Mark Chapter 9 Read as one passage
Mark 9:19–20
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
19“O unbelieving generation!” Jesus replied. “How long must I remain with you? How long must I put up with you? Bring the boy to Me.” 20So they brought him, and seeing Jesus, the spirit immediately threw the boy into a convulsion. He fell to the ground and rolled around, foaming at the mouth.
What the first hearers heard
Mark's first readers would have heard Jesus speaking in the voice of Israel's own story. The God of the Exodus had asked "how long?" of a generation that saw his wonders and still would not trust him. Now Jesus asks the same question of his own generation, including his own disciples. Mark repeatedly shows the disciples failing to understand (6:52; 8:17–21), and here the failure is sharp because they had already driven out spirits before.
The lament also carries a note of departure. "How long will I be with you?" stands between two predictions of his suffering (8:31; 9:31), reminding hearers that the teacher's presence among them will not last. Yet the scene does not end in rejection. The command "Bring him to me" places the remedy in Jesus himself. In the following verses the trust that is lacking becomes the explicit theme: the father's honest cry, "I trust; help my lack of trust!" (9:24), and Jesus' word that this kind comes out only by prayer (9:29). For a community that may itself have struggled with failed attempts at healing and with persecution, the verse names their weakness bluntly and still points them back to dependence on Jesus.
From the study of Mark 9:19.
Verse by verse
-
19“O unbelieving generation!” Jesus replied. “How long must I remain with you? How long must I put up with you? Bring the boy to Me.”
Full study →Jesus turns to the whole crowd around him: the disciples who could not drive the spirit out, the scribes arguing with them, the onlookers and the desperate father. He cries out: "O generation that will not trust! How long am I to be among you? How long must I hold up under the weight of you and keep bearing with you? Bring him to me."
"Generation" means this whole people of the present age, considered as one body. The phrase deliberately echoes the Scriptures, where God laments the wilderness generation, "sons in whom there is no trust" (Deuteronomy 32:20), and asks, "How long will this people not trust me?" (Numbers 14:11). The fault named is not unbelief in the sense of rejecting a doctrine. It is a failure to rely on God's power, the dependence that shows itself in prayer (9:29). "How long will I be with you?" looks ahead: his time among them is limited, and he will soon announce his death again (9:31). "Bear with" is the language of patience under strain. It voices exhaustion and keeps enduring all the same. The lament ends at once in a command: whatever their failure, the boy is to be brought straight to him.
-
20So they brought him, and seeing Jesus, the spirit immediately threw the boy into a convulsion. He fell to the ground and rolled around, foaming at the mouth.
Full study →They brought the boy to Jesus, just as he had ordered. The moment the spirit caught sight of Jesus, it recognised him and struck back. At once it wrenched the boy's whole body in a violent spasm, the way an attacker tears at its victim. The boy dropped to the dirt and kept rolling and thrashing there, foaming at the mouth, in front of the crowd, the arguing scribes, the disciples who had failed, and his own father.
Mark does three things here:
- The trigger is Jesus' presence. The spirit attacks because it sees him, as unclean spirits do elsewhere in Mark (1:24; 3:11; 5:6–7). Mark presents this as a confrontation, not just a medical episode.
- The violence is the spirit's. The verb comes from 'tear' and is made stronger, so the spasm is something done to the boy.
- The father's words become a scene. Falling, foaming and convulsing were exactly what the father had described (9:18). The tenses switch from a single sudden attack (convulsed, fell) to ongoing action (was rolling, foaming), so the reader watches the boy's helplessness go on before Jesus speaks.
Where the English drifted
-
in v19
faithless (KJV, ESV)
apistos
- What we hear
- Disloyal or unfaithful, like a 'faithless spouse' who betrays a commitment.
- What they heard
- Lacking trust: not relying on God and his power. Here it shows up as the inability to deal with the spirit, which Jesus later connects with prayer (9:29).
-
in v19
unbelieving (BSB, NASB, WEB)
apistos
- What we hear
- Not accepting religious claims, the way an atheist or skeptic does.
- What they heard
- Everyone present believed in God. The charge is that they do not trust him or depend on him in the concrete situation.
-
in v19
how long shall I suffer you? (KJV, YLT)
anexomai
- What we hear
- How long must I endure pain because of you?
- What they heard
- How long must I put up with you, bear with you, tolerate you patiently?
-
in v20
tare (KJV, YLT)
synesparaxen
- What we hear
- 'Tare' now suggests the weight of a container or the weeds ('tares') of the parable, or it means nothing to readers today.
- What they heard
- The old past tense of 'tear'. The spirit tore at the boy, wrenching him in a violent convulsion.
-
in v20
wallowed (KJV)
ekylieto
- What we hear
- Lolling or luxuriating, like a pig in mud or someone 'wallowing in self-pity', which suggests indulgence.
