Leviticus Chapter 27 Read as one passage

Leviticus 27:26–33

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

26But no one may consecrate a firstborn of the livestock, because a firstborn belongs to the LORD. Whether it is an ox or a sheep, it is the LORD’s. 27But if it is among the unclean animals, then he may redeem it according to your valuation and add a fifth of its value. If it is not redeemed, then it shall be sold according to your valuation. 28Nothing that a man sets apart to the LORD from all he owns—whether a man, an animal, or his inherited land—can be sold or redeemed; everything so devoted is most holy to the LORD. 29No person set apart for destruction may be ransomed; he must surely be put to death. 30Thus any tithe from the land, whether from the seed of the land or the fruit of the trees, belongs to the LORD; it is holy to the LORD. 31If a man wishes to redeem part of his tithe, he must add a fifth to its value. 32Every tenth animal from the herd or flock that passes under the shepherd’s rod will be holy to the LORD. 33He must not inspect whether it is good or bad, and he shall not make any substitution. But if he does make a substitution, both the animal and its substitute shall become holy; they cannot be redeemed.’”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelite herders and farmers, the verse shut a tempting loophole. A man making a vow, perhaps for recovery from illness or a safe journey, might want to offer an animal he was going to have to give anyway, the firstborn calf or lamb, and count it as his special gift. The law says no. The firstling was never his to give. A vow had to cost the vow-maker something beyond what he already owed.

It also taught them something about how holiness works. Some things become God's by a person's choice (a vowed field or house). Others are God's by his own claim, built into the order of life itself (the firstborn, the tithe). The second kind cannot be "upgraded" or re-labelled by human ritual. Each firstling handed over at the sanctuary recalled the Exodus story (Exod 13:14–15) and reminded Israel that their flocks, their families and their freedom came from Yahweh. The closing words, "it is Yahweh's," would have sounded as a simple statement of fact, like a property line.

From the study of Leviticus 27:26.

Verse by verse

  1. 26But no one may consecrate a firstborn of the livestock, because a firstborn belongs to the LORD. Whether it is an ox or a sheep, it is the LORD’s.

    "There is one exception: a firstling, the animal born first, which by that birth is already Yahweh's, from among your livestock. No one may 'consecrate' it to him by vow. Whether it is one of the herd or one of the flock (sheep or goat), it is Yahweh's already."

    The verse turns on ownership. Leviticus 27 has just explained how an Israelite could vow persons, animals, houses or fields to the sanctuary and, in most cases, buy them back at a set price. Then comes the exception. The Hebrew repeats its root ("a firstborn that is first-born to Yahweh") to make the point that the animal's holy status comes from the plain fact of being born first, not from anything its owner does. "To Yahweh" opens and closes the verse, so the ban sits inside its reason: you cannot give God as a gift what he already owns. "Consecrate" here does not mean making something morally pure. It means a legal transfer of property into the sanctuary's hands, and a firstling has nothing left to transfer. The form of the ban ("no one shall") is a standing prohibition, not advice. "Ox or sheep" is shorthand for every clean herd and flock animal, goats included.

    Full study →
  2. 27But if it is among the unclean animals, then he may redeem it according to your valuation and add a fifth of its value. If it is not redeemed, then it shall be sold according to your valuation.

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  3. 28Nothing that a man sets apart to the LORD from all he owns—whether a man, an animal, or his inherited land—can be sold or redeemed; everything so devoted is most holy to the LORD.

    But here is the one exception. Anything a man puts under the ban for Yahweh, out of what is truly his own, cannot be sold and cannot be bought back. That holds whether it is a person in his household, an animal from his herd, or a field of his family's ancestral land. Everything put under the ban belongs to the highest rank of holiness. It is Yahweh's, permanently.

    What the first hearers would have caught:

    • The contrast with the rest of the chapter. Leviticus 27 is mostly about gifts that can be taken back. A man could vow a person, consecrate an animal, a house or a field, and later reclaim it by paying its assessed value plus one fifth. This verse closes that door for one kind of gift, the ḥerem.
    • What ḥerem means. The word is far stronger than "devote" sounds today. It is the same word used for the war ban, where a city and its spoils were handed over to God by destroying them. In this private form the item is not necessarily destroyed. But it goes over to God's side completely, which in practice meant the sanctuary and its priests (Num 18:14), and nobody can ever get it back.
    • "Holy of holies". The phrase puts the banned item in the same class as the holiest offerings and the inner shrine: off-limits to ordinary people and ordinary use.
    • "Sold" and "bought back". Both words are commercial. The sanctuary cannot turn the item into cash, and the owner's family cannot buy it back the way a next of kin buys back family land.
    Full study →
  4. 29No person set apart for destruction may be ransomed; he must surely be put to death.

