Numbers Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Numbers 9:9–14

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

9Then the LORD said to Moses, 10“Tell the Israelites: ‘When any one of you or your descendants is unclean because of a dead body, or is away on a journey, he may still observe the Passover to the LORD. 11Such people are to observe it at twilight on the fourteenth day of the second month. They are to eat the lamb, together with unleavened bread and bitter herbs; 12they may not leave any of it until morning or break any of its bones. They must observe the Passover according to all its statutes. 13But if a man who is ceremonially clean and is not on a journey still fails to observe the Passover, he must be cut off from his people, because he did not present the LORD’s offering at its appointed time. That man will bear the consequences of his sin. 14If a foreigner dwelling among you wants to observe the Passover to the LORD, he is to do so according to the Passover statute and its ordinances. You are to apply the same statute to both the foreigner and the native of the land.’”

What the first hearers heard

For Israelites, Passover was the night that made them a people: the night YHWH spared their houses and brought them out of Egypt. Being shut out of it was serious. The men in v. 7 speak of being "diminished" or "held back" from YHWH's offering among the community.

This ruling told them three things:

  • Holiness stays intact. Impurity still bars a person from the sacrifice in the first month, and no shortcut is offered.
  • Being shut out through no fault of one's own is not final. A family member who buried the dead, or a traveller far from the altar, gets a full Passover a month later, with the same lamb, unleavened bread and bitter herbs (v. 11).
  • It is a firm obligation, not a loophole. Verse 13 goes on: anyone who was pure and not travelling but skipped Passover anyway is to be "cut off". The second date is for those who could not, not for those who would not.

Because the ruling covers "your generations", it became standing law. Later Israel did put it into practice (2 Chr 30).

From the study of Numbers 9:10.

Verse by verse

  1. 9Then the LORD said to Moses,

    Not studied yet. Study this verse

  2. 10“Tell the Israelites: ‘When any one of you or your descendants is unclean because of a dead body, or is away on a journey, he may still observe the Passover to the LORD.

    YHWH tells Moses to announce this to the whole family of Israel: any Israelite at all, now or in any later generation, who at Passover time is ritually impure because he has been in contact with a dead human body, or who is on a road too far away to reach the sanctuary on the appointed day, shall still perform the Passover sacrifice to YHWH.

    Each part carries weight. Impurity from a corpse was usually picked up doing something right, such as preparing or burying a relative. It was no moral failing, but it made a person unfit to eat holy sacrificial meat. The word for the corpse is nefesh, the ordinary word for a living person, used here for that person after death. "Make a Passover" means slaughtering, roasting and eating the lamb or kid, not just remembering a date. The main verb has the force of an instruction, not just permission: such a person is to do it. The next verse says when: a month later, on the 14th of the second month, with all the original rules.

    The ruling holds two things together. Holiness is not relaxed, since the impure still may not eat in the first month. And no faithful Israelite is to be shut out of the night that made Israel a people.

    Full study →
  3. 11Such people are to observe it at twilight on the fourteenth day of the second month. They are to eat the lamb, together with unleavened bread and bitter herbs;

    One month later, on the same day and at the same hour, with nothing left out.

    The verse answers a real problem. Some men were ritually unclean because they had touched a dead body (a seven-day state, Num 19), and others were too far away to come. They had missed the one meal that made Israel Israel. God's ruling is that they get a second chance, but not a smaller version of the meal:

    In the second month, on the fourteenth day (the full-moon night, one moon after the original Passover), in the window "between the two evenings" (as the sun goes down toward dark, the same hour set for the first Passover), they are to perform the Passover: slaughter, roast and hold the meal themselves. They are to eat the Passover animal (a young sheep or goat) together with flat loaves baked without leaven and with bitter plants.

    Each detail repeats the original rite (Exod 12:6–8). The date is moved by exactly one moon and nothing else changes. Verse 12 adds that none of the meat may be left until morning, no bone may be broken, and every statute applies. So the provision is generous about who may take part: the unclean and the traveller are not shut out of Israel's founding meal for good. It does not bend on what the meal is. "Bitter things" (not literally "herbs") and the hurried flatbread come with it. Later Jewish readers heard in them the bitterness of slavery (Exod 1:14) and the haste of the night the people left Egypt.

    Full study →
  4. 12they may not leave any of it until morning or break any of its bones. They must observe the Passover according to all its statutes.

    "Not one scrap of it may be left over until daybreak, and not a single bone in it may they crack. They are to perform it, the Passover, in line with the whole of its fixed prescription."

