Job Chapter 34 Read as one passage

Job 34:1–9

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

1Then Elihu continued: 2“Hear my words, O wise men; give ear to me, O men of learning. 3For the ear tests words as the mouth tastes food. 4Let us choose for ourselves what is right; let us learn together what is good. 5For Job has declared, ‘I am righteous, yet God has deprived me of justice. 6Would I lie about my case? My wound is incurable, though I am without transgression.’ 7What man is like Job, who drinks up derision like water? 8He keeps company with evildoers and walks with wicked men. 9For he has said, ‘It profits a man nothing that he should delight in God.’

What the first hearers heard

To readers of the book of Job, steeped in Israel's wisdom tradition, this line would sound like the familiar opening of a sage's address or a public pronouncement: "Hear… give ear." It sets Elihu up as a man claiming the authority to speak before a council of the discerning.

It also changes the dynamic of the debate. Elihu no longer speaks to Job (as in ch. 33) but about him to a group of judges. That moves the conversation from personal argument toward a verdict. The appeal to "wise ones" and "knowing ones" invites the audience, and by extension the book's readers, to weigh Elihu's case themselves. Verse 3's proverb about the ear testing words like the palate tasting food makes that the explicit task. Readers who remembered Elihu's earlier dismissal of the friends' wisdom (32:7–12) might also hear a challenge in the address: show that you really are wise by judging rightly now.

From the study of Job 34:2.

Verse by verse

  1. 1Then Elihu continued:

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 2“Hear my words, O wise men; give ear to me, O men of learning.

    "Listen to my words, you wise ones. You who know how to judge, turn your ears to me."

    Elihu opens his second speech with a formal call to attention, the kind a sage or a speaker in a public council would use. The two lines say the same thing twice, which is how Hebrew poetry works. "Hear" is matched by "give ear", a verb made from the word for ear. "Wise ones" is matched by "those who know". The thing to be heard, "my words", sits in the middle. Elihu offers both what he says ("my words") and himself ("to me") for judgment.

    The people he addresses are not described as educated or "learned" in a modern sense. They are people with skilled, experienced judgment, the kind of hearers who can weigh an argument. The next verse makes this clear: "for the ear tests words as the palate tastes food." Elihu is calling a jury of discerning listeners. Job is now spoken about in the third person (vv. 5–9), and these listeners are invited to decide with Elihu "what is right" (v. 4). The address may also carry an edge, since Elihu has just said the friends' age-old wisdom failed (32:7–12).

    Full study →
  3. 3For the ear tests words as the mouth tastes food.

    "Listen to me, you wise men," Elihu says, "because the ear exists to put words to the proof, just as the palate tastes food before it is eaten."

    The verse is a proverb, a statement of how things always are. Some things are not visible on the surface. Metal is assayed to show whether it is real silver, and a mouthful of food is tasted before it is swallowed. In the same way, a speech is weighed by the ear before it is accepted. The word for "taste" in Hebrew also produces the word for "good judgment," so the comparison is closer than it sounds in English: listening well is a kind of tasting, a judgment about whether something is good to take in.

    The line is not new. It is almost word for word what Job himself said in 12:11 ("Does not the ear test words as the palate tastes its food?"). Elihu takes Job's own proverb about weighing what you hear and uses it against him. He invites the wise to test Job's claims, which he quotes in the next verses, and his own reply. Verse 4 states the goal with a similar-sounding verb: having tested (bāḥan), "let us choose (bāḥar) what is just."

    Full study →
  4. 4Let us choose for ourselves what is right; let us learn together what is good.

    "Let us settle on the right verdict for ourselves. Among ourselves, let us find out what is good."

    Elihu, the young man who has kept silent through all the earlier speeches, is speaking to a circle of men he calls "wise" and "knowledgeable" (v. 2). He speaks to them as if they were a panel of judges. The first word in the Hebrew, for emphasis, is mishpāṭ. It means a just ruling, the decision a fair court would reach. This is the same word Job is about to be quoted using in the next verse, where he says God "has taken away my mishpāṭ", that is, God has refused him his right and denied him a fair hearing. So the court Elihu calls together will rule on Job's own claim that he has been denied justice.

    "Let us choose" follows from the image just before it: "the ear tests words as the palate tastes food" (v. 3). In Hebrew, "test" (bāḥan) and "choose" (bāḥar) sound almost the same. First you taste the arguments, then you keep the one that proves sound. Choosing here is not following a preference. It means weighing the arguments and committing to the verdict that holds up. "For ourselves" and "among ourselves" make it a group decision. The listeners are to work it out together and reach a shared finding, not just accept what Job or Elihu tells them.

    The second line repeats the first in other words: "let us know what is good." Here "good" (ṭôv) means the sound conclusion. It also keeps a little of the food image, as in what is good to taste. Together the two lines declare a trial open: let's examine Job's case properly and agree on the just verdict. The verdict Elihu himself goes on to argue for is that God never perverts justice (34:10–12).

