Mark Chapter 10 Read as one passage
Mark 10:38–40
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
38“You do not know what you are asking,” Jesus replied. “Can you drink the cup I will drink, or be baptized with the baptism I will undergo?” 39“We can,” the brothers answered. “You will drink the cup that I drink,” Jesus said, “and you will be baptized with the baptism that I undergo. 40But to sit at My right or left is not Mine to grant. These seats belong to those for whom they have been prepared.”
What the first hearers heard
To the brothers on the road, the reply turned their request around. They asked to share Jesus' royal glory. He asked whether they could share what had to come first: his cup and his immersion, the suffering he had just described in detail (10:33–34). Their quick "We can!" (v.39) shows they still do not understand. Within days, all the disciples run away (14:50).
To Mark's first readers, the saying set the pattern for following Jesus. The way to the "right and left" runs through the cup and the flood. Jesus does not cancel the brothers' future: he says they will drink his cup (v.39). Readers who knew that James had been beheaded would hear that promise fulfilled. Some in a persecuted community may also have heard their own two rites, the cup of the Lord's Supper and baptism, behind Jesus' words. Mark's surface meaning, though, is martyr-like suffering joined to his.
The scene also prepares the irony of Mark's crucifixion story. When Jesus is finally shown publicly as "King of the Jews," the ones at his right and left are two crucified bandits (15:27).
From the study of Mark 10:38.
Verse by verse
-
38“You do not know what you are asking,” Jesus replied. “Can you drink the cup I will drink, or be baptized with the baptism I will undergo?”
Full study →Jesus answers James and John's request to sit at his right and left in his glory with a gentle but cutting reply: "You don't understand what you are asking for." Then he asks a question built from two old pictures of a God-given fate. "Are you able to drink down the cup that I myself am already drinking, the cup the Father has poured for me? Or to be plunged under the flood that I myself am already going under?"
The cup comes from Israel's Scriptures, where God hands a cup to a person or nation. Sometimes it is a cup of blessing. More often it is the cup of his wrath, which the guilty must drain until they stagger. The baptism is not the church's water rite. The word means immersion, being swamped and going under, like the drowning waters of the Psalms. Both verbs are in the present tense ("I am drinking," "I am being immersed"), so Jesus speaks of his suffering as already beginning, not only as something far off. The passive "am being immersed" suggests another hand doing the plunging. The emphatic "I myself," repeated twice, makes the cup and the immersion unmistakably his.
The brothers want to share Jesus' throne. He asks whether they can share his drowning. In Mark the places at his "right and left" turn out to belong to two crucified bandits (15:27).
-
39“We can,” the brothers answered. “You will drink the cup that I drink,” Jesus said, “and you will be baptized with the baptism that I undergo.
Full study →James and John have just asked Jesus for the two places of highest honour, at his right and his left, when he comes into his royal glory. Jesus has told them they do not understand what they are asking, and has put a counter-question to them: Are you able to drink the cup I am drinking, or to be plunged under the flood I am being plunged under? They answer at once with one word: "We are able."
Jesus does not correct their confidence. He confirms their future, and in a way that turns their request upside down. In the Greek the emphasis falls on the things themselves: "The cup that I myself am drinking, that is what you will drink. The drowning I myself am going under, that is what you will go under."
The cup is the portion God pours for someone to swallow. Israel's prophets repeatedly spoke of the cup of God's wrath that makes nations stagger, and Jesus will soon pray in Gethsemane, "remove this cup from me." The baptism here is not the church's water rite. It is the ordinary Greek picture of being dipped, swamped, sunk, like a man overwhelmed by flood waters in the Psalms ("the waters have come up to my neck"). Jesus speaks of both in the present tense: he is already drinking this cup and already going under, because he is walking up to Jerusalem to be handed over, mocked, flogged and killed (10:33–34). The passive "I am being baptized" shows that this is being done to him, not something he performs.
So the brothers will get a share with Jesus, but it is a share in his suffering, not in his throne. The seats they asked for are not his to hand out (v. 40). Mark's readers would have caught the irony: when Jesus is finally "enthroned" on the cross, the places at his right and his left go to two crucified bandits (15:27). The prophecy was fulfilled for James, executed by Herod Agrippa I around AD 44 (Acts 12:2). What exactly happened to John is disputed in early tradition.
-
40But to sit at My right or left is not Mine to grant. These seats belong to those for whom they have been prepared.”
Full study →"But as for taking a seat at my right, or at my left, that is not mine to hand out. Those places already stand prepared, and they belong to the ones they were prepared for."
