1 Samuel Chapter 10 Read as one passage

1 Samuel 10:17–25

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17After this, Samuel summoned the people to the LORD at Mizpah 18and said to the Israelites, “This is what the LORD, the God of Israel, says: ‘I brought Israel up out of Egypt, and I rescued you from the hands of the Egyptians and of all the kingdoms that oppressed you.’ 19But today you have rejected your God, who saves you from all your troubles and afflictions, and you have said to Him, ‘No, set a king over us.’ Now therefore present yourselves before the LORD by your tribes and clans.” 20Thus Samuel had all the tribes of Israel come forward, and the tribe of Benjamin was selected. 21Then he had the tribe of Benjamin come forward by its clans, and the clan of Matri was selected. Finally, Saul son of Kish was selected. But when they looked for him, they could not find him. 22So again they inquired of the LORD, “Has the man come here yet?” And the LORD replied, “Behold, he has hidden himself among the baggage.” 23So they ran and brought Saul, and when he stood among the people, he was a head taller than any of the others. 24Samuel said to all the people, “Do you see the one the LORD has chosen? There is no one like him among all the people.” And all the people shouted, “Long live the king!” 25Then Samuel explained to the people the rights of kingship. He wrote them on a scroll and laid it up before the LORD. And Samuel sent all the people away, each to his own home.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite hearers, this verse signals a formal, high-stakes national gathering. The prophet who also judged Israel calls out the tribes, as leaders had done in a crisis since the days of Judges. They are to appear before Yahweh at Mizpah, a place already linked with all-Israel assemblies, repentance and deliverance.

The verse sets up what follows:

  • A prophetic charge before any coronation. Samuel begins with "Thus says Yahweh," recalls the exodus and the rescues from oppressors, and says "today you have rejected your God" (vv. 18–19). Calling them "to Yahweh" means Israel stands before the God whose kingship they are setting aside.
  • God still chooses. Even with a human king, Yahweh picks him by lot. The king is accountable and does not own the throne by right.
  • Irony in the place. At Mizpah, Yahweh had saved Israel without a king (ch. 7). The hearers are invited to weigh the request for a king against that memory.

Telling the story this way supported two things at once. Kingship was real and came from God's choice. It was also born out of a lack of trust and stayed under prophetic and covenant scrutiny. That double view runs through 1 Samuel 8–12.

From the study of 1 Samuel 10:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17After this, Samuel summoned the people to the LORD at Mizpah

    "So Samuel had the call cried out and mustered the people, the whole kin-based body of Israel, to come before Yahweh at Mizpah, 'the Lookout'."

    The sentence follows straight on from the private scene before it. Saul has just kept his secret anointing to himself (10:16). Now Samuel makes the matter public. The verb is the causative form of the Hebrew word for crying out: a call goes out and the tribes are summoned, as when a leader in Judges raised the tribal levy. The people come as an organised body. The next verses show them arranged by tribe and clan, ready for the lot.

    They are summoned not just to a town but "to Yahweh", Israel's God named by his own covenant name. That makes the gathering a sacred assembly in God's presence. There he will first speak through Samuel, reminding them that he brought them out of Egypt and charging them with rejecting him by asking for a king (vv. 18–19). Then he will pick out the king by lot (vv. 20–21).

    The place is loaded too. Mizpah is where Israel had recently gathered in repentance, and where Yahweh, with no king, had thrown back the Philistines (ch. 7). The first hearers would feel the irony: Israel is called to the scene of God's own rescue to receive the king they asked for in place of that rescue.

    Full study →
  2. 18and said to the Israelites, “This is what the LORD, the God of Israel, says: ‘I brought Israel up out of Egypt, and I rescued you from the hands of the Egyptians and of all the kingdoms that oppressed you.’

    Samuel has called the tribes together at Mizpah to stand “before Yahweh.” He speaks as a herald, using the fixed formula a messenger used when delivering his master's words: “This is what Yahweh, the God of Israel, has said.” What follows is not Samuel's opinion. It is the message of the God who belongs to Israel and to whom Israel belongs.

    The message opens with an emphatic “I”: It was I, I myself, who brought Israel up out of Egypt. The words “brought up out of Egypt” were a well-known phrase that called up the whole founding story: slavery, plagues, the sea, the climb out of the low land of bondage into a land of their own. Then the speech turns from “Israel” to “you”, the people actually standing there: and I pulled you out of Egypt's grip. The picture is a captive pried loose from a captor's hand, the way a shepherd snatches a lamb from a lion's jaws. And it did not happen only once. I pulled you out of the grip of every kingdom that kept squeezing you. That covers Moab, the kings of Canaan, Midian, Ammon and the Philistines, the whole round of crushing foreign rule told in Judges.

    The verse works like the opening of a court case. It lists what Yahweh has done before the charge is read. The charge comes in the next breath: “But today you have rejected your God, who saves you… and you have said, ‘Set a king over us’” (v.19). The choice of word sharpens it. The oppressors are called kingdoms, states ruled by kings. Israel had been rescued from kingdoms over and over, and now it was asking to become one.

    Full study →
  3. 19But today you have rejected your God, who saves you from all your troubles and afflictions, and you have said to Him, ‘No, set a king over us.’ Now therefore present yourselves before the LORD by your tribes and clans.”

    "But you, this very day, have rejected your God, the God who himself is the one who keeps rescuing you out of every disaster and every tight place you have been pressed into. And you said to him (or, as the ancient versions read: you said, 'No!'), 'A king: that is what you must set over us.' So now, take your places before the LORD, tribe by tribe and clan by clan."

    The verse turns sharply on God's statement in verse 18: I brought you up from Egypt, I rescued you from every kingdom that crushed you. You, in return, have thrown me off. "Rejected" is covenant-breaking language, the same verb God used when he told Samuel "they have rejected me from being king over them" (8:7). Later in the book God will use it to reject Saul. The God described here is not a distant deity. He is Israel's standing deliverer, the role played by the rescuers in Judges, and the "troubles" are the oppressions, raids and squeezes of their history. The irony is pointed. They want a king to "fight our battles" (8:20), yet the one who has fought every one of them is the one they are pushing aside.

    Then comes the surprise. Samuel does not refuse. "So now" turns from accusation to procedure. The people must stand formally in God's presence while the lot works down through tribe and clan to find the king. God gives them what they asked for, but he still does the choosing. The narrowing from tribe to clan to household also recalls the day Israel found the guilty man Achan this way (Joshua 7), so the ceremony that makes a king is framed by an accusation.

    Full study →
  4. 20Thus Samuel had all the tribes of Israel come forward, and the tribe of Benjamin was selected.

    Samuel presented every tribe of Israel before the LORD, one after another, and the lot caught Benjamin.

    The first verb is the one used for bringing an offering or a person into God's presence at the sanctuary. Samuel is not chairing an election. He is putting the whole nation before God for a ruling. The second verb is the word for capturing a town or catching an animal in a trap. In lot-casting it means "singled out." The point of the passive is that no human picks Benjamin. Samuel doesn't and the people don't. The lot falls, and the lot was understood to be God's decision (Prov 16:33).

    The verse is the first step of a narrowing that continues in v. 21: tribe, then clan, then one man, Saul son of Kish. The tribe that gets caught is Benjamin. It was the smallest, and it had barely survived the civil war after the outrage at Gibeah (Judges 19–21). Saul himself had already called it the least of Israel's tribes (9:21).

