Ezra Chapter 5 Read as one passage
Ezra 5:11–16
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
11And this is the answer they returned: “We are servants of the God of heaven and earth, and we are rebuilding the temple that was built many years ago, which a great king of Israel built and completed. 12But since our fathers angered the God of heaven, He delivered them into the hand of Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, the Chaldean who destroyed this temple and carried away the people to Babylon. 13In the first year of his reign, however, Cyrus king of Babylon issued a decree to rebuild this house of God. 14He also removed from the temple of Babylon the gold and silver articles belonging to the house of God, which Nebuchadnezzar had taken and carried there from the temple in Jerusalem. King Cyrus gave these articles to a man named Sheshbazzar, whom he appointed governor 15and instructed, ‘Take these articles, put them in the temple in Jerusalem, and let the house of God be rebuilt on its original site.’ 16So this Sheshbazzar came and laid the foundation of the house of God in Jerusalem, and from that time until now it has been under construction, but it has not yet been completed.”
What the first hearers heard
Within the story (the Persian court of 520 BC), the reply was crafted to be persuasive under imperial rules:
- Identity: we serve the God of heaven, the God your own chancery recognizes.
- Continuity: this is a restoration of an existing temple, not a new foundation.
- Precedent: a great king founded and completed it, so it is a legitimate royal sanctuary.
The verses that follow complete the case. The temple fell because our ancestors angered God (5:12), and Cyrus himself decreed its rebuilding (5:13–16). Darius's archives later confirmed the decree (6:1–12).
For the Jewish readers of Ezra, a small community in the Persian province of Yehud, the verse did several things:
- Identity: it named them first as "servants of the God of heaven and earth". Their worth and authority did not come from being a minor subject people, but from belonging to the God who rules everything.
- Continuity: it tied their modest rebuilding (cf. Haggai 2:3, where the older generation wept at how small it seemed) directly to Solomon's glory. This was the same house, on the same foundations, under the same God.
- The empire as witness: the book quotes the governor's own letter, so the account of the temple's legitimacy is preserved in the empire's own paperwork. Even the opponents' official record carries the community's confession.
From the study of Ezra 5:11.
Verse by verse
-
11And this is the answer they returned: “We are servants of the God of heaven and earth, and we are rebuilding the temple that was built many years ago, which a great king of Israel built and completed.
Full study →"And this is the reply they gave us, for the record: 'We are the servants of the God of heaven and earth, the supreme God to whom heaven and earth both belong, and we are acting on his authority. What we are building is no new project. It is the house, the temple whose foundations stand on this very spot. It was built here long ago, many generations before our time. A king of Israel, a great king, built it and saw it through to completion.'"
Notes on what the English can miss:
- This is a quoted reply inside a Persian governor's letter to King Darius. The elders' words come to us as officials recorded them for the royal archive.
- The answer follows the officials' questions point by point. Asked who are you?, they say they are servants of the God of heaven and earth. Asked who authorized you to build and finish this?, they say a great king of Israel already built and finished it, using the officials' own word for "finish".
- "Build" appears three times: we are building, it had been built, he built it. The repetition presses home that this is a restoration of something old, not a new foundation.
- "God of heaven" is the title the Persian court itself used for Israel's God. Adding "and earth" quietly reaches into the land the governor administers.
- Solomon is meant but not named. A Persian reader needed only the essential point: an ancient royal founder, a legitimate sanctuary.
-
12But since our fathers angered the God of heaven, He delivered them into the hand of Nebuchadnezzar king of Babylon, the Chaldean who destroyed this temple and carried away the people to Babylon.
Full study →"But—and this is why it lay in ruins—our ancestors provoked the God of heaven until he shook with anger. So he himself handed them over into the power of Nebuchadnezzar, king of Babylon, the Chaldean. And this very house, the one we are now rebuilding, he tore down. And the people he deported to Babylon."
The Jewish elders are answering a Persian governor's question. They have just said that a great king of Israel built this temple (v. 11). Now they explain, without excuses, why it was a ruin. The fault lay with their own ancestors, whom they claim as "our fathers". God's anger was something the ancestors caused, not a whim. Nebuchadnezzar is not presented as the victor over a weak god. He is the hand God put his people into. The Aramaic puts "this house" and "the people" first, so the verse ends on two losses: the temple that was torn down and the people taken away. Babylon opens and closes the verse. The next verse then moves to the turn: Cyrus, the new "king of Babylon", ordered the house rebuilt.
-
13In the first year of his reign, however, Cyrus king of Babylon issued a decree to rebuild this house of God.
Full study →"But that was not the end of it. In the very first year that Cyrus reigned as king of Babylon, Cyrus himself, the king, issued an official order that this house of God, the very temple standing here in ruins, should be built again."
