Jeremiah Chapter 16 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 16:14–18

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

14Yet behold, the days are coming, declares the LORD, when they will no longer say, ‘As surely as the LORD lives, who brought the Israelites up out of the land of Egypt.’ 15Instead they will say, ‘As surely as the LORD lives, who brought the Israelites up out of the land of the north and all the other lands to which He had banished them.’ For I will return them to their land that I gave to their forefathers. 16But for now I will send for many fishermen, declares the LORD, and they will catch them. After that I will send for many hunters, and they will hunt them down on every mountain and hill, even from the clefts of the rocks. 17For My eyes are on all their ways. They are not hidden from My face, and their guilt is not concealed from My eyes. 18And I will first repay them double their iniquity and their sin, because they have defiled My land with the carcasses of their detestable idols, and they have filled My inheritance with their abominations.”

What the first hearers heard

For Jeremiah's first hearers, the verse would have been startling on two levels.

  1. It assumes the worst will happen. A return from "all the lands where he had driven them" (v. 15) only makes sense if the exile of v. 13 really comes. The promise did not offer a way to escape judgment. It offered hope on the far side of it.

  2. It promised a rescue bigger than the founding one. The exodus was the deepest layer of Israel's identity, recited in worship, built into the law ("I am YHWH your God who brought you out of Egypt"), and spoken every time someone swore an oath. To hear that a future act would replace it as the name they swore by meant that God's history with Israel was not over. Its greatest chapter was still to come.

For the exiles in Babylon who later read Jeremiah's scroll, the verse worked as a promise to hold on to. The God who once brought their ancestors up from Egypt would bring them up again. Their loyalty in exile would be shown partly by keeping the oath "as YHWH lives" and not swearing by the gods of the land they lived in (compare v. 13, "there you will serve other gods").

From the study of Jeremiah 16:14.

Verse by verse

  1. 14Yet behold, the days are coming, declares the LORD, when they will no longer say, ‘As surely as the LORD lives, who brought the Israelites up out of the land of Egypt.’

    "So then, look! An era is on its way (this is the LORD's own declaration) when people will no longer take their oath by saying, 'As surely as the LORD lives, the God who brought the children of Israel up out of the land of Egypt…'"

    For centuries, when an Israelite wanted to bind themselves to the truth of their words, they swore by the life of the living God, and they named that God by what he had done: he was the one who brought Israel up out of Egyptian slavery. The exodus was Israel's identity card, the great proof of who their God was.

    Jeremiah has just announced that the people will be thrown out of their land into exile, among foreign gods, with no favor shown (v. 13). Then, abruptly, God announces a future so remarkable that it will change the way people swear oaths. The sentence finishes in v. 15: people will instead swear by the God "who brought the children of Israel up out of the land of the north and from all the lands where he had driven them." The coming return from exile will be a second exodus, described in the same verb ("brought up"), and it will be so great that it eclipses the first as the defining act people point to when they name their God.

    The exodus is not being cancelled or forgotten. The point is comparison: what God is about to do will outshine even the founding miracle of the nation.

    Full study →
  2. 15Instead they will say, ‘As surely as the LORD lives, who brought the Israelites up out of the land of the north and all the other lands to which He had banished them.’ For I will return them to their land that I gave to their forefathers.

    Verse 14 said a day was coming when people would stop swearing by "the LORD who brought Israel up out of Egypt". This verse gives the oath that will replace it: "By the life of YHWH, who brought the whole family of Israel up out of the land of the north, and out of every land where he had scattered them like a driven flock!" People will still swear by the same living God. But they will name him by a new and greater act. The Exodus from Egypt had defined Israel's God for centuries, and it will be outdone by a second exodus. This one comes out of the north, the country of the Babylonian and Assyrian conquerors whose armies had swept down on Israel, and out of every far place the exiles had ended up. The oath is phrased in the past tense, as people will say it after the event, when the return is already history.

    Then God steps in and speaks in his own voice to guarantee it: "And I will make them return, onto their own soil, the ground I gave to their ancestors." The scattering was God's doing, and so is the gathering. The goal is not just "a land" but their soil. The word means the actual farmed ground of home, and it is set against the many foreign "countries" of exile. It belongs to them because God gave it, long ago, to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, and the gift was never taken back. The verse sits right after a sentence of exile ("I will hurl you out of this land", v.13) and right before more judgment (vv.16–18). That placement shows the exile is real but not final, and that the land promise outlasts the punishment.