    This comes straight after Samuel's charge that the people have "rejected your God" by demanding a king (v. 19). So the scene holds two things together. Israel gets the king it asked for, but it does not choose him. God does, by a procedure that the earlier history of Israel had last used to uncover a guilty man, Achan (Joshua 7).

    Full study →
  5. 21Then he had the tribe of Benjamin come forward by its clans, and the clan of Matri was selected. Finally, Saul son of Kish was selected. But when they looked for him, they could not find him.

    Samuel presented the tribe of Benjamin before the LORD clan by clan, and the sacred lot caught the clan of the Matrites. Then it caught Saul, son of Kish. They went looking for him, and he was nowhere to be found.

    The verb behind "selected" or "taken" is the word for capturing a city or snaring an animal. The lot does not pick a willing candidate. It closes in on one man, step by step: nation, then tribe, then clan, then individual. Israelites knew this procedure from the story of Achan (Joshua 7), where the same narrowing-down, in nearly the same words, exposed the man who had brought disaster on Israel. Here it is used to find a king the people demanded and Samuel has just called a rejection of God (vv. 18–19). The choice really is God's, and the echo makes it uneasy.

    The verse ends in anticlimax. The newly chosen king cannot be found. The words "sought" and "found" are the ones that ran through Saul's search for his father's lost donkeys in chapter 9. The searcher has become the one searched for. His name, Sha'ul, means "asked for", and the people now have to "ask" the LORD again (v. 22) to find the man they asked for.

    Full study →
  6. 22So again they inquired of the LORD, “Has the man come here yet?” And the LORD replied, “Behold, he has hidden himself among the baggage.”

    So once more they put the question to Yahweh, formally consulting him through the sacred oracle: "Has the man arrived here yet?" (or, as the Hebrew can be read, "Is there still someone else to come?"). And Yahweh answered, "Look, there he is, hiding in among the gear."

    The verse is full of irony that a Hebrew listener would catch. The people had asked (sha'al) for a king. The lot has fallen on Saul, whose name Sha'ul means "asked for." Now they have to ask again just to find him. The lot, the very procedure once used to expose the guilty Achan (Joshua 7), has picked out the future king, and he has disappeared. God's answer points straight at him: look, there. He is not at the front of the assembly. He is crouched among the stacked packs and equipment at its edge, the place for baggage and the men who guard it. He keeps hiding even as he is named. The next verse makes the scene more pointed still: when they drag him out, he stands a head taller than everyone. The biggest man in Israel was hiding among the luggage, and he had already been secretly anointed (10:1), so he knew exactly what the lot would reveal.

    Full study →
  7. 23So they ran and brought Saul, and when he stood among the people, he was a head taller than any of the others.

    The moment the LORD reveals where the man is ("he has hidden himself among the baggage"), people run. They fetch him out from there, from the heap of gear and supplies at the edge of the camp, and bring him forward. Then the man who had been hiding takes his stand right in the middle of the assembly. He places himself in front of the same Israel that had just been told to "present yourselves before the LORD." Once he is standing there, the reason everyone stares is obvious: he stands higher than every single person present. The others come up only to his shoulders. His head and neck rise above the whole crowd.

    The narrator uses the exact words he used when Saul was first introduced (9:2). That signals that the young man secretly anointed by Samuel and the man the sacred lot has now picked are one and the same. The scene has a touch of comedy and irony: the tallest man in Israel tried to hide behind the luggage. It also works as a setup. Israel asked for a king who would "go out before us and fight our battles," and the man they get looks exactly the part. The Hebrew verb for "being high" is the same root later used when God tells Samuel not to look at "the height of his stature" (16:7). So the reader is quietly invited to remember this impressive first look when that later verse comes.

    Full study →
  8. 24Samuel said to all the people, “Do you see the one the LORD has chosen? There is no one like him among all the people.” And all the people shouted, “Long live the king!”

    Samuel, the old "seer," turns to the whole assembled nation of Israel and asks a question expecting a yes: "Have you seen the man the LORD has chosen? See that there is no one like him in the whole nation!" The man they are looking at had been picked out moments before by the sacred lot (tribe, then clan, then household), dragged out from hiding among the baggage, and has just stood up a head taller than every one of them. "The LORD has chosen" uses the same words as Deuteronomy's law of the king ("a king whom the LORD your God chooses"), so Samuel is declaring Saul to be the lawful, God-picked king. "There is no one like him" is the kind of praise usually kept for God himself ("there is none holy like the LORD," 1 Sam 2:2). Here it is said of a man whose obvious distinction is his height.

    Then the crowd raises a great roar, the same kind of shout used for a battle cry or for greeting a sovereign, and cries out "May the king live!": life, health and a long reign to him. With that shout they accept him publicly. It is the first time Israel hails one of its own as melek, "king," the title they had demanded so they could be "like all the nations." Read in the flow of the book, the moment is both genuine and loaded. God really has chosen Saul. But the people are judging by what they can see, and the same Samuel will later be told, "Do not look at his appearance or the height of his stature… the LORD looks on the heart" (16:7).

    Full study →
  9. 25Then Samuel explained to the people the rights of kingship. He wrote them on a scroll and laid it up before the LORD. And Samuel sent all the people away, each to his own home.

    Then Samuel publicly declared to the people the binding order of the kingship: the norms that define what the royal office is, what it may claim, and what it is bound by. He did not leave it as spoken words. He wrote it down in a formal document, the kind of record used for deeds and covenants, and deposited it before the LORD at the sanctuary. There it was put to rest in God's custody as a permanent witness, much as the jar of manna and Aaron's staff had once been laid up "before the LORD". Then Samuel, who was still presiding, dismissed the whole assembly, every man back to his own household.

    The verse shows Israel's first king being installed under terms he did not write and could not keep in his own hands. The God who allowed the people to have a king (8:7, 22) keeps the charter that defines the king's place. And the ending is plain: no palace, no court. The people go home, and so does Saul (10:26).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17, v18

    the LORD

    YHWH (Yahweh)

    What we hear
    A general title for God ('the Lord', the master).
    What they heard
    The personal name of Israel's covenant God, the one who 'brought Israel up out of Egypt' (v. 18). Being summoned 'to Yahweh' means appearing before that particular God at a sacred assembly.
  • in v17

    summoned the people to the LORD

    hiṣʿîq … ʾel-YHWH

    What we hear
    Easily heard as a revival meeting or prayer gathering, a call to come to God in a devotional sense.
    What they heard
    A formal, national, sacred assembly held in God's presence to receive a prophetic word and a decision by lot. It is a legal and political event as much as a religious one; in that world the two were not separate.
  • in v19

    who saves you / your saviour

    môšîaʿ (yāšaʿ)

    What we hear
    Salvation from sin, a spiritual or eternal rescue.
    What they heard
    Rescue in history: military and political deliverance from oppressors and disasters, the role of the 'deliverers' in Judges. Here it describes God's ongoing work as Israel's protector and war-leader.
  • in v19

    by your thousands

    ʾalāpîm

    What we hear
    Groups of exactly a thousand people.
    What they heard
    Clans: kin groups within a tribe, which also served as units of fighting men. Verse 21 calls the unit selected a 'clan' (mišpāḥâ).
  • in v19

    your evils (YLT)

    rāʿôtêkem

    What we hear
    Your sins or wicked deeds.
    What they heard
    Your disasters and misfortunes: bad things done to Israel, not by Israel.
  • in v20

    was selected / was chosen (BSB, WEB)

    vayyillakhed (from lakhad)

