Mark Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Mark 9:10–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

10So they kept this matter to themselves, discussing what it meant to rise from the dead. 11And they asked Jesus, “Why do the scribes say that Elijah must come first?”

What the first hearers heard

For Mark's first readers, Christians probably in the 60s or 70s, many of whom had faced suffering, this verse did several things:

  • It showed that the resurrection was not something the disciples expected or invented. Even the three closest followers, fresh from seeing Jesus' glory, could not work out what 'rising from the dead' would mean for him. When it came, it was not the fulfilment of a hope they already held in that form.
  • It explained why the transfiguration was not preached earlier. The disciples held to the silence command. Their testimony came only after Easter, and the resurrection was the key that unlocked it.
  • It kept to Mark's pattern of uncomprehending disciples (6:52; 8:17–21; 9:32). Jesus' way of suffering, death and rising cannot be grasped by sight or glory alone. It becomes clear only on the far side of the cross.
  • It linked the glory on the mountain to the death ahead. The readers knew the ending: the Son of Man did die and did rise. They could see what the disciples, debating on the path, could not yet see. The rising of Jesus was the first act of the general resurrection Israel had hoped for.

From the study of Mark 9:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 10So they kept this matter to themselves, discussing what it meant to rise from the dead.

    Coming down from the mountain where they had just seen Jesus transfigured and talking with Moses and Elijah, Peter, James and John got a strict order: tell no one what you saw until the Son of Man has risen from the dead (v. 9).

    Verse 10 tells how they took it. They gripped that word. Mark uses the same strong verb he uses for seizing a hand or arresting a man. They held fast to the command and kept silent, and they also latched onto the one phrase that would not let them go. Among themselves they kept debating, back and forth: "What is this 'rising out from among the dead'?"

    They were not confused about resurrection as an idea. Many Jews of their day expected the righteous dead to stand up bodily at the end of the age. What baffled them was Jesus speaking of it as something that would happen to him, soon, inside ordinary history, with them still around to talk afterwards. Speaking of the Son of Man 'rising' also meant he must first die, which Peter had refused to accept a few days earlier (8:31–33).

    So they argued it out with each other rather than asking Jesus directly. They could not yet fit a dying and rising Son of Man together with the glory they had just seen.

    Full study →
  2. 11And they asked Jesus, “Why do the scribes say that Elijah must come first?”

    On the way down from the mountain, the three disciples keep pressing Jesus with a question that is bothering them: "Why is it that the experts in the Scriptures teach that Elijah has to come first?"

    They have just seen Elijah talking with Jesus (9:4). Then Jesus told them to say nothing until "the Son of Man has risen from the dead," and they puzzled over what rising from the dead could mean (9:9–10). Their question comes out of that puzzle. The recognised teachers of the Law read Malachi as a fixed part of God's plan: God must send Elijah back before the great Day of the LORD, and Elijah's work is to set things right ("restore"). If resurrection and the end are as near as Jesus suggests, where is that restoration? Was Elijah's brief appearance on the mountain all of it? And how can a Son of Man who must suffer (8:31) fit a plan in which Elijah first puts everything right?

    "First" is left open: first before the end-time events and, as many expected, before God's final act of rescue. The "must" is the language of something God has decreed in Scripture. It is not mere scholarly opinion or a forecast.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    rising from the dead

    to ek nekrōn anastēnai

    What we hear
    Many modern readers hear 'rise from the dead' as a general idea of life after death, often the soul going on to heaven. Or they assume the disciples had simply never heard of resurrection.
    What they heard
    A dead person standing up again bodily. In Jewish hope this was an end-of-the-age event for God's people together. The disciples knew the idea. What baffled them was its application to one man, soon, which also implied that he would first die.
  • in v11

    scribes

    grammateis

    What we hear
    Copyists, clerks or secretaries who write things down for others.
    What they heard
    Recognised experts and teachers of the Law of Moses, whose interpretation of Scripture carried authority with the people.
Every word
  1. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v10, v11

    Mark's usual 'and' linking one scene to the next. It ties the disciples' reaction straight to Jesus' command on the way down the mountain (v. 9).

  2. τὸν

    ton · G3588

    the · v10, v11

    The definite article points back to something specific: 'that' word, the one Jesus had just spoken.

  3. λόγον

    logon · G3056

    word, saying, matter · v10

    Jesus' statement in verse 9: the order to tell no one 'until the Son of Man has risen from the dead.' It can mean the spoken saying itself or, as with Hebrew davar, the 'matter' it concerns. BSB, NIV and ESV take it as 'matter'; KJV and WEB as 'saying.'

  4. ἐκράτησαν

    ekratēsan · G2902

    to grasp, seize, hold fast · v10

    A strong verb of gripping. Here it means either 'they held fast to (obeyed) the command,' keeping silent, or 'they seized on the saying,' fastening on its puzzling phrase. The aorist tense presents it as a single, complete response.

  5. πρὸς

    pros · G4314

    toward, with, among · v10

    With 'themselves' it gives 'among themselves' or 'to themselves.' It is unclear whether it goes with 'held' (kept it to themselves) or with 'questioning' (debating among themselves).