The brothers had asked, "Give us…" (v. 37). Jesus answers that this is not his to give. The places of honour beside him are real, but they were settled beforehand, and the passive "has been prepared" points to God as the one who settled them (Matthew says "by my Father"). They are not favours to be won by asking first. In the Greek, "mine" is emphatic. Jesus is not admitting a lack of power. He is saying the seating at this royal table is his Father's decision.
Two details would strike Mark's first readers:
- "Give" comes back five verses later. What Jesus does give is "his life as a ransom for many" (10:45).
- The word for "left" changes. Jesus' word is the one Mark uses again when he describes two bandits crucified "one at his right and one at his left" (15:27).
James and John pictured thrones. The first people Mark shows at Jesus' right and left are the men dying beside him.
Where the English drifted
-
in v38
baptism / be baptized
baptisma / baptizō
- What we hear
- The church's water ceremony, or (in some circles) a "baptism in the Spirit" experience.
- What they heard
- Being plunged or immersed, and figuratively being overwhelmed or swamped. Here it is Jesus' coming ordeal of suffering and death. He had already received water baptism from John (1:9).
-
in v38
the cup
potērion
- What we hear
- A vague "lot in life," or the communion cup.
- What they heard
- The cup God hands someone to drink. In the Hebrew Scriptures this is usually the cup of his judgment. Here it is the specific fate the Father has given Jesus (14:36).
-
in v39
baptized / baptism
baptizō / baptisma
- What we hear
- The church's water rite of initiation (or, for some readers, an experience of the Spirit).
- What they heard
- A plunging under, being overwhelmed or swamped. Here a picture of being submerged in suffering and death, as by flood waters.
-
in v39
the cup that I drink
to potērion ho egō pinō
- What we hear
- A general metaphor for any hardship, or an echo of the communion cup.
- What they heard
- The specific portion God hands Jesus to drink: his coming suffering and death, described in the prophets' language of the cup received from God's hand, often a cup of judgment.
-
in v40
for whom it has been prepared
hois hētoimastai
- What we hear
- Heard as something still being worked out: places that will go to whoever turns out to qualify, or a vague 'set aside'. Some hear it the other way, as a statement about individual predestination to salvation.
- What they heard
- A perfect passive with God as the implied actor. In Jewish speech about the end of days it means places already appointed in God's settled plan. The subject is rank in the coming reign, not who is saved.
Every word
-
Ὁ
Ho · G3588
the · v38, v39, v40
Greek often puts "the" before a personal name. It is not translated in English, but it marks Jesus as the familiar main character taking over the conversation.
-
δὲ
de · G1161
but, and · v38, v39, v40
A light connecting word that marks the change of speaker. After the brothers' bold request (v.37), it can carry a slight sense of contrast: "but Jesus…"
-
Ἰησοῦς
Iēsous · G2424
Jesus (Joshua) · v38, v39
The Greek form of the Hebrew Yeshua/Yehoshua, "the LORD saves." Here he is the one who has just predicted his own death for the third time (10:33–34).
-
εἶπεν
eipen · G2036
said · v38, v39
A simple past-tense verb for speaking. It introduces Jesus' reply, which comes as a gentle but piercing correction rather than a rebuke.
-
αὐτοῖς·
autois · G846
to them · v38, v39
Plural, "to them": James and John, the sons of Zebedee (10:35). Both brothers are addressed together.
-
οὐκ
ouk · G3756
not · v38, v40
Placed first for emphasis: "Not do you know…" The first thing Jesus says is that they do not understand.
-
οἴδατε
oidate · G1492
you know · v38
A perfect-tense form that works as a present: "you know, you understand." They are asking for something without grasping what it involves. (The supplied data lists the lemma under the root εἴδω; the usual dictionary form is οἶδα.)
-
τί
ti · G5101
what · v38
"What" you are asking. The problem is the content of the request, not how they asked it.
-
αἰτεῖσθε.
aiteisthe · G154
you ask, request · v38
Present tense, middle voice: "you are asking (for yourselves)." Some grammarians think the middle form stresses a request made in one's own interest. In New Testament Greek the difference is loose, so this should not be pressed hard.
-
δύνασθε
dynasthe · G1410
you are able, can · v38, v39
"Are you able?" It is a real question about their capacity. It sets up their confident one-word answer in v.39, dynametha, "We are able!"
-
πιεῖν
piein · G4095
to drink · v38, v39
The form presents drinking as one complete act: drinking the cup down, not just tasting it.
