Isaiah Chapter 41 Read as one passage
Isaiah 41:25–29
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
25I have raised up one from the north, and he has come—one from the east who calls on My name. He will march over rulers as if they were mortar, like a potter who treads the clay. 26Who has declared this from the beginning, so that we may know, and from times past, so that we may say: ‘He was right’? No one announced it, no one foretold it, no one heard your words. 27I was the first to tell Zion: ‘Look, here they are!’ And I gave to Jerusalem a herald of good news. 28When I look, there is no one; there is no counselor among them; when I ask them, they have nothing to say. 29See, they are all a delusion; their works amount to nothing; their images are as empty as the wind.
What the first hearers heard
To Judean exiles in Babylon in the mid-500s BC, this verse was news and an argument at once.
- News: The rising power out of the east and north, the Persian king whose victories everyone was watching, was not a random threat or Marduk's chosen king. He was the LORD's instrument. The God of a small, defeated people claimed to be directing the greatest empire-builder of the day.
- Argument: In the trial against the idols, this was proof. The LORD both caused these events and announced them in advance (v. 26). The gods of Babylon did neither, which is why they are declared "nothing" (v. 24). For exiles surrounded by Babylon's huge temples and processions, that claim mattered for whether they stayed loyal to the LORD at all.
- Reversal: "From the north" had once meant the enemy coming against Jerusalem. Now the threat from the north is aimed at Babylon. The officials who administered the exile will be trodden down like mud.
- The Potter: Isaiah regularly calls the LORD the yotser, the one who formed Israel. So the closing image would have reminded hearers that the conqueror treading clay is himself clay in the LORD's hands.
The verse called for trust that their God still ruled history, and a refusal to credit Babylon's gods with what was happening.
From the study of Isaiah 41:25.
Verse by verse
-
25I have raised up one from the north, and he has come—one from the east who calls on My name. He will march over rulers as if they were mortar, like a potter who treads the clay.
Full study →"I woke him up and set him moving, out of the north, and he has come. From where the sun rises he will invoke my name. He will fall on the empire's appointed governors as if they were wet mud, the way a potter kneads clay under his feet."
God is speaking in a courtroom scene against the gods of the nations (41:21–29). He calls his evidence: a conqueror he himself has roused, as one wakes a sleeper and sends him off. The verbs move from past to future. God has already stirred him up, and he has already appeared on the horizon. What follows, his invoking of God's name and his trampling of officials, is still unfolding. The first hearers knew who this was. He is named later as Cyrus of Persia (44:28; 45:1), who came out of the east and swept down through the north to take Babylon.
The phrase "he will call on my name" does not mean that Cyrus became a worshipper of Israel's God. The same prophet says plainly that he "does not know" the LORD (45:4–5). It means that this foreign king acts under the LORD's name and authority, and will in the end have to acknowledge whose hand moved him. Some scholars think the line originally said "I called him by his name."
The final picture is earthy and humiliating. The seganim, the governors and officials who ran the empire and ran the exiles' lives, will be treated like the mud a potter treads to make it workable. The word for potter, yotser, "the one who forms," is the word Isaiah uses for God himself as the one who formed Israel. The conqueror treads the clay, but the real Potter is the God who woke him up. The idols, by contrast, could neither predict this nor cause it (41:24, 26).
-
26Who has declared this from the beginning, so that we may know, and from times past, so that we may say: ‘He was right’? No one announced it, no one foretold it, no one heard your words.
Full study →"Which of you announced this ahead of time, at the very start, so that we could check it? Which of you spoke it beforehand, so that we could stand up in court and say, 'Correct, that one was in the right!'? Nobody. Not one of you told it. Not one of you made it heard. And not one person ever heard a word out of you."
Israel's God is speaking in a mock trial against the gods of the nations. He has just announced that he has stirred up a conqueror from the north and east who will trample rulers like a potter treading clay (v.25). Now he puts the deciding question to the gods. Did any of them predict it? Prediction is the test: a god who can say what will happen, before it happens, has shown he is real and in control. The word translated "righteous" or "right" is the verdict a judge or crowd gives to the side whose case holds up. The issue is accuracy, not moral goodness. The answer comes as three blunt denials, each starting with "No, indeed": no announcer, no proclaimer, no listener. The wording is built to bite. The question "Who told?" is answered with "no teller", and "no one who made it heard" is followed by "no one who heard". The gods are addressed directly ("your words"), and the insult is that nobody has ever heard anything from them. The next verse gives the contrast: Israel's God was "first" to tell Zion and sent Jerusalem a messenger with good news (v.27).