  6. ἑαυτοὺς

    heautous · G1438

    themselves · v10

    Here it means 'one another': the circle of Peter, James and John, talking among themselves rather than asking Jesus.

  7. συζητοῦντες

    syzētountes · G4802

    to seek together, discuss, dispute · v10

    Literally 'seeking together.' This is back-and-forth questioning, sometimes heated. The present participle shows an ongoing activity: they kept turning it over.

  8. τί

    ti · G5101

    what? · v10

    An indirect question, 'what (it) is.' They are asking what the phrase refers to, not whether it can happen.

  9. ἐστιν

    estin · G1510

    is · v10

    Present tense, 'what is.' Greek keeps the tense of the original question when it reports one indirectly. KJV's 'should mean' and BSB's 'meant' smooth this into English idiom.

  10. ἐκ

    ek · G1537

    out of, from · v10

    'Out from (among).' It pictures someone coming out of the realm of the dead.

  11. νεκρῶν

    nekrōn · G3498

    dead (ones) · v10

    Plural and without an article, 'dead ones.' It means dead people, the company of the dead, not an abstract 'death.' It is the fixed phrase of Jewish resurrection talk.

  12. ἀναστῆναι

    anastēnai · G0450

    to stand up, rise · v10

    Literally 'to stand up (again).' The verb is a bodily picture of a dead person getting up. It is the same verb Jesus used in his prediction of his suffering in 8:31 ('after three days rise again'), so the disciples are puzzling over his own words.

  13. ἐπηρώτων

    epērōtōn · G1905

    to question, ask · v11

    The tense pictures an action in progress: 'they were questioning him' or 'they began to ask.' It suggests a puzzle the disciples kept pressing on the way down the mountain, not a single passing remark.

  14. αὐτὸν

    auton · G0846

    him · v11

    Jesus. The three disciples, Peter, James and John, put the question to him directly.

  15. λέγοντες·

    legontes · G3004G

    saying · v11

    Introduces the words of the question, as Greek often does after a verb of asking.

  16. ὅτι

    hoti · G3754G

    why? (here); that, because · v11

    Most likely used here as a question word, 'why?', as also in Mark 2:16 and 9:28. Some read it as a quotation marker, which would make the sentence a statement ('The scribes say...'). YLT takes it that way.

  17. γραμματεῖς

    grammateis · G1122

    scribe, expert in the Law · v11

    Not copyists or secretaries. These were the professional interpreters and teachers of the Torah, whose reading of Scripture set what people expected. In Mark they are often Jesus' critics.

  18. Ἠλίαν

    Ēlian · G2243

    Elijah · v11

    The prophet from 1 Kings 17 to 2 Kings 2, who was taken up alive in a whirlwind. Malachi had promised that he would be sent back before the Day of the LORD. The disciples had just seen him on the mountain (Mark 9:4).

  19. δεῖ

    dei · G1163

    it is necessary, must · v11

    A necessity rooted in God's plan as Scripture lays it out, not just a likely forecast. It is the same 'must' Jesus used of the Son of Man's suffering in 8:31, and that clash is what lies behind the question.

  20. ἐλθεῖν

    elthein · G2064

    to come · v11

    Refers to Elijah's promised arrival or return as God's messenger in the last days. The form views it as one complete event.

  21. πρῶτον;

    prōton · G4413G

    first · v11

    Used as an adverb: 'first,' before something else. The verse leaves 'before what' unstated: before the Day of the LORD, before the resurrection of the dead they had just been discussing, and, in the expectation of some, before the Messiah.

The world behind it

The scene. This verse falls between the transfiguration (9:2–8) and the conversation about Elijah (9:11–13). Only the inner three, Peter, James and John, were on the mountain. Jesus' order to keep silent is one of several in Mark: he repeatedly limits public talk about who he is until the cross and resurrection make sense of it. This one is the only silence order in Mark with an end date: 'until the Son of Man rises.'

Jewish resurrection hope. By the first century, many Jews, especially those close to the Pharisees, expected a bodily resurrection of the dead at the end of the age. Its roots are in Daniel 12:2 ('many who sleep in the dust of the earth shall awake'), Isaiah 26:19, and the martyr stories of 2 Maccabees 7. The Sadducees denied it (Mark 12:18; Josephus, Antiquities 18.16). In this hope, resurrection was a single event at the end of history, for the righteous of Israel together (or for all, for judgment), and it would bring in God's new age.

Why the phrase puzzled them. Jesus' words did not match that pattern. One individual, the Son of Man, would rise ahead of everyone else, at a time the disciples would live through, so that afterwards they could speak. And rising presupposes dying. Jesus had already said plainly that the Son of Man 'must suffer… be killed, and after three days rise' (8:31), and Peter had rebuked him for it.

The Elijah question. The disciples had just seen Elijah, so their next question follows naturally: 'Why do the scribes say Elijah must come first?' (9:11). That expectation came from Malachi 4:5–6 and Sirach 48:10. If Elijah comes first to 'restore all things,' why would the Son of Man have to die and rise at all? Verse 10 is the disciples trying, and failing, to fit these pieces together.