    Full study →
  5. 5For Job has declared, ‘I am righteous, yet God has deprived me of justice.

    Elihu turns to the circle of wise men and reads out the charge, the way a statement is read into the record at a trial: "Job has said: 'I am in the right — my case is just, I have done nothing to deserve this — and yet God, the very one who should guarantee justice, has pushed my claim aside and refused me the ruling I am owed.'"

    Both halves are courtroom language. "I am righteous" does not mean "I am morally flawless." It means "I am innocent in this dispute." "God has taken away my right" pictures a judge who throws a just case out of court before it is heard. Elihu is quoting Job nearly word for word (27:2, "God, who has taken away my right"), but he squeezes Job's long, anguished lawsuit into one blunt sentence. The question he then puts to the council is: can a man say this about God and be right?

    Full study →
  6. 6Would I lie about my case? My wound is incurable, though I am without transgression.’

    Elihu, the young speaker who enters at the end of the debate, is quoting Job, or rather putting Job's complaint in Job's mouth as he understands it:

    "Am I supposed to perjure myself about my own case? Am I, who am in the right, to be branded a liar? The arrow lodged in me is deadly and past all healing, and I never once broke faith with him."

    The picture is a courtroom combined with a battlefield. Job has a legal case (mishpat) that deserves a verdict, but the verdict seems to have been carried out on his body before any hearing. If he admits guilt to make his suffering make sense, he would be lying. If he keeps protesting, his suffering seems to call him a liar. The Hebrew can be read either way, and both sit in the line.

    The wound is described as "my arrow": the arrow shot into me, by an archer everyone in the conversation knows is God (compare 6:4, "the arrows of the Almighty are in me"). The arrow is incurable, the word Jeremiah uses for a wound no healer can close, and it means Job expects to die with his case unresolved.

    Last comes the sharpest claim: "without pesha'." This is not "I have never done anything wrong." Pesha' is rebellion, the deliberate breaking of loyalty that a vassal commits against his lord. Job denies ever revolting against God, and so denies that such a blow was deserved. Elihu quotes this so that he can refute it.

    Full study →
  7. 7What man is like Job, who drinks up derision like water?

    "Has there ever been a man like Job? He gulps down mockery the way a thirsty man drinks water."

    Elihu is speaking to a circle of sages (34:2). He has just quoted Job's own words: "I am righteous, yet God has denied me justice… my wound is incurable, though I am without transgression" (vv. 5–6). Now he gives his verdict on that kind of talk. The question "Who is like Job?" is an exclamation, not a request for information: no one else talks like this. The second line paints the picture. Scoffing, the contemptuous ridicule of what ought to be revered (here, God's justice), has become Job's ordinary drink. The verb describes a habit: he keeps drinking it, freely and eagerly, as easily as water.

    The line deliberately echoes Eliphaz, who said humans "drink iniquity like water" (15:16). Elihu puts "mockery" where Eliphaz had "iniquity". For him, Job's offence lies mainly in his mouth. The next verse finishes the thought: talk like this puts Job in the company of evildoers (v. 8).

    Full study →
  8. 8He keeps company with evildoers and walks with wicked men.

    "He has taken the road as a sworn companion of those who manufacture trouble, walking the same way of life as the men who stand guilty."

    Elihu is still describing Job, the man of verse 7 "who drinks up scorn like water." The first verb pictures a traveller who has set out on a route. The rare word for "company" comes from a root meaning "to bind together," so Job is not a passer-by. He has joined the band. His fellow travellers are the "workers of trouble," the familiar enemies of the Psalms who scheme harm against the innocent. The second line repeats the charge in matching form. "Walking with" someone is Hebrew for sharing their way of life, and the people he walks with are "men of wickedness," a word that in court means the guilty party.

    The language echoes Psalm 1 ("does not walk in the counsel of the wicked… nor sit in the seat of scoffers") and turns it upside down. It also hands Job's own oath back to him ("If I have walked with falsehood," 31:5; calamity belongs to "the workers of trouble," 31:3). Verse 9 shows the grounds of the charge. The point is not Job's choice of friends but his words. By saying it does not pay to please God, Job has said what the wicked say, and so he has placed himself on their road.

    Full study →
  9. 9For he has said, ‘It profits a man nothing that he should delight in God.’

    Elihu is building a charge against Job before the "wise men" who are listening (34:2). He has just said Job keeps company with evildoers and walks with wicked men (v. 8). Now he gives his evidence: "For he has said, 'A person gains nothing, it is no use at all, from being on good terms with God, from being someone God is pleased with.'"

    The sentence is Elihu's summary of Job, in Elihu's words. It is not Job's own sentence. The word for "gain" or "be of use" is a word already in play in the debate: Eliphaz had asked whether a human being is of any use to God (22:2). Elihu now says Job's real complaint is the reverse: God is of no use to the human being. The phrase translated "delight in God" describes standing in God's favour, a friendly and accepted relationship (the same verb is used when God accepts an offering). It is not mainly about inner devotional pleasure. The repeated "with" carries the sting: Job, Elihu says, keeps company with the wicked because he has decided that being on good terms with God gets you nothing. Elihu then calls on the listeners in verse 10 to reject this as an insult to God's justice: "Far be it from God to do wrong."