    This verse finishes God's answer to men who could not keep the Passover on the right date. They were ritually unclean from contact with a dead body, or they were travelling far away. They get a second chance one month later (vv. 6–11). Verse 11 has just said they eat "it" (the Passover lamb) with unleavened bread and bitter herbs. Verse 12 adds that everything else about the original rite applies too:

    • No leftovers. The meat belongs to one night. Whatever is not eaten by morning is not saved for breakfast. Exodus 12:10 says it is burned. The holy meal cannot become ordinary food.
    • No broken bones. The lamb has been roasted whole, head, legs and inner parts (Exod 12:9), and it is to stay whole as it is eaten. No one cracks a bone for marrow or splits the carcass apart, as people normally did with meat.
    • The whole statute. "Passover" in Hebrew names both the feast and the animal. Both are to be handled exactly as prescribed, as one unbroken set of procedure. The late Passover is not second-rate. It is the same Passover a month later.
    Full study →
  5. 13But if a man who is ceremonially clean and is not on a journey still fails to observe the Passover, he must be cut off from his people, because he did not present the LORD’s offering at its appointed time. That man will bear the consequences of his sin.

    "But as for the man who is ritually fit to come near, and who is not away on the road, and who still holds back and does not keep the Passover: that person, that life, will be cut off from his kin. He did not bring near YHWH's bringing-near, the Passover lamb that belongs to the LORD, at the time the LORD fixed for it. He will carry his own sin, that man."

    The verse comes straight after God's generous ruling in verses 6–12. Anyone who could not keep Passover because of a corpse impurity or a distant journey may keep it a month later. The text then removes every excuse, one at a time: he is clean (no ritual obstacle), he is not on the road (no distance obstacle), and still he holds back. The verb points to a decision, not an accident.

    The penalty uses Israel's gravest formula, karet, being "cut off". It falls on the man's nefesh, his whole living self, and removes him from his kin, the family line he belongs to. That is the reverse of being "gathered to one's people" at an honourable death.

    The reason given is a play on words. Qorban, "offering", literally means "a bringing-near", and he "did not bring near" what is YHWH's own. The man who would not come near is put at a distance. The last line leaves him holding the load: no sacrifice, priest or second date will carry this sin for him. The verse begins and ends with "the man", underlining that this is personal accountability.

    Full study →
  6. 14If a foreigner dwelling among you wants to observe the Passover to the LORD, he is to do so according to the Passover statute and its ordinances. You are to apply the same statute to both the foreigner and the native of the land.’”

    "Now suppose an outsider has settled among you, someone of another people who has made his home in your camp and has no Israelite clan or land of his own, and he wants to make the Passover to YHWH: to slaughter, roast and eat the Passover animal as an offering to Israel's God. Then he must do it exactly according to the Passover's fixed decree and its proper procedure, just as you do. There is no adjusted version for him (and, as Exodus 12:48 has already said, that includes circumcising the males of his household first). One fixed statute governs you all: the resident outsider and the one whose roots are sunk in the land alike."

    The verse pulls in two directions at once. It opens the door: the outsider is not barred from Israel's most identity-defining meal. It also keeps the rite intact: he enters on Israel's terms, not his own. The repeated word "statute" (a decree 'engraved' and fixed) and the closing "one" make the point. Coming right after verses 6–13, where Israelites who were unclean or travelling were given a second date a month later, the message is that Israelites can receive timing adjustments, but neither Israelite nor outsider gets a different rite.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v10

    unclean

    ṭāmēʾ

    What we hear
    Dirty, or morally defiled and sinful.
    What they heard
    Ritually impure: temporarily unfit to approach holy things or eat sacred food. This impurity came from touching a corpse, often while doing the duty of burying family. It carried no guilt and was removed by purification.
  • in v10

    observe / keep the Passover

    ʿāśāh pesaḥ

    What we hear
    Celebrate a holiday or take part in a commemorative meal such as a seder.
    What they heard
    Carry out the Passover sacrifice: slaughter the lamb or kid at twilight, then roast and eat it as holy food (v. 11; Exod 12).
  • in v11

    bitter herbs

    merorim

    What we hear
    A specific herb, often pictured as horseradish from the modern Seder plate.
    What they heard
    'Bitter things': unnamed bitter plants, most likely wild leafy greens such as lettuce, endive or chicory types. 'Herbs' is a translator's addition.
  • in v11

    the lamb

    (implied pesaḥ; seh)

