Genesis Chapter 18 Read as one passage

Genesis 18:23–28

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

23Abraham stepped forward and said, “Will You really sweep away the righteous with the wicked? 24What if there are fifty righteous ones in the city? Will You really sweep it away and not spare the place for the sake of the fifty righteous ones who are there? 25Far be it from You to do such a thing—to kill the righteous with the wicked, so that the righteous and the wicked are treated alike. Far be it from You! Will not the Judge of all the earth do what is right?” 26So the LORD replied, “If I find fifty righteous ones within the city of Sodom, on their account I will spare the whole place.” 27Then Abraham answered, “Now that I have ventured to speak to the Lord—though I am but dust and ashes— 28suppose the fifty righteous ones lack five. Will You destroy the whole city for the lack of five?” He replied, “If I find forty-five there, I will not destroy it.”

What the first hearers heard

Israelites hearing this story would have recognised a legal scene. Their ancestor comes forward before the divine Judge and challenges a sentence that might fall on innocent and guilty alike. The story did several things for them:

  • It defined their God's character. Unlike gods who destroy on a whim, YHWH is bound by justice and lets himself be questioned on its terms. The God who told Abraham to practise "righteousness and justice" (18:19) is held to that same standard.
  • It defined Abraham's role. Abraham is shown as someone who pleads for others, and he is later called a prophet who will pray for others (Gen 20:7). Moses (Exod 32:11–14), Samuel and Amos (Amos 7:1–6) stand in the same tradition.
  • It raised a lasting question. Can the innocent rightly die in a judgment on a whole community? Abraham's question sits in tension with the reality of exile and national disaster, and the prophets later take it up (Jer 5:1; Ezek 14:12–20; 18).
  • It prepared for the ending. The story does not resolve the question by sparing Sodom. It resolves it by bringing out the one household that is in the right (19:15–29), and "God remembered Abraham" (19:29).

From the study of Genesis 18:23.

Verse by verse

  1. 23Abraham stepped forward and said, “Will You really sweep away the righteous with the wicked?

    Abraham stepped up close, the way someone comes forward before a ruler or a judge to plead a case, or the way a worshipper approaches the altar, and he said: "Would you really, you, sweep away the innocent together with the guilty?"

    The question is asked in disbelief and expects the answer "No, of course not." "Sweep away" pictures a single blow that carries off everyone at once, and the narrator uses the same verb again when the angels warn Lot not to be "swept away" with the city (19:15, 17). "Righteous" and "wicked" here are courtroom words. They mean the party in the right (innocent of the charge) and the party in the wrong (guilty). They do not mean saints and monsters. Abraham is not asking whether perfect people will be spared. He is asking whether the Judge will pass the same death sentence on people who have not committed the crime. God has just said that Abraham is to teach his household "righteousness and justice" (18:19), and Abraham now appeals to that same standard, before God himself. The argument builds to verse 25: "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do justice?"

    Full study →
  2. 24What if there are fifty righteous ones in the city? Will You really sweep it away and not spare the place for the sake of the fifty righteous ones who are there?

    "Perhaps, just perhaps, there are fifty people in that city who are in the right: not guilty of the crimes whose outcry has reached you, but living right there inside it. Will you really bring a sweeping destruction down on it, one that takes everything in its path and sorts nothing, instead of lifting the guilt off the whole place and forgiving it, for the sake of those fifty innocent people embedded in its heart?"

    Abraham is not asking only that the good people be pulled out before the blow falls. He has already objected to the innocent dying with the guilty (v. 23). Now he goes further and asks for the whole city to be forgiven. The verb he uses, nasa', pictures guilt being carried away, and it is the ordinary Hebrew way of saying "forgive". The disbelieving "Will you really…?" repeats his opening objection, and the verse is framed at both ends by the innocent standing "in the midst of the city … within it". That frame is the whole problem: a sweep cannot spare the people it passes over. His "perhaps" opens a negotiation that will run from fifty down to ten. It rests on one conviction, stated in the next verse: "Will not the Judge of all the earth do what is just?"

    Full study →
  3. 25Far be it from You to do such a thing—to kill the righteous with the wicked, so that the righteous and the wicked are treated alike. Far be it from You! Will not the Judge of all the earth do what is right?”

    "Unthinkable, a desecration for you, to act in such a way: to put to death the innocent along with the guilty, so that innocent and guilty end up treated exactly alike! Unthinkable for you! The one who rules and judges the whole earth, is he not going to give a just verdict?"

