Job Chapter 6 Read as one passage
Job 6:5–7
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
5Does a wild donkey bray over fresh grass, or an ox low over its fodder? 6Is tasteless food eaten without salt, or is there flavor in the white of an egg? 7My soul refuses to touch them; they are loathsome food to me.
What the first hearers heard
The first hearers would have taken this as an obvious rhetorical point from the world of herds and pasture. Everyone knew that a fed animal is a quiet animal. Two answers of "no" set up the unspoken conclusion: Job's loud complaint is evidence of real deprivation. It is not proof of foolishness or sin.
In the flow of the dialogue, the verse is part of Job's reply to Eliphaz (chs. 4–5):
- In 6:2–3 Job wishes his anguish could be weighed. It would be heavier than the sand of the sea, and that is why his words were rash.
- In 6:4 he names the cause: the poisoned arrows and terrors of God.
- In 6:5 comes the proof from nature: animals cry only when they lack something.
- In 6:6–7 he moves from animal feed to human food. Some food is tasteless and repulsive, and Job's soul refuses to touch it. This is his present lot, or possibly the counsel his friends have served him.
So the verse works as self-defence. Job asks his friends to judge his words in light of his suffering, not the other way round. It also sets up a theme the book returns to: a sufferer's protest should be heard as a cry of need, not explained away as a moral failure. At the end, God says Job spoke rightly where the friends did not (42:7–8).
From the study of Job 6:5.
Verse by verse
-
5Does a wild donkey bray over fresh grass, or an ox low over its fodder?
Full study →"Does the wild donkey of the steppe set up its harsh braying while it stands over fresh green grass? Does the ox bellow while it stands at its trough of good mixed feed? Of course not."
Job is taking a piece of farmyard common sense and using it to defend himself. Animals make that noise when they lack something. A wild onager has no one to feed it. When it finds green growth, it stops calling and eats. A stall ox with its owner's mixed fodder in front of it is quiet too. Every herdsman knew this, and Job had owned five hundred yoke of oxen and five hundred donkeys (Job 1:3).
The application is left for the listener to supply. My cry has a cause too. Just before this, Job admitted that his words "have been rash" (6:3). He now argues that his outburst in chapter 3 was not a fool's complaining, which is what Eliphaz had suggested (5:2). It was the cry of a creature that has been deprived, wounded by "the arrows of the Almighty" (6:4). The verb for "bray" is the one Job later uses for starving outcasts crying among the bushes (30:7). In the language of this book, braying is the sound of hunger. Do not blame the animal for the noise. Look at what it is missing.
-
6Is tasteless food eaten without salt, or is there flavor in the white of an egg?
Full study →"Does anyone eat bland food when there's no salt to season it? Is there any flavour at all in that slimy stuff, the slippery juice of mallow (or, as old Jewish tradition read it, the goo around an egg yolk)?"
Both questions expect the answer No, of course not. They come straight after another pair in v. 5: a wild donkey does not bray, and an ox does not bellow, when it has good fodder. Animals complain only when something is wrong with what they are given to eat. Job turns the picture on himself. What he has been given is like unsalted, slimy, tasteless food that nobody could stomach. So his loud complaint (his "braying", 6:2–3) is not senseless. It is the natural reaction to what has been put in front of him. Verse 7 finishes the thought: "I refuse to touch them; they are like sickness in my food."
Two words add depth. The word for "tasteless" (tāfēl) elsewhere means "empty, worthless", as in empty prophecy. The word for "flavour" (ṭa'am) also means "good sense" or "judgment". Job likes to compare testing words to tasting food (12:11), so a listener could also hear: "Is there any sense in this? Can anyone swallow advice with no salt in it?" That would be a jab at Eliphaz's tidy counsel in chapters 4–5. The main image is food, but the second meaning sits close to the surface.
The last word, ḥallāmût, occurs only here and its exact meaning is uncertain. Whatever it was, it stood for the most insipid, slimy food an ancient hearer could imagine.
-
7My soul refuses to touch them; they are loathsome food to me.
Full study →Job is answering his friend Eliphaz, and he has just defended his own angry outburst with two pictures from the farmyard and the kitchen. A wild donkey doesn't bray when it has grass (v. 5). No one can eat tasteless food without salt or find flavour in something slimy and bland (v. 6). Then he says, in effect:
"My throat refuses to touch it. My appetite won't come near. These things are like the food of a sick man, food that turns my stomach."
The word usually translated "soul" is the Hebrew for the throat and its appetite. It is the part of a person that hungers, swallows and gags, and through it Job speaks of his whole living self. The verb is not "cannot" but "refuses": his body digs in its heels. "Touch" means he won't so much as taste it. The last phrase, literally "like the sickness of my bread", ties his revulsion to the very illness he is suffering. What he is given to eat has become the kind of food a sick person can't keep down.
