Daniel Chapter 11 Read as one passage

Daniel 11:10–16

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10But his sons will stir up strife and assemble a great army, which will advance forcefully, sweeping through like a flood, and will again carry the battle as far as his fortress. 11In a rage, the king of the South will march out to fight the king of the North, who will raise a large army, but it will be delivered into the hand of his enemy. 12When the army is carried off, the king of the South will be proud in heart and will cast down tens of thousands, but he will not triumph. 13For the king of the North will raise another army, larger than the first, and after some years he will advance with a great army and many supplies. 14In those times many will rise up against the king of the South. Violent ones among your own people will exalt themselves in fulfillment of the vision, but they will fail. 15Then the king of the North will come, build up a siege ramp, and capture a fortified city. The forces of the South will not stand; even their best troops will not be able to resist. 16The invader will do as he pleases, and no one will stand against him. He will establish himself in the Beautiful Land, with destruction in his hand.

What the first hearers heard

Within the book, this is part of the revelation given to Daniel "in the third year of Cyrus" (10:1). Daniel 11 is presented as a sealed outline of future history. The kings are deliberately left unnamed, as in a coded chronicle that the reader is meant to decode.

For the readers the book was finally addressed to, Jews living under Seleucid rule in the 2nd century BC, verse 10 described events they or their grandparents knew: Antiochus III's armies sweeping down the coast and through the land. Several things stood out to them:

  • The great powers' wars follow a script. Advance, retreat, renewed advance, sudden reversal (v. 11). The confident language of 'surely coming' and 'flooding' is followed at once by defeat. The chapter shows imperial power as something that swings back and forth, not as something in control of history.
  • The flood language placed these kings among Israel's historic oppressors. Isaiah had used 'flood and pass through' for Assyria. Using the same words for the Seleucid king marked him as one more empire whose flood God had already set limits on.
  • Fortresses fail. The chapter keeps returning to māʿôz, 'stronghold'. Kings press on to each other's fortresses and trust their own (later even a 'god of fortresses', 11:38). In Israel's songs, the people's true māʿôz was the LORD (Ps 27:1; 37:39). The chapter shows step by step that military strongholds are not that.
  • It builds toward the crisis. Each round of 'North against South' moves the story closer to Antiochus IV and the desecration of the temple (11:31). Readers in that crisis could see that their suffering was the last part of a sequence already foretold, and that it would end (11:35, 45; 12:1–3).

From the study of Daniel 11:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10But his sons will stir up strife and assemble a great army, which will advance forcefully, sweeping through like a flood, and will again carry the battle as far as his fortress.

    "And his sons will throw themselves into war and muster a roaring throng of many armies. And one of them will come, and keep on coming, like a river in flood that sweeps over the land and passes right through it. Then he will turn back and take up the war again, pressing it all the way to the enemy's stronghold."

    The verse continues the story of the "king of the North" from verse 9. His sons do not merely become upset. They take up hostilities: the Hebrew verb means deliberately starting a war. The army they gather is a hămôn, a noisy, swarming crowd of forces. The sentence then changes from "they" to "he". Of the brothers, one carries the campaign. The doubled verb ("coming, he will come") makes his advance sound certain and relentless. "Flood and pass through" is Isaiah's wording for the Assyrian invasion (Isa 8:8), so the invader is pictured as a torrent pouring over the countryside. The movement has two stages: he pulls back, then "again" makes war, and this time the campaign reaches the enemy's fortress, the stronghold the other side relies on for safety. The next verse turns this round: the enraged king of the South comes out, and the great army is handed over to him (v. 11).

    Full study →
  2. 11In a rage, the king of the South will march out to fight the king of the North, who will raise a large army, but it will be delivered into the hand of his enemy.

    Stung into fury by the invasion, the king of the South will work himself into a bitter rage. He will take the field in person and fight it out with the king of the North. The northern king will field a huge, roaring army. But that whole army will be handed over into the southern king's power.

    The verse moves from emotion to action. The first verb comes from the Hebrew word for bitter and pictures a king stirring himself up into fury. Daniel uses the same rare form for the goat's rage against the ram in 8:7. "Go out" and "fight with" are the ordinary words for a king marching to a pitched battle. The army word, hamon, means a noisy throng, a host whose sheer mass you could hear. It appears twice on purpose: a great host is raised, and that host is given away. The final phrase, "given into his hand", is the standard Hebrew way of saying "delivered to defeat". No giver is named, which fits the book's belief that God decides who wins (Dan 2:21). Daniel's readers would have recognised the Battle of Raphia (217 BC). There Ptolemy IV of Egypt, roused at last, routed the large army of Antiochus III of Syria. Verse 12 then adds the sting: the victor's heart swells, and his victory comes to nothing.