    Abraham is speaking as an advocate before the supreme court of the world. The opening cry, ḥālilāh, comes from a root meaning "profane", so it is closer to "That would defile you!" than to a polite "far be it". He says it twice, wrapped around the act he dreads. The "righteous" and "wicked" are the plain courtroom categories of innocent and guilty, not saints and villains. The basic rule of Israel's law was that a judge must never condemn the innocent with the guilty (Exod 23:7; Deut 25:1). Abraham's last line is a rhetorical question that expects "yes". It also plays on words: "Shall the Judge not do judgment?" A true judge, by definition, judges justly. And "Judge" here means more than a neutral referee. It means the ruler of every land, whose job is to set things right and protect the wronged. The question is bold. It holds God to his own standard, the very "righteousness and justice" God had just said Abraham must teach his household (18:19). It also expresses trust: Abraham is sure the Judge will do what is just, and he argues on that basis.

    Full study →
  4. 26So the LORD replied, “If I find fifty righteous ones within the city of Sodom, on their account I will spare the whole place.”

    The LORD answered Abraham without rebuke and in his own words: "If I actually find, when I look into the city as I said I would, fifty people in Sodom who are in the right, innocent of the crimes the outcry is about, living right there inside the city, then I will lift the guilt off the whole place. I will carry it away and pardon the entire community, guilty and innocent together, because of them."

    Abraham had appealed to justice: the Judge of all the earth must not treat the innocent the same as the guilty (v. 25). God's answer goes further than that. He doesn't simply promise to pull the innocent out. He promises to forgive the whole city for their sake. The verb usually translated "spare" literally means "lift up, carry". It is the ordinary Hebrew way of saying that guilt is borne away. "Righteous" here is a courtroom word, meaning those not guilty of the charge, set against "the wicked/guilty" of the previous verse. The first hearers would have picked up an assumption the story shares with them: a community stands or falls together, and a small innocent remnant can weigh in favour of mercy for everyone.

    Full study →
  5. 27Then Abraham answered, “Now that I have ventured to speak to the Lord—though I am but dust and ashes—

    Abraham answered: "Look, if you'll permit me: I have already made bold to speak up to my Lord, I, who am nothing but dirt and ash..."

    The verse does not finish a thought. It is the polite, self-lowering preface Abraham sets in front of his next request (v.28: "suppose there are five fewer than fifty...").

    • "Look, please" (hinneh-na) is courtly softening. Abraham points at his own forwardness before anyone else can, the way a servant says "forgive me, but..." to a master.
    • "I have made bold / taken it on myself" describes something already done. He has crossed the line of arguing with God (v.23–25, "Shall not the Judge of all the earth do what is just?"), and he owns that. The underlying idea is: I've started, so let me go on. The ancient Greek and Latin translations read it exactly that way: "I have begun."
    • "My Lord": he uses a title of rank, "Master", rather than God's personal name, the way a servant addresses a superior.
    • "And I, dust and ash": the "I" is emphatic, I of all people. In Hebrew the phrase rhymes, ʿafar va-ʾefer, something like "dirt and cinders." Dust recalls what humans are made from and return to (Gen 2:7; 3:19): Abraham is a mortal creature talking to his Creator. Ash is what fire leaves behind and what mourners sit in, and it is exactly what Sodom is about to become (19:24, 28).

    The tone joins two things a modern reader might expect to clash: real boldness (he keeps pushing the number down) and real humility (he never forgets who he is talking to). He isn't calling himself morally worthless. He is naming the vast gap between a creature of earth and the Judge of all the earth, and pleading anyway.

    Full study →
  6. 28suppose the fifty righteous ones lack five. Will You destroy the whole city for the lack of five?” He replied, “If I find forty-five there, I will not destroy it.”

    Abraham presses on, still careful and polite: "What if the fifty innocent people fall short by five? Will you bring ruin on the whole city for the sake of five?" And the LORD answers: "I will not bring ruin on it, if I find forty-five there."

    Abraham does not ask, "Will you spare it for forty-five?" He keeps God's agreed figure of fifty as the baseline and calls the new number a shortfall: the fifty are five short. That makes the question sound almost absurd: would the Judge of all the earth wipe out an entire city over a gap of five people? The verb he uses for "bring ruin" is the same one used of the Flood, when a corrupt world was destroyed and only one righteous family came through. Abraham is probing whether Sodom will get the same treatment, or whether a group of innocent people can protect everyone else.

    "The righteous" here means the people in the right, the ones not guilty of the crimes behind the outcry against Sodom. It does not mean flawless saints. God's reply is short and immediate. He uses Abraham's own verb ("I will not bring ruin"), states the number directly ("forty-five") instead of "fifty minus five", and repeats the wording of his earlier promise: "if I find there." The verdict still waits on the investigation God has announced (v. 21), but the terms are set: a smaller innocent minority can save the city too.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v23

    the righteous

    tsaddiq

    What we hear
    Morally upright, pious or holy people, sometimes heard as 'the saved' or as sinless.
    What they heard
    The party in the right in a judicial case: those innocent of the charge being judged, here people not guilty of Sodom's crimes. It is a courtroom and relational term, not a claim of moral perfection.
  • in v24, v26

