Leviticus Chapter 20 Read as one passage

Leviticus 20:17–21

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

17If a man marries his sister, whether the daughter of his father or of his mother, and they have sexual relations, it is a disgrace. They must be cut off in the sight of their people. He has uncovered the nakedness of his sister; he shall bear his iniquity. 18If a man lies with a menstruating woman and has sexual relations with her, he has exposed the source of her flow, and she has uncovered the source of her blood. Both of them must be cut off from among their people. 19You must not have sexual relations with the sister of your mother or your father, for it is exposing one’s own kin; both shall bear their iniquity. 20If a man lies with his uncle’s wife, he has uncovered the nakedness of his uncle. They will bear their sin; they shall die childless. 21If a man marries his brother’s wife, it is an act of impurity. He has uncovered the nakedness of his brother; they shall be childless.

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites, this law drew the boundaries of the household. The family was the basic unit of land, inheritance, worship and identity, and inside it certain bodies were 'covered', not to be sexually approached. A sister was one of them, whether she shared your father or your mother. The law's open reference to half-sisters closed off the loophole that polygamous households and the customs of nearby elites, including the patriarchs' own story, might suggest.

The language would have hit hard:

  • 'Disgrace' says the act shames the whole family before the clan. It is not a private matter between two consenting people.
  • 'Cut off… before the eyes of the sons of their people' says the community will see the couple removed from the people and their line ended. Nothing about it is hidden.
  • 'He shall bear his iniquity' says the man who 'took' her carries the guilt, and no offering will clear it.

Within Leviticus, the chapter ends by grounding these laws in Israel's call to be distinct: 'You are to be holy to Me… and I have set you apart from the nations' (20:26). Behaviour in the family bedroom was part of what made Israel a holy people living on God's land. The land itself is pictured as 'vomiting out' peoples who do such things (20:22).

From the study of Leviticus 20:17.

Verse by verse

  1. 17If a man marries his sister, whether the daughter of his father or of his mother, and they have sexual relations, it is a disgrace. They must be cut off in the sight of their people. He has uncovered the nakedness of his sister; he shall bear his iniquity.

    If a man takes his sister as his wife, and that includes a half-sister, whether they share a father or share a mother, and the two of them expose themselves to each other in sexual union, he seeing her and she seeing him, it is a disgrace. It is a shameful thing that brings public reproach on the family and the people. The two of them will be cut off, removed from their kin and their line, and this will happen openly, before the eyes of their own clan. He has laid bare what kinship was meant to keep covered, his own sister's body. The guilt is his to carry, with all its consequences, and no offering will take it off him.

    A few features matter. The phrasing is mutual ('he sees… she sees'), so this is not a case of rape but of two willing partners, and both are cut off. The word for 'disgrace' is spelled like the Bible's famous word for loyal love (chesed), but it is a different, rarer word meaning reproach. 'Take' is the normal Hebrew for marrying, so the law has in view a union that might be openly recognised, not only a secret act. And the verse ends by placing the main weight of guilt on the man.

    Full study →
  2. 18If a man lies with a menstruating woman and has sexual relations with her, he has exposed the source of her flow, and she has uncovered the source of her blood. Both of them must be cut off from among their people.

    If a man has sex with a woman while she is in her monthly bleeding (literally, while she is "unwell", the ordinary gentle word for her period), he has done more than lie with her. He has exposed what was meant to stay covered. He has laid bare her spring, the hidden source her life-blood flows from. And she is not passive in this. She herself has uncovered the spring of her blood. The verse uses three verbs of uncovering in a row (uncover, lay bare, uncover), and two of them sound alike in Hebrew ("nakedness" / "made naked"). All of them land on one image: a wellspring of blood, which in Leviticus means a wellspring of life (17:11), opened and drained at the wrong time.