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v2

    men of learning (BSB, NIV)

    yodeʿim

    What we hear
    Educated or scholarly people: the academically trained, the well-read.
    What they heard
    'Those who know': people with discernment and experienced understanding who can judge rightly. The qualification is the ability to test words (v. 3), not formal education.
  • in v3

    meat (KJV: "as the mouth tasteth meat")

    leʾekhol (from ʾakal, 'to eat')

    What we hear
    Animal flesh.
    What they heard
    Simply 'eating' or 'food' in general. Nothing points to meat in particular.
  • in v3

    trieth / tries (KJV, WEB)

    tivḥan (from bāḥan)

    What we hear
    Attempts, makes an effort with.
    What they heard
    Tests, assays, puts to the proof, as a metalworker tests silver.
  • in v4

    judgment (KJV, YLT)

    mishpāṭ

    What we hear
    Either condemnation and punishment ('judgment day'), or one person's good sense or opinion ('use your judgment').
    What they heard
    A just verdict: what a fair hearing would rule in the case, and with it the right Job claims he was denied (v. 5).
  • in v5

    I am righteous

    ṣādaqtî

    What we hear
    I am morally perfect / I am holier than others (heard as smug self-righteousness).
    What they heard
    I am in the right in this dispute. It is a legal plea of innocence: I have done nothing that deserves this treatment.
  • in v5

    God hath taken away my judgment (KJV)

    hēsîr mišpāṭî

    What we hear
    God has taken away my good sense or discernment, or God has sentenced me.
    What they heard
    God has set aside my case, or my legal right, and denied me the just ruling I am owed.
  • in v6

    without transgression

    bəlî fešaʿ

    What we hear
    Without any sin at all; a claim to be morally perfect.
    What they heard
    Without rebellion: Job denies any deliberate breach of loyalty against God that would deserve this punishment. He does not deny ordinary faults, which he admits elsewhere (7:21; 13:26).
  • in v6

    my right (KJV, ESV)

    mishpāṭî

    What we hear
    My personal rights or entitlements.
    What they heard
    My legal case: my claim to a fair verdict in a dispute.
  • in v8

    workers of iniquity

    pōʿălê ʾāwen

    What we hear
    People who commit sins in general, in churchly language.
    What they heard
    People who habitually produce ʾāwen: trouble, harm and deceit aimed at others. In the Psalms they are the psalmist's scheming enemies.
  • in v9

    delight in God / delight himself with God

    birṣōtô ʿim-ʾĕlōhîm

    What we hear
    Taking personal, emotional pleasure in God, like the devotional 'Delight yourself in the LORD' (Ps 37:4).
    What they heard
    Being on good terms with God, standing in his favour and goodwill. The verb is the one used for God accepting a worshipper or an offering, and with 'with' it describes a friendly relationship. The line asks whether that relationship brings a person any benefit.
Every word
  1. שִׁמְע֣וּ

    shimʿu · H8085

    hear (plural command) · v2

    A plural command that opens the speech: 'Listen!' In Hebrew, 'hearing' means attending closely enough to weigh and respond, and that is the sense Elihu wants, since in the next verse the ear 'tests' words.

  2. חֲכָמִ֣ים

    ḥakhamim · H2450

    wise ones · v2

    Spoken directly to the listeners: 'you wise ones.' It names the people who were known for skill in judging life and speech, the kind who sat in council. Whether Elihu means this sincerely or with a touch of irony is debated (see debates).

  3. מִלָּ֑י

    millay · H4405

    my words · v2, v3

    'My words', meaning my speech or my arguments. מִלָּה is a poetic word, close to Aramaic, and almost all its biblical uses are in Job. Elihu leans on it heavily. The word is placed between the two halves of the address, so it is the thing the wise are asked to receive.

  4. וְ֝יֹדְעִ֗ים

    veyodeʿim · H3045

    and knowing ones · v2, v4

    'And you who know.' This participle of 'to know' is used as a noun for people with knowledge: experienced, discerning people who can tell right from wrong. It is not a word for formal schooling. It pairs with 'wise ones' and means much the same.

  5. הַאֲזִ֥ינוּ

    haʾazinu · H0238

    give ear (plural command) · v2

    A verb formed from 'ear' (ozen): 'turn your ear', 'lend your ear'. It is the standard formal partner of 'hear' in solemn openings (Deut 32:1; Isa 1:2). It also sets up the next verse, 'for the ear (ozen) tests words.'

  6. לִֽי׃

    li · H9030

    to me · v2

    'To me.' The first half asks for attention to 'my words', the second for attention to 'me'. The speaker and his speech are offered together for the hearers to judge.

