John Chapter 8 Read as one passage
John 8:22–23
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
22So the Jews began to ask, “Will He kill Himself, since He says, ‘Where I am going, you cannot come’?” 23Then He told them, “You are from below; I am from above. You are of this world; I am not of this world.
What the first hearers heard
For John's first readers, this verse is one more example of a pattern they would recognise throughout the Gospel. Jesus speaks of heavenly realities, and his hearers take his words at ground level: being "born again" heard as physical rebirth (3:4), "living water" as spring water (4:11), "my flesh to eat" as cannibalism (6:52). Here "going away" is heard as fleeing abroad (7:35) and now as suicide.
Readers who knew how the story ended would feel the irony at once:
- The people speculating that Jesus will kill himself are the very people trying to kill him.
- Jesus' death will be voluntary ("I lay it down of my own accord", 10:18), and that death is his return to the Father.
- The emphatic "I... you" contrast prepares for the next verse: "You are from below; I am from above."
So the verse serves John's purpose: to show that Jesus' departure is beyond the grasp of those who reject him, and that their failure to understand is itself the "cannot come" he warned about. For the Gospel's audience, who were probably living through painful separation from the synagogue (9:22; 16:2), the scene explained why so many of their own people did not follow Jesus where he went.
From the study of John 8:22.
Verse by verse
-
22So the Jews began to ask, “Will He kill Himself, since He says, ‘Where I am going, you cannot come’?”
Full study →Hearing Jesus say again, "I am going away, you will look for me, and you will die in your sin; where I am going, you cannot come," the Judean crowd in the temple started muttering among themselves: "He's not going to kill himself, is he? Is that why he keeps saying, 'Where I am going, you can't come'?"
The question leans toward "no". They float the idea half in puzzlement, half in scorn. They are trying to explain a place they "cannot" reach. A few weeks earlier (7:35) their guess was that he meant to slip off to the Jewish communities among the Greeks. Now they reach for something darker. If he takes his own life, he will go somewhere no decent, law-keeping person would ever follow. In popular Jewish thought of the time, a suicide went down to the gloomiest part of the world of the dead.
Every part of the guess is ironic:
- They are the ones seeking to kill him (7:25; 8:37, 40).
- He will indeed go to his death by his own choice, but by laying his life down, not by taking it (10:17–18).
- That death is the very road by which he "goes away" to the Father. They really cannot follow him there, not because he will sink below them, but because, as the next verse says, he is "from above" and they are "from below."
-
23Then He told them, “You are from below; I am from above. You are of this world; I am not of this world.
Full study →Jesus went on speaking to the people who had just mocked his words "where I am going, you cannot come." They had asked whether he planned to kill himself. He answers with four short, balanced statements, setting an emphatic "you" against an emphatic "I" each time:
"You have your origin in the realm below; I have mine in the realm above. You come from, and belong to, this present world order; I do not come from it and do not belong to it."
"Below" and "above" use the picture of the universe everyone then shared: God's heaven above, the human earth below. "From above" means "from God." "From below" is explained by the next line: it means "this world," the human order as it stands apart from God. It does not mean hell. The little word translated "from/of" points to origin and belonging: where you come from shapes what you are, whose voice you can recognise, and where you can go.
So the verse explains the riddle of 8:21-22. They cannot follow him, and cannot understand where he is going, because they do not share his origin. He is not talking about suicide. He is talking about returning to the One who sent him. "This world" is the present order that John's Gospel says is under judgment. That leads straight into the warning of the next verse: whoever stays tied only to that order will "die in your sins" unless they trust that Jesus is who he claims to be. The saying does not call the physical world evil, and it does not mean "worldly" in the sense of bad habits. It is a claim about where Jesus comes from and where his hearers come from.
Where the English drifted
-
in v22
the Jews
hoi Ioudaioi
- What we hear
- The Jewish people as a whole, as an ethnic or religious group set against Jesus and Christians.
- What they heard
- In this scene, the particular Judean audience in the temple who are hostile to Jesus and follow the Jerusalem leadership. Jesus, his disciples, and the Jews who believe in him in this same chapter (8:30) are all equally Jewish.
-
in v23
this world
ho kosmos houtos
- What we hear
- Either the physical planet and material things, as opposed to 'spiritual' things, or 'worldliness' in the sense of indulgent habits and entertainment.
-
in v23
from beneath (KJV, WEB)
ek tōn katō
- What we hear
- From the underworld or hell, as if Jesus were calling them demonic offspring.