    "Any human being who has been placed under the ḥerem, the ban, can never be bought back. No price and no substitute will release him. He must certainly be put to death."

    Leviticus 27 is a chapter about vows and gifts to the sanctuary. Almost everything in it can be bought back: a vowed person by a fixed sum of silver, an animal, a house or a field by its value plus one-fifth. Verses 28–29 set out the one category that money cannot reverse, the ḥerem. A ḥerem is something handed over completely and permanently to God's sole claim. It is "most holy", taken out of human ownership for good.

    Verse 28 covers what an owner devotes from his own goods. That ḥerem goes to the sanctuary and is never sold or bought back. Verse 29 then turns to a sharper case. The wording changes from "a man devotes" to "is devoted", with no one named as doing it, and it narrows the case to people: "from among humankind." The same passive wording is used in Exodus 22:20 for a person condemned for sacrificing to other gods. So the picture is of someone who has come under the ban: an enemy under the ban of holy war, or an Israelite condemned for apostasy. That person's life has passed beyond any human claim.

    "Shall not be ransomed" uses the verb for buying something free by payment, as a firstborn son was bought back. For this person the transaction is closed. The verse ends with the fixed formula of Israel's capital laws, "dying, he shall be put to death." This is the language of a legal sentence carried out, not of an offering laid on an altar. The sentence is certain and cannot be bought off.

    Full study →
  5. 30Thus any tithe from the land, whether from the seed of the land or the fruit of the trees, belongs to the LORD; it is holy to the LORD.

    "And every tenth of the land, from what is sown in the land's soil and from the fruit of its trees, is Yahweh's. It is a holy thing, Yahweh's."

    The verse states a fact; it is not an appeal. Every tenth of every crop, whether grain from the fields or wine, oil and fruit from the vines and orchards, already belongs to Yahweh. It is not the farmer's gift to God. It is God's share of God's own land, which Israel farms as his tenant ("the land is mine," Lev 25:23). "The land" comes up twice, tying the tenth to the soil itself.

    The second half adds the tithe's status: it is qodesh, "a holy thing." That means sacred property moved out of ordinary use into God's sphere, much like a dedicated object in the sanctuary. It is not mainly about moral purity. The verse opens and closes with "Yahweh's," wrapping the tithe in God's ownership at both ends.

    The verse's place matters. Leviticus 27 is about vows: what an Israelite may promise to God and how it can be bought back. Verses 26–33 list things that cannot be vowed because they already belong to God: firstborn animals, things "devoted" to destruction, and tithes. You cannot promise God what is already his. If a farmer wanted to keep some of his tithe produce, he could buy it back only by paying its value plus a fifth (v. 27:31). That is the same penalty paid for misusing sacred property.

    Full study →
  6. 31If a man wishes to redeem part of his tithe, he must add a fifth to its value.

    The verse before this one has just declared that every tenth of the land's harvest, whether grain from the fields or fruit from the trees, belongs to the LORD and is holy: once set apart, it is no longer the farmer's property but the sanctuary's. This verse opens a single controlled exit: "And if a man actually chooses to buy back any part of his tenth, he must pay its value and add a fifth on top of it."

    The doubled Hebrew verb ("redeeming, he redeems") stresses that this is a deliberate act the owner chooses. Nobody is required to do it, and the farmer may buy back only part of the tithe if he likes. "Redeem" here is the ordinary language of buying back property. It is the same word used for a family buying back ancestral land. The sanctuary is to receive the tithe's worth in silver, as valued by the priest (v. 25 sets the standard as the sanctuary shekel), plus twenty percent. That surcharge is the same "fifth" Leviticus charges whenever holy property comes back into ordinary hands. It makes keeping the holy portion cost more than giving it. That discourages casual reclaiming of what belongs to God and makes sure the sanctuary is never short-changed. The next verses draw the line: a tenth of the herd and flock may not be bought back or swapped at all (vv. 32–33). So the option applies only to produce.

    Full study →
  7. 32Every tenth animal from the herd or flock that passes under the shepherd’s rod will be holy to the LORD.