The verse is part of a legal defence. Jewish elders in Jerusalem are being questioned by Tattenai, the Persian governor of the province 'Beyond the River', about who authorized them to build. He quotes their answer in a letter to King Darius (5:6–17). They have just admitted that their ancestors provoked God and that a king of Babylon, Nebuchadnezzar, destroyed 'this house' (v. 12). Now they turn the story with a sharp 'nevertheless'. A later king of Babylon, Cyrus, reversed it. They give the exact year, name the king twice for precision, and use the governor's own administrative phrase, 'set an order' (the standard wording for a binding royal command). They also use the same verb he used in his challenge: 'to build'. In effect they say: we are not rebels; we are carrying out a royal order still on the books. Check the archives. Underneath the legal argument lies a theological one. The God who handed his people over to one king of Babylon has moved another king of Babylon to restore his house.
-
14He also removed from the temple of Babylon the gold and silver articles belonging to the house of God, which Nebuchadnezzar had taken and carried there from the temple in Jerusalem. King Cyrus gave these articles to a man named Sheshbazzar, whom he appointed governor
Full study →"And there is more: the sacred gold and silver implements that belong to God's house, which Nebuchadnezzar took out of the temple that stood in Jerusalem and hauled off to the temple of Babylon, put there as trophies of his god's victory. Those very objects King Cyrus took out of the temple of Babylon again. They were officially handed over to a man by the name of Sheshbazzar, whom Cyrus had installed as governor."
The sentence is shaped as a reversal. The same verb, "took out," is used first for the Babylonian conqueror and then for the Persian king, and "temple" moves from Jerusalem to Babylon and, in the next verse, back to Jerusalem. The speakers are the Jewish elders, and their words reach Darius inside the report of a suspicious Persian official. They are not telling a pious story. They are presenting evidence: the king's own predecessor gave the holy objects back, through his own officials, to a man holding his own commission. The equipment of Yahweh's worship was coming home by royal order, so rebuilding the house to hold it was not rebellion. It was carrying out Persian policy.
-
15and instructed, ‘Take these articles, put them in the temple in Jerusalem, and let the house of God be rebuilt on its original site.’
Full study →Cyrus, the Persian king who conquered Babylon, gives his appointed governor Sheshbazzar three quick orders, the way an official speaks: pick up these vessels, go, and set them down in the temple that is in Jerusalem. "These" points to the actual gold and silver bowls and basins that Nebuchadnezzar had looted decades earlier and kept in a Babylonian god's temple. The same objects are now being carried home, out of one god's house and back into their own. Then comes the formal permission: "and the house of God — let it be built on its own place." The wording is a royal authorization in the passive voice ("let it be built"). It orders restoration on the original site, on the old foundations, not a new sanctuary somewhere else.
All of this is a quotation inside a quotation. The governor Tattenai is writing to King Darius (5:6–17). He reports what the Jewish elders told him, and they are quoting what Cyrus said. The elders' point is legal: we are not rebels building without permission; the king of Persia himself handed back the temple's vessels and ordered this house rebuilt where it stood.
-
16So this Sheshbazzar came and laid the foundation of the house of God in Jerusalem, and from that time until now it has been under construction, but it has not yet been completed.”
Full study →"Then that same Sheshbazzar, the man Cyrus handed the temple vessels to and commissioned, came to Jerusalem and laid down the foundations of the house of God there. And from that day right up to this moment the house has been in the process of being built. It has never been brought to completion."
These are the last words of the Jewish elders' defence, as the Persian governor Tattenai quoted them in his letter to King Darius. Each phrase does legal work:
- "that same Sheshbazzar" points back to the official named a sentence earlier (v. 14). The foundations were laid by the king's own appointee, not by some local initiative.
- "laid the foundations" is literally "gave the foundations", the formal language of temple founding known from Mesopotamian building inscriptions. It continues a chain of "giving" in the speech: God gave Judah into Nebuchadnezzar's hand, the vessels were given back to Sheshbazzar, and he gave the foundations.
- "from then until now it is being built" describes one continuous, still-open project. The elders are not claiming that crews worked nonstop for eighteen years; Ezra 4:24 and Haggai 1 show they did not. They are claiming that the work Cyrus authorized never lapsed and was never closed.
- "and it is not finished" explains why there are builders on the site at all. They are completing an old royal order, not starting anything new. Whether that order really exists is exactly what verse 17 asks Darius to check in the archives.
Where the English drifted
-
in v11
the house (KJV, WEB, YLT)
baytāʾ
- What we hear
- A dwelling, or loosely "God's house" meaning any church or place of worship.
- What they heard
- The temple: the one sanctuary in Jerusalem, understood as the residence of God, rebuilt on its original foundations.
-
in v11
set up (KJV)
šakhlel
- What we hear
- Erected, assembled or established, i.e. the start of something.
- What they heard
- Completed, brought to finish. It is the official building term the inspectors had used when they asked who authorized "finishing" this structure.
-
in v12
provoked … unto wrath / angered
hargizû
- What we hear
- A god losing his temper, an irritable or arbitrary deity.