    Full study →
  3. 12When the army is carried off, the king of the South will be proud in heart and will cast down tens of thousands, but he will not triumph.

    The great horde that the northern king had massed, the army handed over to his rival in the previous verse, is swept away: killed, captured, carried off the field. And as that army is "lifted" away, the southern king's own heart is lifted high. In Hebrew that is not cheerfulness. It is the stock phrase for a man who now thinks himself bigger than his limits, the same phrase Moses used to warn Israel's kings and that Daniel used of Nebuchadnezzar. Riding that pride, he strikes down tens of thousands, a slaughter counted in "myriads." And yet he will not become strong. He wins the battle but gains no lasting strength or control from it. He does not press his advantage, and his great day comes to nothing. The very next verse shows the northern king back with an even larger army.

    Read in sequence, the verse moves like this: enemy carried off, heart carried up, enemies cast down, but no real strength. A victory full of noise and blood leaves the winner no stronger than before. In the world of Daniel 11, kings rise in arrogance and fail, and only God's set time decides the outcome.

    Full study →
  4. 13For the king of the North will raise another army, larger than the first, and after some years he will advance with a great army and many supplies.

    "And the king of the North will come back, and he will again muster a roaring horde, greater than the first one. When the stretch of time has run out (a matter of years), he will come, and come on relentlessly, with a great army and a vast baggage train of goods and supplies."

    The verse answers the defeat in vv. 11–12. The southern king beat the northern army there, but he "will not prevail" (v. 12). The northern king did not stay beaten. He went home, and then he stood up a new host (hamon, a word that suggests noise and mass as well as numbers) larger than the one he lost. Then comes a gap: "at the end of the times, years". This is ordinary language for "after a number of years", the same expression used in 11:6. It does not jump forward to the end of the world. Hebrew repeats the verb "come" (yavo vo) to make the advance emphatic and certain. The last pair of phrases sets manpower (chayil, army) beside material strength (rekhush, movable goods: supplies, equipment, and the wealth that pays for them). The king returns stronger in men and in resources.

    Full study →
  5. 14In those times many will rise up against the king of the South. Violent ones among your own people will exalt themselves in fulfillment of the vision, but they will fail.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  6. 15Then the king of the North will come, build up a siege ramp, and capture a fortified city. The forces of the South will not stand; even their best troops will not be able to resist.

    Then the king of the North will march in. He will heap up a siege ramp, basket after basket of earth poured against the walls, and take a fortress-city, a place built to be untakeable. The armed might of the South, its strong arm, will not hold its ground. Even the king's hand-picked elite will have no strength left to stand.

    The verse reads like a dispatch from the front. It is a quick string of linked verbs: he comes, he heaps up, he takes. Then comes a double denial that Egypt can resist: first its forces in general, then its very best. The word "stand" frames the collapse. The South "will not stand" and has "no strength to stand." In the next verse the conqueror himself "stands" in the Beautiful Land, Judea. For readers in Judea, the point was that one siege of one great stronghold ended Egypt's century of rule over them and handed their land to the king of the North.

    Full study →
  7. 16The invader will do as he pleases, and no one will stand against him. He will establish himself in the Beautiful Land, with destruction in his hand.

    The king who has come down from the North against the king of the South now does exactly as he likes. Daniel uses this phrase for every overbearing ruler in the book, and each of them is later brought down. No one can hold his ground against him. Having swept every rival off the field, he plants himself in the Beautiful Land. That is Daniel's name for Judea, the jewel among lands that God gave to Israel. And the land is now in his grip. In the traditional Hebrew vowels, destruction, a full end, is in his hand: he has the power to ruin it, and the war that brought him there had already left it battered. The same letters can also be read all of it is in his hand: the whole land is now his to dispose of.

    The verse turns on the word stand. The southern armies could not stand (v. 15). No one stands before this king. So he stands in God's land. In the very next verse his own plans 'will not stand'. Even at the height of his power, the hearer is meant to sense that standing and falling are not finally his to decide.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    shall be stirred up (KJV)

    yiṯgārū / hitgārâ

    What we hear
    The sons became agitated, upset or emotionally provoked.
    What they heard
    They stirred themselves up against an enemy, that is, they deliberately opened hostilities and went to war.
  • in v10

    overflow (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    šāṭap̄

    What we hear
    Spilling over the edge, like a full cup or a river slightly over its banks.
    What they heard
    A torrent sweeping over and washing away a land. It was a standard prophetic image for a devastating invasion (Isa 8:7–8).
  • in v11

