1 John Chapter 5 Read as one passage
1 John 5:6–12
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
6This is the One who came by water and blood, Jesus Christ—not by water alone, but by water and blood. And it is the Spirit who testifies to this, because the Spirit is the truth. 7For there are three that testify: 8the Spirit, the water, and the blood—and these three are in agreement. 9Even if we accept human testimony, the testimony of God is greater. For this is the testimony that God has given about His Son. 10Whoever believes in the Son of God has this testimony within him; whoever does not believe God has made Him out to be a liar, because he has not believed in the testimony that God has given about His Son. 11And this is that testimony: God has given us eternal life, and this life is in His Son. 12Whoever has the Son has life; whoever does not have the Son of God does not have life.
What the first hearers heard
For the first readers this verse was a line drawn through their own community. Former members had walked out, probably claiming spiritual insight, and were teaching a Christ who came "in the water" but not "in the blood". On such a view the divine Christ joined Jesus at his baptism and was gone before the cross, so Jesus' death meant nothing for salvation.
The author answers with three moves:
- Identity: the one who came is Jesus, and Jesus is the Christ. There is no split between a heavenly Christ and a human Jesus.
- The whole story: his coming includes both the water (baptism, the start of his public mission) and the blood (his death). The cross is not something that happened to a man the Christ had left; it is where the Christ came. That keeps the letter's earlier promise standing: his blood "cleanses us from all sin" (1:7).
- The witness: the readers are not left to weigh one group's spiritual claims against another's. The Spirit, who is the truth, keeps on testifying to this Jesus. A "spirit" that taught otherwise would show itself to be the spirit of error (4:1–6).
So the verse gave the community confidence about who belonged to the truth, and why "believing that Jesus is the Son of God" (5:5) meant believing in the crucified one.
From the study of 1 John 5:6.
Verse by verse
-
6This is the One who came by water and blood, Jesus Christ—not by water alone, but by water and blood. And it is the Spirit who testifies to this, because the Spirit is the truth.
Full study →This is the one who came, the long-awaited Coming One, and he came by way of water and blood: Jesus, who is himself the Messiah. He did not come in the water only, as though the Christ arrived at Jesus' baptism in the Jordan and then withdrew before the suffering. He came in the water and in the blood. His baptism and his bloody, sin-cleansing death both belong to his coming, and you cannot keep one and drop the other.
And the Spirit is the witness who keeps testifying to this. The Spirit is not one witness among many who might be mistaken. The Spirit is the truth: God's own reality, the opposite of the lie that rival teachers are spreading.
The verse speaks the language of a court case. Verse 5 has just said that the one who overcomes the world believes "Jesus is the Son of God". Verse 6 says exactly which Jesus: the man baptized and the man crucified, the same person, the Christ throughout. Then it calls the first witness, the Spirit, before the next verses count up the "three that testify" that a valid case requires.
-
7For there are three that testify:
Full study →"Because there are three who stand as witnesses —" and in the next breath (v. 8) John names them: the Spirit, the water, and the blood, and the three point to one and the same verdict.
Verse 7 is half a sentence: a courtroom hinge. Verse 6 has just said that Jesus Christ "came through water and blood", not by water only, and that "the Spirit is the one testifying". Verse 7 adds that the Spirit is not a lone witness: there are three. Under the law of Moses, a matter was settled only "at the mouth of two or three witnesses" (Deut 19:15). John calls a full panel, and in verse 9 he says that in their combined testimony God himself is giving evidence about his Son. The word for "testify" is legal: to give evidence that settles a fact. The present tense pictures the witnesses as still speaking.
Readers of the King James Version know a longer verse: "in heaven, the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one." Those words were not part of what John wrote. They are missing from every Greek manuscript for over a thousand years. They first appear in Latin writers in late 4th-century Spain, and entered the printed Greek New Testament only in 1522. John's own sentence is about something more concrete. Three witnesses agree that the Jesus who was baptised and who bled and died is the Christ, the Son of God.
-
8the Spirit, the water, and the blood—and these three are in agreement.
Full study →Three witnesses have taken the stand, and they agree. First is the Spirit, God's own Spirit of truth, still speaking inside the community of believers. Next comes the water: the baptism at the Jordan, where Jesus was publicly marked out as the Son of God. Third is the blood: his real death on the cross, which shows that the Son of God himself died, and not just a man the divine Christ had left behind. The Greek counts these three with the grammar of persons, as if they had stood up in court. It says that they "are into the one thing": their three testimonies meet at one point and give one verdict. The tense is present. They are not just past events but a testimony still being given.
The background is the Law of Moses: "on the evidence of two or three witnesses a matter shall be established" (Deut 19:15). John is saying that the claim "Jesus is the Son of God" (5:5) has met the full legal standard. The next verse tells us whose case it really is: this agreeing testimony is God's own testimony about his Son, and it outweighs any human testimony. The verse is about converging evidence, not about the inner being of God. The well-known KJV words about three witnesses "in heaven" and "in earth" were not part of what John wrote.
-
9Even if we accept human testimony, the testimony of God is greater. For this is the testimony that God has given about His Son.
Full study →Since we accept the word of human witnesses as a matter of course, God's own testimony carries far more weight. And this is exactly what is at stake here: it is God himself who has testified, and his sworn testimony about his own Son stands on the record.