    Because both of them did it knowingly, both of them bear the penalty: they will be cut off, removed from the midst of their own kin-people. Elsewhere in this chapter God himself is the one who does this (20:3, 5, 6), and the Hebrew does not hand it to a human court. To an Israelite it meant losing one's place in the family line and among the people, most likely through early death or the dying out of one's descendants. The verse does not condemn menstruation, and it does not condemn the woman for bleeding. It condemns treating the source of life and blood as though it were nothing.

    Full study →
  3. 19You must not have sexual relations with the sister of your mother or your father, for it is exposing one’s own kin; both shall bear their iniquity.

    Your aunt, on your mother's side or your father's side: you must never have sex with her. Whoever does has stripped bare his own flesh and blood, and both of them will carry their guilt and its consequences.

    The Hebrew opens with "the nakedness of" for emphasis. "Uncover the nakedness" is the Bible's polite way of saying sexual intercourse, and it keeps a strong sense of shame: what should stay covered inside a family is exposed. The aunt meant here is a blood aunt, your parent's own sister. The reason is given in one word, she'er, "flesh". She is the same flesh as your mother or father, so to lie with her is to lay bare your own flesh. The verbs echo each other: the verse begins with 'ervah ("nakedness") and its reason clause ends with he'erah ("he has laid bare"), both from the same root.

    The verse starts as a direct command ("you shall not") and then switches to describing the offender ("he has laid bare"), as if pronouncing a verdict on anyone who does it. The last clause is plural: the man and the aunt together "will carry their 'avon". That word means the wrong act, the guilt it creates, and the punishment it brings, all at once. No human court is told to do anything. The guilt is not taken away from them; they carry it themselves, and the outcome is left to God.

    Full study →
  4. 20If a man lies with his uncle’s wife, he has uncovered the nakedness of his uncle. They will bear their sin; they shall die childless.

    If a man sleeps with the wife of his father's brother, he has exposed what belongs to his uncle. Her body and her marriage are his uncle's domain, and he has laid them bare. The man and the woman together will carry the guilt and its consequence: they will go to their deaths stripped of children, with no heirs to carry on their name.

    The Hebrew is brief and pointed. The woman is called dodah, "aunt", but the next clause makes clear she is the uncle's wife, related by marriage rather than by blood. The wrong is described as "uncovering the nakedness of his uncle." Husband and wife are treated as one unit, so sleeping with her exposes and dishonours him. The verbs move from "a man" (singular) to "they" (plural): both partners are answerable.

    The penalty involves no human court. Earlier in the chapter the formula "shall surely be put to death" orders execution. Here it is simply "they will die", and what matters is the manner: aririm, "stripped bare" of offspring. The sound echoes ervat, "nakedness". Laying bare the uncle is answered by being left bare of descendants. In ancient Israel your name, your share of the land and your memory lived on through your children. To die childless was to have your family line end with you.

    Full study →
  5. 21If a man marries his brother’s wife, it is an act of impurity. He has uncovered the nakedness of his brother; they shall be childless.

    "If a man takes his brother's wife as his own, that is niddah: as repellent and separating as the gravest bodily impurity the law knows. He has invaded the sexual intimacy that belongs to his brother's marriage, his brother's 'nakedness'. The two of them will be left stripped of children, with no heir to carry their name into the future."

    Read in order, the verse has three short verdicts:

    1. The act. "Takes" is ordinary marriage language. The case is a lasting union, a man forming a household with the woman who is (or was) his brother's wife. It is not a one-time act.
    2. Its label. Niddah is the word for menstrual impurity. Using it here says the union pollutes and separates in the same deep way. It is far stronger than "an unclean thing".
    3. Its victim. "His brother's nakedness" makes the brother the injured party. In Israelite thinking a wife's sexual intimacy belonged to her marriage, so to take her was to break into the brother's own sphere.
    4. Its outcome. "Childless they will be" is a consequence God brings about, not a sentence for a court to carry out. It probably carries a wordplay: he laid bare his brother, so they will be stripped bare of heirs. A man who seized what belonged to his brother's line loses his own.
    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v17

    see her nakedness

    ra'ah et-ervatah

    What we hear
    Looking at someone naked, perhaps by accident or as a voyeur.
    What they heard
    A modest Hebrew phrase for sexual intercourse, parallel to 'uncover nakedness'. The whole verse concerns a sexual union, not a glance.
  • in v17

    cut off

    nikhretu (karet)

