2 Samuel Chapter 21 Read as one passage

2 Samuel 21:20–21

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

20And there was also a battle at Gath, where there was a man of great stature with six fingers on each hand and six toes on each foot—twenty-four in all. He too was descended from Rapha, 21and when he taunted Israel, Jonathan the son of David’s brother Shimei killed him.

What the first hearers heard

To Israelites hearing David's story, this short notice did several things:

  • It closed an old fear. The giants who had made the spies feel "like grasshoppers" (Num 13:33) and who survived in Philistine Gath (Josh 11:22) are shown dying one by one. They are not killed by David alone but by men of his household and army. This champion falls to David's nephew Jonathan.
  • It echoed Goliath. A huge man from Gath who "taunted Israel" (v. 21 uses the same verb, ḥaraf, as 1 Sam 17:10, 25–26, 36, 45) is struck down. The Goliath pattern repeats, and Israel's victory over Philistine champions becomes lasting rather than a single miracle.
  • It honoured David's warriors. Lists like this kept alive the names and family ties of the men who made David's kingdom secure. Belonging to David's line (Jonathan son of Shimei, David's brother) is part of the honour.
  • It marked the enemy as uncanny. The enormous size, the twenty-four counted digits and the ancestry from the Rapha all made him an opponent from the edge of the ordinary world. That made his defeat all the more worth remembering.

From the study of 2 Samuel 21:20.

Verse by verse

  1. 20And there was also a battle at Gath, where there was a man of great stature with six fingers on each hand and six toes on each foot—twenty-four in all. He too was descended from Rapha,

    Yet again there was fighting, this time at Gath itself, the Philistine city that was Goliath's home. A champion stood there, a man of enormous size. The Hebrew calls him literally a "man of measure", and the unusual word used can also suggest a "man of strife". He had a body people would remember. There were six fingers on each hand and six toes on each foot, and the narrator counts them for us: twenty-four in all. And he too, like the champions in the battles before, belonged to the line of the Rapha. That was the ancient warrior race of legend, the Rephaim, whose last survivors were said to linger in Philistine towns like Gath.

    The verse is building toward v. 21. This frightening figure taunts Israel, as Goliath once did, and he is killed by David's own nephew, Jonathan son of Shimei. The sentence keeps returning to "again" and "he too" to show this was one of a set: four "sons of the Rapha" from Gath, each brought down by an ordinary man from David's circle (v. 22).

    Full study →
  2. 21and when he taunted Israel, Jonathan the son of David’s brother Shimei killed him.

    "He hurled his scorn at Israel, and Jonathan, son of Shimeah, David's own brother, struck him down."

    The man in question is the giant of verse 20, a huge Philistine fighter from Gath with six fingers on each hand and six toes on each foot, counted among the descendants of "the Rapha". The Hebrew verb for what he did means more than "opposed" or "disobeyed". He reviled Israel: he shouted contempt across the battle line to shame the Israelite army and the God whose army it was. It is the same word used for Goliath's challenge, so an Israelite hearer would at once think "another Goliath from Gath."

    The Hebrew uses no "when" or "because". It simply runs one action into the next, he taunted… and he was struck, so the killing lands as the direct reply to the insult. The man who answers is not the king but his nephew Jonathan, son of Jesse's third son. The family that produced the boy who silenced Goliath produces another champion. The disgrace the giant tried to put on Israel ends with him.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v20

    born to the giant (KJV, WEB)

    yullad leharafah

    What we hear
    The son of one particular giant, perhaps Goliath, or a 'giant' in the fairy-tale or mythic sense.
    What they heard
    Descended from (or belonging to) the Rapha, the namesake ancestor of the Rephaim, a remembered warrior people of great size. It names a clan and lineage. It is not a description of one father, and it says nothing about a mythic species.
  • in v21

    defied (KJV, WEB)

    vaychareph (charaph)

    What we hear
    Refused to obey or resisted; stood up against.
    What they heard
    Taunted, reviled, insulted: shouted contempt meant to bring public disgrace on Israel, and by extension on Israel's God.
Every word
  1. וַתְּהִי־

    vattehi · H1961

    and there was · v20

    The standard way Hebrew storytelling moves forward: 'and there came to be'. It is feminine because it agrees with 'war' (milḥamah), which comes after it.

  2. עוֹד

    ʿod · H5750

    again, still · v20

    'Yet again'. It ties this fight to the run of Philistine battles in vv. 15, 18 and 19. This is the fourth and last.

  3. מִלְחָמָה

    milḥamah · H4421

    war, battle · v20

    A battle or armed clash. Here it means one engagement in the ongoing border war with the Philistines, not a full campaign.

  4. בְּגַת

    begat · H1661

    at Gath · v20

    Gath was one of the five main Philistine cities and Goliath's hometown (1 Sam 17:4). Israel is fighting at the enemy's home ground, where tradition said the last of the giant clans lived (Josh 11:22).

  5. אִישׁ

    ʾish · H0376G

    man · v20

    'A man of…'. It is linked to the next word to describe what kind of man he was.

