Romans Chapter 2 Read as one passage
Romans 2:26–29
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
26If a man who is not circumcised keeps the requirements of the law, will not his uncircumcision be regarded as circumcision? 27The one who is physically uncircumcised yet keeps the law will condemn you who, even though you have the written code and circumcision, are a lawbreaker. 28A man is not a Jew because he is one outwardly, nor is circumcision only outward and physical. 29No, a man is a Jew because he is one inwardly, and circumcision is a matter of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the written code. Such a man’s praise does not come from men, but from God.
What the first hearers heard
To a Jewish hearer steeped in Genesis 17 and the memory of the Maccabean martyrs, this was a provocation framed as a question nobody could fairly answer "no". Paul has argued that God judges impartially (2:6–11) and that the law's value lies in doing it (2:13, 25). Grant that, and you must also grant that an uncircumcised man who truly keeps God's commands is counted, in God's reckoning, as one of the covenant people.
For Gentile hearers in Rome, many of whom had been called "the foreskin" and kept at arm's length in synagogue life, the verse took the insulting label and declared that it did not decide their standing before God.
The verse did several jobs:
- It undercut confidence in the covenant sign alone. Circumcision does not guarantee a favourable verdict without faithfulness (v.25).
- It moved covenant identity into God's accounting ("will be reckoned"), and so away from human ritual records.
- It set up v.27, where the law-keeping uncircumcised will "judge" the circumcised law-breaker. It also set up v.29, which defines the true "Jew" and true "circumcision" as inward, "by the Spirit, not the letter", echoing Ezekiel 36:26–27, where God promises his Spirit so that his people will keep his dikaiōmata.
- It anticipated Romans 4, where Abraham is "reckoned" righteous while still uncircumcised and so becomes father of both circumcised and uncircumcised believers.
From the study of Romans 2:26.
Verse by verse
-
26If a man who is not circumcised keeps the requirements of the law, will not his uncircumcision be regarded as circumcision?
Full study →Paul is still arguing with an imagined Jewish teacher who rests on the law and on his circumcision (2:17–25). He has just said that a law-breaking Jew's circumcision 'has become foreskin' (v.25). Now he turns the logic around:
"Then suppose the Foreskin, the uncircumcised outsider, guards and keeps the law's righteous commands as a way of life. Won't his foreskin be entered in God's books as circumcision? Of course it will."
Several layers sit inside that sentence:
- "The Foreskin" is a group label. Jews of the time used it for non-Jews, naming them by the body part that marked them as outsiders. Paul uses that very label, and then narrows to one man ("his foreskin").
- "The law's requirements" is plural and concrete: the statutes and decrees of the Torah, the commands the Greek Old Testament calls dikaiōmata. It does not mean an abstract "righteousness". Yet the man keeps them while not doing the one thing Genesis 17 demands of every covenant male. Without saying so, Paul assumes that the law's real demand and its outward sign can come apart.
- "Keeps" is Israel's own covenant verb, to guard faithfully. It describes the outsider with words normally used of faithful Jews.
- "Will be reckoned as circumcision" is accounting language, with God as the one making the entry. It probably looks ahead to the judgment day Paul has just described (2:5–16). It also prepares for chapter 4, where Abraham is "reckoned" righteous while still in "foreskin".
- The question expects a yes. Paul assumes his conversation partner cannot deny it without denying that God judges impartially (2:11).
The shock lies in the reversal. Covenant membership as God counts it does not follow the cut in the flesh. What counts is faithful keeping of what God requires, which v.29 will call circumcision "of the heart, by the Spirit".
-
27The one who is physically uncircumcised yet keeps the law will condemn you who, even though you have the written code and circumcision, are a lawbreaker.
Full study →And the person still uncircumcised from birth (a Gentile, with the very foreskin you treat as the mark of an outsider) who actually carries out what the law requires will stand up at God's judgment as evidence against you. You have the law in writing and the covenant mark in your body, and with all that in hand you still step across the law's lines.
Paul is speaking directly to an imagined Jewish conversation partner, the "you who call yourself a Jew" of 2:17. The sentence is built on shock. The grammatical subject is literally "the foreskin." The uncircumcised outsider is the one who "judges." The circumcised insider who owns the written Torah is the one called a "transgressor": someone who steps over a known boundary.
"Will judge" looks ahead to the last day (2:16). It does not mean Gentiles will preside over a court. As with Jesus' saying that "the men of Nineveh will rise up and condemn this generation," their obedience will be the evidence that leaves the disobedient without excuse.
"Letter" means the written law as a possession, not a literal way of reading it. The phrase "with letter and circumcision" most likely means even though you have these advantages. The privileges do not protect the one who breaks the law. They make his failure worse.