    What we hear
    Shunned or excommunicated, or else simply executed.
    What they heard
    A formal priestly penalty: removal of the person, and often their family line, from the people, generally understood as carried out by God (compare Leviticus 20:3, 'I will cut him off'). Here it is also made public.
  • in v17

    bear his iniquity

    avono yissa

    What we hear
    A vague religious way of saying 'he is wicked'.
    What they heard
    He carries the guilt and the punishment it brings, like a load. No sacrifice lifts it from him.
  • in v17

    a wicked thing

    chesed

    What we hear
    Simply evil, an abstract moral judgment.
    What they heard
    A disgrace, something that brings public reproach and shame. The word belongs to honour and shame vocabulary, not general wickedness.
  • in v18

    having her sickness / a sick woman (KJV, YLT)

    davah

    What we hear
    A woman who is ill or has a disease.
    What they heard
    A woman who is 'unwell' in the sense of her monthly period. It was the standard gentle term for menstruation, not a word for disease.
  • in v18

    he hath discovered her fountain (KJV)

    meqorah heʿerah

    What we hear
    He found or came across something.
    What they heard
    He laid bare, exposed, made naked her spring (the source of her blood).
  • in v18

    uncover her nakedness

    gillah ʿervah

    What we hear
    Undress her or see her naked.
    What they heard
    A fixed idiom for having sexual intercourse, with an overtone of shameful exposure.
  • in v18

    cut off from among their people

    nikhrᵉtu… miqqerev ʿammam

    What we hear
    Excommunicated, shunned or expelled by the community.
    What they heard
    A penalty from God (karet). In this chapter God says he will do it himself (20:3, 5, 6). It most likely meant early death and/or the ending of one's family line among one's kin, not a congregation's ban.
  • in v19

    uncover the nakedness (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    'ervah + galah

    What we hear
    Seeing a relative undressed, or exposing her body. A rule about modesty or looking.
    What they heard
    A fixed polite expression for sexual intercourse, with a strong sense of shame and exposure.
  • in v19

    bear their iniquity

    nasa 'avon

    What we hear
    They are sinful, or they will feel guilty: a statement about moral character or conscience.
    What they heard
    They are liable to punishment for what they did. Because no human penalty is given, the punishment is left to God.
  • in v20

    uncovered the nakedness of his uncle

    ervat dodo gillah

    What we hear
    Taken literally it suggests stripping or seeing someone undressed. It can also sound strange, as though the uncle himself were exposed.
    What they heard
    A fixed polite expression for sexual intercourse within a forbidden relationship. "His uncle's nakedness" means the uncle's marital and sexual domain, embodied in his wife, so the wrong is done to the uncle.
  • in v20

    bear their sin

    chet'am yissa'u

    What we hear
    A feeling of guilt or a general moral burden.
    What they heard
    A legal formula: they are liable and will suffer the penalty for the offence. In this setting God imposes the penalty, not a court.
  • in v21

    an unclean thing / impurity

    niddah

    What we hear
    Something dirty or mildly improper, a vague moral blemish.
    What they heard
    The technical word for menstrual impurity, the most familiar severe and separating impurity in Leviticus. Applied here, it brands the union as deeply defiling and repellent.
  • in v21

    uncovered his brother's nakedness

    ervat achiv gillah

    What we hear
    Seeing or exposing the brother's naked body.
    What they heard
    A fixed idiom for sexual relations. 'His brother's nakedness' means the sexual intimacy that belongs to the brother's marriage, so the brother is the one wronged.
  • in v21

    childless

    aririm

    What we hear
    Medically infertile, unable to conceive.
    What they heard
    Left without heirs: the family line and name cut off. Jer 22:30 uses the word of a man who did have sons but no successor. It is a divine sanction on the couple's future.
Every word
  1. וְאִ֣ישׁ

    ve'ish · H0376

    and a man · v17, v18, v20, v21

    Opens a new case in the law list ('and a man who…'), the standard formula for case law in Leviticus 20.

