2 Samuel Chapter 21 Read as one passage
2 Samuel 21:6–9
Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.
6let seven of his male descendants be delivered to us so that we may hang them before the LORD at Gibeah of Saul, the chosen of the LORD.” “I will give them to you,” said the king. 7Now the king spared Mephibosheth son of Jonathan, the son of Saul, because of the oath before the LORD between David and Jonathan son of Saul. 8But the king took Armoni and Mephibosheth, the two sons whom Rizpah daughter of Aiah had borne to Saul, as well as the five sons whom Merab daughter of Saul had borne to Adriel son of Barzillai the Meholathite. 9And he delivered them into the hands of the Gibeonites, and they hanged them on the hill before the LORD. So all seven of them fell together; they were put to death in the first days of the harvest, at the beginning of the barley harvest.
What the first hearers heard
For Israelite hearers this verse settled a terrible question: why famine had struck the land, and what it took to lift it. The story assumes several things they took for granted:
- An oath sworn in the LORD's name binds across generations. Israel had sworn an oath to Gibeon in Joshua's day. Saul broke it centuries later, and the whole land suffered. The LORD himself guards a treaty, even one with foreigners obtained by trickery.
- Blood demands an answer in kind. Money could not cover it (v. 4). Only the blood of the guilty house could cleanse the land (Num 35:33). Like the executions at Peor (Num 25:4), the public deaths "before the LORD" were meant to turn away wrath from all Israel.
- Saul's house carries Saul's guilt. The family was one unit, so his descendants could answer for him.
- The irony of "the LORD's chosen." The first king, chosen by the LORD, became the oath-breaker whose line pays for it in his own hometown.
For a reader following the story of David's rise, the verse is also uncomfortable. David agrees in two words, and the deaths remove most of Saul's remaining male line. The narrative does not explicitly accuse or excuse him. It immediately shows him sparing Mephibosheth because of a different oath (v. 7). It then gives the last word to Rizpah's long vigil over the bodies (vv. 10–14), which moves David to give Saul's house an honourable burial. Only after that, "God responded to the plea for the land" (v. 14). The hearers were left with a world where oaths, blood, land and kingship were bound together before God, and where the cost fell on real people.
From the study of 2 Samuel 21:6.
Verse by verse
-
6let seven of his male descendants be delivered to us so that we may hang them before the LORD at Gibeah of Saul, the chosen of the LORD.” “I will give them to you,” said the king.
Full study →The Gibeonites finish their demand. Saul tried to wipe them out in breach of a treaty Israel had sworn in the LORD's name, so they ask: "Let seven grown men from Saul's own line be handed over to us." That means his sons and grandsons, a full and complete number. "Then we will put them to death publicly and leave their bodies on display. We will do it in the LORD's presence, as a matter between us and the God who witnessed the oath. And we will do it in Gibeah, Saul's own town, the home of the man the LORD himself once chose as king."
The word usually translated "hang" does not mean a rope and gallows. It is a rare word for a brutal execution, perhaps impaling, perhaps breaking or wrenching the limbs, perhaps throwing down from a height, followed by leaving the bodies exposed to the sun. The calling of Saul "the LORD's chosen" has a bitter edge: the chosen king broke the LORD's oath, and his house now answers for it in the place where he ruled.
The king's answer is two words in Hebrew, with an emphatic "I": "I myself will give." They had asked politely, "let there be given." David answers personally and without hesitation.
-
7Now the king spared Mephibosheth son of Jonathan, the son of Saul, because of the oath before the LORD between David and Jonathan son of Saul.
Full study →But the king held back his hand, out of pity, from Mephibosheth, the son of Jonathan, the son of Saul. He did it because of the oath sworn by Yahweh that stood between the two of them, between David and Jonathan, Saul's son.
The verb carries both feeling and action. David felt for the young man, and that feeling became a decision not to hand him over to death. The verse places the reason firmly in the oath. Years earlier, with Yahweh called as witness and enforcer, Jonathan had made David swear never to cut off his loyalty from Jonathan's house, 'my offspring and your offspring forever' (1 Samuel 20:14–17, 42).