From the study of Mark 9:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

What does 'they held/seized the word' (ekratēsan ton logon) mean: obedience to silence, or fastening onto a puzzling phrase?

  • They kept the command. They obeyed the order not to tell anyone (secrecy).

    Krateō with traditions means 'observe, hold fast' (Mark 7:3, 4, 8). The previous verse is a command to silence, so the natural response is obedience. The Vulgate's 'continuerunt' and most English versions ('kept… to themselves') read it this way.

  • They seized on the saying. They grabbed hold of the strange phrase 'rise from the dead' and would not let it go.

    Mark mostly uses krateō for forceful grasping. The rest of the sentence is about puzzling over the phrase's meaning, not about silence. NASB 'seized upon' and several commentators take this line.

  • Both. Mark uses a verb that covers obeying the command and clinging to its puzzling content.

    The verb's range includes both senses, and the context contains both elements (the silence order and the puzzling phrase). Many commentators see no need to choose.

in v10

Does 'among themselves' (pros heautous) go with 'held' or with 'questioning'?

  • With 'held': 'they kept it to themselves.'

    Word order: it follows ekratēsan directly. This is the reading of most English translations (KJV, BSB, WEB, NIV, ESV).

  • With 'questioning': 'questioning among themselves.'

    Mark's idiom pairs pros heautous with verbs of discussion (1:27 uses the identical syzētein pros heautous; also 11:31; 12:7; 16:3). NASB's 'discussing with one another' reflects this.

in v10

What exactly puzzled the disciples about 'rising from the dead'?

  • The idea of one individual rising before the general end-time resurrection.

    Jewish expectation (Daniel 12:2; 2 Maccabees 7) pictured the dead rising together at the end of the age. Jesus spoke of the Son of Man rising alone, inside history, followed by a time when the disciples could speak.

  • The implication that the Son of Man must die.

    Rising presupposes death. Peter had already rejected the suffering-Son-of-Man prediction (8:31–33). Messianic hopes of the time did not generally include the Messiah's death. In 9:32 they 'did not understand and were afraid to ask.'

  • The concept of resurrection itself.

    Not all Jews believed in resurrection (the Sadducees denied it). Galilean fishermen may not have had a clear doctrine. Most scholars find this less likely, because the idea was widespread and Mark 12 shows it was a live, known topic.

in v11

Did Jewish teachers before Jesus' time expect Elijah specifically as the forerunner of the Messiah, or only before the Day of the LORD?

  • Evidence before the first century for 'Elijah before the Messiah' is thin. Malachi and Sirach put Elijah before the Day of the LORD, not before a Messiah, and the clear 'forerunner of Messiah' idea may have grown later, partly from Christian usage.

    M. Faierstein, 'Why Do the Scribes Say That Elijah Must Come First?' (JBL 1981): Malachi 4:5 and Sirach 48:10 say nothing of a Messiah. Rabbinic texts that link the two are later.

  • The idea was current enough in Jesus' day for the Gospels and the disciples to assume it.

    D. C. Allison's reply (JBL 1984) and others point to Mark 9:11 itself, John 1:19–25 (John asked if he is the Messiah, Elijah or the Prophet), Justin's Trypho (Dialogue 8, 49), and possibly 4Q558. The Day of the LORD and the arrival of God's anointed were often closely linked.

in v11

What does 'first' mean: before what?

  • Before the resurrection and the end-time events Jesus has just mentioned.

    The question follows straight on from 9:9–10 about rising from the dead. Mishnah Sotah 9:15 later links Elijah with the resurrection.

  • Before the Messiah, so the disciples are asking how Jesus can be the Messiah if Elijah has not yet done his work.

    Peter has just confessed Jesus as Messiah (8:29). Matthew 17:10 joins the question to the vision. NLT translates on this basis.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. κρατέω
  • BDAG s.v. συζητέω
  • BDAG s.v. ἀνίστημι
  • BDAG s.v. λόγος
  • Thayer s.v. κρατέω
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
  • Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
  • N. T. Wright, The Resurrection of the Son of God
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed., critical apparatus at Mark 9:10
  • Josephus, Antiquities 18.12–17; Jewish War 2.162–166
  • Daniel 12:2; Isaiah 26:19 LXX; 2 Maccabees 7:9, 14
  • Malachi 4:5–6; Sirach 48:10
  • Vulgate, Mark 9:10
  • BDAG s.v. ὅτι, γραμματεύς, δεῖ
  • Thayer s.v. ἐπερωτάω
  • Malachi 3:23–24 MT / 4:5–6 LXX
  • Sirach 48:10
  • Mishnah Eduyot 8:7; Sotah 9:15
  • Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 8, 49
  • M. M. Faierstein, 'Why Do the Scribes Say That Elijah Must Come First?' JBL 100 (1981)
  • D. C. Allison, 'Elijah Must Come First,' JBL 103 (1984)
  • J. Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).