Daniel Chapter 5 Read as one passage

Daniel 5:7–8

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

7The king called out for the enchanters, astrologers, and diviners to be brought in, and he said to these wise men of Babylon, “Whoever reads this inscription and tells me its interpretation will be clothed in purple and have a gold chain placed around his neck, and he will be made the third highest ruler in the kingdom.” 8So all the king’s wise men came in, but they could not read the inscription or interpret it for him.

What the first hearers heard

For Jewish listeners, especially those living under foreign empires, this verse sets up a contest they knew well from the Joseph story and Daniel 2 and 4. The mighty king of Babylon, who has just used the gold vessels from God's temple in Jerusalem as party cups (vv. 2–4), is reduced to shouting for help. The empire's whole intellectual and religious system is marched in, and its experts cannot even read the words (v. 8), let alone interpret them.

The extravagant rewards (purple, gold torque, a place at the summit of power) measure how desperate the king is and how important the sign is. They also set up the irony of the chapter's end. Daniel refuses the gifts (v. 17), receives them anyway (v. 29), and the kingdom in which he is to "rule as third" ends that same night (v. 30). The message for exiles was that real knowledge of what is coming belongs to Israel's God, who "reveals deep and hidden things" (2:22). Imperial wealth and rank, however lavish, are temporary and cannot buy that knowledge. Gentile powers have their days "numbered" by him.

From the study of Daniel 5:7.

Verse by verse

  1. 7The king called out for the enchanters, astrologers, and diviners to be brought in, and he said to these wise men of Babylon, “Whoever reads this inscription and tells me its interpretation will be clothed in purple and have a gold chain placed around his neck, and he will be made the third highest ruler in the kingdom.”

    The king is shouting, at the top of his voice, a man whose strength has just drained out of him (v. 6), for the palace specialists to be brought in: the enchanters (ritual experts in spells and exorcism), the Chaldeans (the scholar-class trained in Babylon's ancient lore of signs and stars), and the "determiners" (diviners who pronounced fates). To this whole guild of Babylon's experts he makes a public, open offer: anyone at all who can read this writing out loud and lay bare its interpretation, meaning what the sign is really saying and what it portends, will be dressed in the purple robe of royal favour, will have the gold torque of honour set around his neck, and will rule as "the third" in the kingdom. That is either third in rank after Nabonidus and his son Belshazzar, or holder of a high office called "the Third". These are the standard marks of a man raised to the top of government in one ceremony.

    In Aramaic, the king who calls out is waiting for someone who can read out: the same verb. All his loud command achieves nothing until someone else reads. The gold he offers echoes the gold temple vessels he has just profaned. And the "rule" he promises is in a kingdom that will not survive the night.

    Full study →
  2. 8So all the king’s wise men came in, but they could not read the inscription or interpret it for him.

    Then in they came, every one of the king's experts: the whole royal staff of scholars, astrologers, incantation-priests and diviners, people whose profession was reading signs. But they could not read the writing out loud, and they could not make known to the king its interpretation, the one true solution locked inside it.

    Some features of the Aramaic are lost in English:

    • Pictures in motion. The verbs are participles, which describe action as it happens: they are coming in, they are not able. We watch the procession arrive and then stall.
    • A pun on 'call' and 'read'. In verse 7 the king called out (qərāʾ) at the top of his voice and offered purple, gold and power to whoever could read (qərāʾ) the writing. Here no one can read (qərāʾ) it. The same Aramaic verb covers both. The king's shout is met with silence.
    • 'Interpretation' as decoding. The word (pəšar) means the solution of a coded message, the way a knot is untied. It is not an opinion.
    • 'Make known' as revelation language. Earlier in Daniel, the court experts could not 'make known' Nebuchadnezzar's dream, while 'the God in heaven who reveals mysteries' did (2:28). Their failure here repeats that pattern and clears the stage for Daniel.
    • 'All' is pointed. All the king's wise men came, except the one who had once been their chief (2:48), whom this court had forgotten.
    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v7

    astrologers (KJV, for the first group)

    'āšəpayyā'

    What we hear
    People who cast horoscopes from the stars.
    What they heard
    Enchanters or exorcists: Babylonian ritual specialists (Akkadian āšipu) who used spells and purification rites against evil powers.
  • in v7

    Chaldeans

    kaśdā'ê

    What we hear
    Simply an ethnic or national label: people from Chaldea / Babylon.
    What they heard
    In Daniel's court lists, a professional class of learned diviners trained in Babylonian scholarly and astrological lore. It is an occupation, not only an ethnicity.
  • in v7

    wise men

    ḥakkîmê

    What we hear
    Thoughtful sages or philosophers; people with good judgment.
    What they heard
    A guild of state-employed professional experts in divination, ritual and esoteric knowledge.
  • in v7

    scarlet (KJV)

    'argəwānā'