That oath now meets another one. Saul had broken Israel's ancient oath to the Gibeonites (Joshua 9), and the land was in its third year of famine because of the bloodguilt (21:1). David is handing over seven of Saul's descendants to settle that debt. In the same moment he holds back the one descendant the other oath protects. Breaking an oath sworn by Yahweh brought death, and keeping one preserved life, a generation after the people who swore them.
The phrase 'son of Jonathan, son of Saul' is not filler. There are two men named Mephibosheth (see v. 8). The one spared is the one whose father was David's sworn partner. Even his name carries a scribal mark: 'bosheth', 'shame', stands where the original name had 'baal', 'lord'.
-
8But the king took Armoni and Mephibosheth, the two sons whom Rizpah daughter of Aiah had borne to Saul, as well as the five sons whom Merab daughter of Saul had borne to Adriel son of Barzillai the Meholathite.
Full study →So the king took them. Having spared Jonathan's son Mephibosheth because of his sworn oath to Jonathan (v. 7), David took seven others from Saul's house:
- Two sons of Saul himself, Armoni and another Mephibosheth. Their mother was Rizpah daughter of Aiah, Saul's secondary wife. She had borne them to Saul, so they were his own sons and full members of his house.
- Five grandsons of Saul, sons of Saul's daughter, whom she had borne to Adriel son of Barzillai, the man from Abel-meholah. The traditional Hebrew text names this daughter as "Michal". But it was Merab, Saul's older daughter, whom Saul gave to Adriel (1 Samuel 18:19), and Michal had no children (2 Samuel 6:23). So most scholars read "Merab" here. Merab was the very daughter Saul had once promised to David and then given to another man.
The verb "bore" is used twice, for both mothers: these women gave birth to the men now being handed over. The two Mephibosheths side by side are deliberate. One is spared because David keeps his oath; the other is taken because Saul broke Israel's ancient oath to Gibeon. Two plus five makes exactly the seven the Gibeonites demanded. The verse reads like an official list, but every name ties back to "Saul", and the mothers named here, above all Rizpah, prepare for the grief that follows.
-
9And he delivered them into the hands of the Gibeonites, and they hanged them on the hill before the LORD. So all seven of them fell together; they were put to death in the first days of the harvest, at the beginning of the barley harvest.
Full study →David handed the seven men, two sons of Saul by his concubine Rizpah and five of Saul's grandsons, over to the Gibeonites, giving them into the legal power of the people Saul had wronged. The Gibeonites executed them on the sacred hill, in the presence of Yahweh. This was not a gallows hanging. The bodies were publicly displayed, fixed or laid out under the open sky (possibly impaled, possibly with their limbs broken), at a holy place where the act was offered to the God by whose name Israel had once sworn to protect Gibeon. All seven died together in one act. Seven was the number demanded, a full and complete payment for the blood Saul had shed (the scribes' written text even says "sevenfold"). The narrator adds the date with legal flatness: "they were put to death", the language of a judicial sentence, at the very start of the harvest season, the first days of the barley harvest in early spring. In a land that had gone hungry for three years, that was the moment everyone was watching the fields. The timing also sets up what follows: the bodies would lie exposed through the dry season until rain fell from heaven, the sign that God had once again "responded to the land".
Where the English drifted
-
in v6
hang them (up)
hôqaʿ (from yāqaʿ)
- What we hear
- Execution by noose and gallows, as in modern hanging.
-
in v6
his sons (KJV, WEB)
bānāyw (bēn)
- What we hear
- Saul's immediate sons only.
- What they heard
- His descendants. Five of the seven named in v. 8 are Saul's grandsons through his daughter.
-
in v7
the LORD's oath
shĕbuʿat YHWH
- What we hear
- An oath the LORD himself swore, a divine promise made by God.