    "And the whole tithe of your livestock, cattle as well as sheep and goats: every animal that files past under the herdsman's counting staff, the one that comes out tenth, becomes sacred property belonging to the LORD."

    The picture is a working farm. At counting time the animals are driven one by one through a narrow opening. The herdsman holds his staff over each as it passes, counting one, two, three…. Whichever animal is tenth, strong or scrawny, is touched and set apart. From that moment it is holy. That does not mean morally pure. It means it has left its owner's ordinary property and become God's. The owner does not choose God's share, and so he cannot keep back the best. The next verse closes the loopholes: he may not inspect the animals to pick good from bad, and he may not swap one for another. If he tries, both animals become holy. Produce tithes could be bought back by paying their value plus a fifth (v. 31), but the animal tithe cannot be bought back at all (v. 33). The tenth animal simply belongs to the LORD.

    Full study →
  8. 33He must not inspect whether it is good or bad, and he shall not make any substitution. But if he does make a substitution, both the animal and its substitute shall become holy; they cannot be redeemed.’”

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

Where the English drifted

  • in v26

    sanctify (KJV, YLT)

    yaqdish (hiphil of qadash)

    What we hear
    To make someone or something morally or spiritually pure; personal holiness.
    What they heard
    To formally declare an item holy, i.e. hand it over by vow into the sanctuary's ownership. A change of legal status and owner.
  • in v26

    sheep

    seh

    What we hear
    Sheep only.
    What they heard
    Any single animal of the flock, sheep or goat.
  • in v28

    devote / devoted thing

    ḥāram / ḥērem

    What we hear
    Loving, loyal commitment, as in 'a devoted follower' or 'devotional time'.
    What they heard
    Put under the ban: handed over to God irrevocably and taken out of human use, ownership and redemption. In war it meant destruction; here it means a permanent transfer to the sanctuary.
  • in v28

    redeemed

    gāʾal

    What we hear
    Spiritual salvation from sin.
    What they heard
    Bought back: the owner or his next of kin pays the assessed price plus a fifth to take back property dedicated to the sanctuary.
  • in v28

    most holy

    qōdesh qŏdāshîm

    What we hear
    Extremely pure or morally perfect.
    What they heard
    The highest rank of sacred ownership. It belongs to God's sphere, only priests may handle it, and it can never return to ordinary use.
  • in v29

    devoted (KJV, WEB, ESV)

    ḥērem / yoḥŏram

    What we hear
    Loyal, affectionate, committed, as in "a devoted husband" or "devoted to her work."
    What they heard
    Put under the ban: surrendered irrevocably to God's sole claim and removed from human use. For a person this meant death.
  • in v29

    set apart (BSB, NASB)

    ḥērem

    What we hear
    Consecrated or sanctified for holy service. Many church readers know the phrase as positive language about being chosen.
    What they heard
    A category distinct from ordinary consecration (qōdesh). Ordinary consecrated things could be bought back. A ḥerem could not, and a human ḥerem was to be killed.
  • in v29

    redeemed (KJV)

    pādāh

    What we hear
    Saved spiritually or forgiven, in the church sense of "redemption."
    What they heard
    Bought free by paying a price or giving a substitute, a legal and commercial transaction like ransoming a firstborn or a pledged item.
  • in v30, v31

    tithe

    ma'aser

    What we hear
    Ten percent of a person's income or paycheck, given to a local church.
    What they heard
    The fixed tenth of the harvest of Israel's farmland (grain, wine, oil and fruit, and in v. 32, herds and flocks), set apart for the sanctuary system. It is a tenth of what the land produced, not of wages.
  • in v30, v32

    holy

    qodesh

    What we hear
    Morally pure, spiritually devout, especially good.
    What they heard
    Sacred property: removed from ordinary use and placed in God's sphere, so that using it as common goods counts as trespass.
  • in v31

    redeem

    ga'al

    What we hear
    Spiritual salvation, or 'redeeming' oneself after failure.
    What they heard
    A property transaction: buying back produce that has become sanctuary property, paying its silver value plus 20%.
  • in v32

    tithe

    maʿaser

    What we hear
    Ten percent of one's (money) income, given to one's local church.
    What they heard
    A tenth of farm produce and, here, of livestock (literally every tenth animal counted), paid into the sanctuary system of ancient Israel. Money comes in only when produce is bought back (v. 31). Animals could not be bought back at all (v. 33).
Every word
  1. אַךְ־

    'akh · H0389

    only, however, surely · v26, v28

    A limiting word that brings in an exception: 'Only this...' After the long list of things a person may vow to the sanctuary (vv. 1–25), it marks the first of three things that cannot be vowed because God already owns them.

