Isaiah Chapter 16 Read as one passage

Isaiah 16:8–10

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

8For the fields of Heshbon have withered, along with the grapevines of Sibmah. The rulers of the nations have trampled its choicest vines, which had reached as far as Jazer and spread toward the desert. Their shoots had spread out and passed over the sea. 9So I weep with Jazer for the vines of Sibmah; I drench Heshbon and Elealeh with my tears. Triumphant shouts have fallen silent over your summer fruit and your harvest. 10Joy and gladness are removed from the orchard; no one sings or shouts in the vineyards. No one tramples the grapes in the winepresses; I have put an end to the cheering.

What the first hearers heard

For Judean hearers this was an oracle about Moab, a close neighbor and frequent rival east of the Dead Sea. Its people were related to Israel through Lot and to David through Ruth, and Israel had fought it repeatedly. A Judean might have expected gloating. Instead the poem mourns Moab's lost vineyards using the very images Israel used for itself: the choice vine (Isaiah 5:2) and the vine that sends out its shoots to the sea (Psalm 80:11). The next verse is striking: "I weep with the weeping of Jazer for the vine of Sibmah."

The verse communicated several things together:

  • The scale of the catastrophe. Moab's signature wealth, its wine country from Jazer to the desert to the sea, has withered. The harvest festival goes silent (verses 9–10).
  • Pride brought low. Verse 6 has just named Moab's pride. A vine whose wine "struck down the lords of the nations", or a vine famous enough that the world's lords came and struck it down, is exactly the kind of national glory that can be lost in a single campaign.
  • Shared grief, not triumph. Judgment on the nations is real in Isaiah, but here it is voiced as a lament. That told Israel something about how its God regards even its neighbors' ruin, and it warned that Judah's own vineyard (Isaiah 5) could be stripped the same way.

From the study of Isaiah 16:8.

Verse by verse

  1. 8For the fields of Heshbon have withered, along with the grapevines of Sibmah. The rulers of the nations have trampled its choicest vines, which had reached as far as Jazer and spread toward the desert. Their shoots had spread out and passed over the sea.

    Yes, this is why Moab wails: the terraced vineyards of Heshbon have shriveled and gone limp, and so has the great vine of Sibmah. Its prize red-grape vines were the kind whose wine could knock the lords of the nations flat. Or, read the other way, the lords of the nations have now hammered those vines to the ground. That vine had once reached all the way north to Jazer. It straggled east into the desert steppe where no vine belongs. Its runners spread out freely and crossed over the sea to the west.

    The verse is a lament (a mourning song) shaped like a map. It does not just say "the crops failed". It pictures a single legendary vine whose tendrils covered the whole of Moab: north, east and west. Then it says that vine is withered. The verbs are mostly completed actions ("has withered", "reached", "crossed"), so the glory is told as something now in the past. The pairing of "hammer" and "stray" with a wine country may carry a hint of drunkenness: wine that floors rulers, tendrils that wander like a reeling drinker. Above all, the language for the vine ("choice vine", shoots "sent out to the sea") is the same language Israel's own scriptures use for Israel as God's vine. In the next verse the prophet weeps for it.

    Full study →
  2. 9So I weep with Jazer for the vines of Sibmah; I drench Heshbon and Elealeh with my tears. Triumphant shouts have fallen silent over your summer fruit and your harvest.

    Therefore I weep. I join my weeping to the wailing of Jazer for the vine of Sibmah, the famous vine whose branches once spread to the desert and the sea and have now been trampled by foreign lords. Heshbon, Elealeh, I soak you with my tears. Where rain and wine should have watered your fields, my weeping waters them now. For over your late-summer fruit and over your harvest the hedad has fallen.

    The hedad was the rhythmic shout of men stamping grapes in the winepress, the sound of a good year. The same word was used for the war cry of attacking soldiers. Both meanings are at work here. The harvest cheer has fallen silent, and the shout now coming down on Moab's crops is the enemy's. The line pictures the climax of the farming year, when villages would be loud with celebration. The mourner stands in that silence and weeps along with the towns themselves. Verbs written as finished ('has fallen') present the ruin as already done.

    Full study →
  3. 10Joy and gladness are removed from the orchard; no one sings or shouts in the vineyards. No one tramples the grapes in the winepresses; I have put an end to the cheering.

