Amos Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Amos 5:13–15
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
13Therefore, the prudent keep silent in such times, for the days are evil. 14Seek good, not evil, so that you may live. And the LORD, the God of Hosts, will be with you, as you have claimed. 15Hate evil and love good; establish justice in the gate. Perhaps the LORD, the God of Hosts, will be gracious to the remnant of Joseph.”
What the first hearers heard
To the comfortable elite of Samaria and Bethel, the verse would have stung in two ways.
-
As an indictment. You have made your courts so corrupt that the people with real insight have stopped speaking. The silence in your gate is not peace. It is a symptom. For a society that prided itself on prosperity and on the LORD being "with us" (5:14, "as you have claimed"), being told "it is a bad time" contradicted everything they believed about their moment. They were "putting far away the evil day" (6:3), and Amos says it is already here.
-
As a warning. The "evil time" is also the coming disaster. On that day the successful people at the top will be struck silent, among the mourners and the dead (5:16-17; 6:10; 8:3).
The verse then turns at once to the alternative: "Seek good and not evil, that you may live… Hate evil, love good, and establish justice in the gate" (5:14-15). The silence in v.13 is not offered as a model. It describes a situation that only repentance and real justice in the courts could reverse, and "it may be that the LORD… will be gracious" (5:15).
From the study of Amos 5:13.
Verse by verse
-
13Therefore, the prudent keep silent in such times, for the days are evil.
Full study →"That is why the person who sees clearly falls silent at that time, because it is a bad time, an evil, disastrous time."
The verse comes straight after God's charge in v.12: you oppress the innocent, you take bribes, you push the poor aside in the gate. "The gate" was the town court. Two verses earlier Amos said the people "hate the one who reproves in the gate and despise the one who speaks with integrity" (5:10). Against that background the first meaning is bitter: things have got so bad that the sensible person, the one with insight, has stopped talking. Speaking up in a bought court gets you nowhere, or gets you hurt. Their silence is itself evidence against the nation.
The Hebrew carries more than that. The word for "the prudent" also means "the one who prospers". The verb "be silent" also means "be struck still" or "be silenced" in death. And "an evil time" in Hebrew normally means a time of disaster (the same clause appears in Micah 2:3 about coming judgment). So a second meaning sits under the first: the successful people at the top, the ones profiting from the bribes, will be struck dumb when that day comes. Amos uses this kind of silence elsewhere: "Hush!" among the dead in 6:10, and "Silence!" over the corpses in 8:3.
Either way, the verb describes or predicts. It is not a command. The "bad time" is both the moral rot of the present and the calamity it is bringing. And the next line, "Seek good and not evil, that you may live" (5:14), shows that Amos himself has not gone quiet.
-
14Seek good, not evil, so that you may live. And the LORD, the God of Hosts, will be with you, as you have claimed.
Full study →"Make good the thing you go after (not evil) so that you, as a people, may stay alive. Then it will really be true: Yahweh, the God who commands the armies, will be with you, just as you keep saying he is."
Each part of the verse carries weight:
- "Seek" is the word for going to a shrine to consult God. A few lines earlier Amos said "Seek me and live; do not seek Bethel" (5:4–5). Now he says "Seek good." To approach God you do not make a pilgrimage. You do justice.
- "Good" and "evil" are not vague morality. Verse 15 defines them: "Hate evil, love good, establish justice in the gate." The town gate was the law court, and the "evil" was bribed judges, silenced witnesses and the poor taxed and turned away (5:10–12). The verse also plays on the one before it: "it is an evil time" (5:13). Chase evil and you will live in evil times, meaning disaster.
- "That you may live" is spoken to a nation Amos has just mourned in a funeral song (5:1–2). It means surviving as a people: avoiding defeat, the death of nine-tenths of the army (5:3) and exile (5:27). It echoes Moses' "I have set before you life and good, death and evil… choose life" (Deuteronomy 30:15, 19).
- "The God of Hosts" means "the God of armies," the divine warrior. Israel was sure this warrior fought for them.
- "As you have said" quotes their own slogan back at them: "Yahweh is with us!" Amos does not mock the hope. He makes it conditional. The presence they announce in worship will be real only where justice is done. Without that, the God of armies will not be beside them. He will come against them.
The next verse adds a careful "perhaps": even then, God may be gracious to "the remnant of Joseph." The offer is real, but it is not something Israel can take for granted.
-
15Hate evil and love good; establish justice in the gate. Perhaps the LORD, the God of Hosts, will be gracious to the remnant of Joseph.”
