territory of Israel'. (This is what the KJV means by 'coasts'.)

  34. יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל

    Yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v12

    The people and land that David has just counted (21:1–6). The census that caused this was a count of 'Israel', and now all of Israel stands under the threat.

  35. וְעַתָּ֣ה

    ve'attah · H6258

    and now · v12

    The usual Hebrew turn from setting out facts to calling for action: 'so now'.

  36. רְאֵ֔ה

    re'eh · H7200J

    see; consider, decide · v12

    Literally 'See!' Here it means 'look carefully and decide'. The decision is put back on David himself.

  37. מָֽה־

    mah · H4100

    what? · v12

    'What': the content of the answer David has to give.

  38. אָשִׁ֥יב

    'ashiv · H7725G

    I will bring back, return · v12

    'Shall I bring back'. 'Return a word' is the Hebrew idiom for 'reply'. The prophet goes back and forth between God and the king.

  39. אֶת־

    'et · H0853

    (direct-object marker) · v12

    Not translated. It marks 'the one sending me' as the person who receives the reply.

  40. שֹׁלְחִ֖י

    sholchi · H7971G

    the one sending me · v12

    A participle, 'my Sender'. Gad speaks of himself as a messenger whom God is sending right now. That makes him a human counterpart to the destroying 'messenger' (mal'akh) earlier in the verse.

  41. דָּבָֽר׃

    davar · H1697H

    word, answer · v12

    'A word', meaning the answer. Hebrew saves it for the end of the sentence: 'what shall I bring back to my Sender, as a word?'

The world behind it

The census and its fallout. In 1 Chronicles 21 David orders a count of Israel's fighting men, against Joab's protest (21:3) that it will bring guilt on Israel. The Chronicler says "Satan" (or "an adversary") stirred David up (21:1). The earlier account in 2 Samuel 24:1 attributes it to the LORD's anger. A military census was a show of royal power and a basis for conscription and taxation. Exodus 30:12 already warns that counting the people without a ransom payment brings a plague. David confesses (21:8). Verse 10 is God's answer to that confession: forgiveness does not cancel the consequence.

The king and his people. In ancient Israel a king's guilt was not private. The choice is addressed to David ("over you", "to you"), but every option falls on the nation: famine, defeat in war, or plague (21:12). Ancient hearers took this for granted, since the king stood for his people before God. That is why David later protests, "I am the one who sinned… but these sheep, what have they done?" (21:17).

The seer as messenger. Gad is called David's "seer" (ḥōzeh), a court prophet. In the ancient Near East a royal messenger memorised his master's words and repeated them in the first person, introduced by "Thus says…". Gad's role here is exactly that.

Where the story is going. For the Chronicler this episode explains where the temple came from. The plague stops at the threshing floor of Ornan the Jebusite (Araunah in Samuel). David buys it and builds an altar there, and the Chronicler identifies it as the site of Solomon's temple (22:1; 2 Chr 3:1). The judgment "stretched out" in verse 10 leads straight to the place of atonement.

From the study of 1 Chronicles 21:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

Is Chronicles' 'stretching out' (nōṭeh) or Samuel's 'laying upon' (nōṭēl) the earlier wording?

  • Samuel's nōṭēl is earlier, and Chronicles changed it, deliberately or by accident.

    nāṭal is rare, and scribes tend to replace a rare word with a common one. The Samuel text is the Chronicler's source for this chapter. The Greek 'lift / take up' may reflect a Hebrew text with nāṭal.

  • Chronicles reflects a different Hebrew text of Samuel, or a deliberate rewording that ties the verse to 21:16.

    The Chronicler's Samuel source often differs from the traditional Hebrew Samuel. nōṭeh ʿal matches the 'outstretched sword over Jerusalem' in 21:16 and the familiar prophetic idiom of God stretching out his hand over a people.

in v10

Is giving David a choice an act of mercy or an added burden?

  • Mercy: God lets David shape the judgment, which leads him to throw himself on God's compassion.

    David's answer in 21:13 appeals to God's 'very great mercies', and God relents at the threshing floor (21:15).

  • Burden and accountability: the king must take responsibility for how the penalty falls on his people.

    The emphatic 'choose for yourself', the wording of hostility ('stretching out over you', 'do to you'), and David's anguish over the innocent 'sheep' (21:17).

in v12

Was the famine originally 'three years' or 'seven years'?

  • 'Three' is original. Samuel's 'seven' crept in through copying.

    The Greek of 2 Sam 24:13 reads 'three', agreeing with Chronicles. 'Three' also matches the rest of the series (three months, three days).

  • 'Seven' is original in Samuel. Chronicles evened out the series.

    'Seven' is the harder reading, and Chronicles often tidies its sources. Some link 'seven' to the seven-year famine traditions (Gen 41; 2 Kgs 8:1) or to adding up the three years of 2 Sam 21:1.

in v12

Why does Chronicles have 'being swept away' where Samuel has 'fleeing'?

  • The Chronicler had a different Hebrew text, or the text was miscopied.

    The early Greek and Latin of Chronicles appear to reflect 'fleeing', which suggests some witnesses had a reading like Samuel's.

  • A deliberate change.

    Chronicles often makes this story more vivid and more about the whole nation, for example with the visible angel and 'all the territory of Israel'. 'Swept away' moves the focus from the king's flight to the people's destruction.

Sources
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. נָטָה (stretch out; with עַל, against)
  • HALOT s.v. נָטַל (lift, lay upon), for 2 Sam 24:12 and Lam 3:28
  • BDB s.v. בָּחַר
  • Masoretic Text of 2 Samuel 24:12–13 compared with 1 Chronicles 21:10–12, 16
  • Supplied interlinear data (lemma, Strong's, morphology)
  • Standard commentary discussion of the Chronicler's use of Samuel (e.g. Japhet, I & II Chronicles, OTL; Williamson, 1 and 2 Chronicles, NCB)
  • On the messenger formula: comparative ancient Near Eastern letter and prophecy texts (Mari, Akkadian 'umma X-ma')
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. סָפָה, דֶּבֶר, מַשְׁחִית / שָׁחַת, גְּבוּל, מַלְאָךְ
  • Sara Japhet, I & II Chronicles (Old Testament Library)
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Chronicles (Hermeneia)
  • Gary N. Knoppers, I Chronicles 10–29 (Anchor Bible)
  • H. G. M. Williamson, 1 and 2 Chronicles (New Century Bible)
  • P. Kyle McCarter, II Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 2 Sam 24:13
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Sam 24 / 1 Chr 21
  • Epic of Gilgamesh, Tablet XI (Ea's speech after the flood)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) and Vulgate of 1 Chronicles 21:12 and 2 Samuel 24:13

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.