    What we hear
    Strictly a young sheep.
    What they heard
    The Passover animal was a seh, a young animal from the flock, either a sheep or a goat (Exod 12:5). The Hebrew of this verse just says 'it.'
  • in v11

    at even / at evening

    bein ha'arbayim

    What we hear
    In the evening or at night, after dark.
    What they heard
    'Between the two evenings': a set ritual window as the day ended. Ancient readers took it as either late afternoon up to sunset, or sunset to full dark. The slaughter happened then and the meal followed after nightfall.
  • in v12

    the Passover … keep it / observe it

    ha-pesach … ya'asu oto

    What we hear
    A holiday on the calendar that one 'observes' or 'celebrates', like a date one marks.
    What they heard
    *Pesach* names the sacrificial animal as well as the feast. 'Doing the Passover' is a hands-on act: slaughtering, roasting and eating the lamb under set rules. The 'it' with unbroken bones is the animal.
  • in v12

    statute / ordinances

    chuqqah

    What we hear
    A piece of legislation or legal code, a rule enforced by a court.
    What they heard
    A fixed, 'engraved' prescription for how a rite is performed, the set procedure of worship. The singular here presents the Passover rules as one whole.
  • in v13

    that same soul (KJV)

    hanefesh hahiv

    What we hear
    The immaterial, eternal soul, as if the penalty were about the soul's fate after death.
    What they heard
    That living person, that life: the whole embodied individual.
  • in v13

    clean

    tahor

    What we hear
    Physically washed, or morally innocent.
    What they heard
    Ritually fit to approach holy things; free of a status such as corpse impurity, which was contagious but not sinful.
  • in v13

    bear his sin

    chet'o yissa

    What we hear
    Feel guilty; carry an emotional burden.
    What they heard
    Remain legally liable and suffer the penalty, with no ritual provided to remove it.
  • in v13

    fails (BSB, WEB)

    chadal

    What we hear
    An accidental lapse or inability.
    What they heard
    Leaves off, holds back, refrains: a deliberate omission once every excuse has been removed.
  • in v14

    stranger (KJV)

    ger

    What we hear
    Someone I don't know; an unfamiliar person.
    What they heard
    A settled outsider: a person of foreign origin who lives long-term inside Israel's community, without clan or land rights.
  • in v14

    foreigner (BSB, WEB)

    ger

    What we hear
    A citizen of another country, a visitor or tourist who belongs elsewhere.
    What they heard
    Someone who has *left* his own people and settled here. Hebrew has a different word (*nokhri*) for the foreigner who keeps his foreign identity, and Exodus 12:43 bars that kind of foreigner from the Passover.
  • in v14

    observe / keep / celebrate the Passover

    'asah pesach

    What we hear
    Mark a holiday; hold a commemorative meal or service.
    What they heard
    'Make a passover': slaughter, roast and eat a sacrificial animal offered to YHWH (v. 13 calls it 'the offering of YHWH').
Every word
  1. דַּבֵּ֛ר

    dabber · H1696G

    speak · v10

    A command to Moses: 'Speak!' YHWH answers the question Moses brought him (vv. 6–8), and Moses now has to announce the ruling publicly as law.

  2. אֶל־

    ʾel · H0413

    to, toward · v10

    Marks who receives the message: the whole people, not only the men who asked.

  3. בְּנֵ֥י

    bənê · H1121G

    sons of, descendants of · v10

    'Sons of Israel' is the standard name for the people as one family descended from Jacob. It means the whole community, not only males.

  4. יִשְׂרָאֵ֖ל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v10

    The covenant people camped at Sinai, named after their ancestor Jacob-Israel.

  5. לֵאמֹ֑ר

    lēʾmōr · H0559

    saying · v10

    The usual formula that introduces quoted speech, like opening quotation marks. What follows is the ruling word for word.

  6. אִ֣ישׁ

    ʾîš · H0376G

    man, person · v10, v13

    First of a doubled word. Hebrew law uses the masculine 'man' as its default for a legal person.

  7. כִּי־

    kî · H3588A

    if, when · v10, v13, v14

    Opens a case-law condition: 'if (or when) this happens…'. It is the standard opening of a legal case in Torah.

  8. יִהְיֶֽה־

    yihyeh · H1961

    he will be · v10, v13, v14

    'Is / happens to be.' It describes a situation someone is in at Passover time, not a deliberate act.

  9. טָמֵ֣א

    ṭāmēʾ · H2931

    unclean, impure · v10

    In a state of ritual impurity that bars a person from holy things and holy food. It is a status, not a moral judgment (see study).

  10. לָנֶ֡פֶשׁ

    lannepeš · H5315M

    corpse, dead person · v10, v13

    'By a nefesh', meaning a dead human body. The usual word for a living being or 'person' is used here, by a recognised idiom, for a person who has died.

  11. אוֹ֩

    ʾô · H0176A

    or · v10

    Adds a second, separate reason for missing Passover: being away.

  12. בְדֶ֨רֶךְ

    bəderek · H1870L

    road, way, journey · v10, v13

    'On a road', meaning travelling and away from the place where the sacrifice is offered.

  13. רְחֹקָ֜הׄ

    rəḥōqāh · H7350

    far, distant · v10

    'Distant.' The journey takes the person too far away to reach the sanctuary on the right day. A scribal dot sits over its last letter (see textual notes).