    Full study →
  3. 16But for now I will send for many fishermen, declares the LORD, and they will catch them. After that I will send for many hunters, and they will hunt them down on every mountain and hill, even from the clefts of the rocks.

    "Look — I am already sending for fishermen, many of them," declares the LORD, "and they will haul my people out like fish. And after that I will summon hunters, many of them, and they will track them down and take them like game: off every mountain, off every hill, and out of the narrowest cracks in the rock."

    The picture is total pursuit. First come the nets, sweeping people up in large numbers. Then come the hunters for anyone who slipped through, chasing them into the hill country, the high places where Judah had worshipped other gods, and into the caves and crevices where fugitives hid when armies invaded. God is the one doing the summoning: these catchers are the invading armies, Babylon above all, called up as his agents. The next verses explain why: "My eyes are on all their ways; they are not hidden from my face, and their guilt is not concealed from my eyes. I will first repay double for their iniquity and their sin" (vv. 17–18). To the first hearers, "fishermen" did not sound like rescue. It was the familiar language of conquest, of captives taken away with hooks and nets.

    Full study →
  4. 17For My eyes are on all their ways. They are not hidden from My face, and their guilt is not concealed from My eyes.

    Because the hunters of verse 16 will find them even in the cracks of the rocks: my own eyes are fixed on every road they have walked, on the whole course of their lives as they have chosen to live them. Neither they nor their ways have slipped out of my sight. However deep the crevice they crawl into, they are still standing in front of my face. And their guilt has not been stowed away somewhere out of view, filed and forgotten, like something put in storage. The wrong they did, and the debt of guilt it has built up, is lying right in front of my eyes.

    The verse opens and closes with God's eyes, so everything it says happens inside his field of vision. The two verbs build on each other. First the people are not hidden. Then their guilt is not packed away. Hebrew ʿavon, rendered "iniquity" or "guilt", covers both the crooked act and the guilt that has to be settled. That is why the next verse speaks of God repaying it. This is not the comforting gaze of a guardian. It is the gaze of a judge who already has the whole file open.

    Full study →
  5. 18And I will first repay them double their iniquity and their sin, because they have defiled My land with the carcasses of their detestable idols, and they have filled My inheritance with their abominations.”

    "Before anything else, before the return I have just promised, I will settle their account in full. I will pay them back a matching double for their crooked guilt and their sins, because they have taken my holy land and made it common, unholy ground. With the corpse-like idols they detest me with, and with every forbidden rite, they have packed my own family estate full."

    The verse reads like a court ruling. The verb is the language of restitution, related to shalom: making things whole by paying off a debt. "Double" recalls the law that a thief who took another's property must repay twice. Judah has in effect stolen and polluted YHWH's estate. Whether "double" means strictly twice or "a full matching equivalent," the debt is paid without discount.

    The charge is in priestly terms. The land belongs to God, and it is his inalienable ancestral holding (naḥalah, "inheritance"). His tenants have "profaned" it. They have filled it with "carcasses": idols are dead things, and like a corpse they pollute whatever they touch. The word "first" puts this judgment in sequence. The new exodus of vv. 14–15 is real, but it comes after the debt is paid, not instead of paying it.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v14, v15

    The LORD liveth (KJV)

    chai YHWH

    What we hear
    A statement of belief that God is alive, like a creed or a worship slogan.
    What they heard
    The opening of a solemn oath: 'As surely as YHWH lives…', 'By the life of YHWH…'. It is how one swore to tell the truth or keep a promise.
  • in v14

    children of Israel

    benei Yisra'el

    What we hear
    Young children, or a sentimental picture of Israel as little ones.
    What they heard
    The descendants of Israel (Jacob), meaning the whole people of every age, understood as one kinship group.
  • in v15

    land of the north / north country

    erets tsafon

    What we hear
    Whatever country lies due north of Israel on a modern map.
    What they heard
    In Jeremiah, the homeland of the invader: Babylon and Mesopotamia, whose armies reached Judah from the north along the Fertile Crescent.
  • in v16

    fishers / fishermen

    dayyāgîm

    What we hear
    Gospel workers or missionaries gathering people in, as in Jesus' 'fishers of men'.
    What they heard
    Agents of capture and judgment, enemy forces God summons to drag his guilty people out, in line with the prophets' image of captives taken with hooks and nets (Amos 4:2; Hab 1:14–17).
  • in v17

    iniquity

    ʿavon

    What we hear
    An old-fashioned religious word for wickedness or a bad act, and nothing more.
    What they heard
    The crooked act together with the guilt it creates. That guilt is like a debt still owed, which will bring its consequences. Here it is the very thing God "repays" in the next verse.
  • in v17