  6. מָדוֹן

    madon · H4067

    stature, size · v20

    An unusual word. The parallel in 1 Chr 20:6 has middah ('measure'), so the sense is 'a man of measure', meaning a very tall man. Spelled the same way, madon elsewhere means 'strife', and some have heard a pun: a 'man of size' who was also a 'man of contention'.

  7. וְאֶצְבְּעֹת

    veʾetsbeʿot · H0676

    fingers · v20

    'And the fingers of…'. Hebrew uses the same word for fingers and toes.

  8. יָדָיו

    yadav · H3027G

    his hands · v20

    'His two hands'. The form is dual, the Hebrew form for a natural pair.

  9. רַגְלָיו

    raglav · H7272

    his feet · v20

    'His two feet' (dual). It pairs with 'his two hands' to cover all four limbs.

  10. שֵׁשׁ

    shesh · H8337

    six · v20

    Six digits.

  11. עֶשְׂרִים

    ʿesrim · H6242

    twenty · v20

    First part of the total.

  12. וְאַרְבַּע

    veʾarbaʿ · H0702

    and four · v20

    'Twenty and four' is the Hebrew order for twenty-four.

  13. מִסְפָּר

    mispar · H4557

    number · v20

    'In number'. The narrator does the counting for us, as you would when recording something remarkable.

  14. וְגַם־

    vegam · H1571

    and also · v20

    'He too'. It puts him in the same group as Ishbi-benob and Saph in vv. 16 and 18, who are also called descendants of the Rapha.

  15. הוּא

    hu · H1931

    he · v20

    An emphatic 'he'. The pronoun is not needed for the grammar, so including it stresses that this man too belongs to the line.

  16. יֻלַּד

    yullad · H3205

    was born · v20

    A passive form: 'was born, was begotten'. With 'to' (le-) it names who someone was born to. It can mean direct parentage or, more loosely, membership in a lineage.

  17. לְהָרָפָה

    leharafah · H7497A

    to the Rapha · v20

    'To the Rapha', with the definite article. Rapha is the ancestor or namesake of the Rephaim, a people Israel remembered as huge ancient warriors (Deut 2:10–11, 20; 3:11). It is a clan name, not the English word 'giant' as such.

  18. וַיְחָרֵ֖ף

    vaychareph · H2778A

    to taunt, reproach, scorn · v21

    The giant of verse 20 hurls insults at Israel. This is the same verb used for Goliath's challenge in 1 Samuel 17, so the scene deliberately echoes it: verbal contempt aimed at Israel's honour, and by implication at Israel's God.

  19. אֶת־

    et- · H0853

    [marks the direct object] · v21

    An untranslatable particle that marks 'Israel' as the target of the taunting.

  20. יִשְׂרָאֵ֑ל

    Yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v21

    Israel as a people, here in practice the Israelite fighting force drawn up facing the Philistines. The insult falls on the whole group, not on one soldier.

  21. וַיַּכֵּ֙הוּ֙

    vayyakkehu · H5221

    to strike, strike down · v21

    'And he struck him': a deadly blow, as verse 22 confirms ('they fell'). The 'and' that runs straight on from the taunt makes the killing read as the answer to the insult.

  22. יְה֣וֹנָתָ֔ן

    Yehonatan · H3083O

    Jonathan ('YHWH has given') · v21

    David's nephew. This is not Saul's son Jonathan, though both men are remembered for beating Philistines.

  23. בֶּן־

    ben- · H1121A

    son of · v21

    Literally 'son of'. It names Jonathan by his father and so places him inside David's own family.

  24. שִׁמְעָ֖ה

    Shim'ah (written Shim'i) · H8093

    Shimeah · v21

    David's older brother, the third son of Jesse. The consonants are spelled 'Shimei' but scribal tradition reads 'Shimeah', and elsewhere he is called Shimea or Shammah.

  25. אֲחִ֥י

    achi · H0251G

    brother of · v21

    Here it means a real full brother. The phrase belongs to Shimeah, so Jonathan is David's nephew.

  26. דָוִֽד׃

    David · H1732

    David · v21

    The king. Naming him at the very end ties this victory to David's house and prepares for verse 22: 'by the hand of David and by the hand of his servants.'

The world behind it

An appendix of war stories. 2 Samuel 21–24 is a collection of short pieces added after the main story of David's reign: a famine story, lists of heroes, songs, a census. Verses 15–22 are a brief catalogue of four duels against Philistine champions "born to the Rapha". Ishbi-benob nearly kills the aging David and is struck down by Abishai (vv. 15–17). Saph is killed by Sibbecai (v. 18). Goliath, or Goliath's brother, is killed by Elhanan (v. 19, compare 1 Chr 20:5). The six-fingered man is killed by Jonathan (vv. 20–21).

Gath. Gath was one of the five Philistine city-states. It is generally identified with Tell es-Safi, where excavations have revealed a large and powerful Iron Age city. Joshua 11:22 says the Anakim, a giant people grouped with the Rephaim in Deuteronomy 2, survived only in Gaza, Gath and Ashdod. So when Israelites heard of giants at Gath, they heard of the last remnant of the race whose size had once frightened them away from the land (Num 13:28–33; Deut 1:28).

