Jeremiah Chapter 17 Read as one passage
Jeremiah 17:1–4
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
1“The sin of Judah is written with an iron stylus, engraved with a diamond point on the tablets of their hearts and on the horns of their altars. 2Even their children remember their altars and Asherah poles by the green trees and on the high hills. 3O My mountain in the countryside, I will give over your wealth and all your treasures as plunder, because of the sin of your high places, within all your borders. 4And you yourself will relinquish the inheritance that I gave you. I will enslave you to your enemies in a land that you do not know, for you have kindled My anger; it will burn forever.”
What the first hearers heard
To people in Judah who trusted their sanctuaries, this verse took away their security in two ways.
-
It cannot be erased. Their disloyalty was not a passing lapse that the next sacrifice could fix. It had been cut in as a permanent record, like a royal inscription in stone. Verses 3–4 draw the conclusion: their wealth will be plundered, they will lose their inheritance, and they will serve enemies in a land they do not know.
-
The remedy has become the evidence. The altar horns were where the sin offering's blood cleaned away sin and where a person in danger could grab hold for protection. Jeremiah says the sin is now carved into those very horns. The altars they trusted, many of them local altars with Asherah poles beside them, testify against them. This fits Jeremiah's wider attack on false confidence in ritual (Jer 7).
The "tablet of the heart" would also call the covenant to mind. Israel had the commandments cut in stone and was told to keep them on its heart. Hearers would see the reversal: their inner life now carried a record of betrayal instead. The shift to "your altars" made it a direct charge. The prophet was not describing other people; he was addressing his hearers.
Later in the same book, the remedy matches the indictment. God promises to write his Torah on their heart (31:33), on the very surface where sin is engraved here.
From the study of Jeremiah 17:1.
Verse by verse
-
1“The sin of Judah is written with an iron stylus, engraved with a diamond point on the tablets of their hearts and on the horns of their altars.
Full study →"Judah's sin stands written, cut with an iron chisel tipped with the hardest stone there is. It is furrowed into the tablet of their inner self, where they think and decide, and into the horns of your altars."
The picture is a monument, not a page. Ink could be washed away. This record was cut into a hard surface with tools nothing could resist. The verb translated "engraved" is the same one used for plowing, so the sin lies in furrows.
There are two surfaces, and both are chosen with intent:
- The tablet of their heart. "Tablet" is the word for the stone tablets of the Ten Commandments, and Israel was told to write God's words on its heart (Deut 6:6; Prov 3:3). What is cut into Judah's heart instead is its sin. Here "heart" means the whole inner life of thought, memory and will, not only feelings. The sin has become part of how the nation thinks and chooses.
- The horns of the altars. The corner points of the altar were where priests daubed the blood of the sin offering to clean away the stain of sin. Hebrew uses one word, ḥaṭṭaʾt, for both "sin" and "sin offering". So the verse starts with ḥaṭṭaʾt and ends at the place where ḥaṭṭaʾt was supposed to be removed. Instead of being wiped off, the sin is carved into the altar itself. The horns were also where a fugitive grabbed hold to seek protection, so the place of refuge has become the evidence against them.
The plural "altars" and verse 2 show what sin is meant: the many hilltop altars and Asherah poles where Judah worshiped other gods alongside, or instead of, the LORD. The sudden switch from "their heart" to "your altars" turns a description into a direct accusation. Jeremiah stops speaking about his audience and speaks to them.
-
2Even their children remember their altars and Asherah poles by the green trees and on the high hills.
Full study →The LORD has just said that Judah's sin is carved with an iron stylus and a diamond point on their hearts and on the horns of their altars (v.1). Now he shows how deep the carving goes. It has entered the family memory. Judah's children cherish and keep alive (remember in the full Hebrew sense: hold dear and keep up by practice) the altars and the wooden Asherah emblems, the carved poles that stood for the goddess Asherah. These stood beside the leafy, spreading shade trees, symbols of fertility, and on the tops of the high hills, where everyone could see them.
The Hebrew is compact and can be read two ways. It may mean "even their children remember their altars": the next generation has taken the shrines as its own heritage. Or it may mean "as they remember their children, so they remember their altars": the people hold these shrines as dear as their own sons. Either way the sting is the same. Deuteronomy told Israel to remember what the LORD had done and to teach it to their children. Instead, what is being handed down is the hilltop shrine. The sin is not a passing lapse. It is in the landscape and in the household, and it is passed on.