    My eyes are on all their ways

    ʿeinai ʿal kol-darkheihem

    What we hear
    Often quoted alone as a warm assurance that God watches over and cares about everything in our lives.
    What they heard
    A judge's scrutiny before sentencing. In context (vv. 16–18) it explains why fugitives cannot escape the hunters and why their guilt will be repaid. The same idiom is used for protective care elsewhere (Ps 33:18), but not here (compare Amos 9:4).
  • in v18

    double

    mishneh

    What we hear
    Exactly twice what was deserved, as if God over-punishes.
    What they heard
    'Double / duplicate / second.' In context it is restitution language: full repayment on the scale the law required of someone who misappropriated another's property, possibly meaning 'a full equivalent.'
  • in v18

    inheritance

    naḥalah

    What we hear
    Property received after someone's death.
    What they heard
    An inalienable ancestral estate tied to a family's identity. Here it is YHWH's own holding, which no one can take from him, and Israel lives on it as his tenants.
  • in v18

    abominations

    toʿevah

    What we hear
    Things that are physically or emotionally disgusting.
    What they heard
    Things YHWH has declared completely off-limits, a boundary violation. Here that means idolatrous worship, which was often attractive and popular rather than repulsive.
Every word
  1. לָכֵ֛ן

    lakhen · H3651C

    therefore · v14, v16

    Normally the hinge in a prophetic speech that turns from the charge to the sentence ('therefore I will…'). Here, right after a sentence of exile (v. 13), it introduces a promise instead, which is why some translations soften it to 'yet' or 'however'.

  2. הִנֵּֽה־

    hinneh · H2009

    behold, look · v14

    A spoken pointer, 'look!', that grabs the hearer's attention and fixes it on what comes next as something certain and close.

  3. יָמִ֥ים

    yamim · H3117G

    days · v14

    'Days' as a stretch of time, an era. Not a set number of 24-hour days, but a coming period when things will be different.

  4. בָּאִ֖ים

    ba'im · H0935G

    coming · v14

    A participle meaning 'are coming', 'on their way'. The future is pictured as already moving toward the hearers. 'Days are coming' is Jeremiah's signature formula for a decisive turn in history (compare 31:31).

  5. נְאֻם־

    ne'um · H5002

    utterance, declaration · v14, v16

    A technical prophetic marker: 'the declaration of YHWH'. It stamps the words as God's own speech, not the prophet's opinion.

  6. יְהוָ֑ה

    YHWH · H3068G

    the LORD (Yahweh) · v14, v15, v16

    The personal name of Israel's God, which English Bibles conventionally render 'the LORD'. He is the one speaking.

  7. וְלֹֽא־

    velo · H3808

    and not · v14, v17

    'And not' negates the verb that follows: in those days people will not say this.

  8. יֵאָמֵ֥ר

    ye'amer · H0559

    it will be said · v14

    A passive form, 'it will be said', with no named subject. It refers to the everyday speech of the whole people, here specifically the words they use when swearing an oath.

  9. עוֹד֙

    od · H5750

    again, any longer · v14

    With the negative it means 'no longer', 'not any more'. A long-standing habit of speech is going to be replaced.

  10. חַי־

    chai · H2416A

    living, life · v14, v15

    The opening word of Israel's most solemn oath: 'as YHWH lives', or 'by the life of YHWH'. The speaker stakes their word on the reality of the living God.

  11. אֲשֶׁ֧ר

    asher · H0834A

    who, which · v14, v15

    'Who'. It introduces the phrase that says which God is meant: the one known by what he did.

  12. הֶעֱלָ֛ה

    he'elah · H5927H

    brought up · v14, v15

    'Brought up', the causative form of 'go up'. It is the standard verb of Israel's exodus confession: God brought them up from low Egypt to the land of promise.