Full study →Hate what is evil, all of you: reject it, break with it, stop protecting it. Love what is good: commit yourselves to it as loyally as you would to your lord. Then take the justice you have knocked to the ground and stand it back up, firmly, in the city gate, where the elders sit to judge, where the poor man's case is heard, and where you have been taking bribes and pushing the needy aside. If you do, perhaps (only perhaps, because he is under no obligation) Yahweh, God of the armies of heaven and earth, will freely show favor to whatever is left of Joseph after the blow falls.
The verse is built as a turnaround. In 5:10 Israel "hated" the person who spoke up for the right in the gate. Now they must hate the evil itself. In 4:5 they "loved" their crowded festivals. Now they must love the good. "Love" and "hate" are verbs of choice and allegiance, not mainly of feeling: you show them by how you rule in court. "Make stand" pictures justice as something that has fallen over (5:7, "cast righteousness to the ground") and has to be raised and kept upright.
The promise is held back on purpose. "Perhaps" leaves the outcome with God. "Remnant" admits that the nation will be cut down whatever happens. The title "God of Hosts" reminds the hearers that the God whose favor they hope for is the commander of the army coming against them. The most hope Amos offers is a "maybe" for the survivors, and justice in the courtroom comes before it.
Where the English drifted
-
in v13
the prudent
hammaśkîl
- What we hear
- The cautious, sensible person who avoids risk, especially someone careful with money or trouble.
- What they heard
- The person with insight, who sees what is really going on. The same word also means the person who succeeds or prospers.
-
in v13
evil ("the days are evil" / "an evil time")
ʿēt rāʿâ
- What we hear
- A wicked or sinister era, morally dark days.
-
in v13
keep silent (as advice)
yiddōm
- What we hear
- A recommendation: in bad times the smart move is to keep your head down.
- What they heard
- A statement of what does or will happen: the wise fall silent, or are silenced. The root also covers being struck still in grief or death.
-
in v14
good … evil
tov … ra'
- What we hear
- Personal moral goodness in general; 'evil' as dark, extreme wickedness.
-
in v14
that you may live
lema'an tichyu
- What we hear
- Spiritual life or eternal life for the individual believer.
- What they heard
- The survival of the nation through coming military defeat and exile, and continued life on the land under God's favour (cf. 5:1–3, 27; Deut 30:15–19).
-
in v14
the God of Hosts
elohei tseva'ot
- What we hear
- 'Host' as someone who receives guests, or just a vague crowd; the title sounds ceremonial.
- What they heard
- 'God of armies': the divine warrior commanding heavenly and earthly forces, the God Israel expected to fight on its side.
-
in v15
hate / love
sane / ahev
- What we hear
- Feelings: disgust toward evil, warm affection for good.
- What they heard
- Choices of loyalty shown in action: reject and break with evil; commit to and side with the good, especially in court.
-
in v15
judgment (KJV)
mishpat
- What we hear
- Condemnation or punishment, God's judgment falling on someone.
- What they heard
- A fair legal decision and the protected rights it upholds, which the people are told to put in place.
-
in v15
remnant
sheʾerit
- What we hear
- A faithful, chosen inner group whose survival is guaranteed.
-
in v15
in the gate
vashaʿar
- What we hear
- At the entrance or doorway of the city.
- What they heard
- In the town's court and public assembly, held in the gate complex.
-
in v15
God of Hosts / God Almighty
ʾelohei tsevaʾot
- What we hear
- A general title of worship; "hosts" can sound like angel choirs or crowds.
- What they heard
- God of armies, the divine commander. In Amos the title carries a threat: this commander is mustering forces against Israel.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v13
Amos 5:13 doesn't tell you to stay quiet about injustice
- What's often taught
- The verse teaches that in corrupt or dangerous times the wise course is to keep your head down and stay out of public controversy.
- What the text supports
It gets one thing right: the verse recognises that speaking up in a corrupt court was dangerous (5:10), and Proverbs does praise restraint in speech (Prov 10:19). But the Hebrew verb yiddōm describes or predicts ('will be silent / falls silent'). It is not a command. In its setting the silence is evidence against Israel: the courts are so rotten that people with insight have given up. Or, on another strong reading, it is a threat that the prosperous will be silenced in the coming disaster. The verses on either side make Amos's own position clear. He condemns those who 'hate the one who reproves in the gate' (5:10), keeps prophesying when told to stop (7:10-17), and commands 'establish justice in the gate' (5:15).
- Where the English feeds it
- Present-tense, plural renderings such as 'the prudent keep quiet in such times, for the times are evil' make a specific line about Israel's crisis sound like timeless advice. The modern sense of 'prudent' (cautious, self-protective) points the same way.