- What they heard
- He was rolling and thrashing helplessly on the ground, against his will.
Every word
-
Ὁ
Ho · G3588
the; he · v19, v20
The article used as a pronoun with δέ, 'and he'. It moves the speaker from the father (v.18) to Jesus.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
and, but · v19
A light connective marking a new speaker. It is not a strong 'but'.
-
ἀποκριθεὶς
apokritheis · G0611
to answer · v19
'Answering.' Jesus is responding to the father's report that the disciples 'were not strong enough' (v.18). The answer is a lament, not information.
-
αὐτοῖς
autois · G0846
them · v19, v20
Plural, 'to them'. The reply takes in the group around him: the failed disciples, the arguing scribes and the crowd (vv.14–18), not only the father.
-
λέγει·
legei · G3004
to say · v19
'He says.' A present tense used for a past event, which Mark often does to make a scene feel vivid and immediate.
-
ὦ
ō · G5599
O! · v19
An emotional interjection. In ordinary Koine Greek speech you could address someone without it, so its presence marks strong feeling: grief and exasperation.
-
γενεὰ
genea · G1074
generation · v19
The people of this age taken together. It echoes Israel's Scriptures, where God complains about a whole 'generation' that refused to trust him in the wilderness.
-
ἄπιστος,
apistos · G0571
without trust, unbelieving · v19
Lacking pistis: trust and reliance on God, shown here in the failure to rely on God's power against the spirit. This is not about rejecting a doctrine.
-
ἕως
heōs · G2193
until · v19
First part of the idiom 'until when?' = 'how long?'
-
πότε
pote · G4219
when? · v19
Completes 'how long?', the classic phrasing of a biblical lament.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
with, toward · v19, v20
With the verb 'to be' it means 'in company with, among'. Mark uses the same phrase in 6:3 ('his sisters are here with us').
-
ὑμᾶς
hymas · G4771
you (plural) · v19
'You all', the whole group, matching 'generation'.
-
ἔσομαι;
esomai · G1510
I will be · v19
Future tense, 'will I be?'. It implies that his time among them has a limit. Just after this he predicts his death a second time (9:31).
-
ἀνέξομαι
anexomai · G0430
to bear with, endure · v19
Middle voice, 'hold myself up under', meaning to put up with or tolerate patiently. It is the language of patience under strain, not of giving up.
-
φέρετε
pherete · G5342
bring, carry · v19, v20
A plural command, 'bring!'. Right after the lament Jesus acts. The weariness ends in an order to bring the boy, not in withdrawal.
-
με.
me · G3165
me · v19
'To me', with emphasis on Jesus himself after his delegates have failed.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v20
Mark's usual way of linking one event to the next. It picks up straight from Jesus' order in 9:19, 'Bring him to me.'
-
ἰδὼν
idōn · G1492
having seen · v20
'On seeing.' The form is masculine, but 'spirit' (pneuma) is neuter in Greek. The best explanation is that Mark treats the spirit as a person who sees and reacts. Some readers take the boy as the one who sees instead (see debates).
-
πνεῦμα
pneuma · G4151
spirit, breath, wind · v20
A hostile spirit-being that has taken control of the boy. Later it is called 'mute and deaf spirit' and 'unclean spirit' (9:25). It is an agent that acts, not a mood or an attitude.
-
εὐθὺς
euthys · G2112
immediately, at once · v20
Mark's favourite word for speed, used about forty times. There is no delay at all: the spirit reacts the instant it sees Jesus.
-
συνεσπάραξεν
synesparaxen · G4952
convulse violently, tear about · v20
The spirit throws the boy into a violent, wrenching spasm. The root means to tear or rip, and the prefix makes it stronger: the whole body is pulled about.
-
πεσὼν
pesōn · G4098
fall · v20
'Having fallen,' a single sudden collapse. The father described the same thing: the spirit 'throws him down' (9:18).
-
ἐπὶ
epi · G1909
upon, on · v20
He lands 'on' the ground.
-
γῆς
gēs · G1093
earth, ground, land · v20
The bare ground or dust where the crowd stands. He is lying in the dirt in front of everyone.
-
ἐκυλίετο
ekylieto · G2947
roll, roll about · v20
'He kept rolling about.' The tense describes action still going on: the reader watches the thrashing as it continues. This is the only place the word appears in the New Testament.
-
ἀφρίζων.
aphrizōn · G0875
foam (at the mouth) · v20
'Foaming.' The present tense means the foaming goes on while he rolls. It repeats the father's word in 9:18 ('he foams'), so the father's account is now happening in front of Jesus.