- What they heard
- An oath sworn by Yahweh, with Yahweh called on as witness and as the one who would punish anyone who broke it. The swearers were David and Jonathan. Yahweh was the guarantor between them.
-
in v8
whom she brought up for Adriel (KJV)
ʾăsher yāldāh ləʿAdrîʾēl
- What we hear
- A KJV reader takes it that Michal raised or adopted these five boys for Adriel, perhaps her sister's children, so she was their foster mother.
- What they heard
- 'Whom she bore to Adriel': she physically gave birth to them as Adriel's children. It is the same verb the KJV itself renders 'bare' for Rizpah earlier in the verse.
-
in v9
hanged them
wayyōqîʿum (from yāqaʿ)
- What we hear
- Execution by noose on a gallows: death by strangulation or a broken neck.
- What they heard
- A public execution with display of the bodies, method uncertain: possibly impaling, exposure with broken or dislocated limbs, or fixing the corpse on a stake. The stress is on exposure 'before the LORD' and under the sky.
-
in v9
before the LORD
lip̄nê YHWH
- What we hear
- Generally 'in God's sight', the way God sees all things everywhere.
- What they heard
- At a holy place, in the deity's presence, as a deliberate act offered to Yahweh. Here it is an expiation for violating an oath sworn in his name.
Every word
-
יֻתַּן
yuttan · H5414G
let it be given · v6, v9
A passive wish or request ('let there be given'). The Gibeonites phrase their demand politely and impersonally. They do not say 'you give'. The same verb returns at the end of the verse when the king says 'I will give.'
-
לָנוּ
lānû · H9035
to us · v6
The Gibeonites as the injured party. They have already said (v. 4) that they have no right to put any Israelite to death themselves, so the men must be handed over to them.
-
שִׁבְעָה
šiḇʿāh · H7651
seven · v6, v9
A real count: seven men are named in v. 8. In Israel seven was also the number of fullness and completion, so the number marks this as a full settlement of the debt.
-
אֲנָשִׁים
ʾănāšîm · H0582
men · v6
Adult males. The demand is for grown men of Saul's house, not children.
-
מִבָּנָיו
mibbānāyw · H1121G
-
וְהוֹקַעֲנוּם
wəhôqaʿănûm · H3363
and we will hang/impale/expose them · v6, v9
States the purpose: 'so that we may ___ them.' The verb is rare. It names a form of execution, with public display of the bodies, carried out 'before the LORD'. Its exact method is uncertain (see studies). It is not hanging with a rope.
-
לַיהוָה
laYHWH · H3068G
-
בְּגִבְעַת
bəḡiḇʿaṯ · H1390H
at Gibeah of · v6
Gibeah was Saul's hometown and royal seat (1 Sam 10:26; 15:34). Displaying his descendants in his own town is pointed. The Greek reads Gibeon, the Gibeonites' own city (see textual notes).
-
שָׁאוּל
šāʾûl · H7586G
Saul · v6, v7, v8
The first king. He broke Israel's sworn treaty with Gibeon out of zeal for Israel and Judah (v. 2).
-
בְּחִיר
bəḥîr · H0972
chosen one of · v6
'The chosen one of the LORD.' As the Hebrew stands, this is a title for Saul, recalling 1 Sam 10:24 ('Do you see the one the LORD has chosen?'). In the Gibeonites' mouth it has a bitter edge: the LORD's own chosen king broke the LORD's oath. Some scholars think the text originally read 'on the mountain of the LORD.'
-
וַיֹּאמֶר
wayyōʾmer · H0559
and he said · v6
An ordinary narrative 'and he said.' The reply is told without delay or comment.
-
הַמֶּלֶךְ
hammeleḵ · H4428G
the king · v6, v7, v8
David, named by his office rather than his name. He acts here as the authority who answers for Israel's sworn treaties and has power over Saul's house.
-
אֲנִי
ʾănî · H0589
I · v6
The verb already contains 'I', so the separate pronoun adds emphasis: 'I myself will give.' The king takes personal responsibility for handing them over.