What "these things" stand for is left to the hearer. They may be the bland, unsalted comfort his friends are offering. They may be the bitter portion of suffering God has served him (v. 4 speaks of God's poisoned arrows). Either way, Job is saying that his complaint is as natural as a hungry animal's cry or a sick man's nausea. He is not being irreverent. He is reacting the way any living creature reacts to what cannot be swallowed.
Where the English drifted
-
in v5
loweth / low (KJV, BSB, WEB, YLT)
gaʿah
- What we hear
- Many readers do not recognise "low" as a verb. They may read KJV's "loweth" as "lowers" or take it to mean something about height.
- What they heard
- The deep mooing or bellowing of cattle, a sound that here signals want or distress (compare 1 Sam 6:12).
-
in v5
wild ass (KJV, YLT)
pere'
- What we hear
- To many modern ears "ass" sounds rude or comic. "Wild donkey" can also suggest a stray farm donkey.
- What they heard
- The onager, a separate wild species of the steppe that needs no keeper and goes looking for green pasture. The word carries no insult.
-
in v6
the white of an egg
rîr ḥallāmût
- What we hear
- The Hebrew clearly names egg white, a well-known bland food.
- What they heard
- 'The slime of ḥallāmût', where ḥallāmût is a word found only here. It may be egg yolk (so 'the slime around the yolk'), but it may just as well be a slimy plant such as mallow or purslane. The certainty in the English is not in the Hebrew.
-
in v6
unsavoury (KJV)
tāfēl
- What we hear
- Morally dubious or disreputable.
- What they heard
- Unseasoned, tasteless, flat. The word can extend to 'empty, worthless', but has nothing to do with being shady.
-
in v7
my soul (refuses)
nafshi (nefesh)
- What we hear
- Job's immaterial, spiritual inner self, as distinct from his body, recoils.
- What they heard
- My throat, my appetite: the bodily organ of hunger and swallowing, and through it Job as a living, desiring being. The image is physical gagging at food.
-
in v7
meat (KJV 'my sorrowful meat')
laḥmi (leḥem)
- What we hear
- Animal flesh.
- What they heard
- Bread, food in general. In 1611 'meat' meant any food.
Every word
-
הֲיִֽנְהַק־
hayinhaq · H5101
to bray (with question marker ha-) · v5
The prefix ha- turns the line into a question that expects the answer "no." The verb is a sound word for the harsh cry of a donkey. The only other place it appears is Job 30:7, where Job uses it of starving outcasts who "bray" among the bushes. The bray is a cry of need.
-
פֶּ֥רֶא
pere' · H6501
wild donkey, onager · v5
The onager, the wild ass of the steppe. It is untamed and roams far for grazing, and nobody feeds it (compare Job 39:5–8). Whether it eats depends entirely on finding pasture.
-
עֲלֵי־
ʿale · H5921A
upon, over, beside · v5
This is a longer, poetic form of ʿal. It pictures the animal standing over its food. The sense is "when it has grass in front of it," which is why KJV and WEB translate "when he hath grass."
-
דֶ֑שֶׁא
deshe' · H1877
-
אִ֥ם
ʾim · H0518H
if; in paired questions, "or" · v5, v6
This word introduces the second half of a paired question ("Does X...? Or does Y...?"). Both halves expect the answer "no."
-
יִגְעֶה־
yigʿeh · H1600
to low, bellow (of cattle) · v5
The deep call of cattle. The only other place it appears is 1 Samuel 6:12, where the milk cows low as they pull the ark away from their penned-up calves. In both places the sound comes from distress or want.
-
שּׁ֝֗וֹר
shor · H7794
ox, a head of cattle · v5
A single domestic bovine, the working ox of the farm. It is the tame partner to the wild donkey in the first line, so between them the two lines cover wild and domestic animals alike.
-
בְּלִילֽוֹ׃
belilo · H1098
-
הֲיֵאָכֵ֣ל
hayē'ākēl · H0398
to eat (here: is it eaten?) · v6
The question marker ha- plus a passive form of 'eat': 'Does anyone eat…?' / 'Can it be eaten?' The question expects the answer 'No', and it opens a pair of everyday food questions.
-
תָּ֭פֵל
tāfēl · H8602
bland, insipid, tasteless · v6
Food with no flavour, flat and unappetising. Elsewhere the word describes empty, worthless prophecy (Lamentations 2:14), so it can carry a hint of 'empty, no substance' as well as 'no taste'.
