Colossians Chapter 2 Read as one passage

Colossians 2:20–23

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

20If you have died with Christ to the spiritual forces of the world, why, as though you still belonged to the world, do you submit to its regulations: 21“Do not handle, do not taste, do not touch!”? 22These will all perish with use, because they are based on human commands and teachings. 23Such restrictions indeed have an appearance of wisdom, with their self-prescribed worship, their false humility, and their harsh treatment of the body; but they are of no value against the indulgence of the flesh.

What the first hearers heard

To the believers in Colossae, mostly non-Jews who had recently come to faith, this verse was a sharp reminder of what their baptism meant. They had been told (2:9–15) that in Christ they already had fullness, that their debt-record with its decrees was nailed to the cross, and that the rulers and authorities had been stripped and paraded in defeat. Now teachers in or around the community were urging extra measures for real holiness or spiritual experience: food taboos, sacred days, self-denial and angelic visions.

Paul's question turns the issue into a matter of who owns them. These practices were not simply optional extras. Submitting to them meant acting as citizens of a world-order they had already left by dying with Christ. It put them back under the elements and powers Christ had defeated. The rhetorical "why?" invited them to see that it made no sense, and the next verses (21–23) mock the rules as human commands about things that "perish with use", which have "an appearance of wisdom" but do not restrain the flesh.

In the letter as a whole, the verse forms a pair with 3:1: "If you died with Christ..." (2:20) is followed by "If then you were raised with Christ..." (3:1). Death frees them from the old regulations, and resurrection points them to a new orientation, "the things above". Paul is not replacing discipline with nothing. He is replacing one source of life with another.

From the study of Colossians 2:20.

Verse by verse

  1. 20If you have died with Christ to the spiritual forces of the world, why, as though you still belonged to the world, do you submit to its regulations:

    Since you died together with Christ, and that death took you out from under the basic powers and principles that run this present world, why do you act as though you were still alive in that old order, and let yourselves be put back under its rulebook?

    Paul is not asking whether they died with Christ. He takes it as settled (it happened when they were joined to Christ in baptism, 2:12). The point of the death is release. In law, death ends every claim a master or creditor has over someone. The "elements of the world" are the basic building blocks and governing forces of the present order: the physical elements, the heavens that set the sacred calendar, the spiritual powers associated with them, and the rules about food, days and holiness that grow out of them. Believers have "died away from" all of that.

    The contrast is sharp and almost comic: you died, yet you behave as living in the world. The last word, "submit to decrees", is built on the same root as the "decrees" Paul just said were nailed to the cross (2:14). The cross wiped out one set of decrees, and now they are signing up for a new set. The question expects the answer "There is no reason". Verse 21 then quotes the kind of rules he means: "Do not handle! Do not taste! Do not touch!"

    Full study →
  2. 21“Do not handle, do not taste, do not touch!”?

    Paul has just asked (2:20): "If you died with Christ and left behind the 'elemental principles of the world', why do you let people hand you decrees as if you still lived under that world?" Verse 21 then gives a sample of those decrees. He mimics the rule-makers in their own clipped, breathless voice:

    "Don't grab it! Don't even taste it! Don't so much as brush against it!"

    These are not Paul's commands. They are the slogans of the "philosophy" troubling the Colossian believers (2:8), quoted with irony. The three verbs tighten as they go. The first is a firm grip (haptomai, "handle, lay hold of", the old purity word for touching unclean things). Then a mere taste. Then the lightest possible contact (thinganō, "touch, brush against"). No object is named, which is part of the parody: the list of forbidden things could keep growing. In the next verse Paul gives his verdict. The things these rules fuss over are perishable stuff that is "used up in the using" (2:22). The rules themselves are "human commands and teachings", an echo of Isaiah 29:13. They look like piety but are no use against the real problem (2:23).

    Full study →
  3. 22These will all perish with use, because they are based on human commands and teachings.

