Luke Chapter 23 Read as one passage
Luke 23:18–23
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
18But they all cried out in unison: “Away with this man! Release Barabbas to us!” 19(Barabbas had been imprisoned for an insurrection in the city, and for murder.) 20Wanting to release Jesus, Pilate addressed them again, 21but they kept shouting, “Crucify Him! Crucify Him!” 22A third time he said to them, “What evil has this man done? I have found in Him no offense worthy of death. So after I punish Him, I will release Him.” 23But they were insistent, demanding with loud voices for Jesus to be crucified. And their clamor prevailed.
What the first hearers heard
Luke's readers met this scene inside a carefully built account (Luke 1:1–4). The scene supports several points Luke wanted them to grasp:
- Jesus was innocent, and Rome said so. Pilate declares him innocent three times (23:4, 14, 22), and Herod agrees. For readers who lived under Roman rule and might be suspected of following an executed rebel, this mattered. Jesus did not die because Rome found him guilty of sedition. He died because the crowd demanded it.
- The guilty went free and the innocent was condemned. The crowd demands freedom for a real rebel and murderer. Peter later preaches this contrast in Jerusalem: "you denied the Holy and Righteous One and asked for a murderer to be granted to you" (Acts 3:14). In the same sermon he adds, "you acted in ignorance, as did your rulers" (Acts 3:17).
- Jesus is "taken away" like the Servant of Isaiah. The cry αἶρε, "take away", fits Luke's wider use of Isaiah 53 ("his life is taken away from the earth", Acts 8:33; and "he was counted with the lawless", Luke 22:37).
- Paul's story mirrors Jesus'. Readers of Luke's second volume would hear the same shout again, "Away with him!", from a Jerusalem crowd against Paul (Acts 21:36; 22:22). The disciple suffers what his master suffered.
Luke also limits who is responsible. The shout comes from the gathering before Pilate, and that gathering was led by the chief priests and rulers. Elsewhere in the same chapter, ordinary people grieve for Jesus (23:27, 48).
From the study of Luke 23:18.
Verse by verse
-
18But they all cried out in unison: “Away with this man! Release Barabbas to us!”
Full study →Then the whole mass of them, everyone gathered before Pilate, roared out with one voice: “Get rid of this fellow! Away with him! Set Barabbas free, and give him to us!”
A few things are lost in most English versions:
- The shout is a roar, not a lament. The verb means a sudden, loud yell. Luke uses it elsewhere for the shrieks of possessed men. The crowd is shouting the governor down, not pleading with him.
- It comes as one voice. Luke uses a rare word meaning "with the whole multitude". The demand comes from everyone at the hearing, so it cannot be blamed on a few loud voices.
- "Away with this one" means "kill him." The same cry is shouted at Paul in Acts 22:22: "Away with such a man from the earth, for he ought not to live!" They do not name Jesus. He is just "this one."
- They take Pilate's own word. Pilate has just said, "I will punish him and release him" (v.16). The crowd picks up his word "release" and demands it for someone else. The man they want is Barabbas, who was in prison for an uprising and murder (v.19). Jesus' accusers had charged him with stirring up rebellion (23:2, 5), and now they ask for the release of a man who actually led one. "To us" claims the prisoner as theirs, a favour they say they are owed.
-
19(Barabbas had been imprisoned for an insurrection in the city, and for murder.)
Not studied yet. Study this verse
-
20Wanting to release Jesus, Pilate addressed them again,
Full study →Once again Pilate raised his voice to the crowd. He wanted, and kept wanting, to set Jesus free.
The verse is short, but it sits in the middle of a carefully built scene. "Again" tells us this is Pilate's second attempt. He has already said publicly that he finds no basis for a charge (23:4, 14–15), and he will try a third time (23:22). The verb for speaking means calling out loud to the crowd, and it begins a contest of voices. Pilate calls out to them. They shout back over him: "Crucify, crucify him!" (v.21). Finally "their voices prevailed" (v.23).
"Wanting" gives the motive. The tense shows a desire that was still active, not a passing thought. "To release" is the legal word for freeing a prisoner, and Luke repeats it until the end of the scene, when it is used of Barabbas, the rebel and murderer, instead of Jesus. Pilate's want (thelō) is beaten by the crowd's will (thelēma, 23:25). The man with the power of life and death, who wants to free the innocent man, ends up giving way to the shouting crowd.
-
21but they kept shouting, “Crucify Him! Crucify Him!”