-
27I was the first to tell Zion: ‘Look, here they are!’ And I gave to Jerusalem a herald of good news.
Full study →"I, the First, was first to speak to Zion, before any of it happened. And now: 'Look! There they are!' The things I said have come into view. And to Jerusalem I am sending a runner with the news of victory."
The line is clipped and breathless. It has no main verb until the very last word, so it reads like an exclamation. It comes at the end of a courtroom scene in which the LORD has challenged the gods of the nations to prove themselves divine by predicting the future (41:21–26). None of them did. "No one announced it, no one foretold it" (41:26), and when God looks there is "no counselor" among them (41:28). Against that silence God makes his own claim. Ri'shon, "first," echoes his title in 41:4 ("I, the LORD, the first"): he is the First, and he was first to tell Zion. The doubled "look, look-them!" is the cry of someone who sees what was promised arriving. The predicted events, set off by the conqueror God "stirred up from the north" (41:25), are happening.
The second half turns from prediction to delivery. God "gives," meaning he appoints and sends, a mevasser to Jerusalem: a messenger who runs ahead with news, normally the good news of a won battle. This is the herald of 40:9 and 52:7, who will tell the ruined city that its God has won and its people are coming home. The verse joins two claims: God's word came first, and God himself sees to it that the city hears the word has come true.
-
28When I look, there is no one; there is no counselor among them; when I ask them, they have nothing to say.
Full study →God is speaking as judge in a courtroom he has convened against the gods of the nations. He has just said that he alone announced ahead of time what is now happening (v. 27). Now he turns to look at the other side, and the bench is empty:
"I look round, and there is no one. Among these so-called gods there is not a single counselor, no one who can lay out a plan or say what is coming. There is no one I could question who would bring back even one word in reply."
"Counselor" here does not mean someone who offers comfort. It means the king's adviser: the one who knows the plan, reads events and says what will happen. That was exactly the job people expected their gods to do. The verbs are hypothetical: "that I might ask, and they might answer". So the point is not that the gods answered badly. Nobody is there who could answer at all. God, who in Isaiah 40:13–14 needed no counselor, now finds that the gods have none to offer. Their silence is their verdict, and verse 29 reads it out: "they are all nothing".
-
29See, they are all a delusion; their works amount to nothing; their images are as empty as the wind.
Full study →"There — look at them! Every one of them is false and empty, a bringer of trouble. What they do adds up to zero. Their gleaming cast-metal statues are wind blowing over a wasteland."
This is the judge reading out a verdict. In the courtroom scene of 41:21–28, God has challenged the gods of the nations to prove they are gods: tell what happened before, announce what is coming, do anything, good or bad. They have stood silent; no one among them can give counsel or answer (v. 28). Now the sentence comes in three short clauses with no verbs. The Hebrew simply points and labels: Look — all of them: 'aven. Nothing — their works. Wind and emptiness — their cast images.
- 'Aven combines falsehood, emptiness and harm. The gods are not just useless. They are deceptions that lead people into trouble.
- 'Efes, "nothing, zero", is the same word Isaiah uses for God's uniqueness ("there is none besides me"). The gods' activity amounts to none. "Their works" may mean what the gods do, which is nothing, or what their makers make, which is the idols themselves. Either way the result is zero.
- Ruach and tohu, "wind and wasteland", picture desert air blowing over barren ground, the condition of the earth before God shaped it (Gen 1:2). The costly statues, poured from molten metal, are as empty as moving air.
The verse is also built to point forward. Its opening "Look!" (hen) is answered at once in 42:1 by another "Look!": "Look — my servant, whom I uphold… I have put my ruach upon him." The gods' images are only ruach (wind). God's servant carries God's ruach (Spirit). The same word links two opposite realities, one empty and one full.
Where the English drifted
-
in v25
calls on My name
yiqra vishmi
- What we hear
- Cyrus became a believer: he prayed to the LORD and turned to him in faith, as in 'everyone who calls on the name of the Lord will be saved.'