    What we hear
    Someone weighed the options and picked Benjamin, the way a committee selects a candidate.
    What they heard
    Benjamin was 'caught' or 'captured' by the lot. The tribe is passive, no human makes the choice, and the result is understood as God's ruling. It is the same verb used for a city captured or an animal trapped, and for Achan being exposed in Joshua 7.
  • in v21

    families (KJV, WEB)

    mishpachah

    What we hear
    A household of parents and children.
    What they heard
    A clan: a large group of related households inside a tribe, often sharing land and a district.
  • in v21

    selected / chosen (BSB, WEB)

    nilkad (from lakad)

    What we hear
    Picked or preferred, as in an election or appointment, with a sense of being favoured.
    What they heard
    Caught or seized by the sacred lot. It is the same verb used for capturing cities and the term used when lots exposed Achan and Jonathan. The choice is God's verdict landing on someone, not a vote of approval.
  • in v22

    inquired of the LORD

    sha'al baYHWH

    What we hear
    Prayed and sought God's guidance privately or as a group.
    What they heard
    Formally consulted God's oracle, usually the priest's sacred lots (Urim and Thummim) or a prophet, expecting a concrete answer to a specific question.
  • in v22

    stuff (KJV)

    kelim

    What we hear
    Random odds and ends; junk.
    What they heard
    Equipment, gear, packs and provisions: the baggage of an assembled camp.
  • in v22

    baggage

    kelim

    What we hear
    Often heard figuratively in sermons as 'emotional baggage', the unresolved past and insecurities.
    What they heard
    Literal equipment and supply loads. The Hebrew word has no psychological meaning.
  • in v24

    God save the king (KJV)

    yəḥî hammelek

    What we hear
    A prayer asking God to protect or rescue the monarch; to many ears, the British national anthem.
    What they heard
    'May the king live!': a crowd's cry wishing the new king life and a long reign, and publicly accepting him. God is not named and 'saving' is not mentioned.
  • in v24

    the one the LORD has chosen

    ʾăšer bāḥar-bô YHWH

    What we hear
    Divinely elected in a permanent sense, guaranteed to succeed, or marked out as especially godly.
    What they heard
    Selected by God (here through the sacred lot) for the office of king, in line with Deut 17:15. In Samuel this choice does not prevent later rejection (15:23, 26) and says nothing about Saul's character.
  • in v25

    book (KJV, WEB)

    sefer

    What we hear
    A bound volume, possibly a literary work, perhaps even a lost book of the Bible.
    What they heard
    A written document of any length: a legal record, deed or scroll, here a formal charter set down as evidence.
  • in v25

    kingdom (KJV, WEB)

    melukhah

    What we hear
    A realm or country, or, in church language, God's kingdom.
    What they heard
    The kingship as an office: the institution of royal rule now being created.
  • in v25

    rights (BSB)

    mishpat

    What we hear
    The king's entitlements, what he is allowed to claim, in the modern sense of rights.
    What they heard
    The governing norm or order of the office. It covers its legitimate claims and its obligations and limits, and it binds the king.
  • in v25

    manner (KJV)

    mishpat

    What we hear
    Style or way of behaving, as in 'manners'.
    What they heard
    Established and binding practice or regulation: the legal order of the kingship.
Every word
  1. וַיַּצְעֵ֤ק

    wayyaṣʿēq · H6817

    to cry out; (causative) to summon, call out · v17

    The causative form of the verb for crying out: Samuel 'had a cry raised' and called the people out. It is a mustering word, used when a leader calls the tribes to assemble. The opening 'and' carries the story on directly from 10:16. Saul has kept the anointing secret, and now Samuel takes the matter public.

  2. שְׁמוּאֵל֙

    šəmûʾēl · H8050G

    Samuel · v17, v20, v24, v25

    The prophet, priestly figure and last judge, who led Israel in its tribal period. He is the one with authority to call the national assembly. The verse brings him back to Mizpah, where he once led Israel in repentance and victory (ch. 7).

  3. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    [marks the direct object] · v17, v18, v19, v20, v21, v25

    Untranslatable grammatical marker showing that 'the people' are the ones summoned.

  4. הָעָ֔ם

    hāʿām · H5971A

    people, kin-group, nation · v17, v23, v24, v25

    Israel as one body made up of kinship groups. These are the same 'people' who demanded a king in ch. 8. Verse 19 shows they arrive organised by tribe and clan, ready for the lot-casting.

  5. אֶל־

    ʾel- · H0413

    to, toward · v17, v18, v22, v24, v25

    Marks where they are going. Here the destination is a person, Yahweh, and not only a place.

  6. יְהוָ֖ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    Yahweh (the divine name; 'the LORD') · v17, v18, v19, v22, v24, v25

    Israel's God, called by his personal covenant name. To be summoned 'to Yahweh' means coming into his presence at a holy assembly. He will speak a charge against them (v. 18–19) and choose the king by lot (v. 20–21).

  7. הַמִּצְפָּֽה׃

    hammiṣpâ · H4709G

    Mizpah ('the Watchtower/Lookout') · v17

    A hilltop town in Benjamin and a traditional place where the tribes met. Hebrew needs no preposition here: the bare place name with 'the' means 'to Mizpah'. The article keeps the place name's original sense of 'the lookout'.

  8. וַיֹּאמֶר

    wayyōʾmer · H0559

    and he said · v18, v19, v22, v24

    Samuel is the speaker. He has just called the people together “to Yahweh” at Mizpah (v.17). This verb form is the ordinary way Hebrew moves a story forward, so his speech is presented as the next event.

  9. בְּנֵי

    bənê · H1121

    sons of, descendants of · v18, v21

    “Sons of Israel” is the usual name for the people as one family descended from Jacob/Israel. It makes the audience a single kin-group, not a crowd of individuals.

  10. יִשְׂרָאֵל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v18, v20

    The people as a whole, gathered by tribes and clans (v.19). The name comes three times in this verse, which keeps the people's identity at the centre.

  11. כֹּה־

    kōh · H3541

    thus, so · v18

    This word opens the standard messenger formula. What follows is someone else's message, and Samuel is only delivering it.

  12. אֱלֹהֵי

    ʾĕlōhê · H0430

    God of · v18, v19

    “God of Israel” names a relationship. This is the God who has bound himself to this people, which makes the coming charge (“you have rejected your God,” v.19) more pointed.

  13. אָנֹכִי

    ʾānōkî · H0595

    I · v18

    The verb already shows “I,” so adding the pronoun makes it emphatic: “It was I who…”. It sets up the contrast that comes next. I did this, and you want someone else (a human king) to do it.

  14. הֶעֱלֵיתִי

    heʿĕlêtî · H5927

    I brought up · v18

    This is the causative form of “go up,” a fixed phrase for the exodus: Yahweh made Israel go up out of Egypt. In context it means “brought up,” not the supplied dictionary sense “establish.”

  15. מִמִּצְרָיִם

    mimmiṣrāyim · H4714

    from Egypt · v18

    The land of slavery, the starting point of Israel's whole story as a people.

  16. וָאַצִּיל

    wāʾaṣṣîl · H5337

    and I snatched away, rescued · v18

    The verb means pulling someone out of another's grip, like prey from a predator or a captive from a captor. The rescue it describes is physical and political.

  17. מִיַּד

    miyyad · H3027

    from the hand of · v18

    “Hand” stands for power and control. To be “in the hand of” someone is to be under their control, so this means “out of Egypt's grip.”

  18. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all, every · v18, v19, v20, v23, v24, v25

    This covers the whole record: Moab, Canaanite kings, Midian, Ammon, the Philistines. None of them ever got the better of Yahweh.