  13. אֶת־

    et · H0853

    [direct object marker] · v14, v15, v18

    An untranslatable grammatical marker showing that 'the sons of Israel' is the object of 'brought up'.

  14. בְּנֵ֥י

    benei · H1121G

    sons, children, descendants · v14, v15

    'Sons of' in the sense of descendants. With 'Israel' it names the whole people as one extended family descended from Jacob.

  15. יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל

    Yisra'el · H3478

    Israel · v14, v15

    Jacob's covenant name, used here for the whole people descended from him and not only the northern kingdom.

  16. מֵאֶ֥רֶץ

    me'erets · H0776G

    from the land of · v14, v15, v18

    'From the land of'. It marks Egypt as the place of slavery they were taken out of.

  17. מִצְרָֽיִם׃

    Mitsrayim · H4714G

    Egypt · v14

    Egypt, the house of slavery. The exodus from Egypt was the event that founded Israel's identity and its creed.

  18. כִּי

    ki · H3588

    for, that, but · v15, v17

    This is the first half of the pair ki im. It answers the 'no longer will they say…' of verse 14: 'but instead…'.

  19. אִם־

    im · H0518

    if; with ki: but, except · v15

    Together with ki after a negative it means 'but rather'. The old oath is not added to. It is replaced.

  20. צָפוֹן

    tsafon · H6828

    north · v15

    In Jeremiah, 'the north' is where the invader comes from. That means Babylon and Mesopotamia, whose armies reached Judah from the north.

  21. וּמִכֹּל

    umikkol · H3605

    and from all · v15, v16, v17

    This widens the picture past one empire to every place where Israelites had ended up.

  22. הִדִּיחָם

    hiddicham · H5080

    drive away, banish, scatter · v15

    'He had scattered them'. The word suggests a flock driven off and strayed. The exile is presented as God's own act, which is why God can undo it.

  23. שָׁמָּה

    shammah · H8033

    there, thither · v15

    'There' with a sense of direction. It completes 'the lands to which'.

  24. וַהֲשִׁבֹתִים

    wahashivotim · H7725

    and I will bring them back · v15

    God now speaks in the first person: 'and I will make them return.' The verb form looks ahead. It is a promise about the future, not a report of the past.

  25. עַל־

    al · H5921

    upon, onto · v15, v16, v17, v18

    'Onto' their soil. They are set back down on the ground itself.

  26. אַדְמָתָם

    admatam · H0127

    their ground, soil · v15

    Adamah is the farmed earth of home, the family soil. It is a warmer and more physical word than eretz ('land, country'), which is used for the lands of exile.

  27. נָתַתִּי

    natatti · H5414

    I gave · v15

    'I gave' is a completed gift. The land was God's grant, and the grant was never cancelled.

  28. לַאֲבוֹתָם

    la'avotam · H0001

    to their fathers · v15

    'To their fathers' means the ancestors, back to the patriarchs (Abraham, Isaac and Jacob), to whom the land was first promised. The return makes good on the oldest promise.

  29. הִנְנִ֨י

    hinnənî · H2005

    look, here I am · v16

    'Look — I…' A pointing word joined to 'I'. Followed by a participle, it announces something God is about to do, and do soon.

  30. שֹׁלֵ֜חַ

    shōlēaḥ · H7971

    send · v16

    'Sending' (participle): the action is already in motion. With the preposition le- it means 'send for, summon', as a king calls up agents.

  31. לְדַיָּגִ֥ים

    lədayyāgîm · H1771

    fisherman · v16

    'For fishermen.' Men who catch with nets and hooks. Here they stand for the invading armies God calls up to haul his people out of their hiding places.

  32. רַבִּ֛ים

    rabbîm · H7227

    many · v16

    'Many': there are many catchers, so no one gets away.

  33. וְדִיג֑וּם

    wədîgûm · H1770

    to fish · v16

    'And they will fish them.' A verb formed from the noun 'fish' that appears only here in the Bible. People are the catch.

  34. וְאַֽחֲרֵי־

    wə'aḥărê · H310

    after · v16

    'And after': the start of the second stage of the pursuit.

  35. צַיָּדִ֔ים

    ṣayyādîm · H6719

    hunter · v16

    'Hunters': men who track and run down game on land, in the hills and rough country.

