Numbers Chapter 15 Read as one passage

Numbers 15:27–31

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

27Also, if one person sins unintentionally, he is to present a year-old female goat as a sin offering. 28And the priest shall make atonement before the LORD on behalf of the person who erred by sinning unintentionally; and when atonement has been made for him, he will be forgiven. 29You shall have the same law for the one who acts in error, whether he is a native-born Israelite or a foreigner residing among you. 30But the person who sins defiantly, whether a native or foreigner, blasphemes the LORD. That person shall be cut off from among his people. 31He shall certainly be cut off, because he has despised the word of the LORD and broken His commandment; his guilt remains on him.”

What the first hearers heard

To Israelites hearing this as the next generation after the spy disaster, the verse said several things:

  • Mistakes were expected. A people living with a holy God among them would still break His commands without meaning to. The law did not pretend otherwise. It built a remedy in ahead of time, for life "when you enter the land."
  • The individual counts. After providing for national error (vv. 22–26), the law turns to "one person". No one's private slip is beneath notice, and no one is left without a remedy.
  • Error still has weight. Doing wrong by mistake is not nothing. It breaks a command, it stains, and it costs a valuable animal to put right. Intention reduces the seriousness but does not erase the fact.
  • The way back is to approach. The person "brings near" an offering, the priest makes atonement, and "he will be forgiven" (v. 28). Forgiveness is stated as a promise, in the passive, with God as the one who forgives.
  • One law for all. Verse 29 applies the same provision to the resident foreigner. Access to cleansing did not depend on birth.
  • A sharp boundary. The next verses (30–31) say that defiant, contemptuous rejection of the LORD's word has no such remedy. The hearer is made to see the difference between straying from the path and refusing it. The Sabbath-breaker story (vv. 32–36) then drives that home.

From the study of Numbers 15:27.

Verse by verse

  1. 27Also, if one person sins unintentionally, he is to present a year-old female goat as a sin offering.

    "And if a single person, just one individual, goes wrong by mistake, that person is to bring near to the LORD a she-goat in its first year, as a chattat, the offering that cleanses away the wrong."

    Several things sit in the Hebrew that English flattens:

    • "One person" is set deliberately against the case before it (vv. 22–26), where the whole community had erred together. The law moves from the nation to the lone individual: each person's mistake is also provided for.
    • "Person" (nefesh) means a living human being, the whole self. It does not mean an inner "soul" separate from the body, as the KJV's "any soul" may now suggest. Verse 29 extends the same rule to the foreigner living in Israel.
    • "Sins" means really breaking one of the LORD's commands (v. 22). It is a concrete act, a missing of the mark. "By mistake" (bishgagah) covers not knowing the act was wrong, not realising what one was doing, or a careless slip. It is the opposite of the defiant, "high-handed" sin of v. 30, for which no offering is given.
    • "Bring near" is the language of approaching the sanctuary. The one who erred is told to come close, not to stay away.
    • "A she-goat, daughter of its year" is a healthy young female in its first year. It was a real loss to a household, since she would have given milk and kids, but an ordinary family could afford it.
    • "For a chattat" comes from the same root as "sins": if she sins … she brings a sin-thing. The chattat was the cleansing sacrifice. Its blood was put on the altar, and the next verse gives its result: the priest "makes atonement" and the person "will be forgiven."

    The verse says that a real wrong done by mistake still matters and must be dealt with, and that God has provided a way for it to be cleansed and forgiven.

    Full study →
  2. 28And the priest shall make atonement before the LORD on behalf of the person who erred by sinning unintentionally; and when atonement has been made for him, he will be forgiven.

    "And the priest shall carry out the cleansing, ransoming rite before Yahweh for the person who went astray, who fell into a sin by mistake. He shall perform that rite on the person's behalf, and the person will be pardoned."

    A fuller reading brings out what the Hebrew packs in:

    • The priest's act is a ritual, not a speech or a feeling. "Make atonement" stands for a concrete procedure. The worshipper brings a year-old female goat (v. 27). The priest slaughters it, daubs its blood on the horns of the altar, and burns its fat (Lev 4:28–31). The word suggests wiping away pollution and ransoming a life, so that the wrong no longer stands between the person and the God whose house is among them.
    • The person "strayed". The Hebrew piles up the same root, roughly "the one erring in a sin by erring," to make it unmistakable that this was a mistake. The person did not mean to defy God, and may not have known it was wrong at the time. But the sin is still called a sin: it was real and it needed dealing with.
    • "Before Yahweh" puts all of this in God's presence at the sanctuary. The wrong was against him, and the rite is done before his face.
    • The verse opens and closes the rite with the same verb ("make atonement … to make atonement"), so the priest's act frames everything.
    • "It will be forgiven him" is passive, and in Hebrew only God ever forgives with this verb. The priest performs the rite, but the pardon is God's. And it is stated plainly as pardon, a settled outcome, not a temporary cover-up.

    Read against the next verses, the sentence is also a promise. For anyone, native Israelite or foreigner living among them (v. 29), who goes wrong by mistake, God has provided a sure way back. The one who sins "with a high hand", in open defiance, has no such rite (vv. 30–31).

    Full study →
  3. 29You shall have the same law for the one who acts in error, whether he is a native-born Israelite or a foreigner residing among you.

