Isaiah Chapter 3 Read as one passage
Isaiah 3:10–14
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
10Tell the righteous it will be well with them, for they will enjoy the fruit of their labor. 11Woe to the wicked; disaster is upon them! For they will be repaid with what their hands have done. 12Youths oppress My people, and women rule over them. O My people, your guides mislead you; they turn you from your paths. 13The LORD arises to contend; He stands to judge the people. 14The LORD brings this charge against the elders and leaders of His people: “You have devoured the vineyard; the plunder of the poor is in your houses.
What the first hearers heard
To people in Jerusalem watching their leaders rot and hearing that God was about to tear down the city's whole structure, this verse said one thing: God's judgment sorts people. Verses 9 and 11 pronounce "woe" on the guilty. Verse 10 says that those who have kept faith will not be lost in the general disaster.
In the agrarian world they lived in, the picture was easy to follow. Everyone eats what they grow. The princes who had "devoured the vineyard" of the poor (3:14) would find that their crop was disaster (3:9, 11). The ṣaddîq, who had dealt justly, would have something to eat when the bread ran out (3:1). The verse put back into force the choice Isaiah had already laid out: "If you are willing and obedient, you shall eat the good of the land; but if you refuse and rebel, you shall be eaten by the sword" (1:19–20).
For faithful hearers it was reassurance that their faithfulness counted with God even as the nation went under. For everyone else it was a call to decide which group they belonged to.
From the study of Isaiah 3:10.
Verse by verse
-
10Tell the righteous it will be well with them, for they will enjoy the fruit of their labor.
Full study →"Announce it about the one who is in the right: it is good, it will go well with him. For people like that will eat the harvest their own conduct has grown."
The verse is a short public announcement in the middle of a courtroom-style judgment on Jerusalem. The verb is plural, so a group is told to spread the message, though the verse doesn't say who. The word for "righteous" is singular: the righteous one, a type of person who stands for everyone who has kept faith with God and neighbor while the city's leaders robbed the poor. The message is just two Hebrew words, kî ṭôv, "that (it is) good." It is the opposite of the "evil" or "disaster" (ra') that verse 9 says the guilty have brought on themselves and that verse 11 pronounces on the wicked.
The reason follows in a farming picture. Deeds are like seed, and a person ends up eating whatever crop they produce. The word for "deeds" is the same one used two verses earlier for Jerusalem's "deeds against the LORD" (3:8). Both groups' actions bear fruit. The rebels reap ruin, and the righteous reap food to live on. In a chapter where God threatens to cut off "all supply of bread and water" (3:1), and where the rulers have "devoured the vineyard" of the poor (3:14), "they will eat" is a concrete promise. When God strips the city bare, the faithful will not be swept away with the guilty. The verse states the good outcome as already settled and grounds it in what the righteous have actually done. It does not promise a life free of trouble or a payout for hard work.
-
11Woe to the wicked; disaster is upon them! For they will be repaid with what their hands have done.
Full study →"Alas for the one who is in the wrong — it will go bad for him! Because what his own hands have dealt out to others will be dealt back to him."
Verse 11 is the dark twin of verse 10. There the prophet says of the one who is in the right: "Good!", for he will eat the fruit of what he has done. Here, of the guilty one: "Bad!", and in Hebrew the word for the guilty person (rasha') and the word for bad (ra') sound alike, so the man and his fate share a sound. The opening cry is not a calm moral; it is the same shout of alarm Isaiah has just raised over Jerusalem's leaders ("Woe to their soul! For they have dealt evil to themselves," v.9).
The reason is given in the picture of a man's hands. That is what he has actually done with his power. In this chapter it means hands that plundered the poor (vv.14–15). The word translated "repaid" or "reward" (gemul) means both the treatment a person hands out and the return he gets for it. So the line says: his dealings will be done back to him. Same coin, same weight. The verb is future and passive ("will be done"). The verse does not name who does it, but in a chapter where the Lord himself strips Jerusalem of its leaders and rises to argue his case (3:1, 13), the hearers would know whose court this is. The weight falls on the last little word, lo, "to him": the harm comes back to the person who started it.
-
12Youths oppress My people, and women rule over them. O My people, your guides mislead you; they turn you from your paths.
Full study →"My people! Their slave-drivers are children, impulsive boys who pick them clean like gleaners stripping a vineyard. Women have come to rule over them (or, as the ancient Greek read the same letters: creditors lord it over them). My people! The very ones who are supposed to lead you down the straight road, the ones who keep telling you how blessed you are, are leading you astray. They have swallowed up the road you were meant to walk, so that it can no longer be found."