    Paul has just asked the Colossians (v. 20): if you died with Christ to the basic powers and principles of this world, why do you let yourselves be ruled by regulations as if you still lived under them? He quotes the regulations as slogans: "Don't handle! Don't taste! Don't touch!" (v. 21). Then he adds a dry aside and finishes his question:

    (all of which are things that are headed for decay, used up and gone the moment you consume them) — rules handed down according to the commands and teachings of mere human beings?

    The verse makes two points. First, the things these rules fuss over are food and drink. They perish in the act of being used: eaten, digested, gone. Things that short-lived cannot make a person holy or defile them before God. Second, the rules come from human command and human teaching, not from God. Paul's wording echoes Isaiah 29:13 as the Greek Bible had it: "in vain they worship me, teaching human commands and teachings." Jesus quoted the same line against human food-and-washing traditions. So these practices look devout, but Paul puts them in the category the prophets and Jesus had already judged empty.

    Full study →
  4. 23Such restrictions indeed have an appearance of wisdom, with their self-prescribed worship, their false humility, and their harsh treatment of the body; but they are of no value against the indulgence of the flesh.

    Paul is looking at the rules he has just quoted: don't handle, don't taste, don't touch. He grants that they have a reputation for wisdom. People respect them and treat them as serious spirituality. He names three reasons for that reputation:

    • devotion people have chosen for themselves: worship and religious observance taken on by their own choice, added to what God has given in Christ;
    • self-humbling: not "false humility" but a practised lowering of oneself, especially fasting and denial, often thought to prepare a person for heavenly visions (2:18);
    • unsparing treatment of the body: actively hard on it, not merely careless with it.

    Then the sentence breaks off. The "but" his "indeed" set up never comes, and Paul ends abruptly: not of any real worth. All this disciplined denial of food and comfort does nothing about the gorging of the flesh. "Flesh" here means the self-centred human nature, not the body the rules are punishing. Most translators read this as "no value against indulgence": the rules cannot hold back what they claim to hold back. The Greek can also be read more bitingly: the rules are of no real honour and in fact serve toward the flesh's own satisfaction, since a rigorous self-made religion feeds pride ("puffed up by the mind of his flesh," 2:18). On either reading, the food imagery is pointed: rules about not tasting end in the flesh being filled full.

    The answer Paul gives is in the next verse (3:1). It is not more rules. It is being raised with Christ and setting the mind on where he is.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v20

    ordinances (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    dogmatizesthe (from dogma)

    What we hear
    In many churches "ordinances" means baptism and the Lord's Supper. A reader could think Paul is telling believers not to submit to those.
    What they heard
    Decrees or regulations laid down by an authority. Verse 21 shows what they are: taboo-style rules about handling, tasting and touching.
  • in v20

    rudiments (KJV, YLT)

    stoicheia

    What we hear
    Simply "the basics" or "beginner's material", something harmless you grow out of.
    What they heard
    The basic components of the world-order: the physical elements, the heavenly bodies and calendar, and the powers associated with them. In Paul's usage they are something you are enslaved "under" (Gal 4:3), not just lessons you move beyond.
  • in v20

    dogma (as readers may connect it)

    dogmatizō / dogma

    What we hear
    Fixed theological doctrine, or a rigid, opinionated attitude.
    What they heard
    A public decree or official ruling (Luke 2:1, Caesar's decree). Here it means rules imposed on the community, not beliefs.
  • in v21

    Touch not; taste not; handle not

    mē hapsē mēde geusē mēde thigēs

    What we hear
    A biblical command to abstain, often cited against alcohol, tobacco or other substances.
    What they heard
    A quotation of the rule-makers' slogans, offered by Paul as an example of the human decrees he says believers should *not* submit to.
  • in v21

    handle (KJV, for θιγγάνω)

    thinganō

    What we hear
    To take hold of firmly, to manage or manipulate something.
    What they heard
    To touch lightly or brush against. It is the faintest kind of contact, and it closes the list.
  • in v22

    doctrines of men

    didaskaliai tōn anthrōpōn

    What we hear
    The creeds, theological systems or official beliefs of a rival church or denomination; sometimes used to dismiss any church teaching that is not a direct Bible quote.
    What they heard
    Humanly devised instructions, here concrete ascetic rules about what not to handle, taste or touch, presented as necessary for spiritual life.
  • in v23