The verse is a courtroom argument. The verses just before it named three witnesses in agreement: the Spirit, the water and the blood. That more than meets the old legal rule that a matter is settled by "two or three witnesses" (Deuteronomy 19:15). John now says: in daily life we routinely accept human testimony. Courts convict on it, deals are closed on it, families settle inheritances by it. If that lesser evidence is good enough, how much more God's. The witness in this case is God himself, giving evidence about his own Son. That is the strongest witness there could be, a father vouching for his son.
"Has testified" is in a Greek tense that describes a completed act whose result lasts. God has given his evidence and it remains in force, like a sworn statement entered into the court record. The word "testimony" appears three times in one sentence and runs through the whole passage (ten times in verses 6–11). The next verse spells out what is at stake: whoever refuses this testimony is not merely undecided but "has made him a liar."
-
10Whoever believes in the Son of God has this testimony within him; whoever does not believe God has made Him out to be a liar, because he has not believed in the testimony that God has given about His Son.
Full study →Anyone who keeps on trusting in, and committing himself to, the Son of God has God's own sworn witness about that Son inside him: received, taken in, now his to hold. But anyone who refuses to take God at his word has, by that refusal, already branded God a liar, and the verdict stands. The reason is that he has refused to entrust himself to the testimony God has formally given, and keeps on record, about his own Son.
The picture is a courtroom. In v. 9 John has just argued that people accept human witnesses all the time, and that God's witness is weightier. Now there are only two positions. One person accepts the witness and finds it has come to live in him. The other rejects it, and rejecting a witness's statement means calling the witness a perjurer. Neutral ground is ruled out. You cannot set the testimony aside and keep honouring the one who gave it.
The verb "believe" appears three times in three shapes: trusting into the Son, believing God (taking his word as true), and trusting into his testimony. John treats them as one act seen from three sides. Several verbs are perfects ("has made", "has believed", "has testified"), a Greek tense for a completed act whose result continues: God's testimony has been given and stands, and the unbeliever's rejection has hardened into a settled position. Verse 11 then says what the testimony is: God has given us eternal life, and this life is in his Son.
-
11And this is that testimony: God has given us eternal life, and this life is in His Son.
Full study →And this is what God's testimony says: the evidence God himself has put on record, which is greater than any human witness (v.9), is this. God has given us life: not just ordinary existence, but the life of the coming age, the life that belongs to God himself and was 'with the Father' before it was revealed to us (1:2). And it is not only promised for some later day. God has already handed it over as a gift, so the community can know that they have it now (5:13). And this life is in his Son. It is found in Jesus, God's own Son, and only there. It is not a reward that exists apart from him, nor a private spiritual possession you could keep while turning away from him. To have the Son is to have the life, and to be without the Son is to be without it (v.12).
Two details in the Greek are worth noticing. Life comes first in its clause for emphasis ("life, eternal life, God gave us"), and the second clause repeats "this life, the life", so it is clear that the gift and the Son cannot be pulled apart.
-
12Whoever has the Son has life; whoever does not have the Son of God does not have life.
Full study →The person who has the Son — who holds on to him and belongs to him as the one God has testified him to be — already has the life: the very life of God's coming age, the life God has given and placed in his Son. The person who does not have the Son of God — the life, that he simply does not have.
The verse finishes a short legal-style argument (vv. 9–11). God has given testimony. The content of that testimony is that he has given eternal life, and that this life is in his Son. Verse 12 draws the logical conclusion in two mirror-image lines. Since the life is located in the Son, whoever has the Son has the life, and whoever lacks the Son lacks it. There is no third option, and no way to keep the life while setting the Son aside.
Several details carry meaning that English often flattens:
- "Has" is present tense in both halves. The life is a present possession, not only a future reward (compare v. 13: "so that you may know that you have eternal life").
- "Having" the Son is relational. The present participle describes a continuing state ("the one who is having"). John uses the same idiom for "having" the Father (2:23; 2 John 9). It means being joined to the Son in confession and loyalty, not grabbing hold of him once.
- "The life" has an article. It points back to the specific eternal life of v. 11. Elsewhere in the letter that life is identified with Jesus himself (1:2; 5:20).
- The second half adds "of God" and moves "the life" forward before the verb. The result has a hammer-blow ending: "the life — he does not have."
Where the English drifted
-
in v6
Jesus Christ
Iēsous Christos
- What we hear
- A personal name, like a first name and a surname.
-
in v6
testifies
martyreō
- What we hear
- Sharing a personal faith story ("giving your testimony").
- What they heard
- Giving evidence as a witness to establish that a claim is true, as in a court. Here the Spirit confirms the facts of Jesus' baptism and death.
-
in v6
the Spirit is the truth
to pneuma estin hē alētheia
- What we hear
- The Spirit tells the truth; the Spirit is honest.
- What they heard
- That is included, but the claim is bigger. The Spirit belongs to God's own reality and stands against "the lie" and the "spirit of error" (4:6). The Spirit's witness is the unfalsifiable kind.
-
in v7
bear record (KJV)
martyreō
- What we hear
- Keep or write down a record, like a file or register.