God is speaking, and the cry "My people!" comes twice. It is lament as much as accusation. Israel's own rulers are given the name once used for Pharaoh's taskmasters: men who drive, squeeze and extract. A play on sound links "child" and "glean bare". It continues verse 4, where God warns that boys and infants will rule. The ancient hearer would picture a kingdom whose grown men and seasoned leaders have been taken away (vv. 1–3, 25), so that power has fallen to people who in that society were not expected to hold it. In the second half the speaker turns from talking about the people to speaking straight to them. "Your guides" comes from a root that means both "lead straight on" and "call happy", so it carries an irony: the leaders who reassure are the ones misleading. The last image is not just a wrong turn. The road itself has been engulfed or thrown into confusion. Verses 13–15 then show God taking the leaders to court for devouring His vineyard and crushing the poor.
-
13The LORD arises to contend; He stands to judge the people.
Full study →Yahweh has stepped into the courtroom and taken his place. He is standing there now, ready to argue the case, standing ready to give the ruling over the peoples.
The Hebrew opens with two images of someone standing before it names him. Only after the hearer sees a figure rise and take position does the name come: Yahweh. Both verbs are participles, so this is not a distant future judgment. The hearing is already open. The first half says why he stands: to bring a lawsuit (rîb), to press charges as accuser and advocate. The second half says he stands to give judgment (dîn), to decide the case as judge. In Israel's courts those were normally two different people: the accuser stood and the judge sat. Here one person fills both roles, and no one sits above him to appeal to.
"Peoples" (plural in the Hebrew) uses the familiar psalm language of God as judge of all nations. The next verse narrows sharply: the defendants are "the elders and princes of his people," Judah's own judges, who have "devoured the vineyard" and stored "the plunder of the poor" in their houses. The men who used to hold court in the city gate are now on trial. Yahweh's lawsuit against them is also his defence of the poor they robbed.
-
14The LORD brings this charge against the elders and leaders of His people: “You have devoured the vineyard; the plunder of the poor is in your houses.
Full study →Yahweh himself is going to court, and the defendants are the elders of his people and its officials. The judges have become the accused. The men who sat at the city gate to decide land and debt cases, and the royal administrators in Jerusalem, now face a trial in which Yahweh is both the injured owner and the judge.
Then the accusation, delivered as if pointing at them: "And you, you are the ones who have grazed my vineyard bare!" The vineyard is Yahweh's people (Isaiah 5:7 will say so explicitly). The verb pictures livestock let loose to strip a field, or possibly fire burning it. Either way the damage is done and complete. To an Israelite ear this echoes a known law: whoever lets his animals graze another man's vineyard must repay from the best of his own (Exodus 22:5). The leaders were supposed to be the hedge around the vineyard. Instead they behaved like the animals that eat it.
"What you have robbed from the afflicted is in your houses." The word for 'robbery' refers to property taken openly by force or by abuse of power, often through foreclosure, seized pledges and rigged judgments. Israel's law required it to be returned in full. The 'afflicted' are people pressed down into poverty and powerlessness, the very group the law told judges to protect. The case is open and shut: the stolen goods are sitting in the defendants' own homes. The next verse gives the owner's outraged question: "What do you mean by crushing my people?"
Where the English drifted
-
in v10
the righteous
ṣaddîq
- What we hear
- Morally pure or religious people, or people with right standing before God in the later theological sense.
- What they heard
- The person who is "in the right" because they keep their obligations of justice and loyalty to God and neighbor. In this chapter that means people who are not among the leaders who rob the poor.
-
in v10
enjoy the fruit of their labor (BSB) / the rich reward they have earned (NLT)
pərî ma'aləlêhem yō'khēlû
- What we hear
- A payoff for working hard, like career success or wages earned.
- What they heard
- "They will eat the fruit of their deeds": they will live with the natural results of how they have acted. In the verses around it the same idiom is used for destruction, and here it means survival when Jerusalem is judged.
-
in v11
wicked
rāšāʿ
- What we hear
- A villain: someone sinister, cruel, unusually evil, unlike ordinary people.
- What they heard
- The guilty party, the one 'in the wrong' before God and the community. The opposite of the tsaddiq, the one 'in the right.' In this chapter it points mainly at respectable leaders who exploit the poor.
-
in v11
reward (KJV)
gəmûl
- What we hear
- A prize or payment for doing well.
- What they heard
- Neutral payback. A person's own dealings toward others, returned to him. Here it means harm returned for harm.
-
in v12
women rule over them
nāšîm māšəlû bô
- What we hear
- A general statement, or even a rule, that women in leadership is a mark of God's displeasure in any time and place.
