Mark Chapter 4 Read as one passage

Mark 4:16–17

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

16Some are like the seeds sown on rocky ground. They hear the word and at once receive it with joy. 17But they themselves have no root, and they remain for only a season. When trouble or persecution comes because of the word, they quickly fall away.

What the first hearers heard

For Jesus' Galilean hearers, the picture was immediate and familiar. Everyone had seen wheat shoot up early on the rock shelves and then turn brown by early summer. Hearing their own response to Jesus described in those terms was a warning. The crowds who flocked to him in Mark 1–3 were enthusiastic, but enthusiasm was not the harvest.

The explanation of the parable is given privately to "those around him with the Twelve" (4:10). It prepares insiders for the fact that not everyone who welcomes the message will last. It also points ahead in Mark's story: Jesus later uses the same verb, "you will all fall away" (skandalizō, 14:27), for his own disciples, and they scatter when the "trouble" of his arrest comes.

For Mark's first readers, likely a persecuted community, the verse named something they knew painfully: converts who had received the message with real joy and then disappeared under pressure. The verse does not mock their joy. It says joy has to be matched by depth, by being rooted "in themselves" (4:17), if the word is to survive the heat.

From the study of Mark 4:16.

Verse by verse

  1. 16Some are like the seeds sown on rocky ground. They hear the word and at once receive it with joy.

    "And these are the ones sown on the rocky places, a thin skin of soil over bedrock. Whenever they hear the message, they take it up straight away, and gladly."

    Jesus is decoding the second scene of his sowing story (4:5–6). Every Galilean farmer knew those patches at the edge of a field where the limestone sat only a few inches down. Seed there came up faster than anywhere else, because the shallow soil warmed quickly. Within days it was green and promising, and soon afterwards it was scorched, because its roots had nowhere to go.

    These hearers are like that. They really hear Jesus' announcement that God's kingdom has arrived, and they welcome it at once with real joy. Nothing in the wording makes the joy false. Joy is the right response to good news. But Mark's repeated "immediately" sets a quiet trap. The quick welcome here is the mirror of the quick collapse in the next verse ("immediately they fall away," 4:17), and both come from the same cause: no depth. The verse describes a typical, repeated pattern ("whenever they hear"). It describes a kind of hearer, not one moment. The verse looks hopeful on its own, but it is the first half of a sentence that ends in failure when pressure comes "because of the word."

    Full study →
  2. 17But they themselves have no root, and they remain for only a season. When trouble or persecution comes because of the word, they quickly fall away.

    "But they have no root down inside themselves. They are people of a season, lasting only as long as the weather stays kind. Then, when crushing pressure or active hostility arrives, and it arrives precisely because of the message they took up, at once they are tripped up and fall away."

    This is the explanation of the seed that landed on rocky ground (Mark 4:5–6). In Galilee that meant a thin crust of soil over limestone. Seed there sprouts fast because the warm shallow soil gives it a head start, but its roots hit rock. When the sun comes up it scorches and withers. Jesus now applies the picture. These hearers really did receive the word, and they received it with joy and at once (v.16). What they lack is depth. Nothing has gone down into them that could draw on deeper water.

    Three details sharpen the point:

    • "Immediately… immediately." Mark uses the same word for their quick welcome (v.16) and their quick collapse. A fast start is matched by a fast falling away.
    • "Because of the word." The trouble is not just the ordinary hardship of life. It is hostility aimed at the message itself. The seed brings its own heat. Holding to Jesus' announcement of God's kingdom will cost something, and that cost is what shows how deep the soil is.
    • "Stumble / fall away." The Greek pictures a trap being sprung or a foot catching on an obstacle. The result is not hurt feelings but a break: they give up the allegiance they had joyfully taken on. The verb is in the present tense and describes what typically happens with this kind of hearer.

    The word "temporary" (literally "for a season") does not say their joy was fake. It says their faith was tied to good conditions and could not outlast a change in the weather.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v16

    stony ground (KJV)

    ta petrōdē

    What we hear
    A field scattered with loose stones that crowd out the seed.
    What they heard
    Ground where bedrock lies just under a thin layer of soil. The problem is depth, not stones in the way (Mark 4:5: 'it did not have much soil').
  • in v16

    the word

    ho logos

    What we hear
    The Bible, Scripture as a written book.
    What they heard
    Jesus' spoken announcement of God's arriving kingdom (Mark 1:14–15; 2:2; 4:33), heard in person.
  • in v16