-
3O My mountain in the countryside, I will give over your wealth and all your treasures as plunder, because of the sin of your high places, within all your borders.
Full study →God turns to his people and calls out to the mountain he claims as his own, most likely Zion, Jerusalem on its height above the open countryside. Then comes the shock: everything that made you strong, your wealth, every storehouse and treasury you have, I myself will hand over to be carried off as an army's loot. The "you" is Judah. The word for "wealth" means strength, resources and riches all at once, so this is the loss of what Judah relied on, not only of property. The treasuries are the real stores of temple and palace, the kind invading kings had emptied before.
The second half names the cause. Your shrines, the raised altar platforms you set up on hills, in towns and in valleys, are the sin, and they go too, everywhere within your borders. "Sin" picks up the first word of verse 1, "the sin of Judah is written with an iron pen," so the passage ends where it began. The altars that should have carried the blood that removes sin carry the record of it instead.
Two parts of the Hebrew are unsettled. "My mountain in the open country" could instead be "on the mountains in the open country," finishing verse 2's list of hilltop shrines. And "your high places for sin" may originally have read "as the price of your sin," as in the parallel threat at 15:13. Under every reading the core holds: God himself hands Judah's riches to plunderers, and the cause is the worship at shrines spread across the whole land.
-
4And you yourself will relinquish the inheritance that I gave you. I will enslave you to your enemies in a land that you do not know, for you have kindled My anger; it will burn forever.”
Full study →"And you will let it drop. Yes, by your own doing you will let go of your inheritance, the land I gave you. I will make you a slave to your enemies in a country you have never known. For you have struck a fire in my flaring nostrils, and it will go on burning with no end in sight."
The opening verb is the word for the sabbatical "release," when every seventh year the land was left unworked and debts were let go (Deut 15). Judah never gave that release, so now Judah will be made to release the land itself. The inheritance (nachalah) is not an abstraction. It is the ancestral family ground God handed out to the tribes, which by law was never to leave the family, and it will slip out of their grip. "That I gave you" makes clear whose gift it always was.
The people who chose to serve other gods will be made to serve enemies, and God himself is the one doing it. They will serve in "a land you have not known," the exact language of the covenant curses in Deuteronomy 28. The reason comes from the Song of Moses (Deut 32:22): a fire kindled in God's "nose," the Hebrew picture of hot, snorting rage. Here the line is turned so that the people (now addressed in the plural, all of them) are the ones who lit it. The fire "will be kept burning" (the same verb form used for the altar fire that must never go out) "until ʿolam": a lasting, open-ended judgment that will not quickly burn itself out.
Where the English drifted
-
in v1
heart
lēb
- What we hear
- Emotions, feelings, affection: the 'heart' as opposed to the 'head'.
- What they heard
- The inner person as a whole, especially the mind, memory, intention and will: where a person thinks, plans and commits. The sin is cut into how Judah thinks and decides, not only how it feels.
-
in v1
diamond
šāmîr
- What we hear
- A cut gemstone, the precious diamond of jewelry.
- What they heard
- A very hard natural stone, probably emery or corundum, used as an abrasive and cutting point and described as harder than flint (Ezek 3:9). The image is of an unstoppable cutting tool, not of luxury.
-
in v1
sin
ḥaṭṭaʾt
- What we hear
- An individual's private moral failing.
- What they heard
- Here, a corporate offense of the nation, specifically disloyal worship (v. 2). The word also names the 'sin/purification offering' whose blood went on the altar horns, a meaning the end of the verse plays on.
-
in v2
groves (KJV)
asherim
- What we hear
- A natural stand of trees, a wooded area.
- What they heard
- Wooden cult objects (poles or carved posts) that stood for the goddess Asherah, set up by people beside altars.
-
in v2
green trees
ʿēṣ raʿănān
- What we hear
- Trees of a green colour, any ordinary tree.
- What they heard
- Luxuriant, thickly leafed, flourishing shade trees: symbols of fertility and the stock sites of illicit shrines.
-
in v2
remember
zakar
- What we hear
- A passing mental recollection.
- What they heard
- To hold dear and keep alive, often through ritual practice. It is the verb of covenant memory that Deuteronomy commands parents to pass on to their children.
-
in v3
high places
bamot
- What we hear
- Hilltops or mountain peaks; scenic heights.