-
מִבְּלִי־
mibbəlî- · H1097
without, for lack of · v6
Literally 'from without': because there is no salt. It gives the reason the food is bland.
-
מֶ֑לַח
melaḥ · H4417
salt · v6
Ordinary table salt, the basic seasoning and preservative of the ancient Near East. Nothing ritual is meant here; the image is the kitchen.
-
יֶשׁ־
yesh- · H3426
there is · v6
'Is there any…?' The question asks whether any flavour exists at all.
-
טַ֝֗עַם
ṭa'am · H2940
taste, flavour; discernment, good sense · v6
First of all 'flavour'. But the same word means 'good sense, judgment' elsewhere (1 Samuel 25:33; Job 12:20), so a hearer could also catch the question 'Is there any sense in this?'
-
בְּרִ֣יר
bərîr · H7388
in the slime/spittle of · v6
rîr is slimy fluid, the word for the spittle David let run down his beard when he pretended to be mad (1 Samuel 21:13). It points to something gooey and slick, a texture as off-putting as the taste.
-
חַלָּמֽוּת׃
ḥallāmût · H2495
a bland, slimy food (mallow/purslane? egg yolk?) · v6
A word found only here. Jewish tradition took it as the egg yolk, so 'the slime of the yolk' means egg white. Many modern scholars connect it to a Syriac plant name and read the slimy juice of mallow or purslane. Either way it is the most tasteless, slimy thing a hearer could imagine eating.
-
מֵאֲנָה
mēʾănāh · H3985
to refuse · v7
A flat, willed refusal ('it refuses' / 'it has refused'). Its subject is the feminine noun nefesh further on, so it is Job's appetite itself that digs in its heels. Putting the verb first throws the weight onto the refusal.
-
לִנְגּוֹעַ
linggôaʿ · H5060
-
נַפְשִׁי
napšî · H5315
throat, appetite, life, self · v7
'My throat / my appetite / my very self.' In a food context the word's concrete sense is the hungry throat and its craving, which shades into Job himself as a living, desiring being. It is not the 'soul' as a non-bodily part.
-
הֵמָּה
hēmmāh · H1992
they · v7
'They' (masculine plural): the things just described, the tasteless, unsalted foods of v. 6. What those foods stand for (the friends' words, or Job's sufferings) is debated.
-
כִּדְוֵי
kidwê · H1741
sickness, faintness, revulsion · v7
'Like the sickness of…' The word means illness or faintness. Here it suggests food that is itself sickening, or the nausea a sick person feels at food. The idiom is compressed and its exact force is debated.
-
לַחְמִי
laḥmî · H3899
bread, food · v7
'My bread / my food': the everyday word for bread, standing for food in general. The 'my' stresses that this is the portion Job is now being given to eat.
The world behind it
Two kinds of animals, one rule. In ancient Israel and its neighbours, livestock were part of daily life. The onager (wild ass) roamed the dry steppe and desert edges. It was famously untameable, and in drought it was famously desperate (Jer 14:6; Job 39:5–8). The ox was the working animal of the farm. It was stall-fed with belil, a mix of chopped straw and grain or legumes. Listeners would know both animals and both sounds. Pairing a wild animal with a domestic one is a poetic way of saying "every animal, wild or tame."
Arguing from nature. Wisdom teachers in the ancient Near East often argued from how animals behave (compare Prov 6:6–8; 30:24–31). Job turns that method against his friend. Eliphaz had used a proverb to suggest that Job's distress marked him as a fool: "vexation kills the fool" (5:2). Job answers with a proverb of his own (6:2–7): weigh my vexation before you judge my words, because no creature cries out without a cause.
From the study of Job 6:5.
Where scholars differ
in v5
What exactly does the animal picture apply to?
-
Job's suffering is the 'missing food'. His outcry, like the animals', proves real deprivation and should not be judged as foolish complaint.
The verse comes straight after 6:2–4, where Job explains his rash words by pointing to his heavy anguish and God's arrows. Job 30:7 uses the same verb nahaq for the starving. The Septuagint's paraphrase ("unless seeking food") reads it this way. This is the majority reading.
-
The image also hints at the friends. They are 'well fed', comfortable and not suffering, so it is easy for them to be quiet and to criticise someone who cries out.
This is a possible secondary implication of the contrast between full and hungry animals, and it fits Job's later complaint that his friends lack sympathy (6:14–27). The verse never addresses the friends directly, so this remains an inference.
-
The verse leads into a food metaphor in 6:6–7. What Job is being 'fed', either Eliphaz's insipid counsel or his own loathsome suffering, is not nourishment, so of course he cries out.