  14. לָכֶ֗ם

    lākem · H9036

    to/of you · v10, v14

    'Of you (plural).' It goes with 'any man': any man of you. Its odd place in the sentence, after 'distant journey', is why YLT puts this part in parentheses.

  15. לְדֹרֹ֣תֵיכֶ֔ם

    lədōrōtêkem · H1755

    generations · v10

    'Of your generations': your descendants down the line. This marks the ruling as permanent law and not a one-time exception for the men at Sinai.

  16. וְעָ֥שָׂה

    wəʿāśāh · H6213A

    do, make, perform · v10, v11, v12, v13, v14

    'Then he shall make/perform': the main clause of the ruling. The verb form carries the force of a command. 'Make a Passover' is the standard idiom for carrying out the Passover sacrifice and meal.

  17. פֶ֖סַח

    pesaḥ · H6453

    Passover (sacrifice) · v10, v12, v13, v14

    The Passover offering itself, the lamb or kid slaughtered at twilight and eaten that night (v. 11). It is not just a date on the calendar.

  18. לַיהוָֽה׃

    laYHWH · H3068G

    to YHWH (the LORD) · v10, v13, v14

    'To YHWH.' The Passover is offered to Israel's God by name. It is his sacrifice, and taking part in it means belonging to his people.

  19. בַּחֹ֨דֶשׁ

    baḥodesh · H2320G

    in the month · v11

    Ḥodesh comes from the word for 'new' and first meant the new moon. A month began when the new crescent appeared, so the date is set by the moon.

  20. הַשֵּׁנִ֜י

    hashsheni · H8145

    the second · v11

    The second month of the religious year, which began in spring with the month of the Exodus (Exod 12:2). It falls exactly one month after the normal Passover.

  21. בְּאַרְבָּעָ֨ה

    be'arba'ah · H0702

    on four- · v11

    First half of 'fourteen.' The day is the same as the regular Passover (9:3), only a month later. Nothing changes but the month.

  22. עָשָׂ֥ר

    'asar · H6240

    -teen · v11

    The 'ten' part of a compound number, 'four-ten' = fourteen. In a lunar month the fourteenth day is about full moon, so the meal took place under a bright moon.

  23. י֛וֹם

    yom · H3117G

    day · v11

    Day, here the calendar date: 'on the fourteenth day.'

  24. בֵּ֥ין

    bein · H0996G

    between · v11

    'Between,' opening the fixed time phrase 'between the two evenings.'

  25. הָעַרְבַּ֖יִם

    ha'arbayim · H6153

    the (two) evenings · v11

    A 'dual' form, meaning a pair: 'the two evenings.' Together with 'between' it names the exact time the Passover animal was slaughtered, somewhere between the sun starting to go down and full dark. The exact span was argued over in ancient times.

  26. אֹת֑וֹ

    oto · H0853

    [object marker] + it · v11, v12

    'It' (masculine) points back to the pesaḥ of 9:10. The word means both the Passover festival and the Passover animal itself.

  27. עַל־

    'al · H5921A

    upon, with · v11

    Literally 'upon.' Here it means 'along with,' as in Exodus 12:8. The roast meat is eaten together with the bread and the bitter plants.

  28. מַצּ֥וֹת

    matsot · H4682

    unleavened breads · v11

    Plural: flat loaves or cakes baked without any rising agent. In Exodus they recall a departure too hurried for dough to rise (Exod 12:39), and Deuteronomy calls them 'bread of affliction' (Deut 16:3).

  29. וּמְרֹרִ֖ים

    umerorim · H4844

    and bitter things · v11

    Literally 'bitter things.' The word 'herbs' is not in the Hebrew. These were bitter plants, most likely wild leafy greens. The text does not say which plants.

  30. יֹאכְלֻֽהוּ׃

    yokheluhu · H0398

    they shall eat it · v11

    'They shall eat it,' meaning the Passover animal. Eating the meal is the centre of the rite. Without the meal no Passover has been kept.

  31. לֹֽא־

    lo · H3808

    not · v12, v13

    The flat, permanent 'not' of Hebrew law. Put before a future-form verb it makes a standing ban, 'they shall never…', not a one-time request.

  32. יַשְׁאִ֤ירוּ

    yash'iru · H7604

    to remain; (causative) to leave over · v12

    'They shall leave over.' The causative form means letting something remain as leftovers. The same root gives the word for a 'remnant'. Nothing of the sacrificial animal may outlast the night.

  33. מִמֶּ֙נּוּ֙

    mimmennu · H4480A

    from (with 'him/it') · v12

    'From it', meaning 'any part of it'. The 'it' is the Passover animal that verse 11 says they are to eat.