- What they heard
- Part of a picture of Jerusalem in collapse in Isaiah's day. With children ruling (v. 4) and men lost in war (v. 25; 4:1), power has passed to those who, in that patriarchal society, were not expected to hold it. The line describes a judgment that has fallen; it gives no command. The consonants can also be read 'creditors', as the oldest translation (the Greek) took them.
-
in v12
children / infants / youths
məʿôlēl
- What we hear
- Literal minors, actual boys holding office.
- What they heard
- The Hebrew word sounds like 'child' but comes from a root that also means 'deal harshly, abuse, glean every last grape'. It points to immature, impulsive rulers. It may also, or instead, mean rulers who strip the people bare, which is how the Greek and Latin took it.
-
in v13
plead (KJV, YLT)
rîb
- What we hear
- To beg, implore, or ask emotionally, as if Yahweh were pleading with his people.
- What they heard
- To argue a legal case: to bring charges as prosecutor or to defend someone as advocate. Here it means bringing a lawsuit against Judah's leaders.
-
in v13
judge
dîn
- What we hear
- To condemn or pass a negative verdict, or to be critical.
-
in v14
enter into judgment with (KJV, WEB)
bo' bəmišpāṭ ʿim
- What we hear
- Join with the elders in judging, or deliver a final condemnation.
- What they heard
- A legal idiom for taking someone to court. 'With' marks the opposing party, so it means a lawsuit against the leaders. The verdict comes later.
-
in v14
spoil (KJV, ESV) / plunder
gəzēlāh
- What we hear
- Booty taken in war or raids.
- What they heard
- Property taken from a fellow Israelite by force or abuse of power, including through courts, debts and seizure of pledges. It was a legal offence requiring full restitution (Leviticus 6:2–5).
-
in v14
elders / ancients
zəqēnîm
- What we hear
- Church officers, or simply old people.
- What they heard
- Heads of leading clans who formed the local court and civic council at the city gate. They were the judicial establishment.
Every word
-
אִמְר֥וּ
'imrû · H0559
say! (plural) · v10
A command given to a group of people, but the verse never says who they are: fellow prophets, heralds, or the listeners themselves. It works like a public announcement: "Make this known."
-
צַדִּ֖יק
ṣaddîq · H6662
righteous, in the right · v10
Grammatically singular ("the righteous one"), but it stands for a type of person. That is why the verse switches to "their" and "they" later. In this chapter it means the people who are not taking part in the leaders' corruption and oppression of the poor.
-
כִּי־
kî · H3588A
that · v10, v11
Introduces what is to be said. Hebrew often names a person first as the object of the verb and then says something about them: "Say the righteous, that good" means "Say of the righteous that it is good." Genesis 1:4 has the same shape: "God saw the light, that it was good."
-
ט֑וֹב
ṭôv · H2895
to be good, go well · v10
Used impersonally: "it is good" or "it goes well." It is the direct opposite of ra' (evil, disaster) in verses 9 and 11. It means good outcome and well-being, not only moral goodness. The perfect form presents the outcome as settled.
-
פְרִ֥י
fərî · H6529
fruit, produce · v10
The harvest of a field, vine or tree. It is a farming picture: actions are like seed, and their results grow out of them the way a crop does.
-
מַעַלְלֵיהֶ֖ם
ma'aləlêhem · H4611
deeds, practices · v10
"Their deeds": conduct, a habitual way of acting. The same word appeared two verses earlier, where Jerusalem's "speech and deeds" were "against the LORD" (3:8). Here the righteous person's deeds bring a different harvest.
-
יֹאכֵֽלוּ׃
yō'khēlû · H0398
they will eat · v10
Literally "eat." They will live off the produce of their own conduct. The form points to the future, or to what reliably happens. The sentence's final word lands on the concrete act of eating, the reverse of the famine and loss of "all supply of bread" threatened in 3:1.
-
א֖וֹי
ʾôy · H0188
woe!, alas! · v11
A cry of alarm and distress, not a calm statement. Coming right after the same cry in verse 9 ('Woe to their soul!'), it sounds like a shout of horror at the disaster that is coming.
-
לְרָשָׁ֣ע
lərāšāʿ · H7563
wicked, guilty · v11
'To the guilty one.' The word is singular and stands for a type of person. It is the direct opposite of the 'righteous' (tsaddiq) of verse 10: the one who is in the wrong before God and before the community, not only someone who is unusually evil.
-
רָ֑ע
rāʿ · H7489A
be bad, evil · v11
One curt word: 'Bad!' It answers the 'Good!' (tov) said of the righteous in verse 10, and it sounds like rāšāʿ just before it (rāšāʿ rāʿ), so the guilty one and his bad end sound alike. It covers both moral evil and misfortune; here it mainly means harm, disaster.