-
וַיַּחְמֹ֣ל
wayyaḥmōl · H2550
and he spared / had pity · v7
The usual Hebrew 'and then' verb form that moves a story forward. In context it reads as 'but': David has just promised to hand over seven of Saul's descendants (v. 6), and now he holds one back. The verb means to feel for someone and, because of that, keep harm away from them.
-
עַל־
ʿal- · H5921
upon, over · v7
The preposition that marks who receives the pity: 'had pity on'. The same word comes back a few words later with a different sense ('because of'). The sentence turns on this pair: pity on the man because of the oath.
-
מְפִי־
mĕpî- · H4648
Mephi- (first part of the name) · v7, v8
In this verse the Hebrew text writes the name as two parts joined by a hyphen-like mark. The meaning of 'mephi' is uncertain. It may mean 'from the mouth of', or it may be a distorted form of an older element.
-
יְהוֹנָתָ֣ן
yĕhônātān · H3083
Jonathan ('Yahweh has given') · v7
Saul's eldest son and David's sworn friend, killed at Gilboa (1 Samuel 31). He is named first as the father, the link that brings the oath into play.
-
שְׁבֻעַ֤ת
shĕbuʿat · H7621
oath of · v7
A solemn sworn statement that calls on God as witness and as the one who will punish if it is broken. The form ties it to the next word: 'the oath of Yahweh'.
-
אֲשֶׁ֣ר
ʾăsher · H834
which, that · v7, v8
This opens a description of the oath. Hebrew leaves the verb 'was' unstated.
-
בֵּֽינֹתָ֔ם
bênōtām · H996
between them · v7
'Between them': the oath was a two-way bond, not a one-sided promise. The verse then spells out who 'them' are.
-
דָּוִ֔ד
dāwid · H1732
David · v7
Named here as the sworn party, not as 'the king'. The obligation goes back to before he was king, and it binds him now that he is.
-
וַיִּקַּח
vayyiqqaḥ · H3947
take · v8
'And he took.' The ordinary verb for taking hold of something or someone. With people as its object it often means seizing or removing them by authority. The form continues the story straight on from v. 7: David spared one Mephibosheth and took these men.
-
אֶת־
ʾet · H853
[object marker] · v8
An untranslatable particle that marks a definite direct object. Here it points to the first group, the two sons.
-
שְׁנֵי
shənê · H8147
two · v8
'The two of.' The count matters because the Gibeonites asked for exactly seven (v. 6): two sons plus five grandsons.
-
רִצְפָּה
Ritspāh · H7532
-
בַת־
vat · H1323
daughter · v8
'Daughter of.' This is the normal way to identify a woman, by her father.
-
אַיָּה
ʾAyyāh · H345
Aiah · v8
Rizpah's father. The name is the same as a word for a bird of prey, a kite or falcon (Lev 11:14). Nothing else is known of him.
-
יָלְדָה
yāldāh · H3205
bear, give birth · v8
'She bore.' The ordinary verb for a woman giving birth. It does not mean 'raised' or 'brought up'.
-
אַרְמֹנִי
ʾArmōnî · H764
Armoni · v8
A son of Saul by Rizpah, mentioned only here. The name may be connected with ʾarmôn, 'citadel/palace' ('palace-born'?), but that is uncertain.
-
חֲמֵשֶׁת
ḥămēshet · H2568
five · v8
'The five of.' This completes the seven the Gibeonites demanded.
-
מִיכַל
Mîkhal · H4324
Michal · v8
The traditional Hebrew text reads 'Michal', David's first wife. But 1 Sam 18:19 says Merab, Saul's older daughter, was the one married to Adriel. 2 Sam 6:23 says Michal had no child to the day of her death. Most scholars and modern translations take 'Merab' to be the original reading.
-
לְעַדְרִיאֵל
ləʿAdrîʾēl · H5741
Adriel · v8
'To Adriel.' He is the man Saul gave Merab to after first promising her to David (1 Sam 18:17–19). The name probably means 'God is my help'.