    Joy and exultation are gathered up and carried off from Moab's rich garden-land. It is harvest time, the season when everything is gathered in, but the only thing being "gathered" is the gladness itself. In the vine-lands there is no ringing song, there is no cheering. The verbs have no subject: it is not that particular singers stop, but that the sound itself is gone from hills that should be loud with the vintage. As for wine, in the vats the treader does not tread. The rock-cut presses that should hold barefoot men stamping grapes are empty, and the repeated words ("the treader does not tread") make the stillness felt. The treaders' rhythmic shout — I have stopped it. The verse saves its subject for last: the silence is not an accident of war or weather but the act of the God of Israel. The word for the shout (hêdād) is also used elsewhere for an army's battle-cry, so behind the vanished harvest cheer a first hearer might catch the shout of the invader that replaced it. All this is spoken in the middle of a lament (verses 9 and 11: "I weep… my inner parts moan like a harp"), so the one who ends Moab's song is also the one who mourns over it.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v8

    the lords of the heathen (KJV)

    baʿălê gôyim

    What we hear
    'Heathen' now suggests uncivilized, irreligious or godless people, a moral and religious judgment.
    What they heard
    'Lords of nations', meaning the powerful rulers of the surrounding peoples. Gôyim is the ordinary word for nations, and Israel itself is called a gôy. The point is political power, not religious status.
  • in v8

    the sea

    yām

    What we hear
    Readers may picture the Mediterranean or the open ocean, and imagine Moabite vines or trade reaching overseas.
    What they heard
    In this map of Moab (Jazer, desert, sea) the 'sea' is almost certainly the Dead Sea on Moab's western edge. The vine reaches the country's natural border.
  • in v8

    languish (KJV, WEB, YLT)

    ʾumlal

    What we hear
    Today 'languish' usually means pining, lingering in boredom or suffering emotionally ('languishing in prison').
    What they heard
    A plant word: drooping, shriveling, drying up. It describes the physical withering of vineyards, though the same verb can also be used of people wasting away.
  • in v9

    shouting / triumphant shouts

    hêdād

    What we hear
    General yelling, or (BSB) a victory cheer.
    What they heard
    The rhythmic work-song shout of grape-treaders at the winepress, the sound of a joyful harvest. The same word means an army's war cry, and the line plays on both.
  • in v10

    shouting / cheering

    hêdād

    What we hear
    General loud noise: yelling, perhaps in anger, or a crowd cheering at an event.
    What they heard
    The specific rhythmic call of grape-treaders at work, a harvest work-song cry. The same word can mean a battle-shout, which gives the passage a darker double meaning.
Every word
  1. כִּ֣י

    kî · H3588A

    for, because, indeed · v8, v9

    Links this verse to verse 7: here is why Moab wails over its raisin cakes. Its vineyards are gone. It may also simply add emphasis ('Yes, indeed...').

  2. שַׁדְמוֹת֩

    shadmôt · H7709

    fields, terraces · v8

    Cultivated plots, very probably the stepped vineyard terraces of the Heshbon plateau. The word sits next to 'vine' elsewhere too (Deuteronomy 32:32), so a hearer would picture vineyard land rather than open grain fields.

  3. חֶשְׁבּ֨וֹן

    ḥeshbôn · H2809

    Heshbon · v8, v9

    The major town on the northern Moabite plateau (modern Tell Hesban, Jordan). It was once Sihon's capital (Numbers 21) and by Isaiah's day it was in Moabite hands.

  4. אֻמְלָ֜ל

    ʾumlal · H0535

    to wither, languish · v8

    'Has shriveled, has gone limp.' This is a plant word for drooping and drying up, and it is also used for people who are wasting away. The verb is singular, so the fields and the vine are treated as one ruined landscape.

  5. גֶּ֣פֶן

    gefen · H1612

    vine · v8, v9

    The grapevine, singular but standing for the whole vine culture of the region. It becomes the 'she' of the rest of the verse ('its/her choice vines', 'its/her shoots').

  6. שִׂבְמָ֗ה

    sivmāh · H7643H

    Sibmah · v8, v9

    A town near Heshbon (Numbers 32:38; Joshua 13:19) whose exact site is unknown. Here and in Jeremiah 48:32 it is famous for its vine, a bit like a named wine region.