  2. בְּכוֹר

    bekhor · H1060

    firstborn, firstling · v26

    The first male offspring to 'open the womb' of its mother (Exod 13:12). For animals this is a legal category, not just a birth order, and it carries the status 'Yahweh's property' from the moment of birth.

  3. אֲשֶׁר־

    'asher · H0834A

    which, that · v26, v28, v29, v32

    Brings in a clause that explains the firstling's status: the one that is already firstborn-for-Yahweh.

  4. יְבֻכַּר

    yevukkar · H1069

    to be born first, be made firstborn · v26

    A rare passive form built on the same root as bekhor: literally 'a firstling which is first-born'. The repetition makes the point that the animal's claim on it comes from birth itself. Nobody's act makes it holy; being born first does.

  5. לַיהוָה

    laYHWH · H3068G

    to/for Yahweh (the LORD) · v26, v28, v30, v32

    'Belonging to Yahweh.' The preposition 'to/for' marks ownership. English 'the LORD' in small capitals stands for Israel's God's personal name, YHWH.

  6. בִּבְהֵמָה

    bivhemah · H0929

    beast, livestock · v26, v28

    'Among livestock', meaning domestic herd and flock animals as opposed to humans (whose firstborn are dealt with elsewhere, Num 18:15–16) and wild animals.

  7. לֹא־

    lo' · H3808

    not · v26, v28, v29

    With the following verb it forms a standing ban, the same 'you shall not' form used in the Ten Commandments: not 'should not' but 'never may'.

  8. יַקְדִּישׁ

    yaqdish · H6942H

    to consecrate, dedicate, declare holy · v26

    In this chapter it is the technical term for a worshipper formally transferring something he owns (a house, v. 14; a field, v. 16) to the sanctuary by vow. Here it is forbidden for firstlings: they are already in God's domain, so there is nothing left to transfer.

  9. אִישׁ

    'ish · H0376I

    man, anyone · v26, v28, v31

    Used as 'anyone, no one' (with the negative). It is the same word that opens the chapter's vow laws ('when anyone makes a special vow', v. 2), so it ties this exception back to the vow-maker.

  10. אֹתוֹ

    'oto · H0853

    [object marker] + it · v26

    'It', marking the firstling as the thing that may not be consecrated.

  11. אִם־

    'im · H0518H

    if, whether · v26, v31

    The first half of 'whether... or...', listing the cases the rule covers.

  12. שׁוֹר

    shor · H7794

    ox, head of cattle · v26

    A single animal of the herd, male or female in general use: bull, ox or cow. Here it stands for all cattle.

  13. שֶׂה

    seh · H7716

    one of the flock (sheep or goat) · v26

    A single animal of the flock, which covers both sheep and goats (compare Exod 12:5, where the Passover seh may be 'from the sheep or from the goats'). Together with shor it means 'every clean herd or flock animal'.

  14. הוּא׃

    hu' · H1931

    he, she, it · v26, v28, v30

    'It is.' The verse closes with a flat statement of ownership: it is Yahweh's already, before any vow.

  15. כָּל־

    kol · H3605

    all, every · v28, v29, v30, v32

    'Every': the rule holds for any ḥerem, whatever kind it is.

  16. חֵ֡רֶם

    ḥērem · H2764A

    thing under the ban, devoted thing · v28, v29

    Something put under the ban: handed over to God for good, taken out of all human use and ownership. It is the noun here; the verb comes next.

  17. יַחֲרִם֩

    yaḥărim · H2763A

    to put under the ban; devote; destroy · v28, v29

    The verb is in the causative active form with a man as subject: the owner himself does it, deliberately and by his own choice. In v. 29 the verb is passive ('is put under the ban'), which many read as a different situation.

  18. ל֗וֹ

    lô · H9033

    to him, his · v28

    'That belongs to him.' A man can ban only what is really his own, not someone else's property and not what already belongs to God, such as a firstborn animal (v. 26).

  19. מֵאָדָ֤ם

    mēʾādām · H0120G

    human being, humankind · v28, v29

    'Of human beings': people who belong to him, probably slaves or other dependents in his household. What became of them is disputed (see Debates).