  7. כִּי־

    ki · H3588

    for, because · v3, v5, v9

    Gives the reason for verse 2's call to 'hear' and 'give ear': listen to me, because the ear is the organ made for judging words. It ties the proverb to the summons before it.

  8. אֹ֭זֶן

    ʾozen · H241

    ear · v3

    The ear as the place where speech is received and weighed. It picks up verse 2's verb 'give ear' (haʾazinu, from the same root), so Elihu is saying: use the ear for what ears are for.

  9. תִּבְחָ֑ן

    tivḥan · H974

    to test, examine, assay · v3

    To put something through a trial so its true quality shows, as a smelter tests metal. The verb is feminine to agree with 'ear'. The present-habitual verb form states what the ear always does: it is a general truth, not a single event.

  10. וְ֝חֵ֗ךְ

    veḥekh · H2441

    palate, roof of the mouth · v3

    The palate, the organ of taste. In Job it also stands for the organ that discerns and speaks (Job 6:30), so it is a natural partner to the ear as an instrument of judgment.

  11. יִטְעַ֥ם

    yitʿam · H2938

    to taste, perceive · v3

    To taste food. The root also gives the noun taʿam, 'discernment, good sense' (1 Sam 25:33; Ps 119:66), so tasting is already a picture of judging.

  12. לֶאֱכֹֽל׃

    leʾekhol · H398

    to eat · v3

    Literally 'to eat' or 'for eating': the palate tastes before swallowing, or tastes what is to be eaten. Most translations reasonably render it 'food'. Job 12:11 has the noun ʾokhel, 'food', in the same place.

  13. מִשְׁפָּ֥ט

    mishpāṭ · H4941

    justice, judgment, verdict, right · v4, v5, v6

    The right ruling in a disputed case: what a fair court would decide. It comes first in the Hebrew for emphasis, and Job uses the same word in the next verse when he says God has 'taken away my mishpat', meaning his right or his case.

  14. נִבְחֲרָה־

    nivḥărāh · H977

    to choose, select; (by testing) to prove · v4

    'Let us choose.' The form is a 'let us' invitation (cohortative). The choosing comes after testing: it means weighing the arguments and settling on the verdict that holds up, not picking whatever you like. It echoes 'tests' (tivḥān) in v. 3.

  15. לָּ֑נוּ

    lānû · H9035

    for us, for ourselves · v4

    'For ourselves.' The listeners are to come to the verdict themselves, as a panel of judges, instead of taking Job's or Elihu's word for it.

  16. בֵינֵ֣ינוּ

    bênênû · H996

    between, among · v4

    'Between us, among ourselves.' It pictures a group talking it over and comparing views. The words are said in front of everyone, so this is not secret discussion. BSB's 'together' captures this.

  17. מַה־

    mah · H4100

    what? · v4

    Here it is not a question. It introduces the thing to be found out: 'what [is] good'.

  18. טּֽוֹב׃

    ṭôv · H2896

    good, pleasant, fitting · v4

    What is good, sound and fitting. In the second line it matches mishpāṭ in the first, so here it means the good, right conclusion in Job's case. It also carries the sense of something that tastes good, which follows on from the tasting image in v. 3.

  19. אָ֭מַר

    ʾāmar · H0559

    to say · v5, v9

    Perfect tense, 'has said'. Elihu is citing Job's earlier words as evidence before the listening wise men, the way a witness's statement would be read out in court.

  20. אִיּ֣וֹב

    ʾiyyôb · H0347

    Job · v5, v7

    Elihu names Job outright, in the third person, to the gathered elders (34:2). That makes Job the defendant whose statement is under review.

  21. צָדַ֑קְתִּי

    ṣādaqtî · H6663

    to be in the right, be just, be innocent · v5

    A verb that describes a state: 'I am in the right.' It is courtroom language. Job is saying his case is just and he does not deserve what has happened to him. He is not claiming to be sinless.

  22. וְ֝אֵ֗ל

    wəʾēl · H0410G

    and God · v5

    ʾĒl is the short, old poetic name for God that Job uses often. The 'and' joins two clauses that clash, so 'yet' or 'but' fits: I am in the right, yet God…

  23. הֵסִ֥יר

    hēsîr · H5493G

    to remove, turn aside, take away · v5

    Causative form, 'has made to turn aside, has removed'. Job pictures his legal claim being pushed off the table, so it never gets a hearing.

  24. עַל־

    ʿal · H5921A

    upon, concerning, against, in spite of · v6

    A flexible preposition. It can mean 'concerning' ("should I lie about my case?") or 'in spite of' ("although I am in the right, I am a liar"). Job uses it in that second sense elsewhere (10:7, 'although you know'; 16:17, 'although there is no violence in my hands'), which makes 'in spite of' a strong option.

  25. אֲכַזֵּ֑ב

    ʾăkhazzēv · H3576

    to lie, to be false; (intensive form) to make or prove a liar · v6

    Either a protesting question ('Am I to lie?', meaning 'Should I confess a guilt I don't have?') or a complaint ('I am counted a liar'). In both readings Job's truthfulness is pitted against the verdict his suffering seems to declare.

