Romans Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Romans 9:25–29

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

25As He says in Hosea: “I will call them ‘My People’ who are not My people, and I will call her ‘My Beloved’ who is not My beloved,” 26and, “It will happen that in the very place where it was said to them, ‘You are not My people,’ they will be called ‘sons of the living God.’” 27Isaiah cries out concerning Israel: “Though the number of the Israelites is like the sand of the sea, only the remnant will be saved. 28For the Lord will carry out His sentence on the earth thoroughly and decisively.” 29It is just as Isaiah foretold: “Unless the Lord of Hosts had left us descendants, we would have become like Sodom, we would have resembled Gomorrah.”

What the first hearers heard

For Paul's Roman hearers, many of them Gentiles meeting with Jewish believers in house churches, this line did several things at once:

  • It answered an identity question. Gentiles who worshipped Israel's God without circumcision could be asked, "By what right do you call yourselves God's people?" Paul's answer is: by God's naming. The God who once declared "Not-My-People" has said "My People."
  • It grounded inclusion in Israel's own Scriptures. This was not a new idea from Paul. It was a prophetic word about God reversing a verdict of exclusion. Jewish hearers would know Hosea's story of disowned children taken back, and would hear God's mercy toward the estranged reaching further than expected.
  • It kept the stress on mercy. The chapter's key words are "mercy" (9:15–18, 9:23) and "calling" (9:7, 9:12, 9:24). The renamed are not described as having earned anything. They were "not loved" until God spoke.
  • It prepared for the Isaiah quotations that follow (9:27–29). God's people now consist of called Gentiles and a called remnant of Israel, which sets up Paul's later picture of the olive tree in Romans 11.

The verse would not have been heard as a promise to individuals considered one by one. It is a promise to a community, about a people being re-formed by God's naming.

From the study of Romans 9:25.

Verse by verse

  1. 25As He says in Hosea: “I will call them ‘My People’ who are not My people, and I will call her ‘My Beloved’ who is not My beloved,”

    Paul has just said that God has called a people "not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles" (9:24). Now he says: this is exactly what God says in the book of Hosea.

    God speaks, in the present tense: what he said through the prophet he is saying now. "I will name the one called Not-My-People — 'My People.' And the one called Not-Loved — 'Loved.'"

    The background is a pair of real names. Hosea had been told to give his children names that announced a verdict on Israel. A daughter was named Lo-Ruhamah, "No-Compassion" or "Not-Pitied," using the Hebrew word for a parent's deep, womb-like tenderness. A son was named Lo-Ammi, "Not-My-People," which flatly reversed the covenant promise "you will be my people and I will be your God." Later in Hosea, God promises to undo it. He will speak the same names again without the "not."

    Paul keeps that renaming and sharpens it in two ways:

    • He uses "I will call" instead of "I will say." God's naming of these people is the same thing as God's calling of them in the verse before. A name given by God is not a label. It establishes what they are.
    • He renders the daughter's name with "loved" (a perfect passive participle, meaning one who has been loved and remains so). This echoes "Jacob I loved" earlier in the chapter (9:13), while Hosea's theme of mercy stays underneath it.

    "My People" is Israel's own covenant title. "Loved" is the name of a daughter taken back after being publicly disowned. In Hosea these words were spoken over estranged Israelites. Paul applies them to the mixed community of Jews and Gentiles that God is now calling. People who had no claim to the name are given it by God's word alone.

    Full study →
  2. 26and, “It will happen that in the very place where it was said to them, ‘You are not My people,’ they will be called ‘sons of the living God.’”

    And this is what will happen: in the very place where the verdict once rang out, "You are not my people," in that same place God himself will give them a new name: "sons of the living God."

    The verse quotes Hosea (1:10 in English Bibles, 2:1 in Hebrew and Greek). Hosea had named his third child Lo-Ammi, "Not-My-People". The name was a living sign that God was cancelling the covenant formula "you will be my people and I will be your God." Paul quotes the promise in which God reverses that sentence. Several details matter:

    • The rejection was real and came from God. "It was said to them" leaves the speaker unnamed, but God is meant: God had disowned them.
    • The renaming also comes from God, and the name brings about what it says. "They will be called" means God names them, and his naming makes it so. In Romans 9, God's "calling" is the thread of the argument (9:24: "us, whom he also called, not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles").
    • The new status goes beyond the old one. The curse "not my people" is answered not just with "my people" but with "sons": family members and heirs of the household, women included.
    • "The living God" is the real, life-giving God, as opposed to lifeless idols. Outsiders are adopted by the God who actually lives.
    • "There" stresses that the reversal happens on the ground of the old rejection, not by moving the people somewhere else.