  20. וּמִשְּׂדֵ֣ה

    û-mi-śədēh · H7704G

    field, open country · v28

    'And of the field of': farmland.

  21. אֲחֻזָּת֔וֹ

    ʾăḥuzzātô · H0272

    holding, ancestral property · v28

    'His holding': the family's inherited land, which normally could never leave the clan for good (Lev 25:23–28). Banning it is the one thing that takes it away permanently (compare 27:21).

  22. יִמָּכֵ֖ר

    yimmākhēr · H4376

    be sold · v28

    'It shall not be sold.' The sanctuary may not turn the banned thing into cash, as it could with an unclean animal that was not bought back (v. 27).

  23. יִגָּאֵ֑ל

    yiggāʾēl · H1350A

    be redeemed, bought back · v28, v31

    'Nor bought back': the owner or a relative cannot pay its value plus a fifth to reclaim it, which was allowed for ordinary dedications (vv. 13, 15, 19, 27).

  24. קֹֽדֶשׁ־

    qōdesh · H6944G

    holiness, holy thing · v28, v30, v32

    'Holy thing of…': something that belongs to God's sphere.

  25. מִן־

    min- · H4480A

    from, out of · v29

    Here it means "from among": the ḥerem in question is drawn from the class of human beings rather than animals or land, the other categories listed in v. 28.

  26. יִפָּדֶ֑ה

    yippādeh · H6299

    to ransom, buy free · v29

    "Shall be ransomed": released by a payment or a substitute, as firstborn sons and donkeys were ransomed (Exod 13:13). The ransom option, which the rest of Leviticus 27 offers for almost everything vowed, is shut off.

  27. מ֖וֹת

    môt · H4191

    to die · v29

    An infinitive ("dying") placed in front of the main verb from the same root for emphasis: "he shall certainly be put to death."

  28. מַעְשַׂ֨ר

    ma'sar · H4643

    tenth, tithe · v30, v31, v32

    Built on the word for "ten" (eser), it means literally "the tenth part". Here it is the fixed tenth of the harvest. It is a set portion, not an amount the farmer chooses.

  29. הָאָ֜רֶץ

    ha'arets · H776

    land, earth, country · v30

    "The land" means the land of Israel as farmland. Two chapters earlier God says, "the land is mine; you are strangers and sojourners with me" (Lev 25:23).

  30. מִזֶּ֤רַע

    mizzera' · H2233

    seed, what is sown; offspring · v30

    "From the seed": the sown crops of the field, chiefly grain such as wheat and barley. "Seed" here means the crop that comes from sowing, not only the kernels saved for planting.

  31. מִפְּרִ֣י

    mipperi · H6529

    fruit, produce · v30

    "From the fruit": the yield of orchards and vineyards. Elsewhere this is summed up as new wine and olive oil (Deut 14:23), along with figs, dates and similar crops.

  32. הָעֵ֔ץ

    ha'ets · H6086

    tree, wood · v30

    A singular standing for the whole group, "the tree" meaning trees in general. Together with "seed of the land" it covers both halves of farm produce: what you sow every year and what grows on long-lived plants.

  33. חֲמִשִׁיתוֹ

    chamishito · H2549

    its fifth · v31

    'Its fifth', meaning a fifth of the value of the portion being bought back. This is the same 20% surcharge Leviticus applies elsewhere when holy things are bought back or misused.

  34. יֹסֵף

    yosef · H3254H

    he shall add · v31

    'He shall add'. In law this is a binding requirement: the surcharge comes on top of the base price.

  35. עָלָיו׃

    'alav · H5921A

    upon it, to it · v31

    'Upon it', meaning on top of the value of the tithe. The payment is the full value plus one fifth more.

  36. בָּקָר

    baqar · H1241

    cattle, herd · v32

    Large livestock: oxen, cows, calves. Together with the next word it covers all the domestic animals that could be offered.

  37. וָצֹאן

    watsoʾn · H6629G

    flock (sheep and goats) · v32

    Small livestock, sheep and goats together. Herd and flock side by side make a stock phrase for a household's animal wealth.

  38. יַעֲבֹר

    yaʿavor · H5674A

    to pass over, pass by, go through · v32

    The animals file past one at a time. The verb form describes a regular, repeated event: whenever the flock is counted.

  39. תַּחַת

    taḥat · H8478G

    under, beneath · v32

    Each animal walks under the counter's staff, which is held out over it or touches it as it goes by.