- What they heard
- Give testimony as a witness, give evidence that establishes a fact.
-
in v7
Holy Ghost (KJV, in the added words)
pneuma hagion
- What we hear
- The ghost of someone dead; a phantom.
- What they heard
- The holy Spirit (breath, wind) of God, who in John's writings teaches and testifies.
-
in v7
testify
martyreō
- What we hear
- Share a personal faith story (a 'testimony').
- What they heard
- Legal witness: evidence offered to settle a disputed fact, here who Jesus is and how he came.
-
in v8
these three agree in one (KJV)
hoi treis eis to hen eisin
- What we hear
- Read next to the KJV's verse 7 ("the Father, the Word, and the Holy Ghost: and these three are one"), the line sounds like a statement about the three persons of the Trinity sharing one nature.
- What they heard
- Three witnesses (Spirit, water, blood) whose testimony converges on one verdict about Jesus. This is courtroom agreement, not a statement about the being of God.
-
in v9
testimony
martyria
- What we hear
- A believer's personal story of conversion or answered prayer, shared in church.
- What they heard
- Legally weighty evidence given by a witness. Here it is God's own evidence about who Jesus is, not anyone's account of their inner experience.
-
in v10
testimony / has the testimony in himself
martyria
- What we hear
- A person's own story of how they came to faith ('sharing my testimony'), or an inner feeling of certainty.
- What they heard
- A witness's formal, evidential statement. Here it is God's own testimony about his Son, which the believer has received and now holds within.
-
in v10, v11
record (KJV)
martyria
- What we hear
- A written document, file or archive.
- What they heard
- Attestation by a witness. It is the same word KJV renders 'witness' earlier in the verse.
-
in v11
eternal life
zōē aiōnios
- What we hear
- Living forever, mainly in heaven after death. An endless amount of time that begins when you die.
- What they heard
- The life of the coming age: God's own life, revealed in Jesus and shared with those joined to him. It is already given (past-tense 'gave') and held now (5:12–13). It never ends, but its main mark is where it comes from and what kind of life it is, not only how long it lasts.
-
in v12
has life
echei tēn zōēn
- What we hear
- Is alive, or has a full and meaningful life; or, alternatively, will go to heaven someday.
-
in v12
has the Son
ho echōn ton huion
- What we hear
- Has, at some point, made a decision to accept Jesus, a one-time transaction.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v11
'Eternal life' here isn't only about after you die
- What's often taught
- Eternal life is the reward believers receive when they die: going to heaven and living forever. This verse promises that future destination to those who believe.
- What the text supports
The common reading gets one thing right: John does expect a life that never ends (2:17 'abides forever'; 2:25 'the promise… eternal life'). But this verse puts the weight somewhere else:
- Already given. Edōken is a past tense: God gave it. Verse 12 uses the present: whoever has the Son has the life. Verse 13 says the letter was written 'so that you may know that you have eternal life'.
- A kind of life, not just a length. Zōē aiōnios echoes the Jewish 'life of the age to come' (Dan 12:2). In John it is God's own life, which 'was with the Father and was revealed to us' (1:2), and it means knowing God (John 17:3).
- Located in a person. The life is 'in his Son'. It is not a benefit that can be held apart from him, which is why v.12 equates having the Son with having the life.
So the verse is about present union with the Son, who carries God's own life into the present. Life beyond death follows from that union, but it is not the main point here.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'Eternal' in English mostly suggests endless time, and the phrase is often heard together with 'go to heaven'. Translations that say 'has given' help, but nothing in English signals the 'age to come' background of aiōnios.
in v12
"Has life" is present tense, not only a ticket for later
- What's often taught
- This verse is often taught as being about going to heaven when you die: whoever has accepted Jesus will receive eternal life after death, and whoever has not will not.
- What the text supports
That reading gets something right. The verse does draw a real dividing line, and John elsewhere expects future resurrection life (John 6:40; 1 John 3:2). But the verb here is present tense in both halves: the one who has the Son has the life now. Verse 13 makes the same point: "so that you may know that you have eternal life." In John, "eternal life" means the life of God's coming age, and it is identified with Jesus himself (1:2; 5:20). John 17:3 defines it as knowing the Father and Jesus Christ. So the verse describes a present sharing in God's life through belonging to the Son. Its future completion is included, but the verse is not only about where a person goes after death.
- Where the English feeds it
- Translations that drop the article ("has life" rather than "has the life") weaken the link to the specific eternal life of v. 11. Separately, the English word "eternal" in nearby verses is usually heard as "endless", which turns attention to duration and the afterlife rather than to the kind of life and its present possession.
Every word
-
οὗτός
houtos · G3778
this, this one · v6, v7, v9, v11
Points back to the Jesus confessed in verse 5 ("Jesus is the Son of God") and puts weight on him: this very person, and no one else, is the one who came.
-
ἐστιν
estin · G1510
is · v6, v7, v8, v9, v11
Simple present "is", setting up an identification: the believer's Jesus is the same as the one who came through water and blood.
-
ὁ
ho · G3588
the · v6, v7, v8, v9, v10, v11, v12
The article turns the following participle into a title: "the one who came", echoing "the Coming One", a way people spoke of the expected Messiah.