  7. בַּעֲלֵ֤י

    baʿălê · H1167G

    owner, master, lord · v8

    'Lords of', meaning those with power: rulers, masters, overlords. Whether they are the ones who destroy the vine or the ones the vine's wine 'knocks down' is debated (see below).

  8. גוֹיִם֙

    gôyim · H1471A

    nation, people · v8

    'Nations', meaning peoples in general. 'Lords of nations' means great rulers of the wider world, not specifically 'pagans' in a religious sense.

  9. הָלְמ֣וּ

    hālmû · H1986

    to strike, hammer · v8

    'They hammered, beat down.' This is a violent verb for blows (Judges 5:26, of Jael's hammer), but Isaiah also uses it of people 'hammered by wine', meaning dead drunk (Isaiah 28:1). That double use is what makes the clause ambiguous.

  10. שְׂרוּקֶּ֔יהָ

    śerûqqêhā · H8291

    choice vine, tendril · v8

    'Its prize red vines' or their clusters. The related word sōrēq is the choice vine the Beloved planted in Isaiah's vineyard song (Isaiah 5:2) and probably comes from a root meaning 'red'. These are the finest grapes.

  11. עַד־

    ʿad · H5704

    as far as, until · v8

    'All the way to.' It marks how far the vine stretches, the first of three directions it spreads.

  12. יַעְזֵ֥ר

    yaʿzēr · H3270G

    Jazer · v8, v9

    A town north of Heshbon toward Gilead (Numbers 21:32; 32:1–3). Its exact site is debated. It marks the vine's northern limit.

  13. נָגָ֖עוּ

    nāgāʿû · H5060

    to touch, reach · v8

    'They reached, touched.' The tendrils stretch until they touch Jazer, a picture of a single vine spread across the whole country.

  14. תָּ֣עוּ

    tāʿû · H8582

    to wander, stray, stagger · v8

    'They strayed, wandered off' into the desert, the way runaway tendrils sprawl. Isaiah also uses this verb for drunks staggering (Isaiah 28:7), which may be a deliberate echo in a verse full of wine.

  15. מִדְבָּ֑ר

    midbār · H4057B

    wilderness, steppe · v8

    The dry steppe and desert east of the Moabite plateau, land used for grazing and not for farming. The vine pushes out even into land where vines do not belong. This is the eastern limit.

  16. שְׁלֻ֣חוֹתֶ֔יהָ

    sheluḥôtêhā · H7976

    shoots, branches · v8

    'Its sent-out shoots', from the verb 'to send'. These are the runners a vine throws out. The word occurs only here in the Hebrew Bible.

  17. נִטְּשׁ֖וּ

    nitteshû · H5203

    to leave, let loose; spread out · v8

    'They were let loose, spread out freely' (compare 1 Samuel 30:16, raiders 'spread out' over the land). The same root can mean 'abandoned', so a hearer might also catch a hint of the vine now being left to ruin.

  18. עָ֥בְרוּ

    ʿāverû · H5674A

    to pass over, cross · v8

    'They crossed over.' The shoots go beyond the border of the land itself.

  19. יָֽם׃

    yām · H3220G

    sea · v8

    'Sea' without the definite article. In this geography it almost certainly means the Dead Sea to the west, which closes the circle: north (Jazer), east (desert), west (sea).

  20. עַל־

    ʿal- · H5921A

    upon, on account of · v9

    First half of the stock phrase 'al-ken, 'therefore'. It ties the weeping directly to the ruin of the vineyards described in verse 8.

  21. כֵּן

    kēn · H3651C

    so, thus · v9

    Together with 'al it means 'on account of this', 'therefore'. The tears are a response to the trampled vines.

  22. אֶבְכֶּה

    ʾebkeh · H1058

    to weep · v9

    'I weep' or 'I will weep'. The Hebrew form covers both ongoing and coming action. This is loud mourning, the kind done in public for the dead, not quiet sadness. The 'I' is the voice of the oracle: the prophet, or God speaking through him (see debates).

  23. בִּבְכִי

    bibkî · H1065

    weeping · v9

    'With the weeping of'. The noun comes from the same root as the verb before it, so it reads 'I weep the weeping of Jazer'. The speaker joins in Jazer's own lament and weeps as Jazer weeps.