    receive it

    lambanousin auton

    What we hear
    The moment of conversion, as in 'receiving Christ', which raises the question whether these people were 'saved'.
    What they heard
    To take up or accept a message, here gladly. A real acceptance, but the parable judges hearers by fruit over time, not by the moment of welcome.
  • in v17

    they are offended (KJV)

    skandalizontai

    What we hear
    They feel insulted or upset; their feelings are hurt.
    What they heard
    They are tripped up or snared, and so they abandon their allegiance to the message. It is an act of falling away, not an emotional reaction.
  • in v17

    tribulation (YLT)

    thlipsis

    What we hear
    'The Tribulation', a specific future end-times period of seven years.
    What they heard
    Any crushing pressure or affliction, here the hardship that comes on hearers because they hold to Jesus' message.
  • in v17

    the word

    logos

    What we hear
    The Bible, or 'the Word' as a title of Christ.
    What they heard
    The spoken message Jesus was proclaiming about the arrival of God's kingdom, which the sower 'sows' (4:14).
Every word
  1. καὶ

    kai · G2532

    and · v16, v17

    Moves the explanation on to the second kind of hearer. Mark strings his explanation together with simple 'and's, the way spoken storytelling does.

  2. οὗτοί

    houtoi · G3778

    these · v16

    Points to a group of people. 'These' are the hearers who match the rocky-ground part of the parable (4:5–6).

  3. εἰσιν

    eisin · G1510

    are · v16, v17

    'Are' in the sense of 'stand for' or 'correspond to'. It is the standard way of decoding a parable: this picture equals that reality.

  4. ὁμοίως

    homoiōs · G3668

    likewise · v16

    Found only in some editions (the KJV's 'likewise'). It marks this group as a parallel case to the path-side hearers of verse 15.

  5. οἱ

    hoi · G3588

    the (ones) · v16, v17

    The article together with the participle 'being sown' makes a noun phrase: 'the ones sown'.

  6. ἐπὶ

    epi · G1909

    upon, on · v16

    'On' or 'upon'. The seed lands on top of the rock layer and cannot get down into it.

  7. πετρώδη

    petrōdē · G4075

    rocky · v16

    Rocky ground: a thin skin of soil over bedrock, not a field scattered with loose stones. Verse 5 has already said the problem: 'it did not have much soil.'

  8. σπειρόμενοι

    speiromenoi · G4687

    being sown · v16

    A present passive participle, 'the ones being sown'. Mark here identifies the hearers with the seed that lands in a certain place. In verse 15 the word was sown 'in them'. The image moves between seed and soil, and the point is the result: what happens to the word in a given kind of person.

  9. οἳ

    hoi · G3739

    who · v16

    Introduces the description of how these people typically respond.

  10. ὅταν

    hotan · G3752

    whenever, when · v16

    'Whenever'. With the subjunctive that follows, it describes a typical, repeated pattern, not a single event.

  11. ἀκούσωσιν

    akousōsin · G0191

    they hear · v16

    'They hear.' In Mark 4 hearing is the key theme: the parable opens with 'Listen!' (4:3) and closes with 'whoever has ears to hear, let him hear' (4:9). These people do hear, and the question is what the hearing does in them.

  12. λόγον

    logon · G3056

    word, message · v16, v17

    The message Jesus is announcing, that God's kingdom has come near (1:14–15; 2:2; 4:33). It is not yet 'the Bible' as a written book.

  13. εὐθὺς

    euthus · G2112

    immediately, at once · v16, v17

    'Right away.' It echoes the seed that 'immediately sprang up' because the soil was shallow (4:5), and it anticipates 'immediately they fall away' in verse 17. The quick start and the quick collapse have the same cause.

  14. μετὰ

    meta · G3326

    with · v16

    'With', marking the manner of the response.

  15. χαρᾶς

    charas · G5479

    joy · v16

    Real gladness. Nothing in the word suggests that the joy is fake or that joy is the problem. Verse 17 puts the fault in the lack of root.

  16. λαμβάνουσιν

    lambanousin · G2983

    take, receive · v16

    'They take it up' or 'accept it'. A present tense describing what they typically do. It is a real, welcoming acceptance, but the parable judges by what happens later, not by this first moment.

  17. αὐτόν

    auton · G0846

    it · v16

    'It', meaning the word (masculine, agreeing with logos).

  18. οὐκ

    ouk · G3756

    not · v17

    A flat statement of fact. They simply do not have root.

