Romans Chapter 2 Read as one passage

Romans 2:19–20

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

19if you are convinced that you are a guide for the blind, a light for those in darkness, 20an instructor of the foolish, a teacher of infants, because you have in the law the embodiment of knowledge and truth—

What the first hearers heard

To Roman believers, Jewish and gentile, who knew the synagogue, these titles sounded familiar and honourable. They were Isaiah's words for Israel's role among the nations, words Jewish teachers really did use of themselves. A Jewish hearer would at first agree with the list: yes, the law does make us guides and lights.

The list is a setup, though. The sentence never resolves. Instead Paul asks: do you who teach against stealing steal? Do you who forbid adultery commit it? (vv. 21–23). The point lands in v. 24: through such conduct God's name is dishonoured among the very gentiles the "light" was meant to enlighten. For the first audience, this verse affirmed the calling and also prepared them to see that having the calling, and being sure you have it, is not the same as fulfilling it. That serves Paul's larger argument in Romans 2–3: Jews and gentiles stand on the same footing before God's impartial judgment (2:11; 3:9, 22–23).

From the study of Romans 2:19.

Verse by verse

  1. 19if you are convinced that you are a guide for the blind, a light for those in darkness,

    Paul is speaking directly to an imagined Jewish teacher (or someone who calls himself a Jew, v. 17) and listing what that person is sure of:

    "…and you are settled in the conviction that you, yes you yourself, are the one who takes blind people by the hand and leads them along the road, a light for people sitting in darkness…"

    Each phrase comes from the vocabulary of Israel's calling in Isaiah. There God's servant is made "a light to the nations, to open blind eyes… to bring out those who sit in darkness" (Isa 42:6–7; 49:6). The "blind" and "those in darkness" are the nations who do not yet know the one God. The "guide" and "light" is Israel, holding God's law (v. 20 calls it "the embodiment of knowledge and truth").

    The word for "confident" means having been persuaded and staying that way: a settled reliance, the same kind of reliance as "you rely on the law" in v. 17. The stress on "you yourself" is deliberate. Paul is building a long "if…" sentence (vv. 17–20) that he never finishes as a sentence. He breaks off in v. 21 and turns the list into questions: "You then who teach others, do you not teach yourself?" So this verse is a true description of a high calling, set up so that Paul can ask whether the person who claims it actually lives it. That turn is sharper for anyone who remembered that in Isaiah the servant who was to cure blindness is himself called blind (Isa 42:19).

    Full study →
  2. 20an instructor of the foolish, a teacher of infants, because you have in the law the embodiment of knowledge and truth—

    Paul is speaking to an imagined Jewish conversation partner ("if you call yourself a Jew…", v. 17) and is still listing the roles this person is confident he holds. Verse 19 gave "a guide for the blind, a light for those in darkness". Verse 20 adds: a trainer and corrector of the senseless, a teacher of those who are still infants in the knowledge of God. Then comes the reason behind the whole list: because in the Torah you possess the real, concrete embodiment of knowledge and of truth. That means knowing God and his will, and the reality about God that the nations pushed away (1:18, 25), set down in shaped, written form.

    Paul does not call these claims empty. "Form" here does not mean a hollow shell. It means knowledge and truth given a shape you can hold, read and teach. The roles echo Israel's calling in Isaiah to be "a light to the nations" and to "open the eyes of the blind" (Isa 42:6–7). The picture is a parent-educator raising children: someone who both teaches content and corrects behaviour.

    The sentence is built as the long "if" half of a statement (vv. 17–20), and Paul never finishes it. He breaks off and turns the list into questions: "You, then, who teach another, do you not teach yourself?" (v. 21). Verse 20 is the high point of the privilege. Paul builds it up honestly so that the gap between possessing God's truth and living it is unmistakable.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v19

    a light for those in darkness

    phōs tōn en skotei

    What we hear
    Someone who cheers up people who are sad or going through hard times, or more loosely a good example to 'lost' people in general.
    What they heard
    A fixed phrase from Isaiah (42:6–7; 49:6; 9:2). It describes Israel's calling to bring knowledge of the one true God to the nations, who were seen as living in ignorance and idolatry.
  • in v20

    the form (of knowledge and of the truth)

    morphōsis

    What we hear
    A mere outward form, a formality or appearance without substance, like the 'form of godliness' that denies its power (2 Tim 3:5).
    What they heard
    The concrete embodiment or formulation of something: knowledge and truth actually given shape in the law. Here it is meant positively.
  • in v20

    the law

    nomos

    What we hear
    A legal code of rules, or law in general, a principle of moral obligation.
    What they heard
    The Torah given through Moses: Israel's God-given instruction (commandments together with the scriptural teaching around them), which Jews studied and taught and which set them apart from the nations.
Every word
  1. πέποιθάς

    pepoithas · G3982

    to persuade; (perfect) to be confident, rely on · v19

    The perfect tense of 'persuade' means 'I have been persuaded and stay persuaded', so: you are settled in your conviction, you rely on this. It describes a firm, lasting stance, not a passing feeling.