    false humility (BSB, NIV)

    tapeinophrosynē

    What we hear
    Pretended or hypocritical humility, people faking modesty.
    What they heard
    Real, practised self-abasement, especially fasting and self-denial as a religious discipline. Paul does not call it fake. He says it is useless against the flesh.
  • in v23

    neglecting of the body (KJV)

    apheidia sōmatos

    What we hear
    Carelessness about health, letting oneself go.
    What they heard
    Unsparing severity toward the body: deliberate hardship, harsh discipline.
  • in v23

    worship / will worship

    ethelothrēskeia

    What we hear
    Singing or praise services; 'will worship' is opaque.
    What they heard
    Religious observance and devotional practice taken on by one's own choice, beyond what God gave.
  • in v23

    flesh

    sarx

    What we hear
    The physical body, or sexual and sensual appetite.
    What they heard
    Human nature turned toward itself and away from God, including pride. Paul uses a different word, 'body', for the physical body in the same verse.
Every word
  1. Εἰ

    Ei · G1487

    if · v20

    With a past-tense verb stated as fact, this "if" assumes the condition is true: "if, as is the case". It comes close to "since". Paul is not doubting that they died with Christ. He is reasoning from it.

  2. ἀπεθάνετε

    apethanete · G0599

    to die · v20

    "You died". The tense points to a single past event, not a gradual process. In context (2:11–12, "buried with him in baptism") the death happened when they were joined to Christ and baptized.

  3. σὺν

    syn · G4862

    with · v20

    Shared participation. Their death is not a copy of Christ's death but a share in it. This is one of several "with Christ" verbs in Colossians (buried with, raised with, made alive with: 2:12–13; 3:1).

  4. Χριστῷ

    Christō · G5547

    Christ, Anointed One · v20

    The Messiah, the one whose death and resurrection the believers now share. Earlier in the letter all the fullness of deity dwells in him (2:9), and the powers are disarmed in him (2:15).

  5. ἀπὸ

    apo · G0575

    away from · v20

    An unusual pairing with "die". Paul elsewhere says "died to" something (Rom 6:2). "Died away from" carries a sense of separation: they died and were thereby released from the elements' grip, as a dead slave is out of the master's reach.

  6. τῶν

    tōn · G3588

    the · v20, v22, v23

    Marks "the elements of the world" as a known category. Paul has already named it in 2:8.

  7. στοιχείων

    stoicheiōn · G4747

    element, basic component, elementary principle · v20

    The "elements". These are the basic building blocks or ruling components of the present world-order. Scholars debate whether the stress falls on elementary teachings, the physical elements, or the spirit-powers linked with them (see Studies and Debates).

  8. κόσμου

    kosmou · G2889

    world, ordered system · v20

    The present order of things: the created and human world as it is arranged and run apart from Christ. It is not simply the physical planet.

  9. τί

    ti · G5101

    what? why? · v20

    Used as an adverb: "why?" The question is a rebuke. It expects the answer "there is no reason".

  10. ὡς

    hōs · G5613

    as, as though · v20

    "As though": they are acting as if something were true that is no longer true.

  11. ζῶντες

    zōntes · G2198

    to live · v20

    "Living", in deliberate contrast with "you died". They are behaving as if they were still alive in, and owned by, the old order they died out of.

  12. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v20, v23

    "In" in the sense of belonging to and governed by, not mere physical location. They obviously still live physically in the world.

  13. δογματίζεσθε

    dogmatizesthe · G1379

    to issue decrees; (middle/passive) to submit to decrees · v20

    "Do you let yourselves be put under decrees?" The verb is built on dógma, "decree". It echoes 2:14, where the record with its decrees (dógmasin) was nailed to the cross. The present tense points to something ongoing or being pressed on them right now.

  14. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v21

    The negative used with commands and wishes. Paired with the aorist subjunctive that follows, it makes a flat, absolute ban: 'Don't!'