  19. ἔχουσιν

    echousin · G2192

    have · v17

    Present tense: this describes their ongoing condition, not one bad moment. The lack is already there before any trouble comes.

  20. ῥίζαν

    rhizan · G4491

    root · v17

    This picks up the parable directly (v.6, 'because it had no root, it withered'). A root anchors the plant and draws moisture from deep down. Without one, a plant has nothing to live on once the surface dries.

  21. ἐν

    en · G1722

    in · v17

    Places the missing root inside the person. The problem is not the seed or the sower but what lies beneath the surface in the hearer.

  22. ἑαυτοῖς

    heautois · G1438

    themselves · v17

    'In themselves': the word has not gone down into them. Their response stays on the surface.

  23. ἀλλὰ

    alla · G0235

    but · v17

    A strong contrast: not rooted, *but rather* temporary. It sets permanence against impermanence.

  24. πρόσκαιροί

    proskairoi · G4340

    temporary, for a season · v17

    Literally 'for a season', lasting only for a particular stretch of time. Their commitment is real while it lasts, but it lasts only while conditions are favourable.

  25. εἶτα

    eita · G1534

    then, next · v17

    Marks the next stage of the story: first the joyful sprouting (v.16), then the heat. Trouble is expected to follow the word.

  26. γενομένης

    genomenēs · G1096

    having come about · v17

    'When it has come about.' The grammar sets the trouble as the background circumstance against which the falling happens. Matching the parable's 'when the sun rose' (v.6), it is pictured as something that arrives sooner or later.

  27. θλίψεως

    thlipseōs · G2347

    pressure, affliction · v17

    Crushing pressure from outside: hardship, distress, social squeeze. In the parable this is the scorching sun.

  28. ἢ

    ē · G2228

    or · v17

    Puts pressure and persecution side by side as two forms of the same heat.

  29. διωγμοῦ

    diōgmou · G1375

    persecution, pursuit · v17

    Active hostility: being hunted down, harassed or prosecuted. It is more targeted than general hardship.

  30. διὰ

    dia · G1223

    on account of · v17

    Gives the cause. The trouble comes *because of* the message they have received, not just from the ordinary troubles of life.

  31. σκανδαλίζονται

    skandalizontai · G4624

    they are caused to stumble, they fall away · v17

    Passive: they are tripped up, caught as if by a snare, and give up their allegiance. The present tense presents this as what typically happens with such people.

The world behind it

Farming in Galilee. Galilee's hill country sits on limestone and basalt bedrock. Fields often had patches where the rock lay only a few inches under the surface. Ancient sowing was done by broadcasting, scattering seed by hand, so some always fell on paths, rock shelves and thorny margins. The farmer did not do this carelessly. It was simply how sowing worked. Shallow soil over rock heats up fast in spring, so seed there sprouts sooner than in deep soil. When the strong sun of the dry season arrives, the plants wither, because their roots cannot reach moisture (4:6). In the explanation, that "sun" becomes "trouble or persecution because of the word" (4:17).

Sowing as an image for God's people. Jewish writers already used the farmer and his seed as a picture of God and his people. Isaiah compares God's word to rain and seed that does not return empty (Isa 55:10–11). Closest of all, the late first-century apocalypse 4 Ezra says: "For just as the farmer sows many seeds on the ground… yet not all that have been sown will come up in due season… so also those who have been sown in the world will not all be saved" (2 Esdras 8:41). Jesus' hearers knew that sowing does not guarantee a harvest.

Mark's first readers. Most scholars think Mark wrote for communities that knew persecution firsthand, often placed in Rome around the time of Nero (mid-60s AD), though Syria and Galilee are also proposed. For them, "falling away under persecution" was not hypothetical. They had seen people who welcomed the message gladly and then gave way when it became costly.

From the study of Mark 4:16.

Where scholars differ

in v16

Were the rocky-ground hearers true believers who fell away, or people who were never truly converted?

  • Never truly converted: their faith was only temporary.

    Verse 17 says they have 'no root in themselves'. Many Reformed interpreters (following Calvin's 'temporary faith') read the lack of root as the absence of real inner change, while granting that the joy was felt.

  • They truly believed and then fell away.

    Luke 8:13 says they 'believe for a while'. The verbs 'hear' and 'receive' are used of good responses elsewhere. Wesleyan and Arminian interpreters take the passage as a warning that real faith can be abandoned.

  • The parable does not address this later question.