The Rephaim. Israel remembered the Rephaim as a huge and ancient people (Deut 2:10–11; 3:11, Og's enormous iron bed). The same word also named the shades of the dead (Isa 14:9). Texts from Ugarit speak of the rpum as heroic dead warrior-ancestors. To a first hearer, "born to the Rapha" did not mean only a tall family. It meant heroes out of the deep past, the old enemies of the conquest stories.

Remarkable bodies. Ancient peoples watched unusual births closely. Mesopotamian omen collections list births with extra digits. Counting the twenty-four digits marks the man as a wonder, the sort of opponent people would tell stories about.

From the study of 2 Samuel 21:20.

Where scholars differ

in v20

What does 'born to the Rapha' mean?

  • Descent from a giant ancestor or clan: the Rapha is the namesake ancestor of the Rephaim, and these men belong to that line.

    The Rephaim are a remembered giant people (Deut 2:10–11, 20–21; 3:11). Anakim survived in Gath (Josh 11:22). Ordinary 'born to X' language is used of lineage (Gen 10:21). 'Man of measure' and the huge weapons (vv. 16, 19) fit a people known for size.

  • Membership in a warrior group dedicated to a god Rapha (for example F. Willesen 1958; C. L'Heureux 1976).

    'Born to / sons of' can mark membership in a group ('sons of the prophets'). Ugaritic texts link the rpum and the god Rapiu with warrior-heroes. Four men from one city being all 'born to the Rapha' reads naturally as a corps. Critics answer that the Hebrew elsewhere links Rapha/Rephaim to physical size and ancestry, and that a cult-guild reading is speculative.

in v20

What does madon mean here?

  • 'Stature', a byform of, or slip for, middah ('measure').

    The parallel 1 Chr 20:6 has ʾish middah. The same phrase is used of large men in Num 13:32 and 1 Chr 11:23. The reading tradition (qere) gives madon.

  • A word or name of another kind: 'strife' (a pun), or a gentilic such as 'Madonite/Midianite'.

    Madon commonly means 'strife'. The written consonants מדין look like 'Midian'. Madon is a town in Josh 11:1. Some Greek witnesses seem to treat the word as a name. None of these explains the Chronicles parallel as well.

in v21

What does 'born to the Rapha' (yullad la-rapha, vv. 20, 22) mean for this giant's identity?

  • Physical descent from a giant ancestor or giant people, the Rephaim, so the man was literally of 'giant stock'.

    The Rephaim are presented as a race of giants (Deut 2:10–11, 20–21; 3:11). The description of this man's size and extra fingers and toes fits that picture. Most translations take it this way.

  • Membership in an elite warrior group devoted to a god or patron called Rapha, so 'born to' means 'dedicated to' rather than biological descent.

    Proposed by F. Willesen (1958) and C. L'Heureux (1976). They point to the article ('the Rapha'), the unusual passive form of the verb, and Ugaritic texts where the rpum are a group of heroic or dead figures. The idea is debated and has not been widely accepted.

in v21

Is Jonathan son of Shimeah the same person as Jonadab son of Shimeah (2 Sam 13:3, 32)?

  • Two different sons of Shimeah, so Jonathan and Jonadab were brothers.

    The names are different and the roles are very different (a warrior here, a shrewd courtier there). Chronicles also has 'Jonathan' in the parallel to this verse. This is the majority view.

  • The same man, with one name a variant or garbled form of the other.

    The two names are similar (Yehonatan / Yehonadab), and both men are 'son of Shimeah, David's brother'. Some ancient witnesses to 2 Samuel 13 have 'Jonathan', which keeps the question open.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. מָדוֹן, רָפָא, יָלַד
  • HALOT s.v. מָדוֹן II, רְפָאִים
  • Strong's H4067, H7497, H3205, H0676
  • P. K. McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9), on 2 Sam 21:15–22
  • F. Willesen, 'The Philistine Corps of the Scimitar from Gath', Journal of Semitic Studies 3 (1958)
  • C. E. L'Heureux, 'The yelîdê hārāpâ — A Cultic Association of Warriors', BASOR 221 (1976)
  • E. Leichty, The Omen Series Šumma Izbu (1970)
  • Ugaritic texts on the rpum (KTU 1.20–1.22, 1.108, 1.161)
  • Tell es-Safi/Gath Archaeological Project reports (A. M. Maeir)
  • 1 Chronicles 20:4–8 (parallel account)
  • BDB s.v. חָרַף
  • HALOT s.v. חרף II
  • HALOT s.v. נכה
  • P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9)
  • C. E. L'Heureux, 'The yelîdê hārāpā—A Cultic Association of Warriors', BASOR 221 (1976)
  • E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (on the written and read forms of the text)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 21:15–22
  • 1 Chronicles 20:4–8 (parallel text)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).