  2. אֲשֶׁר־

    asher · H0834

    who, which · v17, v18, v20, v21

    Introduces the condition: 'any man who does X'. Functions like 'if' in English.

  3. יִקַּ֣ח

    yiqqach · H3947

    take; take as wife · v17, v21

    'Take' a woman is ordinary Hebrew for marrying her. The case envisages a formal union, not only a secret act, though the law applies to the sexual relationship either way.

  4. אֶת־

    et · H0853

    (object marker) · v17, v18, v19, v20, v21

    Untranslatable marker showing that 'his sister' is the direct object.

  5. אֲחֹת֡וֹ

    achoto · H0269

    his sister · v17, v19

    His sister, defined in the next words so as to include half-sisters on either side.

  6. בַּת־

    bat · H1323

    daughter of · v17

    Begins the clarification: 'daughter of his father'.

  7. אָבִ֣יו

    aviv · H0001

    his father · v17, v19

    A paternal half-sister (same father, different mother) counts as a sister. In a household with several wives this was a live case.

  8. א֣וֹ

    o · H0176

    or · v17

    Either kind of half-sister falls under the law. Neither line of descent gives a loophole.

  9. אִ֠מּוֹ

    immo · H0517

    his mother · v17, v19

    A maternal half-sister (same mother, different father), for example from a mother's earlier or later marriage.

  10. וְרָאָ֨ה

    vera'ah · H7200

    and he sees · v17

    'See' here belongs to a set phrase, 'see the nakedness', which is a polite way of saying sexual intercourse, not just looking.

  11. עֶרְוָתָ֜הּ

    ervatah · H6172

    her nakedness · v17, v18, v19, v20, v21

    Her genitals, her exposed body. In this phrase it is a modest way of describing sexual union.

  12. וְהִֽיא־

    vehi · H1931

    and she · v17, v18, v21

    The pronoun is stated outright for emphasis. She is an active party too.

  13. חֶ֣סֶד

    chesed · H2617B

    disgrace, reproach · v17

    Not the famous chesed meaning 'loyal love'. This is a rare word spelled the same way that means shame or disgrace, a thing that brings public reproach.

  14. וְנִ֨כְרְת֔וּ

    venikhretu · H3772

    and they shall be cut off · v17, v18

    The penalty known as karet, being 'cut off'. Its subject is plural, so both partners are cut off. The passive leaves unstated who does the cutting; other passages say God does it.

  15. לְעֵינֵ֖י

    le'einei · H5869

    before the eyes of · v17

    'In the sight of': the punishment is public and conspicuous, the opposite of hidden.

  16. בְּנֵ֣י

    benei · H1121

    sons of, members of · v17

    'Sons of their people' means their fellow clan members and kin, the community that sees the shame.

  17. עַמָּ֑ם

    ammam · H5971

    their people · v17, v18

    Their kin group. In early Hebrew 'am often keeps its old sense of extended family or clan.

  18. גִּלָּ֖ה

    gillah · H1540

    he has uncovered · v17, v18, v19, v20, v21

    An intensive verb form meaning 'expose'. 'Uncover nakedness' is the standard phrase in Leviticus 18 and 20 for forbidden sexual relations.

  19. עֲוֹנ֥וֹ

    avono · H5771

    his iniquity / guilt / punishment · v17, v19

    One word covers the wrong, the guilt it leaves, and the punishment it brings. The singular 'his' puts the main responsibility on the man.

  20. יִשָּֽׂא׃

    yissa · H5375

    he shall bear, carry · v17, v19, v20

    'Bear his iniquity' means he carries the guilt and its consequences himself. No sacrifice removes it.