- What they heard
- The ancestors are the active subject: by breaking faith with their God they 'made him rage'. In Israel's own account this is the justified reaction of the covenant Lord to a long, warned-against betrayal (the language of 2 Kings and Jeremiah).
-
in v12
the Chaldean
kasdāʾāh
- What we hear
- An astrologer or magus (from Daniel, or from 'Chaldean' as a byword for stargazers).
- What they heard
- An ethnic and family label: Nebuchadnezzar belonged to the Chaldean ruling family of southern Babylonia.
-
in v13
house of God
bêt ʾĕlāhāʾ
- What we hear
- A church building, or any place where people gather to worship.
- What they heard
- The temple in Jerusalem, understood as God's residence: the one sanctuary with its altar and sacrifices, standing on the site of Solomon's temple.
-
in v14
vessels
mā'nayyā
- What we hear
- Containers such as jars or pots, or even ships.
- What they heard
- Sacred implements of the temple: bowls, basins, dishes, knives, all the gold and silver equipment used in worship.
-
in v14
governor
peḥāh
- What we hear
- An elected head of a state or region with constitutional powers.
- What they heard
- A provincial official appointed by the Persian king who served at the king's pleasure under a regional satrap.
-
in v15
in his place (KJV)
'al-'atreh
- What we hear
- A modern reader may take 'his' to mean God's place or a person's place, as if the temple were to be built in God's chosen location in some spiritual sense.
- What they heard
- 'On its place': the house's own original site, the old foundations. In KJV English 'his' was the normal possessive for things, before 'its' became standard.
Every word
-
וּכְנֵ֥מָא
ukhenēmāʾ · H3660
-
פִתְגָמָ֖א
pitgāmāʾ · H6600
word, message, reply · v11
A Persian loanword for an official message or report. Here it is the elders' formal answer, recorded for the king as a statement on file.
-
הֲתִיב֣וּנָא
hătîbûnāʾ · H8421I
to return, to give back (a reply) · v11
Literally "they returned to us". "Returning a word" is the standard Aramaic way to say "to reply". The subject is the Jewish elders and "us" is the writers of the letter, Tattenai and his colleagues.
-
לְמֵמַ֑ר
lemēmar · H0560
to say · v11, v15
"Saying". It works like an opening quotation mark: what follows is the elders' answer as the officials report it.
-
אֲנַ֣חְנָא
ʾănaḥnāʾ · H0586
-
הִמּ֡וֹ
himmô · H1994
they · v11, v12, v14, v15
Literally "they", but here it acts as the linking verb "are". Aramaic can use a third-person pronoun this way, so "we, they, servants" means "we are servants".
-
עַבְדוֹהִי֩
ʿabdôhî · H5649
servant, slave, subject · v11
"His servants": people who belong to, serve and worship a master, here a god. In a report to the Persian court it states whose authority they act under.
-
דִֽי־
dî · H1768
who, which, of · v11, v12, v13, v14, v15, v16
Here it marks belonging ("of"). It spells out whose servants they are, after the "his" already attached to "servants".
-
אֱלָ֨הּ
ʾĕlāh · H0426
god, God · v11, v12, v13, v14, v15, v16
"God", the ordinary Aramaic word for a deity. With "of heaven" it becomes the title Persian-era Jews used for their God when writing to officials.
-
שְׁמַיָּ֜א
šemayyāʾ · H8065
-
וְאַרְעָ֗א
weʾarʿāʾ · H0772I
earth, land · v11
"And the earth". Adding it to the usual "God of heaven" turns the title into a claim that he rules everything, the land where the officials govern included. The full phrase "God of heaven and earth" appears only here in Ezra.
-
וּבָנַ֤יִן
ûbānayin · H1124
to build · v11, v13, v15, v16
"And [we are] building". The participle describes work in progress, which is exactly what the officials had seen (5:8). This is the first of three forms of "build" in the verse.
-
בַּיְתָא֙
baytāʾ · H1005
house; temple · v11, v12, v13, v14, v15, v16
"The house". In this context, as in "house of God", it means the temple. The definite article points to a known building: that house, the one on this site.
-
הֲוָ֨א
hăwāʾ · H1934
to be · v11
"Was". Together with the next word it forms "had been built", a state that held in the past.
-
מִקַּדְמַ֤ת
miqqadmat · H6928
former time, before · v11
"From before". It establishes that the building is old, which is the heart of their case.
-
דְּנָה֙
denāh · H1836
this · v11, v12, v13
"This", meaning the present moment: "before this [time]".
-
שְׁנִ֣ין
šenîn · H8140
years · v11, v13
"Years". From Solomon's temple (10th century BC) to 520 BC is over four centuries.
-
שַׂגִּיאָ֔ן
śaggîʾān · H7690
many, much, great · v11
"Many". The building's age is stressed, so this is a restoration, not something new.
-
וּמֶ֤לֶךְ
ûmelekh · H4430
king · v11, v12, v13, v14
"And a king". It has no article and no name. Solomon is meant, but he is described rather than named, perhaps because the name would mean nothing to a Persian reader.