  40. הַשָּׁבֶט

    hashshavet · H7626G

    rod, staff, club, sceptre; tribe · v32

    The herdsman's staff used to count and mark animals. It is a working tool here, not a rod for punishment.

  41. הָעֲשִׂירִי

    haʿasiri · H6224

    tenth (ordinal) · v32

    'The tenth one': whichever animal happens to come tenth in the line. The definite article picks out that one animal.

  42. יִהְיֶה־

    yihyeh · H1961

    to be, become · v32

    'Shall be' or 'becomes'. The animal's status changes the moment it comes tenth in the count.

The world behind it

Vows and their prices. Leviticus 27 is a set of rules for voluntary vows: a worshipper in trouble or in gratitude might promise a person, an animal, a house or a field to Yahweh's sanctuary. The priest fixed a value in silver "by the sanctuary shekel" (v. 25), and most vowed things could be bought back by paying that value plus a fifth. This kept the sanctuary funded and let people keep their land and households while honoring their vows.

Three things that cannot be vowed. The chapter ends with three categories outside this system because they already belong to God by law: firstlings (v. 26–27), things "devoted" by ḥerem, an irrevocable ban (vv. 28–29), and tithes (vv. 30–33). A vow is a voluntary gift. These are owed.

Why firstlings are Yahweh's. Israel tied this claim to the Exodus. Yahweh struck the firstborn of Egypt and spared Israel's, so every male that "opens the womb" in Israel, human or animal, belongs to him (Exod 13:2, 12–15; Num 3:13). Clean firstlings (cattle, sheep, goats) were brought to the sanctuary and could not be redeemed (Num 18:17). Human firstborn were redeemed with silver (Num 18:15–16). Unclean animals such as the donkey were redeemed (Exod 13:13; Num 18:15), which is the case the next verse (v. 27) appears to take up. In a farming and herding society the first calf or lamb was real wealth, and handing it over each time was a regular, concrete acknowledgment that the herd itself was a gift from Yahweh.

From the study of Leviticus 27:26.

Where scholars differ

in v26

What exactly does the ban forbid: any vow involving a firstling, or re-assigning a firstling to a different kind of offering?

  • It forbids vowing a firstling at all as a voluntary gift, since it is already owed. This is the plain sense in the flow of Lev 27, where vows and redemption are the subject.

    The chapter's structure: vows (vv. 1–25), then three categories already owned by God (firstlings, devoted things, tithes, vv. 26–33). The closing 'it is Yahweh's' gives ownership as the reason.

  • Rabbinic readings take it more narrowly: a firstling cannot be consecrated as a *different* sacrifice (e.g. made into a burnt offering or peace offering to fulfil a vow), because it already carries its own holiness.

    Early rabbinic interpretation of Leviticus (Sifra) and the Mishnah's treatment of firstlings (Bekhorot); discussed by Milgrom (Leviticus 23–27, Anchor Bible). The two views overlap: both rest on the firstling already being holy.

in v26

Does the next verse (v. 27) about unclean animals refer to unclean *firstlings* or to any unclean animal vowed to the sanctuary, and how does it fit Exod 13:13?

  • Verse 27 continues v. 26 and deals with unclean firstlings: since they cannot be sacrificed, they are redeemed at the assessed value plus a fifth, or sold.

    Its close link to v. 26 and the parallel in Num 18:15. Many commentators (e.g. Wenham, Milgrom) read it this way while noting that it differs from Exod 13:13 (donkey redeemed with a lamb or its neck broken).

  • Verse 27 deals with unclean animals vowed in general, picking up v. 11–13, so it does not need to agree with the firstling laws of Exodus.

    Verse 27 does not repeat the word 'firstborn', and its wording echoes the earlier vow rules about unclean animals (vv. 11–13). Some interpreters prefer this reading to ease the tension with Exod 13:13.

in v28

What happened to a human being whom an owner put under the ban (v. 28), and how does that relate to v. 29's 'he shall surely be put to death'?

  • Verse 28 is about dependents, especially slaves, whom the owner transfers to permanent sanctuary service. Verse 29 is a separate case: people condemned to the ban by the community, through a court sentence (Exod 22:20, idolaters) or in war.

    The change from the owner's active verb (v. 28) to a passive with no owner (v. 29). The scope changes from 'of all that is his' to 'from humankind'. Persons do serve permanently at sanctuaries elsewhere (Josh 9:27). Num 18:14 gives ḥerem to the priests, which assumes it survives. This view is held by Milgrom and by Levine, among others.