  24. אֲרַיָּוֶךְ

    ʾărayyāwek · H7301

    to drench, saturate · v9

    'I drench you' or 'I soak you'. The verb is used for ground soaked by rain and for a thirst fully satisfied. The tears are pictured as watering the very fields the enemy has stripped. The spelling is unusual (see textual notes).

  25. דִּמְעָתִי

    dimʿātî · H1832

    tear(s) · v9

    'My tear'. Singular in form but meaning tears in general, like English 'my weeping'. It is the liquid that soaks the land.

  26. וְאֶלְעָלֵה

    wəʾelʿālēh · H0500

    and Elealeh · v9

    'And Elealeh'. A town about 3 km northeast of Heshbon, always paired with it (Isaiah 15:4; Numbers 32:3, 37). The two neighbours are soaked with tears together.

  27. קֵיצֵךְ

    qêṣēk · H7019

    summer; summer fruit · v9

    'Your summer fruit'. Here the word means the late-summer fruit crop, chiefly figs and grapes, not the season. 'Your' is feminine, addressing the personified cities or land.

  28. קְצִירֵךְ

    qəṣîrēk · H7105A

    harvest · v9

    'Your harvest'. The usual word for the grain harvest. Paired with summer fruit, it sums up the whole farming year's yield. The parallel in Jeremiah reads 'your grape-harvest' instead.

  29. הֵידָד

    hêdād · H1959

    shout, cheer · v9, v10

    The rhythmic shout of men treading grapes in the winepress. The same word is used for a war cry (Jeremiah 51:14). The double meaning is deliberate: the happy harvest cheer is gone, and an enemy's shout has taken its place.

  30. נָפָל

    nāpāl · H5307G

    to fall · v9

    'Has fallen'. Written as a completed event. 'Fallen' can mean 'collapsed, ceased', so the cheer is silenced. With 'upon' it can also mean 'fell upon, attacked', so a battle cry has struck the harvest.

  31. וְנֶאֱסַ֨ף

    wəneʾĕsap · H0622

    to gather; (passive) be gathered up, taken away · v10

    "And it is gathered away." The usual verb for bringing in a harvest, here used passively. At harvest time the one thing being "gathered in" from Moab's fields is the joy itself, and it is taken away.

  32. שִׂמְחָ֤ה

    śimḥâ · H8057

    joy, gladness · v10

    The normal word for joy, often joy you can see and hear at feasts and festivals. Here it means the festive mood of the grape harvest.

  33. וָגִיל֙

    wāgîl · H1524A

    rejoicing, exultation · v10

    "And exultation." A more exuberant word, paired with śimḥâ to mean "all joy, every kind of rejoicing." Jeremiah 48:33 repeats the same pair.

  34. מִן־

    min- · H4480A

    from · v10

    Marks where the joy is taken from.

  35. הַכַּרְמֶ֔ל

    hakkarmel · H3759

    garden-land, fruitful plantation · v10

    "The garden-land." Rich cultivated ground planted with vines and fruit trees. This is not Mount Carmel in Israel. It sounds like the next word, kərāmîm (vineyards), and the echo is clearly deliberate.

  36. וּבַכְּרָמִ֥ים

    ûbakkərāmîm · H3754

    vineyard · v10

    "And in the vineyards." These are the famous vineyards of the Moabite plateau named in verses 8–9: Sibmah, Jazer, Heshbon, Elealeh.

  37. לֹֽא־

    lōʾ · H3808

    not · v10

    Negates the singing.

  38. יְרֻנָּ֖ן

    yərunnān · H7442B

    to give a ringing cry, sing out · v10

    A passive form with no subject: "there is no ringing song." The point is not that some particular person stops singing. The sound itself is gone from the vineyards.

  39. יְרֹעָ֑ע

    yərōʿāʿ · H7321

    to shout, raise a loud cry · v10

    "There is no shouting." Also passive and impersonal. The verb covers loud cries of joy and acclaim as well as war-cries. Here it is the cheering of harvesters.

  40. יַ֗יִן

    yayin · H3196

    wine · v10

    Placed first for emphasis. Treaders tread grapes, but Hebrew speaks of "treading wine": the purpose of the work is named instead of the raw fruit.