-
ἐλθὼν
elthōn · G2064
having come · v6
A past-tense form pointing to a completed, historical event. The coming took place in real events of Jesus' life, not as a timeless idea or an ongoing church ritual.
-
δι᾽
di' · G1223
through, by means of · v6
"Through" water and blood: he came by way of these events, passing through them as stages of his mission.
-
ὕδατος
hudatos · G5204
water · v6, v8
Without the article here, in a set pair with "blood". Most interpreters take it as Jesus' baptism by John in the Jordan (see debates).
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v6, v7, v8, v11
Joins water and blood as a pair; the rest of the verse insists the two cannot be separated.
-
αἵματος
haimatos · G0129G
blood · v6, v8
In this letter blood means Jesus' violent, atoning death (1:7, "the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin").
-
Ἰησοῦς
Iēsous · G2424G
Jesus · v6
The human name of the man from Nazareth, placed alongside the title: the man himself is the one who came.
-
Χριστός
Christos · G5547
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v6, v10, v12
Introduces a correction aimed at a rival view, building toward "not only... but".
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in, with, by · v6, v7, v10, v11
The preposition changes from "through" to "in/with"; most take this as a variation in style. It may suggest the sphere in which he came: in the water and in the blood.
-
μόνον
monon · G3441
only, alone · v6
The key word of the dispute. Someone was saying "by water only". The author does not deny the water; he denies that it is the whole story.
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G0235
but · v6
A strong contrast that brings in the author's correction.
-
πνεῦμά
pneuma · G4151G
spirit, breath, wind · v6, v7, v8
God's Spirit, presented as a witness who speaks. In John's Gospel he is "the Spirit of truth" who testifies about Jesus (John 15:26).
-
μαρτυροῦν
martyroun · G3140
testifying, bearing witness · v6, v7, v9, v10
Present tense: the Spirit keeps on testifying, now, in the community. This is courtroom language for confirming that something is true.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754H
because, that · v6, v7, v9, v10, v11
Most read it as "because", giving the reason the Spirit's testimony can be trusted. A less likely reading takes it as "that", stating the content of the testimony.
-
ἀλήθεια
alētheia · G0225
truth, reality · v6
In John's writings this means God's real, reliable self-disclosure, set against the lie and deception of the "spirit of error" (4:6). A witness who *is* the truth cannot give false testimony.
-
τρεῖς
treis · G5140
three · v7, v8
Comes first for emphasis: *three* is a legally sufficient number of witnesses. It is masculine, although the three things named in verse 8 (Spirit, water, blood) are neuter nouns in Greek. That suggests John is treating them as personal witnesses standing in court.
-
οὐρανῷ
ouranō · G3772
heaven · v7
Textus Receptus only. It sets up a contrast between a heavenly trio of witnesses and an earthly one. Nothing in the surrounding Greek text of 1 John prepares for that contrast.
-
πατήρ
patēr · G3962
father · v7
Textus Receptus only. The Father as a witness; compare verse 9, where the original text does speak of 'the testimony of God'.
-
λόγος
logos · G3056
word · v7
Textus Receptus only. 'The Word' as a title for the Son, borrowed from John 1:1. Nowhere else in 1 John is the Son called simply 'the Word' with no qualifier.
-
ἅγιον
hagion · G40
holy · v7
Textus Receptus only. Elsewhere 1 John just says 'the Spirit' (as in vv. 6, 8). The full phrase 'Holy Spirit' does not occur anywhere in the letters of John.
-
ἕν
hen · G1520
one · v7, v8
Textus Receptus only. Neuter 'one', as in John 10:30 ('I and the Father are one'). It looks modelled on the original ending of verse 8, 'the three are *eis to hen*' (literally 'into the one', meaning they agree or point to one thing).
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into, toward, for · v8, v10
"Into" or "toward". With "are", it describes the three moving toward a single point, converging on it. They do not merely sit side by side.
-
εἰ
ei · G1487
if · v9
Opens a condition the writer takes as true. It is not 'if, perhaps' but 'if, as we do'. In practice it means 'since'.
-
μαρτυρίαν
martyrian · G3141
testimony, witness · v9, v10, v11
Evidence given by a witness, especially the kind that settles a case. It is the object of 'we receive'.
-
ἀνθρώπων
anthrōpōn · G444
human beings · v9
'Of men' in the generic sense: ordinary human witnesses of either sex. The contrast is human against divine, not male against female.
-
λαμβάνομεν
lambanomen · G2983
take, receive, accept · v9
A present tense for what we normally do. We accept testimony as valid and act on it, as a court, a market or a family does every day.
-
θεοῦ
theou · G2316
God · v9, v10, v11, v12
God is the one giving the testimony. It is God's own sworn evidence, not testimony about God.
-
μείζων
meizōn · G3173
greater · v9
A comparative: greater in weight, authority and reliability. Placed before 'is', it carries the stress of the clause.
-
περὶ
peri · G4012
concerning, about · v9, v10
The subject of the testimony: what the evidence is about.
-
υἱοῦ
huiou · G5207
son · v9, v10, v11, v12
Jesus as God's Son. The whole dispute in the letter is about who Jesus is, so God's evidence concerns his identity.