    righteous

    tsaddiqim

    What we hear
    Pious, deeply religious, morally exceptional people (or even 'self-righteous' ones), or people counted right with God in a theological sense.
    What they heard
    In this courtroom-style speech: people who are in the right, innocent of the crimes charged against the city, as opposed to the rasha', the guilty. Compare Abimelech's 'will you kill an innocent (tsaddiq) nation?' (Gen 20:4).
  • in v24

    spare

    nasa' lə-

    What we hear
    Hold back from harming, let off: the city is simply left standing.
    What they heard
    Lift or carry away guilt for someone, i.e. forgive them. The same construction is used in Num 14:19 ('as you have forgiven this people'). Abraham asks for the whole place to be forgiven, not just left alone.
  • in v25

    the righteous … the wicked

    ṣaddîq … rāšā‘

    What we hear
    Spiritually good, devout people versus evil, irreligious people. Sometimes it is even heard as 'sinless' versus 'sinners'.
    What they heard
    Courtroom categories: the party who is in the right (innocent) and the party in the wrong (guilty). Abraham is asking that innocent people not be sentenced with guilty ones, not claiming that perfect people live in Sodom.
  • in v25

    Judge (of all the earth)

    šōfēṭ

    What we hear
    A detached courtroom official, or in religious talk mainly a God who condemns and punishes.
    What they heard
    The ruler responsible for justice across his realm. He decides cases, but also defends the wronged and puts things right. Psalms 96 and 98 treat God's coming 'to judge the earth' as good news.
  • in v26

    spare

    nasa (le-)

    What we hear
    Hold back from destroying; give a reprieve.
    What they heard
    Lift up or carry away guilt, so forgive or pardon. The city's guilt is borne away. It is not merely that the punishment is put off.
  • in v27

    dust and ashes

    ʿafar vaʾefer

    What we hear
    In devotional language the phrase is often heard as moral self-condemnation: 'I am a wretched, worthless sinner.'
    What they heard
    Mainly creatureliness and mortality: a being made of earth and headed back to it, low in rank before the Creator. Ash adds mourning and lowliness. Abraham is not confessing sin here. He is acknowledging the gap in status between himself and God while continuing to argue boldly for justice.
  • in v28

    the righteous

    ha-tsaddiqim

    What we hear
    Especially devout or morally upright people, or (in Christian terms) people saved and right with God.
    What they heard
    The innocent: people in the right, not guilty in the matter under judgment, as opposed to the 'wicked/guilty' (rashaʿ). It describes conduct and legal standing, not spiritual perfection.
Every word
  1. וַיִּגַּ֥שׁ

    vayyiggash · H5066G

    draw near, approach · v23

    Abraham steps close to address someone above him. The same verb is used for coming forward to plead a case (Gen 44:18; Isa 41:1) and for approaching God at an altar, so it marks the start of a formal appeal, not a casual step.

  2. אַבְרָהָ֖ם

    avraham · H0085

    Abraham · v23, v27

    The patriarch whom God has just described (18:19) as the one who will teach his household 'righteousness and justice'. He now appeals to that same standard.

  3. וַיֹּאמַ֑ר

    vayyomar · H0559

    say · v23, v26, v27, v28

    Introduces Abraham's direct speech. This is the first time in the conversation that Abraham speaks first.

  4. הַאַ֣ף

    ha'af · H0637

    also, even, indeed (with question marker) · v23, v24

    The question marker ha- plus af ('even, indeed') makes an incredulous question: 'Would you really, even you, do this?' It expects the answer 'surely not'. Targum Onkelos and Rashi also hear af as 'anger': 'Will you destroy in anger…?'

  5. תִּסְפֶּ֔ה

    tispeh · H5595

    sweep away, snatch away, destroy · v23, v24

    Second-person imperfect: 'will you sweep away'. It pictures everyone carried off together in one blow, the way the angels later warn Lot 'lest you be swept away' (19:15, 17).

  6. צַדִּ֖יק

    tsaddiq · H6662

    righteous, in the right, innocent · v23, v24, v25, v26, v28

    Singular with no article, so it means 'anyone who is in the right'. In this courtroom-style speech it means the party who is innocent of the charge, here someone not guilty of Sodom's crimes.

  7. עִם־

    im · H5973A

    with, together with · v23, v25

    'Along with': the innocent caught up in the same act of destruction as the guilty. Abraham's whole objection rests on this little word.

  8. רָשָֽׁע׃

    rasha' · H7563

    wicked, guilty · v23, v25

    The legal opposite of tsaddiq: the party in the wrong, the one found guilty. It refers back to the 'outcry' against Sodom (18:20–21).

  9. אוּלַ֥י

    'ulay · H0194

    perhaps, what if · v24, v28

    Opens a hypothetical that Abraham cannot check. It is the first of a run of 'perhaps' clauses (vv. 28–32), each one lowering the number. It sounds tentative and hopeful, not like someone laying down terms.