-
גְמ֥וּל
gəmûl · H1576
recompense, dealing, deed · v11
'The dealing of.' The word means both what a person has done to others and what comes back to him for it. Either sense, good or bad, depends on the context. Here it means the harm his hands have handed out.
-
יָדָ֖יו
yādāyw · H3027G
hand · v11
'His (two) hands.' In Hebrew the hands stand for what a person actually does and the power he uses, especially in grabbing or striking. Verses 14–15 show what these hands have been doing: plundering and crushing the poor.
-
יֵעָ֥שֶׂה
yēʿāśeh · H6213A
do, make · v11
'Will be done.' The verb is passive and future: what his hands did will be done back to him. The verse does not say who does it. In Isaiah's setting the hearers would have understood that God oversees it.
-
לּֽוֹ׃
lô · H9033
to him · v11, v12
'To him.' The deed comes back to the very person who did it. The verse closes on this short word, the way a boomerang ends up back with the thrower.
-
עַמִּי֙
ʿammî · H5971A
my people · v12, v13, v14
God is speaking, calling Israel 'my people', the language of the covenant bond. Putting it first makes it a pained exclamation: 'My people!' The people are treated as one body, so the next words say 'its taskmasters'.
-
נֹגְשָׂ֣יו
nōgəśāyw · H5065
its oppressors, taskmasters · v12
Literally 'its drivers / exactors'. The word was used for Pharaoh's slave-drivers (Exodus 3:7; 5:6) and for officials who squeezed out tribute (2 Kings 23:35). Here it is a bitter name for Judah's own rulers: they behave like Egypt's taskmasters toward their own people.
-
מְעוֹלֵ֔ל
məʿôlēl · H5953C
acting like a child / dealing harshly, gleaning · v12
A singular participle (a verb form used like an adjective) from a root that gives both 'child' (ʿôlēl) and 'deal harshly with, glean every last grape'. The traditional Hebrew reading takes it as 'is a child / behaves like a child', which links back to verse 4 ('infants will rule over them'). The ancient Greek took it as 'strips bare'. The sound probably calls up both ideas.
-
וְנָשִׁ֖ים
wənāšîm · H0802G
and women · v12
The traditional Hebrew vowels read 'women'. In that world, women ruling would be heard as a sign that the normal order of the kingdom had been turned upside down, alongside children ruling. Without vowels, the same letters can be read nōšîm, 'creditors', and the Greek translators read it that way.
-
מָ֣שְׁלוּ
māšəlû · H4910
they have ruled · v12
An ordinary word for exercising rule or dominion. The perfect form here describes a state that has already set in: 'they have come to rule' or 'they are ruling'.
-
מְאַשְּׁרֶ֣יךָ
məʾaššəreykā · H0833
your guides / those who call you happy · v12
A participle from a root meaning 'to step straight, lead on', which also gives the verb 'to call someone blessed or happy' (ʾašrê, 'happy is…'). It points to those who lead the people. The second sense also suggests people who tell them all is well. The ancient Greek and Latin chose 'those who call you blessed'.
-
מַתְעִ֔ים
matʿîm · H8582
leading astray · v12
'Making [you] wander.' The root is used for straying animals and staggering drunks (Isaiah 28:7). The guides are not merely mistaken: they actively lead the people off course.
-
וְדֶ֥רֶךְ
wəderek · H1870G
and the road / way of · v12
A road or track, and by extension a course of life or conduct. Here it is a concrete picture: the road itself.
-
אֹֽרְחֹתֶ֖יךָ
ʾōrəḥōteykā · H0734
your paths · v12
A poetic word for paths or tracks. 'The road of your paths' piles up two road words: the actual course the people should be walking.
-
בִּלֵּֽעוּ׃
billēʿû · H1104
they have swallowed up / confused · v12
An intensive form of 'swallow'. The picture is the road being swallowed, wiped out so no one can find it. Many lexicons also list a related sense, 'confuse, throw into disorder' (compare Isaiah 19:3). Either way, the people are left with no visible road.
-
נִצָּ֥ב
niṣṣāb · H5324
to take one's stand, station oneself · v13
A participle, so the scene is already happening: Yahweh has stepped forward and is now standing in position in the courtroom. The word stresses deliberate, firm positioning. The same form opens Psalm 82:1, where God 'takes his stand' to try corrupt judges.
-
לָרִ֖יב
lārîb · H7378
to contend, conduct a legal case · v13
'In order to bring a lawsuit' or 'to argue a case.' Yahweh appears as the one pressing charges. Verse 14 shows the charges are against Judah's elders and officials, on behalf of the poor they robbed.