  21. יִשְׁכַּב

    yishkav · H7901

    lie down; lie with (sexually) · v18, v20

    'Lies with', the ordinary Hebrew phrase for sexual intercourse. The verb form sets up a general hypothetical case: whoever does this.

  22. אִשָּׁה

    ʾishshah · H0802

    woman, wife · v18, v21

    Any woman, his wife included. The law has nothing to do with marital status; the issue is her bodily condition at that time.

  23. דָּוָה

    davah · H1739

    unwell, faint, sick · v18

    Literally 'unwell' or 'faint'. In the purity laws it is the set word for a woman during her period (Lev 12:2; 15:33). It describes the physical malaise of menstruation and is a gentle way of putting it. It does not mean she has a disease.

  24. מְקֹרָהּ

    meqorah · H4726

    spring, fountain, source · v18

    'Her spring', the source her blood flows from. Leviticus 12:7 uses the same image of the bleeding after childbirth. It pictures her body as a wellspring of life-blood.

  25. הֶעֱרָה

    heʿerah · H6168

    lay bare, make naked, pour out · v18, v19

    'He has laid bare'. It comes from the same root as ʿervah, 'nakedness', so it sounds like 'he has made her spring naked'. The verb can also mean 'empty out' or 'pour out', which fits the image of a flowing spring.

  26. דָּמֶיהָ

    dameha · H1818

    blood (plural: bloods, flow of blood) · v18

    'Her bloods'. The plural often means shed or flowing blood. In Leviticus blood is the carrier of life (17:11, 14), so this is not an ordinary bodily fluid.

  27. שְׁנֵיהֶם

    shᵉneihem · H8147

    two; both of them · v18

    'The two of them'. The penalty falls on both equally, which confirms that this is a willing act on both sides.

  28. מִקֶּרֶב

    miqqerev · H7130

    from the midst of, from among · v18

    'From the inner part of, from among'. They are removed from inside the living community.

  29. לֹא

    lo · H3808

    not · v19

    Joined to the following verb, it makes a permanent prohibition ("you shall never…") rather than a one-time instruction.

  30. כִּי

    ki · H3588

    for, because · v19

    This word introduces the reason. The act is wrong because of who the woman is.

  31. שְׁאֵרוֹ

    she'ero · H7607

    his flesh, his blood relative · v19

    Literally "flesh, meat". By extension it means a close blood relative, one's own flesh and blood. The aunt shares the man's own flesh through his parent, so exposing her is in a sense exposing himself.

  32. דֹּ֣דָת֔וֹ

    dodato · H1733

    his aunt · v20

    The feminine of dod ("uncle"). The next clause, "his uncle's nakedness", shows she is the uncle's wife, so she is related to him by marriage rather than by blood. That is why most translations say "his uncle's wife".

  33. דֹּד֖וֹ

    dodo · H1730

    his uncle (father's brother) · v20

    Usually the father's brother, the senior male relative next to the father in a family traced through the male line (compare Lev 25:49). The wrong is described as done to him.

  34. חֶטְאָ֥ם

    chet'am · H2399

    their sin · v20

    An offence, together with the guilt and liability that come with it. The suffix is plural ("their"), so the woman is held answerable along with the man.

  35. עֲרִירִ֥ים

    aririm · H6185

    childless · v20, v21

    Literally "stripped, bare" of offspring. It sounds like ervat ("nakedness") earlier in the verse, so laying bare a relative's nakedness is answered by being left bare of children.

  36. יָמֻֽתוּ׃

    yamutu · H4191

    they will die · v20

    A plain "they will die". It is not the courtroom formula "they shall surely be put to death" (mot yumat) used in vv. 9–16. They are not executed. They die in the ordinary course of life, but with no heirs.

  37. אָחִ֖יו

    achiv · H0251

    his brother · v21

    His brother, most naturally a full or half-brother of the same father's house. The bond between brothers was one of the strongest in Israel's kinship system.