  34. עַד־

    ad · H5704

    until, as far as · v12

    Marks the time limit: the meal is bounded by the night.

  35. בֹּ֔קֶר

    boqer · H1242

    morning, daybreak · v12

    Daybreak ends the Passover night. In the Exodus story it is the morning after the night of deliverance (Exod 12:22), and the time by which any remains must already have been burned (Exod 12:10).

  36. וְעֶ֖צֶם

    ve'etsem · H6106G

    and a bone · v12

    'And a bone…' It comes first in its clause for emphasis: 'a bone, they shall not break.' A single bone stands for any bone at all.

  37. יִשְׁבְּרוּ־

    yishberu · H7665

    to break, shatter · v12

    'They shall break.' This is the ordinary word for snapping or smashing something hard. Here it means cracking the lamb's bones, for example to get at the marrow or to cut up the carcass.

  38. ב֑וֹ

    vo · H9033

    in it, of it · v12

    'In it': no bone in the animal's body is to be broken. The supplied data gives a placeholder lemma ('Os3m'). The form is simply the preposition 'in' with the pronoun 'it'.

  39. כְּכָל־

    kekhol · H3605

    according to all · v12

    'In line with all of…' It stresses completeness: the make-up Passover keeps the whole rite, not a cut-down version.

  40. חֻקַּ֥ת

    chuqqat · H2708

    statute, fixed prescription · v12, v14

    'The statute of.' The Hebrew is singular: the Passover regulation taken as one whole set of prescribed procedure (as in Exod 12:43, 'This is the statute of the Passover').

  41. אֲשֶׁר־

    asher · H0834

    who, which · v13

    Introduces the conditions that define this person: clean, not travelling, and still refraining.

  42. הוּא

    hu · H1931

    he · v13

    Points back to the man: 'who, he, is clean'. It stresses that the condition really belongs to him.

  43. טָהוֹר

    tahor · H2889

    clean, pure · v13

    Ritually fit to approach holy things, as opposed to the corpse impurity of verses 6–10. It means he has no legitimate obstacle. It says nothing about hygiene or moral goodness.

  44. וְחָדַל

    vechadal · H2308

    and he ceased/refrained · v13

    'And he holds back / leaves off.' The verb means stopping or choosing not to act, not forgetting by accident. With both excuses ruled out, what is left is deliberate neglect.

  45. וְנִכְרְתָה

    venikhretah · H3772

    and she shall be cut off · v13

    'Then shall be cut off.' The verb is passive, and in the Torah God is often the hidden agent (compare Leviticus 20:3–6, 'I will cut him off'). It is a fixed legal formula for the gravest penalty, the one called karet. It is feminine because it agrees with nefesh.

  46. מֵעַמֶּיהָ

    me'ammeyha · H5971

    from her kinspeople · v13

    'From her kin', plural: the clan and family line, not only 'the nation'. It is the reverse of the phrase for an honourable death, being 'gathered to one's kin' (Genesis 25:8).

  47. קָרְבַּן

    qorban · H7133

    offering (of) · v13

    Literally 'a bringing-near'. Here it is the Passover animal, called 'YHWH's offering' because it belongs to him.

  48. הִקְרִיב

    hiqriv · H7126

    he brought near · v13

    'He did not bring near.' This comes from the same root as qorban, so the offence is literally failing to 'bring near the bringing-near'. The man kept himself and his offering away from God.

  49. בְּמֹעֲדוֹ

    bemo'ado · H4150

    at its appointed time · v13

    'At its fixed time': the 14th of the first month at twilight (verses 2–3). This is the same word used in verses 2, 3 and 7. God sets the time, not the worshipper.

  50. חֶטְאוֹ

    chet'o · H2399

    his sin · v13

    His failure or offence. In this phrase it covers both the wrong and the liability that comes with it.

  51. יִשָּׂא

    yissa · H5375

    he will carry/bear · v13

    'He will carry.' The guilt stays on him like a load, and no sacrifice is provided to lift it. This is an idiom for being liable to punishment.

  52. יָג֨וּר

    yagur · H1481A

    to sojourn, reside as an outsider · v14

    To live somewhere as a long-term resident without the native's kinship and land rights. The verb describes ongoing residence, not a passing visit.

  53. אִתְּכֶ֜ם

    ittekhem · H0854

    with · v14

    'With you' (plural): living alongside Israel, in its camp and later its towns, attached to its households.

  54. גֵּ֗ר

    ger · H1616

    sojourner, resident alien · v14

    A person of non-Israelite origin who has settled among Israel. He is not a tourist or a passing foreigner, but he does not belong to an Israelite clan or hold ancestral land.