-
יְהוָ֑ה
YHWH · H3068
Yahweh (the LORD) · v13, v14
The personal name of Israel's God, held back until after the two opening verbs. The hearer sees the courtroom figure standing up first and only then hears who it is.
-
וְעֹמֵ֖ד
wəʿōmēd · H5975
and standing · v13
A second participle matching the first: he is standing, upright and ready to act. Put together, the two 'standing' verbs show a figure who is fully present and about to speak.
-
לָדִ֥ין
lādîn · H1777
to judge, give a ruling, plead a cause · v13
'In order to give judgment,' meaning to decide the case and carry out the ruling. It matches 'to bring a lawsuit' in the first half of the verse: the one who brings the charge is also the one who will rule on it.
-
בְּמִשְׁפָּ֣ט
bəmišpāṭ · H4941
judgment, legal case, justice · v14
'Into a legal case.' Here mishpat means a court proceeding, not yet a verdict: Yahweh is coming to argue and decide a case.
-
יָב֔וֹא
yābôʾ · H935
come, enter · v14
'He will come / he is coming.' Joined with 'in judgment' and 'with', it is a fixed legal idiom: to go to court against someone (compare Job 22:4; Psalm 143:2). The tense points to something imminent or already starting.
-
עִם־
ʿim- · H5973
with · v14
In this legal idiom 'with' marks the opposing party: Yahweh goes to court with them, meaning against them, not alongside them as fellow judges.
-
זִקְנֵ֥י
ziqnê · H2205
elder, old man · v14
'The elders of.' These are the heads of clans and leading households who sat at the town gate as the local court and council. They were not simply old people, and they were not church officers.
-
וְשָׂרָ֑יו
wəśārāyw · H8269
official, prince, commander · v14
'And its officials.' Sarim were the royal administrators, commanders and court officials of Jerusalem. Together with the elders they cover both the old clan-based leadership and the newer royal leadership: the whole ruling class.
-
וְאַתֶּם֙
wəʾattem · H859
you (plural) · v14
'And you!' The pronoun is not needed by the Hebrew verb, so its presence is emphatic: 'It is you who…' or 'As for you…'. The accusation opens abruptly, as if the prosecutor points straight at the defendants.
-
בִּֽעַרְתֶּ֣ם
biʿartem · H1197
burn; graze bare; consume · v14
'You have grazed bare / burned up.' The verb can mean to burn, or to let livestock graze a field down to nothing. The picture is the vineyard stripped and ruined, possibly with the leaders as animals let loose in a field they were meant to guard. The completed form presents the damage as already done.
-
הַכֶּ֔רֶם
hakkerem · H3754
vineyard · v14
'The vineyard.' The definite article points to a vineyard everyone knows: Yahweh's vineyard, his people (Isaiah 5:7 states it outright). It may also echo actual vineyards seized from small farmers.
-
גְּזֵלַ֥ת
gəzēlat · H1500
robbery, thing taken by force · v14
'The robbery of / the stolen goods of.' A legal term for property taken by force or by abusing power, which the law required to be given back (Leviticus 6:4 [Hebrew 5:23]). It is not war booty.
-
הֶֽעָנִ֖י
heʿānî · H6041
poor, afflicted, humbled · v14
'The afflicted one.' A person who has been pressed down, economically weak and without protection. The singular stands for the whole class. The law gave them special protection (Exodus 22:25–27; Deuteronomy 24:12–15).
-
בְּבָתֵּיכֶֽם׃
bəbāttêkem · H1004
house, household · v14
'In your houses.' The evidence is on the premises. The stolen goods sit in the defendants' own homes, which proves the case. There may also be a jab at the large houses of the rich (Isaiah 5:8–9).
The world behind it
Jerusalem under judgment (8th century BC). Isaiah 3:1–4:1 announces that God is about to take away everything holding Jerusalem and Judah up. That includes the food supply (3:1) and every kind of leader: warrior, judge, prophet, elder, counselor (3:2–3). In their place come chaos and immature rulers (3:4–7). The cause is stated in verses 8–9: the people's words and deeds defy the LORD, and they flaunt their sin "like Sodom." Verses 13–15 then stage a courtroom scene in which God takes the stand against the elders and princes for "devouring the vineyard" and "grinding the faces of the poor."
An agrarian world. Isaiah's audience lived by vineyards, olive groves and grain fields. "Eating the fruit" of something was ordinary language for living off what you had planted. The vineyard image runs through these chapters: in 3:14 the leaders have consumed the vineyard, and in 5:1–7 Israel itself is God's vineyard that produced bad grapes.