Full study →“But they shouted back at him, again and again: ‘Crucify! Crucify him!’”
Pilate has just spoken to the crowd a second time because he wants to let Jesus go (v. 20). Luke uses two verbs from the same root for the exchange. Pilate addresses them; they shout back. The tense pictures the shouting as going on and on, a crowd chanting rather than a single cry. Their words are a blunt order to the Roman governor, and the doubled “Crucify! Crucify!” is the beat of that chant. In some of the oldest manuscripts the command is in a form that can carry a pressing, insistent tone: get on with it, crucify him.
For the first time in Luke’s account, the crowd names the exact death they want. For people living under Rome, “crucify” was not a solemn religious word. It meant the slow, naked, public death that Rome reserved for slaves, bandits and rebels against its rule. A Judean audience would also have heard the curse on one “hanged on a tree” (Deuteronomy 21:23). The demand comes moments after the same voices asked for Barabbas, a jailed insurrectionist, to be freed. They want the rebel’s punishment for the man the governor keeps calling innocent, and freedom for the actual rebel. They do not even use Jesus’ name, only “him”.
-
22A third time he said to them, “What evil has this man done? I have found in Him no offense worthy of death. So after I punish Him, I will release Him.”
Full study →For the third time Pilate turned to them and pushed back: "Well then, what crime has this man actually committed?" As the presiding Roman judge he gave his formal finding: "I have examined the case, and I have found not a single ground in him for a capital sentence." Then he offered a compromise: "So I will have him beaten as a lesson, and then I will set him free."
What the Greek carries:
- "A third time" is Luke's deliberate count. Pilate declares Jesus innocent three times (23:4, 14, 22), so the record shows the Roman authority clearing him over and over.
- "What evil" means a punishable wrongdoing, a crime. It does not mean wickedness in a spiritual sense.
- "Worthy of death" is legal language: there are no grounds for the death penalty.
- "Chastise" or "punish" stands for a word whose root meaning is to train a child. Here it is a magistrate's warning beating with rods or whips. The bitter irony is that Pilate offers to beat a man he has just declared innocent, to calm the crowd.
- "I will release him" is stated as a firm intention. A few lines later the same verb describes Pilate releasing Barabbas instead.
-
23But they were insistent, demanding with loud voices for Jesus to be crucified. And their clamor prevailed.
Full study →But they would not let up. Pilate had just said, for the third time, "I find nothing in him that deserves death; I will flog him and let him go." They bore down on him like a weight, shouting at the top of their voices and pressing their demand again and again: that Jesus be crucified, executed by the Roman punishment for slaves and rebels. And their voices were winning. Bit by bit the noise overpowered the governor's own judgment, until in the next verse he gave them what they demanded.
The Greek paints a sustained, physical scene. The verbs describe ongoing action: they kept pressing, the voices were gaining the upper hand. The word for "pressing" literally means "lying on top of" something. The word for "prevailing" is a word for winning a contest of strength. Luke repeats "voices" at the start and the end of the verse, so that shouting, not evidence, decides the case. Earlier in the Gospel a crowd "pressed upon" Jesus to hear him (5:1), and his followers praised God "with a loud voice" as he entered Jerusalem (19:37). Now loud voices press upon a Roman judge to have him killed, and they succeed.
Where the English drifted
-
in v18
Away with this man
aire touton
- What we hear
- Take him out of here, remove him from our sight.
- What they heard
- Do away with him, put him to death. It was a set crowd cry calling for execution, as Acts 22:22 makes explicit: 'away from the earth… he ought not to live.'
-
in v18
cried out
anekragon
- What we hear
- Called out in distress, or even wept.
- What they heard
- Shouted, yelled, roared: a loud, aggressive outburst.
-
in v20
willing (KJV: "willing to release Jesus")
thelōn
- What we hear
- Prepared to release Jesus if pressed; open to the idea.
- What they heard
- Actively wanting or wishing to release him. It states Pilate's real desire and motive.
-
in v21
Crucify
stauroō
- What we hear
- A solemn, sacred word tied to the cross of Christian worship and art. In casual English it can also mean “criticise harshly”.
- What they heard
- A demand for the most degrading death Rome used: public, slow and naked, reserved for slaves, bandits and rebels. Respectable people avoided even naming it, and Judeans also linked it with the curse of Deuteronomy 21:23.
-
in v22
chastise (KJV, WEB)
paideuō
- What we hear
- To scold or rebuke someone severely with words.