  55. וּכְמִשְׁפָּט֖וֹ

    ukhemishpato · H4941G

    judgment; rule, prescribed manner · v14

    'And according to its rule/procedure': the proper way the rite is done. In this verse it is not a court verdict. KJV's 'the manner thereof' catches the sense well.

  56. כֵּ֣ן

    ken · H3651C

    so, thus · v14

    'Just so', pointing back: exactly in that way and no other.

  57. אַחַת֙

    achat · H0259

    one · v14

    'One', meaning a single, shared rule. The stress falls on there being no separate standard.

  58. וּלְאֶזְרַ֥ח

    ul'ezrach · H0249

    native, native-born · v14

    …and for the native: the full Israelite whose family roots are in the land, a word also used of a tree growing in its own soil.

  59. הָאָֽרֶץ׃

    ha'arets · H0776G

    land, earth · v14

    'The land', meaning the promised land. Spoken in the wilderness, the phrase looks ahead to settled life in Canaan.

The world behind it

The case behind the law (Num 9:6–8). In the second year after the Exodus, the first Passover at Sinai came around. Some men were impure from a corpse and so could not take part. They came to Moses and Aaron and asked, "Why should we be held back from presenting YHWH's offering at its appointed time among the Israelites?" Moses had no ruling and waited for YHWH's answer. This verse is that answer. Torah has a few other cases like this, where a real problem is brought to Moses and the answer becomes law: the blasphemer (Lev 24), the man gathering wood on the Sabbath (Num 15), and the daughters of Zelophehad (Num 27).

Why impurity mattered. The Passover animal was a sacrifice, and its meat was holy food. Priestly law said that anyone who ate sacrificial meat while impure would be "cut off" (Lev 7:20–21). Contact with a human corpse was the strongest kind of impurity. It lasted seven days and needed the red-heifer purification water (Num 19:11–22). Someone who buried a relative a few days before the 14th simply could not become pure in time.

Why distance mattered. In the wilderness everyone camped around the Tabernacle. Deuteronomy, though, requires the Passover to be offered only "at the place YHWH will choose" (Deut 16:5–6). Once Israel lived across the land, someone travelling or living far away could miss the day. The law expects this.

Later use. Hezekiah held a national Passover in the second month because the priests were not consecrated and the people had not gathered in time (2 Chr 30:2–3). Later Jewish tradition calls the make-up date Pesach Sheni, "Second Passover" (Mishnah Pesachim 9). In the first century the purity rule was still in force: pilgrims arrived early to purify themselves (John 11:55), and leaders avoided defilement so they could eat the Passover (John 18:28).

From the study of Numbers 9:10.

Where scholars differ

in v10

What do the dots over the final letter of 'distant' mean?

  • A rabbinic hint that 'distant' is meant narrowly: any distance that keeps a person from the Temple court at the time of slaughter.

    Mishnah Pesachim 9:2 (Rabbi Yose), developing a dispute between Rabbi Akiva (Modi'in and beyond) and Rabbi Eliezer (from the threshold of the court outward). Sifre Numbers 69.

  • A scribal mark from the copying tradition flagging a letter as doubtful or to be deleted, later read as a hint by the rabbis.

    Similar to the critical signs used by Alexandrian Greek scholars (Saul Lieberman, Hellenism in Jewish Palestine). Dots of this kind mark doubtful letters in the Dead Sea Scrolls. Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, discusses the ten puncta extraordinaria in the Torah.

in v10

Why does a law given at Sinai mention people too far away to attend?

  • The law looks ahead: it is written for the later life in the land, where the whole people will not be camped around the sanctuary.

    'Or of your generations' explicitly extends the ruling beyond Sinai, and Deut 16:5–6 expects worship at one central place.

  • The travel clause reflects a later setting, when worship was centralised in Jerusalem, and was added to an older ruling about corpse impurity.

    The narrative in vv. 6–8 raises only impurity, and the journey condition has no matching case in the story. Critical commentators such as Baruch Levine (Anchor Yale Numbers 1–20) and Jacob Milgrom (JPS Numbers) discuss the clause in light of centralisation.

in v11

When exactly is 'between the two evenings'?

  • From the sun's afternoon decline until sunset (the Pharisee and rabbinic view).

    Mishnah Pesachim 5:1 puts the slaughter in the afternoon. Josephus (War 6.423) gives the ninth to eleventh hour (about 3–5 p.m.) for the Passover slaughter in his day. This window made it practical to slaughter huge numbers of animals at the Temple.

  • From sunset until full darkness (the Samaritan and Karaite view).

    Deuteronomy 16:6 places the Passover sacrifice 'in the evening, at the going down of the sun.' The 'two evenings' would then be sunset and nightfall. Some modern scholars think this was the older practice.

in v11

Did the second-month Passover include the seven-day Festival of Unleavened Bread?