-
בַּרְזִלַּי
Barzillay · H1271
Barzillai · v8
A name built on barzel, 'iron'. He is not the same man as Barzillai the Gileadite who helped David (2 Sam 17:27; 19:31–39). The clan name that follows tells them apart.
-
הַמְּחֹלָתִי
hamMəḥōlātî · H4259
Meholathite · v8
'The Meholathite': a man from Abel-meholah in the Jordan valley, later Elisha's home town (1 Kgs 19:16). The same label is used for Adriel in 1 Sam 18:19, which is the key to identifying his wife as Merab.
-
בְּיַ֣ד
bəyad · H3027
hand; power, control · v9
'Into the hand of', meaning into the power and legal custody of. Together with the verb it is a fixed phrase for surrendering someone to another's authority.
-
הַגִּבְעֹנִ֗ים
haggiḇʿōnîm · H1393
Gibeonite · v9
The people of Gibeon, a non-Israelite (Hivite/Amorite) enclave protected by an oath Israel swore to them in Joshua's day (Josh 9). They are the injured party, so they carry out the sentence.
-
בָּהָר֙
bāhār · H2022
mountain, hill · v9
'On the mountain', the definite one, probably the hill shrine at or near Gibeon (compare 'the great high place' at Gibeon, 1 Kgs 3:4). It is a raised, visible, sacred spot.
-
לִפְנֵ֣י
lip̄nê · H6440
before, in front of (lit. 'to the face of') · v9
'Before the face of', meaning in the presence of the deity at a sanctuary. The execution is presented to Yahweh as the god who witnessed the broken oath.
-
וַיִּפְּל֥וּ
wayyippəlû · H5307
fall · v9
'And they fell', the ordinary Hebrew idiom for dying a violent death (as in battle). It is a plain statement that they died.
-
יָ֑חַד
yāḥad · H3162
together, at once · v9
'Together', all at the same time and in one act. It stresses that the whole required number died at once.
-
וְהֵ֨מָּה
wəhēmmâ · H1992
and they · v9
An emphatic 'and as for them'. It opens a closing note giving the date, which shifts the narrative from the event to its timing.
-
הֻמְת֜וּ
humtû · H4191
die; (passive causative) be put to death · v9
'They were put to death.' The form is the legal one used for judicial execution (as in the law's 'he shall surely be put to death'). It marks the killing as a sentence carried out, not a murder.
-
בִּימֵ֤י
bîmê · H3117
day(s) · v9
'In the days of', a season or period rather than one exact date.
-
קָצִיר֙
qāṣîr · H7105
harvest, reaping · v9
'Harvest', the spring reaping season. The date matters because the land had been in famine for three years (v. 1).
-
בָּרִ֣אשֹׁנִ֔ים
bāriʾšōnîm · H7223
first · v9
'In the first (days)', the very start of the harvest season.
-
בִּתְחִלַּ֖ת
biṯḥillat · H8462
beginning · v9
'At the beginning of'. The narrator restates the timing a second, more exact way.
-
שְׂעֹרִֽים׃
śəʿōrîm · H8184
barley · v9
'Barley', the first grain to ripen in Israel, around March-April (the Passover season). This dates the executions to early spring, which sets up Rizpah's long vigil in v. 10.
The world behind it
The broken treaty. In Joshua 9 the Gibeonites, a non-Israelite people in the hills north of Jerusalem, tricked Israel into a sworn treaty of protection. Even after the trick came out, Israel's leaders held that the oath "by the LORD, the God of Israel" could not be broken (Josh 9:18–20). 2 Samuel 21:2 says Saul, "in his zeal for Israel and Judah," tried to destroy them anyway. This incident is not narrated elsewhere.