- What they heard
- To discipline with physical punishment. Here it is a Roman warning beating with rods or whips.
-
in v22
no cause of death (KJV)
ouden aition thanatou
- What we hear
- Sounds like a medical or coroner's phrase, i.e. what physically causes someone to die.
- What they heard
- No legal grounds for a capital sentence. Nothing in the case justifies execution.
-
in v22
What evil
ti kakon
- What we hear
- Moral or spiritual wickedness, possibly something sinister or demonic.
- What they heard
- "What wrong" or "what crime": a specific punishable act, asked in a courtroom.
-
in v23
instant (KJV: "they were instant with loud voices")
epekeinto
- What we hear
- Immediate, happening at once.
- What they heard
- Pressing hard, insistent, bearing down without letting up. The English word once meant this too (Latin instare, 'to press upon').
-
in v23
requiring (KJV: "requiring that he might be crucified")
aitoumenoi
- What we hear
- Making something necessary, imposing a requirement.
- What they heard
- Asking for, demanding: a petition pressed before the governor.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v18
In Luke, the 'Hosanna' crowd isn't the 'Away with him' crowd
- What's often taught
- The same crowd that welcomed Jesus into Jerusalem on Palm Sunday turned on him within a week and shouted for his death before Pilate, which shows how fickle human devotion is.
- What the text supports
Luke does not say this, and his wording points away from it.
- Who praised Jesus at the entry? In Luke the people praising Jesus on the descent from the Mount of Olives are "the whole multitude of the disciples" (ἅπαν τὸ πλῆθος τῶν μαθητῶν, 19:37). That is his own followers, not the general public of the city.
- Who shouted before Pilate? Here the shout comes from the gathering Pilate called together: "the chief priests, the rulers and the people" (23:13). The leaders had brought it together early in the morning after the council met at daybreak (22:66; 23:1). Luke's adverb παμπληθεί ("with the whole multitude") refers to that assembly.
- What other crowds does Luke show? Before this, the people are protective of Jesus: the leaders could not act "for all the people hung on his words" (19:48), and they feared the people (22:2). Afterwards, "a great multitude of the people" follows Jesus to the cross mourning (23:27), and the crowds go home beating their breasts (23:48).
The popular reading is partly right. Luke does include "the people" in the hearing before Pilate (23:13), so the people of Jerusalem are not wholly absent, and it is historically possible that some individuals were in both crowds. But no Gospel says the same people who praised Jesus later called for his death. In Luke's account the two crowds are described differently.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'They all cried out' (BSB, WEB) and 'the whole crowd' (NIV) can sound as if 'all' means the whole city, including everyone from Palm Sunday. Readers also tend to merge the four Gospels' crowd scenes into a single story, rather than reading Luke's own distinction between 'the multitude of the disciples' (19:37) and the assembly before Pilate.
in v23
Luke doesn't say the Palm Sunday crowd turned on Jesus
- What's often taught
- The same crowd that welcomed Jesus into Jerusalem with praise on Palm Sunday turned, within a week, to shouting 'Crucify him!' This shows how fickle human devotion is.
- What the text supports
The teaching gets something right: Luke deliberately matches the two scenes. Both feature 'loud voices' (19:37; 23:23), and Luke does include 'the people' among those demanding crucifixion (23:13, 18). But Luke never says the two groups were the same people:
- In Luke the praise on the way into Jerusalem comes from 'the whole multitude of the disciples' (19:37), Jesus' followers.
- The people who demand crucifixion are those Pilate summoned to his court with 'the chief priests and the rulers' (23:13). The pressure is driven by the temple leadership (22:2; 23:10).
- Elsewhere Luke keeps the wider population sympathetic: the leaders feared 'the people' (22:2), a great crowd 'of the people' mourned Jesus on the way to the cross (23:27), and the crowds went home beating their breasts (23:48).
So the contrast between the two scenes is real and intended. The claim that one week turned the same people from praise to hatred is a harmonising inference that the text of Luke does not make. (Luke's entry account does not even contain the word 'Hosanna'.)
Every word
-
ἀνέκραγον
anekragon · G0349
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and, then · v18, v20, v21, v22, v23
Marks a shift. Pilate has just proposed to flog Jesus and release him (v.16). This shout is the crowd's answer, and it goes against what he proposed.