    "Whether it is the native-born member of Israel's family or the outsider who has settled and lives right among them, you are all to have one and the same procedure for the person who goes wrong by mistake."

    The verse closes the paragraph on individual wrongdoing (vv. 27–29). If any single person strays, by not knowing the rule, by not realising what they were doing, or by plain carelessness, they bring a year-old female goat, the priest performs the atonement rite before the LORD, and the promise is: he will be forgiven (v. 28). Verse 29 then says who that promise covers. It names the full Israelite, rooted in the land by birth, and the resident alien, the outsider with no ancestral land who lives "in their midst". The Hebrew stresses that he really lives there: "the sojourner who sojourns". The "law" here is not the whole Torah. It is this specific ritual instruction, and there is only one of it. The outsider is not given a lesser rite or a separate line.

    The word for "in error" pictures straying off the path, like a wandering sheep. It is broader than English "ignorance". It covers any wrong done without the intent to defy. The next verse makes this the hinge of the passage: whoever acts "with a high hand", openly and defiantly, native or alien alike, has no offering to bring and is "cut off". Native and outsider are equal on both sides of that line. They share the same remedy for mistakes and face the same verdict for defiance.

    Full study →
  4. 30But the person who sins defiantly, whether a native or foreigner, blasphemes the LORD. That person shall be cut off from among his people.

    But the person who acts with an arm raised high — openly, defiantly, shaking a fist at the LORD's command — whether that person is a born Israelite or a foreigner settled among you, is insulting the LORD himself. That person shall be cut off from the heart of their people.

    The verse turns on a contrast with what comes just before it (vv. 22–29). Someone who sins by mistake, through error, carelessness or ignorance, can bring a purification offering, and the priest makes atonement, "and it shall be forgiven." Now the law turns to someone who sins with a high hand. The Hebrew picture is of a lifted arm, the same gesture Israel made marching out of Egypt in triumph, now turned against God himself. This is not the sin of a weak or confused person. It is open rebellion that says "I know whose command this is, and I reject it."

    Such an act, the verse says, is not just a broken rule. It is a taunt aimed at the LORD. The Hebrew puts "the LORD" first for emphasis: it is the LORD this person is insulting. The word for insult is the one used of the Assyrian envoys mocking Israel's God outside Jerusalem's walls. No words need to be spoken, because the deed itself is the insult.

    So no offering is provided. The sacrifices of vv. 24–29 belonged to people living within the covenant who had slipped. The defiant person has stepped outside it by their own act. The result is karet, being "cut off": removed by God from the centre of the community gathered around his presence. The next verse spells out the reason: "he has despised the word of the LORD and broken his commandment; his guilt remains on him." The same rule holds for native and foreigner alike: one law, one mercy for honest error, one judgment for open defiance.

    Full study →
  5. 31He shall certainly be cut off, because he has despised the word of the LORD and broken His commandment; his guilt remains on him.”

    "For it was YHWH's own word that he treated as worthless, and YHWH's command that he declared void. That person will be cut off, without fail and completely. The guilt stays in him; nothing carries it away."

    This verse explains verse 30. The person who sins "with a high hand", the raised fist of open defiance, is not someone who slipped or did not know. He knew the command came from Israel's covenant God, judged it not worth obeying, and treated it as cancelled. The verb for "broken" is the verb used for voiding a covenant or annulling a vow.

    The penalty is the priestly sentence called karet, being "cut off." Hebrew doubles the verb for emphasis ("cut off, he shall be cut off"). The passive leaves the agent unstated, and in these laws that agent is normally God. The person is uprooted from among his own people, and in that world that could mean early death and an ended family line, not merely being shunned.

    The last clause is the sharpest contrast with what comes just before. For unwitting sins, whether by the whole community or an individual, native Israelite or resident foreigner, the priest makes atonement and "it shall be forgiven" (vv. 25–28). For this person there is no offering to transfer the guilt. His iniquity, meaning the wrong, its guilt and its penalty all at once, remains "in him".

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v27

    any soul (KJV)

    nefesh

    What we hear
    An immaterial, immortal inner part of a person, distinct from the body.
    What they heard
    A living person, an individual, 'anyone'. The whole self as a living being.
  • in v27

    through ignorance (KJV) / in ignorance (YLT)

    bishgagah

    What we hear
    Not knowing the rule, or being uneducated.
    What they heard
    By error or inadvertence. It includes not knowing the law, not realising what one was doing, and accidental or careless acts. The opposite is open defiance ('with a high hand', v. 30), not knowledge.
  • in v27

    sin offering

    chattat

    What we hear
    A penalty payment, or an animal punished instead of the sinner.
    What they heard
    The sacrifice for removing sin and impurity. Its blood cleanses the altar, and it is also required where there is no moral fault (childbirth, recovery from skin disease, end of a Nazirite vow). Many scholars therefore call it a 'purification offering'. It deals with sin, but its main idea is cleansing.
  • in v28

    make an atonement / make atonement

    kipper

    What we hear
    Christ's death paying the penalty for sin, or more loosely 'making up for' a wrong by one's own effort.
    What they heard
    A priestly blood rite that purges the pollution a wrong has caused and ransoms the offender, done at the sanctuary 'before Yahweh', after which God pardons.
  • in v28, v30