  36. וְצָד֞וּם

    wəṣādûm · H6679

    to hunt · v16

    'And they will hunt them': stalk, trap and take as prey. The word is used elsewhere for hunting a person's life (1 Sam 24:11; Lam 3:52).

  37. הַר֙

    har · H2022

    mountain · v16

    'Mountain': the high country of Judah, a traditional refuge in invasion. In Jeremiah it is also where idols were worshipped (2:20; 3:23; 13:27).

  38. גִּבְעָ֔ה

    gibʿāh · H1389

    hill · v16

    'Hill.' 'Every high hill' is a stock phrase in Jeremiah for where the people worshipped other gods (2:20; 3:6), so the places of their sin become the places where they are caught.

  39. וּמִנְּקִיקֵ֖י

    ûminnəqîqê · H5357

    cleft, crevice · v16

    'And from the clefts of': narrow cracks in rock. A rare word, used only here, in Jer 13:4 and in Isa 7:19. It is the last and smallest hiding place.

  40. הַסְּלָעִֽים׃

    hassəlāʿîm · H5553

    crag, cliff rock · v16

    'The crags': cliffs and rock faces with caves, where fugitives hid. Even there the hunters reach them.

  41. עֵינַי֙

    ʿeinai · H5869

    my eyes · v17

    God's eyes, in the dual form used for a pair of eyes. In this context it means a close, examining look: the gaze of a judge who has the evidence in front of him.

  42. דַּרְכֵיהֶ֔ם

    darkheihem · H1870

    their ways, conduct · v17

    Literally "roads". Here it means their whole course of conduct, the habitual paths of their lives, especially the paths to other gods (v. 11–12).

  43. נִסְתְּר֖וּ

    nisteru · H5641

    they have been hidden / hid themselves · v17

    A passive or reflexive form of "hide" with a plural subject. The subject can be "their ways" or the people themselves, who in verse 16 hide in the clefts of the rocks. Neither the people nor their deeds have got out of sight.

  44. מִלְּפָנָ֑י

    millefanai · H6440

    from before me, from my face · v17

    "From before my face", meaning from my presence. The image is of something standing directly in front of God and in full view.

  45. נִצְפַּ֥ן

    nitspan · H6845

    has been stored away, concealed · v17

    From a verb used for storing treasure away or hiding something in a safe place. Their guilt has not been tucked away anywhere out of God's sight.

  46. עֲוֹנָ֖ם

    ʿavonam · H5771

    their iniquity, guilt · v17, v18

    Their wrongdoing together with the guilt it built up, which must still be paid for. Verse 18 then says God will "repay" this ʿavon.

  47. מִנֶּ֥גֶד

    minneged · H5048

    from in front of, opposite · v17

    "From right in front of". It stresses that the guilt is directly in God's line of sight.

  48. וְשִׁלַּמְתִּ֣י

    ve-shillamti · H7999A

    and I will repay · v18

    An intensive form of the root behind shalom. It means to make whole, settle an account, or pay restitution. Here God settles a debt that Judah has run up. The word comes from the vocabulary of the law court and of compensation.

  49. רִֽאשׁוֹנָ֗ה

    riʾshonah · H7223G

    first · v18

    Used as an adverb: 'first, before anything else.' The Masoretic accent marks it off from the next word. It sets this repayment before the return promised in vv. 14–15: judgment first, restoration after.

  50. מִשְׁנֵ֤ה

    mishneh · H4932H

    double, second, copy · v18

    'The double of' or 'the duplicate of' their guilt. The word can mean twice the amount or a matching copy. Which one is meant here is debated (see studies).

  51. וְחַטָּאתָ֔ם

    ve-ḥattaʾtam · H2403B

    and their sin · v18

    Their failures and offenses. Paired with ʿavon, it covers their wrongdoing as a whole, as a debt that is now due.

  52. חַלְּלָ֣ם

    ḥallelam · H2490H

    to profane · v18

    'Their profaning': making something holy into common or polluted ground. This is the vocabulary of priests and holiness, applied here to the land itself.

  53. בְּנִבְלַ֤ת

    be-nivlat · H5038

    carcass, corpse · v18

    'With the carcass of.' The word is singular but stands for a group. It is the word for a dead body or carrion, and carrion makes people ritually unclean. Calling idols 'carcasses' treats them as lifeless and as a source of pollution.