  10. יֵ֛שׁ

    yesh · H3426

    there is / there are · v24

    Asserts existence: 'there are'. The whole argument rests on whether such people actually exist inside Sodom, which is what God has gone down to 'see' (v. 21).

  11. חֲמִשִּׁ֥ים

    ḥamishshim · H2572

    fifty · v24, v26, v28

    Abraham's opening figure. It is a real group but a small share of a city. 'Fifty' was also a standard unit for a company of men in Israel (Exod 18:21; 2 Kgs 1:9). Over the next verses it will be bargained down to ten.

  12. בְּת֣וֹךְ

    betokh · H8432

    in the midst of · v24, v26

    Places the righteous physically inside the city and woven into it. It sets up the problem: a judgment that sweeps over the whole town cannot miss them.

  13. הָעִ֑יר

    ha'ir · H5892B

    the city, town · v24, v26, v28

    Sodom: a settled community, probably walled, whose people share one fate in war or disaster. The city is treated as a single unit facing judgment.

  14. וְלֹא־

    velo- · H3808

    and not · v24, v25, v28

    Joins the two halves of the question: sweeping the city away is the same act as refusing to forgive it.

  15. תִשָּׂ֣א

    tissa · H5375H

    lift, carry, bear; (with lə-) forgive, spare · v24, v26

    The basic sense is 'lift / carry'. Followed by lə- ('to, for') it is the usual Hebrew way of saying 'forgive someone': the guilt is lifted off them or carried away. Abraham is asking God to forgive the place, which goes further than simply leaving it standing.

  16. לַמָּק֔וֹם

    lammaqom · H4725

    the place · v24, v26

    The whole locality: the city and everyone in it. In God's answer this becomes 'all the place' (v. 26). The later rabbinic custom of calling God 'HaMaqom' ('the Place') has nothing to do with this verse.

  17. לְמַ֛עַן

    lema'an · H4616

    for the sake of, on account of · v24

    Gives the grounds for forgiving the city: the presence of the fifty. The few become the reason the many are spared.

  18. אֲשֶׁ֥ר

    'asher · H0834A

    who, which · v24

    Introduces the closing clause, which places the righteous inside the city once more.

  19. בְּקִרְבָּֽהּ׃

    beqirbah · H7130G

    in its inner part, within it · v24

    Literally 'in her inward part'. Cities are feminine in Hebrew. The verse ends where it began, with the innocent deep inside the city, so the verse is framed by 'in the midst of the city … within it'.

  20. חָלִ֨לָה

    ḥālilāh · H2486

    far be it; God forbid · v25

    An exclamation of horror built on the root ḥ-l-l, 'to profane, make common'. Roughly 'A desecration!' or 'Unthinkable!'. Abraham opens by calling the idea something that would defile God's own character.

  21. לְּךָ֜

    lekhā · H9031

    to you · v25

    'For you', 'as regards you'. The unthinkable thing is unthinkable for God in particular, given who God is.

  22. מֵעֲשֹׂ֣ת

    mē‘ăśōt · H6213A

    to do, make · v25

    'From doing'. The 'from' marks distance: let it be far from you to do this. The same verb comes back at the end of the verse ('do justice'), framing it.

  23. כַּדָּבָ֣ר

    kaddāvār · H1697O

    word, thing, matter · v25

    'According to the thing / in this manner'. Davar here means a deed or course of action, not a spoken word.

  24. הַזֶּ֗ה

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v25

    'This': the act Abraham is about to describe, the wholesale destruction of Sodom with everyone in it.

  25. לְהָמִ֤ית

    lehāmît · H4191

    to cause to die, put to death · v25

    A causative form of 'die': to put to death, to execute. In this context it is the language of a death sentence carried out.

  26. וְהָיָ֥ה

    wehāyāh · H1961

    and it will be · v25

    'So that it would turn out…'. It introduces the result of such an act: the moral distinction is wiped out.

  27. הֲשֹׁפֵט֙

    hăšōfēṭ · H8199

    judge, ruler · v25

    'The one who judges', with the question marker ha- attached. A shofet decides cases, rules and puts wrongs right. Here it names God as the supreme magistrate over every land.

  28. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all, whole · v25, v26, v28

    'All'. God's jurisdiction is universal, not tied to Abraham's clan or to Canaan, so it covers Sodom too.

  29. הָאָ֔רֶץ

    hā’āreṣ · H0776G

    earth, land · v25

    'The earth': the whole inhabited world with its peoples and cities. 'Judge of all the earth' presents God as the court of final appeal for every nation.

  30. מִשְׁפָּֽט׃

    mišpāṭ · H4941H

    justice, judgment, verdict, what is right · v25

    The just verdict, the right ordering of things, giving each party what is due. It comes from the same root as shofet: 'Shall the Judge not do judging, that is, judge justly?'