  38. נִדָּ֣ה

    niddah · H5079

    impurity, menstrual impurity, abhorrent thing · v21

    The word Leviticus uses for the impurity of menstruation (12:2; 15:19–33; 18:19). Here it is used in an extended sense: the union is as repellent and separating as the strongest bodily impurity the law knew. It is a much stronger word than the bland 'unclean thing'.

  39. יִהְיֽוּ׃

    yihyu · H1961

    they will be · v21

    'They will be'. Plural, so both the man and the woman share the outcome. The future form announces a consequence that God will bring about. No human court carries out this penalty.

The world behind it

Leviticus 18 and 20 work as a pair. Leviticus 18 lists forbidden unions as commands ('you shall not uncover the nakedness of…'). Leviticus 20 repeats many of them as case law with penalties. The sister law appears first at 18:9 ('your sister, your father's daughter or your mother's daughter, whether born at home or born outside') and again at 18:11. It is also among the curses of Deuteronomy 27:22 and in Ezekiel's charges against Jerusalem (Ezekiel 22:11).

Why spell out half-sisters? In a household with more than one wife, children of the same father but different mothers grew up as separate sub-families. A man might think his paternal half-sister was fair game. Israel's own stories show the practice existed: Abraham says Sarah is 'the daughter of my father but not the daughter of my mother' (Genesis 20:12). Tamar tells her half-brother Amnon, 'speak to the king, for he will not withhold me from you' (2 Samuel 13:13). That may be a desperate stalling tactic or evidence that such a marriage was still thinkable in David's court. Neighbouring cultures varied. Egyptian royal houses at times practised brother–sister marriage. Classical Athens allowed marriage to a half-sister by the same father, and Sparta reportedly allowed it with a half-sister by the same mother. Leviticus shuts both doors.

Honour and shame. In a kinship society, a family's standing before the clan was a real social asset. Calling the act a disgrace and placing the punishment 'before the eyes of the sons of their people' fits that world. The household's shame is public, and so is the response to it.

The shift in penalties. Leviticus 20:9–16 says repeatedly 'they shall surely be put to death', meaning execution by the community. Verses 17–21 change to 'cut off' and 'they shall die childless'. Many interpreters read these cases as left to God's own punishment, often understood as ending the person's family line, rather than to a human court.

From the study of Leviticus 20:17.

Where scholars differ

in v17

Is the chesed of this verse a separate word meaning 'disgrace', or the usual chesed ('loyal love') used in a twisted sense?

  • Separate word (most lexicons and scholars): a second root חסד meaning 'reproach'.

    Aramaic and Syriac ḥsd 'revile'; the verb in Proverbs 25:10 ('lest he shame you'); the Septuagint's ὄνειδος ('reproach'); the parallel sense in Proverbs 14:34.

  • Same word with a reversed meaning: an excess of family 'kindness' or affection that becomes shameful (proposed by some medieval Jewish commentators and a few modern scholars).

    Hebrew does sometimes use one root with opposite senses, and the rabbinic tradition linked this verse to Cain marrying his sister as an act of 'kindness' in the first generation (e.g. Sanhedrin 58b). The comparative linguistic evidence favours the separate-word view.

in v17

What does 'cut off in the sight of their people' (karet) involve?

  • Punishment from God: early death and/or the ending of the person's family line, not a human sentence.

    God is the stated agent in Leviticus 20:3, 5–6. The penalty changes from 'put to death' (vv. 9–16) to 'cut off' and 'childless' (vv. 17–21). The Mishnah treats karet as heavenly punishment (Keritot 1:1).

  • A human, community-enforced penalty: public expulsion or execution.

    'Before the eyes of the sons of their people' suggests a visible public act, and the passive verb leaves the agent open. Some think 'cut off' in some texts meant banishment from the clan.

  • Both together: punishment from God made publicly visible.

    'Before the eyes' can mean the punishment will be openly evident to all, without saying who carries it out.

in v18

How does this verse relate to Leviticus 15:24, which gives only seven days of impurity for the same act?