    soul (KJV, WEB)

    nefesh

    What we hear
    The immaterial inner self, distinct from the body, that survives death.
    What they heard
    A person, an individual: 'anyone' in legal language.
  • in v28

    sinneth ignorantly (KJV) / unintentionally

    shegagah / shagag

    What we hear
    Either 'out of stupidity' (KJV) or 'a mistake that doesn't really count' (modern), since we tend to think guilt depends on intent.
    What they heard
    Wrongdoing by error, without defiance. It is still a real sin that brings guilt and needs a sacrifice once discovered; intent decides whether a remedy is available, not whether the wrong is real.
  • in v29

    ignorance (KJV: "sinneth through ignorance")

    bishgāgâ

    What we hear
    Not knowing the rules, or a lack of education. Today it can even sound like an insult.
    What they heard
    Going astray or erring: any wrong done without intent to defy. That includes not knowing the law, not knowing the facts, accidents and negligence. The same word covers accidental manslaughter (Num 35:11).
  • in v29

    stranger (KJV, also ESV)

    gēr

    What we hear
    Someone you have never met, an unknown person.
    What they heard
    A resident alien: an outsider settled long-term in the community, known to its members, but without inherited land or clan standing, and so legally vulnerable and protected by law.
  • in v29

    law

    tôrâ

    What we hear
    A legal code or 'the Law' as a whole system, often heard as a burden set against grace.
    What they heard
    A single priestly ruling or procedure, here the rite of atonement that ends in 'he will be forgiven'.
  • in v30

    blasphemes (BSB, NIV, WEB)

    megaddef (gadaf)

    What we hear
    Saying something irreverent or profane about God, such as swearing or mocking religion in words.
    What they heard
    To insult, taunt or treat with contempt. Here the insult is the defiant act itself, and no words are involved.
  • in v30

    presumptuously (KJV)

    beyad ramah

    What we hear
    Taking liberties, assuming too much, being forward or overconfident.
    What they heard
    With a raised hand: in open, deliberate defiance of the LORD's authority.
  • in v31

    cut off

    karat (niphal: hikkaret tikkaret)

    What we hear
    Shunned, excommunicated or disowned, with ties severed. Some Christian readers also hear 'cut off from God's grace or salvation forever.'
    What they heard
    A technical priestly penalty. The person is uprooted from among his kin-people, normally by God's action, which most likely meant premature death and the end of the family line. Whether it also had a sense beyond death, or a social side, is debated. Simple shunning is not its main sense.
  • in v31

    despised

    bazah

    What we hear
    Hated intensely, loathed.
    What they heard
    Treated as worthless, held cheap, brushed aside. Esau 'despised' his birthright by trading it for a meal. The emphasis is contemptuous disregard, not emotional hatred.
  • in v31

    broken his commandment

    hefar mitsvato

    What we hear
    Committed an infraction or broke a rule once.
    What they heard
    Made the command void and treated it as having no force over him. This is the vocabulary of annulling a covenant or cancelling a vow (Gen 17:14; Num 30). It describes repudiation, not a lapse.
  • in v31

    that soul (KJV, WEB)

    nefesh

    What we hear
    The immortal inner soul as distinct from the body, as though the soul is what gets cut off.
    What they heard
    The person, the living individual, 'that someone'. It is the ordinary legal word for 'anyone' in the Torah's laws.
  • in v31

    the word of the LORD

    devar YHWH

    What we hear
    The Bible, the written Scriptures as a book.
    What they heard
    What YHWH had spoken: the commands given through Moses, still being delivered in the wilderness. No written canon yet existed for anyone to despise.
Every word
  1. וְאִם־

    ve'im · H0518A

    and if · v27

    Opens a new case in the law. Verses 22–26 dealt with the whole community going wrong; this 'and if' moves to one individual. It is the standard way Israelite case law begins a scenario.

  2. נֶ֥פֶשׁ

    nefesh · H5315J

    person, living being · v27, v28, v30, v31

    Here it simply means 'a person', a living individual. The point is not some inner part of a human. The word is grammatically feminine, which is why the Hebrew verbs that follow are feminine ('she sins … she brings'), even though the person may be a man or a woman.

  3. אַחַ֖ת

    achat · H0259

    one · v27, v29

    'One' or 'a single'. It sets this case against the community case just before it: not all Israel, just one person. The whole system makes room for the lone individual's mistake as well as the nation's.

  4. תֶּחֱטָ֣א

    techeta · H2398

    to sin, miss, go wrong · v27, v28

    'Goes wrong' or 'offends'. The verb's root picture is missing a mark or failing to hit the right path. Here it means breaking one of the LORD's commands (see v. 22), but by mistake, as the next word says.

  5. בִשְׁגָגָ֑ה

    bishgagah · H7684

    in inadvertence, by error · v27, v28, v29

    'By inadvertence': the person did not mean to break the command. Either they did not know the act was forbidden or did not realise what they were doing. This is the key qualifier. It is set directly against sinning 'with a high hand' in v. 30, meaning openly defiant sin, which has no sacrifice.

  6. וְהִקְרִ֛יבָה

    vehiqrivah · H7126H

    and bring near, offer · v27

    Literally 'cause to come near'. This is the ordinary word for presenting an offering at the sanctuary. The offerer brings the animal into the LORD's presence; the priest then performs the ritual (v. 28).