  26. אָנ֖וּשׁ

    ʾānûsh · H0605

    incurable, desperately sick, mortal · v6

    Describes the arrow-wound as past healing and deadly. It is the word Jeremiah uses for his own 'incurable wound' (Jer 15:18). Because it sounds like 'enosh, 'frail mortal man', YLT renders it 'mortal'.

  27. חִצִּ֣י

    ḥiṣṣî · H2671

    arrow · v6

    Literally 'my arrow': not an arrow Job shoots but the one lodged in him. It recalls 6:4, 'the arrows of the Almighty are in me'. Most English versions turn it into 'my wound', which keeps the meaning but loses the picture of God as the archer.

  28. בְלִי־

    bəlî · H1097

    without, lacking, not · v6

    'Without'. It sets the deadly wound against the absence of any cause: he was struck without rebellion on his part.

  29. פָֽשַׁע׃

    fāshaʿ · H6588

    rebellion, transgression, breach of loyalty · v6

    The strongest Hebrew word for wrongdoing: a deliberate breach against someone you owe loyalty to. Job (as Elihu quotes him) is not claiming he has never done wrong. He is claiming he never broke faith with God in a way that could explain such a blow.

  30. מִי־

    mî · H4310

    who? · v7

    Opens a question that is really an exclamation of disapproval: 'Has there ever been a man like this?' Elihu isn't asking for information. He's holding Job up as one of a kind, and not in a good way.

  31. גֶ֥בֶר

    geḇer · H1397

    man, (strong) male · v7, v9

    A common poetic word for 'man', related to the root for strength. The supplied gloss 'great man' overstates it: in Job it usually just means a man, a human being in his manhood (e.g. 3:3, 14:10). Here it means 'what man anywhere?'

  32. יִֽשְׁתֶּה־

    yišteh · H8354

    to drink · v7

    Imperfect form, which here describes a habit: 'he drinks (and keeps drinking)'. The clause has no 'who' in Hebrew. It describes Job straight off. Drinking stands for taking something in eagerly and in quantity until it becomes part of you.

  33. לַּ֥עַג

    laʿag · H3933

    mockery, derision, scorn · v7

    Contemptuous ridicule, scoffing speech. In context, Elihu most likely means Job's own derisive talk against God's justice (vv. 5–6, 9), which Job takes in and pours out as easily as water.

  34. כַּמָּֽיִם׃

    kammāyim · H4325

    like (the) water · v7

    kə- ('like') plus the article and 'water'. 'Like water' means freely, constantly, without a second thought, the way a thirsty person gulps water. Here it marks something that ought to be shocking as routine for Job.

  35. וְאָרַ֣ח

    wəʾāraḥ · H0732

    to journey, travel a road · v8

    "And he has taken the road." This is the verb of the traveller on a route. Its related nouns ʾōraḥ ("path") and ʾōrēaḥ ("wayfarer") belong to the wisdom books' picture of life as a road. Here it picks up from verse 7 ("who drinks up scorn… and travels…") and describes Job as someone who has set out on the same route as the wicked.

  36. לְ֭חֶבְרָה

    ləḥebrâ · H2274

    company, association · v8

    "Into company, as a companion." The noun appears only here in the Hebrew Bible. It comes from ḥābar, "to join or bind together," so it pictures a joined band or partnership. It is stronger than happening to be in the same place.

  37. עִם־

    ʿim · H5973A

    with · v8, v9

    "Alongside, together with." It marks who he travels with.

  38. פֹּ֣עֲלֵי

    pōʿălê · H6466

    to do, work, practise · v8

    "Workers of, those who practise." This is an active participle used as a noun. The people are defined by what they habitually produce.

  39. אָ֑וֶן

    ʾāwen · H0205G

    trouble, harm, deceit, wickedness · v8

    "Trouble, mischief, harmful deceit." Together with the word before it, it forms the stock phrase pōʿălê ʾāwen, "workers of harm." Psalms and Job use it for people who bring ruin on others.

  40. וְ֝לָלֶ֗כֶת

    wəlāleket · H1980I

    to walk, go · v8

    "And so as to walk." Hebrew uses the infinitive with 'to' here to carry on the main verb, so it reads "and walking." In Hebrew, "walking" with someone stands for a habitual way of life and the company one chooses. Compare Psalm 1:1.

  41. אַנְשֵׁי־

    ʾanšê · H0582

    men, people · v8

    "Men of." This is the ordinary plural for people or men. Joined to an abstract noun, it describes people by their defining quality: "men characterised by wickedness."

  42. רֶֽשַׁע׃

    rešaʿ · H7562

    wickedness, guilt · v8

    "Wickedness, being in the wrong." The word comes from the same root as rāšāʿ. In a lawsuit, the rāšāʿ is the party found guilty, the opposite of the ṣaddîq, who is found in the right. In a book full of courtroom language, Elihu is placing Job on the guilty side.