-
28A man is not a Jew because he is one outwardly, nor is circumcision only outward and physical.
Full study →"For being a Jew is not a matter of what is on public view, and circumcision is not the cut that can be seen in the body."
Paul has just made a startling claim (vv. 26–27): an uncircumcised Gentile who keeps what the law requires will be counted as circumcised, and will even stand as a witness against the circumcised person who breaks the law. Verse 28 gives the reason ("for"). The honoured name Jew, and the covenant mark that goes with it, are not decided by what other people can see.
The key word is not "outward" in the sense of "fake" or "shallow". It is phaneros, "visible, in plain view", which Paul sets against kryptos, "hidden", in the next verse. That is the language of Jesus' "your Father who sees in secret" and of Romans 2:16, where God judges "the hidden things of people". Humans read identity off visible markers: descent, public observance, and the mark of the covenant cut into the flesh, in the very words of Genesis 17 ("my covenant shall be in your flesh"). Paul says those visible things are not the reality God is looking for.
The Greek is clipped, almost proverbial: "Not the visible one is a Jew; nor the visible-in-the-flesh one is circumcision." The reader has to supply the positive side, which v. 29 gives: the real Jew is one "in the hidden", and real circumcision is "of the heart, by the Spirit, not the letter". His praise comes from God, not from people. Here Paul plays on the name Judah, which in Hebrew sounds like "praise".
Paul is not inventing a new idea. He is applying Moses ("circumcise the foreskin of your heart", Deut 10:16; 30:6) and Jeremiah ("circumcised yet uncircumcised", Jer 9:25–26). He is also not saying the physical rite or Jewish identity is worthless: in 2:25 and 3:1–2 he says both have real value. His claim is that the visible sign cannot stand in for the hidden reality it was meant to point to.
-
29No, a man is a Jew because he is one inwardly, and circumcision is a matter of the heart, by the Spirit, not by the written code. Such a man’s praise does not come from men, but from God.
Full study →No, the real Jew, the true bearer of Judah's name, is the one whose Jewishness lies in the hidden place that only God sees. Real circumcision is the cutting Moses and Jeremiah called for, a circumcision of the heart. It is done by God's Spirit, not by a written code that can tell people what to do but cannot change them. That person's praise does not come from human beings, who can only see the visible mark. It comes from God, who judges what is hidden.
A few things English tends to lose:
- "Hidden" answers "visible" in 2:28. It points back to 2:16, where God "judges the hidden things of people" on the day of judgment. "Inwardly" here does not mean private feelings. It means the reality that holds up under God's examination.
- "Circumcision of the heart" is not Paul's invention. It is Moses' command and promise (Deuteronomy 10:16; 30:6) and Jeremiah's charge against Judah (Jeremiah 4:4; 9:25–26). Paul's hearers would have recognised the language.
- "Spirit… not letter" contrasts two agents: God's Spirit, who rewrites hearts (Ezekiel 36:26–27), and the law as something written outside a person. It does not set 'the intent of the rule' against 'its wording'.
- "Praise" is almost certainly a play on words. Judah (the root of Jew) is explained in Genesis as "praise" (29:35; 49:8). So the true Judah-man gets Judah's "praise", and he gets it from God.
- The Greek has almost no verbs. It is a terse, punchy reversal of 2:28, and translators have to supply "is".
Where the English drifted
-
in v26
uncircumcision
akrobustia
- What we hear
- An abstract physical condition, a clinical description of one man's body.
- What they heard
- Literally 'foreskin'. It was used as a blunt collective label for Gentiles, an in-group Jewish term naming outsiders by the mark of their exclusion. Paul uses the label in order to overturn it.
-
in v26
the righteousness of the law (KJV, YLT)
ta dikaiōmata tou nomou
- What we hear
- An abstract moral quality, or the righteous standing before God that the law gives or demands.
- What they heard
- A plural word for concrete things: the law's statutes, ordinances and decrees, the specific commands one 'keeps'.
-
in v27
letter (KJV, WEB, YLT)
gramma
- What we hear
- "The letter of the law": a rigid, hyper-literal reading as opposed to the law's real intention or "spirit."
- What they heard
- The law as a written text, a document Israel possessed. Paul's contrast in v.29 is between that written code and the Spirit God gives, not between literal and generous ways of reading.
-
in v27
uncircumcision which is by nature (KJV)
ek phuseōs
- What we hear
- Something to do with fallen "human nature," or with the natural world.
- What they heard
- By birth, physically. The person was born a Gentile and never circumcised.
-
in v27
judge thee / judge you (KJV, WEB, YLT)
krinei
- What we hear
- Gentiles will hold the office of judge over Jews.