-
παμπληθεὶ
pamplēthei · G3826
with the whole multitude, all together · v18
This word appears nowhere else in the New Testament. It means 'with the whole mass of them', so the shout comes as one roar from the gathered crowd. It echoes 'the whole multitude' that brought Jesus to Pilate in 23:1.
-
λέγοντες·
legontes · G3004G
saying · v18, v21
Introduces the words they shouted. It is plural because the whole crowd shouts as one.
-
αἶρε
aire · G0142
to lift, take away, remove · v18
'Take away!' It is a command to one person, Pilate. In crowd cries like this it means 'get rid of him' and calls for death. Compare Acts 22:22: 'Away with such a man from the earth, for he ought not to live.'
-
τοῦτον,
touton · G3778
this one · v18, v22
'This one.' The crowd does not use Jesus' name. In context the pointing word sounds dismissive, much like 'this fellow'.
-
ἀπόλυσον
apoluson · G0630G
to release, set free, let go · v18, v20, v22
'Release!' Pilate had just used this verb about Jesus: 'I will release him' (v.16). The crowd takes his word and turns it toward Barabbas. The same verb comes back in vv.20, 22 and 25.
-
ἡμῖν
hēmin · G3165
to us · v18
'To us.' The crowd claims the prisoner as their own, as if the release were a favour owed to them.
-
τὸν
ton · G3588
the · v18, v20, v21, v22, v23
The Greek puts 'the' before personal names, as here. English leaves it out.
-
Βαραββᾶν·
Barabban · G0912
Barabbas · v18
An Aramaic name, most likely Bar-Abba, 'son of Abba (father)'. Luke has not introduced him before this point. Verse 19 then explains that he was in prison for an uprising in the city and for murder.
-
Πάλιν
Palin · G3825
-
Πιλᾶτος
Pilatos · G4091
Pilate · v20
Pontius Pilate, the Roman governor of Judea (about 26–36 AD). He alone had the legal power to order an execution.
-
προσεφώνησεν
prosephōnēsen · G4377
-
αὐτοῖς
autois · G0846
to them · v20, v21, v22, v23
The chief priests, the rulers and the people gathered in 23:13, who had just shouted for Barabbas.
-
θέλων
thelōn · G2309
wanting, wishing, desiring · v20
A present-tense participle, so it describes a desire that was ongoing as he spoke. It gives his motive: he actively wanted Jesus freed. The story later turns on this word when Jesus is handed over to the crowd's 'will' (thelēma) in 23:25.
-
Ἰησοῦν
Iēsoun · G2424
Jesus (Hebrew Yeshua/Yehoshua) · v20
The object of the release Pilate wants. It stands in direct contrast to Barabbas, the rebel and murderer the crowd has just asked for (23:18–19).
-
ἐπεφώνουν
epephōnoun · G2019
to shout out, call out in response · v21
A loud shout thrown back at a speaker, the kind of collective cry a crowd raises. The imperfect tense shows the action as ongoing or repeated: “they kept shouting”. It answers Pilate’s *prosephōnēsen* (“he addressed”) in verse 20, a deliberate echo of the same root.
-
σταύρου
staurou · G4717
crucify! (command) · v21, v23
A direct command to the governor: “Crucify!” The crowd now names, for the first time in Luke’s trial account, the exact Roman death they want: the penalty for slaves, bandits and rebels.
-
τρίτον
triton · G5154
third · v22
Used as an adverb: "a third time". Luke deliberately counts Pilate's attempts, so the innocence verdict lands three times over.
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
said · v22
"He said". A simple past tense that reports a single, definite statement.
-
πρὸς
pros · G4314
to, toward · v22
"To". He speaks directly to the accusers and crowd.
-
τί
ti · G5101
what? · v22
"What?" It opens a question that expects no answer: there is nothing to name.
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v22
In questions γάρ adds exasperation or surprise, as in "Why, what...?" (KJV, YLT, WEB). It works like "Well then, what...?" in reply to their demand.
-
κακὸν
kakon · G2556
bad, evil, wrong · v22
"Wrong" or "crime". Pilate is asking what punishable wrongdoing Jesus has committed. He is not talking about evil as a spiritual force.
-
ἐποίησεν
epoiēsen · G4160
did, made · v22
"Did" or "committed". The question is about a concrete deed, not about character or teaching.
-
οὐδὲν
ouden · G3762
nothing, no · v22
"Nothing at all". The word comes first for emphasis: not even one ground.