  19. הַמַּמְלָכוֹת

    hammamlākôt · H4467

    the kingdoms · v18

    These are states ruled by kings, the very kind of nation Israel now wants to be (8:5, 20). The word shares its root with melek, “king,” which comes in the next verse.

  20. הַלֹּחֲצִים

    hallōḥăṣîm · H3905

    the ones oppressing / squeezing · v18

    The verb's root meaning is to press or squeeze, as when Balaam's donkey crushes his foot against a wall (Num 22:25). It is the word the exodus and Judges use for foreign domination. The participle describes the kingdoms as habitual oppressors.

  21. וְאַתֶּ֨ם

    wəʾattem · H0859D

    and you (plural) · v19

    The pronoun is written out even though the verb already marks 'you'. That makes it emphatic: 'But you…', setting Israel's conduct against what God has just said he did in verse 18.

  22. הַיּ֜וֹם

    hayyôm · H3117G

    the day; today · v19

    'This very day.' It ties the charge to the assembly at Mizpah and has the ring of a formal public ruling, as in Deuteronomy's 'this day'.

  23. מְאַסְתֶּ֣ם

    məʾastem · H3988A

    to reject, refuse, despise · v19

    A completed act: 'you have rejected'. This is the language of breaking a covenant (a binding relationship of loyalty), the same verb God used in 8:7: 'they have rejected me from being king over them.'

  24. אֲשֶׁר־

    ʾăšer- · H0834A

    who, which · v19, v24

    Opens a description of who this God is, and that description is the reason the rejection is absurd.

  25. ה֣וּא

    hûʾ · H1931

    he · v19, v22

    Emphatic: 'he himself' is the one who saves. KJV and WEB bring this out with 'himself'.

  26. מוֹשִׁ֣יעַ

    môšîaʿ · H3467

    to save, deliver, rescue · v19

    A participle (a verb form for an ongoing activity or role): 'the one who keeps rescuing you', or 'your deliverer'. In Judges and Samuel it means military and political rescue from oppressors.

  27. לָכֶם֮

    lākem · H9036

    to/for you · v19

    'For you', meaning on your behalf. God's saving has been aimed at this people.

  28. רָעוֹתֵיכֶ֣ם

    rāʿôtêkem · H7451C

    evil, harm, disaster · v19

    Bad things that happen to someone: disasters and calamities, not moral wickedness. The plural pictures a long run of them.

  29. וְצָרֹֽתֵיכֶם֒

    wəṣārōtêkem · H6869B

    distress, trouble · v19

    From a root meaning 'narrow, tight': being hemmed in and pressed. Paired with the previous word it echoes Deuteronomy 31:17, 21 ('many evils and troubles') and Judges 10:14.

  30. ל֔וֹ

    lô · H9033

    to him · v19, v24

    The Hebrew text has 'to him', meaning God. The ancient versions read the same-sounding lōʾ, 'No!' (see variants). Either way the request was effectively put to God.

  31. כִּי־

    kî- · H3588A

    for, that, but rather · v19, v24

    After 'No' it means 'but rather', as in 8:19 ('No, but a king…'). After 'to him' it simply introduces the quoted words.

  32. מֶ֖לֶךְ

    melek · H4428G

    king · v19, v24

    Comes first in its clause for emphasis: 'a KING you must set over us.' In 8:5 and 8:20 the people asked for a king to judge them and fight their battles 'like all the nations', which were roles God had filled himself.

  33. תָּשִׂ֣ים

    tāśîm · H7760L

    to put, set, appoint · v19

    'You (singular) shall set': a demand worded as an expectation. In 8:5 they told Samuel 'set (śîmâ) for us a king'. Here the demand is treated as made to God.

  34. עָלֵ֑ינוּ

    ʿālênû · H5921A

    upon, over · v19

    'Over us': a ruler placed above the people, with the burdens Samuel listed in 8:11–18.

  35. וְעַתָּ֗ה

    wəʿattâ · H6258

    and now · v19

    The standard turn in a formal speech from the review of events to what must happen next: 'So now…'.

  36. הִֽתְיַצְּבוּ֙

    hityaṣṣəbû · H3320

    to take one's stand, present oneself · v19, v23

    A command: 'take your stations'. It is used for standing formally before God in solemn assembly (Exodus 19:17; Joshua 24:1), and here sets up the casting of lots.

  37. לִפְנֵ֣י

    lipnê · H6440G

    before (literally 'to the face of') · v19, v25

    In God's presence. The choosing that follows is understood as God's own decision.

  38. לְשִׁבְטֵיכֶ֖ם

    ləšibṭêkem · H7626H

    tribe (also 'rod, staff') · v19, v20, v21

    'By your tribes': Israel's largest kinship units, the first level the lot narrows through (v. 20, Benjamin is taken).

  39. וּלְאַלְפֵיכֶֽם׃

    ûləʾalpêkem · H0505H

    thousand; clan, military contingent · v19

    Here a kin group below the tribe (the clan), which also supplied a unit of fighting men. Not a head-count of a thousand. In v. 21 the lot falls on 'the clan of the Matrites'.

  40. וַיַּקְרֵ֣ב

    vayyaqrev · H7126

    bring near, present · v20, v21

    The causative form: Samuel made the tribes come close, that is, presented them 'before the LORD' (v. 19). It is the same verb used for presenting offerings and people at the sanctuary, so the assembly is a sacred proceeding, not a vote.

  41. וַיִּלָּכֵ֖ד

    vayyillakhed · H3920

    be captured, caught, taken · v20, v21

    Passive: 'was caught.' The ordinary verb for capturing a city or trapping an animal is also the technical verb for being picked out when lots are cast. Nobody chooses Benjamin; Benjamin is caught.

  42. בִּנְיָמִֽן׃

    Binyamin · H1144

    Benjamin ('son of the right hand' / 'son of the south') · v20, v21

    The smallest tribe, and one with a disgraced past (Judges 19–21). Saul himself had called it 'the smallest of the tribes of Israel' (9:21), so the lot lands where nobody would have expected.

  43. לְמִשְׁפְּחֹתָ֔יו

    lĕmišpĕḥōtāyw · H4940

    clan, kin-group · v21

    "By its clans": the tribe comes forward in its sub-groups. A mishpachah is a clan, a group of related households, bigger than a household but smaller than a tribe.

  44. הַמַּטְרִ֑י

    hammaṭrî · H4309

    Matrite, (of) Matri · v21

    "The Matrite" clan. It appears only here and is missing from the Benjaminite clan lists in Genesis 46, Numbers 26 and 1 Chronicles 7–8, and from Saul's family tree in 9:1.

  45. שָׁא֣וּל

    šāʾûl · H7586

    Saul · v21

    Saul's name means "asked for". That fits a people who asked for a king (8:5–10), and it plays on v. 22, where they "ask" (wayyishalu) the LORD where he is.

  46. קִ֔ישׁ

    qîš · H7027

    Kish · v21

    Saul's father, introduced in 9:1 as a Benjaminite of standing, "a mighty man of wealth/valor".

  47. וַיְבַקְשֻׁ֖הוּ

    wayḇaqšuhû · H1245

    seek, search for · v21

    "And they sought him": the crowd searches for the man just chosen. The verb repeats the key word of chapter 9, where Saul spent days "seeking" his father's lost donkeys.

  48. וְלֹ֥א

    wĕlōʾ · H3808

    not · v21

    Plain negation: "and not".