- What they heard
- At God's judgment the obedient Gentile's conduct will testify against and condemn the disobedient insider by comparison. God remains the judge (2:16).
-
in v27
fulfil the law (KJV, WEB)
telousa
- What we hear
- Bringing the law to its goal or end, as Christ "fulfilled" it.
- What they heard
- Actually carrying out and performing what the law requires, as a continuing practice.
-
in v28
outwardly / outward
en tō phanerō
- What we hear
- Merely superficial, for show, insincere; or the body as opposed to the soul.
-
in v28, v29
Jew
Ioudaios
- What we hear
- Either a follower of the religion Judaism, or a person of Jewish ethnic ancestry, treated as separate questions.
- What they heard
- A member of the covenant people of Judah/Israel. Descent, ancestral law, temple, land and God made up one identity. The name carried honour and a claim to stand in a special relationship with God (2:17).
-
in v28
flesh
sarx
- What we hear
- Readers steeped in Paul may hear 'the sinful nature'.
- What they heard
- Literally the physical body where circumcision is performed, echoing Gen 17:13 'my covenant shall be in your flesh'.
-
in v29
letter ("not in the letter")
gramma
- What we hear
- The 'letter of the law': its strict wording or technicalities, as against its intent. Or, in Bible reading, a literal reading as against a figurative one.
- What they heard
- The written Torah as an external code, the law as inscribed text (compare 2:27; 7:6; 2 Corinthians 3:7, 'engraved in letters on stones'). It can command but cannot transform the heart.
-
in v29
spirit (lowercase, KJV/WEB/YLT)
pneuma
- What we hear
- The underlying attitude or intent of something, as in 'the spirit of the law', or simply inner sincerity.
- What they heard
- Most likely God's own Spirit, the promised gift that renews the heart and enables obedience (Ezekiel 36:26–27; Romans 7:6; 8:4; 2 Corinthians 3:3–6).
-
in v29
inwardly
en tō kryptō
- What we hear
- Private, personal spirituality or sincere feelings, as opposed to outward religious practice, which is assumed to be unimportant.
Where popular teaching often drifts
in v28
'Outwardly' here doesn't mean ritual doesn't matter
- What's often taught
- This verse is often read as Paul teaching that outward religious practice, rites and identity markers don't really matter to God. Only the inner heart counts, so ritual and visible observance are at best optional.
- What the text supports
Paul's contrast is not ritual versus sincerity, or body versus soul. It is visible (φανερός, what people see) versus hidden (κρυπτός, what God sees, 2:16, 29). The real question is whose verdict counts.
The passage itself rules out reading 'the outward doesn't matter':
- 2:25: 'Circumcision indeed has value if you keep the law.'
- 3:1–2: 'What is the value of circumcision? Much in every way.'
Paul's point, drawn from Moses and Jeremiah (Deut 10:16; 30:6; Jer 9:25–26), is that the visible sign cannot stand in for the hidden reality it signifies. When it is cut off from obedience and a heart turned toward God, it does not secure God's approval. The popular reading is right that God looks at the heart. It goes beyond the text when it says the visible sign is therefore worthless.
- Where the English feeds it
- English 'outward/outwardly' suggests 'superficial, mere show', and some versions add 'only' or 'merely'. Readers then hear a put-down of externals. The Greek word simply means 'visible, in plain view', with no negative sense of its own.
in v29
'Spirit, not letter' isn't about intent over wording
- What's often taught
- This verse is often taken to teach that God cares about the 'spirit' of the law (its intent) rather than its 'letter' (its exact wording), so believers should follow the purpose behind commands rather than their literal requirements. Some extend it to mean that Scripture should be read spiritually rather than literally.
- What the text supports
In Paul, gramma ('letter') means the written law as a code inscribed outside a person. The same word in 2:27 refers to the Jew who has 'the written code and circumcision', and 2 Corinthians 3:7 speaks of the law 'engraved in letters on stones'. Pneuma is most likely God's Spirit, the gift Ezekiel promised: 'I will put my Spirit within you and cause you to walk in my statutes' (Ezekiel 36:26–27; compare Romans 7:6; 2 Corinthians 3:3, 6).
The contrast is between what a written command can do (state a requirement) and what God's Spirit does (circumcise the heart, as Deuteronomy 30:6 promised). It is not a contrast between strict and loose interpretation, or between literal and figurative reading.
The popular reading gets one thing right: Paul does rank the heart above outward conformity. But for Paul the Spirit's work leads to the law's 'just requirement' being fulfilled (8:4; compare 2:26–27). It does not make those requirements optional.