  • The two verses are one continuous rule: a human being put under the ban, privately or otherwise, could not be bought back and had to die, a survival of archaic ban practice that the law limits but keeps.

    Verse 29 follows straight on with the same noun ḥerem and 'not shall be ransomed'. In war the ban on persons regularly meant death (Josh 6:21; 1 Sam 15:3). Some interpreters also point to vow stories such as Jephthah's (Judg 11), though that is a vow, not ḥerem.

  • Rabbinic reading: verse 29 is about a person already sentenced to death, whose assessed value cannot be vowed or paid. It does not authorise anyone to ban a person to death.

    m. Arakhin 1:3 and the Talmud's discussion of it (b. Arakhin 6b). This harmonising reading reflects later legal interpretation, not necessarily the original sense.

in v28

Who received private ḥerem: the priests personally or the sanctuary's upkeep fund?

  • The priests, as their personal share.

    Num 18:14 ('every ḥerem in Israel shall be yours'), Ezek 44:29, Lev 27:21 (the priest's holding). This is the majority position of the sages in m. Arakhin 8:6.

  • An unspecified ḥerem went to the Temple's upkeep, and only one explicitly assigned to the priests went to them.

    The view of R. Judah ben Bathyra in m. Arakhin 8:6. The verse itself only says 'to Yahweh', which does not settle the question.

in v29

Who puts a person under the ḥerem in this verse: a public or legal authority, or a private owner?

  • Public ban: holy war or a court sentence (the majority of modern commentators).

    The switch from v. 28's active "a man devotes… from all that he has" to the passive yoḥoram with no named agent. The same passive form in Exodus 22:20 for the condemned idolater. Deuteronomy 13 and the war-ban narratives (Num 21; Josh 6–7; 1 Sam 15). The capital-punishment formula môt yûmāt. Israel's laws protecting slaves' lives (Exod 21:20) make a private right to devote people to death unlikely.

  • Continuation of v. 28: a private owner who devotes a human being (e.g., a slave or captive) thereby condemns that person to death.

    Verse 28 explicitly includes "whether human" (me-ʾadam) among things a man may devote, and v. 29 picks up the same word ʾadam. Some older critical scholars read the two verses as one sequence. Jephthah's vow (Judg 11), though it uses neder ("vow"), not ḥerem, shows that vows with deadly consequences for people were imaginable. Opponents reply that v. 28 sends human ḥerem to the sanctuary (compare Num 18:14), which suggests sanctuary service rather than death.

  • Rabbinic reading: the verse concerns someone already condemned to death, whose life cannot be bought out through the valuation system.

    Mishnah Arakhin ch. 1 and Rashi on the verse. The reading fits the chapter's subject, the money valuations of vv. 2–8, and the verb "ransom", but it reads ḥerem more narrowly than its biblical usage elsewhere.

in v29

Is the ḥerem of persons a form of human sacrifice?

  • Yes, or close to it: the ban gives the deity his portion.

    The ḥerem is "to YHWH" and "most holy" (v. 28). Mesha's stele presents the slaughter of Nebo as dedicated "to Ashtar-Chemosh." Some scholars (e.g., Susan Niditch) describe one strand of the biblical ban as a sacrificial way of thinking, in which the enemy is God's share.

  • No: it is a sentence of destruction, not an altar offering.

    The verse uses the judicial execution formula môt yûmāt, not sacrificial vocabulary (zābaḥ, ʿōlāh, hiqrîb). There is no altar, priestly handling or eating. Leviticus itself condemns human sacrifice in the strongest terms (Lev 18:21; 20:2–5), and Deuteronomy 12:31 calls it an abomination. The ban is better described as removing something from human use by destroying it. Scholars such as Lohfink (TDOT) and Stern stress consecration-by-destruction and judgment rather than offering.

in v30

How does the tithe of Lev 27:30 relate to the tithe laws of Numbers 18 and Deuteronomy 14?

  • Several tithes paid together (traditional Jewish harmonisation): a "first tithe" to the Levites (Num 18), a "second tithe" eaten by the owner in Jerusalem (Deut 14:22–27), and a "poor tithe" in the third and sixth years (Deut 14:28–29). Lev 27:30–31 is taken as the general principle, applied especially to the second tithe.