-
αὐτοῦ
autou · G846
his · v9, v10, v11
'His' Son. A father vouches for his own son. The witness has the closest possible relation to the one he testifies about.
-
πιστεύων
pisteuōn · G4100
believing, trusting · v10
A present participle. It describes someone who goes on believing, a settled stance rather than a single past moment.
-
ἔχει
echei · G2192
has, holds · v10, v12
Present tense: the believer possesses God's testimony now. It has been received and is held, not merely heard.
-
ἑαυτῷ·
heautō · G1438
himself · v10
Reflexive: 'in himself', within his own person. Some manuscripts can be read 'in him' (see variants).
-
μὴ
mē · G3361
not · v10, v12
The normal negative with a participle. It describes the type of person: anyone who does not believe.
-
ψεύστην
pseustēn · G5583
liar · v10
Placed first in its clause for emphasis: 'a LIAR he has made him'. To refuse a witness's sworn statement is to treat the witness as false.
-
πεποίηκεν
pepoiēken · G4160
has made · v10
Perfect tense: the unbeliever has already, in effect, branded God a liar, and that verdict stands. 'Make' here means 'treat as, declare to be', as in 1:10.
-
ἣν
hēn · G3739
which · v10
Relative pronoun linking to 'testimony'.
-
ζωὴν
zōēn · G2222
life · v11, v12
Placed first in its clause for emphasis: it is *life* that God gave. In John's writings this is the life that belongs to God himself and is shared with people, not just biological existence.
-
αἰώνιον
aiōnion · G0166
eternal, of the age · v11
Describes the life as belonging to 'the age', the coming age of God's rule in Jewish expectation. It points to the quality and source of the life (God's own life) as well as to its never ending.
-
ἔδωκεν
edōken · G1325
gave · v11
A past tense that treats the giving as an accomplished act. The life is not only promised for later. God has already handed it over. It is a gift, not wages.
-
ἡμῖν
hēmin · G3165
The world behind it
A divided community. 1 John was written to believers in the Johannine circle (traditionally around Ephesus, late first century) after a split: "They went out from us, but they were not of us" (2:19). The ones who left are called liars and antichrists for denying that "Jesus is the Christ" (2:22) and for refusing to confess "Jesus Christ having come in flesh" (4:2–3). They evidently claimed the Spirit for their teaching, which is why the author says "test the spirits" (4:1).
"Not by water only." The phrase only makes sense if someone was saying "by water only". The best-known ancient parallel is Cerinthus, a teacher of Asia Minor who, according to Irenaeus (Against Heresies 1.26.1, around AD 180), taught that "the Christ" descended on the human Jesus as a dove at his baptism and left him before the crucifixion. On that view Jesus suffered and died, but the Christ, being incapable of suffering, did not. Irenaeus also tells a story of John the apostle fleeing a bathhouse in Ephesus when Cerinthus walked in (3.3.4). Whether 1 John's opponents were Cerinthus's followers or a related group is debated, but the target is clear either way: a Christ who comes at the water but bypasses the blood.
Water, blood and witness in the Johannine tradition. These readers knew the Fourth Gospel's story. At the Jordan the Baptist testifies that he saw the Spirit descend and remain on Jesus (John 1:32–34). At the cross, water and blood flow from Jesus' pierced side, and an eyewitness solemnly vouches for it "so that you also may believe" (John 19:34–35). Water, blood, Spirit and testimony were already bound together in their shared story.
Blood in a Jewish frame. For anyone formed by Israel's Scriptures, blood meant sacrifice and atonement: "the life of the flesh is in the blood... it is the blood that makes atonement" (Lev 17:11). The letter has already said that "the blood of Jesus his Son cleanses us from all sin" (1:7). Removing the blood from the Christ's coming would remove the cleansing.
Witness law. Deuteronomy 19:15 says a matter stands only "on the evidence of two or three witnesses". Verses 7–8 apply it directly: "there are three that testify: the Spirit, the water and the blood; and the three agree."
From the study of 1 John 5:6.
Where scholars differ
in v6
What do "water" and "blood" refer to?
-
Jesus' baptism (water) and his death (blood): the beginning and end of his public mission.
The past-tense "came" points to completed events in Jesus' own life. "Not by water only" fits a rival view that the Christ joined Jesus at his baptism but left before the cross (compare Irenaeus on Cerinthus). In John 1:32–34 the Spirit testifies at the water. The letter elsewhere stresses the blood as Jesus' atoning death (1:7). This is the majority view of modern commentators (e.g. Brown, Smalley, Marshall, Yarbrough).
-
The water and blood that flowed from Jesus' pierced side (John 19:34).
Close verbal link to the Gospel, where the event is backed by solemn eyewitness testimony (19:35), matching this passage's witness language. Many early interpreters, including Augustine, read it this way. Weakness: John 19 is a single moment, while the verse's "not by water only" implies two distinct things that could be separated.
-
Christian baptism and the Lord's Supper.
Verse 8 uses the present tense ("three *testify*"), suggesting continuing witnesses in the community's life. The pairing was read sacramentally by some church fathers and Reformers (Luther among them). Most modern scholars think this may be a secondary echo at most in verse 8, since verse 6's past-tense "came" points to Jesus' own history.