Deeds and their consequences. Israel's prophets and wisdom teachers often describe actions as carrying their own results within them, the way seed carries a crop. God oversees and guarantees the harvest, but the outcome grows from the act itself. Verses 9–11 use this language throughout. The guilty "have dealt evil to themselves" (v. 9), and the "recompense of his hands" will be done to the wicked (v. 11, using the same root g-m-l). Verse 10 is the positive side of that pattern.
From the study of Isaiah 3:10.
Where scholars differ
in v10
Are verses 10–11 original to Isaiah's speech, or a later addition?
-
A later wisdom-style insertion
The verses break into a judgment speech on Jerusalem's leaders (3:1–9, 12–15). Their righteous/wicked contrast and "eat the fruit" idiom sound like Proverbs and Psalm 1. Several critical commentators (e.g. Wildberger, Kaiser, Blenkinsopp) regard them as a scribal or wisdom addition qualifying the blanket judgment.
-
Integral to the passage
"Their deeds" (3:8) is picked up in 3:10, the root g-m-l joins 3:9 and 3:11, and Isaiah 1:19–20 already used eat/good language for the obedient. Commentators such as Oswalt read verses 10–11 as Isaiah's own aside, making clear that judgment separates the faithful from the guilty.
in v10
What did the first word originally say?
-
"Say" ('imrû), as in the Hebrew text
Supported by the Masoretic text, apparently by the Qumran scroll, and by the Vulgate. It makes good sense as a command to announce the message.
-
"Happy is" ('ashrê), by emendation
It would match "Woe" in verse 11 exactly and fits the Psalm 1 pattern. But it has no manuscript support.
-
"Bind" ('isrû), as behind the Septuagint
The Greek "Let us bind the righteous" points to a Hebrew text, or a misreading, with s for m. Most scholars see it as a secondary reading, since it does not fit the second half of the verse well.
in v10
"Say TO the righteous" or "Say OF the righteous"?
-
Address: "Say to the righteous"
The traditional reading (KJV, Vulgate, most modern versions): heralds are told to reassure the faithful.
-
Description: "Say of the righteous that it is good"
There is no "to" in the Hebrew. The pattern "X, that good" is the same construction as Gen 1:4 ("God saw the light, that it was good"), where the noun is the subject of the following clause. On this reading the verse is a public declaration about the righteous.
in v11
Do the deeds come back by themselves, or does God actively repay them?
-
Built-in consequence. Actions carry their results within them, like seed and harvest, and God is the guarantor of that order more than a judge who adds punishments.
Klaus Koch's influential 1955 study of the 'deed–consequence connection' in the Hebrew Bible; the passive 'will be done' here; the fruit-eating image in v.10; v.9 'they have dealt evil to themselves'; Prov 12:14 'comes back to him.'
-
Divine retribution. The passive verb hides God as the one acting, and the setting is explicitly a court in which God judges.
Isa 3:1 ('the Lord… is taking away'), 3:13–14 ('the LORD rises to argue his case… enters into judgment'); parallel texts where God is the one who renders gəmûl (Ps 28:4; Jer 51:56, 'the LORD is a God of recompense'; Isa 59:18).
-
Both together. Many commentators see no real conflict: the outcome fits the deed and comes out of it, and God sees that it happens.
The Hebrew Bible regularly places both images side by side, e.g. Ps 7:15–16 (the pit the wicked dig) with Ps 7:11–13 (God as judge).
in v11
Are vv.10–11 original to Isaiah's oracle or a later addition?
-
A later insertion in wisdom style that interrupts the oracle against Jerusalem's leaders.
The proverb-like form, the closeness to Prov 12:14, the singular 'righteous/wicked' in a plural context, and the awkward 'say' in v.10 (argued by commentators such as Wildberger and Kaiser).
-
Integral to the passage.
The vocabulary connects tightly with v.9 ('woe,' gāmal, rāʿāh), and the verses meet a real worry in a coming national disaster: will the innocent suffer with the guilty? (defended by commentators such as Oswalt).
in v12
Does מְעוֹלֵל mean the rulers are 'children / childish' or that they 'glean / strip' the people?
-
'Child, acting like a child': immature, impulsive rulers (the traditional Hebrew reading and most English versions).
Verse 4 has just said 'infants (taʿălûlîm, same root) will rule over them' beside 'boys'. Ecclesiastes 10:16 uses a child king as an image of national misfortune. The nouns ʿôlēl/ʿôlāl mean 'child'.
-
'Glean bare, deal harshly with, abuse': rulers who pick the people clean.