-
לְיִשְׂרָאֵל֙
leyiśrāʾēl · H3479
Israel · v11
"Of Israel". It claims a royal, national history for the people now living in the small province of Yehud.
-
רַ֔ב
rab · H7229
great, chief · v11
"Great", placed after "of Israel": "a king of Israel, a great one". In this imperial setting "great king" was a weighty title, so the temple's founder is presented as a real monarch of standing.
-
וְשַׁכְלְלֵֽהּ׃
wešakhlelēh · H3635A
-
לָהֵ֗ן
lāhēn · H3861
but, however; except; therefore · v12
Marks a turn away from v. 11. A great king of Israel built and finished the temple, *but* there is more to tell. It brings in the uncomfortable part of the story.
-
מִן־
min- · H4481
from · v12, v14, v16
With the next word it forms the joining phrase min-dî, literally 'from (the fact) that'. That can mean either 'because' or 'after'.
-
הַרְגִּ֤זוּ
hargizû · H7265
to enrage, provoke to anger · v12
A 'causing' form of a root whose basic sense is to shake or tremble with agitation: 'they made (him) rage'. The ancestors are the active party. God's anger is a reaction they provoked by breaking faith, not a mood that came from nowhere.
-
אֲבָהֳתַ֙נָא֙
ʾăbāhātanāʾ · H0002
father; ancestor · v12
'Our fathers' means the earlier generations of Judah before the exile. The speakers claim them as their own ('our') and accept the family's history, guilt included.
-
יְהַ֣ב
yĕhab · H3052
to give · v12, v14, v16
'He gave'. The subject is God, not Nebuchadnezzar. God himself handed his people over.
-
בְּיַ֛ד
bĕyad · H3028
hand · v12
'Into the hand of' means into the power and control of. With 'gave' it is the stock phrase for a god handing a people over to an enemy.
-
נְבוּכַדְנֶצַּ֥ר
nĕbûkadneṣṣar · H5020
Nebuchadnezzar · v12, v14
Nebuchadnezzar II of Babylon (reigned 605–562 BC). In Babylonian his name was Nabû-kudurri-uṣur, 'O Nabu, protect my heir'. Here he appears only as the instrument God used.
-
בָּבֶ֖ל
bābel · H0895
Babylon · v12, v13, v14
The city and empire that destroyed Jerusalem.
-
כַּסְדָּאָ֑ה
kasdāʾāh · H3679
Chaldean · v12
'The Chaldean' is an ethnic and family label. Nebuchadnezzar's ruling family came from the Chaldean tribes of southern Mesopotamia. Here it does not mean 'astrologer', as it sometimes does in Daniel.
-
סַתְרֵ֔הּ
satrēh · H5642B
to demolish, tear down · v12
'He demolished it'. The final -ēh ('it') points back to the house mentioned first. This Aramaic word is unrelated to the Hebrew word satar, 'hide'. It refers to the destruction of 587/586 BC.
-
וְעַמָּ֖ה
wĕʿammāh · H5972
people · v12
'And the people' means the population of Judah. Like 'this house', it is placed first: house and people are the two things lost.
-
הַגְלִ֥י
haglî · H1541
to uncover, reveal; (causing form) to deport · v12
'He deported'. The root means 'uncover, lay bare', and the same root came to mean 'go into exile', as if the land were stripped bare. The supplied gloss 'to reveal' gives the root's other sense; here it plainly means deportation.
-
בְּרַם֙
bəram · H1297
however, nevertheless · v13
A strong 'but' that turns the story around. Verse 12 ended with the temple destroyed and the people deported; this word opens the reversal: that was not the end of the matter.
-
חֲדָ֔ה
ḥădāh · H2298
one · v13
Literally 'one'. Aramaic, like Hebrew, often uses the plain number 'one' where English says 'first': 'year one' of the king's reign.
-
לְכ֥וֹרֶשׁ
lə-Kōreš · H3567
of Cyrus · v13, v14
'Belonging to Cyrus': the year is counted by his reign. Cyrus (Persian Kuruš) was Cyrus II 'the Great', founder of the Persian Empire, who took Babylon in 539 BC.
-
שָׂ֣ם
śām · H7761G
set, put, make · v13, v14
Literally 'set' or 'placed'. With the next word it forms a fixed phrase of the imperial chancery (the royal writing office): 'set an order', meaning 'issued a command'. Completed action: the order was given and stands.
-
טְעֵ֔ם
ṭəʿēm · H2942
order, decree; judgment; report · v13
An authoritative order or ruling. It is the standard word in Persian-era Aramaic administration for a binding instruction from a superior. Darius later finds it written down as an official memorandum (6:2–5).
-
וְאַף
we'af · H0638
and also · v14
Adds a second proof to the argument the elders started in v.13. Cyrus did not only order the rebuilding; he also gave back the sacred objects.