  15. ἅψῃ

    hapsē · G0681

    (middle) take hold of, touch; (active) fasten, kindle · v21

    In the middle voice, as here, it means to take hold of or lay hands on something. It is the firmest kind of contact in the list: 'Don't handle it.' In the Greek Old Testament it is the standard verb for touching unclean things, so it carries the sound of a purity rule.

  16. μηδὲ

    mēde · G3366

    and not, nor, not even · v21

    Joins one ban to the next, and can carry the force of 'not even'. That gives the list its tightening rhythm.

  17. γεύσῃ

    geusē · G1089

    taste, eat a little of · v21

    To taste or take even a sample of food or drink. It links directly to the 'food and drink' rules of 2:16: not even a mouthful is allowed.

  18. θίγῃς

    thigēs · G2345

    touch lightly, brush against · v21

    The lightest contact there is: a fingertip touch or a brush. Ending on this word makes the slogan more and more scrupulous: don't grab it, don't taste it, don't so much as brush against it.

  19. ἅ

    ha · G3739

    which · v22

    Neuter plural 'which (things)'. It most likely points back to the items named in the slogans of v. 21, the food and drink one must not handle, taste or touch, rather than to the rules themselves.

  20. ἐστιν

    estin · G1510

    to be · v22, v23

    'Are' (singular verb with a neuter plural subject, normal in Greek). It states a plain fact about how such things work, not a prediction.

  21. πάντα

    panta · G3956

    all · v22

    'All of them': every item on the forbidden list, without exception, has the same short life.

  22. εἰς

    eis · G1519

    into, toward · v22

    Marks direction or destiny: these things are headed for decay. 'Destined for' captures it.

  23. φθορὰν

    phthoran · G5356

    decay, ruin, perishing · v22

    Physical breakdown. Food is consumed, digested and gone. Elsewhere Paul uses the word for the perishable condition of the present world (1 Cor 15:42; Rom 8:21), which adds an undertone: these rules fuss over things that belong to the passing order.

  24. ἀποχρήσει

    apochrēsei · G0671

    using up, consumption · v22

    Used only here in the New Testament. It means use that uses a thing up, consumption. The point is that these foods perish in the very act of being used, so they cannot carry spiritual weight.

  25. κατὰ

    kata · G2596

    according to · v22

    'In line with, based on'. This phrase reaches back past the parenthesis to the verb of v. 20 ('why do you submit to rules…?'). The rules are shaped by human commands and teaching.

  26. ἐντάλματα

    entalmata · G1778

    command, precept · v22

    Specific orders or injunctions. The word comes straight from Isaiah 29:13 in the Greek Old Testament, the same text Jesus quoted against human food-and-washing traditions (Mark 7:7).

  27. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v22, v23

    Joins commands and teachings.

  28. διδασκαλίας

    didaskalias · G1319

    teaching, instruction · v22

    Plural: 'teachings', meaning the instructions handed on by a teacher, here practical rules about what to avoid. It does not mean a formal creed or theological system.

  29. ἀνθρώπων

    anthrōpōn · G0444

    human being · v22

    'Of humans'. The stress is on the source: these rules come from people, not from God. That picks up 2:8, 'according to human tradition… and not according to Christ.'

  30. ἅτινά

    hatina · G3748

    which, such as · v23

    Points back to the rules of vv. 20–22 ('do not handle, do not taste, do not touch'). This form often carries a sense of kind: 'things of the sort that…'.

  31. λόγον

    logon · G3056

    word, account, reputation · v23

    Here it means 'reputation' or 'name': the rules have a name for wisdom, people speak of them as wise. It does not by itself mean 'a fake show', though the sentence goes on to say the reputation is not deserved.

  32. μὲν

    men · G3303

    on the one hand, indeed · v23

    Sets up a contrast ('indeed… but'). The expected 'but' (de) never comes. The sentence turns sharply at 'not in any value', which is part of why the verse is so hard to construe.

  33. ἔχοντα

    echonta · G2192

    having · v23

    'Having a reputation': the rules really do have this standing in people's eyes.

  34. σοφίας

    sophias · G4678

    wisdom · v23

    Wisdom in the sense of religious and philosophical insight. It echoes 2:3, where all the treasures of wisdom are said to be hidden in Christ, and 2:8, where the rival teaching calls itself a 'philosophy'.