-
Jesus' real human birth (water) and real death (blood): the full reality of the incarnation.
Fits the letter's concern with Jesus "having come in flesh" (4:2) and some readings of "born of water" in John 3:5. Weakness: the opponents seem to have accepted the "water" but rejected the "blood", which suits baptism better than birth.
in v6
Who were the opponents behind "not by water only"?
-
Cerinthus or a group like his, who separated the heavenly Christ from the human Jesus.
Irenaeus (*Against Heresies* 1.26.1) describes exactly such a teaching in Asia Minor, the region traditionally linked to John, and connects Cerinthus to John in Ephesus (3.3.4).
-
Former members of the community who did not deny Jesus' humanity outright but downplayed the saving value of his earthly life and especially his death.
Raymond Brown's reconstruction: the letter's targets read like an internal misreading of the Fourth Gospel's emphasis on Jesus' divine glory, not a fully developed later system.
-
The opponents cannot be precisely identified, and the language may be partly general warning.
The letter never names or describes a system. Some recent commentators warn against reconstructing a detailed heresy from a few negations. Even so, "not by water only" plainly answers a real claim.
in v7
Is the Johannine Comma original to 1 John?
-
No. It began as a Latin interpretive gloss, a symbolic reading of verse 8 as pointing to the Trinity, that slipped into the text and was later translated into Greek. This is the near-universal view of textual scholars of every tradition, Catholic, Protestant and Orthodox.
It is missing from all early Greek manuscripts and all non-Latin versions. Greek fathers never cite it, even in the Trinitarian debates. Its first clear appearance is in 4th-century Latin Spain, and its position and wording differ from one Latin manuscript to another, a typical sign of a gloss. The Greek forms in late manuscripts look like translations of Latin. Its vocabulary ('the Word' standing alone, 'Holy Spirit') is foreign to 1 John (Metzger; R. E. Brown, Anchor Bible appendix).
-
Yes. It is original and was lost from the Greek tradition early, possibly removed or dropped by a scribe's eye skipping. This view is held mainly by defenders of the Textus Receptus.
Cyprian's 'and the three are one' of Father, Son and Spirit (c. 250). The masculine 'three' with neuter nouns in verse 8 is said to read more smoothly if masculine 'Father' and 'Word' come first. The pseudo-Jerome prologue complains that the passage was omitted. Its long use in the Latin church. Critics answer that personification explains the masculine and that Cyprian may be reading verse 8 symbolically.
in v7
Did Cyprian (c. 250) know the Comma?
-
He was reading verse 8 as a symbol, not quoting a longer text.
Later Latin writers such as Facundus (6th c.) explicitly explain Cyprian's words as a Trinitarian reading of the Spirit, water and blood. Cyprian's wording 'Father, Son and Spirit' does not match the Comma's 'Father, Word and Spirit'.
-
He was quoting a form of the Comma in his Latin Bible.
He introduces the words with 'it is written' (*scriptum est*) and applies them directly to the Father, Son and Spirit.
in v7
Did Erasmus promise to include the Comma if a single Greek manuscript containing it were found?
-
The 'promise' is a later legend.
H. J. de Jonge (1980) showed that no such promise appears in Erasmus's writings. He included the words in 1522 to avoid being accused of heresy, while doubting that they were genuine and saying he suspected that the manuscript which had come to light was written to match the Latin.
-
The popular story contains a grain of truth.
In his reply to Edward Lee, Erasmus did say he would have printed the words if he had found them in any Greek manuscript, and he did add them once Codex 61 came to light.
in v7
What do the water and the blood (vv. 6, 8) refer to?
-
Jesus' baptism and his death.
This fits the argument against a Christ who came at the baptism and left before the cross ('not by water only, but by water and blood').
-
The water and blood from his side at the cross (John 19:34–35).
In that passage the Gospel itself stresses the witness of someone who saw it ('he who saw it has borne witness').
-
Baptism and the Lord's Supper as continuing witnesses.
The present tense 'are testifying', and the use of water and blood imagery for these rites in the early church.
in v8
What do "the water" and "the blood" refer to?
-
Jesus' baptism and his death
5:6 says he "came" (past tense) by water and blood, "not by water only". This fits a dispute with teachers like Cerinthus, who accepted the baptism but denied that the Christ suffered (Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.26.1). Held by many modern commentators, including Brown in some respects, Smalley, and Kruse.
-
The water and blood from Jesus' pierced side (John 19:34)
It is the only place in the Johannine writings where water and blood appear together, and it is followed at once by an eyewitness claim ("he who saw has testified", 19:35), which matches the theme of testimony here.
-
The sacraments of baptism and the Lord's Supper
In v. 8 the present tense ("are testifying") suggests ongoing witnesses in the church. Common from Augustine and the medieval interpreters onward, and many modern scholars see at least a secondary echo. Critics note that "blood" alone is an unusual way to name the Eucharist.
-
His real human birth or incarnation
Water and blood go with physical birth, and the opponents denied Christ "come in the flesh" (4:2). This is a minority view with less contextual support.
in v8
Is any part of the Johannine Comma original, and is Cyprian an early witness to it?