-
מָאנַיָּא
mā'nayyā · H3984
vessels, utensils · v14, v15
The temple's sacred equipment: bowls, basins, dishes and knives used in worship (compare Ezra 1:9–10). It does not mean ordinary household pots.
-
דַהֲבָה
dahăvāh · H1722
gold · v14
'The gold.' The vessels were precious metal, which is why they were worth looting and worth keeping as trophies.
-
וְכַסְפָּא
wekhaspā · H3702
and silver · v14
'And the silver.' Gold and silver objects were the ones that survived. The bronze temple fittings had been broken up for their metal (2 Kings 25:13).
-
הַנְפֵּק
hanpēq · H5312
brought out, took out · v14
'Took out.' This is the causative form of 'go out': he made the vessels leave the temple. The same verb is used again for Cyrus below.
-
הֵיכְלָא
hêkhlā · H1965G
temple, palace · v14, v15
'The temple,' here the Jerusalem sanctuary. The word goes back to Sumerian/Akkadian 'great house.'
-
בִירוּשְׁלֶם
vîrûshəlem · H3390
in Jerusalem · v14, v15, v16
Names the place. The whole dispute in Ezra 5 is about whether building may go on at this site.
-
וְהֵיבֵל
wəhêvēl · H2987
and carried, brought · v14
'And he carried [them] off.' It completes the picture of the deportation: out of Jerusalem and away to Babylon.
-
לְשֵׁשְׁבַּצַּר
ləshēshbaṣṣar · H8340
-
שְׁמֵהּ
shəmēh · H8036
his name · v14
'His name [was].' This is the formula Aramaic official documents use to introduce a person: 'one Sheshbazzar by name.' It implies Darius would not know who he was.
-
פֶחָה
feḥāh · H6347
governor · v14
An imperial governor of a province, appointed by the crown. Tattenai, who wrote this letter, holds the same title (v.3).
-
לֵהּ
leh · H9034
to him · v15
The preposition 'to' with a 'him' ending. It points back to Sheshbazzar, whom Cyrus had appointed governor (5:14).
-
אֵל
'el · H0412
these · v15
'These' points to the particular gold and silver vessels just described in 5:14, the very objects Nebuchadnezzar had looted. Their sameness is the point: what was taken is what is going back.
-
שֵׂא
se' · H5376
take! lift up! · v15
A command, 'pick up, carry'. The first of three quick orders (take, go, set down) that sound like an official giving instructions.
-
אֵזֶל־
'ezel · H0236
go! · v15
A command, 'go'. It authorizes the journey from Babylon to Jerusalem.
-
אֲחֵת
'aḥet · H5182
bring down, deposit! · v15
A causative command from the root 'to go down', meaning 'cause to go down, set down, deposit'. Ezra 6:5 uses the same verb for placing the vessels in God's house. It is the language of putting something in its proper storage or place.
-
עַל־
'al · H5922
upon, on · v15
'Upon', meaning on top of the original location. The supplied gloss 'since' does not fit here.
-
אַתְרֵהּ
'atreh · H0870
its place · v15
'Its place': the original site of the house. The order is to rebuild on the same ground and foundations, not to found a new sanctuary somewhere else. Ezra 6:5 uses the same word for each vessel returning 'to its place'.
-
אֱדַ֙יִן֙
ʾĕdayin · H0116
then · v16
The ordinary Aramaic word for moving a story to its next step. It picks up from verse 15: once Cyrus had given Sheshbazzar the temple vessels and his orders, the next thing was that he came.
-
דֵּ֔ךְ
dēk · H1791
this, that · v16
A pointing word placed after the name: 'that Sheshbazzar', meaning the one just mentioned in verse 14. It fixes him as the same man who received the royal order and the vessels.
-
אֲתָ֗א
ʾătāʾ · H0858
to come · v16
'He came', a completed past action. Sheshbazzar actually travelled from Babylon to Jerusalem and carried out what he was ordered to do.
-
אֻשַּׁיָּ֛א
ʾushshayyāʾ · H0787
foundation · v16
'The foundations', plural and definite: the base courses or substructure the building stands on. This is building-inscription language. It matches the Akkadian word uššu, which Mesopotamian kings used when they 'laid the foundations' of temples.
-
וְעַד־
wĕʿad · H5705
and until · v16
It closes the span: 'and up to…'
-
כְּעַ֛ן
kĕʿan · H3705
now · v16
'Now', the moment of the inspection in Darius's second year (about 520 BC). That is roughly eighteen years after Cyrus's decree.
-
וְלָ֥א
wĕlāʾ · H3809
and not · v16
The plain Aramaic 'not', joined by 'and'. The translations' 'yet' and 'but' are implied, not written.
-
שְׁלִֽם׃
shĕlim · H8000
to be complete, finished · v16
'It is complete', here negated: 'it has not come to completion'. This is the root behind Hebrew shalom (wholeness). The elders' speech ends on the temple's unfinished state, which explains why work is going on at all.