  35. ἐθελοθρησκίᾳ

    ethelothrēskia · G1479

    self-chosen worship · v23

    Religious devotion people take on by their own choice, beyond anything God asked for. It is probably a word Paul coined. It picks up the 'worship of angels' in 2:18.

  36. ταπεινοφροσύνῃ

    tapeinophrosynē · G5012

    lowliness, humility · v23

    Here it means a practised self-abasement, most likely fasting and other self-humbling disciplines (as in 2:18). The Greek does not say 'false'. It is the same word Paul praises in 3:12, used here for a ritual technique.

  37. ἀφειδίᾳ

    apheidia · G857

    unsparingness, severity · v23

    Literally 'not sparing': harsh, unsparing treatment. The body is denied food, drink and comfort. It describes active severity, not neglect.

  38. σώματος,

    sōmatos · G4983

    body · v23

    The physical body as the object of the severe discipline.

  39. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v23

    The turning point of the sentence. It does the work of the missing 'but' after 'indeed'.

  40. τιμῇ

    timē · G5092

    honour; price, value · v23

    Either 'value' (the rules are worth nothing) or 'honour' (they bring no real honour, or they give the body none of the honour it is due). Which one is meant is a real puzzle; see debates.

  41. τινι

    tini · G5100

    any, some · v23

    'Not in any value at all'. It sharpens the denial.

  42. πρὸς

    pros · G4314

    toward, for, against · v23

    Either 'against' (no value for checking indulgence) or 'toward/resulting in' (they only lead to the flesh being gratified). The verse turns on which one is meant.

  43. πλησμονὴν

    plēsmonēn · G4140

    filling, satiety, gratification · v23

    Being filled full, gorging. It is often used of food, and so of overindulgence. That is ironic after the food rules of vv. 16 and 21.

  44. σαρκός.

    sarkos · G4561

    flesh · v23

    Not mainly the physical body (Paul has just used 'body' for that). It means human nature turned in on itself and away from God. In 2:18 the visionary is 'puffed up by the mind of his flesh'.

The world behind it

Colossae and its "philosophy". Colossae was a small town in the Lycus valley of Asia Minor (modern western Turkey), near Laodicea and Hierapolis. It had a mixed population of native Phrygians, Greeks and a sizable Jewish community. The letter warns against a "philosophy and empty deceit" (2:8). Paul's own descriptions are the only evidence for what it taught, and they include:

  • food and drink rules, and keeping festivals, new moons and Sabbaths (2:16);
  • harsh treatment of the body and humility practices, perhaps fasting (2:18, 23);
  • "worship of angels" (or worship with angels) and visionary experiences (2:18);
  • prohibitions like "do not handle, do not taste, do not touch" (2:21).

Elements, stars and calendars. In the ancient world the four elements and the heavenly bodies were widely thought of as ruling powers. In Jewish tradition angels were set over the winds, fire and stars (1 Enoch, Jubilees). The heavenly bodies also fixed sacred time: Genesis 1:14 says the lights are for "seasons, days and years". So calendar observance and the "elements" were naturally connected, as in Gal 4:3–10. For Paul's hearers, being "under the elements" meant living inside a cosmos run by powers, with rules for keeping on their right side.

Death ends obligation. Everyone in the Roman world knew that death cancels legal claims. Paul uses this commonplace: once a person has died with Christ, the old rulers' decrees have no one left to bind.

From the study of Colossians 2:20.

Where scholars differ

in v20

What are "the elements (stoicheia) of the world"?

  • Elementary principles or rudimentary teachings: the "ABCs" of religion, whether Jewish law or pagan religion, that people are meant to move beyond.

    This is the most common non-physical sense of the word (Heb 5:12). Gal 4:1–3 frames it with the image of a child under guardians. KJV and NASB, and older commentators such as Lightfoot, take this view.

  • Personal spiritual beings: angels, demons or star-spirits that rule the cosmos.