    Paul uses this text to show that God calling people who were "not his people" is no innovation. It is what God promised through Hosea.

    Full study →
  3. 27Isaiah cries out concerning Israel: “Though the number of the Israelites is like the sand of the sea, only the remnant will be saved.

    Isaiah, says Paul, raises his voice urgently, and is still raising it, about Israel: "Even if the people of Israel become as countless as the sand on the seashore, just as God promised Abraham, it is the remnant, the survivors God leaves, who will be brought safely through."

    The first half admits that God's promise of countless descendants has come true. The second half says that size alone does not carry the nation through God's judgment (v. 28). Those who come through are the remnant. In the prophets that word does not mean worthless scraps. It means the living stump from which the people grows again, the 'seed' of v. 29 without which Israel would have been wiped out like Sodom.

    The Greek has no word for 'only'. The sentence holds two things together: the narrowing (not all of Israel) and the mercy (there will be a remnant, rescued by God). Paul has also blended the wording. 'The number of the sons of Israel' comes from Hosea, whom he has just quoted, and the rest comes from Isaiah. The join ties the 'sons of the living God' of v. 26 to the 'sons of Israel' here. Behind the Greek 'will be saved' stands Isaiah's Hebrew 'a remnant will return': come back alive and turn back to God.

    Full study →
  4. 28For the Lord will carry out His sentence on the earth thoroughly and decisively.”

    "For the Lord will do what he has said on the earth, carrying his word all the way through to its end and cutting it short, settling it by firm decree."

    The sentence opens with "a word": the word God spoke through Isaiah, the same "word of God" Paul insisted in 9:6 had not failed. The Lord will do that word; he will put it into effect. He does it in two ways at once. He completes it, bringing it to its full outcome with nothing left undone. He also cuts it short. Behind this phrase is a Hebrew picture of a decision that has been "cut", meaning decreed and settled beyond appeal. It also carries a sense of swiftness, and of cutting down: a people as countless as the sand of the sea is pared back to a remnant.

    In Isaiah's own setting this was a warning of judgment: a destruction God had decreed against his people, which would leave only survivors. Paul quotes it to explain why most of Israel has not embraced the Messiah, while the community of believers includes Gentiles. This was not God's promise collapsing. It was God's announced word being carried out exactly, thoroughly and decisively. The next verse holds out the hope inside the judgment: "Unless the Lord of Hosts had left us descendants…" A remnant left means a seed for the future.

    Full study →
  5. 29It is just as Isaiah foretold: “Unless the Lord of Hosts had left us descendants, we would have become like Sodom, we would have resembled Gomorrah.”

    Paul adds a second quotation from Isaiah to the one he has just given: "And just as Isaiah said earlier on: If the Lord, commander of heaven's armies, had not deliberately kept back for us a seed, a small surviving remnant that still carried a future, we would have become like Sodom. Our fate would have matched Gomorrah's: wiped out completely, with no one left and no line to carry on."

    The sentence describes a disaster that did not happen, and the only reason it did not happen is God's act. Israel survived, but not because of its own strength or goodness. In Isaiah, the next verse calls Jerusalem's leaders "rulers of Sodom." The people were like Sodom in conduct and were kept from Sodom's fate only because God chose to leave some behind. The word "seed" matters. It is small, but seed is kept back so that something can grow from it. It also echoes the "seed" of Abraham and Isaac that Paul has just discussed (9:7–8). Applied to Paul's day, the verse says two things together. It is sobering: as in Isaiah's day, only a remnant of Israel is responding. It is also hopeful: that remnant exists only because God has kept faith with his promise. So God's word has not failed (9:6).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v25

    my people

    laos mou

    What we hear
    A general, warm way of saying 'my folks', the persons I care about.
    What they heard
    A covenant status: the community bound to God as his own, the title that defined Israel over against 'the nations'. Giving outsiders this name means giving them Israel's covenant identity.
  • in v25

    call

    kaleō

    What we hear
    To label or address someone by a name, or to invite them, with nothing changing as a result.
    What they heard
    With two objects it means 'to name X as Y'. When God names someone, the name settles their identity. Paul also uses the same verb for God's summons into his people (9:24), so the naming and the calling are one act.
  • in v26

    sons / children (of the living God)

    huioi

    What we hear
    With 'sons' readers hear males only. With 'children' they hear affection and smallness or dependence.
    What they heard
    The legal status of heir in God's household, the standing Israel held as God's 'firstborn son' (Exodus 4:22). The whole people is in view, women included (9:25 uses the feminine 'beloved').
  • in v26

    they will be called

    klēthēsontai (kaleō)