    moved with choler (KJV)

    yitmarmar

    What we hear
    An obscure word. Some readers confuse it with the disease cholera, or with 'collar'.
    What they heard
    Became bitterly enraged, worked himself into fury.
  • in v11

    multitude (KJV, WEB)

    hamon

    What we hear
    A large crowd of people, possibly civilians.
    What they heard
    A roaring host. Here it means an army in battle array.
  • in v12

    his heart shall be lifted up (KJV, ESV, NASB)

    ram levavo

    What we hear
    Feeling uplifted, encouraged or elated: the language of joy or of being 'lifted up' in spirit.
    What they heard
    Arrogance: an inflated sense of oneself, one's mind and will set above proper limits. In Hebrew it is always a warning, and it usually comes before a fall.
  • in v13

    at the end of the times (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    lekets ha'ittim shanim

    What we hear
    "The end times": the last days before the world ends.
    What they heard
    "When the periods, that is, years, had run their course": a gap of several years inside the history being told. 11:6 uses the same idiom ('ulekets shanim', 'after some years').
  • in v13

    riches (KJV)

    rekhush

    What we hear
    Treasure, money, luxury.
    What they heard
    Movable goods. On a campaign that means the baggage train, provisions and equipment, along with the wealth that pays for them.
  • in v15

    his chosen people (KJV)

    ʿam mivcharav

    What we hear
    Israel, God's chosen people
    What they heard
    The king of the South's elite troops, his picked soldiers
  • in v15

    the most fenced cities (KJV)

    ʿir mivtsarot

    What we hear
    Several cities with fences round them
    What they heard
    A single heavily walled fortress-city
  • in v15

    the arms of the south (KJV)

    zeroʿot hanegev

    What we hear
    The South's weapons
    What they heard
    The South's military forces, its 'strong arm'
  • in v15

    cast up a mount (KJV)

    shaphakh solelah

    What we hear
    Climbing or raising a mountain, or mounting a horse
    What they heard
    Building an earthen siege ramp against a city wall
  • in v16

    the glorious land / the Beautiful Land

    erets ha-tsevi

    What we hear
    A general compliment ('a glorious land'), or even a picture of heaven or a future paradise.
    What they heard
    A fixed name for Judea, the land of Israel: 'the land of the Jewel', God's prized land (Jer 3:19; Ezek 20:6; Dan 8:9; 11:41). Readers knew at once that the conqueror was now in their own homeland, around Jerusalem and its temple.
Every word
  1. וּבָנָיו

    ūḇānāw · H1121A

    and his sons · v10

    The sons of the 'king of the North' from v. 9. 'His' refers back to that king. The written consonants can be read as singular ('his son'), and the verse does move from 'they' to 'he' a few words later.

  2. יִתְגָּרוּ

    yiṯgārū · H1624

    they will engage in strife · v10

    This verb form means 'to stir oneself up against someone', that is, to start hostilities or go to war (compare Deut 2:5, 9). It describes taking military action, not just feeling agitated.

  3. וְאָסְפוּ

    wəʾāsəp̄ū · H0622

    and they will gather · v10

    To gather or muster. Here it means calling up and assembling troops.

  4. הֲמוֹן

    hămôn · H1995A

    throng, roar, multitude · v10, v11, v12, v13

    The word comes from a root meaning 'to roar' or 'make a din'. It suggests a noisy, swarming mass of people, not just a large number.

  5. חֲיָלִים

    ḥăyālîm · H2428A

    forces, armies · v10, v13

    Ḥayil covers strength, wealth and armed force. In the plural it means military forces, probably the separate contingents of a large Hellenistic army.

  6. רַבִּים

    rabbîm · H7227A

    many, great · v10, v11, v13

    Describes the forces as numerous. The phrase as a whole means 'a roaring throng of many forces'.

  7. וּבָא

    ūḇāʾ · H0935G

    and he will come · v10, v13, v15, v16

    The verb suddenly becomes singular: one leader now acts. 'Come' here also carries the military sense of 'invade'.

  8. וְשָׁטַף

    wəšāṭap̄ · H7857

    and he will flood, sweep away · v10

    The picture is of a flash flood or river in spate sweeping over the land. It is a stock image for an invading army (Isa 8:7–8).

  9. וְעָבָר

    wəʿāḇār · H5674A

    and he will pass through · v10

    The invader crosses over and through the territory. Paired with 'flood', it repeats the exact wording Isaiah used of the Assyrian army ('it will flood and pass through', Isa 8:8).

