Luke Chapter 24 Read as one passage

Luke 24:9–11

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

9And when they returned from the tomb, they reported all these things to the Eleven and to all the others. 10It was Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James, and the other women with them who told this to the apostles. 11But their words seemed like nonsense to them, and they did not believe the women.

What the first hearers heard

To Luke's first readers, among them "most excellent Theophilus" (1:3), who wanted to know the facts were reliable, this verse was part of a carefully built chain of eyewitnesses. Luke begins his Gospel by promising an orderly account handed down by "eyewitnesses and servants of the word" (1:2). Here the first link in that chain is a group of women whom Luke goes on to name (v. 10).

Readers would notice several things:

  • The women act on their own understanding. The angels told them only to remember. Having remembered, they go and tell. In Luke, telling others is what naturally follows once Jesus' words make sense.
  • Their report is complete and goes to everyone. It reaches "the Eleven and all the rest," the whole community, not just its leaders.
  • The irony is deliberate. In a world that gave less weight to women's testimony, Luke shows their report being dismissed (v. 11), even though it was true and matched what Jesus himself had predicted. The two on the road to Emmaus later admit that "some women of our group" told them, and that they still did not understand (24:22–24). Luke shows that the problem was the hearers' disbelief, not the witnesses' reliability.
  • The return to Jerusalem. This is the first of the chapter's returns to Jerusalem (24:9, 33, 52), the city from which, Luke will say, the message is to go out "to all nations" (24:47).

From the study of Luke 24:9.

Verse by verse

  1. 9And when they returned from the tomb, they reported all these things to the Eleven and to all the others.

    And once they had turned back from the tomb, they brought word of all these things to the Eleven and to all the rest.

    The Greek endings make clear it is the women who do this: the Galilean women who followed Jesus (8:1–3; 23:49, 55). They had come at dawn with spices, found the stone rolled away and no body, and heard two men in dazzling clothes say, "He is not here; he has been raised. Remember how he told you…" (24:5–7). V. 8 says they remembered. V. 9 says they left the tomb. The Greek word for tomb (mnēmeion) comes from the root for "remember", so the place that should have held a dead man's memory became the place where they remembered his promise to rise.

    The order is deliberate: first they turned back, then they reported. The verb for reporting is what a messenger or eyewitness does when bringing news. In Luke, unlike Mark and Matthew, no one tells them to go and tell. The angels only say "remember", and the report comes from the women once they understand. And they tell "all these things": the stone, the empty tomb, the angels' words, Jesus' own prophecy. Nothing is held back.

    They take the news to two groups. First come "the Eleven": the Twelve with Judas gone, a number that quietly recalls the betrayal. Then come "all the rest": the wider group of followers staying in Jerusalem for the festival, people like Cleopas. Luke has set this up carefully, because in v. 11 the full and faithful report is brushed aside as "nonsense." The first people to announce the empty tomb were these women, and the men they told did not believe them.

    Full study →
  2. 10It was Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James, and the other women with them who told this to the apostles.

    "Now these were the women: Mary, the one from Magdala; Joanna; Mary, the [mother] of James; and the rest of the women who were with them. They kept telling the apostles these things."

    Luke pauses the story to name his witnesses. In verse 9 he has said that the women came back from the tomb and reported "all these things": the stone rolled away, the body gone, two men in lightning-bright clothes saying "He is not here; he has risen", and their own sudden memory of Jesus' words. Only now does he say who they were, in the form of a roll call.

    Mary "the Magdalene" is named by her hometown, the lakeside fishing town of Magdala, because there were so many Marys. Readers know her from 8:2 as the woman freed from seven demons. Joanna is the wife of the manager of Herod Antipas's household (8:3), a woman of some standing who had paid for Jesus' travels out of her own purse. Mary "of James" is identified, as women often were, through a male relative. Mark tells us he was her son. "The rest" is a definite and larger group: the Galilean women who had followed Jesus, watched him die, seen where he was laid, and come back with spices (23:49, 55-56; 24:1).

    The verb at the end is not a single "told". It is "they kept telling" or "they were saying". It sets up the next verse, where the men "kept not believing them" and treated their words as nonsense. The people Jesus had personally named as his envoys are the ones who have to be told. The women do the telling, and they go on doing it.