  49. נִמְצָֽא׃

    nimṣāʾ · H4672

    find; (passive) be found · v21

    "He was found". With the negative: he was not to be found. The king God has just picked is missing at the moment he is chosen. This sets up v. 22, where the LORD reveals he is hiding among the baggage.

  50. וַיִּשְׁאֲלוּ־

    vayyish'alu · H7592

    to ask, inquire · v22

    Followed by 'of Yahweh', this is the standard phrase for formally consulting God through a sacred oracle, not private prayer. It is also the root of Saul's name, Sha'ul ('asked for'), so the people 'ask' again in order to find the 'Asked-for' one.

  51. עוֹד֙

    od · H5750

    again, still, further · v22

    'Again' or 'further'. The lot-casting that has just picked out Saul (v. 21) was already a way of asking God. Now a second inquiry is needed because the man the lot chose is missing.

  52. הֲבָ֥א

    havā · H935

    to come, enter · v22

    The prefix 'ha-' turns it into a question. 'Has (he/anyone) come?' The form could also be read as 'is coming', which leaves room for 'Is there still someone to come?'

  53. הֲלֹ֣ם

    halōm · H1988

    here, hither · v22

    'Here, to this place', meaning the assembly at Mizpah where the lots are being cast before Yahweh.

  54. אִ֑ישׁ

    ish · H376

    man, person · v22, v25

    'A man' (the Hebrew has no 'the'). It refers to the individual the lot has just narrowed down to. A paragraph-break marker (ס) follows in the Hebrew manuscript tradition, setting God's answer apart.

  55. הִנֵּה־

    hinneh · H2009

    look, behold · v22

    A word that points: 'Look! There he is.' It is vivid, almost like a finger pointing at the spot. 'Behold' is accurate but sounds stiffer than the Hebrew.

  56. נֶחְבָּ֖א

    nechbā · H2244

    to hide oneself, be hidden · v22

    A participle, describing an ongoing state: 'is hiding himself' or 'is in hiding' right now. The form usually means hiding oneself on purpose. It is the same form Adam uses in Gen 3:10 ('I hid myself'), and the same verb is used of Israelites hiding from the Philistines later in Saul's story (1 Sam 13:6; 14:11).

  57. הַכֵּלִֽים׃

    hakkelim · H3627

    vessel, implement, equipment, baggage · v22

    'The gear': the packs, containers and equipment the assembled tribes had brought and stacked up at the edge of the gathering. The same word also means weapons and armour, which matters later in Saul's story.

  58. וַיָּרֻ֙צוּ֙

    vayyārutsu · H7323

    run · v23

    "And they ran." Nobody is named as the runners; it's simply some of the crowd. The verb shows people hurrying the moment the LORD says where the hidden man is (v. 22). It's a picture of eager excitement.

  59. וַיִּקָּחֻ֣הוּ

    vayyiqqāḥuhu · H3947

    take, fetch · v23

    "And they took him." Here it means they fetched him and brought him out. Saul does not walk out on his own. Others bring him out of hiding.

  60. מִשָּׁ֔ם

    mishshām · H8033

    there; from there · v23

    "From there" means from among the baggage (v. 22) where he had hidden. It ties this scene straight to the comic picture of the chosen king crouched among the luggage.

  61. בְּת֣וֹךְ

    betokh · H8432

    in the midst of · v23

    "In the middle of" the people. He stands among them, surrounded, where everyone can see him and compare.

  62. וַיִּגְבַּהּ֙

    vayyigbah · H1361

    be high, be tall · v23

    "And he was tall," or literally "and he was high." Here the word is about his body. Elsewhere the same root also describes pride (a "high" heart), and it comes back in 16:7, where God tells Samuel not to look at the "height" of Eliab's stature.

  63. מִשִּׁכְמ֖וֹ

    mishshikhmo · H7926

    shoulder, upper back · v23

    "From his shoulder." Shekhem is the shoulder area, where loads are carried. The picture is that everyone else reached only up to his shoulders.

  64. וָמָֽעְלָה׃

    vāmā'lāh · H4605

    above, upward · v23

    "And upward." Taken together, "from his shoulder and upward" means his head and neck rose above everyone else's. These are the very words used when Saul is introduced in 9:2.

  65. הַרְּאִיתֶם֙

    harəʾîtem · H7200

    have you seen? · v24

    A question expecting the answer 'yes': 'Have you seen…?' Samuel, who was known as 'the seer' (9:9), asks the crowd to look at the man who has just stood up a head taller than all of them.

  66. בָּֽחַר־

    bāḥar · H0977

    he chose · v24

    Choosing as selecting someone from a group for a role. Here it refers to the lot that has just picked out Benjamin, then the Matrite clan, then Saul (10:20–21). The perfect tense presents the choice as done.

  67. אֵ֥ין

    ʾên · H0369

    there is not · v24

    The standard word for saying something does not exist: 'there is no one…'.

  68. כָּמֹ֖הוּ

    kāmōhû · H3644

    like him · v24

    'Like him', a comparison. The words 'there is none like…' are usually said of God in Israel's poetry (e.g. 1 Sam 2:2). Here they are said of a man whose obvious distinction is that he is tall (v. 23).

  69. וַיָּרִ֧עוּ

    wayyāriʿû · H7321

    and they shouted · v24

    To raise a loud group shout. The same verb is used for a battle cry, an alarm, and the roar that greets a king or God. It is loud and collective, not polite applause.

  70. יְחִ֥י

    yəḥî · H2421

    may he live · v24

    A wish form of 'to live': 'May (the king) live!' It wishes him life, health and a long reign, and is the standard Israelite cry when a king is acclaimed (2 Sam 16:16; 1 Kgs 1:25, 34, 39; 2 Kgs 11:12).

  71. וַיְדַבֵּ֨ר

    vayedabber · H1696G

    speak · v25

    'And he spoke / declared.' The intensive form of the verb is the ordinary word for speaking at length or formally; here it is a public declaration to the assembly, not a private chat.

  72. מִשְׁפַּ֣ט

    mishpat · H4941J

    judgment, ordinance, custom, rightful due · v25

    'The regulation / rule / proper order of.' Here it means the binding norm that defines how kingship is to work: what belongs to it and what it owes. It covers both the king's prerogatives and his limits.

  73. הַמְּלֻכָ֔ה

    hammelukhah · H4410

    kingship, royal office · v25

    'The kingship': the office and rule of a king, not a territory. The word is different from 'the king' used in Samuel's earlier warning (8:9, 11), which may signal a different document.

  74. וַיִּכְתֹּ֣ב

    vayyikhtov · H3789

    write · v25

    'And he wrote.' The spoken terms are fixed in writing so they can serve as a lasting witness that cannot later be quietly revised.

  75. בַּסֵּ֔פֶר

    bassefer · H5612H

    written document, scroll · v25

    'In the document / on the scroll.' Any written record (letter, deed, certificate, scroll). The article ('the') probably means 'the document in question', though some take it as a known existing scroll.

  76. וַיַּנַּ֖ח

    vayyannaḥ · H5117

    set down, deposit, cause to rest · v25

    'And he deposited [it].' The same verb is used for laying up the jar of manna and Aaron's staff 'before the LORD' as permanent witnesses (Exod 16:33–34; Num 17:7 [Heb 17:22]).

  77. וַיְשַׁלַּ֧ח

    vayeshallaḥ · H7971G

    send, send away, dismiss · v25

    'And he dismissed.' The formal close of the assembly. Samuel, not the new king, still presides.