  31. יְהוָ֔ה

    YHWH · H3068

    Yahweh, the LORD · v26

    God's personal, covenant name. The one Abraham has just called 'the Judge of all the earth' (v. 25) answers him personally.

  32. אִם־

    im · H0518

    if · v26, v28

    Sets up a real condition. The outcome depends on what is actually found in the city.

  33. אֶמְצָ֥א

    emtsa · H4672

    I find · v26, v28

    Investigative language. It picks up v. 21, where God says 'I will go down and see' whether the outcry is true. God is pictured as a judge checking the facts on the ground before giving a verdict.

  34. בִסְדֹ֛ם

    vi-Sdom · H5467

    in Sodom · v26

    The city where Lot lives. Genesis has already branded it as 'wicked, great sinners against the LORD' (13:13), and a cry against it has gone up to God (18:20).

  35. בַּעֲבוּרָֽם

    ba'avuram · H5668

    for their sake · v26

    'On their account, because of them.' The presence of the innocent minority becomes the reason the whole community is pardoned.

  36. וַיַּ֥עַן

    vayyaʿan · H6030B

    to answer · v27

    'And he answered.' Abraham is replying to God's promise in v.26 to spare Sodom for fifty righteous people. The verb shows this is a back-and-forth conversation, not a speech to the air.

  37. הִנֵּה־

    hinneh · H2009

    behold, look · v27

    A word that points at something to get attention. Here it points at Abraham's own boldness: 'Look at what I've done, I've started speaking up.'

  38. נָ֤א

    na · H4994

    please, I pray · v27

    A small courtesy word that softens speech, used when an inferior asks something of a superior. Together with hinneh it works like 'Look, if you'll permit me...'. YLT's 'I pray thee' keeps it; most modern versions drop it.

  39. הוֹאַ֙לְתִּי֙

    hoʾalti · H2974

    to be willing, undertake, venture · v27

    'I have made up my mind to / I have taken it on myself to.' A form describing a finished act: Abraham has already crossed the line of speaking boldly to God and owns up to it. It carries a sense of daring, of presuming beyond one's place.

  40. לְדַבֵּ֣ר

    ledabber · H1696G

    to speak · v27

    'To speak.' The ordinary word for speaking, here describing the act of pleading, which is the daring thing Abraham has undertaken.

  41. אֶל־

    ʾel · H0413

    to, toward · v27

    'To.' He is speaking face to face with God, not about him.

  42. אֲדֹנָ֔י

    ʾAdonai · H0136

    Lord, my Lord · v27

    Literally 'my Lord' or 'my Master', a title of rank. The narrator calls this figure YHWH (v.22, 26), but Abraham does not use the divine name. He uses the title a servant would use for a master, which fits his humble stance.

  43. וְאָנֹכִ֖י

    veʾanokhi · H0595

    and I · v27

    'And I.' The pronoun is spelled out, which Hebrew does not need to do, so it is emphatic: 'and I, of all people.' The 'and' works like 'though' or 'when I am': it sets Abraham's lowliness right next to the Lord he is addressing.

  44. עָפָ֥ר

    ʿafar · H6083

    dust, dry earth · v27

    'Dust.' This is the stuff humans were made from and return to (Gen 2:7; 3:19). Abraham is calling himself a creature of earth, mortal and fragile, speaking to his Maker.

  45. וָאֵֽפֶר׃

    vaʾefer · H0665

    ashes · v27

    'And ash.' What is left after something burns, and the sign of mourning. It rhymes with ʿafar (ʿafar vaʾefer), which makes a memorable pair meaning 'nothing but dirt and cinders'. Said on the brink of Sodom's burning, the word is especially sharp.

  46. יַחְסְר֞וּן

    yaḥserun · H2637

    to lack, fall short · v28

    'They will fall short.' The subject is 'the fifty righteous': the group falls short of its number by five. The verb has an older, fuller ending (-un instead of -u), which often adds weight or a formal tone in Hebrew narrative.

  47. חֲמִשָּׁ֔ה

    ḥamishshah · H2568

    five · v28

    The shortfall, 'by five'. Abraham does not say 'forty-five'. He says 'fifty, minus five', so that only five are missing.

  48. הֲתַשְׁחִ֥ית

    ha-tashḥit · H7843

    to ruin, destroy · v28

    'Will you bring ruin?' The question prefix ha- and the causative form ('cause ruin') make this a pointed question. It is the verb of the Flood story (Gen 6:13, 17), and the angels use it of Sodom in 19:13.

  49. אֶת־

    ʾet- · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v28

    Marks 'the whole city' as what would be destroyed. It has no English equivalent.

  50. שָׁ֔ם

    sham · H8033G

    there · v28

    There, in Sodom, the city under investigation.