    Full study →
  3. 11But their words seemed like nonsense to them, and they did not believe the women.

    The women (Mary Magdalene, Joanna, Mary the mother of James and the others with them) have just come back from the empty tomb with an astonishing report: two men in dazzling clothes had told them Jesus was alive, and had reminded them that he himself had foretold it. Luke now gives the men's reaction:

    "And in their eyes these words looked like so much rubbish, mere drivel, and they kept refusing to believe the women."

    The Greek word Luke chooses, lēros, is not the gentle 'idle tales' of older English. It is a dismissive, everyday word of contempt: babble, trash, talk not worth hearing. The verb 'disbelieve' is in a tense of ongoing action. This was not a moment's surprise but a continuing refusal. The final pronoun is feminine, so Greek leaves no doubt about who is being disbelieved: the women. Luke, writing about the founding leaders of the church, records without softening that the first witnesses of the empty tomb were dismissed by the apostles. The words they waved away were also, at bottom, Jesus' own words (v.8).

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    Mary Magdalene

    Magdalēnē

    What we hear
    Many people hear "Magdalene" as meaning the reformed prostitute or penitent sinner. The English words "maudlin" and "Magdalene laundry" carry that sense.
    What they heard
    "The woman from Magdala", a place-label for a Galilean fishing town. Luke's only other detail is that seven demons had gone out of her (8:2), which describes healing from possession or illness, not sexual sin.
  • in v11

    idle tales (KJV; ESV 'an idle tale')

    lēros

    What we hear
    Harmless, fanciful little stories, like a fairy tale or a bit of gossip told to pass the time. It sounds faintly charming.
    What they heard
    Rubbish, drivel, nonsense: a scornful dismissal of talk as worthless and even absurd.
Every word
  1. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v9, v10, v11

    Joins this to v. 8 ("they remembered His words"). Remembering leads straight into going back and telling. Luke strings the scene together with simple "and"s, the way a story is told aloud.

  2. ὑποστρέψασαι

    hypostrepsasai · G5290

    to turn back, return · v9

    The ending is feminine plural, so the Greek itself shows the subject is the women. The past-tense participle puts the return first and the report after it: "having come back, they reported." This is one of Luke's favourite words for going back after meeting God at work.

  3. ἀπὸ

    apo · G0575

    from, away from · v9

    Marks where they set out from: the tomb, the place where they had just heard the angels.

  4. τοῦ

    tou · G3588

    the · v9, v10, v11

    "The" tomb: the one already described (23:53–55; 24:1–2), where Joseph of Arimathea laid Jesus.

  5. μνημείου

    mnēmeiou · G3419

    tomb, memorial · v9

    A tomb, here one cut into rock. The word comes from the root for "remember", and v. 8 has just said "they remembered" (emnēsthēsan). The place built to keep a dead man's memory has become the place where the women remember what he said about rising.

  6. ἀπήγγειλαν

    apēngeilan · G0518

    to report, announce, bring word · v9

    To carry news back to others, the way a messenger does. The past tense presents the report as a single completed act. Nobody in Luke's account tells them to do it, though Mark and Matthew include such a command. They report on their own.

  7. ταῦτα

    tauta · G3778

    these (things) · v9, v10, v11

    Points back to everything in vv. 1–8: the stone rolled away, no body, the two men in dazzling clothes, their message, and Jesus' own words that the women now remembered.

  8. πάντα

    panta · G3956

    all · v9

    "All these things": a full account, nothing held back. That makes the dismissal in v. 11 stand out even more.

  9. ἕνδεκα

    hendeka · G1733

    eleven · v9

    The Twelve without Judas. This is the first time Luke uses "the Eleven" as a name, and the shrunken number quietly reminds the reader of the betrayal.

  10. λοιποῖς

    loipois · G3062

    remaining, the rest · v9, v10

    The wider circle of Jesus' followers gathered in Jerusalem. From 24:13–33 this includes Cleopas and his companion, whom Luke later calls "the Eleven and those with them" (24:33). The ending is masculine, but in Greek that covers a mixed group.

  11. ἦσαν

    ēsan · G1510

    they were · v10

    Opens a roll call: "Now the women were…" or "Now these were…". The narrator stops the story to name who had just made the report in verse 9.