- Where the English feeds it
- 'Letter' (KJV, ESV, NASB, WEB) sounds like the English idiom 'letter of the law', and lowercase 'spirit' (KJV, WEB, YLT) sounds like 'the spirit of the law'. RSV and NRSV render it 'spiritual and not literal', and NLT writes 'the letter of the law' into the verse. NIV and BSB 'written code' avoids most of the problem.
Every word
-
ἐὰν
ean · G1437
if · v26
Opens a condition about something that may or may not happen ("if ever, should it be the case that"). The grammar puts the case forward as possible. By itself it does not tell us whether Paul thinks it really happens.
-
οὖν
oun · G3767
therefore, then · v26
Draws the conclusion from v.25. If breaking the law can turn a Jew's circumcision into 'foreskin', then the reverse must be possible too.
-
ἡ
hē · G3588
the · v26, v27, v28, v29
The article goes with 'foreskin'. It makes the word a category, 'the foreskin' meaning the uncircumcised as a group.
-
ἀκροβυστία
akrobustia · G0203
foreskin; uncircumcision; the uncircumcised (Gentiles) · v26, v27
Literally 'foreskin'. Here it is used for a whole class of people: non-Jews, labelled by the body part that marks them as outside the covenant. It is blunt Jewish in-group language, and Paul uses it on purpose.
-
δικαιώματα
dikaiōmata · G1345
righteous requirements, ordinances, statutes · v26
The concrete things the law rightly requires, its statutes and decrees. The word is plural. It means the commands themselves, not an abstract 'righteousness'.
-
νόμου
nomou · G3551
law · v26, v27
The Torah of Moses, the covenant law given to Israel. That is the law the Jewish conversation partner in vv.17–25 boasts in.
-
φυλάσσῃ
phulassē · G5442
guard, keep, observe · v26
'Should guard/keep.' This is the standard Greek Old Testament verb for Hebrew shamar, to keep God's commandments faithfully. The present tense suggests an ongoing way of life, not a single act.
-
οὐχ
ouch · G3756
not · v26, v28, v29
Placed at the start of a question, it expects the answer 'yes': 'Will it not be…? Of course it will.'
-
αὐτοῦ
autou · G0846
his · v26
'His.' Paul switches from the collective 'the foreskin' to a single man. The grammar follows the sense: behind the label stands a real person.
-
εἰς
eis · G1519
into, as · v26
Together with 'reckoned' it forms the idiom 'reckoned as', 'credited as', the same construction as Genesis 15:6 ('it was reckoned to him as righteousness').
-
περιτομὴν
peritomēn · G4061
circumcision · v26, v27, v28, v29
The covenant sign of Genesis 17. By extension it can mean the Jewish people ('the circumcision'). Here it means covenant-member status: he will count as circumcised.
-
λογισθήσεται
logisthēsetai · G3049
to reckon, count, credit · v26
'Will be reckoned.' It is an accounting word for entering something in the books, and the passive implies that God does the reckoning. The future tense likely looks toward the day of judgment Paul names in 2:16. It also anticipates Romans 4, where Abraham is reckoned righteous while still uncircumcised.
-
καὶ
kai · G2532
and · v27, v29
Links this verse closely to the question of v.26 and carries the argument one step further: the uncircumcised law-keeper is not only counted as circumcised, he also stands against the circumcised law-breaker.
-
κρινεῖ
krinei · G2919
-
ἐκ
ek · G1537
out of, from · v27, v29
Marks origin: the person's uncircumcised state comes from birth, from how they were born.
-
φύσεως
phuseōs · G5449
nature, birth, natural state · v27
Here it means physical birth and natural bodily condition, much like Galatians 2:15, "Jews by birth." It does not mean "human nature" in a moral sense.
-
τελοῦσα
telousa · G5055
to finish, carry out, accomplish · v27
A present participle: "carrying out, actually doing" the law. It describes ongoing practice, parallel to "keeps the requirements" in v.26. It is not the "fulfil = bring to an end" sense.
-
σὲ
se · G4771
you (singular) · v27
The object of "will judge." This is the imagined dialogue partner addressed since 2:17, "you who call yourself a Jew." The singular is direct and pointed.
-
διὰ
dia · G1223
through; with, in the state of · v27
With the genitive here it most likely describes the circumstances: "with, even while having" the letter and circumcision. Read this way, the transgression happens despite these privileges. Some read it as "through, by means of" (see debates).
-
γράμματος
grammatos · G1121
letter, written thing, document · v27, v29
The law in its written form, the Torah as a written possession of Israel. It points ahead to the contrast in v.29 between "Spirit" and "letter."