- What they heard
- Local cultic shrines: raised platforms with altars, standing stones and Asherah poles. They were often on hills but also in towns and valleys. In Kings and Jeremiah they stand for worship outside the covenant's terms.
-
in v3
my mountain in the field
hararí basadeh
- What we hear
- A hill standing in a farmer's fenced field.
- What they heard
- Sadeh is the open country outside the walled city, farmed or wild. The phrase pictures Zion standing above the countryside, or the shrines on the hills of the rural land.
-
in v3
thy substance
chayil
- What we hear
- Material or matter; something abstract, as in 'a man of substance' at most.
- What they heard
- Strength, resources and wealth together: the property and power a nation relies on.
-
in v4
forever
ʿad-ʿolam
- What we hear
- Literally endless time; some readers hear eternal, unending punishment.
-
in v4
relinquish / discontinue from (your inheritance)
shamat
- What we hear
- A generic loss or giving up, with no particular background.
- What they heard
- The technical verb of the sabbatical 'release' of land and debts. The loss is shaped as an ironic penalty for the releases Judah refused to give.
Every word
-
חַטַּ֣את
ḥaṭṭaʾt · H2403B
sin; sin-offering · v1, v3
The nation's offense, here above all its worship of other gods (v. 2). The same word is the name of the 'sin offering' whose blood was smeared on the altar's horns, and the verse ends at those horns, so a priest would have caught the double sense.
-
יְהוּדָ֗ה
yəhûdâ · H3063G
Judah · v1
The southern kingdom, the people as a whole and not one person. The sin belongs to the whole community.
-
כְּתוּבָ֛ה
kətûbâ · H3789
to write · v1
'Written', a passive form describing a lasting state: it stands written. It is feminine to agree with 'sin', which is the thing written.
-
בְּעֵ֥ט
bəʿēṭ · H5842
stylus, pen · v1
A writing tool. With 'iron' it means a cutting tool for stone, not a pen for ink.
-
בַּרְזֶ֖ל
barzel · H1270
iron · v1
Iron, the hardest working metal of the day. An iron stylus makes marks that last (compare Job 19:24, 'with an iron stylus… carved in the rock forever').
-
בְּצִפֹּ֣רֶן
bəṣippōren · H6856
fingernail, claw; point · v1
Literally a 'nail' (as in fingernail, Deut 21:12). Here it is the hard tip of the engraving tool that bites into the surface.
-
שָׁמִ֑יר
šāmîr · H8068
very hard stone (emery?); also 'thorns' · v1
An extremely hard stone used for cutting, harder than flint (Ezek 3:9). It was probably emery or corundum, not a cut gem. The point is that it cuts and nothing cuts it.
-
חֲרוּשָׁה֙
ḥărûšâ · H2790A
to cut in, engrave, plow · v1
'Engraved', literally 'furrowed', the same verb used for plowing. The sin is cut into the surface the way a plow cuts a furrow. This is not surface writing.
-
עַל־
ʿal · H5921A
upon · v1, v2
'On', the surface that receives the inscription.
-
ל֣וּחַ
lûaḥ · H3871
board, plank, tablet · v1
A writing tablet. The same word names the stone tablets of the covenant (Exod 31:18; 32:15–16), so the picture invites comparison with the Ten Commandments.
-
לִבָּ֔ם
libbām · H3820A
heart, mind, inner self · v1
'Their heart' (singular, one shared heart of the people). In Hebrew the heart is where you think, intend and decide, not mainly where you feel. The sin is cut into how they think and choose.
-
וּלְקַרְנ֖וֹת
ûləqarnôt · H7161A
horn; corner projection · v1
'And on the horns of', the raised corner points of an altar. This is where sin-offering blood was daubed to purify the altar, and where a fugitive grabbed hold to claim protection.
-
מִזְבְּחוֹתֵיכֶֽם׃
mizbəḥôtêkem · H4196
altar · v1, v2
'Your altars'. The plural points to the many local altars of verse 2, beside the Asherah poles on the hills. The sudden 'your' turns the prophet's report into a direct accusation of his hearers.
-
כִּזְכֹּר
kizkōr · H2142
to remember · v2
The preposition 'as/like/when' joined to a verb form that names the action without a tense: 'as (the) remembering of…'. Zakar is more than recall. It means keeping something alive in mind, often through ritual, and it is the word Deuteronomy uses for Israel remembering what the LORD did. Here what is kept alive is the shrines.