    The context speaks of rulers and authorities (2:15) and worship of angels (2:18), and Gal 4:8–9 places the stoicheia alongside "beings that by nature are not gods". Jewish texts set angels over the elements. Clinton Arnold and others hold this view. A weakness is that clear uses of stoicheia meaning "spirits" mostly come after Paul (e.g. Testament of Solomon).

  • The physical elements (earth, water, air, fire) and the heavenly bodies, understood religiously, together with the calendar and purity regimes tied to them.

    This is the dominant sense of the phrase in Greek literature (Philo, Wisdom 7:17, 2 Pet 3:10). It fits the link between the elements and festivals, new moons and Sabbaths (Col 2:16; Gal 4:10) and the rules about material things that "perish with use" (2:22). Eduard Schweizer, Josef Blinzler and Martinus de Boer argue versions of this. Many recent scholars (e.g. Dunn, Moo) combine this with the second view.

in v20

What kind of teaching was threatening the Colossians?

  • A form of Jewish practice and mysticism focused on Sabbath, food laws and ascetic preparation for visions of angelic worship in heaven.

    Sabbath and new moon (2:16) are distinctively Jewish. "Worship of angels" can mean worship *offered by* angels, as in Jewish visionary texts. F. O. Francis and C. Rowland argue for this.

  • A local folk religion mixing Jewish, Phrygian and magical elements, seeking protection from hostile powers.

    There is inscriptional and magical evidence from western Asia Minor for invoking angels for protection. This view is argued by C. E. Arnold (The Colossian Syncretism).

  • Hellenistic philosophy of a Pythagorean type, with purification of the soul through abstinence from food and attention to the elements.

    The letter calls the teaching a "philosophy" (2:8). Pythagorean texts link the elements, abstinence and the soul's ascent. E. Schweizer argues for this.

  • No organized false teaching, only general pressure from the surrounding Jewish and pagan environment.

    The letter is less polemical than Galatians, and no opponents are named. M. D. Hooker argues for this.

in v20

Were the Colossians already submitting to these rules, or only being pressured?

  • Already submitting (middle voice: "why do you submit yourselves?").

    The present indicative most naturally describes an actual, ongoing practice, and the question reads as a rebuke.

  • Being pressured but not yet yielding (passive or permissive: "why let yourselves be regulated?").

    The letter elsewhere praises their steadfastness (2:5), and the warnings are mostly preventive ("let no one judge you", 2:16; "let no one disqualify you", 2:18).

in v21

What are the forbidden objects of 'handle… taste… touch'?

  • Food and drink, especially ritually suspect or unclean food.

    The parallel with 2:16 ('food and drink') and verse 22, where the things 'perish with use', which fits food. Γεύω is a food verb.

  • Ritual impurity more broadly: corpses, carcasses, unclean persons or objects.

    In the LXX, ἅπτομαι is the standard verb for defiling contact (Leviticus 5, 11; Numbers 19; Isaiah 52:11). The verb θιγγάνω, for contact, is added alongside tasting.

  • Sexual abstinence is included.

    ἅπτομαι is used of sexual contact in 1 Corinthians 7:1, and asceticism in that period often included celibacy (compare 1 Timothy 4:3). Proposed by some commentators, but the context does not demand it.

in v21

Who held the 'philosophy' behind these slogans?

  • Jewish or Jewish-Christian mystical asceticism seeking heavenly visions.

    Sabbaths and new moons (2:16), circumcision imagery (2:11), and fasting as preparation for visions, as in Jewish apocalyptic and mystical texts (F. O. Francis; T. Sappington; J. D. G. Dunn).

  • A local blend of Jewish elements with Phrygian folk religion and fear of spirit powers.

    Lycus valley inscriptions on angels and protective powers, and the language of 'elements' and 'principalities' (C. E. Arnold).

  • A Hellenistic philosophical asceticism (Middle Platonist, Pythagorean or Cynic-influenced).

    The label 'philosophy' (2:8) and Pythagorean food rules (E. Schweizer; T. Martin argues for Cynic critics).

  • No organised false teaching, but general pressure from the surrounding Jewish and pagan environment.