-
αἴτιον
aition · G0159
cause, ground, culpability · v22
A legal word: a ground for a charge, a basis for guilt. Together with "of death" it means "grounds for a capital sentence".
-
θανάτου
thanatou · G2288
death · v22
"Of death", meaning the death penalty. The phrase is a sentencing formula: nothing that would justify execution.
-
εὗρον
heuron · G2147
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in · v22
"In", meaning "in his case" or "in him".
-
παιδεύσας
paideusas · G3811
train, discipline, chastise · v22
"After having him disciplined". Here that means a physical beating ordered by a Roman magistrate as a warning. The word does not mean a verbal reprimand.
-
οὖν
oun · G3767
therefore, so · v22
"So, then". Pilate presents the beating and release as following from his finding, a compromise meant to satisfy the crowd without an execution.
-
ἐπέκειντο
epekeinto · G1945
lie upon; press upon; insist · v23
Literally 'were lying on' or 'bearing down on'. Here it means relentless pressure on Pilate. The past tense describes continuing action: they kept on pressing.
-
φωναῖς
phōnais · G5456
voice, sound · v23
'With voices', the means of the pressure. The plural suggests many people shouting at once.
-
μεγάλαις
megalais · G3173
-
αἰτούμενοι
aitoumenoi · G154
ask, request, demand · v23
An ongoing action, 'asking, demanding'. The verb's middle form (often used for requests made on one's own behalf or before an official) fits people pressing a claim before a governor. The noun from the same root, αἴτημα, 'their demand', comes in the next verse.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v23
Links the pressure to its result: 'and' (in effect 'and so').
-
κατίσχυον
katischuon · G2729
prevail, overpower, be stronger · v23
'Were overpowering' or 'began to win out'. Placed before its subject for emphasis. The past tense pictures the voices gradually wearing Pilate down, until his decisive ruling in 23:24.
The world behind it
The hearing. It is early morning in Jerusalem at Passover. Pilate has called together "the chief priests, the rulers and the people" (23:13). He has declared Jesus innocent twice already, and Herod Antipas has found nothing against him either. Pilate offers a compromise: a flogging, which in Roman practice could serve as a warning punishment, followed by release (v.16). The shout in v.18 is the answer to that offer.
Release to please a crowd. The other Gospels describe a custom of freeing one prisoner at the feast. In the earliest manuscripts of Luke that custom is never explained, because v.17 is a later addition. Outside the Gospels there is no direct evidence for a fixed Passover amnesty. There are some related parallels:
- Mishnah Pesahim 8:6 allows the Passover lamb to be slaughtered for "one whom they have promised to bring out of prison."
- A papyrus from Roman Egypt (P.Flor. 61, 85 AD) records a governor telling a defendant, "You deserved to be scourged… but I give you to the crowds."
Roman officials did sometimes grant releases to please a crowd. That is the background to the crowd's "release to us."
"Insurrection in the city." In first-century Judea, armed uprisings against Rome and its client rulers broke out again and again. Barabbas's crime (στάσις, an uprising or riot, together with murder) was exactly the kind of offence Rome punished by crucifixion. The charge against Jesus was also political: "perverting our nation… saying he himself is Christ, a king" (23:2). So the choice in front of the crowd was between a man accused of rebellion and a man who had actually taken part in one.
From the study of Luke 23:18.
Where scholars differ
in v18
Was there really a custom of releasing a prisoner at Passover?
-
The custom was real, or at least an occasional practice of granting releases to please a crowd.
All four Gospels include the Barabbas release. Mishnah Pesahim 8:6 mentions someone 'promised release from prison' at Passover. P.Flor. 61 shows a Roman prefect handing a prisoner over at a crowd's demand. Livy (5.13) records prisoners released at a Roman festival.
-
The 'custom' is a Gospel-tradition way of explaining a one-off event, or is historically doubtful.
No non-Christian source describes a regular Passover amnesty in Judea. The general wording in Mark 15:6 may build up a single release into a regular practice. Notably, Luke's earliest text never mentions a custom (v.17 being secondary).
in v18
What does the name 'Barabbas' mean, and is there wordplay?
-
Bar-Abba, 'son of Abba/father'. Many see irony: the crowd chooses one 'son of the father' over the true Son of the Father.
Abba is attested as a personal name in Jewish sources. In some manuscripts of Matthew 27:16–17 he is 'Jesus Barabbas', which sharpens the contrast.