Every word
-
לָכֵ֗ן
lāḵēn · H3651C
therefore · v13, v14
Literally 'for so', meaning 'for that reason'. In the prophets this is the usual hinge from charge to consequence (Amos 3:11; 5:11, 16; 6:7; 7:17). Here it follows the charges of v.12 but leads to a statement about the wise person, not a direct sentence from God. That oddity is part of why the verse is debated.
-
הַמַּשְׂכִּ֛יל
hammaśkîl · H7919A
be prudent, have insight; prosper · v13
'The one who has insight': a participle with the article, naming a type of person. The verb covers both seeing clearly and acting so that things go well. So the word can mean 'the wise/discerning person' or 'the one who succeeds/prospers'.
-
בָּעֵ֥ת
bāʿēt · H6256
time · v13
'In the time': a particular time with its own character, not abstract clock-time.
-
הַהִ֖יא
hahîʾ · H1931
that · v13
'That (time)'. It points either to the present corruption just described or forward to the coming judgment, like the prophets' phrase 'in that day'.
-
יִדֹּ֑ם
yiddōm · H1826H
be silent, be still · v13
'Will be silent / keeps silent'. The verb form can describe a habit or predict what will happen; it is not a command. The root also covers being struck still, dumbstruck in grief, or silenced in death. The main pause of the verse falls on this word.
-
כִּ֛י
kî · H3588A
for, because · v13
Introduces the reason for the silence.
-
רָעָ֖ה
rāʿâ · H7451I
bad, evil · v13, v14, v15
'Bad', agreeing with 'time'. It covers both 'wicked' and 'disastrous, harmful'. An 'evil time' in Hebrew usually means a time of calamity, though here the calamity comes from the moral evil of v.12.
-
דִּרְשׁוּ־
dirshu · H1875
-
ט֥וֹב
tov · H2896B
-
וְאַל־
ve'al · H0408
and not · v14
The negative used with commands and wishes. The verb is left out and carried over from 'seek': 'and do not seek evil.' The short, clipped form makes the contrast sharp.
-
לְמַ֣עַן
lema'an · H4616
for the sake of, so that · v14
Introduces the purpose and outcome of seeking good: so that you may live.
-
תִּֽחְי֑וּ
tichyu · H2421
live, stay alive · v14
'You (plural) may live': the nation surviving the judgment Amos has announced, in the sense of 5:3, where only a tenth of the army comes back. Life here is survival and a flourishing life on the land with God, not a statement about the afterlife.
-
וִיהִי־
vihi · H1961
be, become · v14
A wish form, 'and may it be / and then it will be,' following the command: the result that will come if they seek good.
-
יְהוָ֧ה
YHWH · H3068G
Yahweh (the LORD) · v14, v15
The personal name of Israel's God, the God of the covenant whose presence the people claim to have.
-
אֱלֹהֵֽי־
elohei · H0430G
God of · v14, v15
'God of,' bound to the next word: the God who commands the armies.
-
צְבָא֛וֹת
tseva'ot · H6635B
armies, hosts · v14, v15
'Armies': the warrior title of Yahweh, commander of heavenly and earthly forces. Israel counted on this warrior God being on their side. Amos says his presence depends on justice.
-
אִתְּכֶ֖ם
ittekhem · H0854
with you (plural) · v14
'With you all': the language of God going with his people in war and in life, giving help and protection.
-
כַּאֲשֶׁ֥ר
ka'asher · H0834D
just as · v14
'Just as': it compares the real presence of God that will follow justice with the presence the people already take for granted.
-
אֲמַרְתֶּֽם׃
amartem · H0559
you have said · v14
'You (plural) have said': Amos quotes their own confident slogan, 'Yahweh is with us,' back at them. The past tense marks it as something they keep saying.
-
שִׂנְאוּ־
sinʾu · H8130
hate · v15
Command to a whole group ("all of you"). In Hebrew, to "hate" is to reject, push away, and refuse loyalty to something, not mainly to feel loathing. It turns 5:10 around, where they "hate" the person who argues for the right in the gate.
-
וְאֶ֣הֱבוּ
veʾehevu · H0157G
and love · v15
Command to the group. To love is to choose, be loyal to, and side with. Here it means committing yourselves to the good as you would to a lord or a partner.
-
וְהַצִּ֥יגוּ
vehatsigu · H3322
and set, establish · v15
The verb form means "cause to stand" or "set firmly in place", used for setting down an object or posting something where it stays. Justice has been knocked down (5:7). Stand it back up and keep it there.