  7. עֵ֥ז

    ez · H5795

    goat (female) · v27

    A she-goat. In the community case (v. 24) the purification offering is a male goat; for the individual it is a female. A female goat gave milk and kids, so it was a real cost to a household, but within reach of an ordinary family.

  8. בַּת־

    bat · H1323G

    daughter (of) · v27

    Literally 'daughter of'. Combined with the next word it forms the Hebrew idiom for an animal's age. It does not mean a family relationship.

  9. שְׁנָתָ֖הּ

    shenatah · H8141

    year (its) · v27

    'Its year'. 'Daughter of its year' means a yearling, an animal in its first year of life: young, healthy and in its prime. Numbers adds this age requirement; the parallel law in Leviticus 4:28 does not state an age.

  10. לְחַטָּֽאת׃

    lechattat · H2403H

    for a sin offering / purification offering · v27

    'As a chattat', the specific sacrifice for dealing with wrongdoing and impurity. It comes from the same root as the verb 'sins' earlier in the verse, so the Hebrew sounds like 'if she sins … she brings a sin-thing'. That echo is lost in most English.

  11. וְכִפֶּ֣ר

    vekhipper · H3722A

    and he will make atonement · v28

    The priest's ritual act of purging, ransoming or wiping away the effects of the wrong, here by the blood rite of the sin offering (Lev 4:30). The verb form continues the law of v. 27: once the goat is brought, this is what follows.

  12. הַכֹּהֵ֗ן

    hakkohen · H3548

    the priest · v28

    An Aaronic priest serving at the sanctuary. He carries out the rite. He is not the one who forgives: the forgiveness at the end of the verse is phrased so that God is the one acting.

  13. עַל־

    ʿal- · H5921A

    on, over, for · v28

    With the verb 'make atonement' this means 'on behalf of' or 'for'. The rite is performed for the person; the blood is applied to the altar, not to the person.

  14. הַשֹּׁגֶ֛גֶת

    hashshogeget · H7683

    who goes astray, errs · v28

    'The one who erred / strayed.' The form is feminine only to agree grammatically with nefesh. It describes someone who did wrong by mistake, without meaning to defy God.

  15. לִפְנֵ֣י

    lifnei · H6440G

    before, in the presence of · v28

    Literally 'to the face of'. It places the rite at the sanctuary, in God's presence. The Hebrew accents tie it to the whole first clause, so it most naturally goes with 'make atonement before Yahweh'.

  16. יְהוָ֑ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    Yahweh, the LORD · v28, v30, v31

    Israel's God by his personal name. He is present at the sanctuary, and his presence is what the wrong has offended and what the rite is directed toward.

  17. וְנִסְלַ֥ח

    venislaḥ · H5545

    and it will be forgiven · v28

    A passive form: 'it will be pardoned'. In the Hebrew Bible this verb only ever has God as the one who forgives, so the passive points to God and away from the priest.

  18. לֽוֹ׃

    lo · H9033

    to him · v28

    'To him': the pardon is granted to the person. The verse ends with the outcome: the matter is settled between this person and God.

  19. הָֽאֶזְרָח֙

    ha'ezraḥ · H0249

    the native · v29, v30

    The full Israelite native, the person rooted in the land by birth and family inheritance. It stands first in the sentence, without the 'for' that the next noun has, as a heading: 'As for the native…'.

  20. בִּבְנֵ֣י

    bivnê · H1121G

    among the sons of · v29

    'Sons of Israel' is the normal name for the people as a family descended from Jacob. 'Among' places the native inside that kinship group.

  21. יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל

    yisra'ēl · H3478

    Israel · v29

    The ancestor Jacob/Israel, and so the nation descended from him. Belonging is set by descent.

  22. וְלַגֵּ֖ר

    welaggēr · H1616

    and for the sojourner · v29, v30

    The resident outsider: a non-Israelite (or Israelite from elsewhere) who has settled long-term in Israel's territory but has no inherited land and no clan standing. He is named here deliberately alongside the native.

  23. הַגָּ֣ר

    haggār · H1481A

    who sojourns · v29

    A participle (a verb used like 'the one who is sojourning') from the same root as gēr: 'the sojourner who sojourns'. The repetition stresses that he actually lives there, not someone passing through.

  24. בְּתוֹכָ֑ם

    betôkhām · H8432

    in their midst · v29

    Literally 'in the middle of them'. The sojourner lives inside the community, among the camp and later the towns, not on its edges.

  25. תּוֹרָ֤ה

    tôrâ · H8451

    instruction, ruling · v29

    Here it means a specific priestly procedure: the ritual just described in vv. 27–28 (a year-old female goat as a purification offering, and the priest's atonement rite). It does not mean 'the Law' as a whole body of writings.

  26. יִהְיֶ֣ה

    yihyeh · H1961

    shall be · v29

    A standing rule for the future, 'shall be'. It is a legal ordinance, not a prediction.

  27. לָכֶ֔ם

    lākhem · H9036

    for you (plural) · v29

    The whole assembled community is addressed. The rule belongs to 'you all', and the sojourner is counted within it.