- What they heard
- He will invoke, proclaim or act under the LORD's name, as God's agent. Or, in a disputed reading, he was 'called by name' by God. The same prophet says Cyrus 'does not know' the LORD (45:4–5), so the line is about whose authority stands behind him, not a report of his conversion.
-
in v25
princes (KJV) / rulers
seganim
- What we hear
- Royal sons or kings: crowned heads.
- What they heard
- Appointed officials: governors, prefects, deputies of the imperial administration. The word is borrowed from Babylonian šaknu, 'appointed one.'
-
in v25
mortar
chomer
- What we hear
- Hard-setting building cement made with lime or sand, spread between bricks.
- What they heard
- Wet clay or mud: soft earth used for bricks, plaster and pottery. Underfoot it squelches. It does not harden.
-
in v26
righteous (KJV, YLT)
tsaddiq
- What we hear
- Morally upright, holy, virtuous, or right with God.
- What they heard
- 'In the right, correct!' The verdict given to the party whose claim holds up. Here, roughly 'That's true, that god called it.'
-
in v26
from the beginning
merosh
- What we hear
- From creation, from the start of time (an echo of Genesis 1).
- What they heard
- 'From the outset, ahead of time': before the events of v.25 began. It parallels 'from before, beforehand' in the same line.
-
in v27
a herald of good news / one that bringeth good tidings
mevasser
- What we hear
- An evangelist, or a preacher of the gospel of personal salvation. The Vulgate's 'evangelist' strengthens that association.
- What they heard
- A messenger running with news, normally of a victory. Here it is the public announcement that God has acted in history: Babylon is overthrown and the exiles are released to return to Zion.
-
in v27
Behold, behold them (KJV)
hinneh hinnam
- What we hear
- A solemn instruction to gaze at some people.
- What they heard
- An excited cry of arrival: 'Look! There they are!' Most likely 'they' means the foretold events, now visibly happening.
-
in v28
counselor
yo'ets
- What we hear
- A therapist, a school or guidance counselor, or a lawyer: someone who helps a person with problems.
- What they heard
- A king's strategic adviser, someone who knows the plan and can say what is coming and what to do. In Isaiah, 'counsel' is closely tied to controlling and foretelling events.
-
in v29
vanity (KJV, WEB, YLT)
'aven
- What we hear
- Conceit or excessive pride in one's appearance or achievements.
- What they heard
- Emptiness and falsehood that also brings trouble: the gods are hollow, deceptive and harmful. In 1611 'vanity' still carried the Latin sense of vanitas, 'emptiness'.
-
in v29
confusion (KJV, WEB, NIV)
tohu
- What we hear
- Mental bewilderment, being muddled or unsure.
- What they heard
- A barren wasteland, emptiness or formless non-being, as in the trackless desert and the unformed earth of Genesis 1:2. It describes what the idols are, not anyone's state of mind.
Every word
-
הַעִירוֹתִי
ha'iroti · H5782
-
מִצָּפוֹן
mitstsafon · H6828G
north · v25
'From the north.' Seen from Babylon and Judah, Cyrus's conquests of Media and Lydia, and his final move on Babylon in 539 BC, came from the north. 'The north' was also the old direction of the dreaded invader (Jeremiah 1:14). Here that threat is turned against Babylon.
-
וַיַּאת
vayyat · H0857
to come, arrive · v25
'And he came.' This is a rare, poetic verb for 'come', related to Aramaic. Its form narrates the arrival as a fact that follows directly from God's rousing.
-
מִמִּזְרַח־
mimmizrach- · H4217H
rising, east · v25
'From the rising (of).' The word comes from the verb for the sun 'shining forth', so it means sunrise, the east. It pairs with 'north' to cover the whole arc from which the Persian-Median power came.
-
שֶׁמֶשׁ
shemesh · H8121
sun · v25
'The sun.' Together with the previous word it makes the set phrase 'the rising of the sun', meaning the far east. Persia (Anshan) lay east of Babylon.
-
יִקְרָא
yiqra · H7121G
to call, proclaim, invoke · v25
'He will call.' The tense shifts from past to future or ongoing: he was roused and has come, and now he will call. What kind of 'calling' this is depends on the phrase that follows.