  78. לְבֵיתֽוֹ׃

    leveito · H1004B

    house, household, home · v25

    'To his house': back to ordinary life. Verse 26 picks up the phrase: 'Saul also went to his home in Gibeah.' For now the new king goes home too, and there is no palace or standing court yet.

The world behind it

Where this falls in the story. Israel's elders had demanded "a king to judge us like all the nations" (8:5). Samuel took this badly, and Yahweh told him it was a rejection of Yahweh himself (8:7). Even so, Yahweh told Samuel to grant the request. Saul was then anointed privately at Ramah (9:26–10:1), with signs to confirm it (10:2–13), but he told no one (10:16). This verse begins the public stage. The king is chosen openly by sacred lot at Mizpah (10:17–27). He is then confirmed at Gilgal after his victory at Jabesh-gilead (11:14–15).

Why "to Yahweh" matters. Israel was a loose league of tribes with no permanent central government. Big decisions (war, judging a tribe, choosing a leader) were taken at assemblies held "before Yahweh" at a recognised holy site. Yahweh's will could be sought there through a priest or prophet, or by sacred lot. The lot procedure that follows narrows the choice from tribe to clan to household to one man. It matches the way Achan was singled out in Josh 7:14–18. The ancient audience would have understood the result as God's choice, not a vote.

Mizpah. It was a hilltop town in Benjamin, Saul's own tribe. Israel had gathered there before in times of national crisis (Judg 20–21; 1 Sam 7). In 1 Sam 7, Samuel led a repentance ceremony there, and Yahweh defeated the Philistines with thunder. Calling Israel back to this spot to install a king sets the new institution against the memory of what God had done without one.

From the study of 1 Samuel 10:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17

Is the Mizpah lot-scene a separate (and more critical) account of how Saul became king, or a planned second stage of one story?

  • A separate tradition, critical of kingship, set beside a favourable one.

    From Wellhausen onward, many critics have grouped 8; 10:17–27; 12 as negative about kingship (stressing 'you rejected your God'). They group 9:1–10:16 and 11 as positive (a secret anointing and a heroic victory). On this view Saul is made king twice or three times because separate sources were combined.

  • A deliberate sequence: designation, public selection, confirmation.

    Literary and historical studies (e.g. Halpern, Edelman, and many recent commentators) compare ancient Near Eastern accession patterns: a leader is privately designated, then publicly shown, then proven in battle and confirmed. They read 9–11 as one planned story. The private anointing (10:1), the public lot (10:17–24) and the confirmation at Gilgal after Jabesh (11:14–15) are successive steps. The doubters in 10:27 lead into ch. 11.

in v17

Does the verb 'summon' (from the root 'cry out') deliberately echo the 'outcry' theme of chs. 7–9?

  • Yes, it is intentional wordplay.

    The root ṣ/zʿq comes at key points: Samuel's cry at Mizpah (7:8–9), the warning that they will cry out because of their king (8:18), and 'their cry has come to me' (9:16, same ṣ-spelling). Using this root, and not a more common verb such as qārāʾ 'call' or qāhal 'assemble', could be meant to recall them.

  • No, it is simply the normal word for mustering.

    The causative of ṣāʿaq/zāʿaq is a standard term for calling up the tribes (Judg 4:10, 13; 6:34–35; 2 Kgs 3:21 passive), so it needs no special explanation. Any echo is at most in the background.

in v18

Is 1 Samuel 10:17–27 part of a separate source hostile to kings, or a unified telling that is in two minds about them?

  • This passage, along with 8:1–22 and ch. 12, belongs to a later layer hostile to kings. The layer is often linked to the editors who shaped Deuteronomy through Kings, and it sits beside an older strand that welcomes the monarchy (9:1–10:16; ch. 11).

    The tone differs sharply: here the king is a rejection of God, while in 9:16 God himself plans a leader to save Israel. Saul is chosen twice (private anointing, then public lot). The language matches Deuteronomy and Judges (the exodus formula, ‘oppress’, the speech close to Judg 6:8–10).

  • The narrative is a deliberate literary whole that holds divine permission and divine displeasure together. This is in two minds about kingship rather than combining contradictory sources.

    Even here Yahweh grants the king and takes part in choosing him by lot. Chapter 8 already holds both rejection and consent (8:7, 22). Close literary readings find a coherent story about a monarchy granted under protest.

in v18

Does the speech draw on ancient Near Eastern treaty forms?

  • Yes. Listing Yahweh's benefits before the accusation mirrors the historical prologue of treaties between an overlord and a vassal. The vassal is accused of betraying a benefactor.

    Hittite treaties (14th–13th c. BC) open by recounting the overlord's favours. The covenant language in Deuteronomy and Joshua 24 has a similar logic, as does the language of rejecting a ruler (v.19, māʾas).

  • The parallel is a general one. What we have is a native Israelite prophetic accusation, and no direct dependence on treaties needs to be assumed.

    The same rhetorical pattern is common throughout prophetic literature (Judg 6:8–10; Amos 2:9–11; Mic 6:3–5). The treaty parallels are mostly Late Bronze Age, and dating and transmission are uncertain.

in v19

Is this speech hostile to kingship as such, and how does it fit with the friendlier account of Saul in 9:1–10:16?

  • Two sources: an earlier pro-monarchy story (9:1–10:16; 11) and a later anti-monarchy layer (8; 10:17–27; 12), often linked to the editors who shaped Deuteronomy through Kings.

    Shifts in tone and repeated scenes. Saul is chosen privately by anointing and then publicly by lot. The language of this speech resembles Deuteronomy and Judges 10:11–16 (Wellhausen, Noth, McCarter).

  • A unified, deliberately mixed portrait: kingship is allowed (Deuteronomy 17) but was requested for the wrong reasons, so God grants it under protest and on conditions.

    God commands Samuel to 'listen to their voice' (8:7, 9, 22). God chooses Saul (9:16). Chapter 12 ends with conditions, not abolition (12:14, 20–25). Literary readings such as Tsumura and Polzin stress that the narrative is coherent.

in v19

Does the lot procedure deliberately recall the detection of Achan's guilt in Joshua 7?

  • Yes. The verbs ('come near', 'be taken', nilkad) and the narrowing from tribe to clan to household to man echo Joshua 7:14–18, so Saul's selection is framed as the uncovering of a guilty party.

    Identical terminology, and the setting directly after an accusation of rejecting God (McCarter, Edelman).

  • No special echo. Lot-casting by kinship units was simply standard practice for any sacred selection, whether of the guilty or of a leader.

    Similar procedures for dividing land and choosing (Numbers 26:55; Joshua 14–19; 1 Samuel 14:40–42). The same terms would naturally appear in any lot narrative.

in v20

Does the echo of Achan's exposure (Joshua 7) cast a shadow over Saul's selection?

  • Yes. The echo is deliberate and points toward judgment. The narrator uses the same verbs and the same tribe-clan-man procedure that once exposed a guilty man, so the king is found the way a culprit is found. This fits Samuel's indictment just before (v. 19) and Saul's later failure.

    The vocabulary in Josh 7:14–18 and 1 Sam 10:19–21 is closely parallel (bring near / be taken, by tribes and clans). Verse 19 frames the assembly as following the people's rejection of God. Saul hiding among the baggage (v. 22) and his later rejection (chs. 13, 15) also count. Argued by literary readers such as Robert Polzin (*Samuel and the Deuteronomist*) and noted by Robert Alter (*The David Story*).

  • No. This is simply the standard vocabulary for lot-casting and carries no negative meaning of its own.