  28. לָעֹשֶׂ֖ה

    lā'ōśeh · H6213A

    for the one who does · v29, v30

    Simply 'the one doing'. The verb itself does not say 'sin'; the context (v. 27, 'if one person sins') supplies that. In v. 30 the same verb returns, 'the person who does with a high hand', which sets up the contrast.

  29. אֲשֶֽׁר־

    asher · H0834

    who, which · v30

    Introduces the description of which person is meant: the one who acts in the way about to be described.

  30. בְּיָ֣ד

    beyad · H3027

    with a hand · v30

    First half of the idiom 'with a high hand'. In Hebrew the hand stands for power and action.

  31. רָמָ֗ה

    ramah · H7311

    raised, high · v30

    'Raised high' completes the picture of an arm lifted in open defiance, like a fist shaken in someone's face. It describes a public, deliberate act of rebellion, not just knowing that something is wrong.

  32. מִן־

    min · H4480

    from, of · v30

    'Of / from among': the person may come from either group named next.

  33. אֶת־

    et · H0853

    [marks the object] · v30, v31

    Marks YHWH as the object of the verb. It is placed first in the clause for emphasis: it is the LORD, of all people, whom this person is insulting.

  34. ה֣וּא

    hu · H1931

    he · v30, v31

    'He' (the offender) is the one doing the insulting. It switches to masculine here, unlike the feminine 'nefesh', because it points to the person as a man in the community.

  35. מְגַדֵּ֑ף

    megaddef · H1442

    insulting, reviling · v30

    A participle (an ongoing state): 'is insulting'. The defiant act itself is treated as a public insult, a taunt thrown at God. No spoken words are required.

  36. וְנִכְרְתָ֛ה

    venikhretah · H3772

    and shall be cut off · v30, v31

    The penalty known as karet, 'cutting off'. The passive form leaves the one who cuts unnamed; parallel texts (Lev 17:10; 20:3–6) show God as the one who does it.

  37. מִקֶּ֥רֶב

    mikkerev · H7130

    from the midst of · v30

    Literally 'from the inner part of'. The person is removed from the centre of the community's life, where the LORD dwells among his people.

  38. עַמָּֽהּ׃

    ammah · H5971

    her (its) people · v30

    'Her people' (feminine, agreeing with nefesh): the person's own kin and the covenant people they belong to. The loss is a loss of belonging.

  39. כִּ֤י

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v31

    Gives the reason. Verse 30 announced that the defiant sinner is cut off, and verse 31 explains why: the act is treated as contempt for God's word, not just as a wrong deed.

  40. דְבַר־

    devar- · H1697G

    word, matter, thing · v31

    The word that YHWH has spoken, meaning his instructions given through Moses at Sinai and in the wilderness. Hebrew puts this phrase first in its clause, so the stress falls on whose word was despised: YHWH's.

  41. בָּזָ֔ה

    bazah · H0959

    to despise, hold in contempt · v31

    He treated it as worthless and not worth taking seriously. The verb describes how someone values a thing, not a burst of hatred. The perfect tense presents this as a settled, completed attitude.

  42. מִצְוָת֖וֹ

    mitsvato · H4687

    commandment, order · v31

    'His commandment': an order given by a superior who has the right to give it. The singular probably sums up the whole body of YHWH's commands, or whichever command was flouted.

  43. הֵפַ֑ר

    hefar · H6565A

    to break, annul, make void · v31

    He has made it void and treated it as having no force over him. This is the language of breaking a covenant or cancelling a vow. It means more than a single slip.

  44. עֲוֹנָ֥ה

    avonah · H5771G

    iniquity, guilt, punishment · v31

    'Her iniquity', meaning that person's wrongdoing together with the guilt and consequences it carries. One Hebrew word covers the deed, the liability and the penalty.

  45. בָֽהּ׃

    bah · H9034

    in her / on her · v31

    'Is in/on her (the person)'. The guilt stays with the sinner. Nothing takes it away. This contrasts directly with verses 25–28, where the priest makes atonement and 'it shall be forgiven'.

The world behind it

Where this law sits. Numbers 15 comes right after the disaster of the spies (Num 13–14). The adult generation refused to enter Canaan and was sentenced to die in the wilderness. Chapter 15 then opens with "When you enter the land…" (v. 2). By its very wording, the whole chapter assures the next generation that they will arrive and worship there.

The structure of vv. 22–31:

  • vv. 22–26: the whole community errs by mistake. They bring a bull as a burnt offering plus a male goat as a chattat.
  • vv. 27–29: one person errs by mistake. They bring a yearling female goat as a chattat (this verse). There is one law for the native-born and the resident foreigner (ger).
  • vv. 30–31: anyone who acts "with a high hand", openly despising the LORD's word, is "cut off". No sacrifice is named.
  • vv. 32–36 follow at once with the man gathering wood on the Sabbath, a story that puts the high-handed case into practice.

Comparison with Leviticus 4. Leviticus 4:27–31 already has a law for a common person's unintentional sin: a female goat, or a female lamb (4:32). Leviticus grades the offering by status: a bull for the anointed priest, a male goat for a leader, a female goat for an ordinary person. Numbers 15 does not mention rank at all and adds the age requirement ("in its first year"). It also frames the sin as failing to keep "all these commands" (v. 22), which many interpreters take to include failing to do things, not only doing forbidden things.