-
παραβάτην
parabatēn · G3848
transgressor, one who oversteps · v27
Someone who steps across a known, stated boundary. This is the climax word of the sentence and echoes 2:23, "through transgression of the law you dishonor God."
-
γὰρ
gar · G1063
for · v28
Links the verse to vv. 25–27 as their explanation. The uncircumcised law-keeper can 'judge' the circumcised law-breaker *because* Jewishness and circumcision are not settled by what is visible.
-
ἐν
en · G1722
in · v28, v29
Marks the sphere or realm: 'in the visible (realm)'. The supplied gloss 'on' is only an alignment label. The sense is 'in what is open to view'.
-
φανερῷ
phanerō · G5318
-
Ἰουδαῖός
Ioudaios · G2453
Jew, Judean · v28, v29
Member of the people of Judah/Israel by descent, custom and covenant. It picks up 2:17, 'you call yourself a Jew'. Paul asks what the name truly means before God.
-
ἐστιν
estin · G1510
is · v28
Present tense, a general statement of what holds true. Its subject is 'the one in the visible' and its predicate is 'Jew' (see textual notes on the clipped grammar).
-
οὐδὲ
oude · G3761
nor, neither · v28
Adds a second negative statement parallel to the first. The same logic applies to the sign as to the name.
-
σαρκὶ
sarki · G4561
flesh, body · v28
Here it means the literal physical body, the foreskin removed. It is not Paul's later sense of 'flesh' as human weakness that sin exploits (Rom 7–8), though the word sets up the flesh/Spirit contrast of v. 29.
-
ἀλλ᾽
all' · G0235
but, rather · v29
A strong 'no, rather' that answers the two denials of 2:28 ('not the outward Jew… not the outward circumcision'). It turns the sentence from what does not count to what does.
-
κρυπτῷ
kryptō · G2927
-
καρδίας
kardias · G2588
heart · v29
'Of the heart': a circumcision done on the heart. In biblical thinking the heart is the center of thought, will and loyalty, not mainly the feelings. The phrase comes straight from Deuteronomy 10:16; 30:6 and Jeremiah 4:4.
-
πνεύματι
pneumati · G4151
spirit, Spirit, breath · v29
Most likely God's Spirit, the promised gift that renews the heart (Ezekiel 36:26–27). It is set against the written law, which tells people what to do but cannot change them.
-
οὗ
hou · G3739
whose, of whom · v29
This form can only point back to the person, the hidden Jew, not to 'circumcision', which is feminine. So the meaning is 'whose praise', the praise of that person.
-
ἔπαινος
epainos · G1868
praise, commendation, approval · v29
Public commendation, the honor someone is publicly granted. Here it is God's approving verdict at the judgment (compare 1 Corinthians 4:5). It is very probably a play on 'Judah', whose name means 'praise' (Genesis 29:35; 49:8).
-
ἀνθρώπων
anthrōpōn · G0444
human beings, people · v29
People in general, not men as opposed to women. It means the community whose eyes see only the visible mark.
-
θεοῦ.
theou · G2316
God · v29
God, who sees 'the hidden' and gives the final verdict (2:5–16). The verse ends on him as the only judge whose approval decides identity.
The world behind it
Circumcision as the covenant boundary. Genesis 17 made circumcision "the sign of the covenant" and said any uncircumcised male "shall be cut off from his people." By Paul's day this was the sharpest line between Jew and Gentile. During the Maccabean persecution (167–164 BC), mothers were executed for circumcising their babies (1 Macc 1:60–61). Some Hellenizing Jews had surgery to disguise their circumcision (1 Macc 1:15). Jubilees 15 calls the uncircumcised "children of destruction."
A live debate about Gentiles. Jews disagreed over whether a Gentile drawn to Israel's God needed circumcision. Josephus (Antiquities 20.34–48) tells of King Izates of Adiabene. One Jewish teacher, Ananias, told him he could worship God without being circumcised. Another, Eleazar, told him that reading the law while not doing what it commands was impious, and Izates was circumcised. Many synagogues had uncircumcised "God-fearers" who were respected but stood outside full membership. Paul's question would have landed in the middle of this argument.
"Circumcised in heart." The scriptures already reached past the physical rite. They call for circumcising the heart (Deut 10:16; 30:6; Jer 4:4) and condemn those "circumcised yet uncircumcised" (Jer 9:25–26). Paul did not invent that inward meaning. What is new is his conclusion that the physical rite may be lacking altogether while the reality is present.
Romans' audience. The church in Rome mixed Jewish and Gentile believers, with tensions between them (see chs. 14–15). Paul writes in a familiar teaching style of the time, debating an imagined opponent ("you who call yourself a Jew," 2:17). He is not attacking Jews as such. He is dismantling the idea that the covenant sign protects a person at God's judgment without faithfulness.