-
בִשְׁמִי
vishmi · H8034
name · v25
'In / on my name.' 'Call in the name of' usually means invoking a god in worship (Genesis 12:8). It can also mean proclaiming that god's name or acting under its authority. Since 45:4–5 says this conqueror does 'not know' the LORD, the sense here is disputed (see debates).
-
וְיָבֹא
veyavo · H0935G
to come, enter · v25
'And he will come (upon).' With a direct object it means to come against or fall upon, the language of attack. Some scholars suspect it was originally 'trample' (see variants).
-
סְגָנִים
seganim · H5461
prefect, governor, official · v25
'Prefects.' The word is borrowed from Akkadian (the language of Babylon and Assyria) and means appointed provincial officials. It names the administrators of the empires, not royal 'princes.' For exiles in Babylon it pointed at the officials who governed them.
-
כְּמוֹ־
kemo- · H3644G
like, as · v25
'Like.' This is a longer, poetic form of the comparison word, and it opens the first half of a double comparison.
-
חֹמֶר
chomer · H2563C
clay, mud, mortar · v25
'Mud / wet clay.' This is the soft earth used for bricks, plaster and pottery, and the 'mortar' of Genesis 11:3. The picture is of something soft and wet under the feet, not hard cement.
-
יוֹצֵר
yotser · H3335H
potter, one who forms · v25
'A potter.' Literally 'one who forms or shapes.' The same verb is used for God forming humanity (Genesis 2:7) and forming Israel (Isaiah 43:1). In Isaiah the potter image regularly stands for the Creator's total control over what he makes (29:16; 45:9; 64:8).
-
יִרְמָס־
yirmos- · H7429
to trample, tread down · v25
'Tramples.' The verb is used for treading down grapes, streets and defeated enemies. Here it describes the potter kneading clay with his feet. The conqueror will handle the empire's officials just as easily.
-
טִיט
tit · H2916
mud, mire, clay · v25
'Clay / mire.' This is wet, sticky ground. Elsewhere it is the mire of the pit (Psalm 40:2; Jeremiah 38:6) and the dirt of the streets (Micah 7:10). It closes the line with a picture of utter helplessness.
-
מִֽי־
mi · H4310
who? · v26
Opens a challenge question in a courtroom-style debate. The question is rhetorical: the expected answer is 'none of you gods'.
-
הִגִּ֤יד
higgid · H5046
to tell, declare · v26
'Told, announced'. The causative form of a verb meaning to put something in front of someone, so to make it known openly. Here it means announcing an event before it happens, namely the rise of the conqueror described in v.25.
-
מֵרֹאשׁ֙
merosh · H7218
head; beginning, first · v26
'From the head', meaning from the start, in advance. Set beside 'from before' later in the line, it points to telling the outcome ahead of time, before events began to unfold.
-
וְנֵדָ֔עָה
wenedaʿah · H3045
to know · v26
'So that we may know'. A first-person-plural form expressing purpose or resolve. The speaker counts himself among the onlookers who would check the prediction against what happened.
-
וּמִלְּפָנִ֖ים
umilphanim · H6440
face; before, formerly · v26
'And from before', i.e. beforehand, in earlier times. It parallels 'from the beginning' and stresses that the announcement would have to come earlier than the event.
-
וְנֹאמַ֣ר
wenomar · H559
to say · v26
'So that we may say'. It matches 'that we may know': first you know, then you give your verdict out loud.
-
צַדִּ֑יק
tsaddiq · H6662
righteous; in the right, correct · v26
The single-word verdict: 'In the right!' or 'Correct!' In a court setting it is what you say of a party whose case holds up. It is not a statement about moral goodness.
-
אַ֣ף
ʾaph · H637
also, indeed, yes · v26
An intensifier: 'No, indeed...' It opens the first of three hammer-blow denials.
-
אֵין־
ʾen · H369
there is not, nothing · v26, v28
'There is no one', a flat statement that nobody exists who fits the description.
-
מַשְׁמִ֔יעַ
mashmiaʿ · H8085
one who makes heard, proclaims · v26
Causative participle of 'hear': 'one who makes others hear', a proclaimer. It sets up the play on words with the next participle.