    What we hear
    Others will describe them or label them this way. Or, 'called' in the sense of a personal vocation.
    What they heard
    God names them, and his naming makes the status real. It is the same act as God's effective 'call' that runs through Romans 9 (9:7, 12, 24).
  • in v27

    only the remnant / only a remnant

    to hupoleimma

    What we hear
    A grim statement that hardly anyone will make it. 'Remnant' sounds like leftover scraps.
    What they heard
    'The remnant': the surviving core God keeps, through whom the people continues. In context it is first a sign of mercy (v. 29: 'unless the Lord had left us a seed') as well as a sign of judgment.
  • in v27

    will be saved

    sōthēsetai

    What we hear
    Individuals get assurance of going to heaven.
    What they heard
    Will be rescued, brought safely through God's judgment as a surviving people. In Isaiah's Hebrew it is 'will return', to the land and to God. In Paul it also points to God's final rescue.
  • in v28

    finish the work … a short work (KJV, WEB)

    logon … syntelōn kai syntemnōn

    What we hear
    Completing a task, or God doing a quick, brief work, often heard as a rapid end-times revival or harvest.
    What they heard
    God carrying out his spoken word (decree) completely and decisively. In Isaiah this was a decreed judgment that cuts Israel down to a remnant.
  • in v28

    in righteousness (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    en dikaiosynē

    What we hear
    Moral goodness, or the righteousness God credits to believers.
    What they heard
    Isaiah's 'overflowing with righteousness' describes God's just and faithful action in carrying out judgment. In any case the phrase belongs to the later Byzantine text, not to what Paul most likely wrote.
  • in v29

    descendants / offspring (for "seed")

    sperma

    What we hear
    Biological descendants in general, as though the whole ethnic line were meant.
    What they heard
    A small surviving remnant (Hebrew: "a few survivors") pictured as seed: a tiny nucleus God keeps back, from which the people's future grows. It deliberately echoes Abraham's promised "seed" (9:7–8).
  • in v29

    Lord of Sabaoth (KJV)

    sabaōth (Hebrew tsevaot)

    What we hear
    Often heard as "Lord of the Sabbath."
    What they heard
    "Lord of armies": God as commander of heaven's forces, sovereign over every power.
  • in v29

    Lord of Hosts

    kyrios sabaōth

    What we hear
    "Host" as someone who receives guests, or a vague religious title.
    What they heard
    "Hosts" = armies. A military title for God as the divine warrior-king.
  • in v29

    Sodom

    Sodoma

    What we hear
    Mainly a shorthand for sexual sin.
    What they heard
    Here, the standard example of total annihilation with no survivors. Where the prophets name Sodom's sins, they stress arrogance, injustice and neglect of the poor (Isaiah 1:10–17; Ezekiel 16:49) as well as the violence of Genesis 19.
Every word
  1. ὡς

    hōs · G5613

    as, just as · v25, v27, v29

    Introduces the quotation as backing for the claim just made in 9:24: God has called people 'not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles.' It means 'this is just what Scripture said.'

  2. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and, also · v25, v26, v28, v29

    'Also': Hosea is one more witness alongside the earlier proofs Paul has given in the chapter (Genesis, Exodus, Malachi), and the first of a run of quotations that continues with Isaiah in 9:27–29.

  3. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v25, v26

    'In', meaning in the book or scroll of Hosea.

  4. τῷ

    tō · G3588

    the · v25, v26, v27, v28

    The article with a prophet's name, as in 'in the Hosea'. It refers to the written collection that goes under his name. English leaves it out.

  5. Ὡσηὲ

    Hōsēe · G5617

    Hosea · v25

    The Greek form of Hebrew Hoshea, the 8th‑century BC prophet to the northern kingdom of Israel. KJV's 'Osee' comes from this Greek and Latin spelling.

  6. λέγει·

    legei · G3004

    he says · v25

    The subject is God, not Hosea: the 'I' who calls is God. The present tense presents the old prophecy as God speaking now, to Paul's readers.

  7. καλέσω

    kalesō · G2564

    I will call · v25, v26

    A future: 'I will name.' In the ancient world, naming someone settled who they were. Paul swaps this verb in for the Greek Old Testament's 'I will say' so that it matches 'whom he called' in 9:24. God's naming and God's calling are the same act.

  8. οὐ

    ou · G3756

    not · v25, v26

    The flat negative is built into the name itself. It renders the Hebrew 'lo' of Lo-Ammi.