    Paul never names opponents and the letter is less heated than Galatians (M. D. Hooker).

in v22

What does 'which are all for decay in the using-up' refer to: the forbidden things, or the rules themselves?

  • The forbidden items (food, drink, objects): they perish when consumed, so they cannot defile or sanctify.

    This is the majority view (Lightfoot, O'Brien, Dunn, Moo). The 'using-up' language fits food naturally. It parallels Mark 7:18–19 and 1 Cor 6:13, and ESV, NASB and NLT translate this way.

  • The rules or practices themselves: keeping them leads to ruin (spiritual corruption) or they pass away with their use.

    The neuter plural 'which' could pick up the decrees implied in v. 20. 'Phthora' can mean moral or spiritual corruption (Gal 6:8; 2 Pet 2:12, 19). Some older interpreters read it this way. But 'consumption' fits rules awkwardly.

in v22

Who were the teachers whose 'human commands and teachings' Paul rejects?

  • A Jewish mystical-ascetic movement: Sabbath and food observance, with fasting as preparation for visions of angelic worship in heaven.

    Mentions of Sabbaths and new moons (2:16) and circumcision imagery (2:11). Parallels exist in Qumran's Songs of the Sabbath Sacrifice and in Jewish apocalyptic texts (F. O. Francis, Dunn, Sappington).

  • A local syncretism blending folk religion, angel invocation, mystery-cult language and some Jewish elements.

    Phrygian inscriptions invoking angels. 'Entering' (embateuōn, 2:18) appears as a technical term at the Claros oracle (C. E. Arnold, The Colossian Syncretism).

  • A Hellenistic philosophical critique, for example Cynic or Pythagorean-style ascetic teaching.

    Paul calls it 'philosophy' (2:8). Pythagorean and similar groups practised food abstinence and bodily discipline (T. Martin, E. Schweizer).

in v23

What does the final clause, 'not in any value/honour pros the filling of the flesh', mean?

  • The rules are of no value *against* (for checking) the indulgence of the flesh. This is the majority modern reading (BSB, WEB, ESV, NIV, NASB).

    It fits the flow: rules look wise but do not work. Pros can mean 'with a view to' or 'for' (and so, loosely, 'against'), and timē can mean 'value'. The objection is that pros meaning 'against' with this sense is uncommon.

  • The rules are of no real honour, and they serve *toward* the satisfaction of the flesh. They actually feed it.

    Pros + accusative most naturally means 'toward' or 'resulting in'. Plēsmonē means 'filling, satiety'. Colossians ties flesh to pride ('puffed up by the mind of his flesh', 2:18), so ascetic achievement feeds self-regard. KJV and YLT leave this reading open.

  • 'Not in any honour' goes with 'severity to the body' (the body is treated without the honour it is due). 'Toward the filling of the flesh' then sums up the whole: these decrees end up serving the flesh.

    Proposed by some scholars (e.g. B. Hollenbach, 1979). It fits Greek usage of timē for honour owed to the body. Critics say it makes the sentence even more strained.

in v23

What kind of 'philosophy' lies behind the practices named here?

  • Jewish mystical-ascetic piety: fasting and purity to prepare for visions and to join the angels in worship.

    The sabbath and new-moon references (2:16), 'worship of angels' read as the angels' worship (2:18), and Jewish texts linking fasting with visions (Daniel 10, 4 Ezra, Qumran's angelic liturgy). Argued by F. O. Francis, J. D. G. Dunn and others.

  • Local Phrygian folk religion mixing Jewish, pagan and magical elements, including calling on angels for protection.

    Inscriptions and amulets from Asia Minor invoking angels, and the 'elements of the world' as spiritual powers. Argued by C. E. Arnold.

  • A Hellenistic philosophical school (e.g. Pythagorean-type) teaching bodily discipline as the route to purifying the soul.

    The word 'philosophy' (2:8), 'elements', and Greek ascetic traditions. Argued by E. Schweizer and others.

in v23

Is ethelothrēskeia pejorative ('self-made religion') or a self-description by the opponents ('voluntary worship')?

  • Paul's own critical coinage: religion that people invent for themselves.