-
בְּנֵיהֶם
bənêhem · H1121A
son, child · v2
'Their sons/children'. The grammar allows them to be either the ones who remember ('their children remember') or the ones remembered ('as they remember their children'). Either way the next generation is drawn into the picture.
-
וַאֲשֵׁרֵיהֶם
waʾăšērêhem · H0842
Asherah; Asherah pole · v2
'And their asherahs'. These were the wooden cult objects (a carved pole or stylised tree) that stood for the goddess Asherah. They were set up beside altars at local shrines.
-
עֵץ
ʿēṣ · H6086H
tree · v2
The noun is singular but means trees in general: any such tree. Elsewhere the stock phrase is 'every luxuriant tree'.
-
רַעֲנָן
raʿănān · H7488B
luxuriant, leafy · v2
Not mainly the colour green. It means thick with leaves and full of life: a spreading shade tree that stood for fertility. Such trees were favourite sites for shrines.
-
גְּבָעוֹת
gəbāʿôt · H1389I
hill · v2
'Hills': rounded heights in the countryside, the usual sites of the local high places (bamot) named in verse 3.
-
הַגְּבֹהוֹת
haggəbōhôt · H1364
high, lofty · v2
'The high (hills)'. It stresses how high and how visible the sites were. The hilltop shrines could be seen from all around.
-
הֲרָרִי֙
hararí · H2042
mountain (poetic) · v3
An old, poetic word for 'mountain' used in elevated speech (Gen 49:26; Deut 33:15; Ps 87:1). With the Masoretic vowels it means 'my mountain,' with God speaking, most likely Zion/Jerusalem, his own mountain. The same consonants could also be read 'mountains of' and finish the list of hilltop shrines at the end of verse 2.
-
בַּשָּׂדֶ֔ה
basadeh · H7704
field, open country · v3
'In the open country': land outside the walled city, whether farmed or wild. It is not a fenced farm field. The pairing 'mountain in the open country' is odd. It may picture Jerusalem standing above the countryside, or the shrines scattered across the rural hills.
-
חֵילְךָ֥
cheilkha · H2428
strength, army, wealth · v3
'Your wealth.' The word covers strength, ability, armed force and property, all of which are what makes a person or nation strong. Here, alongside 'treasures,' it means accumulated wealth, though the sense of 'what you relied on for strength' is still there.
-
כָל־
khol · H3605
all, every · v3
'All.' Nothing in the storehouses will be held back. Together with 'in all your borders' at the end, it gives the verse its sense of total loss.
-
אוֹצְרוֹתֶ֖יךָ
'otsrotekha · H214
treasury, storehouse, treasure · v3
'Your treasures': both the stores themselves and the treasuries that held them. In Judah the chief treasuries were those of the temple and the royal palace, which Babylon later emptied (2 Kgs 24:13; 25:13–17).
-
לָבַ֣ז
labaz · H957
plunder, spoil, booty · v3
'As plunder.' This is goods seized by a conquering army, the normal prize of ancient siege warfare. The picture is of Judah's riches handed to foreign soldiers.
-
אֶתֵּ֑ן
'etten · H5414
give, hand over · v3, v4
'I will give.' God is the one who hands it over. The invader is only the instrument. The verb is in the imperfect, the Hebrew form used for an action not yet complete, so this is a coming event. The main pause in the verse falls on this word.
-
בָּמֹתֶ֕יךָ
bamotekha · H1116
-
גְּבוּלֶֽיךָ׃
gevulekha · H1366
border; territory · v3
'Your borders,' meaning your whole territory as far as its boundaries reach. Hebrew often uses the border to stand for the land it encloses: the high places were everywhere in Judah, and the loss will be everywhere too.
-
וְשָׁמַטְתָּ֗ה
veshamattah · H8058
to let drop, release · v4
'And you will let go / let drop.' This is the verb of the sabbatical-year 'release' (Deut 15:1–3; Exod 23:11). Judah, which never gave the land and its debtors their release, will now be made to release the land itself.
-
וּבְךָ֙
uvekha · H9031
and in/by you · v4
Literally 'and in/by you.' Read as it stands, it stresses that the loss is your own doing ('even by yourself'). Many scholars think it was miscopied from 'your hand' (see textual notes).
-
מִנַּחֲלָֽתְךָ֙
minnachalatekha · H5159
inheritance, allotted holding · v4
'From your inheritance': the family land handed down within the clan, and on a national scale the land of Israel as God's grant. The people will be pulled loose from it.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
asher · H0834A
which, that · v4
Introduces the clause describing the inheritance.