-
בַשַּׁ֖עַר
vashaʿar · H8179G
in the gate · v15
The city gate complex, where elders sat as the local court and where public business was done. "In the gate" means "in your courts and public life".
-
מִשְׁפָּ֑ט
mishpat · H4941H
justice, right ruling · v15
A fair legal decision and the right order it protects, above all the rights of people who cannot defend themselves. It is the thing that should happen in the gate and has stopped happening.
-
אוּלַ֗י
ʾulay · H0194
perhaps · v15
A real "maybe". It holds out hope without promising anything. Turning around does not force God's hand. His mercy stays his own free choice.
-
יֶֽחֱנַ֛ן
yeḥenan · H2603A
be gracious, show favor · v15
An imperfect verb after "perhaps": "he may show favor". It means a stronger party freely showing kindness or sparing a weaker one who has no claim on it.
-
שְׁאֵרִ֥ית
sheʾerit · H7611
remnant, what is left · v15
Whatever survives a disaster. The word assumes Joseph will be badly cut down. The hope is only for what is left afterwards.
-
יוֹסֵֽף׃
Yosef · H3130G
Joseph · v15
The tribes of Ephraim and Manasseh, the core of the northern kingdom of Israel. Here it stands for the whole northern nation that Amos was speaking to.
The world behind it
Israel under Jeroboam II (c. 760 BCE). Amos, a herdsman from Tekoa in Judah, preached in the northern kingdom at a time of military success and wealth for the elite: ivory-inlaid houses, summer and winter homes (3:15), luxury feasts (6:4-6). That wealth rested on taking land and produce from small farmers (5:11).
The gate as courtroom. Disputes were settled by the elders sitting at the city gate. "Taking a ransom/bribe" (kōper, v.12) meant buying a verdict. "Turning aside the needy in the gate" meant denying them a fair hearing. The môḵîaḥ ("one who reproves", v.10) was the person who stood up in court and objected. Amos says such people are hated.
Prophets were being silenced. Amos accuses Israel of ordering the prophets "Do not prophesy" (2:12). The priest Amaziah reports him to the king for conspiracy and tells him to go home to Judah (7:10-13). Speaking up in Israel had real costs. That gives weight to the reading that sensible people had learned to keep quiet.
Where the verse sits. Amos 5:1-17 is a lament over Israel "as if already dead". Its parts are arranged in mirror order around a hymn to the LORD in vv.8-9. Verse 13 is the only line in its section spoken in the third person, like a proverb, between the second-person charge of v.12 and the call of v.14. Its tone is closer to the wisdom of Proverbs (compare Prov 10:19; 17:28) than to the rest of Amos's speech. That is why many scholars think it is either a deliberate wisdom-style comment or a later addition (see debates).
From the study of Amos 5:13.
Where scholars differ
in v13
What kind of silence is this, and whose?
-
The discerning person keeps quiet out of self-protection, because the courts are corrupt and objectors are hated. The line is a bitter indictment of society, not a recommendation.
The context of 5:10 (they hate the one who reproves in the gate) and 5:12 (bribes, the poor turned aside); the opposition to prophets (2:12; 7:10-13); maśkîl as 'insight' (LXX syniōn); the parallel in Prov 10:19. This is the majority reading in translations and many commentaries.
-
'The prosperous' (another sense of maśkîl) 'will be silenced' (dāmam as struck still / destroyed) in the coming disaster: a judgment announcement.
G. V. Smith, 'Amos 5:13: The Deadly Silence of the Prosperous' (JBL 107, 1988). maśkîl means 'succeed' in 1 Sam 18:14 and Josh 1:8. dāmam means 'perish / be silenced' in Jer 8:14; 48:2; 49:26. 'Therefore' (lāḵēn) normally introduces punishment in Amos (5:11, 16). 'Evil time' means disaster in Mic 2:3. Amos's other 'silence' passages are about the dead (6:10; 8:3).
-
A later wisdom gloss: an editor's reflection that in the disastrous time that followed (the fall of Samaria or the exile), the wise person could only keep quiet.
The change to third person and proverb style between vv.12 and 14; wisdom vocabulary (maśkîl, as in Proverbs and Daniel 11-12); argued by H. W. Wolff and others.
in v13
Does 'that time' refer to the present or to the coming judgment?
-
The present time of corruption described in v.12.
The verse follows directly on the charges, and the silence is explained by what 'they' are doing now.
-
The future day of disaster.