The world behind it
When and where. The year is about 520 BC, the second year of Darius I (Ezra 4:24). The prophets Haggai and Zechariah had stirred Zerubbabel the governor and Jeshua the high priest to resume work on the Jerusalem temple (5:1–2), which had stalled for about 16 years after the foundations were laid under Cyrus.
Who is asking. Tattenai was governor of "Beyond the River", the Persian province west of the Euphrates. He is known outside the Bible from a Babylonian business tablet of 502 BC that names "Tattanni, governor of Ebir-nāri". He came to inspect the building with Shethar-bozenai and their colleagues. Darius had just put down widespread revolts after taking the throne (522–521 BC), so officials had good reason to check any unauthorized building, especially in Jerusalem, which had been accused of rebellion before (4:12–16). Tattenai did not stop the work. He asked questions, wrote down names and referred the matter to the king (5:5–10). Verse 11 begins the elders' answer as his letter reports it.
Why "old" matters. Across the ancient Near East, restoring a god's temple on its original foundations was considered pious and good for a kingdom. Babylonian kings boasted of finding a temple's ancient foundation and rebuilding exactly on it. Cyrus presented himself as a restorer of sanctuaries and displaced gods (the Cyrus Cylinder). A new building could look like a power grab. Restoring an ancient royal temple looked like rightful continuity. So the elders stress age ("many years ago") and royal origin ("a great king of Israel") before explaining the destruction (5:12) and appealing to Cyrus's decree (5:13–16).
The temple's history behind the words. Solomon built and dedicated the first temple in the 10th century BC (1 Kings 6–8; "built and finished" echoes 1 Kings 6:14, 38). Nebuchadnezzar's forces destroyed it in 587/586 BC. By 520 BC its builder lay more than four centuries in the past.
From the study of Ezra 5:11.
Where scholars differ
in v11
Is Tattenai's letter (and so the elders' quoted reply) a genuine Persian-period document, or a later literary composition?
-
Substantially authentic, perhaps lightly edited.
Its form, its official vocabulary (Persian loanwords such as pitgām, Akkadian-derived šakhlel) and its tone match Aramaic administrative letters from Elephantine and the Arshama archive. Tattenai himself is attested as governor of Ebir-nāri in a Babylonian tablet. The letter is also notably fair to the Jews, which an invented hostile letter would hardly be. (Williamson; Porten; many commentators.)
-
Shaped or composed by the author of Ezra.
Spelling and some grammatical forms look later than the 6th–5th century BC. The letter's neat fit with the book's themes, and the elders' theologically polished confession, suggest literary shaping. Some scholars (e.g. Grabbe, Gunneweg) doubt the documents reproduce their originals.
in v11
Is "God of heaven" a deliberate accommodation to Persian religion?
-
Yes, at least partly. It was chosen because Persians could recognize it.
The title appears mostly in documents addressed to or from Persian authorities (Ezra 1:2; 6:9–10; 7:12, 21, 23; the Elephantine petition TAD A4.7). Some link it to the sky-associated supreme god Ahura Mazda of the Achaemenid inscriptions.
-
It is a native Israelite title, used more often in this period but not borrowed.
"God of heaven" and "God of heaven and earth" already appear in Genesis 24:3, 7 and Genesis 14:19, 22. Nehemiah uses "God of heaven" in private prayer (Neh 1:4–5), where no Persian audience was involved.
in v12
Is min-dî here causal ('because') or temporal ('after')?
-
Causal: 'because our fathers angered…' (BSB, ESV, NIV, most modern commentators).
min-dî means 'because' in Daniel 3:22. The argument of vv. 11–13 explains why the temple lay in ruins, and the Kings–Jeremiah background makes the ancestors' sin the cause.
-
Temporal: 'after our fathers had provoked…' (KJV, WEB, YLT, following the Vulgate's postquam).
min-dî can mean 'from the time that' (cf. Daniel 4:23 [ET 4:26]). In practice the two readings overlap, because the sequence implies the cause.
in v12
Is 'God of heaven' a Persian-era accommodation or a native Israelite title?
-
Mainly a way of speaking to the empire: a title chosen so Persian officials could understand it, and possibly meant to resonate with Persian high-god religion.
It clusters in Persian-period documents addressed to or by officials (Ezra 1:2; 6:9–10; 7:12–23; the Elephantine letter TAD A4.7 to the governor of Judah).
-
A native Israelite title that suited the Persian setting, not one borrowed from it.
Earlier uses in Gen 24:3, 7 and Jonah 1:9. In Ezra and Nehemiah it is also used in purely Judean prayer (Neh 1:4–5), and it fits Israel's older picture of YHWH as enthroned above the heavens.
in v13
Did Cyrus really issue an order to rebuild the Jerusalem temple, and are the two versions in Ezra (1:2–4 and 6:3–5) authentic?
-
Both are substantially authentic: the Aramaic text in 6:3–5 is an archival memorandum and the Hebrew text in 1:2–4 a public proclamation to the Jews.