What a she-goat meant. In a herding economy a breeding female goat was a source of milk and future kids. It was a significant gift, chosen to cost the offerer something without being out of reach.

How the chattat worked. In the priestly ritual the chattat's blood was put on the horns of the altar (Lev 4:30), and the fat was burned. For an individual's offering, the priest ate the meat in a holy place (Lev 6:26 [6:19 Heb.]). The ritual is pictured as cleansing the contamination that wrongdoing brings near God's dwelling, and as releasing the offerer from guilt ("he will be forgiven", v. 28).

From the study of Numbers 15:27.

Where scholars differ

in v27

How does Numbers 15:22–31 relate to the similar law in Leviticus 4?

  • Numbers 15 covers failures to do positive commands (omissions) as well as forbidden acts, while Leviticus 4 covers only doing what is forbidden.

    Num 15:22 speaks of not doing 'all these commands', while Lev 4:2 speaks of doing 'any of the things the LORD commanded not to be done'. This view is associated with rabbinic tradition and with Milgrom's reading (JPS Numbers excursus), though Milgrom himself argued Num 15 covers all commands broadly.

  • Numbers 15 is a later or parallel priestly text that reworks and simplifies Leviticus 4. It drops the status grades and adds a burnt offering for the community.

    The differences are real: the community brings a bull as a burnt offering plus a goat as chattat (Num 15:24) versus a bull as chattat (Lev 4:14); no ranks of offerer; the added age requirement. Critical scholars (e.g. Levine, Knohl) often assign Num 15 to the 'Holiness' strand of priestly writing.

  • The two passages address different situations within one system and should be read together.

    Many conservative commentators (e.g. Ashley, Wenham) note that Num 15 is framed for life in the land and concentrates on the community and individual broadly, assuming Lev 4's details.

in v27

What did the chattat sacrifice primarily accomplish?

  • It purified the sanctuary from the contamination that sin and impurity caused. The offerer's forgiveness came because the sanctuary had been cleansed ('purification offering').

    Jacob Milgrom: the blood is applied to the altar, not the person; the offering is required for non-moral impurities (childbirth, skin disease); the related intensive verb means 'to de-sin, purify' (Lev 8:15).

  • It cleansed the offerer first and then the sanctuary, in two stages, with the Day of Atonement completing the process.

    Roy Gane (Cult and Character, 2005) points to the phrase 'make atonement for him from his sin' (Lev 4:26) and to the yearly purging of the sanctuary in Lev 16.

  • It dealt with the offerer's guilt by substitution, the animal's life given in place of the sinner's ('sin offering' in the traditional sense).

    The laying on of the hand (Lev 4:29), Lev 17:11 ('the life is in the blood… to make atonement for your lives'), and later readings in Hebrews. Critics reply that hand-laying may mark ownership rather than transfer of sin.

in v27

Did Israel's sacrifices cover only accidental sins, with no remedy at all for deliberate ones?

  • Yes. Num 15:30–31 shows that only unintentional sins could be atoned for by sacrifice; deliberate sin meant being cut off.

    The plain contrast between shegagah (v. 27) and the 'high hand' (v. 30). Heb 10:26 is often read as echoing it.

  • No. The 'high hand' means brazen, defiant, unrepentant rebellion, not every knowing sin. Some deliberate wrongs could be atoned for after confession.

    Lev 6:1–7 (5:20–26 Heb.) prescribes a guilt offering for deliberate fraud and false oaths once the person confesses and repays. Lev 16:21 covers 'all their transgressions' (pesha', a word for rebellion) on the Day of Atonement. Milgrom argues that repentance and confession turned deliberate sin into the atonable category. Rabbinic tradition similarly stresses repentance.

in v28

What exactly does kipper do in the sin offering: purge the sanctuary, cleanse the offender, or both?

  • Kipper with the sin offering purges the sanctuary of the pollution caused by sin. The offender is not cleansed directly but is released by God's forgiveness once the sanctuary is purged.

    Jacob Milgrom (Leviticus 1–16): the blood is applied to the altar and sanctuary, never to the sinner; 'al with a person means 'on behalf of'; Lev 16:16 speaks of purging the holy place 'from the uncleannesses of the Israelites'.

  • The rite affects the offender too: it removes the person's guilt or liability (and in some views the pollution is carried by the priests and the sanctuary, then removed on the Day of Atonement).

    Roy Gane (Cult and Character), Nobuyoshi Kiuchi, and Jay Sklar (Sin, Impurity, Sacrifice, Atonement) point out that the formulas say 'make atonement for him for his sin' (Lev 4:26) and that forgiveness is granted to the person. Sklar argues kipper joins 'ransom' and 'purge' in one act.

in v28

How does Numbers 15:22–31 relate to Leviticus 4, which also regulates sin offerings for inadvertent sin?

  • Numbers 15 deals with sins of omission (failing to do the commandments), while Leviticus 4 deals with doing something forbidden; or Numbers 15 is a broad summary covering all inadvertent sin.

    Num 15:22 speaks of 'not doing all these commandments'; the community offering differs from Lev 4 (bull as burnt offering plus goat as sin offering vs. bull as sin offering). Milgrom (JPS Numbers) discusses these differences.

  • Rabbinic interpretation: Numbers 15:22–31 refers specifically to idolatry, the sin that breaks 'all the commandments'.