From the study of Romans 2:26.
Where scholars differ
in v26
Who is the uncircumcised law-keeper Paul has in mind?
-
A hypothetical case. Paul argues on his opponent's terms: if such a person existed, God would count him. Romans 3:9–20 then shows that no one, Jew or Gentile, actually keeps the law.
The 'if' is open-ended. Paul's conclusion in 3:20 is that 'by works of the law no flesh will be justified'. The diatribe style tests the opponent's logic. (Held in various forms by Lutheran-tradition interpreters and Moo in part.)
-
Gentile Christians, who fulfil the law's real demand through the Spirit.
V.29 defines true circumcision as 'of the heart, by the Spirit, not the letter'. Rom 8:4 speaks of 'the dikaiōma of the law fulfilled in us who walk… according to the Spirit'. Ezek 36:27 promises the Spirit so that people will keep God's dikaiōmata. (Cranfield, Wright, Gathercole, Jewett.)
-
Righteous Gentiles in general, whose obedience God recognises at judgment, as in 2:14–15. Paul states this without fully reconciling it with chapter 3.
2:14 speaks of Gentiles who 'by nature do what the law requires', and the chapter stresses impartial judgment by deeds (2:6–11). Sanders and Räisänen saw a real tension with 3:20.
in v26
Does 'will be reckoned' refer to the final judgment or to a present logical conclusion?
in v26
What does 'the requirements of the law' include if circumcision is excluded?
-
The law's moral core, such as the commands of 2:21–22 (stealing, adultery, idolatry) or love of neighbour (13:8–10).
The examples Paul gives in 2:21–22 are moral commands, and Rom 13:8–10 sums up the law as love.
-
The law's essential intent as God means it, which Paul sees as achievable apart from its ethnic markers, without a neat moral/ceremonial split.
Paul never sets out a formal moral/ceremonial distinction, and the singular dikaiōma in 8:4 points to the law's unified righteous demand.
in v27
Who is the uncircumcised person who "carries out the law"?
-
A hypothetical figure. Paul is stating a principle (if a Gentile kept the law, he would condemn the disobedient Jew) on the way to concluding that in fact no one keeps it (3:9–20).
The conditional "if" in v.26. The overall argument of 1:18–3:20 that all are under sin. 3:20, "by works of the law no one will be justified." Held in various forms by many Reformation-tradition commentators, e.g. Moo (NICNT).
-
Gentile Christians, who carry out the law's real intent through the Spirit.
Verse 29 explicitly brings in "Spirit, not letter" and circumcision of the heart. That is new-covenant language (Jer 31:33; Ezek 36:26–27). Compare Rom 8:4, "the righteous requirement of the law fulfilled in us who walk according to the Spirit," and 2 Cor 3:3. Held by Cranfield, N. T. Wright, Gathercole and others.
-
Righteous Gentiles in general (God-fearers or morally upright pagans), whose real conduct shows up the inconsistency of the boaster.
The link with 2:14–15, Gentiles who "by nature do the things of the law." The concrete, present-tense participle "carrying out." Jewish traditions that recognized righteous Gentiles.
in v27
What does "through (dia) letter and circumcision" mean?
-
Attendant circumstance: "with" or "despite having" the letter and circumcision.
BDAG lists this verse under dia with the genitive for attendant circumstances. It fits 2:17–24, where the privileges are listed and then not lived up to. Followed by BSB, NIV and WEB.
-
Instrumental: "by means of" the letter and circumcision. Relying on these outward marks is itself part of what makes him a transgressor.
The normal meaning of dia with the genitive. It connects with Paul's later statements that the written law brings transgression and death (Rom 4:15; 7:5–11; 2 Cor 3:6). Some interpreters (e.g. Käsemann) hear this undertone.
in v27
Who is the "you" addressed?
-
A representative Jew (or Jewish teacher) who trusts in Israel's covenant privileges.
2:17, "you call yourself a Jew". The list of Jewish advantages in 2:17–20. 3:1, "what advantage has the Jew?" This is the majority view.
-
A Gentile who has taken on Jewish identity (a proselyte or Judaizing Gentile) and now looks down on other Gentiles.
"Call yourself a Jew" may hint that the identity was adopted. The diatribe style and the Gentile audience of the letter (1:5–6, 13). Argued by Thorsteinsson, Rodríguez and others. A minority position.
in v28
Who is the 'you' who 'calls yourself a Jew' (2:17), whom vv. 25–29 address?
-
An ethnic Jew, a representative Jewish teacher confident in the law and the covenant.