  10. וְיָשֹׁב

    wəyāšōḇ · H7725J

    and he will return / again · v10, v13

    Either 'he will turn back' (withdraw, then come again) or, as a helper verb with the next word, 'he will again wage war'. Both readings describe a second campaign.

  11. עַד־

    ʿaḏ- · H5704

    as far as, up to · v10

    Marks how far the campaign reaches: right up to the enemy's fortress.

  12. מָעֻזּוֹ

    māʿuzzô · H4581

    his stronghold · v10

    A fortified place of safety. 'His' most likely means the king of the South's frontier fortress, though the pronoun is ambiguous (see debates).

  13. וְיִתְמַרְמַר֙

    ve-yitmarmar · H4843

    and he will be embittered / enraged · v11

    From the root for 'bitter'; the doubled, reflexive form pictures someone working himself up into bitter fury. It opens the verse with the southern king's emotional reaction to the northern invasion just described in v. 10.

  14. מֶ֣לֶךְ

    melekh · H4428

    king of · v11, v13, v15

    The subject of the first verb, linked to 'the South': the reigning king of that realm.

  15. הַנֶּ֔גֶב

    ha-negev · H5045

    the South · v11, v15

    Literally the dry southern land below Judah, used here as a fixed title for the power to Judea's south, the Ptolemaic kingdom based in Egypt.

  16. וְיָצָ֕א

    ve-yatsa · H3318

    and he will go out · v11

    Standard language for a king 'going out' to war; it marks the shift from reacting to taking the field himself.

  17. וְנִלְחַ֥ם

    ve-nilcham · H3898

    and he will fight · v11

    Ordinary verb for doing battle; it means a pitched battle, not a skirmish or a war of words.

  18. עִמּ֖וֹ

    immo · H5973

    with him · v11

    'Fight with' in Hebrew means fight against. The pronoun points ahead to the king of the North, who is then named.

  19. הַצָּפ֑וֹן

    ha-tsafon · H6828

    the North · v11, v13, v15

    The power to Judea's north, the Seleucid kingdom ruling from Syria. Armies from Mesopotamia and Syria came into Israel from the north, so 'North' had a long history as the direction invasion came from.

  20. וְהֶעֱמִיד֙

    ve-he'emid · H5975

    and he will cause to stand / raise up · v11, v13, v15, v16

    'Make stand' here means to field, muster or deploy a force. The Hebrew does not name the subject. Most take it to be the king of the North just mentioned; some take it to be the southern king (see debates).

  21. וְנִתַּ֥ן

    ve-nittan · H5414

    and it will be given · v11

    A passive form: the host 'will be given'. The giver is not named, which leaves room for the book's conviction that God is the one who hands kings victory and defeat (Dan 1:2; 2:21).

  22. בְּיָדֽוֹ׃

    be-yado · H3027

    into his hand · v11, v16

    'Given into someone's hand' is the stock Hebrew phrase for being delivered to defeat by an enemy. 'His' most naturally means the king of the South.

  23. וְנִשָּׂ֥א

    venissa · H5375

    lift, carry; (passive) be carried off · v12

    Passive form ('will be lifted / carried away'). The enemy army of v. 11, already handed over to the southern king, is swept off the field: killed, captured or routed. The verb's basic picture of 'lifting' sets up a quiet echo with the 'lifted-up' heart that comes next.

  24. וְרָ֣ם

    veram · H7311

    be high, be exalted · v12

    'And (it) is high': the victor's inner state rises as his enemy's army is carried off. Paired with 'heart', this is the standard Hebrew phrase for arrogance, not for happiness.

  25. לְבָב֑וֹ

    levavo · H3824

    heart (mind, will, inner self) · v12

    'His heart.' In Hebrew this is the center of thought, intention and self-assessment, not mainly the feelings. A 'high heart' is a self that has grown too big in its own estimation.

  26. וְהִפִּ֛יל

    vehippil · H5307

    cause to fall, cast down, strike down · v12

    Causative form of 'fall': he makes men fall, meaning he kills them in battle. A common way of describing slaughter in war.

  27. רִבֹּא֖וֹת

    ribbo'ot · H7239

    ten thousands, myriads · v12

    Plural of 'ten thousand', so 'myriads': a very large death toll. Late Hebrew word (also in Ezra, Nehemiah, Chronicles, Jonah). The plural states the size broadly; it does not have to be an exact count.

  28. וְלֹ֥א

    velo · H3808

    and not · v12, v15

    The turn of the verse: 'yet not'. After the run of victory verbs it brings everything to a sudden halt.