  12. δὲ

    de · G1161

    now, and, but · v10

    Marks an aside ("now"). This is the narrator adding a note, not a new event.

  13. Μαγδαληνὴ

    Magdalēnē · G3094

    Magdalene, woman of Magdala · v10

    A label from her hometown: the Mary from Magdala, a fishing town on the western shore of the Sea of Galilee. It is not a surname and it says nothing about her moral past.

  14. Μαρία

    Maria · G3137I

    Mary (Miriam) · v10

    The Greek form of Hebrew Miryam, the most common Jewish woman's name of the time. That is why she needs the label "the Magdalene".

  15. Ἰωάννα

    Iōanna · G2489

    Joanna · v10

    The Greek form of Hebrew Yohanah, "the LORD has been gracious", the female form of John. Luke alone names her, and his readers already know her from 8:3 as the wife of Chuza, the manager of Herod Antipas's household.

  16. Ἰακώβου

    Iakōbou · G2385I

    of James (Jacob) · v10

    "Of James". The name is the patriarch's name, Ya'aqov. Naming a woman through a male relative was ordinary. This James is usually taken to be "James the younger" (Mark 15:40), not one of the sons of Zebedee.

  17. σὺν

    syn · G4862

    with, together with · v10

    "Together with them": the rest were part of the same company, not a separate group.

  18. αὐταῖς

    autais · G0846

    them (feminine) · v10, v11

    Feminine plural. It refers back to the named women.

  19. αἳ

    hai · G3739

    who (feminine plural) · v10

    Found only in some manuscripts and in the Textus Receptus. It ties the list to the verb as "…who were telling". The KJV's "which told" comes from this reading.

  20. ἔλεγον

    elegon · G3004G

    they were saying/telling · v10

    An ongoing or repeated past action: "they kept telling", "they were saying". Verse 9 sums up the report in one word ("reported"). This verb shows the women going on telling it, and it matches v. 11, where the men "kept disbelieving".

  21. πρὸς

    pros · G4314

    to, toward · v10

    The women speak to the apostles directly, face to face.

  22. ἀποστόλους

    apostolous · G0652

    apostles, envoys, sent ones · v10

    In Luke this means the Twelve, now Eleven after Judas (v. 9 "the Eleven"). They are the men Jesus chose as his envoys. It is not a general word for church leaders.

  23. ἐφάνησαν

    ephanēsan · G5316

    to shine, appear, seem · v11

    Passive past tense: 'appeared, came across as, seemed'. The verse is about how the report looked to the hearers, not about what it really was.

  24. ἐνώπιον

    enōpion · G1799

    before, in the sight of · v11

    'In front of their eyes', a phrase Luke uses often and one that echoes biblical Hebrew. With 'appeared' it means 'in their judgment, to their way of seeing it'.

  25. ὡσεὶ

    hōsei · G5616

    like, as · v11

    'Like, as if it were'. The words were treated as if they were rubbish. Luke is reporting the men's judgment, not giving his own.

  26. λῆρος

    lēros · G3026

    nonsense, rubbish · v11

    A blunt, dismissive word: drivel, babble, talk not worth hearing. It occurs only here in the New Testament. It is stronger than the KJV's 'idle tales'.

  27. ῥήματα

    rhēmata · G4487

    word, saying, matter · v11

    The spoken report the women had just given: the empty tomb, the two men in shining clothes, and the reminder of Jesus' own words (vv.4–9). Grammatically this is the subject of 'appeared'.

  28. ἠπίστουν

    ēpistoun · G569

    to disbelieve, refuse to believe · v11

    Imperfect tense, describing an ongoing state: 'they kept disbelieving, they would not believe'. It was a continuing refusal, not a moment's hesitation. Luke returns to the same verb at v.41.

The world behind it

Who and where. The women had followed Jesus from Galilee and supported his group from their own means (Luke 8:1–3). They watched the crucifixion from a distance (23:49), saw where the body was laid (23:55), prepared spices, rested on the Sabbath as the Law required (23:56), and came back at first light on Sunday (24:1). Jesus' followers were staying in Jerusalem, probably for the week of Unleavened Bread that follows Passover. Luke keeps the whole resurrection story in and around Jerusalem. Unlike Mark and Matthew, he records no appearances in Galilee.