-
אִמְרֵיכֶֽם׃
ʾimrekhem · H561
saying, word · v26
'Your sayings'. The 'your' is plural and addressed to the gods on trial (vv.21–24). The mocking point is that nobody ever heard a single word from them.
-
רִאשׁ֥וֹן
ri'shon · H7223
first, former, foremost · v27
It stands first in the line with no verb. It can be read as 'I first [spoke]' or as the divine title 'the First,' which God claims in 41:4 ('I, the LORD, the first'). In either reading it insists that the LORD announced these events before they happened, which the idols never did (41:26).
-
לְצִיּ֖וֹן
le-tsiyyon · H6726
Zion · v27
'To Zion.' This is the hill of Jerusalem, and here it stands for the city and the people who belong to it, a community whose city is ruined and many of whose members are in exile.
-
הִנֵּ֣ה
hinneh · H2009
look! here! · v27
A word that points and grabs attention: 'Look!' It is the cry of someone who sees something arriving.
-
הִנָּ֑ם
hinnam · H2005
look! + 'them' · v27, v29
The same pointing word with 'them' attached: 'there they are!' The doubled 'look, look-them' sounds breathless. 'They' most likely means the foretold events, which are now actually happening.
-
וְלִירוּשָׁלִַ֖ם
vi-lirushalaim · H3389
and to Jerusalem · v27
It pairs with 'to Zion' in the first half, as Hebrew poetry often does: the same addressee named twice. Jerusalem is the city, pictured as waiting for word.
-
מְבַשֵּׂ֥ר
mevasser · H1319
-
אֶתֵּֽן׃
etten · H5414
I give / will give · v27
'I give.' The verb form usually points to the present or future ('I am giving / will give'), although in poetry it can describe the past (BSB 'I gave'). This one verb may also do the work for the verbless first half of the line.
-
וְאֵ֙רֶא֙
ve'ere' · H7200
and I look / see · v28
God speaks as the judge looking round the courtroom for the other side. The short verb form with plain 'and' can mean 'I look' or 'though I look'. It is not the usual past-narrative form, so it describes the scene as it happens now.
-
אִ֔ישׁ
'ish · H376
man, anyone · v28
With 'there is not', it means 'no one at all', not specifically 'no male'. Nobody stands up to argue the case for the gods.
-
וּמֵאֵ֖לֶּה
ume'elleh · H428
and from / among these · v28
'These' points to the parties summoned in verses 21–24: the gods of the nations (and, in the background, the people who consult them). The word sits at the front of its line for emphasis: 'and as for these…'
-
יוֹעֵ֑ץ
yo'ets · H3289
counselor, adviser · v28
An adviser at court, someone who can lay out a plan and say what will happen and what to do. The gods are supposed to supply exactly this kind of guidance about the future, and they cannot.
-
וְאֶשְׁאָלֵ֖ם
ve'esh'alem · H7592
and I ask them · v28
'Asking' is what a judge does when questioning a witness, and what people do when they consult a god or oracle. Here the roles are flipped: God questions the gods.
-
וְיָשִׁ֥יבוּ
veyashivu · H7725
and they would bring back · v28
The causative form of 'return': 'to bring back'. Together with 'word' it is the ordinary idiom for answering. The form expresses purpose or possibility ('that they might answer'), not a report that they did answer.
-
דָבָֽר׃
davar · H1697
word, matter · v28
'A word': any reply at all. The point is that not even one word comes back.
-
כֻּלָּ֔ם
kullam · H3605
-
אָ֥וֶן
'aven · H205
trouble, wickedness, deceit, nothingness · v29
The first verdict on the gods. 'Aven combines moral evil, the trouble it causes, and hollowness. In idol settings it is close to 'falsehood' or 'nothing-god'. They are both false and harmful. There is no verb: the noun is simply laid on them as a label.
-
אֶ֖פֶס
'efes · H657
-
מַעֲשֵׂיהֶ֑ם
ma'aseihem · H4639
deed, work, thing made · v29
'Their works' can mean what the gods do, which is nothing, since they could not predict or bring about anything (vv. 22–23). It can also mean what their worshippers make, the crafted images. Both senses fit, and the ambiguity sharpens the insult: the gods' only 'works' are objects people made.