Famine as a sign of bloodguilt. A three-year famine leads David to "seek the face of the LORD." He is told it is "because of Saul and his house of blood" (v. 1). Israel believed that innocent blood left unanswered pollutes the land itself (Num 35:33–34; compare Deut 21:1–9; Gen 4:10–12). A striking parallel from the ancient Near East is the Hittite king Mursili II's Plague Prayers (14th c. BC). They attribute a long plague to his father's breaking of a sworn treaty with Egypt and seek to make restitution to the offended gods. In both cases a broken oath brings disaster on the whole land until it is answered.
Why the Gibeonites cannot act themselves. In v. 4 they refuse silver and gold, because blood cannot be paid off with money (Num 35:31). They also say "it is not for us to put anyone to death in Israel." As non-Israelite dependents they had no standing as blood-avengers, so the king had to hand the men over.
Family as one body. Saul was dead, but his "house" continued in his descendants and was still treated as a single bearer of his guilt. Deut 24:16 forbids executing children for their fathers' crimes in ordinary courts. This case is presented as something else: a matter of covenant breach answered by God, not a routine criminal trial. The narrative does not resolve the tension, and readers have long noticed it.
Political background. After Saul's death his house remained a possible rival to David (2 Sam 2–4). The Saulide Shimei later curses David as a "man of blood" who took over "the house of Saul" (2 Sam 16:7–8). Many readers suspect this episode lies behind that accusation.
Gibeah and Gibeon. Gibeah (probably Tell el-Ful, just north of Jerusalem) was Saul's home and capital. Gibeon (el-Jib), a few miles away, was the Gibeonites' city and held a major high place (1 Kgs 3:4). Either site makes the act pointed: in Saul's town it shames his house, and in Gibeon it repays the injured city.
From the study of 2 Samuel 21:6.
Where scholars differ
in v6
What exactly does hôqîaʿ (hang/impale/expose) describe?
-
Impaling or fixing the bodies on stakes (NRSV, NJPS; many commentators).
Ancient Near Eastern practice of impaling and displaying enemies (Assyrian reliefs); later Greek renderings with verbs of fixing; the bodies stayed on display for weeks (v. 10).
-
Execution involving dislocated or broken limbs, perhaps by throwing the men down from a height.
The root means 'dislocate' in Gen 32:25. Verse 9 says 'they fell together', and the site is 'on the mountain'.
-
Exposure of the bodies to the sun after death (Septuagint; NIV 'bodies exposed').
The Septuagint's 'expose to the sun' and the parallel 'before the sun' in Num 25:4. The emphasis on the bodies left out in vv. 10–13.
in v6
Was this a human sacrifice or a judicial execution?
-
A judicial or covenant penalty carried out in God's presence, not a sacrifice.
Num 35:33 (blood cleanses blood-polluted land) and Num 25:4 (execution of the guilty 'to the LORD'). There is no altar, priest or sacrificial terminology.
-
It has sacrificial or fertility-rite overtones.
'To the LORD', the timing at the start of barley harvest (v. 9), the ending of a drought when rain comes (v. 10), and the number seven. Some scholars compare ancient Near Eastern rites to restore fertility.
in v6
Did David act from piety or political advantage?
-
David acted as a king obliged to honour Israel's sworn oath and lift the famine.
The LORD's oracle identifies the cause (v. 1). David spares Mephibosheth because of his own oath (v. 7). He later gives Saul's house honourable burial (vv. 12–14).
-
The episode also removed Saulide rivals, and the narrative may be a defence of David.
Shimei calls David a man of the 'blood of the house of Saul' (16:7–8). David agrees immediately and chooses who dies. Many scholars think the episode originally came before ch. 9 and ch. 16.
in v6
Gibeah of Saul / 'the chosen of the LORD' or Gibeon / 'the mountain of the LORD'?
-
Keep the Hebrew: Gibeah, Saul's town, with Saul ironically titled 'the LORD's chosen'.
The Hebrew reading is the harder and pointed one. It recalls 1 Sam 10:24, and all Hebrew manuscripts have it.
-
Restore 'Gibeon, on the mountain of the LORD'.