  51. אַרְבָּעִ֖ים

    ʾarbaʿim · H0705

    forty · v28

    God states the number directly, as a positive count, instead of 'fifty minus five'.

The world behind it

God's deliberation and Abraham's appeal. In 18:17–21 God decides not to hide his plans from Abraham. The reason given is that Abraham has been chosen to teach his children "to keep the way of YHWH by doing righteousness and justice" (tsedaqah u-mishpat). God then says he will "go down and see" whether Sodom has done all that the outcry against it claims, a phrase that sounds like a judge investigating a complaint. The two men go on toward Sodom, and Abraham stays "standing before YHWH" (18:22) and opens his case.

Collective punishment in the ancient world. In Abraham's world, destroying a whole city, family or people for the crimes of some of them was normal practice, whether in war or in punishments said to come from the gods. The laws of Hammurabi sometimes punished a guilty man's son in his place (e.g. law 230: if a builder's house collapses and kills the owner's son, the builder's son is put to death). A striking Mesopotamian parallel is the flood story in Gilgamesh Tablet XI. After the flood the god Ea rebukes Enlil for destroying humanity without discrimination: "On the sinner lay his sin, on the transgressor lay his transgression." Genesis raises the same moral question, but here a human being puts it to the one God before the judgment, and God engages with the argument. Later Israelite law makes the principle explicit for human courts: each person is to die for his own sin (Deut 24:16; compare Ezek 18).

From the study of Genesis 18:23.

Where scholars differ

in v23

Is Abraham asking that the innocent be separated from the guilty, or that the whole city be spared for the sake of the innocent?

  • Verse 23 asks only that the innocent not die with the guilty, and that is in fact how the story resolves: Lot is taken out and the city is still destroyed.

    The wording of v.23 ('with the wicked') and the narrative outcome in 19:15–29, where the same verb saphah reappears in the warning to Lot.

  • Abraham's real aim, made explicit from v.24 on, is that the presence of the righteous should protect the whole community, so that a few innocent people outweigh many guilty ones.

    V.24 asks God to 'lift/bear' (nasa', forgive) 'the place' for the sake of the fifty. God agrees on those terms (vv.26–32). Jer 5:1 has a similar idea of a city pardoned for one just person.

in v23

What kind of exchange is this: a challenge to God, haggling, or a test set by God?

  • A legal challenge or courtroom plea in which Abraham holds God to his own justice.

    Courtroom vocabulary (nagash, tsaddiq/rasha', 'Judge of all the earth', mishpat in v.25).

  • Bargaining in the manner of a Near Eastern market, with the figures stepping down from 50 to 10.

    The step-by-step reductions (vv.28–32) and the courteous self-deprecation (v.27), which are like the negotiation in Gen 23.

  • A conversation God invited, to form Abraham as one who teaches justice and prays for others.

    18:17–19, where God decides to disclose his plan because of Abraham's calling; the tradition that 18:22 originally had YHWH standing before Abraham; Gen 20:7.

in v24

Is Abraham asking only that the innocent not die, or that the whole city be forgiven because of them?

  • He asks for the whole city to be forgiven because of the innocent minority. This is a principle that the presence of the righteous protects the many.

    The wording: 'not lift [guilt] for the place for the sake of the fifty' (v. 24). God accepts these terms: 'I will forgive (nasa') all the place on their account' (v. 26). Compare cities spared for the sake of David (2 Kgs 19:34) and Jer 5:1. Later Jewish thought developed this into the idea of the protective 'merit' (zekhut) of the righteous, but that is a later development.

  • His real concern is that the innocent not be killed (vv. 23, 25). Because a sweeping judgment cannot sort people, sparing everyone is the only way to spare the innocent.

    The opening and closing objections are about killing 'the righteous with the wicked' and treating them 'alike' (vv. 23, 25). In Gen 19 God takes a third route: he rescues Lot and his family and then destroys the city, which shows that protecting the innocent did not require saving everyone.

in v24

Is Abraham pleading for Lot, or arguing about justice in principle?

  • His motive is personal: Lot lives in Sodom.

    Abraham has rescued Lot before (Gen 14). Gen 19:29 says God 'remembered Abraham and sent Lot out', which links the rescue to Abraham's plea.

  • The plea is about principle: what justice requires of the 'Judge of all the earth'.

    Lot is never named. The argument is in general legal terms (tsaddiq/rasha', mishpat). It follows directly after 18:19, where Abraham is to teach 'righteousness and justice'. The numbers (50 down to 10) are about a class of people, not one family.

in v24

When and why was this dialogue composed?

  • It is a later reflection, probably from the time of the exile or after, on group versus individual judgment, set into the Abraham story.