  29. יָעֽוֹז׃

    ya'oz · H5810

    be strong, prevail, hold firm · v12

    'He will not be/become strong.' Winning the battle does not become lasting strength or control. The victory produces no lasting advantage.

  30. מִן־

    min- · H4480

    from; more than · v13

    Hebrew forms comparisons with this word: 'great from X' means 'greater than X'.

  31. הָרִאשׁ֑וֹן

    harishon · H7223

    first, former · v13

    The earlier army that was lost in vv. 11–12. The new force will outdo it.

  32. וּלְקֵ֨ץ

    ulekets · H7093

    end · v13

    'And at the end of', meaning when a stretch of time has run out. The same phrase is used in 11:6 ('after some years'). Here it marks ordinary time passing, not the final 'end' of 11:35, 40 and 12:4.

  33. הָֽעִתִּ֤ים

    ha'ittim · H6256

    time, period, season · v13

    'The times', a span of periods. The next word pins it down as years.

  34. שָׁנִים֙

    shanim · H8141

    years · v13

    Added after 'the times' to explain them: 'the times, that is, years'. This makes the span plainly a matter of years, a number of them.

  35. גָּד֖וֹל

    gadol · H1419

    great, large · v13

    Describes the army as great.

  36. וּבִרְכ֥וּשׁ

    uvirkhush · H7399

    goods, property, possessions · v13

    'And with goods': movable property. For an army on the march this means its baggage, supplies and gear, and the money and resources behind them.

  37. וְיִשְׁפֹּךְ֙

    veyishpokh · H8210I

    and he will pour out / heap up · v15

    The verb usually means 'pour out' a liquid. Paired with 'siege mound' it is the standard Hebrew way of saying 'build a siege ramp', because the earth was carried in baskets and dumped in a heap against the wall.

  38. סֽוֹלֲלָ֔ה

    solelah · H5550

    siege mound, ramp · v15

    An earthen ramp piled against a city wall so that battering rams and troops could reach the top. Ancient readers knew this as a sign of a serious, drawn-out siege.

  39. וְלָכַ֖ד

    velakhad · H3920

    and he will capture · v15

    Means 'seize' or 'take' a city, like a trap closing. The verb form continues the chain of future events: come, build, take.

  40. עִ֣יר

    ʿir · H5892B

    city of · v15

    Singular, 'a city'. One particular stronghold is meant, not cities in general.

  41. מִבְצָר֑וֹת

    mivtsarot · H4013

    fortifications · v15

    Plural: 'a city of fortifications'. Hebrew uses this phrasing to say the city was heavily fortified, a fortress-city, the hardest kind of place to take.

  42. וּזְרֹע֤וֹת

    uzeroʿot · H2220

    and arms of · v15

    'Arms' in the sense of the body part, standing for strength. Here it means the South's military forces. Daniel 11 uses the image several times (vv.6, 22, 31).

  43. וְעַם֙

    veʿam · H5971K

    and people of · v15

    In a military setting ʿam means fighting men, troops, not 'a people' in the ethnic or covenant sense.

  44. מִבְחָרָ֔יו

    mivcharav · H4005

    his choicest · v15

    'His choice ones', the elite or picked troops of the king of the South. Put together, 'the people of his choicest' means his crack soldiers. It does not mean a religiously 'chosen people'.

  45. וְאֵ֥ין

    veʾein · H0369

    and there is not · v15, v16

    'There is no…' This builds on the earlier 'not': not even the elite will manage.

  46. כֹּ֖חַ

    koach · H3581B

    strength · v15

    Power or capacity. The South's best troops simply do not have it.

  47. וְיַ֨עַשׂ

    ve-ya'as · H6213A

    and he will do · v16

    Opens the verse with the action itself: he will act. Together with 'according to his pleasure' it makes the fixed phrase 'do as he likes', meaning unchecked power.

  48. אֵלָיו֙

    elav · H0413

    to/against him · v16

    'Against him', meaning the king of the South. The usual sense of this preposition is 'toward'. With a verb of coming in a military context it means 'against'.

  49. כִּרְצוֹנ֔וֹ

    kirtsono · H7522

    according to his pleasure/will · v16

    'As he pleases.' Daniel uses this exact phrase for each overpowering ruler: the Persian ram (8:4), Alexander (11:3) and the arrogant king (11:36). It marks the kind of power the book expects God to bring down.

  50. לְפָנָ֑יו

    lefanav · H6440G

    before him · v16

    'Before his face': confronting him directly. 'None standing before him' means no one can resist him.

  51. בְּאֶֽרֶץ־

    be-erets · H0776G

    in the land of · v16

    'In the land of', joined to the next word to form a name.