  54. שִׁקּֽוּצֵיהֶם֙

    shiqqutseihem · H8251

    detestable thing · v18

    'Their detestable things.' This is a standard insult for idols and idol-gods (e.g. Milcom, 'the detestable thing of the Ammonites', 1 Kgs 11:5).

  55. וְתוֹעֲב֣וֹתֵיהֶ֔ם

    ve-toʿavoteihem · H8441

    abomination · v18

    'And their abominations': practices and objects YHWH rules out completely. Here that means idol-worship and the rites that went with it.

  56. מָלְא֖וּ

    malʾu · H4390

    they have filled · v18

    A completed action: the filling is already done. The picture is an estate packed wall to wall with defiling objects.

  57. נַחֲלָתִֽי׃

    naḥalati · H5159

    inheritance, allotted estate · v18

    'My inheritance': YHWH's own family estate, which by right cannot be taken from him. It parallels 'my land' and sharpens it. The same root comes back in v. 19 ('our fathers inherited lies').

The world behind it

When and where. Jeremiah preached in Jerusalem in the decades before its destruction by Babylon in 587/586 BC. Chapter 16 is dominated by grim sign-acts. Jeremiah is forbidden to marry and have children (vv. 1–4), to attend funerals (vv. 5–7), or to go to feasts (vv. 8–9), because normal life is about to collapse. Verse 13 announces exile to an unknown land.

Oaths in Israel. An oath was a serious legal and religious act, used in courts, contracts and personal promises. Swearing "as YHWH lives" put one's words under the guarantee of the living God, and the law required oaths to be sworn in YHWH's name and not by other gods (Deut 6:13; 10:20; compare Jer 4:2; 5:2; 12:16). The phrase that described God in an oath showed what people saw as his defining identity. To change that phrase would be to change how the nation thought of its God.

"The land of the north." In the following verse the exiles return from "the land of the north." Throughout Jeremiah the invader comes "from the north" (1:14; 4:6; 6:1, 22). Babylon lay to the east, but armies and travellers reached Judah along the Fertile Crescent, coming down from the north. The hearers would have understood Babylon and the wider scattering.

The exodus as a model. Hosea and Isaiah 40–55 also picture the future restoration as a new exodus (Hos 2:14–15; Isa 43:16–19, "Do not remember the former things… I am doing a new thing"). Jeremiah 16:14–15 is one of the clearest statements of that hope.

From the study of Jeremiah 16:14.

Where scholars differ

in v14

Do verses 14–15 belong here originally, or were they inserted from 23:7–8?

  • They are a later insertion or duplication. A hopeful note was added to soften the harsh oracle.

    'Therefore' follows awkwardly after 'I will show you no favor' (v. 13). Verse 16 goes straight back to judgment ('fishers… hunters' who track down the guilty), which reads naturally as the continuation of v. 13. The same text appears at 23:7–8, where it fits better. Commentators such as Holladay and McKane treat 16:14–15 as secondary here.

  • They stand where they do on purpose, as an editorial or prophetic interjection of hope inside judgment.

    Jeremiah's book often puts judgment and restoration side by side (e.g. 1:10, 'to uproot… to build and to plant'). The editors of the book could deliberately place a promise of return right after the announcement of exile. The Septuagint also has the passage in this spot, so its placement here is old.

in v14

What return does the verse have in view?

  • The return from Babylonian exile beginning in 538 BC.

    'The land of the north' is Jeremiah's standard term for the Babylonian threat. The book elsewhere sets a limited period of exile (25:11–12; 29:10), and Ezra 1:1 explicitly connects the return to Jeremiah's word.

  • A larger, final regathering that goes beyond the partial return under Persia.

    The scope ('from all the lands where he had driven them') and the claim that it will eclipse the exodus seem larger than the modest return of the 6th–5th centuries BC. Later Jewish and Christian readers therefore read it as still awaiting fuller fulfilment, and some modern readers link it to the 20th-century return of Jews to the land. Whether and how such later events fulfil the text is a question of later interpretation. The text itself does not specify it.

in v15

Were verses 14–15 originally part of this oracle, or added later?

  • Later insertion, copied from 23:7–8.