    Sifre Numbers and the Talmud (b. Horayot 8a) read 'all these commandments' and the 'high hand' as pointing to idolatry, which explains the different offerings.

  • The two passages come from different priestly writers or editing stages, and Numbers 15 represents a later school that reworked Leviticus 4.

    Israel Knohl (The Sanctuary of Silence) and others assign Num 15 to the 'Holiness School', noting its inclusion of the resident foreigner (v. 29) and its distinctive vocabulary.

in v29

Who is the gēr here: a resident alien or a religious convert?

  • A resident alien: a settled outsider, defined by social and legal status, not by conversion.

    The usage in the Hebrew Bible pairs gēr with tôshāv (settler) and lists him with widows and orphans. Israel itself was a gēr in Egypt. The priestly laws treat him as bound by prohibitions but not all positive rites (e.g. he may choose whether to keep Passover, Num 9:14 / Exod 12:48). This is the view of most modern scholars (Milgrom, Levine, van Houten).

  • A full convert (ger tzedeq), equal to a native in all obligations.

    This is the classical rabbinic reading (Sifre Numbers; Talmud), helped by the LXX's prosēlytos. It reflects the later situation, when 'joining Israel' had become a recognised religious act. Its strength is that it explains why the gēr has full access to atonement rites.

in v29

How wide is shegāgâ, and is there any atonement for deliberate wrongs?

  • Shegāgâ covers all non-defiant wrongs. Deliberate but repented wrongs can be brought into the atonable category through confession.

    Milgrom points to Lev 5:20–26 (6:1–7) and Num 5:6–7, where knowingly committed offences such as false oaths and fraud are atoned for after confession and restitution. On this view only 'high-handed', unrepentant defiance (v. 30) is beyond the sacrificial system.

  • The sacrificial system covers only true inadvertence. Deliberate sins are beyond it, and are left to God or punishment.

    A plain reading of the sharp contrast in vv. 29–30. The cities-of-refuge laws also separate accidental from intentional killing (Num 35). Some later interpreters (and the logic of Heb 10:26) read it this way.

in v29

How does Num 15:22–31 relate to Leviticus 4?

  • A different or later layer of priestly law that revises Lev 4.

    The offerings differ: for the community, Lev 4 has a bull as purification offering, while Num 15 has a bull as burnt offering plus a goat as purification offering. Lev 4 also never mentions the gēr. Many critical scholars assign Num 15 to a later 'Holiness' layer concerned with the alien and the land.

  • They deal with different cases. Num 15:22–26 concerns failure in 'all these commandments', i.e. idolatry.

    Rabbinic tradition (Sifre Numbers; b. Horayot 8a) reads 'all these commandments' (v. 22) as the sin that uproots the whole Torah, namely idolatry, and so harmonises the two passages.

in v30

What does 'cut off' (karet) mean?

  • Premature death brought about by God.

    God says 'I will cut him off' (Lev 20:3–6). Mishnah Keritot treats karet as a penalty from heaven, separate from court execution, and rabbinic tradition often linked it with dying young.

  • The ending of the offender's family line.

    In a kinship society, being 'cut off from one's people' naturally suggests losing descendants. Compare the fear of a 'name being cut off' (Ruth 4:10; Ps 109:13). Milgrom stresses the extinction of the lineage.

  • Exclusion from the community (a kind of excommunication).

    The wording 'from the midst of her people' suggests removal from the community. Qumran's use of the 'high hand' category for permanent expulsion (1QS 8) reads it this way.

  • Denial of a share with one's ancestors after death.

    This mirrors the idiom of being 'gathered to one's people' at death. Milgrom argues that karet may include losing that reunion. Later rabbinic texts speak of losing the world to come.

in v30

Is 'high-hand' sin simply any deliberate sin?

  • Yes. The contrast is between unintentional and intentional sin, and only unintentional sins could be atoned for by sacrifice.

    Verses 29–30 place 'in error' (bishgagah) directly against 'with a high hand', and many commentators read these as the only two categories.

  • No. It is a narrower category of open, defiant rejection of God's authority.

    Lev 6:1–7 (5:20–26 in Hebrew) provides a guilt offering for deliberate fraud and false oaths once the person confesses and makes restitution. The Day of Atonement covers Israel's 'transgressions' (pesha'im, rebellious acts) (Lev 16:16, 21). The idiom elsewhere means open, bold action (Exod 14:8), and v. 31 defines the offence as despising the LORD's word. Milgrom argues that repentance could reduce a deliberate sin to the level that sacrifice could cover.

in v31

What exactly does karet ('cut off') mean?

  • Divine punishment: God himself removes the offender by premature death and/or by ending his family line.

    God speaks in the first person, 'I will cut him off' (Lev 17:10; 20:3–6). In Lev 20:2–5 karet is separate from community stoning and applies even if the community fails to act. The Mishnah tractate Keritot treats karet as a penalty from heaven. This is the view of Milgrom and Wold, among others.

  • Execution or expulsion carried out by the community.

    Exod 31:14 puts 'surely be put to death' and 'cut off' side by side for the Sabbath, and the Sabbath-breaker in vv. 32–36 is stoned. Some argue that 'from among his people' implies the community removing him.

  • Loss that extends beyond death: the person is not 'gathered to his people' in the afterlife.