The Septuagint's 'Gibeon', v. 9's 'on the mountain before the LORD', the one-consonant difference between the readings, and Gibeon's great high place.
in v7
Does handing over seven of Saul's descendants break David's earlier oath to Saul?
-
Yes, or at least it is in tension with that oath. The narrator's stress on keeping the oath to Jonathan partly covers the problem.
In 1 Samuel 24:21–22 David swears to Saul that he will not cut off Saul's offspring or wipe out his name. Seven of Saul's descendants are handed over here. Some critical commentators (e.g. P. Kyle McCarter Jr., Anchor Bible) read chs. 9 and 21 as a defence of David against exactly this charge.
-
No. The oath to Saul promised that his line would not be wiped out completely, and it was not.
Jonathan's line survives through Mephibosheth and Mica (2 Samuel 9:12; 1 Chronicles 8:34–40). On this view the handing over is a judicial answer to Saul's own bloodguilt, ordered through Yahweh's oracle (21:1), not David's private revenge.
in v7
Did this episode happen before or after David took Mephibosheth to his table (2 Samuel 9)?
-
Before chapter 9.
David's question in 9:1, 'Is there still anyone left of the house of Saul?', reads naturally after most of Saul's male descendants have been killed. Shimei's accusation about 'the blood of the house of Saul' (16:7–8) also fits best if this event had already happened. Chapters 21–24 are an appendix arranged by theme, not by date.
-
After chapter 9.
As the text now stands, 21:7 assumes the reader already knows about Mephibosheth and the oath. The famine and the Gibeonite demand could have come later in David's reign. The appendix gives no date.
in v7
Was David's sparing of Mephibosheth faithfulness to his oath, political calculation, or both?
-
Faithfulness to the oath, as the text says.
The verse gives only one reason: 'because of the oath of Yahweh'. The verb *ḥāmal* adds real pity. Elsewhere David's loyalty to Jonathan is shown as deep and personal (2 Samuel 1:26).
-
Also politically convenient.
Some historians (e.g. McCarter, Baruch Halpern) note the effect: Saul's other possible heirs were removed, while a lame grandson with no power base was kept close under watch (9:13). On this reading the narrative records the event and also frames it to David's credit.
in v8
Was the original reading 'Michal' or 'Merab'?
-
'Merab' is original; 'Michal' is a scribal error (majority view).
Adriel the Meholathite was Merab's husband (1 Sam 18:19). Michal was childless (2 Sam 6:23). A few Hebrew manuscripts and Lucianic Greek manuscripts read 'Merab'. A copyist could easily substitute the more prominent daughter's name.
-
'Michal' should be kept and explained by harmonization.
It is the reading of the Masoretic Text and most witnesses, and the harder reading is often original. The Targum and the Talmud explain that Michal raised Merab's sons, and the KJV follows. Critics answer that 'bore to' (yāldāh lə-) does not naturally mean 'raised for'.
in v8
Was the handing over of Saul's descendants purely a matter of justice for Gibeon, or also politically convenient for David?
-
The narrative presents it as divinely required expiation that David carried out loyally.
The LORD names Saul's bloodguilt as the cause of the famine (21:1). The Gibeonites set the terms and refuse payment (21:4–6). David spares Jonathan's son because of his oath (21:7) and later honors Saul's bones (21:12–14).
-
The episode also removed rival heirs, and the text may be defending David against that charge.
Shimei accuses David of shedding 'the blood of the house of Saul' (16:7–8). Chapters 21–24 are not in date order, so this event may come before chapter 16. Several historians (e.g. McCarter) read parts of Samuel as defending David's rise against such accusations.
in v9
What exactly does the verb יָקַע (causative) describe?
-
Impaling or fixing the bodies on stakes
Fits ancient Near Eastern display practices (Assyrian reliefs of impaled captives) and the later Targum and Vulgate understanding of hanging or crucifixion. Adopted by NRSV and NJPS.