-
לָ֔ךְ
lakh · H9032
to you · v4
'To you.' This is the pause-position form of the masculine 'to you'. It looks like the feminine form, which is why the supplied lemma tag says 2f, but the morphology (2ms) is right.
-
וְהַעֲבַדְתִּ֙יךָ֙
vehaʿavadtikha · H5647G
I will make you serve · v4
'And I will make you serve,' i.e. put you into forced labour or subjection. God himself does it: the people who would not serve him will be made to serve enemies.
-
אֶת־
et · H0853
[direct object marker] · v4
Marks 'your enemies' as those whom Judah will serve. It is not translated.
-
אֹ֣יְבֶ֔יךָ
oyevekha · H0341
enemy · v4
'Your enemies': in context the invading power from the north, which turned out to be Babylon.
-
בָּאָ֖רֶץ
baʾarets · H0776G
land, country · v4
'In the land.' Here it means a foreign territory, set against the inheritance-land just named.
-
לֹֽא־
lo · H3808
not · v4
Negates 'you have known.'
-
יָדָ֑עְתָּ
yadaʿta · H3045
to know · v4
'You have not known': an unfamiliar, foreign land with no ancestral ties. The phrase repeats the covenant curse of Deut 28:36, 64.
-
כִּֽי־
ki · H3588A
for, because · v4
Gives the reason for the whole sentence of judgment.
-
אֵ֛שׁ
esh · H0784
fire · v4
'A fire.' It is the object of 'you have kindled' and the subject of 'it will burn.' Fire is the standard Hebrew picture of divine anger. Some modern versions leave the word out and simply say 'kindled my anger'.
-
קְדַחְתֶּ֥ם
qedachtem · H6919
to kindle, ignite · v4
'You (plural) have kindled.' The address suddenly moves from the singular 'you' (Judah as one person) to the people as a group. Their actions struck the spark.
-
בְּאַפִּ֖י
beʾappi · H0639G
nose, nostril; anger · v4
'In my nostril / in my anger.' The Hebrew word for anger is the word for the nose, which flares and snorts in rage. The picture is a fire lit inside God's own flaring nostrils.
-
עַד־
ʿad · H5704
until, as far as · v4
'Until': with the next word it gives the time-span.
-
עוֹלָ֥ם
ʿolam · H5769G
long duration, perpetuity · v4
'Perpetuity': a stretch of time with no end in sight. It is not a technical claim about endless eternity. Jeremiah elsewhere limits the exile to seventy years and promises a return.
-
תּוּקָֽד׃
tuqad · H3344
The world behind it
Jeremiah's Judah (about 627–586 BC). Jeremiah preached in the last decades of the kingdom of Judah, from King Josiah's religious reform through the reigns of Jehoiakim and Zedekiah to the Babylonian destruction of Jerusalem. Josiah had torn down local altars and Asherah poles (2 Kgs 23), but according to Jeremiah the worship at these sites came back or never really stopped. Verse 2 says even the children "remember their altars and Asherah poles" by the green trees and on the high hills. Many people also trusted that the temple and its sacrifices would protect them whatever they did (Jer 7:4–11).
Writing that lasts. In the ancient Near East, important things were cut into stone: royal victories, law codes, boundary markers, treaties. Hezekiah's Siloam tunnel inscription is a Judean example. Everyday writing was in ink on potsherds, papyrus or wax-coated boards, and it could be erased or destroyed. Jeremiah 36 tells of King Jehoiakim cutting Jeremiah's scroll apart and burning it. Jeremiah's audience would have understood that something written "with an iron stylus" was meant to be permanent and public.
The altar's horns. Israelite altars had raised points at the four corners. In the sacrificial system (Lev 4; 16), the blood of the ḥaṭṭaʾt (sin or purification offering) was daubed on these horns to cleanse the altar from the pollution that the people's sins caused. A person in danger could also grab the altar horns to claim sanctuary (1 Kgs 1:50; 2:28). Excavated horned altars from Beersheba, Megiddo and Dan show what Jeremiah's hearers would have pictured.
Place in the chapter. Verses 1–4 announce that Judah will lose its land and serve enemies, and verses 3–4 closely repeat 15:13–14. Then come a curse on the one who trusts in human strength and a blessing on the one who trusts the LORD (vv. 5–8), followed by "the heart is deceitful above all things… I the LORD search the heart" (vv. 9–10). Verse 1 opens the heart theme of the whole section.