  43. לֹ֣א

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v9

    A flat negation of the verb that follows: it does *not* benefit. In Elihu's version Job's claim is absolute: piety gets you nothing.

  44. יִסְכָּן־

    yiskon · H5532

    to be of use, benefit · v9

    'It is of use, it benefits.' This verb belongs to the vocabulary of the Job debate: Eliphaz uses it in 22:2 ('Can a man be of use to God?') and Elihu uses it again in 35:3. The question is practical. What does a person gain?

  45. בִּ֝רְצֹת֗וֹ

    birṣōtô · H7521

    to be pleased with, accept, be on good terms with · v9

    Literally 'in his being pleased', meaning 'when he is pleased', or 'by his being on good terms'. Joined to 'with God', it describes a relationship of goodwill and acceptance between the man and God. The line says even that relationship pays nothing.

  46. אֱלֹהִֽים׃

    ʾĕlōhîm · H0430G

    God · v9

    The general word for God. In the next verse Elihu switches to the poetic names El and Shaddai ('the Almighty') to answer the charge.

The world behind it

Elihu's speeches (Job 32–37). After Job and his three friends have fallen silent, a younger man, Elihu, steps in. He is angry at Job for justifying himself rather than God, and at the friends for failing to answer Job (32:2–3). Chapter 33 is addressed to Job directly ("hear my words… give ear", 33:1). Chapter 34 changes audience. Elihu now speaks to a plural group, "wise ones" and "knowing ones", and talks about Job (34:5–9, 35–37).

Wisdom as a public, court-like activity. In ancient Israel, disputes and hard questions were weighed in public, often by elders and respected men at the city gate. Job describes his own former place there (29:7–10, 21–23). Opening with "hear… give ear" was the conventional way to claim the floor for a weighty statement (compare Deut 32:1; Isa 1:2; Ps 49:1–3; Prov 4:1). Elihu's next lines carry the courtroom tone on: "Let us choose for ourselves what is right (mishpat, 'judgment, justice'); let us know among ourselves what is good" (34:4). The "wise" are cast as the bench that will rule on Job's claims.

From the study of Job 34:2.

Where scholars differ

in v2

Who are the 'wise ones' and 'knowing ones' Elihu addresses?

  • The three friends (Eliphaz, Bildad, Zophar), possibly addressed with irony.

    They are the only other speakers named as present. Elihu has just said their age-based wisdom failed and that none of them answered Job (32:7–12). Calling them 'wise ones' could be a pointed challenge to prove it.

  • A wider circle of sages or onlookers acting as a jury, beyond the three friends.

    Elihu never names the friends in ch. 34, and he speaks of Job in the third person as if before a council (34:5–9, 34–37). He appeals to 'men of heart' (34:10, 34) and 'the wise man who hears me' (34:34), and invites a shared verdict, 'let us choose… let us know among ourselves' (34:4). Several commentators (e.g. Clines) favour a general audience of the wise.

  • A conventional, open-ended address to any discerning hearer, including the book's readers.

    'Hear… give ear, you wise' is a stock opening of wisdom teaching (Prov 4:1; Ps 49:1–3). The literary effect is to invite whoever is wise to judge the argument, whether or not a particular group is pictured on stage.

in v3

Is Elihu using Job's proverb sincerely or turning it against him?

  • Elihu is sincere. He appeals to a shared, neutral standard of judgment that Job himself accepted, so the hearing will be fair.

    The proverb is a general truth. Elihu repeatedly invites response and correction (33:5, 32), and verse 4 speaks of choosing 'together' ('among ourselves').

  • It is a pointed rhetorical move. Elihu recycles Job's words so Job is judged by his own standard, and goes on to condemn him harshly (34:7–9, 34–37).

    Elihu quotes Job at length (33:8–11; 34:5–9), then says Job 'drinks scorn like water' and 'adds rebellion to his sin' (34:7, 37). The quotation sets up a verdict against him.

in v3

How is Elihu's role in the book to be valued?

  • Elihu is a real advance, preparing the way for God's speeches.

    His themes of God's justice, suffering as instruction, and the storm (ch. 36–37) anticipate the Lord's speech from the whirlwind (38:1). God does not rebuke him in 42:7.

  • Elihu is a brash latecomer whose speeches add little, or a later addition to the book.

    He is not mentioned in the prologue or epilogue, his style differs (heavier Aramaic colouring, as in forms like millin), and he largely repeats the friends' theology.

in v4

Who is the 'us' Elihu invites to choose the verdict?

  • The 'wise men' Elihu addresses: the listeners, possibly including the three friends, acting as a panel of judges.

    Verses 2, 10 and 34 address 'wise men' and 'men of understanding' in the plural, and this matches how elders heard cases at the town gate.

  • A wider appeal to anyone thoughtful, including the reader and perhaps Job himself.

    Elihu speaks to Job directly elsewhere (33:1; 34:33, 'you must choose, not I'), and the book's courtroom setting invites the audience to act as jurors.

in v4

Is Elihu's call to a fair hearing sincere, or has he already decided the verdict?