  41. בַּיְקָבִ֛ים

    bayqābîm · H3342

    wine-vat, wine-press trough · v10

    "In the vats." Strictly, the rock-cut basin where the juice collected. The word also stands for the whole winepress setup.

  42. יִדְרֹ֥ךְ

    yidrōk · H1869

    to tread, trample · v10

    "Treads." The ordinary verb for walking or stamping, here used for stamping grapes with bare feet.

  43. הִשְׁבַּֽתִּי׃

    hišbattî · H7673A

    to cease; (causative) make to stop, put an end to · v10

    "I have made it stop." The verse ends on God's own first-person act: the silence is no accident of war but his judgment. The form is a completed action, said as though it has already happened.

The world behind it

Moab's wine country. The northern Moabite plateau around Heshbon, Sibmah, Elealeh and Jazer (east of the Jordan and the north end of the Dead Sea) was well watered and terraced. It was known for grapes and raisins (verse 7's "raisin cakes of Kir-hareseth"). Wine was a regional luxury and a trade good, and the grape harvest was the high point of the farming year, with shouting and treading in the presses (verses 9–10). Losing the vineyards meant losing wealth, festivity and national pride all at once (compare Moab's "pride" in 16:6).

The geography is the poetry. Jazer lies to the north, the desert (midbar) to the east, and the "sea", almost certainly the Dead Sea, to the west. Naming these limits makes one vine stand for the whole country, the way Psalm 80:8–11 makes one vine stand for Israel from the sea to the Euphrates. "Crossed over the sea" is either poetic exaggeration (the vines grow right down to the shore) or a hint that Moabite wine was exported across it.

Historical moment. Isaiah 15–16 is an oracle (a prophetic pronouncement) about Moab. It probably belongs to the period of Assyrian expansion in the late 8th century BC, when Tiglath-pileser III, Sargon II and Sennacherib forced the small kingdoms of the Levant (the lands along the eastern Mediterranean) into submission. "Lords of the nations" fits foreign overlords and their armies, who routinely cut down orchards and vineyards in campaigns. Isaiah 16:13–14 itself notes that this was "the word the LORD spoke concerning Moab long ago", which suggests to many scholars that an older lament was taken up and reapplied. Jeremiah 48:29–38 reuses much of this same material a century or more later.

From the study of Isaiah 16:8.

Where scholars differ

in v8

Who strikes whom: do the 'lords of the nations' destroy Sibmah's vines, or do Sibmah's vines (their wine) 'strike down' the lords of the nations?

  • Foreign rulers destroyed the vines (KJV, Vulgate, BSB, NIV, ESV and many commentators).

    This is the natural subject–verb–object order. hālam is a verb of violent striking. Conquering armies routinely cut down vineyards. It fits the theme of devastation in chapters 15–16.

  • The vine's choice clusters 'struck down' (made drunk) the lords of the nations (NRSV and a number of critical commentators).

    Hebrew can put the object first. Isaiah 28:1 uses hālam for people 'struck down by wine', and Proverbs 23:35 uses it in a drunkard's speech. The rest of the verse praises the vine's fame and reach, so a line saying its wine was prized by (and overpowered) great rulers fits the flow. The 'staggering' sense of tāʿû may reinforce the wine theme.

in v8

What is the 'sea' the vine's shoots crossed?

  • The Dead Sea.

    It is the western boundary of Moab and completes the north (Jazer), east (desert), west (sea) frame. It is the most widely held view.

  • A poetic or commercial extension, such as wine exported across the sea, or an unidentified body of water near Jazer.

    Jeremiah 48:32's 'sea of Jazer' has prompted proposals of a local pool or lake. Others take 'crossed the sea' as exaggeration for fame and trade. Both are less secure, since 'sea of Jazer' is likely a copying error.

in v8

Does nitteshû mean the shoots 'spread out' or were 'abandoned'?

  • 'Spread out, let loose' (most translations).

    The Niphal (passive) form is used of things spreading or hanging loose (1 Samuel 30:16; Isaiah 33:23), which fits the run of verbs about the vine's reach.

  • 'Abandoned, left behind', or at least a deliberate double sense.