- What they heard
- From the lower realm, meaning earth and the human sphere as opposed to heaven. The next clause, 'you are of this world,' restates it. The sharper charge, 'of your father the devil,' comes later (8:44) and in different words.
Every word
-
ἔλεγον
elegon · G3004
to say, speak · v22, v23
Imperfect tense: they "were saying" or "began saying". It pictures talk going round among the listeners rather than a single formal reply to Jesus.
-
οὖν
oun · G3767
so, then, therefore · v22
John's usual connecting word. It ties their reaction directly to what Jesus has just said in 8:21.
-
οἱ
hoi · G3588
the · v22, v23
The definite article. It marks "the Jews" as a group the reader already knows from the story so far.
-
Ἰουδαῖοι
Ioudaioi · G2453
Jew, Judean · v22
In this argument in the temple, the word means the Judean audience opposed to Jesus, especially those who follow the Jerusalem authorities. It does not mean the Jewish people as a whole. Jesus and his disciples are Jews too.
-
μήτι
mēti · G3385
surely not? / could it be? · v22
A question word that leans toward the answer "no" while still putting the idea forward: "He's not going to kill himself, is he?" It can sound like genuine puzzlement or like a sneer.
-
ἀποκτενεῖ
apoktenei · G0615
-
ἑαυτόν
heauton · G1438
himself · v22
Reflexive pronoun. Together with the verb it means "kill himself", which is suicide. That is the bitter irony: in fact *they* are the ones trying to kill him.
-
ὅτι
hoti · G3754
because, since; that · v22
Gives the reason for their guess: "since he says...". Here it introduces the evidence they are trying to make sense of.
-
ὅπου
hopou · G3699
where · v22
"Where" introduces the destination Jesus will not name in plain terms. The whole misunderstanding turns on what that place is.
-
ἐγὼ
egō · G1473
I · v22, v23
Greek verbs already include the subject, so adding "I" is emphatic. Combined with the emphatic "you" that follows, it sets "I" sharply against "you".
-
ὑπάγω
hupagō · G5217
go away, depart · v22
"I am going away." In John this is Jesus' code word for going back to the Father who sent him, through his death and exaltation. His hearers take it as a riddle about some earthly place.
-
ὑμεῖς
humeis · G4771
you (plural) · v22, v23
Emphatic "you all", set against "I". It marks out the people who cannot follow.
-
οὐ
ou · G3756
not · v22, v23
A flat negative of fact: you are not able.
-
δύνασθε
dunasthe · G1410
-
ἐλθεῖν
elthein · G2064
to come, go · v22
"To come." The form looks at the arrival as a single whole event: they will never get there at all.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v23
A simple link to the previous verse. It moves the story from the crowd's mocking question (8:22) to Jesus' answer.
-
αὐτοῖς
autois · G846
them · v23
Refers to 'the Jews' of 8:22. In this part of John that means the temple authorities and the hostile listeners in the temple courts, not the Jewish people as a whole.
-
ἐκ
ek · G1537
out of, from · v23
Says where someone comes from: origin, source, belonging. It answers 'where do you come from, and so where do you belong?'
-
κάτω
katō · G2736
below, beneath · v23
'The things below': the lower realm, meaning the earth as opposed to heaven. Verse 23 itself treats it as another way of saying 'this world' in the next clause.
-
ἐστέ
este · G1510
you are · v23
A present-tense statement of what they are now. It describes their present origin and belonging, not a passing condition.
-
ἄνω
anō · G507
above, up · v23
The heavenly realm, where God is. In Jewish speech 'above' often stood in for God himself. To be 'from above' is to come from God.
-
τούτου
toutou · G3778
this · v23
'This' world: the present order of things, as opposed to God's realm. Here it comes first, before the noun, which gives it extra weight.
-
κόσμου
kosmou · G2889
world, ordered whole · v23
In John, the human world as an organised order living apart from God and largely resisting him. It does not mean the physical planet or matter as such.
The world behind it
Where and when. The scene is in the Jerusalem temple, in the treasury area (8:20), during or just after the Feast of Tabernacles (7:2, 37). Jesus is in open dispute with Judean listeners and authorities who are already plotting his death (7:1, 25, 32).
The repeated riddle. Jesus first said "you will seek me and not find me; where I am, you cannot come" in 7:33–34. The listeners then guessed he would go to the Diaspora, the scattered Jewish communities in the Greek-speaking world (7:35). Here he repeats the saying with a harder edge ("you will die in your sin"), and their second guess is suicide.