The world behind it
Jesus has just come down from the mountain where he was transfigured before Peter, James and John, with Moses and Elijah beside him (9:2–13). At the foot of the mountain he finds disorder. The other nine disciples have tried and failed to free a boy from a spirit that throws him down, makes him foam, grind his teeth and go rigid (9:17–18). Scribes are arguing with them, and a crowd has gathered. This failure stands out because earlier Jesus had given the Twelve authority over unclean spirits, and they had driven many out (6:7, 13).
A reader who knew Israel's Scriptures would see the pattern. Moses also came down a mountain from God's presence and found the people below faithless (Exodus 32). The language of a whole 'generation' that would not trust God, and the cry 'how long?', come straight from the wilderness stories (Numbers 14; Deuteronomy 32). People in the ancient world explained the boy's symptoms, which modern readers often compare to epilepsy, as the work of a hostile spirit, and Mark tells the story that way.
From the study of Mark 9:19.
Where scholars differ
in v19
Whom is Jesus rebuking as 'unbelieving generation'?
-
Chiefly the disciples, who failed to drive out the spirit.
The father has just reported that 'your disciples... were not able' (v.18). In private the disciples ask why they failed (v.28), and Mark often stresses their lack of understanding (8:17–21).
-
The whole contemporary generation: crowd, scribes, father and disciples together.
The plural 'them' and the collective 'generation', together with Mark's other 'this generation' sayings (8:12, 38), point to a verdict on the age. The father also admits his own lack of trust (v.24).
-
Mainly the father (the reading of the Byzantine text 'answering him').
This rests on the later variant αὐτῷ. The plural verbs in the rest of the verse weaken it.
in v19
What kind of voice is Jesus using?
-
God's own lament over Israel, placed in Jesus' mouth.
There are close verbal echoes of God's complaints in Num 14:11, 27 and Deut 32:5, 20. In LXX Isa 46:4 God says 'I bear with (ἀνέχομαι) you'.
-
A prophet's weariness, like Moses or Elijah.
The scene immediately follows the transfiguration with Moses and Elijah. Moses descends to a faithless people (Exod 32), and Elijah voices exhaustion (1 Kgs 19).
-
Genuine human exasperation.
Mark freely shows Jesus' emotions (3:5; 8:12; 10:14). These readings are not mutually exclusive, and many commentators combine them.
in v19
Does 'How long will I be with you?' point to his coming death?
-
Yes. It hints at his limited time before his departure.
The verse sits between the passion predictions of 8:31 and 9:31, and the future tense 'will I be' implies an end point.
-
It is primarily the conventional language of lament, not a specific prediction.
'How long?' is a stock formula of biblical complaint (Ps 13; Num 14) and need not carry a coded reference.
in v20
Who 'saw' whom: the spirit or the boy?
-
The spirit saw Jesus and reacted (most commentators and modern versions).
Mark treats spirits as persons in his grammar elsewhere (masculine participles in 9:26). Unclean spirits 'seeing' Jesus is a pattern in Mark (3:11; 5:6). The word order puts τὸ πνεῦμα right after the participle.
-
The boy saw Jesus, and then the spirit convulsed him. The sentence switches subject partway through.
A masculine participle would normally refer to a masculine subject, and the boy is the masculine person in the scene. Mark's Greek sometimes changes subject loosely. The KJV and YLT can be read this way.
in v20
How should the boy's condition be understood?
-
Mark presents a real case of spirit possession whose symptoms looked like seizures.
The text attributes muteness, deafness and convulsions to a spirit that 'sees', is commanded and 'comes out' (9:17–26). Jesus addresses it directly. The story is told as an exorcism.
-
The symptoms describe what we now call epilepsy, and the Gospel writers interpreted it in their culture's terms for spirits.
The symptoms closely match ancient medical descriptions of the 'sacred disease'. Matthew uses the popular term for seizures, 'moonstruck' (17:15). Some scholars, writing as physicians, have analysed the account in these terms.
-
A middle position: the evangelists do not treat every seizure as demonic, but they present this case as one.
Matthew 4:24 lists 'demon-possessed' and 'moonstruck' as separate categories of people who were healed. That suggests the Gospels did not simply equate the two.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. γενεά, ἄπιστος, ἀνέχω
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. ἀνέχω
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk (BDF) §146 on the vocative with ὦ
- Septuagint: Num 14:11, 27; Deut 32:5, 20; Isa 1:13; 46:4
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NICGT)
- J. Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (on Mark 9:19)
- Vulgate, Mark 9:19
- BDAG s.v. συσπαράσσω, σπαράσσω, κυλίω, ἀφρίζω, πνεῦμα
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. συσπαράσσω
- Hippocratic Corpus, On the Sacred Disease
- Josephus, Antiquities 8.45–49
- 1 Enoch 15–16; Jubilees 10; Dead Sea Scrolls 4Q560, 11Q11
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- Vincent Taylor, The Gospel According to St. Mark
- NA28 critical apparatus; Robinson–Pierpont Byzantine text
- Vulgate (Weber–Gryson)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).