The form is a regular intensive participle of a verb used for gleaning and harsh treatment (Lev 19:10; Jer 6:9; Lam 1:22). The Septuagint ('glean the stubble') and Vulgate ('plundered') read it this way. It fits 'taskmasters' and the vineyard image of verse 14.
-
A deliberate double meaning.
Isaiah often plays on sound. The same root gives both senses, and 66:4 uses taʿălûlîm for 'harsh treatments'.
in v12
'Women' or 'creditors' (נשים), and if 'women', in what sense?
-
'Women' (nāšîm), read literally: women of the court, such as the queen mother or royal wives, holding real influence.
The traditional vowels and the Vulgate. Judah's history includes the queen mother Maacah (1 Kgs 15:13) and Athaliah (2 Kgs 11). The next section (3:16–4:1) is about the women of Jerusalem.
-
'Women' as an image of disorder or of weak rule: a society without its men, or rulers called 'women' as an insult.
The parallel with 'children' and the loss of men in war (3:25; 4:1). Ancient Near Eastern texts use 'becoming like women' as a taunt for weak or defeated warriors (compare Isaiah 19:16; Jeremiah 50:37; 51:30).
-
'Creditors' (nōšîm).
The Septuagint's 'those who demand payment'. It pairs naturally with 'taskmasters / exactors' and 'glean bare', and fits the economic charges of verses 14–15 and the use of nōšeh in Isaiah 24:2. Some modern versions (for example the New English Bible) adopted it. Against it: it needs different vowels from the traditional text, and the traditional reading fits the wider chapter.
in v12
Are the מְאַשְּׁרִים 'guides' or 'those who call you blessed'?
-
'Guides, leaders': those who lead the people along the way.
The root means 'step, go straight' (Prov 4:14; 9:6; 23:19), and road imagery runs through the verse ('lead astray', 'road', 'paths'). Isaiah 9:15–16 pairs 'those who lead' with 'those who are led'.
-
'Those who call you happy': flatterers and false comforters.
The same verb form means 'pronounce blessed' (Gen 30:13; Ps 72:17; Mal 3:12). The Septuagint and Vulgate read it this way, and it suits the lying prophets of 9:15.
-
Both at once: the guides are also the flatterers.
Isaiah's habit of wordplay, and the way the two senses support each other.
in v13
Does the verse say Yahweh judges 'the peoples' (all nations) or 'his people' (Judah)?
-
'Peoples' is original: universal judgment, then a focus on Judah.
The Masoretic Text and Vulgate read the plural. It is the harder reading. 'Yahweh judges the peoples' is a set phrase (Ps 7:9; 96:10). The prophets elsewhere move from the nations to Israel (Amos 1–2; Mic 1:2–5).
-
'His people' is original: the court scene concerns Judah alone.
The Septuagint and Peshitta read 'his people.' Verse 14 says 'the elders of his people.' The whole context (3:1–15) deals only with Jerusalem and Judah. The two readings differ by one Hebrew letter, so a copying slip is easy to imagine.
-
'Peoples' is original but refers to Israel's tribes or clans.
ʿammîm sometimes refers to the tribes of Israel (Deut 33:3, 19; Gen 28:3). That would keep the Masoretic text and still fit the Judah-focused context, though the usage is uncommon.
in v13
Is this an example of a formal 'covenant lawsuit' form?
-
Yes: it uses a recognisable prophetic lawsuit pattern.
Huffmon (1959) and others identified a pattern of summons, charges, and verdict built on rîb (Hos 4:1; Mic 6:1–2; Jer 2:9), possibly modelled on how ancient Near Eastern overlords charged disloyal vassals. Isa 3:13–15 has a summons (v. 13), charges (vv. 14–15a), and the speaker's signature (v. 15b).
-
Partly: it is courtroom imagery, not a fixed form.
Later scholars (e.g. De Roche, 1983) argued that rîb is ordinary dispute language and that the passages vary too much to count as one fixed form. On that view the courtroom setting is clear, but 'covenant lawsuit' as a technical category is debated.
in v14
Does בִּעַרְתֶּם mean 'you have burned' or 'you have grazed bare'?
-
Grazing / stripping: the leaders are like livestock let into the vineyard.
Exodus 22:5 (Hebrew 22:4) uses the same verb for animals grazing another's vineyard, with restitution required. Isaiah 5:5 uses it of the vineyard being 'devoured' once its hedge is removed. Jeremiah 12:10 pictures 'shepherds' trampling God's vineyard. The Vulgate reads *depasti* ('grazed off'). HALOT lists a separate root 'graze'.
-
Burning / destroying: the leaders have burned up the vineyard.