  52. הַצְּבִ֖י

    ha-tsevi · H6643A

    the beauty/splendor · v16

    'The Beauty' or 'the Jewel'. 'Land of the Beauty' is Daniel's name for Judea, the land of Israel (8:9; 11:41; compare 11:45). Readers would hear 'our land' at once.

  53. וְכָלָ֥ה

    ve-khalah · H3617

    and complete destruction · v16

    As the Masoretes vowelled it, 'annihilation, a full end'. The same word appears in Daniel 9:27. The consonants could also be read 'and all of it', which would mean the whole land falls into his hand. See textual notes.

The world behind it

Daniel 11 tells the history of the wars between the Ptolemies of Egypt ("king of the South") and the Seleucids of Syria-Mesopotamia ("king of the North") without naming anyone. These were two of the kingdoms that formed after Alexander the Great's empire split up (11:3–4). Judea lay on the land route between them, and both sides kept marching through it.

Ancient readers matched the details to known history from very early on. Jerome's Commentary on Daniel (c. AD 407) draws on the pagan critic Porphyry and on historians. Modern commentators (Montgomery, Collins, Goldingay) generally agree on these identifications:

  • v. 9: Seleucus II Callinicus attacks Ptolemaic territory and retreats (c. 242 BC).
  • "His sons" (v. 10): Seleucus III Ceraunus (reigned 226–223 BC), who was assassinated during a campaign in Asia Minor, and Antiochus III "the Great" (223–187 BC). Because Seleucus III died early, the action passes to Antiochus alone, which fits the verse's switch from "they" to "he".
  • "Come… flood… pass through": Antiochus's Fourth Syrian War. In 219 BC he took back Seleucia Pieria, the Seleucid port held by the Ptolemies, then pushed south through Phoenicia and Palestine and took Tyre and Ptolemais (Acco). Polybius, Histories book 5, describes this in detail.
  • "Turn back and again wage war": a winter truce in 219/218 BC, then a renewed campaign in 218 and another advance in 217 BC to the Ptolemaic frontier near Gaza and Raphia.
  • v. 11: Ptolemy IV Philopator meets him at Raphia (217 BC) and crushes his army, so that "the multitude will be given into his hand".

For Judeans this was not distant news. "Flooding and passing through" the coastal plain and the hill country meant armies requisitioning food, quartering troops and changing overlords. After Antiochus III's later victory at Panium (c. 200 BC, vv. 15–16), Judea moved from Ptolemaic to Seleucid control. That set the stage for the crisis under his son Antiochus IV (vv. 21–35).

From the study of Daniel 11:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

Whose 'fortress' is meant at the end of the verse?

  • The king of the South's frontier stronghold, probably Gaza or Raphia, where the campaign of 218–217 BC came to a head.

    This fits the campaigns Polybius describes (Histories 5) and the battle of Raphia in v. 11. Montgomery, Collins and most modern commentators take this view, and NLT makes it explicit ('the enemy's fortress').

  • The Ptolemaic heartland more broadly, i.e. Egypt's defences (such as Pelusium), taken loosely as 'his' (the South's) refuge.

    In 11:7 and 11:19 'fortress' refers to a king's home stronghold. However, Antiochus did not break into Egypt in this war, so the reading is less precise.

  • 'His' refers to the northern king himself: he fights to protect or recover his own stronghold (e.g. Seleucia Pieria, retaken in 219 BC).

    The pronoun is grammatically open, and recovering Seleucia was the first act of the war. But the movement of the verse ('as far as') suggests an advance toward the enemy, so this is a minority view.

in v10

When was Daniel 11 written, and so how did its first readers hear it?

  • Predictive prophecy given to Daniel in the Persian period (6th century BC), as the book presents itself (10:1).

    The book's own setting, and traditional Jewish and Christian readings that treat the detailed match with history as fulfilled prediction.

  • Composed c. 167–164 BC during the persecution by Antiochus IV, retelling past history as prophecy in order to give hope for the coming end.

    Porphyry argued this already in the 3rd century AD (as reported by Jerome). Modern critical scholars such as Collins point to how precise vv. 2–39 are and how much less accurately 11:40–45 fits Antiochus IV's actual death. Either way, all sides agree that v. 10 refers to Antiochus III.

in v11

Who 'raises up a great host', and into whose hand is it given?

  • The king of the North raises the host, and it is given into the hand of the king of the South (BSB, NIV, most commentators).

    The nearest named person is 'the king of the North'. The phrase 'given into his hand' is the standard idiom for defeat. This matches Raphia, where Antiochus III's large army was routed by Ptolemy IV.