-
ר֥וּחַ
ruach · H7307
wind, breath, spirit · v29
Here it means 'wind': moving air with no substance and nothing you can hold. The next verse (42:1) uses the same word for God's own 'Spirit' placed on his servant. The idols are mere ruach; God gives real ruach.
-
וָתֹ֖הוּ
vatohu · H8414
emptiness, waste, formlessness · v29
'And emptiness': the word for a barren, trackless waste and for the unformed earth of Genesis 1:2. Paired with 'wind', it pictures desert air blowing over nothing. Isaiah uses it repeatedly for idols and those who make them (44:9).
-
נִסְכֵּיהֶֽם
niskeihem · H5262
drink offering; cast (molten) image · v29
From a root meaning 'to pour'. It usually means a poured drink offering. Here, as in Isa 48:5 and Dan 11:8, it means images cast from poured metal: the gleaming metal statues that were the visible face of the gods. A minority read 'their libations', the drink offerings poured to them.
The world behind it
The courtroom of the gods. Isaiah 41:21–29 is set up like a lawsuit. The LORD challenges the gods of the nations to present their case: can they explain the past or announce the future (41:22–23)? They are silent and declared "nothing" (41:24). Verse 25 is the LORD's evidence: he roused the conqueror, and (v. 26) he announced it beforehand.
Cyrus the Great. Chapters 40–55 address Judeans exiled in Babylon. The conqueror is unnamed here but is named as Cyrus in 44:28 and 45:1. Cyrus was king of Anshan in Persia, east of Babylon. He defeated Media (c. 550 BC) to the north-east and Lydia in Asia Minor (c. 547/546 BC), then took Babylon in 539 BC, after first defeating the Babylonian army at Opis to the north. From the exiles' viewpoint he came both from the east and from the north.
A rival claim. The Babylonian Cyrus Cylinder, written for Cyrus after he took Babylon, says that Marduk, Babylon's chief god, searched for a righteous king, "called out his name, Cyrus, king of Anshan," and took him by the hand. Isaiah makes the same kind of claim for the LORD: I roused him (41:2, 25), I call you by name (45:3–4), I grasp his right hand (45:1). The trial scene is therefore a direct contest over which god was really behind the most important political event of the age.
Imperial officials and potter's clay. Seganim is an administrative title borrowed from Babylonian Akkadian. It names the governors and prefects of the empire, the people exiles actually dealt with. Potters in the ancient Near East prepared clay by treading it underfoot in a pit. Everyone had seen it done, and nothing looked less able to resist.
From the study of Isaiah 41:25.
Where scholars differ
in v25
What does 'he will call on my name' mean, given that Cyrus 'does not know' the LORD (45:4–5)?
-
It looks ahead: Cyrus will come to acknowledge the LORD.
Isaiah 45:3 says God acts 'so that you may know that I am the LORD.' Ezra 1:2 presents Cyrus's edict crediting 'the LORD, the God of heaven.' Cyrus's policy of honoring local gods and returning their worshippers made this plausible.
-
It means acting or proclaiming under the LORD's name and authority, not personal worship.
Qara' be-shem can mean 'proclaim the name' (Exodus 33:19; 34:5). YLT's 'calleth in My name' points this way. It fits Cyrus's role in Isaiah as an unknowing agent (45:4–5).
-
The text originally said 'I called him by his name.'
This matches 45:3–4 ('I call you by your name') and the Cyrus Cylinder's statement that Marduk 'called out his name.' The Septuagint's passive 'they will be called by my name' shows that early readers took the line as being about naming or calling. Direct manuscript support is weak.
in v25
When was this prophecy given?
-
In the exile, c. 550–539 BC, by an anonymous prophet in Isaiah's tradition ('Second Isaiah'), as Cyrus's rise was unfolding.
Chapters 40–55 address the exiles in Babylon as present hearers, name Cyrus, and speak of his campaigns as already under way ('he has come'). This is the majority view in critical scholarship.
-
From the 8th-century prophet Isaiah, foretelling Cyrus about 150 years ahead.
This is the traditional Jewish and Christian attribution. The surrounding argument (41:22–26; 44:24–28) rests on God announcing events beforehand. Supporters stress the book's unity of vocabulary, such as 'the Holy One of Israel.'
in v26
Whom or what does the verdict 'tsaddiq' describe?
-
A person: 'He [that god] is in the right.'