-
ποτήριον
potērion · G4221
cup · v38, v39
A drinking cup used as a picture of the fate God hands someone. In the Hebrew Scriptures this is often the cup of God's judgment. Here it points to Jesus' coming suffering and death (compare 14:36, "take this cup from me").
-
ὃ
ho · G3739
which · v38, v39, v40
"Which": links the cup to Jesus' own drinking. It is not any cup but his cup.
-
ἐγὼ
egō · G1473
I · v38, v39
Greek does not need the pronoun, because the verb already says "I." Including it adds emphasis: "the cup that I myself am drinking."
-
ἢ
ē · G2228
or · v38, v40
"Or": brings in a second image for the same reality. The two are parallel, not two separate ordeals.
-
βάπτισμα
baptisma · G908
immersion, baptism · v38, v39
An immersion or plunging. It is used here as a picture of being overwhelmed by suffering, like going under deep waters. It is not a reference to the church's water rite.
-
βαπτίζομαι
baptizomai · G907
I am immersed/baptized · v38, v39
Present passive: "I am being immersed." The passive voice means someone else does the plunging. Behind it may stand God's will, as in 14:36. The present tense again presents the ordeal as already beginning.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v39
Joins the second image to the first. The two pictures, the cup and the flood, describe one reality.
-
καθίσαι
kathisai · G2523
to sit, take a seat · v40
Aorist infinitive, 'to take a seat'. Jesus repeats the brothers' own verb from verse 37 ('grant us that we may sit'). Sitting beside a king means holding a rank, not just resting.
-
ἐκ
ek · G1537
out of, from · v40
In the idiom 'from the right' the preposition marks the side someone is on, so 'at the right'. Greek pictures position as seen 'from' a side.
-
δεξιῶν
dexiōn · G1188
right (hand/side) · v40
A plural adjective used as a noun, literally 'the right parts', meaning the right side. The place at a ruler's right was the highest honour after the ruler himself (Psalm 110:1; 1 Kings 2:19).
-
μου
mou · G3165
of me, my · v40
'My right'. Jesus speaks of his own throne-side, so he accepts that a 'glory' with places of honour beside him is coming (v. 37).
-
εὐωνύμων
euōnymōn · G2176
left (literally 'well-named') · v40
The polite Greek word for 'left'. Literally it means 'of good name', a euphemism, because the left was the side of bad omens. In verse 37 the brothers used the plain word for left (ἀριστερῶν). Jesus uses this one, the same word Mark uses in 15:27 for the bandit crucified 'on his left'.
-
ἔστιν
estin · G1510
is · v40
Present tense, 'is'. It states how things stand: this allocation is not, as a matter of fact, his to make.
-
ἐμὸν
emon · G1699
mine, my own · v40
The possessive pronoun used emphatically: 'not MINE'. The Greek idiom 'it is mine to [do]' means 'it is my prerogative, my job'. Jesus is not saying he lacks power. He is saying this task belongs to someone else.
-
δοῦναι
dounai · G1325
-
ἀλλ᾽
all᾽ · G235
but; (after a negative) except · v40
This sets up the contrast: not mine to give, but it belongs to others. After a negative, ἀλλά can also mean 'except' ('not mine to give except to those…'), so translators must choose. Either way the seats go to those for whom they are prepared.
-
ἡτοίμασται
hētoimastai · G2090
to prepare, make ready · v40
Perfect passive, 'it has been prepared and stands ready'. The passive leaves the preparer unnamed in the Jewish way of speaking reverently about God's action; Matthew 20:23 names him: 'by my Father'. The matter is already settled. It is not open to lobbying.
The world behind it
Where this happens. Jesus and the Twelve are on the road up to Jerusalem (10:32). He has just predicted, for the third and most detailed time, that he will be handed over, mocked, spat on, flogged and killed, and will rise after three days (10:33–34). The very next thing Mark reports is James and John asking for the seats of honour "in your glory" (10:37). These are the places at a king's right and left, kept for his highest officials. They picture Jesus as a Messiah about to be enthroned.
What "cup" meant. For anyone raised on the Psalms and Prophets, the cup in God's hand was a well-known image. Isaiah calls Jerusalem the one "who has drunk from the LORD's hand the cup of his wrath" (51:17). Jeremiah is told to make the nations drink "the cup of the wine of wrath" (25:15). By Jesus' time the cup could also mean a martyr's death. Mark's own story settles what this cup is: in Gethsemane Jesus prays, "Take this cup from me" (14:36).
What "baptism" meant. In ordinary Greek, to be "baptized" in something meant to be swamped or overwhelmed by it: a city by a crowd of refugees, a person by wine or debt. Behind that stands the biblical picture of deep waters closing over a sufferer (Ps 42:7; 69:1–2). Jesus had already received John's water baptism (1:9). This is a different immersion.