    There is no earlier attestation, and the context is critical (v. 22, 'human commands and teachings').

  • It may echo the opponents' own claim to 'freely chosen, extra' devotion, which Paul turns against them.

    Ethelo- compounds can be neutral or positive ('voluntary'). Opponents may have prized above-and-beyond devotion.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. στοιχεῖον
  • BDAG s.v. δογματίζω
  • BDAG s.v. δόγμα
  • BDAG s.v. ἀποθνήσκω (with ἀπό: die and so be freed from)
  • G. Delling, "στοιχεῖον," TDNT 7:670–687
  • J. D. G. Dunn, The Epistles to the Colossians and to Philemon (NIGTC, 1996)
  • D. J. Moo, The Letters to the Colossians and to Philemon (PNTC, 2008)
  • E. Lohse, Colossians and Philemon (Hermeneia, 1971)
  • C. E. Arnold, The Colossian Syncretism (1995)
  • E. Schweizer, "Slaves of the Elements and Worshipers of Angels: Gal 4:3, 9 and Col 2:8, 18, 20," JBL 107 (1988)
  • M. C. de Boer, "The Meaning of the Phrase τὰ στοιχεῖα τοῦ κόσμου in Galatians," NTS 53 (2007)
  • M. D. Hooker, "Were There False Teachers in Colossae?" (1973)
  • F. O. Francis and W. A. Meeks (eds.), Conflict at Colossae (1975)
  • Philo, De Vita Contemplativa 3–4; De Aeternitate Mundi 107–109
  • Wisdom of Solomon 7:17; 13:1–2
  • 1 Enoch 60; 75; 80; Jubilees 2:2
  • D. B. Wallace, Greek Grammar Beyond the Basics (first-class conditions)
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed. apparatus
  • BDAG s.v. ἅπτω, γεύομαι, θιγγάνω
  • LSJ s.v. θιγγάνω
  • R. C. Trench, Synonyms of the New Testament, §17 (ἅπτομαι, θιγγάνω, ψηλαφάω)
  • J. B. Lightfoot, Saint Paul's Epistles to the Colossians and to Philemon
  • J. D. G. Dunn, The Epistles to the Colossians and to Philemon (NIGTC)
  • P. T. O'Brien, Colossians, Philemon (WBC)
  • D. J. Moo, The Letters to the Colossians and to Philemon (PNTC)
  • C. E. Arnold, The Colossian Syncretism
  • M. D. Hooker, 'Were There False Teachers in Colossae?'
  • LXX Leviticus 5:2–3; 11:8; Isaiah 29:13; 52:11
  • BDAG s.v. ἀπόχρησις, φθορά, ἔνταλμα, διδασκαλία
  • Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἀπόχρησις
  • Septuagint, Isaiah 29:13
  • Mark 7:1–23; Matthew 15:1–20
  • P. T. O'Brien, Colossians, Philemon (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • D. J. Moo, The Letters to the Colossians and to Philemon (Pillar)
  • F. O. Francis, 'Humility and Angelic Worship in Col 2:18'
  • Vulgate, Colossians 2:22
  • BDAG s.v. λόγος (logon echein, 'have the reputation of')
  • BDAG s.v. ἐθελοθρησκία
  • BDAG s.v. ταπεινοφροσύνη
  • BDAG s.v. ἀφειδία
  • BDAG s.v. πλησμονή
  • BDAG s.v. τιμή
  • Shepherd of Hermas, Vision 3.10.6; Similitude 5.3.7 (tapeinophrosynē as fasting)
  • Septuagint Lev 16:29; Isa 58:3–5 (tapeinoō for fasting)
  • Thucydides 3.70 (ethelopróxenos); Plato, Symposium 184c (ethelodouleia)
  • C. F. D. Moule, The Epistles to the Colossians and to Philemon (CGTC)
  • F. O. Francis, 'Humility and Angelic Worship in Col 2:18', Studia Theologica 16 (1962)
  • B. Hollenbach, 'Col. II.23: Which Things Lead to the Fulfilment of the Flesh', NTS 25 (1979)
  • NA28 critical apparatus at Col 2:23

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).