Tsaddiq is masculine singular and normally describes a person or party in a lawsuit (Deut 25:1). Most modern versions (BSB, NIV, ESV, NASB) take it this way.
-
A statement: 'It is right / true / correct.'
The Septuagint has 'it is true'. The companion trial speech in 43:9 has the onlookers say ʾemet, 'true'. The words 'so that we may say' introduce a short exclamation, which fits 'Correct!'.
in v26
Does 'from the beginning' (merosh) mean from creation or simply beforehand?
-
Beforehand, ahead of the event.
The parallel milphanim, 'from before', and the focus on Cyrus in v.25 both point to the short-range sense. Compare 48:16.
-
From the start of history, with a hint of God's plan from creation.
Merosh refers to the start of the world in 40:21. Isaiah 46:10 speaks of 'declaring the end from the beginning'.
in v26
When was this prophecy given, and how does that affect the argument from prediction?
-
An exilic prophet (often called 'Second Isaiah') speaking around 550–539 BC, during Cyrus's rise.
The chapters address exiles in Babylon, call Jerusalem ruined, and name Cyrus as a current figure (44:28; 45:1). On this view, the 'prediction' concerns Cyrus's coming victory over Babylon and the release of the exiles, or earlier oracles now coming true.
-
Isaiah of Jerusalem (8th century BC) predicting Cyrus long in advance.
Traditional Jewish and Christian authorship (compare Sir 48:24–25; John 12:38–41 quoting Isaiah 53 and 6 as 'Isaiah'). On this view, the long gap strengthens the chapter's argument from prediction.
in v27
What does ri'shon ('first') mean here?
-
A divine title: 'I, the First'
Isaiah 41:4 ('I, the LORD, the first'), 44:6 and 48:12 make ri'shon one of God's self-descriptions in these chapters, and 41:4 is only a few verses earlier.
-
A time word: 'I first / beforehand declared'
The courtroom question in 41:26 is who declared it 'from the beginning … from times past.' Ri'shon as 'first / earlier' answers it directly (NASB 'Formerly').
-
A separate speaker, 'the first one' (KJV, Vulgate)
This reading follows the Vulgate's added verb dicet. Most modern scholars think it is less natural, because God is clearly speaking in 41:25–29.
in v27
Who or what are 'they' in 'here they are'?
-
The foretold events, now coming true
This best fits the courtroom over prediction (41:22–26) and the Targum's paraphrase.
-
The returning exiles
Compare 49:12 and 49:18 ('Look, these come from afar'; 'they all gather and come to you'), where Zion is told to look up at her children arriving.
-
Cyrus's victories or armies
These follow straight on from 41:25, 'I stirred up one from the north, and he has come.'
in v27
Who is the herald (mevasser)?
-
The prophet himself, or the prophetic message
Isaiah 40:1–9 commissions voices to announce comfort to Zion, and the prophet is the one delivering the announcement.
-
A messenger announcing Babylon's fall and the return
In 52:7–9 the herald announces 'Your God reigns' as the LORD returns to Zion, which fits the image of a victory runner.
-
A future or messianic figure (later Jewish and Christian readings)
11QMelchizedek reads the herald of 52:7 as an end-time figure. The Vulgate's 'evangelist' and the New Testament's use of the herald texts led to Christian readings. These are later interpretive developments, not the plain sense for the exilic audience.
in v28
Who are 'these' among whom there is no counselor?
-
The gods/idols themselves.
They are the ones summoned and challenged in vv. 21–24, and v. 29 calls them 'nothing' and their molten images 'wind and emptiness'.
-
The nations and their diviners or prophets, who speak for the gods.
'Ish' ('man') and 'counselor' are human terms, and the LXX names 'the nations' alongside 'their idols'. Isaiah 44:25 and 47:13 mock Babylon's diviners and astrologers.
-
Both together, as the whole rival side in the case.
Isaiah habitually links idols with their makers and worshippers (44:9–11). The courtroom structure treats the gods and their human mouthpieces as one party.
in v29
Who are 'all of them' in this verse: the gods or the nations and their counsellors?
-
The gods/idols on trial.
The lawsuit of vv. 21–24 is addressed to the gods, and v. 24 already declares them 'nothing'. 'Their cast images' most naturally belong to gods. 'Their works' then means the gods' (non-)deeds, which fits the challenge in v. 23 to 'do good or do harm'.