    Many commentators on Mark (e.g. Marcus, France) note that the parable classifies hearers by outcome to warn and encourage listeners. It is not built to settle later debates about salvation and perseverance. Its concern is fruit-bearing over time.

in v16

Does 'rocky' (petrōdēs) hint at Peter (Petros) and the disciples?

  • Yes, a deliberate wordplay.

    Mary Ann Tolbert (Sowing the Gospel, 1989) argues that the rocky ground anticipates the Twelve, especially Peter, 'the Rock'. They respond eagerly, but they 'fall away' (skandalizō, the same verb as 4:17; see 14:27–29) when the 'trouble' of the passion comes.

  • Possible echo at most, not a coded identification.

    Others say petrōdēs is the natural farming word for the image, and Mark's Peter is later restored (16:7). The verbal links to 14:27 are real, but a one-to-one allegory goes beyond what the text signals.

in v17

Does the rocky ground depict genuine believers who later lose their faith, or people whose faith was never real?

  • They really believed and then fell away.

    They 'receive the word with joy' (v.16). Luke 8:13 says outright that they 'believe for a while'. The verb *skandalizō* elsewhere describes real disciples falling away (Mark 14:27). The word *proskairos* says their faith was temporary, not that it was fake.

  • Their response was only on the surface and never amounted to real, saving faith.

    They have 'no root in themselves', so the word never went down into them. Only the good soil 'bears fruit' (v.20). Supporters link this to passages like 1 John 2:19.

  • The question is outside the parable's concern.

    The parable describes kinds of hearing and how they turn out, to encourage the community and call hearers to listen deeply. It does not set out to answer later debates about whether salvation can be lost. Many commentators (e.g. France, Marcus) note that it describes and does not systematize.

in v17

Is the 'rocky ground' a deliberate hint at Peter and the disciples?

  • Yes. Mark is foreshadowing the disciples' failure.

    'Rocky' (*petrōdēs*) sounds like Peter's name, *Petros*. The verb *skandalizō* comes back at 14:27–29 for the disciples and Peter. Peter and others respond with immediate zeal (1:18; 10:28) and then desert Jesus under threat. This is argued especially by Mary Ann Tolbert, *Sowing the Gospel*.

  • Possible, but not demonstrable.

    *Petrōdēs* is the normal word for stony ground, and the farming image fits Galilee without any wordplay. Peter is restored (16:7), which does not fit a soil that simply withers. Many commentators accept a thematic echo but doubt a coded identification.

in v17

Does the explanation (4:14–20) go back to Jesus or to the early church?

  • It is early church application.

    Joachim Jeremias argued that the vocabulary of this verse, 'the word' used absolutely, *thlipsis*, *diōgmos* and *proskairos*, is typical of the apostolic letters and rare in Jesus' other sayings. He also saw the point-by-point allegory as secondary, reflecting the experience of mission churches.

  • It goes back substantially to Jesus' own teaching.

    Explaining a parable point by point is attested in Jewish parable practice and in the prophets (e.g. Ezekiel 17). The opposition and hostility Jesus faced make warnings about falling away likely. Shared vocabulary may reflect the way the saying was handed down, not invention (e.g. Gerhardsson, Payne, France).

Sources
  • BDAG s.v. πετρώδης, εὐθύς, λόγος, χαρά, λαμβάνω, ἀκούω
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. πετρώδης
  • Joel Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Bible), on 4:13–20
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGTC), on 4:5–6, 16–17
  • Robert Guelich, Mark 1–8:26 (WBC)
  • Mary Ann Tolbert, Sowing the Gospel (1989)
  • Joachim Jeremias, The Parables of Jesus
  • 2 Esdras 8:41
  • Gustaf Dalman, Arbeit und Sitte in Palästina (on Palestinian sowing)
  • BDAG s.v. σκανδαλίζω, πρόσκαιρος, θλῖψις, διωγμός, ῥίζα
  • Thayer's Greek Lexicon s.v. σκανδαλίζω
  • G. Stählin, 'σκάνδαλον, σκανδαλίζω', TDNT 7
  • H. Schlier, 'θλίβω, θλῖψις', TDNT 3
  • Louw–Nida, Greek-English Lexicon (domains 31.77–78, 22.2)
  • Joel Marcus, Mark 1–8 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • R. T. France, The Gospel of Mark (NIGNT)
  • Robert Guelich, Mark 1–8:26 (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • Mary Ann Tolbert, Sowing the Gospel
  • Sirach 40:15; Wisdom of Solomon 4:3–4; 4 Maccabees 15:2 (LXX)
  • Vulgate, Mark 4:17

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).