  • Different cases. Lev 15:24 covers an unknowing act (for example, her period began during intercourse); Lev 20:18 covers a deliberate act.

    This is the rabbinic harmonisation, taken up by Milgrom and many modern commentators. In 20:18 both parties actively 'uncover', and the parallel prohibition in 18:19 forbids 'approaching' her, which suggests intent. Lev 15 deals with impurity consequences and Lev 20 with punishment.

  • Different layers of priestly law. The Holiness Code (Lev 17–26) is stricter than the earlier purity instructions of Lev 11–16 and raises a purity matter to a moral offence.

    Differences of vocabulary and emphasis between Lev 1–16 and 17–26 are widely recognised in scholarship. In the Holiness Code, sexual and purity offences defile the land as well as the sanctuary.

  • Complementary rules. 15:24 states the ritual impurity the act causes, and 20:18 states the penalty. Both apply.

    15:24 says nothing about guilt or punishment, so it need not contradict 20:18. Laws in Leviticus often address one aspect of a case at a time.

in v18

What does 'cut off from their people' (karet) mean?

  • A penalty from God: early death and/or the ending of one's descendants, carried out by God rather than a court.

    Lev 20:3, 5, 6 have God saying 'I will cut him off', distinct from human stoning in 20:2. Lev 20:20–21 pairs related offences with 'they shall die childless'. Mishnah Keritot 1:1 treats karet as a punishment from heaven and lists sex with a menstruating woman among such offences.

  • Exclusion from the community or the afterlife ('being gathered to one's people').

    The phrase contrasts with the idiom 'gathered to his people' at death (Gen 25:8). Some rabbinic and modern interpreters think karet includes being cut off from one's ancestors after death.

  • Human execution or expulsion.

    The Vulgate's rendering of karet in a number of places as 'killed', and some passages where karet sits next to death penalties (e.g., Exod 31:14). Most modern commentators consider this less likely in Lev 20, where the two penalties are deliberately kept apart.

in v18

Why was intercourse during menstruation forbidden?

  • Blood/life symbolism: menstrual blood represents lost life, which belongs to death, so it must be kept apart from the act that brings life.

    Lev 17:11, 14 (life is in the blood). The impurity system tends to cluster around death and the loss of life-fluids (corpses, scale disease, discharges). The verse dwells on the 'spring of her blood'.

  • Boundaries and wholeness: Israel's purity laws keep categories distinct and guard bodily boundaries as a picture of holiness.

    Anthropological readings, notably Mary Douglas. The frame of Lev 18 and 20 is separation from the nations (20:24–26).

  • Procreation: sex at a time when conception is unlikely was seen as misdirected.

    Some scholars connect the prohibitions in Lev 18 to fertility and lineage concerns (cf. 18:20–23). This is suggestive but not stated in the text.

  • Hygiene/health.

    Popular in some modern apologetics, but the text gives no health rationale. Its stated frame is holiness, defilement of the land, and separation (18:24–30; 20:22–26). Most scholars reject it as the original purpose.

in v19

What penalty does "they shall carry their iniquity" imply when no human punishment is named?

  • Punishment from God, not specified. The community takes no action, and God deals with the guilty in his own way.

    With the sinner as subject, the formula marks liability to God in Priestly texts (Leviticus 5:1; 17:16; 19:8; Numbers 5:31). Milgrom and Schwartz read it as distinct from court penalties. Chapter 20 seems to move from court penalties (vv. 9–16) to divine ones (vv. 17–21).

  • Effectively the same as being "cut off", or as the childlessness named in the following verses.

    Verse 17 joins "cut off" and "he shall carry his iniquity" in the same case, and verses 20–21 name childlessness for closely related unions. Some commentators (e.g. Wenham, Hartley) read verses 19–21 as one group with similar divine penalties.

in v19

Why does the verse switch from "you shall not" to "he has laid bare"?

  • It shows how the text was put together: a direct command from the Leviticus 18 style was set among the case laws of chapter 20.