-
The Comma is a later Latin addition (the near-consensus of textual scholarship)
It is absent from all early Greek manuscripts, Greek Fathers and non-Latin versions. Its first clear appearance is in late-4th-century Spain, and it enters Greek only in late manuscripts translated from Latin. Cyprian's "of the Father, Son and Holy Spirit it is written, 'and the three are one'" (On the Unity of the Church 6, c. 251) is best explained as a Trinitarian reading of verse 8's Latin "tres unum sunt", much as Augustine later read it.
-
The Comma, or a form of it, is original or very early (a minority view, held mainly by defenders of the Textus Receptus)
Cyprian is taken as quoting it directly. The masculine "the three" with neuter nouns is said to need masculine Father/Word before it. Its long use in the Latin church and the Council of Trent tradition are also cited. Against this: Gregory of Nazianzus defended the masculine grammar in a text without the Comma, and no Greek evidence supports it before the medieval period.
in v9
What does 'this' (hautē) refer to, and how should the second 'hoti' be read?
-
'This' points back to the threefold witness of verse 8 (Spirit, water, blood), and the second ὅτι means 'because': this threefold witness is God's testimony because God is the one who has testified about his Son.
It follows the flow from verses 7–8, where the three witnesses are just named. ὅτι is causal earlier in the same verse. Commentators such as Westcott and Smalley lean in this direction.
-
'This' points forward, and the second ὅτι means 'that', giving the content: 'the testimony of God is this: that he has testified concerning his Son.'
In John's writings, 'this is...' (αὕτη ἐστίν) usually points forward to a following ὅτι or ἵνα clause (e.g. 1 John 1:5; 5:11, 14). The NASB takes it this way, and so does the supplied gloss.
-
'This' anticipates verses 10–11, where the content is finally stated: 'God gave us eternal life, and this life is in his Son.'
Verse 11 repeats 'this is the testimony, that...' with explicit content, suggesting verse 9 introduces a theme completed there. Some (e.g. Brown) discuss this as part of the forward-looking reading.
in v9
What concrete event or reality is 'God's testimony'?
-
The historical events: Jesus' baptism (the Father's voice and the Spirit's descent) and his death ('water and blood', v. 6).
Verse 6 grounds the testimony in Jesus' coming 'by water and blood'. In the Gospel tradition the Father's direct witness at the baptism is 'This is my Son' (Mark 1:11; John 1:32–34).
-
The continuing witness of the Spirit in the community and the believer.
Verse 6: 'the Spirit is the one who testifies, because the Spirit is the truth'. Verse 10: the believer 'has the testimony in himself'. Compare John 15:26.
-
All of these together: God testifies through the historical events and through the Spirit who makes them known.
Verse 8 says the three 'agree' or 'are for the one thing'. The perfect tense views God's testimony as a single completed and standing whole.
in v10
What does it mean that the believer 'has the testimony in himself'?
-
The inner witness of the Spirit: God's testimony is made present inwardly by the Spirit, who is 'the one who testifies' (5:6), giving the believer settled confidence.
1 John 5:6; 3:24 and 4:13 (we know by the Spirit he has given us); compare Rom 8:16. Taken by many commentators.
-
The testimony received and held: the believer has accepted God's objective witness (water, blood, Spirit; content in v. 11), and it now belongs to him. The emphasis is on reception, not on feeling.
The article 'the testimony' points back to v. 9; v. 11 defines the testimony's content; 'have' parallels 'has the Son' and 'has life' in v. 12. Emphasised by e.g. Brown and Yarbrough.
-
The testimony is the eternal life itself, present in the believer as the proof of God's word.
Verse 11 identifies the testimony with God's gift of eternal life; 3:14 and 3:15 speak of life 'abiding in' the believer. These views are often combined.
in v11
Is the 'testimony' a statement about the Son, or the experienced reality of life itself?
-
Content of a message: v.11 states what God's testimony *says*, namely that he has given life in his Son, and believers accept it as true.
The 'that' clause reads most naturally as the content of a statement. Verse 10 speaks of believing or not believing the testimony, and v.13 of 'writing' it so readers may know (e.g. Marshall, Yarbrough).
-
Experienced reality: the testimony is the life itself, which works as God's evidence inside the believer.
Verse 10 says the believer 'has the testimony within himself'. The gift of life given and possessed is then the inner proof (Westcott; Brown discusses this inward sense).
-
Both together: God's testimony is a statement whose truth the believer finds confirmed in the life received.
Verses 10–12 move back and forth between believing the testimony and having the life. Many commentators (e.g. Smalley) refuse to separate the two.
in v11
When did God 'give' the life: in the Son's historical coming, or at each believer's coming to faith?
-
Historical: the past tense points to God's decisive act in sending the Son, through his life, death and the giving of the Spirit.
1:2 'the life was revealed'. 4:9 'God sent his only Son… so that we might live through him'. 5:6 'came by water and blood'.
-
Personal: it points to the moment believers received the life by believing.
John 5:24 'has passed from death to life'. 1 John 3:14 'we have passed from death to life'. 5:12 'whoever has the Son has life'.
in v12
What exactly does "having the Son" mean?
-
It is essentially believing or confessing: accepting God's testimony about Jesus.
The surrounding verses define the issue as believing God's testimony (v. 10) and believing "in the name of the Son of God" (v. 13). 1 John 2:23 pairs "confesses the Son" with "has the Father".