Women as witnesses. In the Jewish world of the day, women's testimony counted for less in formal legal settings. Josephus says that a woman's testimony is not to be accepted, and he gives a dismissive reason (Antiquities 4.219). The Mishnah, a body of Jewish law written down around AD 200, excludes women from the formal oath of testimony (m. Shevuot 4:1). That rule was not absolute: in some cases a woman's word was accepted, for example about a husband's death (m. Yevamot 16:7). Outside formal courts it still shaped ordinary assumptions about whose word counted. Later, the pagan critic Celsus mocked the resurrection for resting on the word of "a hysterical woman" (quoted in Origen, Against Celsus 2.55). Against this background, Luke's account stands out. The first people to announce the empty tomb are named women (v. 10), and the men they tell treat their words as "nonsense" (v. 11).

The broken Twelve. Twelve disciples stood for the twelve tribes of Israel (cf. Luke 22:30). "The Eleven" is therefore a sign of damage: Judas's betrayal has left the group incomplete. Acts 1 shows the group being made whole again before the Spirit comes.

From the study of Luke 24:9.

Where scholars differ

in v9

How much does the low legal standing of women's testimony explain Luke's account?

  • It explains a great deal. Women's word was widely discounted, which accounts for the disbelief in v. 11. It also suggests the early church would not have invented women as the first witnesses.

    Josephus, Antiquities 4.219; m. Shevuot 4:1; m. Rosh Hashanah 1:8; Celsus's mockery in Origen, Against Celsus 2.55; Luke 24:11, 22–24, where the men dismiss the report.

  • It explains something, but it is often overstated. The rules were about formal court testimony and allowed exceptions. In everyday life women's reports were acted on. The disbelief in v. 11 is better explained by how unheard-of the claim was.

    Exceptions such as m. Yevamot 16:7 (a woman's word accepted about a husband's death); the Mishnah was written down around AD 200, later than Luke; in Luke 24:41 the disciples doubt even when Jesus himself appears, which suggests their disbelief was about the event, not about who reported it.

in v9

Is the reporting in v. 9 the same event as the naming in v. 10, or does v. 10 add something?

  • V. 10 looks back on the same report. Luke tells the event first and then names the witnesses, as an ancient historian citing sources might.

    The tense of "they were telling" (elegon) in v. 10 suggests continued or repeated telling. Luke's preface stresses named eyewitnesses (1:2).

  • V. 10 narrows the audience from "the Eleven and all the rest" to "the apostles", underlining that the apostles in particular were told and did not believe.

    The different nouns: the general audience in v. 9, "apostles" in v. 10; v. 11 "them" refers back to the apostles.

in v10

Who was "Mary of James": mother, wife, or daughter?

  • Mother of James (the majority view and the reading of most English versions).

    Luke's source, Mark, says outright "Mary the mother of James the younger and of Joses" (Mark 15:40). Matthew 27:56 agrees. Luke's phrase is most naturally read as a shortened form of Mark's.

  • The Greek is open, and the relationship could be wife or daughter.

    "Article + genitive name" can mean any close relation, and context decides. In Luke 6:16, "Judas of James" is read as "son" by most and "brother" by the KJV. Without Mark, Luke's words alone would not settle it.

  • She is also the "Mary of Clopas" of John 19:25.

    This rests on early church tradition (e.g. Hegesippus via Eusebius) linking Clopas to Jesus' family. It is possible but unproven, and depends on harmonizing separate lists.

in v10

Why does Luke name the women here, and how would naming women affect the report's credibility?

  • The names mark known eyewitnesses whose testimony stands behind the tradition.

    Luke appeals to eyewitnesses (1:2). The names match his earlier list (8:2-3), and the precise labels suggest people known in the communities (Bauckham, *Gospel Women*; *Jesus and the Eyewitnesses*).

  • The list mainly does literary and theological work: it frames the story and highlights faithful disciples.

    Mary Magdalene and Joanna named both in 8:2-3 and here frame the ministry. Luke gives women unusual attention throughout his Gospel. The list sets up the irony of v. 11.

  • Naming women would have weakened the report in the eyes of outsiders, so its survival suggests the tradition was too firm to change.