-
Exposure with broken or dislocated limbs
Builds on the verb's basic sense of 'dislocate' (Gen 32:25) and on the Septuagint's 'expose to the sun'. Favored by some lexicographers.
-
Throwing down from a height (the rock or mountain)
Proposed from the mention of 'the mountain' and from Arabic cognates. It is a minority view.
-
Generic public execution with exposure, method deliberately unspecified
All occurrences (Num 25:4; 2 Sam 21) stress display 'before the LORD' and under the sun more than technique. NIV and NLT take this line.
in v9
When did the rain of v. 10 fall, and how long did the bodies lie exposed?
-
The first autumn rains, about six months after the barley harvest
The normal climate pattern: rain stops in spring and returns in October-November. On this view Rizpah's vigil was extraordinarily long.
-
An unseasonal rain soon after the executions, read as a divine sign
Rain at harvest was rare and counted as a sign (1 Sam 12:17-18). v. 14 links the end of the crisis to God's response.
in v9
How should the event be understood: covenant expiation, political purge, or fertility rite?
-
Expiation of bloodguilt for a broken oath
The text's own framing (vv. 1-3, 14), Num 35:33, and the parallel in Mursili II's plague prayers.
-
Also (or instead) a politically convenient removal of Saul's heirs
Shimei's accusation of David over 'the blood of the house of Saul' (2 Sam 16:7-8). Some historians think this episode stood earlier in the story than its current position in the appendix (chs. 21-24).
-
Shaped by agricultural or fertility ritual connected to the harvest
The harvest timing, the sacred hill, and the link to rain have led some scholars to propose fertility-rite parallels. Most consider this speculative, since the text itself grounds the act in the oath and bloodguilt.
Sources
- BDB s.v. יָקַע
- HALOT s.v. יקע
- BDB s.v. בָּחִיר
- S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel (on 2 Sam 21:6)
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible 9)
- A. A. Anderson, 2 Samuel (Word Biblical Commentary 11)
- Hittite Plague Prayers of Mursili II (ANET 394–396)
- Septuagint, 2 Kingdoms 21:6, 9, 13; Vulgate, 2 Samuel 21:6
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Sam 21
- BDB s.v. חָמַל
- HALOT s.v. חמל
- HALOT s.v. שְׁבוּעָה
- BDB s.v. בַּיִן
- TWOT s.v. ḥāmal and shābaʿ
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., 'The Apology of David', JBL 99 (1980)
- Robert Alter, The David Story
- A. Malamat, 'Doctrines of Causality in Hittite and Biblical Historiography: A Parallel', Vetus Testamentum 5 (1955)
- Hittite Plague Prayers of Mursili II (trans. in Context of Scripture vol. 1)
- Baruch Halpern, David's Secret Demons
- BDB s.v. יָלַד, לָקַח, רִצְפָּה, מְפִיבֹשֶׁת
- HALOT s.v. מִיכַל, מֵרַב, אַרְמֹנִי
- Masoretic Text (BHS) and apparatus at 2 Sam 21:8
- Septuagint (Rahlfs; Lucianic/Antiochene text) at 2 Kingdoms 21:8
- Targum Jonathan to 2 Samuel 21:8
- Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 19b
- Vulgate, 2 Samuel 21:8
- S. R. Driver, Notes on the Hebrew Text and the Topography of the Books of Samuel
- P. Kyle McCarter Jr., II Samuel (Anchor Bible)
- 1 Samuel 18:17–28; 25:44; 2 Samuel 3:7; 6:23; 16:7–8; Joshua 9; Numbers 35:33
- BDB s.v. לִפְנֵי (under פָּנֶה)
- Septuagint 2 Reigns (2 Samuel) 21:6, 9 (exēliasan)
- Vulgate 2 Samuel 21:9 (crucifixerunt)
- Masoretic ketiv/qere notes, Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, 2 Sam 21:9
- Plague Prayers of Mursili II (Hittite)
- Gezer Calendar (yrḥ qṣr śʿrm)
- IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on 2 Samuel 21
Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).