E. J. Bickerman's classic 1946 study argued that the two differ in language, form and audience as real Persian documents would. The Aramaic memorandum's dry building specifications and the use of the archive at Ecbatana, a known summer residence of Persian kings, fit Achaemenid practice. The policy matches the Cyrus Cylinder's account of restoring sanctuaries. Many commentators (e.g. Williamson) accept at least the Aramaic memorandum as authentic in substance.
-
The Aramaic memorandum may rest on a genuine core, but 1:2–4 (and possibly parts of the Aramaic correspondence) were composed or reworked by the Jewish author.
In 1:2–4 Cyrus speaks of 'the LORD, the God of heaven' in strongly Israelite theological language. Some features of the Aramaic letters reflect later spelling and style. The Cyrus Cylinder concerns Babylonian cities and never mentions Judah. Scholars such as Grabbe and Fried have questioned how far the documents are verbatim.
-
Cyrus's 'order' was a general permission for return and local cult restoration, which the Jerusalem community later presented as a specific temple decree.
Persian kings generally allowed and sometimes funded local sanctuaries that supported imperial order. Little rebuilding happened between 538 and 520 BC (Haggai 1), which some take to mean the original authorization was limited or not enforced.
in v13
When was 'the first year of Cyrus king of Babylon'?
-
538 BC (the regnal year beginning in spring 538).
Babylon fell to Cyrus in October 539 BC. Under Babylonian reckoning the months until the next New Year (Nisan, spring) were his 'accession year', and 'year one' began in spring 538. Babylonian tablets dated to Cyrus as 'king of Babylon' support this.
-
Counted loosely from the conquest, i.e. 539/538 BC.
Biblical writers do not always follow strict accession-year counting. The point of the phrase is 'immediately after he took Babylon', and the gap between the two options is a few months.
in v14
Who was Sheshbazzar, and how does he relate to Zerubbabel?
-
Sheshbazzar and Zerubbabel are the same man under two names.
Both are said to lay the temple foundations (Ezra 5:16 for Sheshbazzar; Ezra 3:8–10, Zechariah 4:9 for Zerubbabel). Judeans often had Babylonian names (compare Daniel and his friends). Older commentators widely held this view.
-
They are two different men. Sheshbazzar led the first return in 538 BC and Zerubbabel came later or took over.
Ezra 5 names them separately (Zerubbabel in v.2, Sheshbazzar in vv.14–16). Both names are Babylonian, so a 'Babylonian name versus Hebrew name' explanation fails. 1 Esdras 6:18 treats them as two people. Most modern scholars hold this view.
-
Sheshbazzar is Shenazzar, a son of King Jehoiachin (1 Chronicles 3:18), and so a Davidic prince.
The names look similar, and Ezra 1:8 calls him 'prince of Judah.' Critics answer that the names are hard to match linguistically (Shenazzar likely comes from Sin-uṣur) and that 'prince' need not mean royal descent.
in v14
Were all the temple's treasures actually returned?
-
The gold and silver equipment that survived was returned in large part.
The inventory in Ezra 1:9–11 and the archive record in Ezra 6:5 both describe a substantial return.
-
Only part came back. Some objects had been melted down or lost, and the ark is never mentioned.
2 Kings 24:13 says Nebuchadnezzar 'cut in pieces' gold vessels. 2 Kings 25:13–17 says the bronze was broken up. No source lists the ark among the returned objects.
in v15
How could the vessels be put 'in the temple in Jerusalem' if the temple still had to be rebuilt?
-
'Temple' means the sacred site and institution, which still existed after the building was destroyed. The vessels were to be returned there, and the house built.
Jeremiah 41:5 shows worshippers still coming to the ruined temple site. Ezra 3:2–6 records the altar being rebuilt and sacrifices resuming before the foundations were laid.
-
The elders compress the sequence: the vessels were meant for the temple once it was rebuilt, and the two orders belong together as one commission.
In 6:5 the vessels are to be restored 'to the temple … each to its place' in the same decree that orders construction, which reads as a single programme rather than a strict timeline.
in v15
Do the Aramaic documents in Ezra 4–6 preserve genuine Persian correspondence?
-
They are substantially authentic Achaemenid documents, perhaps lightly edited.
Their language and formulas match official Aramaic of the period (compare the Elephantine papyri and the Arsames letters). Persian kings are known to have returned cult objects and sponsored local temples. E. J. Bickerman's classic study defended the Cyrus memorandum (6:3–5).
-
They have been shaped or composed by the author of Ezra to make the community's case.
The letters' interest in Jewish concerns, and the way they serve the book's argument, suggest authorial shaping. Some details, such as the dimensions in 6:3, look unusual.
in v16
Who laid the temple's foundations: Sheshbazzar or Zerubbabel?
-
Sheshbazzar and Zerubbabel are the same man, with a Babylonian name and a Judean name.