  • Sincere: Elihu offers a new and partly corrective voice that prepares the way for God's speeches.

    He criticizes the friends for failing to answer Job (32:3, 12). Some of his themes, such as God's greatness shown in the storm (ch. 37), lead into chapter 38.

  • Already decided: Elihu quotes Job selectively and assumes Job is guilty.

    34:7–9 and 34:35–37 call Job a scoffer and ask that he be tried 'to the end'. God's speeches and the epilogue (42:7) never mention Elihu. Many scholars also think chs. 32–37 were added to the book later.

in v5

Does Elihu represent Job fairly?

  • Yes, essentially. Elihu quotes Job's own words and correctly identifies the dangerous core of his position: accusing God of injustice.

    The verse matches Job 27:2 and sums up 9:15, 20 and 13:18. God himself later rebukes Job for 'darkening counsel' (38:2) and asks, 'Will you condemn me so that you may be in the right?' (40:8).

  • Only partly. Elihu's compressed quotation strips out Job's context and makes his plea sound like arrogance, much as the three friends had done.

    Job also said no one can be in the right before God (9:2) and admitted youthful sins (13:26). The narrator calls Job blameless (1:1). God says Job spoke 'what is right' about him (42:7) and never mentions Elihu. Elihu's follow-up charges in 34:7–9 go well beyond what Job said.

in v5

What does mišpāṭ mean in this verse and in the book's argument?

  • Here it is purely legal: Job's case or due verdict in a lawsuit.

    It is paired with ṣādaqtî and sits in a trial setting (34:2–6). Job uses mišpāṭ elsewhere for his case (13:18; 23:4).

  • The word shifts across the book. In Job's mouth it means litigation, but Elihu and God widen it to mean God's sovereign rule over creation.

    This is argued by S. H. Scholnick (JBL 1982). See 34:17 ('Shall one who hates justice govern?') and 40:8 ('Will you annul my mišpāṭ?'), which sit within speeches about God governing the world.

in v6

Is Job asking 'Should I lie?' or complaining 'I am counted a liar'?

  • Active question: 'Should I lie about my case?' Job refuses to confess guilt falsely.

    Follows the vowels of the Masoretic (standard Hebrew) text, where the piel is active. It matches Job's oath in 27:4–6 ('my lips will not speak falsehood... I will not put away my integrity'). Followed by KJV, NASB, BSB, YLT.

  • Passive or declarative: 'In spite of my right I am made out to be a liar.'

    'al often means 'in spite of' in Job (10:7; 16:17). The same verb form means 'prove a liar' in 24:25. Some read the vowels as a pual (passive). The ancient versions also place the falsehood outside Job. Followed by WEB, ESV, NIV, NLT.

in v6

Whose arrow is 'my arrow', and should the word be kept?

  • Keep 'arrow': it is God's arrow lodged in Job.

    Job 6:4 ('the arrows of Shaddai are in me'), 16:12–13 and Lam 3:12–13 use the same image. The Septuagint and Vulgate both keep 'arrow'. NIV and YLT preserve it.

  • Emend to 'my wound', or treat 'arrow' as a figure of speech for the wound.

    'Wound' gives smoother parallelism with 'incurable'. Most English versions translate it as 'wound', though few actually emend the Hebrew text.

in v6, v9

Is Elihu quoting Job fairly?

  • Broadly fair paraphrase.

    Job did say God took away his mishpat (27:2), protested his innocence (16:17; 23:10–12; 31) and described God's arrows (6:4).

  • A sharpened paraphrase that sets Job up for condemnation.

    Job never says 'without pesha'' in these words, and he admits sins (7:21; 13:26). Elihu's framing leads straight into his verdict that Job adds pesha' to his sin (34:37), while God later says Job spoke rightly (42:7).

in v7

Does Job give out mockery, or does he receive it?

  • Job is the mocker: he habitually takes in and produces scoffing speech, especially against God's justice.

    This is the majority view among commentators. It fits the near-identical idiom in 15:16, where the drinker practises the thing he drinks (iniquity), and Zophar's earlier charge that Job mocks (11:3). It also fits the context: Elihu has just quoted Job's protest (vv. 5–6), and in v. 8 he says Job keeps company with evildoers. The Septuagint ('sneering') reads it the same way.

  • Job swallows the mockery directed at him: he is the target of derision and soaks it up, or perhaps invites it.

    The noun laʿag often means being an object of scorn (Ps 44:13; 79:4; Ezek 23:32), and Job complains that he has become a laughingstock (12:4; 30:1, 9). A few interpreters read Elihu as saying Job brings ridicule on himself. The parallel with 15:16 and the flow into v. 8 make this less likely.

in v8

Is Elihu accusing Job of actually spending time with wicked people, or of siding with them in what he says?

  • Siding with them in what he says. By his words Job has taken the side of the wicked.