    Scholars such as Claus Westermann and Joseph Blenkinsopp (JJS 1982) point to its reflective, abstract style and its links to Jer 5:1, Ezek 14 and 18, and the question raised by Jerusalem's fall.

  • It belongs to the narrative and is woven into the surrounding story.

    Commentators such as Gordon Wenham and Nahum Sarna note how tightly it is tied to 18:17–21 (God's reason for telling Abraham) and to Gen 19 (the safah language, Lot's rescue 'remembering Abraham'). They read it as a deliberate part of the Abraham cycle, whatever its prehistory.

in v25

Is Abraham protesting against God or appealing to God's known character?

  • Bold protest. Abraham challenges God's announced plan and holds God to an external moral standard. This 'arguing with God' tradition was later developed in Jewish thought.

    The vehement, repeated ḥālilāh ('a desecration!'); the risky haggling from 50 down to 10; the scribal tradition that later softened 18:22 out of discomfort; parallels in Moses' and Job's complaints.

  • Faithful intercession. Abraham appeals to standards God has already revealed, and God himself invites the exchange to train Abraham in justice.

    18:17–19, where God decides to reveal his plan *because* Abraham must teach 'righteousness and justice'; the question is built to expect yes ('Will not…?'); Abraham's humility (18:27 'I am but dust and ashes'); God agrees at every step without rebuke.

  • Both. The text holds trust and challenge together: Abraham presses hard precisely because he is sure of who God is.

    The verse moves from 'far be it from you' (challenge) to 'shall not the Judge… do justice?' (confidence). Many commentators (e.g. Wenham, Sarna) read the scene as intercession that is both daring and reverent.

in v25

What exactly is Abraham asking for: rescue of the innocent individuals, or sparing the whole city?

  • Verse 25 by itself asks only that the innocent not die with the guilty, a principle of separating them, which God in effect honours by rescuing Lot (ch. 19).

    The wording of v. 25 is about the fate of the righteous ('kill the righteous with the wicked'). Gen 19:29 says God 'remembered Abraham' and brought Lot out.

  • In context Abraham asks more: that the whole city be spared for the sake of an innocent minority.

    Verse 24 asks 'will you not spare (lit. bear with) the place for the sake of the fifty?' and God's answer in v. 26 is 'I will spare the whole place on their account'. Verse 25 states the principle behind that larger request.

in v26

Does Abraham change God's mind, or does the exchange reveal what God already intended?

  • Real persuasion: Abraham's bold intercession actually shapes the outcome, as Moses' does in Exod 32:11–14.

    God accepts each lower figure without protest. The scene is framed as a negotiation. Later tradition (the tiqqun soferim in v. 22) highlights how bold Abraham is.

  • Disclosure and teaching: God draws Abraham out to train him in 'righteousness and justice' (18:19) and to show that the judgment is just.

    In vv. 17–19 God chooses to reveal his plan for Abraham's instruction. God's answer offers more than Abraham's plea for justice in v. 25 strictly required. God's readiness to forgive appears from the very first answer.

in v26

Is this verse about justice (not punishing the innocent) or about mercy (pardoning the guilty)?

  • Mainly about justice: the concern is that the innocent not die with the guilty.

    Verse 25 says so explicitly: 'to kill the righteous with the wicked… far be it from you.' In ch. 19 God's solution is to rescue Lot, which is a separation.

  • It goes beyond justice to mercy: the whole guilty city would be forgiven for the sake of the innocent.

    The verb nasa' + 'to/for' means 'forgive' (Num 14:19; Hos 1:6), and its object is 'all the place', not only the fifty. The Septuagint's aphēsō supports this reading. Commentators such as Sarna and Wenham note this move.

in v27

What exactly does hoʾalti convey: 'I have dared/presumed', 'I have resolved', or 'I have begun'?

  • 'I have dared / made bold / presumed': the speaker oversteps his station.

    The context of a creature bargaining with God, and parallels like Josh 7:7 and Judg 17:11 where the verb means choosing something not required. Most modern lexicons and versions (NIV, NASB, BSB) take this line.

  • 'I have resolved / undertaken / consented': simply a decision to act.

    Deut 1:5 (Moses 'undertook' to explain the law) and 1 Sam 12:22 (the LORD 'was pleased' to make Israel his people), where no presumption is implied. This is the basis for ESV's 'undertaken'.

  • 'I have begun': I've started, so I'll go on.

    The Septuagint (ērxamēn) and the Vulgate ('coepi'). This may reflect contextual interpretation rather than the verb's core meaning.

in v27

Does 'dust and ashes' point mainly to mortality/creatureliness or to moral unworthiness?

  • Mainly creatureliness, mortality and low status before God.

    The echo of Gen 2:7 and 3:19. The bargaining context shows no confession of sin. Sir 17:32 uses the phrase for the human condition in general.

  • Includes a note of self-abasement akin to mourning or penitence.