Both are linked with leading the return and laying foundations (Ezra 5:16; 3:8–10; Zech 4:9). Daniel and his friends also had Babylonian court names. This was a common older view among conservative commentators, for example Keil.
-
They are two people. Sheshbazzar, the first governor, made a beginning around 538 BC. Zerubbabel, a later leader, did the main foundation work (Ezra 3), or relaid it in 520 BC (Hag 2:18; Zech 4:9).
Ezra 1:8 gives Sheshbazzar no Judean genealogy, while Zerubbabel's is given (son of Shealtiel). 1 Esdras 6:18 names both men side by side. The two men's genealogies and titles do not match. This is the majority view in modern critical commentaries (for example Williamson, Blenkinsopp).
-
The elders name Sheshbazzar for legal reasons: in a letter to the Persian court, what counts is the officeholder Cyrus commissioned, whatever the share of the practical work.
The whole speech (5:11–16) is built on the royal chain of authority: Cyrus's decree, the vessels handed to his appointed governor, and the foundations 'given' by that governor. It can be combined with either of the views above.
in v16
How can the elders say the house has been 'being built' continuously, when Ezra 4:24 says work stopped until Darius's second year?
-
It is a legal claim of continuity, not a report of nonstop labour: the authorized project never lapsed.
The passive participle names no workers and stresses the project's open status. The elders' aim is to show the work is not new and therefore needs no fresh permit (5:3, 9, 17).
-
Some intermittent work went on, so the statement is loosely true as a description.
Haggai 1:2–4 suggests neglect rather than an absolute ban. A token or sporadic effort cannot be ruled out.
-
The two passages reflect different sources or a compressed history in Ezra 1–6.
Ezra 4:6–23 is a deliberately out-of-sequence collection of later opposition letters (from the reigns of Xerxes and Artaxerxes), which shows the author arranged material by theme, not strictly by date.
Sources
- BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. פִּתְגָם, כְּלַל, עֲבַד
- HALOT (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. פִּתְגָם, שַׁכְלֵל, בַּיִת
- H.G.M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary 16)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra-Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- F.C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT)
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt, TAD A4.7 (Petition to Bagohi)
- L.L. Grabbe, Ezra-Nehemiah (Old Testament Readings)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezra 5
- Septuagint 2 Esdras 5:11; 1 Esdras 6:13–14; Vulgate Ezra 5:11
- BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. רְגַז, סְתַר, גְּלָא, לָהֵן
- HALOT (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. רגז, סתר, גלה, כַּשְׂדָּי
- F. Rosenthal, A Grammar of Biblical Aramaic (on the object-marking le- and stand-alone object pronouns)
- B. Porten & A. Yardeni, Textbook of Aramaic Documents from Ancient Egypt, A4.7 (Elephantine petition, 'YHW the God of heaven')
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra–Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Library)
- F. C. Fensham, The Books of Ezra and Nehemiah (NICOT)
- Mesha Stele (Moabite Stone), lines 5–6
- BDB (Brown-Driver-Briggs), Aramaic section, s.v. טְעֵם, בְּרַם, בְּנָה
- HALOT (Koehler-Baumgartner), Biblical Aramaic, s.v. טְעֵם, בְּרַם
- E. J. Bickerman, 'The Edict of Cyrus in Ezra 1', Journal of Biblical Literature 65 (1946)
- H. G. M. Williamson, Ezra, Nehemiah (Word Biblical Commentary)
- L. S. Fried, Ezra: A Commentary
- L. L. Grabbe, Ezra–Nehemiah (Old Testament Readings)
- Cyrus Cylinder (British Museum), Akkadian text and translation
- Elephantine Papyri, TAD A4.7 (petition to rebuild the temple of YHW, 407 BC)
- Septuagint, 2 Esdras 5:13; 1 Esdras 6:17
- Vulgate, Ezra 5:13
- HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. מָאן, הֵיכַל, פֶּחָה, נפק, שׂים
- BDB (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. פֶּחָה, הֵיכַל
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezra 1 and 5
- Cyrus Cylinder (British Museum), lines on restoring gods to their sanctuaries
- Elephantine Aramaic papyri (e.g. the Bagohi petition)
- 1 Esdras 6:17–18 (Septuagint)
- Westminster Leningrad Codex / supplied interlinear data
- HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. מָאן, הֵיכַל, אֲתַר, נחת
- BDB Aramaic section s.v. אֲתַר, בְּנָה
- Cyrus Cylinder (translation in COS 2.124)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Ezra 5–6
- BDB (Aramaic section) s.v. אֹשׁ, יְהַב, בְּנָה, שְׁלֵם
- HALOT (Biblical Aramaic) s.v. אֻשַּׁיָּא, שְׁלִם
- CAD s.v. uššu (foundation)
- Elephantine papyri, petition to rebuild the temple of Yahu (TAD A4.7, 407 BC)
- Cyrus Cylinder
- Septuagint 2 Esdras 5:16; 1 Esdras 6:18–20
- Vulgate, Ezra 5:16
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).