The majority reading in church history and modern commentaries (e.g., Cranfield, Dunn, Moo). 2:17–24 describes someone who is instructed in the law and teaches others. 3:1–2 ('what advantage has the Jew?') assumes the previous section concerned Jews as a people. 3:9 sums up: 'Jews and Greeks are all under sin'.
-
A Gentile who has taken on Jewish identity (a proselyte or would-be proselyte) and 'calls himself' a Jew.
Argued by Runar Thorsteinsson (2003), Rafael Rodríguez (2014) and Matthew Thiessen (2016). 'Call yourself' (ἐπονομάζῃ) may suggest a name someone has adopted. Ancient diatribe usually kept the same imagined partner throughout, and 2:1–16 addresses a generic 'person'. Some Jews themselves questioned whether proselytes became Jews in the full sense. If so, v. 28 says that becoming a Jew through visible circumcision does not deliver what such a convert hoped for.
in v28
Does Paul here redefine 'Jew' so that Gentile believers become 'true Jews'?
-
Yes. The 'hidden Jew' of v. 29 includes uncircumcised Gentiles whose hearts the Spirit has circumcised, so the title is opened to them.
Verses 26–27 have the uncircumcised law-keeper 'counted as circumcision'. 'By the Spirit' in v. 29 points to the new-covenant gift Paul elsewhere ties to believers (Rom 7:6; 2 Cor 3:6). Phil 3:3 says 'we are the circumcision'. A long line of interpreters from Augustine onward, and many modern ones, read it this way.
-
No, not a transfer of the name. Paul is describing what genuine Jewishness consists of before God, and he goes on using 'Jew' for the ethnic people.
Right after this, 3:1–2 affirms the Jew's advantage and the value of circumcision. In 9:3–5 and 11:1, 28–29 Israel 'according to the flesh' remains beloved, and its gifts and calling are irrevocable. Paul never calls Gentile believers 'Jews' anywhere in his letters. The heart-circumcision theme comes from Israel's own scriptures and was aimed at Israelites. On this view Gentiles share the praise from God without becoming 'Jews'.
in v29
Who is the 'Jew in the hidden'?
-
Christ-believers, including uncircumcised gentiles. Paul extends the name 'Jew' (or 'circumcision') to all who have the Spirit.
Philippians 3:3 ('we are the circumcision, who worship by the Spirit of God'); Galatians 6:16; Romans 2:26–27 (the uncircumcised counted as circumcised). The link with the Spirit points to the new-covenant gift. Common in Reformed and 'new perspective' readings (e.g. Wright, Schreiner).
-
Paul is making a prophetic critique from inside Israel. The 'inward Jew' is a faithful, heart-circumcised Jew, and the name is not being transferred to gentiles.
The language comes straight from Deuteronomy and Jeremiah, and similar critiques appear in Philo and the Dead Sea Scrolls. In 3:1–2 Paul immediately affirms Jewish advantage. Romans 9:6 ('not all who are from Israel are Israel') makes a distinction within Israel. Paul never calls gentile believers 'Jews' anywhere else.
-
The dialogue partner of 2:17 is a gentile who 'calls himself a Jew' (a convert or a gentile who has taken up Jewish practice). Paul is telling him that the outward mark does not make him a true Jew.
The verb in 2:17 (*eponomazē*, 'you call yourself') can suggest a self-claimed title. The surrounding debate over whether converts needed circumcision supports this (Josephus, *Antiquities* 20.34–48). Argued by Thorsteinsson, Rodríguez and Thiessen.
in v29
Is pneuma here God's Spirit or the human spirit / a 'spiritual' sphere?
-
God's (Holy) Spirit, the one who performs the heart-circumcision.
Every other Spirit/letter pair in Paul clearly means God's Spirit (Romans 7:6; 2 Corinthians 3:3, 6, 8). The background is Ezekiel 36:26–27 and Jubilees 1:23. The verse is built on 'by X, not by Y', which suggests an agent. This is the majority view (Cranfield, Dunn, Moo, Fitzmyer, Jewett).
-
The human spirit, or a 'spiritual' as opposed to 'physical' sphere.
There is no article and no explicit reference to Christ or God in the clause. The contrast with 'in the flesh' (2:28) could suggest inner versus outer. Followed by older translations (KJV lowercase) and RSV/NRSV 'spiritual'.
in v29
Is 'praise' a deliberate pun on 'Judah'?
-
Yes. The true 'Judah-man' receives 'Judah-praise' from God.
Genesis 29:35 and 49:8 tie Judah's name to praise. The clause comes right after 'Jew', and Paul was steeped in Hebrew scripture. Accepted by many commentators (e.g. Cranfield, Dunn, Moo, Jewett).
-
Possible but uncertain. The point stands without it.