How suicide was viewed. Jewish attitudes were mixed but mostly negative. Scripture records the self-inflicted deaths of Saul (1 Sam 31:4) and Ahithophel (2 Sam 17:23) without praise. 2 Maccabees 14:37–46 honours the elder Razis, who killed himself rather than be captured. In Josephus' speech at Jotapata (Jewish War 3.361–382), suicide is called an offence against God, and the souls of those who commit it go to "the darker Hades" (3.375). This background is often cited to explain the jibe: if Jesus means to kill himself, he is heading for a place where the righteous certainly will not follow. Whether the speakers had exactly this in mind cannot be proved, but it fits the remark well.
From the study of John 8:22.
Where scholars differ
in v22
Is the remark genuine puzzlement or a sarcastic jibe?
-
Mockery: they sneer that if he kills himself he will go to the lowest part of the underworld, where they certainly won't follow.
The hostile setting (8:20, 37, 40). Josephus' statement that suicides go to "the darker Hades" (*J.W.* 3.375). The escalation from the milder guess in 7:35.
-
Bewildered speculation: they are honestly trying to make sense of a riddle.
μήτι can introduce a tentative suggestion (compare John 4:29). The parallel in 7:35 reads as genuine confusion. John's "misunderstanding" scenes usually show incomprehension more than scorn.
in v22
Who exactly are "the Jews" here?
-
The Jerusalem religious authorities and their supporters.
In places like 9:22, Jewish parents fear "the Jews", so the term must mean the leadership. The Pharisees are named as the dialogue partners in 8:13.
-
The Judean crowd in the temple more broadly, as representatives of unbelief.
The audience in 8:12–30 is a mixed crowd, some of whom come to believe (8:30–31). John often uses "the Jews" for those in Judea who resist Jesus, without limiting it to officials.
-
Translate "Judeans" rather than "Jews".
Some scholars argue that Ἰουδαῖος in the first century mainly meant a regional or ethnic identity tied to Judea. Others answer that the term was already religious and ethnic across the Diaspora, so "Jews" remains appropriate.
in v23
Does 'from below' carry a demonic or underworld meaning, or does it simply mean earthly?
-
Simply earthly: the lower realm as opposed to heaven.
The second pair of statements restates the first ('from below' = 'of this world'). John 3:31 uses a similar contrast between heaven and earth with no demonic overtone. In Greek usage κάτω means 'below, on earth' in ordinary contexts.
-
It points ahead to a diabolical origin.
The same dialogue climaxes in 'you are of (ek) your father the devil' (8:44), using the same ek construction. 'This world' has a 'ruler' identified with Satan (12:31; 14:30). Some interpreters read 8:23 as the first step towards that charge. Most commentators still read 8:23 itself as earthly rather than demonic.
in v23
Is John's above/below contrast a split between matter and spirit (as in Gnostic thought or Platonism), or something else?
-
A Jewish contrast of origin and allegiance, tied to judgment at the end of history, not a theory that matter is evil.
In John the world is made through the Word (1:3, 10) and loved by God (3:16). The Word 'became flesh' (1:14). People can move from 'below' to 'above' by being 'born from above' (3:3), and disciples become 'not of the world' (17:16). That is change of belonging, not fixed classes of being. The Dead Sea Scrolls and 4 Ezra show similar contrasts inside Judaism.
-
John uses Hellenistic or proto-Gnostic language that later Gnostics found congenial.
The vocabulary of above/below and 'not of this world' resembles later Gnostic texts. The Gnostic Heracleon wrote the earliest known commentary on John. Most scholars hold that John borrows the language without the matter-is-evil worldview, but the overlap in wording is real.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. μήτι
- BDAG s.v. ὑπάγω
- BDAG s.v. Ἰουδαῖος
- Josephus, Jewish War 3.361–382 (esp. 3.375)
- 2 Maccabees 14:37–46
- Raymond E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I–XII (Anchor Bible)
- D. A. Carson, The Gospel according to John (PNTC)
- Craig S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- Origen, Commentary on John, book 19
- BDAG s.v. ἐκ, κάτω, ἄνω, κόσμος
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. κόσμος
- TDNT s.v. κόσμος (Sasse)
- 2 Esdras 4:21; Wisdom of Solomon 9:16-17
- Josephus, Jewish War 3.375
- R. E. Brown, The Gospel according to John I-XII (Anchor Bible)
- C. S. Keener, The Gospel of John: A Commentary
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on John 8
- NA28 Greek New Testament; Vulgate
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).