  • No. It was a one-day make-up of the Passover meal only.

    Numbers 9:10–12 mentions only the pesaḥ, its meal and its statutes. It says nothing about seven days or removing leaven. Mishnah Pesachim 9:3 rules that leaven may stay in the house during the second Passover and that it lasts one day.

  • In some historical cases a full festival was held in the second month.

    In Hezekiah's second-month Passover, the people also kept the Festival of Unleavened Bread for seven days and then extended it (2 Chr 30:13, 21–23). That was a national postponement, a different situation from the individual case in Numbers 9.

in v12

Why must no bone of the Passover animal be broken?

  • Wholeness and unity: the animal stays whole as the household or community that eats it is one.

    Exod 12:9 requires roasting whole, and 12:46 requires eating in one house and taking nothing outside. Together these rules stress one undivided animal for one undivided group.

  • Haste and the dignity of free people: no time or need to crack bones for marrow like the poor.

    The Exodus meal is eaten 'in haste' (Exod 12:11). Medieval Jewish explanation (e.g., *Sefer ha-Chinukh*) holds that free people do not gnaw and crack bones like the destitute.

  • A sign of protection for Israel itself.

    Jubilees 49:13: 'no bone of the children of Israel shall be crushed.' It is an early interpretation, though not stated in the Torah.

  • No reason is given, and any explanation is inference.

    Exodus and Numbers state the rule without explaining it. Proposals drawn from customs elsewhere (such as keeping a sacrificed animal's bones intact) have no direct Israelite evidence.

in v12

When John 19:36 says 'Not a bone of him shall be broken', which scripture is in view?

  • The Passover lamb laws (Exod 12:46; Num 9:12).

    The wording 'bone … of him' matches. John's Gospel times Jesus' death to the slaughter of the Passover lambs (John 19:14) and calls him 'the Lamb of God' (1:29). The hyssop in 19:29 echoes Exod 12:22.

  • The righteous sufferer of Psalm 34:20.

    John's passive verb 'shall be broken' matches LXX Ps 33:21 exactly, and the psalm is about God protecting a righteous person.

  • Both, deliberately combined.

    John's wording matches neither source exactly and mixes features of each. Many commentators see a blended allusion.

in v13

What does 'cut off' (karet) mean: God's punishment, community expulsion, or execution?

  • A penalty carried out by God: premature death and/or the ending of one's family line (the majority view in rabbinic tradition and among many modern scholars, e.g. Milgrom, Wold).

    God says 'I will cut him off' (Leviticus 17:10; 20:3, 5, 6). Leviticus 20:2–5 has the community stone the offender *and* God cut him off, which makes them two separate actions. Karet often applies to private or hidden offences that a human court could not prosecute. Rabbinic sources (b. Mo'ed Qatan 28a, Sifra) take it as death 'at the hands of heaven'. The Septuagint renders it 'utterly destroyed'.

  • Expulsion or excommunication from the covenant community, carried out by humans.

    'From his people / from the assembly' (Exodus 12:19; Numbers 19:20) sounds spatial and social. Ezra 10:8 describes leaders separating people from the assembly as a sanction. In Latin, *exterminare* also means 'banish'.

  • A form of the death penalty carried out by the community.

    Exodus 31:14 places 'shall surely be put to death' alongside 'shall be cut off' for breaking the Sabbath. Some older interpreters read the two as equivalent. Against this, Leviticus 20 keeps them distinct, and no execution procedure is ever attached to karet.

  • Exclusion from the afterlife or the 'world to come' (some medieval Jewish interpreters, e.g. Maimonides).

    This draws on the contrast with being 'gathered to one's kin' and on later belief in resurrection. It goes beyond what the Torah itself states.

in v13

Does the penalty apply to someone who skipped the first Passover on purpose but kept the second one?

  • Yes: the offence was committed on the first date, so karet still applies (one position in b. Pesachim 93a).

    The verse grounds the penalty in not offering 'at its appointed time', and the second date was given only to the unclean and the distant.

  • No: karet applies only if he misses both dates (another position in the same passage).

    The second Passover is a real opportunity to fulfil the command. The verse sits directly after the second-date ruling, so the final omission is what counts.

in v14

Was taking part in the Passover optional or obligatory for the ger?

  • Optional: the ger may join if he chooses, but must then follow the full rite.

    The grammar 'if he settles… and he would make a passover' puts his taking part inside the condition. Exodus 12:48 frames it as 'if a ger… wants to make the Passover'. Milgrom (Numbers, JPS) argues the ger was generally bound by Israel's prohibitions (for example, against defiling the land or eating leaven in the land), but not by commands to perform rites, such as the Passover sacrifice.