From the study of Jeremiah 17:1.
Where scholars differ
in v1
Why are Jeremiah 17:1–4 missing from the Greek Septuagint?
-
The Greek reflects an earlier, shorter Hebrew edition of Jeremiah, and these verses were added later in the Hebrew tradition.
Septuagint Jeremiah is consistently shorter and differently ordered. Qumran fragments (4QJer^b,d) confirm that a Hebrew text like the Greek existed (Tov). Verses 3–4 duplicate 15:13–14, the kind of repetition the expanded edition tends to add.
-
The verses were original but left out of the Greek, either deliberately because 3–4 repeat 15:13–14 or by accident.
Verses 1–2 are not a duplicate and fit the heart and altar themes of chapter 17 closely. They also lead naturally into vv. 5–10. Some commentators (e.g. Lundbom) treat the passage as authentic Jeremianic poetry.
in v1
What is šāmîr?
-
Emery or corundum, a very hard abrasive stone.
Ezekiel 3:9 calls it harder than flint. Emery was used in antiquity for cutting and polishing. Greek smyris, 'emery', may be a related word.
-
Diamond.
Vulgate 'adamantine' and the long English tradition. Diamond is the hardest substance, which fits the point. But it is doubtful that diamond was known or used in Iron Age Judah.
-
Flint.
Flint points were common cutting tools (NIV). But Ezekiel 3:9 sets šāmîr above flint in hardness.
in v1
Is the original reading 'your altars' or 'their altars'?
-
'Your altars' (Masoretic Text) is original.
It is the harder reading, and copyists tend to smooth such shifts. Jeremiah often switches suddenly between 'they' and 'you' when accusing.
-
'Their altars' is original or should be read for sense.
Some Hebrew manuscripts and ancient versions (Vulgate, Syriac, Targum) have it. It matches 'their heart' and verse 2. BHS notes it as a possible correction.
in v2
Are the 'children' the ones remembering, or the ones remembered?
-
Children are the subject: 'while/even their children remember their altars'. Idolatry has been passed down to the next generation.
This is the most natural reading of a verb form followed directly by a noun that does the action. It fits Deuteronomy's theme of passing memory on to children (Deut 6:7, 20). It is followed by KJV, ESV, NIV, BSB and WEB.
-
Children are the object: 'as they remember their children, (so they remember) their altars'. The shrines are as dear to the people as their own sons.
The grammar allows a verb form of this kind to take a direct object with its subject left unstated, so the comparison reading is possible. It is followed by NASB. Some connect it to Jeremiah's charges of child sacrifice (7:31; 19:5), though the verse does not mention sacrifice.
in v2
Is 17:1–4 original to Jeremiah's book?
-
Original or early material, missing from the Greek through accident or the translator's choice.
The vocabulary and themes are typical of Jeremiah (2:20; 3:6, 13). The omission may be explained by the near-duplicate 15:13–14, which may have led the translator or his source to skip the passage.
-
A later expansion in the Hebrew edition of the book.
The Old Greek reflects a shorter and in places earlier Hebrew edition, as Hebrew Jeremiah fragments from Qumran show (e.g. 4QJerb,d). Passages missing from it are often judged to be additions.
in v3
Is 'my mountain in the open country' a direct address to Zion, or the end of verse 2?
-
It belongs to verse 3 and means 'my mountain,' i.e. Jerusalem/Zion, either addressed directly or listed among the things handed over.
The Masoretic vowels, verse division and accents; the old poetic use of harar for sacred mountains (Ps 87:1); Jeremiah addresses Jerusalem by a landscape title in 21:13; the irony fits Jeremiah's attack on misplaced trust in Zion (Jer 7).
-
Read 'mountains in the open country' as the last item in verse 2's list of shrine locations.
The same consonants allow a plural construct; it gives a natural three-part list (green trees, high hills, mountains); it removes the sudden shift to 'my' among second-person 'your' forms. Followed by RSV/NRSV/ESV and many commentators.
in v3
Does 'your high places' belong in the verse, or is it a corruption of 'for a price' (cf. 15:13)?
-
Correct to 'as the price of (your sin),' following 15:13.
The doublet's wording is otherwise close; במחיר and במתיך look alike in Hebrew script; the corrected text reads smoothly. Adopted by NRSV and by commentators such as Holladay.