-
Bar-Rabban, 'son of the teacher', or simply an ordinary family name carrying no symbolic meaning.
Jerome reports that the Gospel of the Hebrews explained the name as 'son of their teacher'. Luke himself makes nothing of the name and focuses on Barabbas's crimes (v.19). Any wordplay is therefore at most Matthew's, not Luke's.
in v18
Who exactly is the 'whole multitude' that shouts?
-
Luke deliberately includes the common people (λαός) here, marking a turning point after their earlier support of Jesus.
In 23:13 Pilate calls together 'the chief priests, the rulers and the people', and v.18 says they shouted 'all together'. Before this, the λαός had hung on Jesus' words (19:48; 21:38).
-
The crowd is the gathering the leaders brought together and stirred up, and Luke takes care not to make the whole people responsible.
In 23:1 'the whole multitude of them' refers back to the council (22:66). Right afterwards Luke shows 'a great multitude of the people' mourning (23:27) and crowds beating their breasts (23:48). In Acts 3:17 Peter says the people acted 'in ignorance, as did your rulers.'
in v20
Is Luke's reluctant Pilate who wants to release Jesus historical, or shaped by Luke's purposes?
-
Luke's portrait is largely shaped by his purpose of showing that Rome found Jesus (and later Christians) innocent, and it softens a governor known for brutality.
Philo and Josephus describe Pilate as harsh and contemptuous of Jewish crowds. Luke's pattern of three declarations matches a theme he repeats in Acts, where Roman officials declare Paul innocent.
-
The portrait is plausible history. Pilate may have had his own reasons not to execute Jesus, such as contempt for the priestly leaders, doubt about the charge, or reluctance to do what they wanted, and he gave way only under pressure.
All four Gospels independently show Pilate trying to release Jesus. Josephus records that Pilate backed down before mass protest over the standards affair, which shows he could be moved by crowd pressure. Some argue that a governor's position after 31 AD, following the fall of his possible patron Sejanus, was politically fragile (compare John 19:12), though that link is debated.
in v21
Who are the “they” who shout, and is this the same crowd that welcomed Jesus into Jerusalem?
-
The same Jerusalem public has turned against Jesus. This is the popular “Hosanna on Sunday, crucify on Friday” reading.
In Luke, “the people” (laos) had hung on Jesus’ words in the temple (19:48; 21:38), and now “the people” stand with the leaders before Pilate (23:13). There is a real reversal in Luke’s use of “the people”.
-
It is a different or narrower group: leaders and the people gathered at the governor’s headquarters, not the crowd of the entry.
Luke says the praise at the entry came from “the whole multitude of the disciples” (19:37), and Luke has no “Hosanna”. Mark 15:11 says the chief priests stirred up the trial crowd. Luke soon shows many of the people mourning Jesus (23:27, 35, 48). The text never says the same individuals did both.
in v21
Does Luke’s present-tense command (σταύρου) carry special force?
-
Yes. It sounds urgent and insistent, as if pressing Pilate to act now and stop delaying.
Present-tense commands are common in urgent appeals. Luke departs from the aorist found in Mark and John, which may be deliberate, and verse 23 stresses the crowd’s insistence.
-
There is little difference in meaning, and the doubling carries the emphasis.
In short shouted commands the choice of tense often makes little difference. Later manuscripts switched freely to the aorist without any apparent change of sense.
in v22
Is Pilate's proposed "discipline" the same as the scourging that came before crucifixion?
-
No. It is a lighter warning beating meant as an alternative to execution.
Roman practice distinguished warning beatings from execution floggings (Digest 48.19.7; Sherwin-White). Pilate offers it explicitly as a step before release, not before death. Luke never narrates a scourging at all and never uses μαστιγόω or φραγελλόω here.
-
The tradition blends the two. John places a scourging in the middle of the trial as Pilate's attempt to win sympathy, and Mark and Matthew place it at the sentence.
John 19:1–6 puts the scourging during the trial, followed by "Behold the man". Mark 15:15 and Matthew 27:26 put it after the sentence. Luke's offer may reflect the same tradition as John's scene, presented as something proposed rather than carried out.
in v22
How far does Luke's sympathetic portrait of Pilate reflect history?
-
Luke stresses Pilate's reluctance mainly to show Jesus' innocence before Roman readers. The historical Pilate was harsher.