  2. τε

    te · G5037

    and, both · v19

    A small, tight link word that adds this clause to the list of the interlocutor's privileges begun in vv. 17–18 ('you call yourself a Jew… rely on the law… boast in God… know his will… and you are confident…').

  3. σεαυτὸν

    seauton · G4771

    yourself · v19

    Stressed: 'you yourself'. Paul puts the spotlight on the person's self-image. This prepares for the sharp turn in v. 21: 'you who teach someone else, do you not teach yourself?'

  4. ὁδηγὸν

    hodēgon · G3595

    guide, one who leads the way · v19

    Literally 'one who leads along the road' (from hodos, 'road', and agō, 'lead'). The picture is someone taking a person who cannot see by the hand and walking them along the right path.

  5. εἶναι

    einai · G1511

    to be · v19

    'To be': what the person is convinced they are. It completes 'you are confident that you yourself are…'.

  6. τυφλῶν,

    tuphlōn · G5185

    blind · v19

    'Of blind people.' Here it is a picture of people who do not know God or his will, in Jewish usage above all the non-Jewish nations, using Isaiah's language (Isa 42:7).

  7. φῶς

    phōs · G5457

    light · v19

    'A light', the same role God gives his servant Israel in Isaiah 42:6 and 49:6, 'a light to the nations'. The person sees themselves as the one who brings God's revelation to others.

  8. τῶν

    tōn · G3588

    the · v19, v20

    Used with 'in darkness' to mean 'those who are in darkness'. It makes the phrase into a description of a group of people.

  9. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v19, v20

    'In': it describes where those people are, inside darkness, surrounded by it.

  10. σκότει,

    skotei · G4655

    darkness · v19

    Darkness as ignorance of God, idolatry and moral confusion. It echoes Isaiah's 'those who sit in darkness' (Isa 42:7; 9:2), people waiting for God's light to reach them.

  11. παιδευτὴν

    paideutēn · G3810

    instructor, trainer, corrector · v20

    Someone who brings up and trains another, including correcting and disciplining them, the way a parent or tutor shapes a child. It continues the list of roles in verse 19 that the person 'is convinced' they hold, so it is grammatically the thing 'you are convinced you are.'

  12. ἀφρόνων

    aphronōn · G0878

    foolish, senseless · v20

    People without sound judgment or practical good sense. In the flow of Romans it points to the non-Jewish nations, whom Paul has just described in chapter 1 as having 'darkened' minds and becoming fools.

  13. διδάσκαλον

    didaskalon · G1320

    teacher · v20

    The ordinary word for a teacher, the one who passes on content. Paired with 'trainer,' it makes the picture of someone who both informs and forms others.

  14. νηπίων

    nēpiōn · G3516

    infant, young child, immature person · v20

    Literally a small child; figuratively someone untaught or immature. Here, people who are beginners in knowing God, most likely outsiders drawn to Israel's God and its way of life.

  15. ἔχοντα

    echonta · G2192

    having, possessing · v20

    A present participle ('having') that gives the ground of the whole list: you can claim to guide, enlighten, train and teach others because you possess something real. BSB brings this out with 'because you have.'

  16. μόρφωσιν

    morphōsin · G3446

    embodiment, formulation, outward form · v20

    The giving of shape to something, so that it exists in a concrete, graspable form. Here it means that knowledge and truth are actually set down and given shape in the law, not that the law is a hollow shell.

  17. γνώσεως

    gnōseōs · G1108

    knowledge · v20

    Knowledge of God and of what he requires. Verse 18 has already said the person 'knows the will' and is 'instructed out of the law.'

  18. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v20

    Joins 'knowledge' and 'truth' as two sides of what the law gives shape to.

  19. ἀληθείας

    alētheias · G0225

    truth · v20

    What is real and reliable about God, not only correct statements but God's faithful reality and the right way of life that follows from it.

  20. νόμῳ

    nomō · G3551

    law · v20

    The Torah given through Moses: Israel's God-given instruction, both its commandments and the scriptural teaching around them. Not law in general.

The world behind it

Paul's debating style. From Romans 2:1 onward Paul uses a well-known teaching style of his day called the diatribe: he speaks to an imaginary partner ("you…"), voices that partner's claims, and then asks probing questions. In 2:17 he addresses "you who call yourself a Jew". Verses 17–20 list that person's real privileges: the law, knowledge of God's will, the ability to tell what matters, and a calling to guide and teach others.

Jewish teachers and gentile seekers in Rome. Rome had a large Jewish community, and many non-Jews were drawn to synagogues, monotheism and the moral teaching of the law. Jewish writings of the period present the law as a light meant for all humanity: Wisdom 18:4, Testament of Levi 14:4, Philo, On Abraham 98, and Josephus, Against Apion 2.282, 2.293. Calling oneself "a guide of the blind, a light to those in darkness" fitted this picture of Jewish teachers instructing interested gentiles.