    Verse 19 is the only case in 20:9–21 that does not follow the "if a man…" pattern, and its wording closely follows Leviticus 18:12–13.

  • It is deliberate: a command to the hearer, followed by a verdict on anyone who breaks it.

    Biblical Hebrew legal and prophetic speech often moves between persons. The "he" clause works as a general definition ("whoever does this has stripped his own flesh"), and the plural closes the case by holding both parties responsible.

in v20

What exactly does "they shall die childless" mean?

  • God will prevent the couple from having children at all, so the union produces no offspring.

    The plainest sense of ariri ("childless"), as in Gen 15:2. The penalty matches the offence: an illicit union is made fruitless.

  • Any children they have, or already have, will not survive them. They will bury their children and die without heirs.

    Medieval Jewish interpretation (e.g. Rashi on this verse and v. 21) distinguishes those who have children at the time of the offence from those who do not. Jer 22:30 calls Jeconiah "childless" although he had sons (1 Chr 3:17), meaning without a successor.

  • It is a form of the divine penalty of being "cut off" (karet): the family line is ended, whatever happens to particular children.

    The Mishnah (Keritot 1:1) lists this union among offences punished by karet. Modern commentators such as Milgrom read the chapter's divine penalties as related ways of ending a line, and note how the penalties are graded across vv. 17–21.

in v20

Why is the uncle's wife forbidden when she is not a blood relative?

  • Because of identity through marriage: husband and wife are one, so the wife's "nakedness" is the husband's.

    The verse itself says "he has uncovered his uncle's nakedness". Compare Lev 18:8 (father's wife = "your father's nakedness") and 18:16. Gen 2:24 speaks of "one flesh".

  • Because of household order and honour: the uncle is a near-father figure, and taking his wife challenges his authority and confuses the lines of inheritance.

    The uncle's role as redeemer (Lev 25:49). The way the extended father's house worked. Comparable offences such as Reuben with Bilhah (Gen 35:22; 49:4) and Absalom with David's concubines (2 Sam 16:21–22), which were acts that challenged a senior man's standing.

in v21

Does the ban cover the widow of a brother who has died, or only the wife of a living (or divorced) brother?

  • It covers a brother's wife in any case, including after his death, with levirate marriage (Deut 25:5–10) as a narrow exception for a brother who died without a son.

    This is the rabbinic view (Sifra; Mishnah and Talmud, tractate Yevamot). Lev 18:16 and 20:21 set no time limit, while Deut 25 is explicitly limited to a brother who 'has no son'. The penalty 'childless' fits well: marrying the widow of a brother who left heirs is forbidden, and the levirate exists only to supply an heir.

  • It mainly targets taking the wife of a brother who is still alive (by adultery or after divorce), so it does not clash with the levirate law.

    'His brother's nakedness' suggests the brother's marital claim is still in force. The New Testament case (Herodias leaving a living husband, Mark 6:17–18; Josephus, Ant. 18.136) fits this pattern. Against it: adultery with a married woman already carries the death penalty in 20:10, so a separate, lighter penalty here would be odd if only a living brother were meant.

  • The Leviticus law and the Deuteronomy levirate law come from different legal traditions that were later read together and harmonised.

    Source-critical scholars note the different vocabulary and outlook of the Holiness laws (Lev 17–26) and Deuteronomy. Gen 38 and Ruth show the levirate custom was practised widely and does not seem to sense any conflict.

in v21

What does 'they will be childless' mean concretely?

  • God will make the union literally barren.

    The plainest reading of the word. Compare v. 20, 'they shall die childless'.

  • Any children will die before them, or the couple will be left without surviving heirs.

    Rashi and earlier rabbinic tradition: 'if he has children he will bury them'. This explains how the penalty could apply to people who already had children.

  • Children will not count as lawful heirs, so the line and name end even if offspring exist.

    Jer 22:30 calls Jehoiachin 'childless' although he had sons (1 Chr 3:17), meaning none would succeed him. In Israel, being 'childless' meant losing name and inheritance more than lacking biological offspring.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).