    The same verbs describe any lot procedure. In 1 Sam 14:41–42 the lot 'takes' Jonathan, who has done nothing morally wrong. Elsewhere in the chapter Saul's selection is presented positively (10:1, 6–7, 24, 'Do you see the one the LORD has chosen?'). Many commentators (e.g. Tsumura, NICOT) read the lot mainly as a public confirmation of God's choice.

in v20

How does this public lot relate to Saul's private anointing (9:1–10:16) and his military victory (ch. 11)?

  • These are originally separate traditions about how Saul became king. An editor placed them side by side.

    Classic source criticism (Wellhausen; P. Kyle McCarter, *I Samuel*, Anchor Bible) points to the different tone of each account. The anointing is favorable to kingship, while the Mizpah speech is critical. Saul's anointing seems unknown at Mizpah, and 11:14–15 speaks of 'renewing' the kingdom.

  • They form one ordered sequence: secret designation, public confirmation, proving in battle, and confirmation by the people.

    Baruch Halpern (*The Constitution of the Monarchy in Israel*) and Diana Edelman argue for a pattern known from ancient Near Eastern and Israelite accounts of how a leader came to power: designation, demonstration of ability, confirmation. A private anointing could not make a man king of the tribes, so a public, God-given sign like the lot was needed.

in v20

What device was used to cast the lot?

  • The priestly Urim and Thummim.

    These were Israel's official means of asking God for yes/no answers. The Greek text of 1 Sam 14:41 explicitly mentions Urim and Thummim in a similar 'taking' scene.

  • Ordinary lots (stones, sticks, or similar), or the text simply does not say.

    Verse 20 names no device and no priest. Lots were widely used for allotting land (Josh 18–19), and Prov 16:33 speaks of the lot cast into the lap. The narrator only cares that God decided.

in v21

Why does Saul hide, and why is he "not found" (vv. 21–22)?

  • Modesty or humility: Saul feels unworthy of the office.

    In 9:21 Saul protests that he comes from the smallest tribe and the least clan. In 10:16 he keeps the anointing secret. In 15:17 Samuel recalls a time when Saul was "little in his own eyes".

  • Fear, reluctance or insecurity, an early sign of the instability that will undo him.

    Hiding "among the baggage" is undignified. Later Saul acts out of fear of the people (15:24) and hesitates at key moments (13:8–12). The narrator often depicts Saul in ambiguous or comic terms.

  • The narrator deliberately leaves it ambiguous.

    The text gives no motive. The same features (shyness, hiding, a reluctant hero) can be read either way, much like Gideon's protests in Judges 6.

in v21

How does this public lot relate to Saul's private anointing (9:1–10:16) and his military acclamation (ch. 11)?

  • Separate traditions about Saul's rise, combined by an editor.

    Three different accounts of how Saul became king (anointing, lot, victory), with no cross-references in 10:17–27 to the earlier anointing. The scholarly theory of a pro-monarchy and an anti-monarchy source has traditionally been used to explain the tension.

  • A deliberate sequence in the story: private designation, then public confirmation, then proof in action.

    Ancient Near Eastern and Israelite parallels for designation followed by public acknowledgement. 11:14–15 frames Gilgal as a "renewal" of the kingdom, which presupposes the earlier steps.

in v21

Does the Achan-like lot procedure signal judgment on Saul or on the people?

  • Yes: the echo of Joshua 7 is deliberately ominous.

    The vocabulary (hiqriv, nilkad) and the nested sequence are the same. The scene follows Samuel's accusation of rejecting God (10:19). The same procedure singles out Jonathan in 14:41–42.

  • No: the lot is simply the standard way of getting God's decision.

    Lots were also used for neutral purposes such as dividing land (Joshua 14–19). The text affirms God's choice in v. 24: "Do you see the one the LORD has chosen?"

in v22

Why did Saul hide?

  • Modesty or humility: he did not want to seem eager to rule.

    Josephus (Antiquities 6) explains the withdrawal this way, and later Jewish interpreters often praised Saul's humility. It fits his self-deprecation in 9:21 and his silence about the kingship in 10:16.

  • Fear, insecurity or reluctance.

    The verb ḥ-b-' usually goes with fear (Gen 3:10; Josh 10:16; 1 Sam 13:6). Samuel later says Saul was 'little in your own eyes' (15:17). The hiding foreshadows his later wavering under pressure (13:8–12; 15:24).

  • The motive is left open on purpose, and the scene works as irony about the monarchy.

    The narrator gives no reason. The contrast with v. 23 (a head taller than everyone) and the scoffers in v. 27 suggests the story is more interested in the picture than in Saul's inner state.

in v22

How did Yahweh's answer come?

  • Through the priestly lots (Urim and Thummim), by a series of yes/no questions.

    'Inquire of Yahweh' is the regular term for this kind of consultation (1 Sam 14:37–42; 23:2–12; 30:7–8). A detailed answer could be worked out step by step.

  • Through Samuel speaking as a prophet.

    The answer is a full sentence, which goes beyond a simple yes or no. Samuel presides over the assembly, and prophets are a recognised channel (1 Sam 28:6). The Septuagint's 'Samuel asked' fits this view.

in v22

What exactly was asked?

  • 'Has the man (Saul) come here yet?'

    The Septuagint has 'the man'. That gives the most natural sense in context, since the chosen man is missing.

  • 'Is there still another man to come?' Did the lot procedure need to continue?

    The Hebrew text as it stands has no article, and od can mean 'still/another'. ESV and WEB render it this way.

in v23

Why was Saul hiding among the baggage (v. 22), and how does this colour the picture of the tall man brought out in v. 23?

  • Modesty: Saul shrank from the honor.

    This fits his self-deprecating words in 9:21 ("am I not a Benjaminite, from the smallest tribe…?") and his silence about the kingship in 10:16. Many older interpreters, and some modern ones, read it as genuine humility at the start of his reign.

  • Fear, reluctance or lack of confidence: a first sign of the insecurity that later undoes him.

    The verb in v. 22 means "hid himself." Saul's later reign is marked by fear of the people (15:24) and by panic (13:11–12; 28:5). Commentators such as Robert Alter and others read the scene as darkly comic: a giant who cannot face his own public selection.

  • Deliberately ambiguous: the narrator leaves it open.

    The text gives no motive. Several recent commentators (e.g. Tsumura) hold that the story describes his behavior without judging it, and lets later events shape how the reader sees it.

in v23

Is the notice of Saul's height straightforward praise or quiet irony?

  • Sincere praise: Saul is shown as a fitting king at this stage.

    Samuel himself praises him in v. 24 ("there is no one like him"). God chose him (9:16; 10:24), and 9:2 describes him admiringly as "choice and handsome." In the ancient world, height really was seen as a sign of fitness to rule.

  • Foreshadowing irony: the narrator is setting up the standard that 16:7 overturns.

    The same root (gvh) comes back in 16:7, "the height (govah) of his stature … for I have rejected him." Elsewhere the root is the standard word for pride. Some readers see a deliberate verbal link prepared by the writer of the finished book. Others reply that the pride sense needs "heart" or "eyes" with it, and that the link in this verse is about appearance only.

in v23

How does this lot scene relate to the private anointing (9:1–10:16) and the Jabesh victory (ch. 11)?

  • Separate traditions about how Saul became king, later combined.

    The three accounts each seem complete on their own, and they differ in attitude toward kingship (8; 10:17–19 are critical, 9:1–10:16 is favorable). This is a common position in historical-critical scholarship (e.g. McCarter, Anchor Bible).