Philo (Embassy to Gaius 299–305) describes Pilate as inflexible and cruel. Josephus records his provocations and massacres (Antiquities 18.55–62, 85–89). Luke 13:1 itself mentions Pilate mixing Galileans' blood with their sacrifices.
-
A reluctant but pragmatic governor is historically plausible.
Governors did weigh accusers' pressure against order and their own careers. Josephus shows Albinus beating and releasing a troublesome prophet instead of executing him (Jewish War 6.300–309). A harsh man could still resist a demand from the local elite and then give in when unrest threatened.
in v23
Does Luke clear Pilate, or condemn him as a weak judge?
-
Luke presents Pilate as a witness to Jesus' innocence, partly to show Roman readers that Christianity was not a rebel movement.
Pilate declares Jesus innocent three times (23:4, 14, 22), Herod agrees (23:15), and the pressure to crucify is laid on the accusers (23:23–25; Acts 3:13).
-
Luke presents Pilate as a judge who knowingly gave up justice, so he shares the guilt.
Pilate grants 'their demand' and hands Jesus 'over to their will' (23:24–25) despite finding no guilt. Acts 4:27 names Pilate among those gathered 'against your holy servant Jesus'. Ancient readers would have seen giving in to a crowd as failure in a judge.
in v23
Who exactly are 'they' whose voices prevailed?
-
Mainly the temple leadership, with a crowd they had gathered.
The chief priests and scribes drive the accusations throughout (22:2; 23:2, 10). Some manuscripts add 'and of the chief priests' here. Elsewhere in Luke 'the people' are often sympathetic to Jesus (19:48; 21:38; 23:27, 35, 48).
-
Luke deliberately includes the people of Jerusalem along with their leaders.
Pilate summons 'the chief priests, the rulers and the people' (23:13). 'They all cried out together' (23:18). Peter says to Jerusalem crowds, 'you asked for a murderer' (Acts 3:14).
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἀνακράζω
- BDAG s.v. παμπληθεί
- BDAG s.v. αἴρω
- BDAG s.v. ἀπολύω
- Thayer s.v. Βαραββᾶς
- Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Luke 23:17
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
- Joseph A. Fitzmyer, The Gospel According to Luke X–XXIV (Anchor Bible)
- Raymond E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, on the Barabbas episode and the Passover amnesty
- Papyrus Florentinus 61 (85 AD)
- Mishnah Pesahim 8:6
- Jerome, Commentary on Matthew 27:16
- Vulgate, Luke 23:18
- BDAG s.v. προσφωνέω, θέλω, ἀπολύω
- Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. προσφωνέω
- Nestle-Aland 28th ed., apparatus at Luke 23:17, 20
- Philo, Embassy to Gaius 299–305
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.55–62, 85–87; Jewish War 2.169–177
- Pilate Stone inscription, Caesarea Maritima
- Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 23
- BDAG s.v. ἐπιφωνέω
- BDAG s.v. σταυρόω, σταυρός
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., apparatus at Luke 23:21
- Martin Hengel, Crucifixion in the Ancient World and the Folly of the Message of the Cross (1977)
- John Granger Cook, Crucifixion in the Mediterranean World (2014)
- Cicero, In Verrem 2.5.165–170
- Josephus, Antiquities 17.295; Jewish War 5.449–451
- Darrell L. Bock, Luke 9:51–24:53 (BECNT)
- Vulgate, Luke 23:21
- BDAG s.v. παιδεύω (sense 2b: whip, scourge, Luke 23:16, 22)
- BDAG s.v. αἴτιος / αἴτιον
- BDAG s.v. κακός
- LXX 3 Kingdoms (1 Kings) 12:11, 14
- Josephus, Jewish War 6.300–309 (Jesus son of Ananias)
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.55–62, 85–89
- Digest 48.19.7 (Callistratus) on grades of beating
- A. N. Sherwin-White, Roman Society and Roman Law in the New Testament (1963)
- Raymond E. Brown, The Death of the Messiah, vol. 1
- BDAG s.v. ἐπίκειμαι, κατισχύω, αἰτέω
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἐπίκειμαι
- Liddell–Scott–Jones s.v. ἐπίκειμαι
- Nestle–Aland 28th ed. apparatus, Luke 23:23
- Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, on Luke 23
- Blass–Debrunner–Funk §316 (middle voice of αἰτέω)
- Josephus, Antiquities 18.55–62; Jewish War 2.169–177
- Cicero, Against Verres 2.5.165
- Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 23
- Vulgate, Luke 23:23
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).
1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.