A known scandal. Josephus (Antiquities 18.81–84) tells of a Jewish teacher in Rome who persuaded a noble convert, Fulvia, to send gifts to the Jerusalem Temple and then kept them. According to Josephus, this led Emperor Tiberius to expel Jews from Rome in 19 CE. Some scholars think stories like this lie behind Paul's charges in vv. 21–22 ("do you rob temples?"). They show how a would-be "guide" could bring shame on God's name before gentiles (v. 24). This is possible background, not something the text names.

Isaiah behind the words. The vocabulary of v. 19 (blind, light, darkness) comes straight from Isaiah 42 and 49, where God's servant is called to be "a light to the nations". First-century Jewish hearers would have recognised these phrases as Scripture's own words about Israel's mission.

From the study of Romans 2:19.

Where scholars differ

in v19

Who is the 'you' Paul addresses in vv. 17–20?

  • Jews in general, or the typical Jewish person confident in the covenant and the law.

    The opening 'you call yourself a Jew' (v. 17) and the following discussion of circumcision and of 'the Jew' (2:25–3:2) suggest a general representative. This is the traditional reading and is held by many commentators (e.g. Moo, Dunn, with nuances).

  • A specific type: a Jewish teacher who instructs gentiles.

    The roles listed (guide, light, instructor of the foolish, teacher of infants, vv. 19–20) describe a teaching role, not every Jew. Paul's diatribe style typically addresses a type of person. Argued especially by Stanley Stowers (A Rereading of Romans).

  • A gentile who has adopted Judaism and 'calls himself a Jew'.

    'Call yourself' (eponomazō) may suggest a name taken on rather than inherited. Romans is addressed mainly to gentiles (1:5–6, 13; 11:13). Argued by Runar Thorsteinsson (Paul's Interlocutor in Romans 2) and Rafael Rodríguez (If You Call Yourself a Jew). Critics answer that 2:25–3:2 seems to assume a born Jew.

in v19

Is Paul being sarcastic in listing these titles, or affirming a genuine calling?

  • Mainly ironic or exposing pride: Paul quotes the interlocutor's boasting to deflate it.

    The context speaks of 'boasting' (vv. 17, 23). The stress on 'you yourself' and the immediate turn to hypocrisy (vv. 21–24) suggest the titles are being used against the speaker.

  • A real scriptural vocation that Paul affirms, with the failure to live it as his target.

    The titles are Isaiah's own language for Israel (42:6–7; 49:6). Paul elsewhere affirms Jewish advantages (3:1–2; 9:4–5) and applies the 'light to the nations' calling to his own mission (Acts 13:47). His charge in vv. 21–24 concerns conduct, not the calling itself. Stressed by Dunn and N. T. Wright, among others.

in v20

Is 'the embodiment (morphōsis) of knowledge and truth' meant sincerely or ironically?

  • Sincere. The law truly embodies knowledge and truth, and Paul affirms this. His critique targets the gap between having it and doing it.

    BDAG's sense 'embodiment, formulation'. Paul's positive statements about the law (Rom 3:2; 7:12, 14; 9:4). Verses 21–24 attack conduct, not the content of the law. This is the majority view of modern commentators (e.g. Cranfield, Dunn, Moo, Jewett).

  • Ironic or limiting. Paul hints that the interlocutor has only an outward shape of knowledge, a semblance without inner reality.

    The only other New Testament use (2 Tim 3:5) is negative. The whole list depends on 'you are convinced' (v. 19), which could suggest self-delusion. Some older interpreters took 'form' as 'appearance'. Against this: nothing else in vv. 17–20 is mocking, and the irony arises only in v. 21.

in v20

Who is the 'you' who calls himself a Jew and claims to teach the foolish?

  • A representative Jew, or Jewish teacher, standing for Israel's confidence in its privileges.

    'You call yourself a Jew' (v. 17), reliance on the law, and Isaiah's 'light to the nations' language. This is the traditional and still majority reading.

  • A specific kind of Jewish teacher who seeks to instruct non-Jews in the law, whose own conduct undermines his mission.

    The roles are all outward-facing (teaching blind, foolish, infants), and v. 24 mentions the nations. Argued by Stanley Stowers (A Rereading of Romans, 1994).

  • A non-Jew who has adopted Jewish identity and the law and now 'calls himself a Jew' and teaches other non-Jews.

    The verb 'call yourself' (eponomazē) might suggest a name taken on rather than born into. This fits Romans' address to non-Jewish readers (1:5–6, 13; 11:13). Argued by Runar Thorsteinsson (2003) and Rafael Rodríguez (2014). Critics answer that 'call yourself a Jew' is a natural way to describe any Jew's self-identification.

in v20

Who are the 'infants' (nēpioi)?

  • Non-Jewish converts or sympathizers, beginners in Israel's faith.

    This fits the outward-facing roles and the Isaianic 'light to the nations'. Later rabbinic texts compare a proselyte to a newborn child (b. Yevamot 22a), though that is centuries after Paul.

  • Anyone untaught, Jewish children and the uninstructed included, with no specific technical reference.

    Nēpios is an ordinary word for the immature in Greek moral writing and in Paul (1 Cor 3:1; Gal 4:1–3). There is no first-century evidence that it was a technical term for converts.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).