  9. λαόν

    laon · G2992

    people · v25, v26

    Part of the old name 'Not-My-People'. In the Greek Old Testament laos is the standard word for Israel as God's covenant people, as opposed to 'the nations'.

  10. μου

    mou · G3165

    my, of me · v25, v26

    'Of me': the denied belonging. They were not his.

  11. ἠγαπημένην

    ēgapēmenēn · G25

    having been loved · v25

    A perfect passive participle, describing a lasting condition: 'the one who has not been loved' and still is not. Here it forms part of the old name.

  12. ἔσται

    estai · G1510

    will be · v26, v27

    This is the prophets' way of announcing a future event: 'it shall come to pass'. Paul's point is that the future Hosea spoke of is now arriving in the people God has called (9:24).

  13. τόπῳ

    topō · G5117

    place · v26

    A place or location. It may be literal (a land or city) or close to 'situation'. The same place that heard the verdict of rejection will hear the new name.

  14. οὗ

    hou · G3757

    where · v26

    'Where', a relative adverb that ties the clause to 'the place'.

  15. ἐρρέθη

    errethē · G2046

    it was said · v26

    A past-tense passive: 'it was said'. God is the unnamed speaker of the verdict. The Greek treats the rejection as already pronounced. It is the earlier word that the coming word will overturn.

  16. αὐτοῖς·

    autois · G0846

    to them · v26

    The people who received the verdict. In Hosea this was the northern kingdom of Israel. Paul applies the words to those God has now called (see debates).

  17. ὑμεῖς,

    hymeis · G4771

    you (plural) · v26

    The quoted verdict is spoken directly to a group: 'You [all] are not my people.' Outside the quotation the verse speaks of 'them' and 'they', and the switch makes the old sentence sound like a voice actually heard.

  18. ἐκεῖ

    ekei · G1563

    there · v26

    'There', meaning in that same place. The main Septuagint text does not have this word, so Paul's wording stresses that the new name is given right where the rejection was spoken.

  19. υἱοὶ

    huioi · G5207

    sons · v26, v27

    'Sons' in the sense of heirs. This is the status Israel held as God's 'firstborn son' (Exodus 4:22). It is more than being 'people' again: it means family standing and the right to inherit.

  20. θεοῦ

    theou · G2316

    of God · v26

    'Of God'. The sonship is defined by whose family they belong to.

  21. ζῶντος.

    zōntos · G2198

    living · v26

    'The living God' was a standard title. It set Israel's God apart from idols and from Baal, whom Canaanite myth pictured as dying and returning. A living God has power to act, and here he gives life to a people who were cut off.

  22. Ἠσαΐας

    Ēsaias · G2268

    Isaiah · v27, v29

    The 8th-century BCE prophet, named as the speaker. Paul treats the scroll of Isaiah as the prophet's living voice.

  23. δὲ

    de · G1161

    and, but · v27

    A light connective with a hint of contrast: Hosea (vv. 25–26) spoke of outsiders becoming God's people; now Isaiah speaks about Israel itself.

  24. κράζει

    krazei · G2896

    to cry out, shout · v27

    A loud, urgent cry, used of solemn public or inspired speech. The present tense makes the prophecy speak now, to Paul's own generation.

  25. ὑπὲρ

    huper · G5228

    over, on behalf of, concerning · v27

    With the genitive here it most likely means 'about, concerning'. Some hear a faint 'on behalf of' as well, but the main sense is the topic of the cry.

  26. Ἰσραήλ·

    Israēl · G2474

    Israel · v27

    The people descended from Jacob as a whole: the historical nation Isaiah addressed and the Jewish people of Paul's day.

  27. ἐὰν

    ean · G1437

    if, even if · v27

    With the following subjunctive it works as 'even though': granting that Israel is countless, the point still stands.

  28. ἀριθμὸς

    arithmos · G0706

    number · v27

    The total count. The phrase 'the number of the sons of Israel' is taken word for word from Hosea 2:1 (1:10 in English Bibles), not from Isaiah.

  29. ἄμμος

    ammos · G0285

    sand · v27

    Countless sand is the image from God's promise to Abraham and Jacob (Gen 22:17; 32:12). The promise of many descendants has come true.

  30. θαλάσσης,

    thalassēs · G2281

    sea · v27

    'Sand of the sea' means the seashore: beyond counting.

  31. ὑπόλειμμα

    hupoleimma · G9577

    remnant, what is left · v27

    The survivors left after a disaster, through whom the people continues. It looks forward to the 'seed' God leaves in v. 29.