The pun depends mainly on Hebrew, and Paul does not flag it. Many in the Roman audience may have read only Greek. 'Praise from God, not people' is a common contrast anyway (John 5:44; 12:43; 1 Corinthians 4:5).
Sources
- BDAG s.v. ἀκροβυστία, δικαίωμα, λογίζομαι, φυλάσσω, περιτομή
- LXX: Gen 15:6; 17:9–14; 26:5; Deut 4:1; 10:16; 30:6; Jer 4:4; 9:25–26; Ezek 36:26–27
- Josephus, Antiquities 20.34–48 (Izates of Adiabene)
- 1 Maccabees 1:15, 48, 60–61; Jubilees 15:26–34
- Philo, On the Migration of Abraham 89–93
- Joel Marcus, 'The Circumcision and the Uncircumcision in Rome', NTS 35 (1989)
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC)
- J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 1–8 (WBC)
- D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
- R. Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
- S. Gathercole, Where Is Boasting?
- E. P. Sanders, Paul, the Law, and the Jewish People
- N. T. Wright, 'The Law in Romans 2'
- NA28 Greek New Testament; Vulgate
- BDAG s.v. κρίνω, φύσις, ἀκροβυστία, τελέω, γράμμα, παραβάτης, διά (A.3.c, attendant circumstance)
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. ἀκροβυστία, παραβάτης
- Nestle-Aland Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed. (punctuation of 2:26–27)
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), vol. 1
- Douglas J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT)
- James D. G. Dunn, Romans 1–8 (WBC)
- Robert Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia)
- N. T. Wright, "Romans" in New Interpreter's Bible vol. X
- Simon Gathercole, "A Law unto Themselves: The Gentiles in Romans 2.14–15 Revisited," JSNT 85 (2002)
- Runar M. Thorsteinsson, Paul's Interlocutor in Romans 2 (2003)
- Jubilees 15:25–34; 1 Maccabees 1:15, 60–61; 1QS 5:5; 1QpHab 11:13
- Septuagint: Gen 17:11–14; Deut 10:16; 30:6; Jer 4:4; 9:25–26
- Vulgate, Rom 2:27
- BDAG s.v. φανερός, κρυπτός, Ἰουδαῖος, περιτομή, σάρξ
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. φανερός, περιτομή
- Nestle-Aland, Novum Testamentum Graece, 28th ed.
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), vol. 1, on 2:25–29
- J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 1–8 (WBC 38A), on 2:25–29
- D. J. Moo, The Epistle to the Romans (NICNT), on 2:28–29
- R. Jewett, Romans (Hermeneia), on 2:25–29
- J. A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible), on 2:28–29
- M. Thiessen, Paul and the Gentile Problem (Oxford, 2016)
- R. M. Thorsteinsson, Paul's Interlocutor in Romans 2 (2003)
- S. Mason, 'Jews, Judaeans, Judaizing, Judaism', JSJ 38 (2007)
- Josephus, Antiquities 20.34–48 (Izates of Adiabene); 11.173
- Philo, On the Migration of Abraham 89–93; On the Special Laws 1.1–11
- Deut 10:16; 30:6; Jer 4:4; 9:25–26; Lev 26:41; Ezek 44:7–9; Gen 17:11–14 (LXX)
- 1QS 5:5; 1QpHab 11:13; Jubilees 1:23; 1 Maccabees 1:15, 48, 60–61
- Tacitus, Histories 5.5; Juvenal, Satires 14.96–106
- BDAG s.v. γράμμα, πνεῦμα, κρυπτός, ἔπαινος, Ἰουδαῖος, περιτομή
- Thayer's Greek-English Lexicon s.v. γράμμα
- C. E. B. Cranfield, Romans (ICC), vol. 1, on 2:28–29
- J. D. G. Dunn, Romans 1–8 (WBC 38A)
- J. A. Fitzmyer, Romans (Anchor Bible 33)
- R. Thorsteinsson, Paul's Interlocutor in Romans 2 (2003)
- M. Thiessen, Paul and the Gentile Problem (2016)
- S. J. D. Cohen, The Beginnings of Jewishness (1999)
- Deuteronomy 10:16; 30:6; Jeremiah 4:4; 9:25–26; Ezekiel 36:26–27 (MT and LXX)
- Dead Sea Scrolls: 1QS 5.5; 1QpHab 11.13
- Jubilees 1:23; 15:26
- Philo, De specialibus legibus 1.304–306; De migratione Abrahami 89–93
- Josephus, Antiquities 11.173; 20.34–48
- Tacitus, Histories 5.5
- Augustine, De spiritu et littera
- Origen, De principiis 4
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).