How it turned out. In v.39 Jesus tells them that they will drink his cup and share his immersion. James, son of Zebedee, was executed by Herod Agrippa I around AD 44 (Acts 12:2). John's fate is less certain: most early tradition has him dying old in Ephesus, while one disputed fragment attributed to Papias says he too was killed. Mark's first readers, whom many scholars place among Christians in or near Rome who had lived through persecution, would have heard this exchange with that knowledge.
From the study of Mark 10:38.
Where scholars differ
in v38
Is "the cup" the cup of God's wrath, or more generally a cup of suffering and martyrdom?
-
Cup of divine judgment: Jesus takes on the judgment that the Prophets assigned to sinful Israel and the nations.
In the Hebrew Bible "cup" in God's hand overwhelmingly means wrath (Isa 51:17, 22; Jer 25:15–28; Ezek 23:31–34; Ps 75:8). In Gethsemane Jesus is in deep anguish over the cup (14:33–36). Mark 10:45, a few verses later, calls his death "a ransom for many." Many commentators (e.g. Cranfield, France, Marcus) see at least this note.
-
Cup of suffering or martyrdom, a fate God assigns, without a specific claim about wrath.
Jesus says the brothers will drink the same cup (v.39). It is hard to see how they could bear divine wrath the way he does, which suggests a shared fate of suffering. Jewish and early Christian texts use "cup" for martyrdom (*Martyrdom of Isaiah* 5:13; *Martyrdom of Polycarp* 14:2). Some scholars (e.g. Collins, Gundry in part) stress this sense.
-
Both: the image covers suffering and death in general, but Jesus' cup carries a weight the disciples' does not.
Verse 39 says the brothers share in the cup. Verse 45 makes Jesus' death uniquely "for many." Many readings hold the two together.
in v38
Do "cup" and "baptism" point to the Lord's Supper and Christian baptism?
-
Yes, as a secondary echo: Mark's readers would have heard their two rites here.
Mark's community practised both baptism and the cup of the Supper (14:23–24). Paul links baptism with sharing in Christ's death (Rom 6:3–4). Some commentators (e.g. Marcus) think Mark lets readers hear this.
-
No: in the story the words are plain metaphors for suffering.
The brothers could not have understood a reference to rites that did not yet exist. Luke 12:50 uses "baptism" for Jesus' ordeal with no rite in view. The ordinary Greek sense "to be overwhelmed" fully explains the word.
in v39
Is the 'cup' specifically the cup of God's judgment, or more generally suffering and death?
-
Cup of divine wrath: Jesus drinks the judgment the prophets assigned to sinful Israel and the nations. The disciples share his suffering but not its redemptive role.
In the Old Testament prophets the cup image is overwhelmingly about wrath (Isa 51:17–22; Jer 25:15–29). Gethsemane's anguish over 'this cup' (14:36) and the ransom saying (10:45) point to something beyond ordinary martyrdom.
-
Cup of destiny or suffering: the image means the fate God assigns, here a martyr's death, which the disciples can genuinely share.
The cup can also mean simply one's portion (Ps 16:5; 11:6). Jewish texts speak of the 'cup of death'. In this verse Jesus says the disciples will drink the same cup, which fits a broader meaning. Early martyr texts speak of a 'share in the cup of Christ' (Martyrdom of Polycarp 14.2).
in v39
Did John, like James, die a martyr's death?
-
Yes: both brothers were killed, fulfilling the prophecy literally.
A fragment attributed to Papias (via Philip of Side and George the Monk) says John and James were killed by the Jews. Some early martyr lists commemorate them together.
-
No: John suffered (prison, exile) but died of old age at Ephesus. The prophecy is fulfilled through suffering, not necessarily execution.
Irenaeus (Against Heresies 3.3.4) and Polycrates of Ephesus (in Eusebius, Church History 3.31; 5.24) place John's long life and death at Ephesus. Acts 4 and 5 record his arrest and flogging. The Papias fragment survives only in late and unreliable sources.
in v39
Did Mark's readers hear an allusion to Christian baptism and the Lord's Supper?
-
Yes, as a secondary layer: 'cup' and 'baptism' together would have reminded believers of their own rites, which unite them with Jesus' death.
Romans 6:3 ('baptized into his death') and 1 Cor 10:16–21 show that this connection existed in early churches. Mark 14:23–24 uses the cup in the Supper.
-
No, or only faintly: the saying is purely figurative in its setting, and reading sacraments into it is anachronistic.