  32. σωθήσεται·

    sōthēsetai · G4982

    to save, rescue · v27

    'Will be rescued/saved.' The future passive means God is the one who rescues: the remnant comes through the judgment that sweeps over the nation (v. 28).

  33. λόγον

    logon · G3056

    word, matter, pronouncement · v28

    The thing God has spoken: his announced decree about Israel. It is the object of 'will do', and it comes first in the Greek for emphasis. It also echoes 9:6, 'it is not as though the word of God has failed.'

  34. γὰρ

    gar · G1063

    for · v28

    Gives the reason for 9:27: only a remnant will be saved because the Lord will carry out his word completely and decisively.

  35. συντελῶν

    syntelōn · G4931

    completing, bringing to an end · v28

    'Bringing it to completion.' This is how the Lord acts: he carries his word all the way through. In the Greek Isaiah it stands for the Hebrew idea of a 'full end'.

  36. συντέμνων

    syntemnōn · G4932

    cutting short, cutting down, deciding · v28

    'Cutting it short.' It stands for the Hebrew word for a decision that has been 'cut', meaning firmly decreed. The shades here are decisiveness, speed, and cutting Israel down to a remnant. The word appears nowhere else in the New Testament.

  37. ποιήσει

    poiēsei · G4160

    will do, will make, will carry out · v28

    Future tense: the Lord 'will do' his word, meaning he will put into effect what he has said. In Paul's reading the prophecy is now being fulfilled.

  38. κύριος

    kyrios · G2962

    Lord · v28, v29

    In this quotation it stands, as in the Greek Old Testament, for Israel's God, whose personal name is YHWH. Isaiah's Hebrew has 'the Lord GOD of hosts'. See also 'Lord of Hosts' in 9:29.

  39. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon, on · v28

    Where the decree is carried out: 'upon' the earth or land.

  40. γῆς

    gēs · G1093

    earth, land · v28

    This can mean 'the land' (Israel's land, as in Isaiah's Hebrew) or 'the earth' (as the Greek Isaiah widened it, 'the whole inhabited world'). Paul's wording keeps both possibilities open.

  41. καθὼς

    kathōs · G2531

    just as, even as · v29

    Introduces Scripture as the pattern that present events fit. What is happening to Israel now matches what Isaiah already said.

  42. προείρηκεν

    proeirēken · G4280

    to say beforehand, foretell · v29

    Literally "has said before." It can mean "foretold" or simply "said earlier" (Isaiah 1:9 comes before Isaiah 10:22 in the scroll). The perfect tense shows the words were spoken in the past and still stand on record.

  43. εἰ

    ei · G1487

    if · v29

    Opens a condition that describes something that did not happen ("if the Lord had not…"). Grammatically, the sentence imagines a disaster that was avoided.

  44. μὴ

    mē · G3361

    not · v29

    With εἰ, "unless / if not." The whole weight falls on the one thing that prevented total ruin: the Lord's act.

  45. σαβαὼθ

    sabaōth · G4519

    of armies, of hosts · v29

    A Hebrew word (tsevaot, "armies") carried over into Greek letters rather than translated. It presents God as commander of heaven's forces, the sovereign over every power, including the Assyrian armies that wrecked Judah.

  46. ἐγκατέλιπεν

    enkatelipen · G1459

    to leave behind; to forsake · v29

    Here "left remaining, let survive." The same verb often means "abandon" ("why have you forsaken me"). Here it is the opposite: God kept something back from destruction.

  47. ἡμῖν

    hēmin · G2248

    to/for us · v29

    "For us," for our benefit. In Isaiah, "us" is devastated Judah. On Paul's lips it is Israel, of whom Paul himself is one (9:3; 11:1).

  48. σπέρμα,

    sperma · G4690

    seed; offspring · v29

    A small surviving remnant pictured as seed: little in amount, but able to grow into a future. It ties back to the "seed" of Abraham and Isaac in 9:7–8.

  49. Σόδομα

    Sodoma · G4670

    Sodom · v29

    The city destroyed in Genesis 19. In Greek the name is grammatically plural. Here it is the byword for a people wiped out completely, with nothing left.

  50. ἂν

    an · G302

    would (particle of contingency) · v29

    Marks the result as hypothetical: "we would have…" but did not.

  51. ἐγενήθημεν

    egenēthēmen · G1096

    to become · v29

    "We would have become." It describes a change of state: from a people to a ruin.

  52. Γόμορρα

    Gomorra · G1116

    Gomorrah · v29

    Sodom's twin city in the Genesis 19 destruction. The pair together is a fixed phrase for total, fiery annihilation.