-
It is a relationship of union or indwelling, the Johannine "abiding" (remaining in) the Son.
2 John 9 links "having" the Father and Son with abiding in the teaching. 1 John 2:24 and 3:24 speak of remaining in the Son and in God. The life is said to be *in* the Son (v. 11), so having it means being joined to him.
-
Both together. Most commentators (e.g., Brown, Smalley, Yarbrough) see confession and union as two sides of the same relationship.
In John's letters, right confession, abiding and love are constantly interwoven (3:23–24; 4:15). The letter does not treat belief as separable from belonging.
in v12
Is the negative half aimed at the departed group specifically, or is it a general statement?
-
Primarily aimed at the secessionists (the group that split off) who denied Jesus as the Christ come in the flesh.
The letter's polemic (2:19, 22–23; 4:1–3) and the added emphasis on "the Son *of God*" suggest a specific target who claimed God while rejecting the Son as confessed.
-
A general principle, applied in this situation.
The form "the one who…" is a general description, and it echoes the universal statement of John 3:36 written in a different setting.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἔρχομαι, ὕδωρ, αἷμα, μαρτυρέω, πνεῦμα, ἀλήθεια
- Raymond E. Brown, The Epistles of John (Anchor Bible 30, 1982)
- Stephen S. Smalley, 1, 2, 3 John (Word Biblical Commentary 51)
- I. Howard Marshall, The Epistles of John (NICNT)
- Robert W. Yarbrough, 1–3 John (BECNT)
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on 1 John 5:6–8
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.26.1; 3.3.4
- Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule (1QS) 3–4 on the spirits of truth and deceit
- Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at 1 John 5:7–8
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on 1 John 5:7–8
- R. E. Brown, The Epistles of John (Anchor Bible 30), Appendix IV: The Johannine Comma
- S. S. Smalley, 1, 2, 3 John (Word Biblical Commentary 51)
- BDAG s.v. μαρτυρέω, μαρτυρία
- Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 31.19
- Cyprian, De unitate ecclesiae 6
- Priscillian, Liber apologeticus 1.4
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.26.1
- H. J. de Jonge, 'Erasmus and the Comma Johanneum', Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses 56 (1980)
- G. McDonald, Biblical Criticism in Early Modern Europe: Erasmus, the Johannine Comma and Trinitarian Debate (2016)
- D. B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics, on personification and gender agreement
- NA28 / UBS5 Greek New Testament; Editio Critica Maior, Catholic Letters
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on 1 John 5:7–8
- BDAG s.v. εἰς (εἶναι εἰς), εἷς, μαρτυρέω, πνεῦμα
- Raymond E. Brown, The Epistles of John (Anchor Bible 30), including appendix on the Johannine Comma
- Colin G. Kruse, The Letters of John (Pillar)
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.26.1 (on Cerinthus)
- Gregory of Nazianzus, Oration 31 (Fifth Theological Oration) 19
- Cyprian, On the Unity of the Church 6
- Augustine, Against Maximinus 2.22.3
- H. J. de Jonge, "Erasmus and the Comma Johanneum", Ephemerides Theologicae Lovanienses 56 (1980)
- Grantley McDonald, Biblical Criticism in Early Modern Europe: Erasmus, the Johannine Comma and Trinitarian Debate (2016)
- Deuteronomy 17:6; 19:15; John 8:17; John 19:34–35
- Dead Sea Scrolls, Community Rule (1QS) 3–4
- BDAG s.v. μαρτυρία, μαρτυρέω, λαμβάνω, μέγας
- Robert W. Yarbrough, 1–3 John (Baker Exegetical Commentary)
- B. F. Westcott, The Epistles of St. John
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (on 1 John 5:7–9)
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 1.26.1 (Cerinthus)
- Deuteronomy 17:6; 19:15; John 3:11, 32–33; 5:31–37; 8:17–18
- Nestle-Aland 28th edition apparatus
- BDAG s.v. πιστεύω
- BDAG s.v. μαρτυρία, μαρτυρέω
- BDAG s.v. ψεύστης
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on 1 John 5:7–10
- Raymond E. Brown, The Epistles of John (Anchor Bible 30)
- Colin G. Kruse, The Letters of John (Pillar NT Commentary)
- BDAG s.v. μαρτυρία, ζωή, αἰώνιος, δίδωμι
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ζωή, αἰώνιος
- R. C. Trench, Synonyms of the New Testament (ζωή vs. βίος)
- B. F. Westcott, The Epistles of St John
- C. H. Dodd, The Interpretation of the Fourth Gospel (on 'eternal life')
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
- Septuagint: Daniel 12:2; 2 Maccabees 7:9; Psalms of Solomon 3:12
- Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QS (Community Rule) 4:7
- Vulgate, 1 John 5:11
- BDAG s.v. ἔχω (relational sense: to have someone as a close associate)
- BDAG s.v. ζωή
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ζωή
- Robert W. Yarbrough, 1–3 John (Baker Exegetical Commentary on the NT)
- Septuagint: Daniel 12:2; Deuteronomy 30:15–19; Psalm 2:7
- Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QS IV 7; 4Q246
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).