Jesus speaks of his own present 'baptism', which cannot be a rite. Luke 12:50 uses the same figurative image without any cup. Both images come from the Old Testament and from ordinary Greek metaphor.
in v40
Who are 'those for whom it has been prepared'?
-
Unnamed people appointed by the Father in the age to come. Jesus deliberately leaves them unidentified.
The perfect passive points to God's settled plan (compare Matthew 20:23, 'by my Father'; Matthew 25:34). Jesus' point is that the decision is not his and not the brothers', not who the people are.
-
Mark is pointing ironically to the two bandits crucified 'one at his right and one at his left' (15:27).
The wording matches exactly: ἐκ δεξιῶν… ἐξ εὐωνύμων, with the same 'left' word that Jesus uses here and that differs from the brothers' word in 10:37. The context (cup, baptism, ransom) is about Jesus' death, and the cross is where Mark shows Jesus as 'King of the Jews'. Several commentators (e.g. Marcus, Collins) see at least a deliberate echo. Others think it is a literary irony, not the literal answer to the question.
-
Those who become fit for it through humility and suffering, as many early Christian writers explained it (e.g. John Chrysostom on the Matthew parallel).
The flow of 10:38–45 links greatness to service and suffering. Critics reply that the verse grounds the allocation in God's preparation, not in the recipients' qualifications.
in v40
Does ἀλλά mean 'but' or 'except' here?
-
'But': it is not mine to give; rather, it belongs to those for whom it has been prepared.
The ordinary meaning of ἀλλά after a negative. Followed by nearly all modern translations and most grammarians.
-
'Except': it is not mine to give except to those for whom it has been prepared.
BDAG records ἀλλά after a negative with the sense 'except' (compare Mark 4:22). This reading was favoured by some early writers who wanted to keep Jesus as the giver within the Father's plan.
in v40
What does 'not mine to give' say about Jesus' authority?
-
A statement of role within Mark's portrait of the obedient Son, not a statement about his nature.
Compare Mark 13:32 ('not even the Son, but only the Father'). The idiom 'it is mine to…' is about prerogative or office. Mark's own interest is in rank and suffering, not later questions about Jesus' divine nature.
-
Read in the fourth-century debates as evidence of the Son's subordination (Arian use), or as spoken only in Jesus' human capacity (a common orthodox reply, e.g. Ambrose and Augustine).
These readings answer questions raised by the creeds and councils, not by Mark's narrative. They show how the verse was used, not what it first meant.
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ποτήριον, βάπτισμα, βαπτίζω
- LSJ s.v. βαπτίζω
- Thayer s.v. βαπτίζω
- Septuagint: Isa 51:17, 22; Jer 25:15 (LXX 32:15); Ps 74:9 LXX; Isa 21:4 LXX
- Josephus, Jewish War 4.137; Antiquities 10.169; 18.117
- Plato, Symposium 176b
- Martyrdom of Isaiah 5:13; Martyrdom of Polycarp 14:2
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (on Matt 20:22)
- C. E. B. Cranfield, The Gospel According to Saint Mark
- R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC)
- J. Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- A. Y. Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- R. H. Gundry, Mark: A Commentary on His Apology for the Cross
- BDAG s.v. ποτήριον, βάπτισμα, βαπτίζω, δύναμαι
- Joel Marcus, Mark 8–16 (Anchor Yale Bible)
- Adela Yarbro Collins, Mark (Hermeneia)
- Septuagint: Isaiah 21:4; Isaiah 51:17–22; Jeremiah 25:15–29 (LXX 32); Psalm 69; Psalm 75
- Josephus, Jewish War 4.137; Antiquities 18.117
- Martyrdom of Polycarp 14.2; Ascension of Isaiah 5:13
- Irenaeus, Against Heresies 3.1.1; 3.3.4
- Eusebius, Church History 3.23; 3.31
- Papias fragment (Philip of Side)
- Acts 12:2; Luke 12:50; Matthew 20:20–23
- BDAG s.v. ἀλλά (sense 'except' after a negative)
- BDAG s.v. ἑτοιμάζω
- BDAG s.v. εὐώνυμος
- LSJ s.v. εὐώνυμος (euphemism for 'left')
- B. M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek New Testament (2nd ed.), on Mark 10:40
- NA28 / UBS5 critical apparatus, Mark 10:37–40
- Morna Hooker, The Gospel According to St Mark (BNTC)
- Josephus, Antiquities 6.235
- John Chrysostom, Homilies on Matthew 65 (on Matt 20:23)
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).