  • In later Jewish reading, the ger is a full convert, so taking part is part of covenant duty; the verse is about how and when.

    Rabbinic tradition reads *ger* here as a convert (*ger tsedeq*). Rashi explains the verse as ruling out the idea that a new convert must bring a Passover offering immediately: he does so at the proper season with everyone else, by the same rule. The Septuagint's *prosēlytos* points the same way.

in v14

How far does 'one statute for the ger and the native' reach?

  • Here it is limited to the Passover rite.

    The immediate subject is the Passover (the 'statute of the Passover', 'its rule'). Elsewhere the law treats the ger differently in some areas: for example, Deuteronomy 14:21 allows giving an animal that died naturally to the ger.

  • It expresses a broader legal principle of equal standing in cultic and criminal law.

    The same formula covers sacrifice and atonement (Numbers 15:15–16, 29–30), blasphemy and homicide (Leviticus 24:16, 22), and purity and the Day of Atonement (Leviticus 16:29; 17:15). Scholars such as Van Houten see a widening legal equality for the ger in the priestly laws.

Sources
  • BDB s.v. טָמֵא, נֶפֶשׁ, פֶּסַח, דּוֹר
  • HALOT s.v. נֶפֶשׁ (sense 'dead person, corpse'), טָמֵא, פֶּסַח
  • Mishnah Pesachim 9:1–2
  • Sifre Numbers 69
  • Avot de-Rabbi Natan (A) 34, the ten dotted passages
  • Jacob Milgrom, The JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990), on 9:1–14
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 1–16 (Anchor Bible), on impurity versus sin
  • Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Yale Bible)
  • Emanuel Tov, Textual Criticism of the Hebrew Bible, on the puncta extraordinaria
  • Saul Lieberman, Hellenism in Jewish Palestine, on scribal critical signs
  • 2 Chronicles 30; John 11:55; 18:28
  • Temple Scroll (11Q19) cols. 49–50, on corpse impurity
  • BDB s.v. עֶרֶב, מָרֹר, מַצָּה, עָשָׂה
  • HALOT s.v. בֵּין הָעַרְבַּיִם; מְרֹרִים
  • Mishnah Pesachim 2:6; 5:1; 9:1–3; 10:5
  • Josephus, Jewish War 6.423
  • Jubilees 49
  • Elephantine 'Passover Papyrus' (TAD A4.1)
  • Jacob Milgrom, JPS Torah Commentary: Numbers (1990), on 9:1–14
  • Baruch A. Levine, Numbers 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • Timothy R. Ashley, The Book of Numbers (NICOT)
  • BDB s.v. שָׁאַר, עֶצֶם, שָׁבַר, חֻקָּה, פֶּסַח
  • HALOT s.v. חֻקָּה; פסח
  • Exodus 12:9–11, 43–46; Leviticus 22:30; Psalm 34:20; 2 Chronicles 30
  • Septuagint, Numbers 9:12; Exodus 12:46; Psalm 33:21 (LXX)
  • Jubilees 49:13
  • Mishnah Pesachim 7:11; 9:3
  • Sefer ha-Chinukh, commandment on not breaking a bone of the Passover offering
  • John 19:31–37
  • BDB and HALOT s.v. כרת, נֶפֶשׁ, טָהוֹר, חדל, קׇרְבָּן, מוֹעֵד, חֵטְא, נשׂא
  • Jacob Milgrom, *Numbers* (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990), on 9:1–14 and Excursus on karet
  • Jacob Milgrom, *Leviticus 1–16* (Anchor Bible), on karet and purity
  • Donald J. Wold, 'The Kareth Penalty in P: Rationale and Cases', SBL Seminar Papers 1979
  • Mishnah Keritot 1:1; Mishnah Pesachim 9:1–4; Babylonian Talmud Pesachim 93a; Mo'ed Qatan 28a
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Numbers 9:13; Vulgate Numbers 9:13
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Numbers 9
  • 2 Chronicles 30 (Hezekiah's second-month Passover)
  • BDB s.v. גּוּר, גֵּר, חֻקָּה, מִשְׁפָּט
  • HALOT s.v. אֶזְרָח, גֵּר, פֶּסַח
  • Jacob Milgrom, Numbers (JPS Torah Commentary, 1990), on 9:14 and Excursus on the ger
  • Jacob Milgrom, Leviticus 17–22 (Anchor Bible), on the ger and prohibitive vs. performative commandments
  • Christiana van Houten, The Alien in Israelite Law (JSOTSup 107)
  • Rashi on Numbers 9:14
  • Septuagint, Numbers 9:14 (Rahlfs/Göttingen)
  • Vulgate, Numbers 9:14
  • Exodus 12:43–49 (parallel legislation)

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).

1 of these verses not studied yet; their meaning appears here once they are.