    Verse 9 gives the reason with "for" (kî): Job has said it does not profit a man to delight in God. That echoes words Job put in the mouth of the wicked (21:14–15). Nothing in the book suggests Job kept criminal company, and Job's oath in ch. 31 denies it. Most modern commentators (e.g. Habel, Clines, Hartley) read the verse this way.

  • Elihu is also suggesting actual moral association, in the traditional style of the friends.

    Eliphaz had earlier invented specific social crimes for Job (22:6–9) and asked whether he kept to 'the old way that wicked men have trodden' (22:15). Elihu's road language may continue that line of insinuation, whether or not he has evidence.

in v8

Who exactly are the pōʿălê ʾāwen, the 'workers of ʾāwen'?

  • A general term for evildoers: people who habitually cause harm and deceive.

    The phrase is used broadly in Psalms and Proverbs (e.g. Prov 10:29; 21:15) as the opposite of the righteous, with no hint of a technical meaning. This is the mainstream view.

  • Originally, people who use harmful supernatural power, such as sorcerers or curse-workers (a theory proposed by S. Mowinckel).

    ʾāwen is sometimes linked with deceptive words and idolatrous or occult practice (e.g. 1 Sam 15:23; Zech 10:2; 'Beth-aven'). In some laments the enemies harm the psalmist by speech. Most scholars think the theory explains too much, and nothing in Job 34:8 points to magic.

in v9

What does birṣōtô ʿim-ʾĕlōhîm describe: the man's delight in God, or his acceptance by God?

  • The man's pleasure or delight in God (KJV, BSB, ESV).

    The verb's subject is the man ('his being pleased'). With a human subject, rāṣāh can mean to like or take pleasure in something.

  • The man's standing in God's favour, being on good terms with him (NASB 'pleased with', NIV 'please God'; several commentators).

    Rāṣāh is the standard word for God's acceptance of worshippers. With ʿim ('with') it describes a relationship, as in Ps 50:18 if that verse uses this root. It also parallels 'keeps company with' in verse 8. The question in context is whether a good relationship with God pays.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. חָכָם, יָדַע, מִלָּה, אָזַן
  • HALOT s.v. מִלָּה; אזן (hiphil)
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (Old Testament Library)
  • J. E. Hartley, The Book of Job (NICOT)
  • M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
  • Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Job 34:2
  • STEPBible tagged Hebrew text (supplied lemma and morphology data)
  • BDB s.v. בָּחַן, טָעַם, מִלָּה, חֵךְ
  • HALOT s.v. בחן; טעם
  • Job 12:11; 6:30 (internal parallels)
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (WBC 18A)
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (OTL)
  • S. R. Driver & G. B. Gray, Job (ICC)
  • BDB s.v. מִשְׁפָּט, בָּחַר, בָּחַן, יָדַע, טוֹב
  • HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפָּט; בחר
  • N. C. Habel, The Book of Job (OTL), on the courtroom language of Job
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (WBC 18A), on 34:1–9
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 34:4; Vulgate Job 34:4
  • Cross-references: Job 12:11; 27:2; 34:2–5, 10–12, 33; Ruth 4:1–11; Isa 7:15–16
  • BDB s.v. צָדֵק, מִשְׁפָּט, סוּר
  • HALOT s.v. צדק, מִשְׁפָּט, סור
  • D. J. A. Clines, Job 21–37 (Word Biblical Commentary 18A)
  • S. H. Scholnick, 'The Meaning of Mišpat in the Book of Job,' JBL 101 (1982)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Job 34:5
  • Vulgate Job 34:5
  • BDB s.v. מִשְׁפָּט, כָּזַב, אָנַשׁ, חֵץ, פֶּשַׁע
  • HALOT s.v. כזב (piel 'make a liar'), אָנוּשׁ, פֶּשַׁע
  • Supplied interlinear data (lemma, Strong's, morphology) for Job 34:6
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia apparatus (proposed revocalisation אֲכֻזָּב)
  • Septuagint and Vulgate of Job 34:6 (as commonly cited)
  • Cross-references: Job 6:4; 10:7; 13:18; 16:12–17; 24:25; 27:2–6; 33:9; 34:37; Jer 15:18; Lam 3:12–13; Deut 32:23; 2 Kgs 8:20
  • BDB s.v. לַעַג; לָעַג
  • HALOT s.v. לַעַג
  • BDB s.v. שָׁתָה
  • HALOT s.v. גֶּבֶר
  • Septuagint, Job 34:7
  • Vulgate, Job 34:7
  • BDB s.v. אָרַח, חֶבְרָה, אָוֶן, רֶשַׁע
  • HALOT s.v. חֶבְרָה; אָוֶן
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar (GKC) on the infinitive construct continuing a finite verb
  • S. Mowinckel, Psalmenstudien I (on pōʿălê ʾāwen)
  • HALOT s.v. סכן I, רצה I
  • BDB s.v. סָכַן, רָצָה, גֶּבֶר
  • R. Gordis, The Book of Job: Commentary, New Translation and Special Studies
  • M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible 15)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.