'In that time / in that day' usually points forward in the prophets. 'Evil time' means calamity (Mic 2:3; Ps 37:19). Ancient versions translate the verb as future (LXX siōpēsetai, Vulgate tacebit).
in v14
Is the offer of life genuine, given that Amos elsewhere announces certain doom (5:2; 8:2; 9:1–4)?
-
A genuine conditional offer: judgment could still be averted or softened if Israel changed.
The repeated 'seek… and live' (5:4, 6, 14) and the prophetic pattern of warning in order to bring repentance (cf. Jonah 3; Jer 18:7–8). Amos's intercession succeeds twice in 7:1–6.
-
A real but narrow hope, aimed at a surviving remnant after judgment rather than at the nation escaping it.
Verse 15 says only 'perhaps' and speaks of 'the remnant of Joseph,' which assumes the catastrophe will happen. Survivors, not the nation as it stood, are in view.
-
Rhetorical: the call shows Israel's guilt, since everyone knows they will not seek good.
Amos 4:6–11 lists warnings ignored again and again ('yet you did not return to me'). The finality of 8:2 ('the end has come upon my people Israel').
in v14
Do verses 14–15 come from Amos himself or from a later editor?
-
Authentic to Amos, part of a deliberately crafted mirror-shaped unit (5:1–17).
They fit the carefully balanced structure of the chapter, matching 5:4–6. The vocabulary (seek, live, the gate, justice) is typical of Amos.
-
A later addition, perhaps by Judean editors after the fall of the North, softening Amos's doom with a call that is more like wisdom teaching or Deuteronomy.
The general good/evil language resembles wisdom literature and Deuteronomy. 'Remnant of Joseph' may assume the events of 722 BCE. Verse 13, just before it, is widely seen as a wisdom-style comment added later (e.g. Wolff).
in v15
Are 5:14–15 Amos's own words, or a later addition that softens his message of doom?
-
A later addition. Editors who knew Samaria had fallen added a call to repent and a hope for a remnant.
The wording is close to Deuteronomy and wisdom literature ("seek good", "hate evil"), and the hope seems to clash with Amos's flat announcements of the end (5:2; 8:2). Wolff and others took this view.
-
Authentic. The conditional, held-back hope fits Amos's method.
The verse picks up Amos's own key words (the gate, 5:10, 12; love, 4:5; justice, 5:7, 24) and fits the matching layers of 5:1–17. "Perhaps" and "remnant" stay grim and promise nothing. Andersen & Freedman and Paul argue for this view.
in v15
Is the "remnant of Joseph" a sincere hope or a bitter irony?
-
A sincere, if small, hope: God may spare survivors if justice returns.
"Perhaps" and "be gracious" are used elsewhere in real appeals for mercy (Exodus 32:30; Zephaniah 2:3).
-
Mostly sobering or ironic: the best case for proud Joseph is to end up a scrap.
Amos's other remnant images are remains from a lion's mouth and a tenth of an army (3:12; 5:3). The verse assumes the catastrophe happens.
Sources
- BDB s.v. שָׂכַל, דָּמַם, עֵת, רַע
- HALOT s.v. שׂכל, דמם I/II, עֵת, רָעָה
- H. W. Wolff, Joel and Amos (Hermeneia)
- S. M. Paul, Amos (Hermeneia)
- F. I. Andersen & D. N. Freedman, Amos (Anchor Bible)
- J. Jeremias, The Book of Amos (OTL)
- G. V. Smith, 'Amos 5:13: The Deadly Silence of the Prosperous,' JBL 107 (1988)
- Septuagint, Amos 5:13
- Vulgate, Amos 5:13
- BDB s.v. דָּרַשׁ, טוֹב, רַע, חָיָה, צָבָא
- HALOT s.v. דרשׁ; צָבָא
- Hans Walter Wolff, Joel and Amos (Hermeneia)
- Shalom M. Paul, Amos (Hermeneia)
- Francis I. Andersen & David Noel Freedman, Amos (Anchor Bible)
- J. de Waard, 'The Chiastic Structure of Amos V 1–17', Vetus Testamentum 27 (1977)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Amos 5
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) Amos 5:14
- Vulgate Amos 5:14
- BDB and HALOT, entries for שׂנא, אהב, יצג, שׁער, משׁפט, אולי, חנן, צבא, שׁארית
- W. L. Moran, "The Ancient Near Eastern Background of the Love of God in Deuteronomy," CBQ 25 (1963)
- G. F. Hasel, The Remnant
- P. J. King & L. E. Stager, Life in Biblical Israel (city gates)
- Rahlfs, Septuaginta (Amos 5:15)
- Biblia Sacra Vulgata (Amos 5:15)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).