-
The people of v. 28: the nations' counsellors and idol-worshippers.
The nearest antecedent is v. 28 ('there is no man… no counsellor among them… when I ask them'). Isaiah 44:9 says the idol-makers 'are all tohu'. On this reading 'their works' are the idols they manufacture.
-
Deliberately both.
Isaiah regularly merges idols and devotees: 'those who make them become like them' (cf. Ps 115:8; Isa 44:9–11). The plural suffixes could cover gods, makers and worshippers together. Many commentators (e.g. Goldingay) read the verdict as falling on the whole system.
in v29
Should the first verdict read 'aven ('trouble/deceit') or 'ayin ('nothing')?
-
Keep the Masoretic 'aven.
It is the harder and more distinctive reading. It fits Isaiah's and Hosea's use of 'aven for idolatry, and the ancient versions mostly reflect it (Vulgate iniusti).
-
Read 'ayin with 1QIsaᵃ.
The Qumran scroll's reading echoes 41:24 ('you are nothing'), forms a natural pair with 'efes (as in 40:17; 41:12), and the two words differ only slightly in Hebrew script.
Sources
- BDB s.v. עוּר, קָרָא, סָגָן, חֹמֶר, טִיט
- HALOT s.v. סָגָן (Akkadian šaknu), עוּר, רָמַס
- Cyrus Cylinder, lines 11–15 (trans. I. Finkel, British Museum)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 40–55 (Anchor Bible)
- C. Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (Old Testament Library)
- J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah, Chapters 40–66 (NICOT)
- Septuagint, Isaiah 41:25
- Vulgate, Isaiah 41:25
- Sirach 38:29–30
- Jeremiah 50–51; Ezra 1:1–4; 2 Chronicles 36:22–23
- Open Scriptures Hebrew Bible morphology (supplied)
- BDB s.v. צַדִּיק, נָגַד, רֹאשׁ
- HALOT s.v. צַדִּיק (forensic sense 'in the right')
- HALOT s.v. אֵמֶר
- Claus Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (OTL): on trial speeches against the nations
- Joseph Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 40–55 (Anchor Bible)
- Brevard Childs, Isaiah (OTL)
- John Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 40–66 (NICOT)
- John Goldingay & David Payne, Isaiah 40–55 (ICC)
- Septuagint, Isaiah 41:26; 43:9
- Cyrus Cylinder (Marduk's selection of Cyrus)
- BDB s.v. רִאשׁוֹן, בָּשַׂר, הִנֵּה
- HALOT s.v. בשׂר, ראשׁון
- Claus Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (Old Testament Library)
- Brevard Childs, Isaiah (Old Testament Library)
- John Goldingay & David Payne, Isaiah 40–55 (International Critical Commentary)
- Septuagint, Isaiah 41:27 (Göttingen edition, ed. Ziegler)
- Vulgate, Isaiah 41:27
- Targum of Isaiah (tr. Chilton)
- Cyrus Cylinder (British Museum)
- 11QMelchizedek (Dead Sea Scrolls)
- BDB s.v. יָעַץ, יוֹעֵץ
- HALOT s.v. יעץ; s.v. שׁוב (Hiphil: 'to reply')
- HALOT s.v. שׁאל (consult an oracle)
- Septuagint, Isaiah 41:28 (Rahlfs)
- Vulgate, Isaiah 41:28
- Claus Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (OTL), on the trial speeches
- John Goldingay and David Payne, Isaiah 40–55 (ICC)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isaiah 41 and Babylonian divination
- BDB s.v. אָוֶן, אֶפֶס, נֶסֶךְ, תֹּהוּ
- HALOT s.v. אָוֶן, נֶסֶךְ, רוּחַ, תֹּהוּ
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus at Isa 41:29
- 1QIsaᵃ (Great Isaiah Scroll), Isa 41:29
- C. Westermann, Isaiah 40–66 (OTL)
- B. S. Childs, Isaiah (OTL)
- J. Goldingay & D. Payne, Isaiah 40–55 (ICC)
- D. T. Tsumura, Creation and Destruction (on tohu)
- Septuagint and Vulgate, Isa 41:29
- STEPBible / TAHOT morphological data (supplied)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).