-
Keep the Masoretic 'your high places.'
It is the only surviving Hebrew reading (the Septuagint has no verse here). It fits the context of altars and Asherahs in verses 1–2 and makes sense as Jeremiah deliberately adapting his own earlier oracle. Defended by more conservative commentators such as Lundbom.
in v3
Why does the Septuagint lack 17:1–4?
-
The Greek reflects a shorter, earlier Hebrew edition of Jeremiah, and the Masoretic text added the passage later.
The Dead Sea Scrolls include Hebrew fragments of Jeremiah close to the shorter Greek form (4QJer^b,d), showing that a shorter Hebrew edition existed (Tov, Janzen).
-
The Greek translator, or the Hebrew text he used, dropped the passage, possibly because it repeated 15:13–14 or through a copying slip.
The passage reads as integral to its context in style and vocabulary. Some commentators (e.g. Lundbom) attribute many of the Septuagint's minuses in Jeremiah to accidental omission by a copyist.
in v4
Should 'and by you' (וּבְךָ) be corrected to 'your hand' (יָדְךָ)?
-
Correct it to 'your hand': 'you will let your hand drop from your inheritance.'
The received text is grammatically awkward. With 'your hand' the phrase reproduces the release law of Deut 15:2–3 almost word for word. ב and יד could plausibly be confused in copying. Followed by RSV/ESV and noted in the BHS apparatus.
-
Keep the Masoretic text as emphatic 'even by yourself / through your own fault.'
No Hebrew manuscript reads 'your hand'. The traditional reading makes sense as stressing that Judah is responsible. Followed by KJV, NASB, NIV, BSB.
in v4
Does 'it will burn forever' mean a permanent, final rejection?
-
It is lasting but bounded: an indefinitely long, unquenchable historical judgment.
ʿolam often means 'for life / for a long age' (Exod 21:6; 1 Sam 1:22). Jeremiah sets seventy years (25:11–12; 29:10) and promises restoration (chs. 30–33). The verb's ongoing form stresses that the fire keeps burning, not that it is metaphysically eternal.
-
In its own oracle it is meant absolutely, announcing that the relationship between this generation and the land is finished.
The oracle of 17:1–4 offers no qualification, and Jeremiah's early oracles often present judgment as irreversible (e.g. 15:1). Hope in the book comes in separate, later oracles, which some scholars think were added in later stages of the book's formation.
Sources
- HALOT s.v. שָׁמִיר, חָרַשׁ, לוּחַ, קֶרֶן
- BDB s.v. חַטָּאת, לֵב, עֵט, צִפֹּרֶן
- J. Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible) on the ḥaṭṭaʾt as purification offering
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
- W. McKane, Jeremiah (ICC), vol. 1
- E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, on the two editions of Jeremiah
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia apparatus at Jer 17:1
- Vulgate, Jeremiah 17:1
- BDB s.v. זָכַר, אֲשֵׁרָה, רַעֲנָן
- HALOT s.v. אֲשֵׁרָה; רַעֲנָן
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 17:1–4
- J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible), on 17:1–4
- W. McKane, Jeremiah (ICC), vol. 1, on 17:1–4
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 17:1–4
- Kuntillet ʿAjrud and Khirbet el-Qom inscriptions ('YHWH and his asherah')
- Ugaritic texts on Athirat
- E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, on the shorter Septuagint text of Jeremiah
- BDB s.v. הָרָר, חַיִל, אוֹצָר, בָּמָה, גְּבוּל
- HALOT s.v. בָּמָה; חַיִל; שָׂדֶה
- W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 15:13–14 and 17:1–4
- W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC), on 17:1–4
- J. G. Janzen, Studies in the Text of Jeremiah
- J. H. Walton, V. H. Matthews, M. W. Chavalas, IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 17:1–4
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), line 3 (bmt)
- 2 Kings 18:4; 20:13–17; 23:8; 24:13; 25:13–17; Micah 3:12; Jeremiah 26:18
- BDB s.v. שָׁמַט, נַחֲלָה, עוֹלָם, יָקַד
- HALOT s.v. שׁמט, קדח, יקד, עוֹלָם
- BHS critical apparatus at Jer 17:4
- W. McKane, Jeremiah vol. 1 (ICC)
- Deut 15:1–3; 28:36, 48, 64; 32:22; Lev 25:23; 26:34–35; 2 Chr 36:21; Jer 15:13–14; 34:8–22
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).