    The jump from judgment (v.13) to hope (vv.14–15) and back to judgment (vv.16–18) is abrupt. 'Therefore' in verse 14 follows awkwardly from verse 13. The saying appears again almost word for word in 23:7–8, and the Septuagint puts that copy somewhere else. Many critical commentators (e.g. McKane, Carroll, Holladay) treat it as a later addition from the exile.

  • Deliberate placement within the book as we have it.

    Verse 13 ends with being hurled into 'a land you have not known'. Verses 14–15 answer that directly with a return to 'the soil I gave your fathers', which sets a limit on the exile. Commentators such as Thompson and Lundbom read the placement as intentional, whoever made it.

in v15

Do the 'fishermen' and 'hunters' of verse 16 continue the promise of return, or resume the judgment?

  • Judgment: they hunt the people down for punishment.

    Verses 17–18 ('my eyes are on all their ways… I will repay double') are plainly about judgment. Elsewhere in the prophets, fishing and hunting images describe capture by enemies (Amos 4:2; Hab 1:14–17). This is the majority view.

  • Restoration: they gather the scattered to bring them home.

    Verse 16 follows directly on verse 15's promise of gathering. Some older interpreters, and readers who link the passage to Jesus' 'fishers of men' (Mark 1:17), read it as an ingathering. Context makes this the minority view.

in v16

Is v. 16 about judgment, or about God gathering Israel back (continuing vv. 14–15)?

  • Judgment. The fishers and hunters are invaders who take Judah captive.

    Verses 17–18 explain the pursuit by guilt ('their iniquity is not hidden… I will repay double'). Fishing and hooks are standard prophetic images of conquest (Amos 4:2; Hab 1:14–17; Ezek 29:4). The parallel construction in Jer 25:9 summons Babylon. Vv. 14–15 duplicate 23:7–8 and interrupt the judgment thread of vv. 10–13. This is the majority view among critical commentators (e.g. Bright, Holladay, McKane, Lundbom).

  • Gathering. The fishers and hunters bring scattered Israel back in the restoration of vv. 14–15.

    In the final form of the text v. 16 directly follows the promise of return, and 'send for' could describe God gathering his people. Some older Jewish and Christian readers, and many popular end-times readings, take it this way. The weakness of this view is that v. 18 speaks of repaying their sin, and catchers who hunt people from hiding are not a natural picture of a welcome homecoming.

in v16

Do the fishers and hunters stand for two distinct historical stages?

  • Two waves, perhaps the deportations of 597 and 586 BC, or a first conquest followed by mopping up.

    'After that' marks a clear sequence, and Judah did suffer more than one Babylonian campaign.

  • A single picture of thoroughness: water and land, mass capture and individual tracking.

    Hebrew poetry often pairs opposites to mean 'everything'. The verse's own focus is on leaving no hiding place (mountain, hill, cleft), not on dates.

in v16

Does Jesus' 'fishers of men' allude to Jeremiah 16:16?

  • Yes, it is a deliberate echo, with a tone of end-time gathering or judgment.

    Jer 16:16 is the most prominent Old Testament text about 'fishing' people, and Jesus' preaching announced the arrival of God's kingdom, which carried judgment.

  • No, or not necessarily. It is a natural wordplay on the disciples' trade.

    Simon and Andrew were literally fishermen. The Gospels do not cite Jeremiah. In Mark the 'fishing' is positive recruitment into the kingdom.

in v17

Who or what is "not hidden": the people or their ways?

  • The people themselves. They hide in the rock clefts (v. 16) but are not hidden from God.

    This links directly to the fugitives of v. 16. The Niphal of satar can be reflexive ("hide oneself"), as in Jer 23:24. In the parallel second line the guilt is the subject, so the progression runs from the persons to their guilt.

  • "Their ways". The ways just mentioned are not hidden.

    This is the nearest plural noun. The Vulgate reads it this way (absconditae agreeing with viae). It also makes a neat chain: eyes on their ways, ways not hidden, guilt not concealed.

in v17

Are the fishermen and hunters of v. 16, which v. 17 explains, agents of judgment or of regathering?

  • Judgment. They are enemies who hunt the people down for punishment.

    The ki ("for") of v. 17 explains the hunting by God's sight of their guilt, and v. 18 speaks of repayment. Hunting and fishing are images of capture and violence elsewhere (Amos 4:2; Hab 1:14–17; Lam 4:18–19). This is the majority view.