  • The king of the South raises the host, and it is placed under his own control (a minority reading, noted by some older and some critical commentators).

    The king of the South is the subject of the earlier verbs, so the subject could carry on. Ptolemy IV did famously raise a vast new army, including the native Egyptian phalanx, before Raphia. In this reading, 'given into his hand' would mean 'put at his disposal'. However, v. 12 ('when the host is carried off, his heart will be lifted up') fits better if the host belongs to the defeated North.

in v11

Is Daniel 11 a prediction written in the 6th century BC, or history written in prophetic form in the 2nd century BC?

  • It was written in the 160s BC, during the persecution under Antiochus IV, and recounts past events in the form of prophecy (the majority of critical scholars).

    The survey is precise up to the events of about 167–165 BC and then becomes general or does not match known history (11:40–45). The Hebrew and Greek loanwords and the place of Daniel in the Jewish canon point to a late date. The genre of 'history told as prophecy' is known from other ancient Near Eastern and Jewish texts.

  • It is genuine prediction given to Daniel in the Persian period (traditional Jewish and Christian view).

    The book presents itself as revelation to Daniel (10:1). Supporters point to Daniel fragments at Qumran (the Dead Sea Scrolls) and the book's early acceptance, and argue that its detailed accuracy reflects God's foreknowledge. Josephus (Antiquities 11.337) reports the book being shown to Alexander.

in v12

Was Daniel 11 written before or after these events?

  • Written in the 2nd century BC (about 165 BC), describing past events in the form of prophecy.

    The chapter's detail is very precise up to the reign of Antiochus IV, and then 11:40–45 does not match what is known of his death. This is the majority critical view, going back to the 3rd-century critic Porphyry (as reported by Jerome).

  • Genuine prediction given in the Persian period (10:1, 'third year of Cyrus').

    The book presents itself this way. Traditional Jewish and Christian interpreters, and many conservative scholars, regard the detailed fulfilment as intended evidence of divine foreknowledge.

in v12

Who is the subject of the first clause: is the army passively 'carried off', or does the king actively 'take' it?

  • Passive: 'the multitude will be carried off' (Masoretic Text).

    The Masoretic vowels give a Niphal (passive) form. It makes good sense after v. 11 ('the multitude will be given into his hand'), and most modern translations follow it.

  • Active: 'he will take / carry off the multitude.'

    Theodotion's Greek and the Vulgate translate it actively, and so does KJV. The consonants allow an active vowelling. The historical event is the same either way.

in v13

When was this detailed history written?

  • Predictive prophecy given in the 6th century BC, foretelling Hellenistic history centuries ahead.

    The book is set in the Babylonian and Persian periods. Traditional Jewish and Christian interpretation reads chs. 10–12 as revelation to Daniel. Jesus refers to 'Daniel the prophet' (Matt 24:15).

  • Written in Judea around 167–164 BC, presenting known history as prophecy up to the time of Antiochus IV.

    Porphyry (3rd century AD) and most modern critical scholars note that ch. 11 is precise up to the 160s BC but does not match Antiochus IV's actual death (11:40–45). They also point to the late Hebrew style.

in v13

How literal is 'the times, years'?

  • An ordinary time phrase: 'after some years'.

    It matches 11:6 *lekets shanim*. The explanation 'years' is added. Historically about fourteen years separate Raphia (217 BC) from the next invasion (c. 202 BC).

  • A deliberate echo of Daniel's 'appointed times' language.

    Daniel elsewhere stresses fixed periods (*mo'ed*, 11:27, 29, 35). On this view the wording hints that even this gap was set in advance. It does not make the verse refer to the end of the world.

in v15

Which fortified city is meant?

  • Sidon, besieged by Antiochus III after the battle of Panium (c. 200–199 BC)

    Jerome's Commentary on Daniel says this explicitly: Scopas was shut up in Sidon, the relief commanders failed, and he surrendered from famine. This fits the sequence of v.15 followed by v.16, where the North takes over the Beautiful Land. Most commentators follow this view.

  • Gaza, which Antiochus III besieged around 201 BC, or the Ptolemaic strongholds in general

    Polybius (16.22a) records a hard siege of Gaza, praised for its loyalty to the Ptolemies. Some take the singular to stand for a typical stronghold, or read it with Theodotion and the Vulgate as plural.

in v15

When was Daniel 11 written, and so how does it relate to these events?

  • Written in the 6th century BC, as predictive prophecy given to Daniel

    The book presents itself this way (10:1; 12:4). Traditional Jewish and Christian interpretation, including Jerome against Porphyry, held this view, and many conservative scholars still do.