    Women's testimony carried less public weight (Josephus, Ant. 4.219; certain Mishnah rules), and Luke himself shows the men dismissing it. Critics answer that women's testimony was not always rejected, so the argument should not be overstated. Celsus later mocked the resurrection report as resting on a "hysterical woman" (Origen, Against Celsus 2.55).

in v11

Did the apostles disbelieve mainly because the witnesses were women, or because the message was unbelievable?

  • Gender was a major factor.

    Luke ends the verse with a feminine pronoun ('they kept disbelieving *them*', the women) and has just named them (v.10). Josephus (Ant. 4.219) and later rabbinic law show that women's testimony was commonly discounted. Celsus later attacked the resurrection for resting on women's word. Scholars such as Richard Bauckham (Gospel Women) stress this background.

  • The content was the main obstacle; gender only made it worse.

    Luke shows the same disbelief when men report, and even with Jesus physically present: the Emmaus pair are 'slow of heart to believe' (v.25), and the Eleven 'still disbelieved for joy' (v.41). Mark 16:13 says the Eleven did not believe the two male disciples either. No one expected a lone man to rise in the middle of history. Luke's chapter-long theme is that only the risen Jesus and the opened Scriptures overcome unbelief.

  • Both together (a common middle position).

    The text names the women and also builds a pattern of disbelief that holds regardless of who the witness is. Luke can show the women's witness being discounted while making the larger point that the message itself was beyond belief.

in v11

Is lēros a medical term (the raving of the delirious) that points to Luke the physician?

  • Yes, it is part of Luke's 'medical language'.

    W. K. Hobart (The Medical Language of St. Luke, 1882) listed λῆρος among words found in Greek medical writers for the delirious talk of fever patients.

  • No, it is ordinary educated Greek.

    H. J. Cadbury (The Style and Literary Method of Luke, 1920) showed that the supposed medical words are equally common in non-medical writers such as Josephus, Plutarch and Lucian. λῆρος is a stock word in comedy and philosophy for 'rubbish'. Most scholars now follow Cadbury, though some think Luke may still have been a physician on other grounds.

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. ὑποστρέφω, μνημεῖον, ἀπαγγέλλω, λοιπός
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. ἀπαγγέλλω
  • Josephus, Antiquities 4.219
  • Mishnah Shevuot 4:1; Rosh Hashanah 1:8; Yevamot 16:7
  • Origen, Against Celsus 2.55
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on Luke 24
  • Westcott & Hort, The New Testament in the Original Greek, Introduction (Western non-interpolations)
  • Nestle-Aland 28th ed., apparatus at Luke 24:9
  • Joel B. Green, The Gospel of Luke (NICNT)
  • I. Howard Marshall, The Gospel of Luke (NIGTC)
  • Craig S. Keener, IVP Bible Background Commentary: New Testament, on Luke 24
  • Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed., Luke 24:10 and apparatus
  • Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament, 2nd ed., on Luke 24:10
  • BDAG s.v. ἀπόστολος
  • BDAG s.v. λοιπός
  • BDAG s.v. Μαγδαληνή
  • Richard Bauckham, Gospel Women: Studies of the Named Women in the Gospels (2002)
  • Richard Bauckham, Jesus and the Eyewitnesses (2006)
  • Tal Ilan, Lexicon of Jewish Names in Late Antiquity, Part I (2002)
  • Josephus, Antiquities 4.219; Jewish War books 2-3 (Taricheae)
  • Mishnah Shevuot 4:1; Mishnah Yevamot 16:7
  • Gregory the Great, Homily 33 on the Gospels (AD 591)
  • Herodotus, Histories 1.21; 5.38 (ἀπόστολος as envoy)
  • BDAG s.v. λῆρος
  • BDAG s.v. ἀπιστέω
  • BDAG s.v. ῥῆμα
  • LSJ s.v. λῆρος
  • 4 Maccabees 5:11 (LXX)
  • Origen, Contra Celsum 2.55
  • Vulgate, Luke 24:11
  • B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (on Luke 24:11–12)
  • NA28 apparatus, Luke 24:11
  • W. K. Hobart, The Medical Language of St. Luke (1882)
  • H. J. Cadbury, The Style and Literary Method of Luke (1920)
  • R. Bauckham, Gospel Women (2002)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).