    Ashes are tied to mourning and repentance rites (Esth 4; Jonah 3:6), and Job 42:6 pairs the phrase with a verb often translated 'repent'. Even so, Job 42:6 is itself disputed, and the verb may mean 'be comforted' or 'relent'.

in v28

Is Abraham changing God's mind, or is God drawing Abraham into his own justice?

  • Abraham's bold intercession actually moves God toward mercy, as Moses does later (Exod 32:11–14).

    Abraham's language of risk ('I have ventured', 'let not the Lord be angry', vv. 27, 30, 32). Each concession follows a request from Abraham. Elsewhere the Hebrew Bible shows God responding to intercession (Amos 7:1–6).

  • God deliberately invites Abraham into the decision to train him in 'righteousness and justice'. God never resists, and it is Abraham, not God, who stops.

    God's inner speech in vv. 17–19 ('Shall I hide from Abraham…?'). God has not announced destruction, only an inquiry (v. 21). God agrees at once each time and never makes a counter-offer. The dialogue ends when Abraham stops asking (v. 33).

in v28

Why does the bargaining stop at ten (v. 32), and what does that say about this verse's logic?

  • Ten is the smallest group that counts as a community. Below that, the innocent are rescued individually, as Lot is, rather than shielding the city.

    The story's own outcome: Lot's family is pulled out instead of the city being spared. Rashi links it to Noah's eight, too few to save their generation. Ten later became a quorum in Jewish practice (later tradition, not stated in the text).

  • Ten is simply where Abraham's boldness or decency stops. The text gives no rule, and later prophets push further (Jer 5:1: even one).

    No explanation is given in Genesis. Jer 5:1 and Ezek 22:30 imagine pardon for even one just person. Ezek 14:14–20, by contrast, says the righteous would save only themselves, which shows the question stayed open in Israel.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. סָפָה I, נָגַשׁ, צַדִּיק, רָשָׁע
  • HALOT s.v. ספה, צַדִּיק
  • Targum Onkelos, Gen 18:23
  • Rashi on Gen 18:23
  • Genesis Rabbah 49:7–8
  • Septuagint, Genesis 18:23
  • Vulgate, Genesis 18:23
  • Epic of Gilgamesh, Tablet XI (Ea's rebuke of Enlil)
  • Laws of Hammurabi §230
  • Gordon Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (WBC)
  • Nahum Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis
  • BDB s.v. נָשָׂא, צַדִּיק, סָפָה, אוּלַי
  • HALOT s.v. נשׂא (forgive, with lə-), צַדִּיק, ספה I
  • Gordon J. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Claus Westermann, Genesis 12–36
  • Nahum M. Sarna, The JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis
  • Joseph Blenkinsopp, "Abraham and the Righteous of Sodom," Journal of Jewish Studies 33 (1982)
  • John H. Walton et al., IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Genesis 18:24
  • BDB s.v. חָלִילָה
  • HALOT s.v. חָלִילָה, צַדִּיק, רָשָׁע, שׁפט, מִשְׁפָּט
  • Gordon J. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (WBC)
  • Nahum M. Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • Genesis Rabbah 49:9; Rashi on Gen 18:25
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Gen 18:25
  • Vulgate Gen 18:25
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Gen 18
  • BDB s.v. נָשָׂא (to forgive, with לְ)
  • HALOT s.v. נשׂא; s.v. צַדִּיק
  • N. Sarna, JPS Torah Commentary: Genesis (1989), on 18:22–33
  • G. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • V. Hamilton, The Book of Genesis 18–50 (NICOT)
  • C. Westermann, Genesis 12–36
  • Septuagint, Genesis 18:26 (ἀφήσω)
  • NJPS Tanakh (Jewish Publication Society), Genesis 18:23–26
  • BDB s.v. יָאַל (Hiphil)
  • HALOT s.v. יאל I, II
  • HALOT s.v. עָפָר
  • HALOT s.v. אֵפֶר
  • BDB s.v. אֲדֹנָי
  • Septuagint, Genesis 18:27 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Genesis 18:27
  • Philo, Quis rerum divinarum heres sit (Who Is the Heir) §§24–30
  • Babylonian Talmud, Hullin 88b; Sotah 17a
  • Sirach 10:9; 17:32
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Genesis 18
  • BDB s.v. צַדִּיק, שָׁחַת, חָסֵר, מָצָא
  • HALOT s.v. צַדִּיק; שׁחת
  • Gesenius–Kautzsch–Cowley (GKC) §47m (paragogic nun)
  • G. J. Wenham, Genesis 16–50 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • N. M. Sarna, Genesis (JPS Torah Commentary)
  • J. Blenkinsopp, 'Abraham and the Righteous of Sodom', Journal of Jewish Studies 33 (1982)
  • Rashi on Genesis 18:32
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Genesis 18:28
  • Vulgate Genesis 18:28

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).