    The basic meaning of nāṭash is 'leave, forsake'. The Septuagint reads 'were abandoned'. A lament could deliberately let the image of a flourishing spread slide into one of desertion.

in v9

Who is weeping, and is the lament sincere?

  • The prophet himself feels real grief for Moab's suffering.

    The emotional first-person language here and in 15:5 ('My heart cries out for Moab') and 16:11 ('my innards moan like a lyre for Moab'). Commentators such as Oswalt and Childs read this as genuine compassion.

  • God is the speaker, mourning the judgment he himself brings.

    Verse 10 ends with 'I have put an end to the hedad', which most naturally means God, since only he 'puts an end' to the harvest in judgment. Jeremiah 48:31–32, 36 also puts the lament in God's mouth ('declares the LORD').

  • The lament is ironic, a mock dirge that announces doom while seeming to mourn.

    Taunt-laments over enemies exist elsewhere (Isaiah 14:4–21). Isaiah 16:6 condemns Moab's pride, and 16:12–14 is severe. Some scholars therefore hear the weeping as formal or ironic rather than heartfelt.

in v9

What does 'the hedad has fallen' mean?

  • The harvest cheer has ceased.

    Verse 10 explicitly describes the absence of singing and shouting in the vineyards and says 'I have put an end to the hedad'. Jeremiah 25:30 confirms hedad as the grape-treaders' shout. ESV, NIV and BSB follow this.

  • A battle shout has fallen upon the crops.

    'Upon... fell' is a normal Hebrew idiom for attack. Hedad means a war cry in Jeremiah 51:14. Jeremiah 48:32 substitutes 'the destroyer'. WEB and the Vulgate lean this way.

  • A deliberate double meaning.

    Both meanings of hedad are attested in the same prophetic circle, and Jeremiah 48:33 openly plays on the word ('a shout that is no shout'). Many commentators (e.g. Wildberger) see a deliberate play.

in v9

What historical disaster does the oracle describe?

  • An Assyrian campaign of the late 8th century BC.

    Isaiah's own era; Tiglath-pileser III, Sargon II and Sennacherib all campaigned in or near the region, and 16:13–14 sets a three-year timeframe.

  • An older oracle, perhaps about a northern or Arab invasion, reapplied by Isaiah.

    16:13 calls the oracle a word spoken 'long ago'. Its geography (an invasion from the north) and archaic style have led some scholars to date the core earlier.

in v10

Who is the weeping "I" around this verse, and is it the same as the "I" who stops the shout?

  • God himself speaks throughout: he judges Moab and mourns over it.

    "I have made it cease" (v. 10) can only be God's act, and nothing marks a change of speaker between v. 9 ("I weep"), v. 10 and v. 11 ("my inner parts moan"). Jer 48:31–36 likewise mixes divine first-person judgment with lament.

  • The prophet laments in vv. 9 and 11, and in v. 10 he quotes God's words or speaks as God's mouthpiece.

    Prophets regularly move between their own voice and God's without marking it. Weeping and inner turmoil are typical of a prophet's personal reaction (compare Isa 21:3–4; 22:4).

in v10

Is the lament sincere sympathy, or an ironic mock-dirge over an enemy?

  • Sincere grief over a neighbouring people.

    The tone is tender and detailed (tears soaking Heshbon, the harp-like moaning). In 16:3–5 Moab's refugees are even urged to seek shelter in Judah.

  • Partly ironic or mixed: lament form used for a judgment oracle, with an edge of taunt.

    Funeral songs could be sung mockingly over enemies (Isa 14:4–21). Moab's pride is condemned in 16:6. Jeremiah's version of the oracle includes open mockery (Jer 48:26–27, 39).

in v10

What historical disaster is in view?

  • Assyrian campaigns of the late 8th century (Tiglath-pileser III, Sargon II or Sennacherib).

    Isa 16:13–14 sets a "three years" deadline in Isaiah's time, and Assyrian records report action against Moab and its tribute in this period.

  • An older oracle (perhaps 9th century, or from an unknown poet) reapplied by Isaiah, and later by Jeremiah.

    16:13 calls it a word spoken "in the past." Jeremiah 48 reuses the same material for a later Babylonian-era disaster, which shows the text was adapted to new events.

Sources

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).