  • Composed around 167–164 BC, during Antiochus IV's persecution, as history written in the form of prophecy, a common device in apocalyptic writing

    The detail is precise up to the events of the 160s and becomes less exact afterward (11:40–45). The Hebrew is late in style. Other writings of the period (e.g. 1 Enoch's Animal Apocalypse) use the same form. This is the majority view in critical scholarship. Porphyry argued for it in the 3rd century AD.

in v16

Does וכלה mean 'destruction' or 'all of it'?

  • 'Complete destruction is in his hand' (Masoretic vowels): he has power to ruin the land, or actually ruins it.

    This is the received vowelling. Kalah is a known word in Daniel (9:27). Judea really was devastated during the war of 202–198 BC (Josephus, Antiquities 12.130). The idea of power to destroy also looks ahead to Antiochus IV.

  • 'All of it is in his hand': he gains full control of the land.

    It needs only different vowels. It fits the parallel with 'none stands before him' (total dominance). It matches the history, since Antiochus III favoured Jerusalem rather than destroying it (Antiquities 12.138–146). NRSV and YLT follow it.

in v16

Is this prediction before the events, or a history written as prophecy?

  • Written in the 6th century BC by Daniel, predicting events about 350 years ahead.

    This is the book's own setting (10:1). Traditional Jewish and Christian readers, and modern conservative commentators, hold it, and see the detail as a mark of divine foreknowledge.

  • The final form was composed around 165 BC. Past history is told in the future tense, a known style of the period, up to events under Antiochus IV.

    The detail is precise up to about 11:39, and then 11:40–45 does not match how Antiochus IV actually died. The Hebrew of chs. 8–12 resembles late Hebrew. Similar 'prophecies after the event' are known from Babylonian and Jewish texts of the period. Porphyry made this argument in antiquity, and Jerome reported it.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. גָּרָה, שָׁטַף, מָעוֹז, הָמוֹן
  • HALOT s.v. גרה (hitp.), שׁטף, מָעוֹז
  • J. A. Montgomery, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Book of Daniel (ICC, 1927)
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia, 1993)
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (Word Biblical Commentary 30)
  • Polybius, Histories, book 5 (Fourth Syrian War, Raphia)
  • Jerome, Commentary on Daniel (with Porphyry's identifications)
  • Isaiah 8:7–8; Deuteronomy 2:5–24; Psalm 27:1 (comparative usage)
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. מָרַר (Hithpalpel 'become embittered, enraged')
  • HALOT s.v. הָמוֹן
  • Polybius, Histories 5.79–86 (Battle of Raphia)
  • 3 Maccabees 1:1–7
  • J. A. Montgomery, A Critical and Exegetical Commentary on the Book of Daniel (ICC)
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia)
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Vulgate, Daniel 11:11
  • BDB s.v. נָשָׂא, הָמוֹן, רוּם, לֵבָב, עָזַז, רִבּוֹ
  • HALOT s.v. רוּם; עזז
  • Polybius, Histories 5.34, 5.79–87, 5.107
  • 3 Maccabees 1–2
  • Jerome, Commentary on Daniel (on 11:10–12)
  • Theodotion and Old Greek Daniel; Vulgate (Daniel 11:12)
  • BDB s.v. הָמוֹן, קֵץ, רְכוּשׁ, עָמַד
  • HALOT s.v. רְכוּשׁ; עֵת
  • Polybius, Histories 5.79–86 (Raphia); 16.18–19 (Panium)
  • Jerome, Commentary on Daniel, on 11:13 (citing Porphyry)
  • Vulgate, Daniel 11:13
  • BDB s.v. שָׁפַךְ, סֹלְלָה, מִבְצָר, זְרוֹעַ, מִבְחָר
  • HALOT s.v. סֹלְלָה; מִבְחָר; עָמַד
  • Jerome, Commentary on Daniel, on 11:15
  • Polybius, Histories 16.18–19, 16.22a
  • Josephus, Jewish Antiquities 12.129–138
  • Open Scriptures Hebrew Bible morphology (supplied data)
  • BDB s.v. רָצוֹן, עָמַד, צְבִי, כָּלָה
  • HALOT s.v. צְבִי I, כָּלָה
  • Josephus, Antiquities 12.129–153
  • Polybius, Histories 16.18–19, 16.39
  • Jerome, Commentary on Daniel (on 11:13–16)
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia), on 11:14–16
  • J. A. Montgomery, Daniel (ICC), on 11:16
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (WBC), on 11:16
  • STEP Bible / TAHOT morphological data (supplied)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.