  • One story in three stages: private anointing, public selection, military confirmation.

    The repeated description of his height (9:2 / 10:23) and 11:14's "let us renew the kingship" point to deliberate sequence. This is a parallel to ancient Near Eastern accession patterns argued by scholars such as Halpern and Tsumura.

in v24

Is Samuel's praise of Saul sincere, or does the narrator mean it ironically?

  • Sincere: Samuel loyally presents the king God has chosen.

    God himself told Samuel to anoint Saul as deliverer (9:16; 10:1). The lot is God's verdict. Samuel's words match Deut 17:15, and 'none like him' is ordinary royal praise (compare 2 Kgs 18:5; 23:25).

  • Ambivalent or ironic: the narrator undercuts the praise.

    It comes straight after the charge 'you have rejected your God' (10:19). The praise rests only on height (v. 23), which God later explicitly dismisses (16:7). 'There is none like…' is language usually reserved for God (2:2), and the people wanted a king to be 'like' the nations (8:5, 20). Some reject Saul at once (10:27). Many literary readers (e.g. Alter, Polzin) see both levels at work.

in v24

How does this public selection relate to the other accounts of Saul becoming king?

  • Separate sources: different traditions have been joined together.

    The private anointing (9:1–10:16), the selection by lot (10:17–27) and the 'renewal' of the kingdom at Gilgal (11:12–15) look like parallel accounts. Since Wellhausen, many critics have also found pro-monarchy and anti-monarchy strands in chs. 8–12.

  • One sequence: a coherent pattern of how a king came to the throne.

    Scholars such as Baruch Halpern argue for a known pattern: designation (anointing and lot), demonstration (the Jabesh-gilead victory, ch. 11), then confirmation (Gilgal). The doubters of 10:27, silenced in 11:12–13, tie the episodes together.

in v25

Is the 'mishpat of the kingship' in 10:25 the same as the 'mishpat of the king' in 8:11–18?

  • Different documents: 10:25 is a charter that defines and limits the royal office, in the spirit of Deuteronomy 17:14–20.

    The wording changes from 'the king' to 'the kingship'. A mere prediction of abuses would hardly be written as a formal document and deposited before YHWH as a witness, which matches covenant practice (Deut 31:26; Josh 24:26). Chapter 12 then holds king and people to covenant terms (12:13–15, 24–25).

  • Essentially the same content: Samuel puts in writing the warning of chapter 8 as a permanent indictment.

    In both places mishpat is used with a royal term and Samuel declares it to the people (8:9, 'declare to them'). Josephus seems to read it this way. A written warning deposited before God would also work as a witness against the people's choice (compare Deut 31:26–29, where the law-scroll is a witness *against* Israel).

  • Both: a document setting out the king's legitimate claims together with his obligations.

    Mishpat naturally covers both 'what is due to' and 'what governs' an office (compare Deut 18:3, 'the mishpat of the priests', meaning their rightful portions). Translations that say 'rights and duties' take this middle path.

in v25

How does this verse relate to the 'law of the king' in Deuteronomy 17:14–20?

  • 10:25 reflects an early tradition of written royal limits that Deuteronomy later formalised, or that Deuteronomy preserves.

    Both texts put the king under a written norm kept at the sanctuary. The idea of covenant between king and people appears in independent-looking traditions (2 Sam 5:3; 2 Kgs 11:17).

  • 10:25 was shaped by the editors who compiled Israel's history in the light of Deuteronomy, writing a Deuteronomic ideal back into Saul's accession.

    Many critical scholars date Deut 17 to the late monarchy and assign 1 Sam 8 and 10:17–27 to an editorial layer that is critical of kingship. The verse's vocabulary (sefer, 'before YHWH', a written witness) closely matches Deut 31.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. צָעַק (Hiphil 'call together, summon')
  • HALOT s.v. צעק, זעק
  • HALOT s.v. מִצְפָּה
  • BDB s.v. עַם
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), on 10:17–27
  • Diana Edelman, King Saul in the Historiography of Judah (designation–testing–confirmation pattern)
  • Baruch Halpern, The Constitution of the Monarchy in Israel
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 7 and 10
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), 1 Kingdoms 10:17
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 10:17
  • BDB s.v. עָלָה, נָצַל, לָחַץ, מַמְלָכָה, יָד
  • HALOT s.v. לחץ; s.v. נצל
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), on 10:17–27 and the Septuagint readings
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 10)
  • Claus Westermann, Basic Forms of Prophetic Speech
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Samuel 8–12
  • Septuagint, 1 Reigns 10:18
  • BDB s.v. מָאַס, יָשַׁע, רָעָה, צָרָה, אֶלֶף
  • HALOT s.v. מאס; ישׁע; אֶלֶף II
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8), on 10:17–27
  • David Toshio Tsumura, The First Book of Samuel (NICOT)
  • G. E. Mendenhall, 'The Census Lists of Numbers 1 and 26', JBL 77 (1958)
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia apparatus to 1 Sam 10:19
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) 1 Reigns 10:19; Vulgate 1 Sam 10:19
  • BDB s.v. לָכַד, קָרַב, שֵׁבֶט, בִּנְיָמִין
  • HALOT s.v. לכד (Niphal, 'be taken' by lot); s.v. קרב (Hiphil)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible 8)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story
  • Robert Polzin, Samuel and the Deuteronomist
  • J. Lindblom, 'Lot-Casting in the Old Testament', Vetus Testamentum 12 (1962)
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms 10:19–21 (Rahlfs)
  • Parallel texts: Joshua 7:14–18; 1 Samuel 9:21; 14:41–42; Proverbs 16:33; Judges 19–21; Genesis 35:18; 49:10
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. לָכַד (niphal "be taken" by lot)
  • HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפָּחָה
  • BDB s.v. קָרַב (hiphil "bring near, present")
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 10:21
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), notes on 10:17–27
  • Ralph W. Klein, 1 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Robert Alter, The David Story (on seek/find wordplay and Saul's name)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on lot-casting and Mizpah assembly
  • BDB s.v. שָׁאַל, חָבָא, כְּלִי, עוֹד
  • HALOT s.v. כְּלִי; חבא
  • S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel (on 1 Sam 10:22)
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible), textual notes on 10:21–22
  • Robert Alter, The David Story (notes on Saul's name and 10:22)
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 10:22
  • Josephus, Jewish Antiquities book 6 (Saul's election at Mizpah)
  • Robert Polzin, Samuel and the Deuteronomist (lot and kingship)
  • BDB s.v. גָּבַהּ
  • HALOT s.v. גבה; יצב (hitpael)
  • BDB s.v. שְׁכֶם
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., I Samuel (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 9–10
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. בָּחַר, רָאָה, רוּעַ, חָיָה, מֶלֶךְ
  • Rahlfs-Hanhart, Septuaginta (1 Kingdoms 10:24)
  • Biblia Sacra Vulgata (1 Reg 10:24)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament (1 Samuel 10)
  • BDB s.v. מִשְׁפָּט, מְלוּכָה, סֵפֶר, נוּחַ
  • HALOT s.v. מִשְׁפָּט; סֵפֶר; נוח (Hiphil)
  • TWOT on shaphat / mishpat
  • Septuagint, 1 Kingdoms (1 Samuel) 10:25
  • Vulgate, 1 Samuel 10:25
  • Josephus, Antiquities of the Jews, book 6 (Saul's accession)
  • Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 20b
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 1 Sam 10:25
  • Egyptian–Hittite treaty of Ramesses II and Hattusili III (deposit clauses)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).