Verse 6 continues with food imagery: tasteless food without salt, and something insipid. Verse 7 says "my soul refuses to touch them." Interpreters disagree about whether the tasteless food is the friends' words or Job's afflictions, and that question affects how tightly verse 5 is tied to what follows.
in v6
What is ḥallāmût?
-
Egg yolk ('the slime of the yolk' = egg white).
The Aramaic Targum and later Jewish usage (ḥelmôn = yolk); this is the oldest Jewish interpretation, followed by KJV and many later versions.
-
A plant with slimy, bland juice: mallow or purslane.
A Syriac plant name of similar form; fits rîr ('slime, sap') well; mallow was a common poor person's green in the region. Favoured by BDB, HALOT and many modern commentators and versions.
-
A soft cheese (its 'slime' being whey).
Comparison with an Arabic word for a type of cheese; a minority proposal.
-
Not a food at all: 'dreams' or 'empty words'.
YLT links it to ḥălôm 'dream'; the Septuagint paraphrases as 'empty words'. Most scholars think these break the food image of vv. 5–7.
in v6
What does the 'tasteless food' stand for?
-
Job's sufferings, the repulsive 'food' God has served him.
Verse 5 (animals complain only when their food is bad) and v. 7 ('they are like sickness in my food') keep the focus on Job's own lot; 6:4 has just spoken of God's poisoned arrows.
-
Eliphaz's speech, words without salt or sense.
tāfēl elsewhere means 'empty' (Lamentations 2:14); ṭa'am also means 'good sense'; Job compares testing words to tasting food (12:11); the Septuagint already read 'empty words'.
-
Deliberately both.
The food image fits Job's suffering, while the double meanings of tāfēl and ṭa'am let it glance at Eliphaz; many readers see this layering as typical of Job's poetry.
in v7
What are 'they', the things Job's appetite refuses?
-
The friends' (Eliphaz's) words: insipid, saltless advice that Job cannot swallow.
V. 6 asks whether tasteless food can be eaten. Words are often compared to food in wisdom literature (Job 12:11; 34:3, 'the ear tests words as the palate tastes food'), and Job goes on to rebuke his friends (6:14–30).
-
Job's sufferings: the bitter 'food' God has served him, which he finds revolting.
The immediate lead-in is God's poisoned arrows (v. 4). Elsewhere suffering is pictured as food or drink (Ps 80:5, 'bread of tears'; Job 3:24, 'my sighing comes as my bread'). Vv. 8–9 turn to his wish to die.
-
Literal food: Job, physically ill, cannot eat.
The sickness word dewai, and the parallels Ps 107:18 and Job 33:20, which describe the appetite loss of the gravely ill. Many interpreters see the literal and figurative senses working together.
in v7
How should kidwê laḥmî ('like the sickness of my food') be understood?
-
'Like loathsome / sickening food': the food itself makes him ill.
BSB, WEB, NASB, ESV, YLT, NIV. Takes dewai as describing the food's effect.
-
'Like food when I am sick': it is like a sick man's food.
JPS Tanakh. Takes dewai as Job's condition, which matches the use of dewai for illness in Ps 41:3 [41:4].
-
Emend the text, e.g. to 'my appetite loathes my food as in sickness'.
Job 33:20 has a close verbal parallel. Proposed because hēmmāh is awkward, but there is no manuscript support.
Sources
- BDB s.v. נָהַק, פֶּרֶא, דֶּשֶׁא, גָּעָה, בְּלִיל
- HALOT s.v. בְּלִיל (mixed fodder, from בלל)
- Septuagint, Job 6:5 (Rahlfs; cf. Brenton's English translation)
- Vulgate, Iob 6:5
- Cross-references: Job 1:3; 5:2; 6:2–7; 24:5–6; 30:3–7; 39:5–8; 1 Sam 6:12; Isa 30:24; Jer 14:6; Gen 16:12
- BDB (Brown–Driver–Briggs) s.v. חַלָּמוּת, תָּפֵל, טַעַם, רִיר
- HALOT (Koehler–Baumgartner) s.v. חַלָּמוּת, תָּפֵל, טַעַם
- Targum of Job 6:6
- Septuagint, Job 6:6
- Vulgate, Job 6:6
- D. J. A. Clines, Job 1–20 (Word Biblical Commentary)
- E. Dhorme, A Commentary on the Book of Job
- M. H. Pope, Job (Anchor Bible)
- BDB s.v. נֶפֶשׁ, מָאֵן, נָגַע, דְּוַי
- HALOT s.v. נֶפֶשׁ, דְּוַי
- H. W. Wolff, Anthropology of the Old Testament (on nefesh as throat/appetite)
- Vulgate, Job 6:7
- Septuagint, Job 6:7
- JPS Tanakh (1985), Job 6:7
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).