  53. ὡμοιώθημεν.

    hōmoiōthēmen · G3666

    to make like; (passive) to become like · v29

    "We would have been made like." It translates Hebrew damînû, "we would have resembled." Israel's fate would have matched Gomorrah's exactly.

The world behind it

Hosea's sign-children (8th century BC). Hosea prophesied to the northern kingdom of Israel (often called "Ephraim") before its fall to Assyria in 722 BC. In Hosea 1, God has him name his children as walking announcements of judgement:

  • Jezreel ("God sows" / the site of a massacre),
  • Lo-Ruhamah, "Not-Pitied" (Hos 1:6),
  • Lo-Ammi, "Not-My-People," explained by "you are not my people, and I am not yours" (Hos 1:9; literally "I am not I-AM to you").

The last of these deliberately overturns the covenant formula of Exodus 6:7 and Leviticus 26:12. In Hosea 2 the marriage picture (Israel as an unfaithful wife) turns toward restoration, and God promises to rename the children: "I will have compassion on Not-Pitied, and I will say to Not-My-People, 'You are my people'" (Hos 2:23 Eng / 2:25 Heb).

Names in the ancient world. A name was not a decoration. Renaming marked a change of status: Abram became Abraham, and Jerusalem goes from "Forsaken" to "My Delight" in Isaiah 62:4. When a family head declared that a child was or was not "his," that settled whether the child was in or out of the household and its inheritance.

Paul's situation. Romans 9–11 struggles with a real problem for the mixed house churches of Rome. Most of Paul's fellow Jews had not accepted Jesus as Messiah, while Gentiles were streaming in. Had God's word failed (9:6)? Paul answers from Scripture that God's people have always been formed by God's calling and mercy, not simply by birth (Isaac and not Ishmael, Jacob and not Esau). Hosea 2:23 and 1:10 (9:25–26) then supply the language of outsiders being named God's people, and Isaiah (9:27–29) supplies the language of a surviving remnant of Israel.

From the study of Romans 9:25.

Where scholars differ

in v25

Who are the 'not my people' in Paul's use of Hosea: Gentiles, Israelites, or both?

  • Paul applies Hosea to Gentiles. He takes a prophecy about estranged Israel and extends its principle (God makes outsiders his people) to Gentiles who were never in the covenant.

    Verse 24 has just mentioned 'also from the Gentiles'. The Hosea quotations (vv. 25–26) seem to answer that, while the Isaiah quotations (vv. 27–29) are explicitly 'concerning Israel'. That gives the pattern Jews/Gentiles, then Gentiles (Hosea)/Israel (Isaiah). This is the majority view (e.g. Moo, Dunn, Cranfield).

  • Paul is aware that Hosea addressed the northern tribes, and sees Gentile inclusion as part of the promised restoration of scattered Israel. Northern Israelites exiled and absorbed among the nations had become 'not my people', so the regathering reaches into the Gentile world.

    In Hosea the words were spoken to Israelites (Ephraim). Hosea 1:10–11 joins the renaming to the reunion of Israel and Judah. Second Temple hopes for the return of the twelve tribes support this reading, argued for example by J. Staples. Romans 11:26, 'all Israel will be saved', is read along the same lines.

  • The quotation covers the whole called community, Jews and Gentiles alike, since in Paul's argument both stand on God's mercy alone.

    Verse 24's 'us… not only from the Jews but also from the Gentiles' is one group. Paul's stress on mercy for all (11:30–32) suggests he does not split the quotations neatly between groups.

in v25

Is Romans 9 about God choosing individuals for salvation, or about God forming a people?

  • The chapter, including God 'calling' in vv. 24–25, concerns God's sovereign choice of individuals for salvation.

    There are singular examples (Isaac, Jacob, Pharaoh), language of 'vessels of mercy' and 'vessels of wrath' (vv. 22–23), and 'not by works but by him who calls' (v. 12).

  • The chapter concerns who makes up God's people and on what basis: God's calling and mercy, not ethnicity or works.

    The question that frames the chapter is whether God's word to Israel has failed (9:6). Jacob and Esau stand for nations (Gen 25:23; Mal 1:2–3). The Hosea quotation is about a people (laos) being renamed, not individuals one by one.

in v26

Who are 'they' in Paul's use of Hosea: Gentiles only, or Israel as well?

  • Paul applies the Hosea texts to Gentiles, and the Isaiah texts (9:27–29) to Israel.