'Burn' is the most common sense of the root. The Septuagint renders 'set on fire'. Fire is a frequent image for destruction in Isaiah (1:7; 9:18–19).
-
Deliberate ambiguity, or a general sense of 'consume / destroy completely'.
The intensive form can mean 'remove completely' (Deuteronomy's 'purge'). Many translations ('devoured', 'consumed', 'ruined') leave the image open. Either way the result is the same: a ruined vineyard.
in v14
Is 3:13–15 a formal 'covenant lawsuit' (*riv*) modeled on treaty disputes?
-
Yes: prophets used a recognisable lawsuit form, echoing ancient treaty procedures in which a great king accused a disloyal vassal.
Proposed by scholars such as H. B. Huffmon (1959) and J. Harvey. They point to the vocabulary of *riv* ('contend'), standing to judge, a summons, accusation and verdict, and parallels in Isaiah 1:2–20, Micah 6:1–8 and Hosea 4:1–3.
-
No fixed genre: the prophets borrowed ordinary courtroom language loosely.
M. DeRoche (1983) and others argue that *riv* means 'dispute' broadly, that the passages vary too much to form one genre, and that the treaty parallels are overstated. On this view 3:13–15 is a vivid trial scene rather than a fixed form.
in v14
Where does God's direct speech begin?
-
At 'And you…' (14b): Yahweh speaks the accusation directly.
There is a shift to second person plural and an emphatic pronoun, and v. 15 closes with 'declares the Lord GOD of hosts'. Most translations (BSB, WEB, ESV) open the quotation here.
-
The prophet speaks throughout as Yahweh's spokesman, and the quotation marks are an editorial choice.
Hebrew has no quotation marks. Prophetic speech often moves between third-person narration and first-person divine speech without marking it.
Sources
- BDB s.v. צַדִּיק, טוֹב, מַעֲלָל, אָכַל
- HALOT s.v. צַדִּיק; מַעֲלָל
- Rahlfs, Septuaginta, Isaiah 3:9–10
- Wisdom of Solomon 2:12
- Epistle of Barnabas 6:7
- Justin Martyr, Dialogue with Trypho 17, 133, 136–137
- Vulgate, Isaiah 3:10
- H. Wildberger, Isaiah 1–12 (Continental Commentary)
- J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Bible)
- J. N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 1–39 (NICOT)
- K. Koch, "Is There a Doctrine of Retribution in the Old Testament?" (1955; ET 1983)
- BDB s.v. אוֹי, רָשָׁע, רַע, גְּמוּל
- HALOT s.v. גְּמוּל, רָשָׁע
- J. Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- K. Koch, 'Gibt es ein Vergeltungsdogma im Alten Testament?' ZTK 52 (1955)
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Isaiah 3:10–11
- Vulgate, Isaiah 3:11
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus at Isa 3:10
- BDB s.v. נָגַשׂ, עָלַל, אָשַׁר, בָּלַע, נָשָׁה
- HALOT s.v. נגשׂ, עלל, אשׁר I, בלע I/II, נשׁה
- Septuagint (Rahlfs-Hanhart), Isaiah 3:12
- Vulgate, Isaiah 3:12
- Hans Wildberger, Isaiah 1–12 (Continental Commentary)
- Joseph Blenkinsopp, Isaiah 1–39 (Anchor Bible)
- John N. Oswalt, The Book of Isaiah 1–39 (NICOT)
- Brevard S. Childs, Isaiah (Old Testament Library)
- STEPBible tagged Hebrew text (supplied lemma and morphology data)
- BDB s.v. נָצַב, רִיב, דִּין, עַם
- HALOT s.v. ריב, דין, נצב
- H. B. Huffmon, "The Covenant Lawsuit in the Prophets," JBL 78 (1959)
- M. De Roche, "Yahweh's rîb against Israel," JBL 102 (1983)
- Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, apparatus at Isa 3:13
- Septuagint (Rahlfs), Isa 3:13
- Vulgate, Isa 3:13
- H. G. M. Williamson, Isaiah 1–5 (ICC)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isa 3:13–15
- BDB s.v. מִשְׁפָּט, בָּעַר, גָּזַל, עָנִי, זָקֵן, שַׂר
- HALOT s.v. בער I, II (burn; graze)
- HALOT s.v. גְּזֵלָה
- B. S. Childs, Isaiah (Old Testament Library)
- H. B. Huffmon, 'The Covenant Lawsuit in the Prophets', JBL 78 (1959)
- M. DeRoche, 'Yahweh's rîb against Israel', JBL 102 (1983)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Isaiah 3:13–15
- Septuagint (Rahlfs) and Vulgate, Isaiah 3:14
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).