  • Gathering for return. Read in light of vv. 14–15, they bring the scattered people back.

    Verse 16 follows directly after the new-exodus promise. Some interpreters have read the image positively, influenced partly by the "fishers of men" language of Mark 1:17. But vv. 17–18 make a purely positive reading hard, and many scholars see vv. 14–15 as an insertion (they recur at 23:7–8), so v. 16 originally continued straight on from v. 13.

in v18

Does mishneh mean 'twice as much' or 'a full equivalent'?

  • Literally double: twice the measure of the offense.

    This is the ordinary sense in Gen 43:12, 15; Exod 16:22; Job 42:10. The double-restitution laws of Exod 22 use the same verb *shillem*. Jer 17:18 has 'double destruction.' Most lexicons (BDB, HALOT) and most translations take it this way.

  • A matching equivalent or duplicate: punishment that corresponds fully to the sin.

    Deut 17:18 uses *mishneh* for a 'copy' of the law, and Deut 15:18 can be read as 'the equivalent of' a hired worker's wage. M. G. Kline ('Double Trouble,' JETS 1989) argued that 'double' in such judgment texts means a full counterpart. Others note that strict 'double' would sit uneasily with ideas of proportional justice.

in v18

What are the 'carcasses of their detestable things'?

  • The idols themselves, mocked as corpses.

    Lev 26:30 speaks of 'the carcasses of your idols.' Idol polemic elsewhere stresses that idols are lifeless (Jer 10:5, 14; Ps 115). Verse 19 calls them 'lies' and 'worthless.'

  • Literal dead bodies: animal sacrifices to idols, or victims of child sacrifice.

    Jeremiah elsewhere links Topheth with child sacrifice and with corpses filling the valley (7:31–33; 19:4–7, 11). Ezek 43:7–9 speaks of corpses defiling the holy place. 'Carcass' is the normal word for a real dead body.

in v18

What does 'first' (riʾshonah) refer to?

  • Time: judgment comes first, before the return of vv. 14–15.

    This is the natural adverbial sense, and the accent separates the word from *mishneh*. ESV and other versions add 'But' to bring out the contrast.

  • It is a later addition, or vv. 14–15 are themselves inserted (they are repeated at 23:7–8), so 'first' is an editor's link.

    The word is absent from the Septuagint. Vv. 14–15 interrupt the judgment flow of vv. 13 and 16–18 (discussed in Holladay, McKane).

Sources
  • BDB s.v. כֵּן (לָכֵן), חַי, עָלָה
  • HALOT s.v. לָכֵן, חַי, עלה
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC)
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • Lachish Ostracon 3 (oath formula חי יהוה)
  • Septuagint Jeremiah 16:14 and 23:7–8 (placement after 23:40)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 16:14
  • BDB s.v. חַי, נָדַח, צָפוֹן, אֲדָמָה
  • HALOT s.v. נדח, צָפוֹן, שׁוב (Hiphil)
  • J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT)
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah I–XXV (ICC)
  • R. P. Carroll, Jeremiah (OTL)
  • Rahlfs, Septuaginta (LXX Jeremiah)
  • Lachish Ostraca (oath formula 'as YHWH lives')
  • STEP Bible / TAHOT morphological data (supplied)
  • BDB s.v. דַּיָּג, דִּיג, צַיָּד, צוּד, נָקִיק
  • HALOT s.v. דַּוָּג/דַּיָּג, נָקִיק
  • J. Bright, Jeremiah (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 16:16
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Jer 16:16
  • Vulgate Jer 16:16
  • BDB s.v. עָוֺן, צָפַן, סָתַר, דֶּרֶךְ
  • HALOT s.v. עָוֺן, צָפַן, סָתַר
  • STEP Bible / Tyndale House tagged Hebrew text (supplied word data)
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs), Jeremiah 16:17
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 16:17
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 16
  • BDB s.v. מִשְׁנֶה, שָׁלֵם, נְבֵלָה, נַחֲלָה
  • HALOT s.v. מִשְׁנֶה; תּוֹעֵבָה; חלל
  • M. G. Kline, 'Double Trouble,' Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 32 (1989)
  • E. Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible (on the shorter Greek Jeremiah)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).