    9:24 ends 'also from the Gentiles'. The Hosea quotes follow at once, then 'Isaiah cries out *concerning Israel*' (9:27), which sets up a contrast. The two sets of quotes would then match 9:24's 'Jews… Gentiles' in reverse order. 1 Peter 2:10 also applies the text to largely Gentile believers. Held by many commentators (e.g. Cranfield, Moo).

  • Paul keeps Hosea's original reference to a rejected Israel being restored, and either includes Gentiles within that restoration or applies the text to Jews and Gentiles together.

    In Hosea the words are about Israel, and the next verse in Hosea speaks of Judah and Israel reunited. Romans 11 expects Israel's own restoration. Some scholars (e.g. J. Ross Wagner, *Heralds of the Good News*) argue Paul reads Hosea as speaking of an Israel that had become 'like the nations', whose restoration opens the door for Gentiles too.

in v26

What is 'the place' where they are renamed?

  • Wherever the outsiders are, chiefly the Gentile world. God names them sons right where they were 'not a people'.

    This fits Paul's mission to the nations and his added 'there': no move to Jerusalem is required.

  • Jerusalem/Zion, as the place where the nations will gather at the end (a minority view, associated with Johannes Munck and others).

    Prophets picture the nations streaming to Zion (Isaiah 2:2–3), and Zion is mentioned in 9:33 and 11:26.

  • Not a geographical place but a situation: 'in the very circumstance of rejection', or even 'instead of' as one possible reading of the Hebrew.

    The Hebrew phrase bimqôm 'ăšer can mean 'instead of' (HALOT). Paul's emphasis falls on the reversal more than on any location.

in v27

Is the remnant line mainly a threat ('only a remnant') or a promise ('a remnant will be saved')?

  • Mainly restrictive: Paul's point is that only part of Israel will be saved, supporting 9:6 ('not all from Israel are Israel').

    The 'even though' clause sets countless numbers against a limited remnant. Verse 28 speaks of judgment carried out decisively. The argument of 9:6–24 is about God choosing within Israel. Held by e.g. Moo and Schreiner, and reflected in the NIV/ESV/NLT 'only'.

  • Mainly hopeful: the stress falls on the fact that a remnant will survive at all, as a pledge of God's faithfulness.

    There is no 'only' in the Greek. Verse 29 frames the remnant as mercy ('unless the Lord had left us a seed'). In 11:1–5 the remnant is proof that God has not rejected his people, and 11:16, 26 look to a wider restoration. Isaiah's son's name works as a sign of hope. Argued by e.g. J. Ross Wagner and, in part, Cranfield.

  • Both at once.

    Isaiah's original oracle is double-edged (judgment decreed, a remnant returns). Paul's argument moves from narrowing in ch. 9 to hope in ch. 11. Many commentators hold the two together.

in v28

Is 'cutting short' about judgment, mercy, or speed?

  • Decisive judgment: God carries out his sentence on Israel thoroughly and with finality.

    The Hebrew behind it (*kalah*, 'full end'; *charats*, 'decreed') is the language of judgment. Daniel 9:26–27 uses the same terms for decreed desolations. Verse 27's point is that only a remnant is saved.

  • Speed: God acts swiftly, without delay.

    Classical *syntemnō* often means shortening in time or length. Many versions (ESV, NIV, NASB, NLT) include a time element.

  • Cutting down or limiting: God pares Israel down to a remnant, or limits his judgment so that it does not end in annihilation.

    The 'sand of the sea' becoming a remnant (9:27) fits 'cutting down'. Verse 29 ('unless the Lord had left us seed… we would have been like Sodom') stresses that judgment stopped short of total destruction.

in v28

Is the 'word' a word of judgment or of promise?

  • Judgment: the 'word' is the sentence announced against Israel in Isaiah 10.

    That is its meaning in Isaiah. Several versions translate it 'sentence'.

  • God's word as a whole, including promise, fulfilled through the remnant.

    The deliberate echo of 9:6 ('the word of God has not failed') and 9:9 ('the word of promise'). The remnant and 'seed' language of 9:27, 29, and 11:5 ('a remnant chosen by grace'), carry hope.

in v28

'Earth' or 'land'?

  • The land of Israel.

    Isaiah's Hebrew refers to Assyrian devastation of Israel and Judah. The context is about Israel (9:27).

  • The whole earth.

    The Greek Isaiah widened it to 'the whole inhabited world'. Paul's phrase resembles Isaiah 28:22, 'all the earth'. Romans 9–11 places Israel's fate within God's dealings with all nations.

in v29

Does proeirēken mean Isaiah "foretold" this, or simply "said earlier" (in his book)?

  • "Said earlier": a cross-reference within Isaiah.