    It contrasts with the idiom 'gathered to one's people' at death (Gen 25:8). Rabbi Akiva reads the doubled verb as 'cut off in this world and in the world to come' (b. Sanhedrin 64b). Milgrom considered this dimension possible alongside extinction of the line.

in v31

Does the doubled verb (hikkaret tikkaret) mean two stages of punishment or simply emphasis?

  • Two stages: this world and the world to come.

    Rabbi Akiva in b. Sanhedrin 64b (cf. 90b).

  • Ordinary Hebrew emphasis meaning 'surely, utterly'.

    Rabbi Ishmael's reply, 'the Torah speaks in human language'. The infinitive-plus-finite-verb construction is used for emphasis throughout biblical Hebrew. Modern grammarians and almost all translations ('utterly', 'certainly', 'completely') take this view.

in v31

Does 'sinning with a high hand' cover every deliberate sin, so that the law offered no atonement for any knowing wrong?

  • Yes: the system offered sacrifice only for unintentional sin, and every deliberate sin fell under verses 30–31.

    The two-part structure of Num 15:22–31 is plain: unwitting sin is atoned for, the 'high hand' is not. Hebrews 10:26 reads it in a similar binary way.

  • No: 'high hand' means brazen, unrepentant defiance. Some knowing sins could be atoned for, especially with confession and restitution.

    Lev 6:1–7 (Hebrew 5:20–26) prescribes a guilt offering for deliberate fraud and false oaths once the person confesses and repays. Lev 16:16, 21 says the Day of Atonement deals with Israel's 'transgressions' (pesha'im, deliberate rebellions). Num 5:6–7 requires confession. Milgrom argued that repentance and confession effectively reduce a deliberate sin to the level of an atonable one. The phrase 'despised the word of the LORD' is used of David (2 Sam 12:9), whose sin is 'put away' on confession (12:13), though not through sacrifice.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. נֶפֶשׁ, חָטָא, שְׁגָגָה, חַטָּאת, קָרַב
  • HALOT s.v. שְׁגָגָה; חַטָּאת
  • Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990), on 15:22–31 and Excursus on inadvertent sins
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible, 1991), on the chattat (purification offering)
  • Roy E. Gane, Cult and Character: Purification Offerings, Day of Atonement, and Theodicy (2005)
  • Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Bible, 1993)
  • Timothy R. Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT, 1993)
  • Gordon J. Wenham, Numbers (Tyndale OT Commentaries)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Numbers 15:27
  • Vulgate, Numeri 15:27
  • BDB s.v. כָּפַר, שָׁגַג, שְׁגָגָה, סָלַח, נֶפֶשׁ
  • HALOT s.v. כפר, שְׁגָגָה, סלח
  • R. E. Averbeck, 'כָּפַר', NIDOTTE vol. 2
  • Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990)
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible, 1991)
  • Jay Sklar, Sin, Impurity, Sacrifice, Atonement: The Priestly Conceptions (2005)
  • Roy E. Gane, Cult and Character (2005)
  • Israel Knohl, The Sanctuary of Silence (1995)
  • Septuagint, Numbers 15:28
  • Vulgate, Numbers 15:28
  • Community Rule (1QS) VIII.21–IX.2
  • Sifre Numbers on 15:22–31; b. Horayot 8a; Mishnah Keritot
  • Hebrews 9:7; 10:26
  • STEPBible tagged Hebrew text (supplied data)
  • BDB s.v. שְׁגָגָה, גֵּר, אֶזְרָח, תּוֹרָה
  • HALOT s.v. שְׁגָגָה; גֵּר; אֶזְרָח
  • Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990), comm. on 15:22–31 and Excursus on the gēr
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on shegāgâ and the purification offering
  • Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • Christiana van Houten, The Alien in Israelite Law (JSOTSup 107)
  • Timothy R. Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT)
  • Septuagint, Numbers 15:29 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Numeri 15:29
  • Sifre Numbers on 15:22–31; b. Horayot 8a
  • 1QS (Community Rule) cols. 8–9
  • BDB s.v. גָּדַף; רוּם; כָּרַת
  • HALOT s.v. גדף; אֶזְרָח; גֵּר
  • Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990), on 15:22–31 and Excursus on karet
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on the ḥaṭṭat and asham and on repentance
  • Baruch Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • Timothy Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT)
  • Septuagint, Numbers 15:30
  • Community Rule (1QS) 8
  • Mishnah Keritot 1:1–2
  • BDB s.v. בָּזָה, פָּרַר, כָּרַת, עָוֹן
  • HALOT s.v. בזה; פרר hif.; כרת nif.; עָוֹן
  • Jacob Milgrom, The JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990), commentary on 15:22–31 and excursus on the karet penalty
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on karet and on confession and deliberate sin
  • Baruch Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Bible), on 15:22–36
  • Donald J. Wold, 'The Kareth Penalty in P: Rationale and Cases', SBL Seminar Papers (1979)
  • Babylonian Talmud Sanhedrin 64b, 90b, 99a; Shevuot 13a; Yoma 85b
  • Mishnah Keritot 1:1
  • Septuagint Numbers 15:31 (Rahlfs)
  • Gesenius' Hebrew Grammar §113 (infinitive used for emphasis)
  • Hebrews 10:26–29 (New Testament echo)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).