    Tobit 1:6–8 and Josephus, Antiquities 4.240 describe several tithes; Jubilees 32 discusses a second tithe; the Mishnah tractates Ma'aser and Ma'aser Sheni systematise it. All of this shows Second Temple Jews practising a combined system.

  • Different laws from different times or priestly circles: Leviticus 27 and Numbers 18 come from priestly writers who direct the tithe to the sanctuary and Levites, while Deuteronomy reflects a separate reform in which the tithe became a family feast and a support for the poor.

    The texts genuinely differ on who eats the tithe and where. Only Leviticus 27:32 mentions an animal tithe. Commentators such as Milgrom (Anchor Bible) treat 27:30–33 as a closing addition to the chapter.

in v30

Was the tithe an act of worship or a tax?

  • Mainly sacred: the language of "holy" and "Yahweh's" makes it an offering acknowledging God as owner of the land.

    qodesh status; Deut 26:13–15 frames the tithe with a confession and prayer; it is eaten "before Yahweh" (Deut 14:23).

  • Also a working revenue system, like temple and royal tithes elsewhere in the ancient Near East.

    Neo-Babylonian temple tithe records; 1 Sam 8:15–17 (the king's tenth); storehouses and their administration in Neh 10:37–39, 13:10–13 and Mal 3:10. Most scholars hold that in the ancient world these two functions were not separate.

in v31

Which tithe does this verse mean?

  • The Levitical tithe of Numbers 18, the sanctuary's due given to the Levites.

    Lev 27:30 calls the tithe 'holy to the LORD', which fits a sanctuary-owned due. Num 18:21–24 likewise treats the tithe as the LORD's portion given to the Levites. Many critical commentators (e.g., Milgrom) read the Leviticus and Numbers tithe laws together.

  • The 'second tithe' that the owner eats at the sanctuary (Deut 14:22–26).

    This is the classic rabbinic reading (Mishnah Ma'aser Sheni 4:3; Sifra). It explains why the owner is the one buying it back: it is still in a sense 'his tithe' to eat in Jerusalem. The surcharge applies only when he redeems his own.

  • The tithe laws come from different periods or circles and should not be forced into one system.

    Deuteronomy allows money conversion without a surcharge, Leviticus requires one, and Numbers says nothing about it. Leviticus 27 is widely seen as an appendix that may come from a later stage of the priestly tradition.

in v31

Is 'a fifth' 20% of the original value or a fifth of the total?

  • 20% of the assessed value (the plain reading).

    'Its fifth' most naturally means a fifth of the item's value. Most modern translations (NLT: '20 percent') and commentators take it this way.

  • A fifth of the final total, i.e., 25% of the base ('a fifth from outside').

    The Talmud (b. Bava Metzia 54a) reads the added fifth so that it makes up one fifth of the whole payment. This became standard in rabbinic law.

in v32

Who received or ate the animal tithe?

  • It went to the sanctuary staff (priests and/or Levites).

    Numbers 18:21-32 gives 'the tithe' to the Levites. 'Holy to the LORD' usually means sanctuary property. Jubilees 32:15 explicitly gives the tithe of cattle and sheep to the priests. 2 Chronicles 31:4-6 presents tithes as support for priests and Levites.

  • The owners ate it at the sanctuary as a sacred meal, like the tithe in Deuteronomy.

    Deuteronomy 14:22-27 has the household eat its tithe, with its firstlings of herd and flock, before God. The Mishnah and later rabbinic law (m. Zevahim 5:8; Bekhorot 9) treat the animal tithe as an offering eaten by the owners in Jerusalem.

  • The tithe laws come from different periods or circles of Israel's history, and this verse should not be forced to match the others.

    The animal tithe appears nowhere else in the Pentateuch. Many critical scholars see Leviticus 27 as a late supplement to Leviticus and the Torah tithe laws as reflecting different times. Others think the animal tithe preserves old sanctuary practice, citing the tithe of flocks in 1 Samuel 8:17 and ancient Near Eastern temple tithes of livestock.

in v32

Did the tithe apply to the whole herd or only to the year's new animals?

  • Only to the annual increase, the newborn animals.

    Rabbinic law (Mishnah Bekhorot 9) limits it to animals born in a given period. Tithing the same adults every year would eat away the herd, and parallel tithes on produce tax the yearly yield, not the field itself.

  • The verse itself does not say.

    'All that passes under the rod' could in principle mean any counted animal. The limit to newborns is a reasonable inference from practice and from the produce parallel, but the text does not state it.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

2 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.