    Isaiah 1:9 stands before Isaiah 10:22, which Paul has just quoted. Paul uses the same verb for "as I said before" in Galatians 1:9 and 2 Corinthians 13:2. Commentators such as Cranfield and Moo take this view or allow it.

  • "Foretold": Isaiah was predicting the situation of Paul's day.

    Paul reads the prophets as speaking ahead of time about the events surrounding the Messiah (Romans 1:2; 15:4), and "pro-" readily suggests prediction. Jesus' sayings in Matthew 24:25 and Mark 13:23 use the verb in this sense.

  • Both

    The two senses do not exclude each other. Paul can point to an earlier passage of Isaiah while also treating it as a pattern fulfilled in his own time.

in v29

Is the "seed" mainly a note of judgment (only a few) or of hope (a guarantee of future restoration)?

  • Mainly judgment: the stress falls on how few are spared.

    Isaiah 1:7–9 describes devastation, and many translations render 9:27 as "only a remnant will be saved." In context, Paul is explaining why most of Israel is not responding.

  • Mainly hope: the remnant is a pledge that the whole will be restored.

    The Greek of 9:27 has no word for "only." "Seed" implies future growth. Paul later calls the remnant "chosen by grace" (11:5) and a "firstfruits" that sanctifies the whole lump (11:16), and he expects "all Israel" to be saved (11:26). J. Ross Wagner and others argue for this reading.

  • Both together

    The verse is a condition about something that did not happen: it admits that judgment was deserved and celebrates that mercy prevented it. Paul's argument in chapters 9–11 moves from the first emphasis to the second.

Sources
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., Rom 9:25
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs; Göttingen ed. Ziegler), Hosea 1:6–9; 2:1, 2:25, with apparatus on Codex Vaticanus
  • Masoretic Text, Hosea 2:25
  • BDAG s.v. καλέω, λαός, ἀγαπάω
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. λαός
  • HALOT s.v. רחם
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
  • J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
  • J. R. Wagner, Heralds of the Good News: Isaiah and Paul 'in Concert' in the Letter to the Romans
  • J. Staples, The Idea of Israel in Second Temple Judaism / 'What Do the Gentiles Have to Do with All Israel?' (JBL 2011)
  • Vulgate, Rom 9:25
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at Rom 9:26)
  • Rahlfs-Hanhart, Septuaginta, Hosea 2:1
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, Hosea 2:1
  • BDAG s.v. λαός, καλέω, υἱός, ζάω, τόπος
  • HALOT s.v. מָקוֹם (bimqôm 'ăšer)
  • J. Ross Wagner, Heralds of the Good News: Isaiah and Paul in Concert in the Letter to the Romans (2002)
  • Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
  • James D. G. Dunn, Romans 9–16 (WBC)
  • Robert Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
  • Mark A. Seifrid, 'Romans', in Beale & Carson (eds.), Commentary on the New Testament Use of the Old Testament
  • Johannes Munck, Christ and Israel: An Interpretation of Romans 9–11
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (apparatus at Rom 9:27)
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs-Hanhart), Isa 10:22–23; Hos 2:1
  • BDAG s.v. κράζω, ὑπέρ, ὑπόλειμμα, σῴζω
  • HALOT s.v. שְׁאָר, שׁוּב
  • T. R. Schreiner, Romans (BECNT)
  • J. R. Wagner, Heralds of the Good News: Isaiah and Paul 'in Concert' in the Letter to the Romans (2002)
  • Damascus Document (CD) 1:4–5
  • Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Romans 9:28
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Isaiah 10:22–23; 28:22; Theodotion Daniel 9:24–27
  • BDAG s.v. συντέμνω, συντελέω, λόγος, γῆ
  • HALOT s.v. חרץ, כָּלָה
  • J. R. Wagner, Heralds of the Good News: Isaiah and Paul in Concert in the Letter to the Romans
  • C. D. Stanley, Paul and the Language of Scripture
  • Vulgate, Romans 9:28
  • Rahlfs-Hanhart Septuaginta, Isaiah 1:9
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, Isaiah 1:9
  • BDAG s.v. ἐγκαταλείπω
  • BDAG s.v. προερέω
  • BDAG s.v. σπέρμα
  • BDAG s.v. σαβαώθ
  • BDB s.v. שָׂרִיד
  • HALOT s.v. צָבָא
  • C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), on 9:27–29
  • D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 9:27–29
  • J. A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible)
  • Sennacherib's annals (Taylor/Chicago Prism), account of the 701 BC campaign
  • Vulgate, Romans 9:29

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).