    What we hear
    A bright red colour.
    What they heard
    Purple: costly murex-dyed cloth, the colour of royalty and high office.
  • in v8

    wise men

    ḥakkîmîn

    What we hear
    Sages or thoughtful people with deep insight, or the Magi of the Christmas story.
    What they heard
    The king's paid professional experts in divination, astrology, incantation and scribal learning, people whose job was decoding signs.
  • in v8

    interpretation / interpret

    pəšar

    What we hear
    One possible reading or opinion about what something means.
    What they heard
    The single true solution of a hidden or coded message, 'untying' what is bound up in a sign.
Every word
  1. קָרֵ֤א

    qārē' · H7123

    to call, cry out; to read · v7, v8

    A participle: the king 'is calling out', a vivid present that puts the reader in the hall. The same verb returns later in the verse as 'reads' (yiqrēh), so the king 'cries out' for someone who can 'read out' the writing.

  2. מַלְכָּא֙

    malkā' · H4430

    king · v7, v8

    'The king', meaning Belshazzar. The Aramaic does not repeat his name here; the narrator keeps calling him by his office while he loses control of his own banquet.

  3. בְּחַ֔יִל

    bəḥayil · H2429

    strength, power; army · v7

    'With strength', meaning loudly or at the top of his voice. Coming right after verse 6, where his strength drains out of him, it reads as panic, not authority.

  4. לְהֶֽעָלָה֙

    ləhe'ālāh · H5954

    to enter; (causative) to bring in · v7, v8

    'To bring in': he orders the specialists to be summoned into the banqueting hall.

  5. לְאָ֣שְׁפַיָּ֔א

    lə'āšəpayyā' · H0826

    enchanter, incantation-priest · v7

    The āšipu-type professional: a Babylonian ritual specialist who recited spells and performed exorcisms and healing rites. He is not a stargazer.

  6. כַּשְׂדָּאֵ֖י

    kaśdā'ê · H3779

    Chaldean · v7

    In Daniel, besides naming the people of southern Babylonia, the word names a class of learned diviners trained in Babylonian scholarly lore, especially reading the heavens. Hence BSB's 'astrologers'.

  7. וְגָזְרַיָּ֑א

    wəgāzərayyā' · H1505

    to cut, decree, determine · v7

    A participle used as a noun: 'the determiners', specialists who worked out (literally 'cut' or decided) fates and omens. They were diviners of some kind; their exact method is uncertain.

  8. עָנֵ֨ה

    'ānēh · H6032

    to answer · v7

    Part of the stock Aramaic formula 'answered and said', which simply means 'spoke up'. Nobody had asked him anything.

  9. וְאָמַ֣ר׀

    wə'āmar · H0560

    to say · v7

    'And said': introduces the formal offer that follows.

  10. לְחַכִּימֵ֣י

    ləḥakkîmê · H2445

    wise; wise man · v7, v8

    'To the wise men of': the umbrella term for the whole court guild of scholar-diviners just listed. It means professional experts, not philosophers or simply sensible people.

  11. בָבֶ֗ל

    bābel · H0895

    Babylon · v7

    The capital itself. These are the most prestigious experts of the most learned city of the ancient world.

  12. דִּ֣י

    dî · H1768

    that, who, which · v7

    Here it introduces the king's actual words, much like quotation marks.

  13. כָל־

    kol- · H3606

    all, every, any · v7, v8

    'Any': the offer is open to whoever can do it, whatever his rank.

  14. אֱ֠נָשׁ

    'ĕnāš · H0606

    man, person, human being · v7

    'Any person'. The word stresses ordinary humanity, which is fitting in a chapter where human expertise fails.

  15. כְּתָבָ֣ה

    kətābāh · H3792

    writing, inscription · v7, v8

    'The writing': the words the hand wrote on the plaster wall (v. 5).

  16. דְנָ֗ה

    dənāh · H1836

    this · v7

    'This': the king is presumably pointing at the wall.

  17. וּפִשְׁרֵהּ֙

    ûpišrēh · H6591

    interpretation · v7, v8

    'And its interpretation': the technical term for decoding a sign, dream or omen. Reading the words is not enough; someone must reveal what they portend.

  18. יְחַוִּנַּ֔נִי

    yəḥawwinnanî · H2324

    to show, declare, make known · v7

    'Shows me' or 'declares to me': to set out the meaning plainly to the king.

  19. אַרְגְּוָנָ֣א

    'argəwānā' · H0711

    purple (cloth) · v7

    'The purple', with the article: the known purple robe of royal favour, dyed with costly murex-shell dye. It marked the wearer as belonging to the king's circle.

  20. יִלְבַּ֗שׁ

    yilbaš · H3848

    to put on, wear · v7

    'He shall put on' or 'wear': an investiture, a public ceremony of being dressed in honour.

  21. וְהַֽמְנִיכָ֤א

    wəhamnîkā' · H2002

    necklace, neck-chain, torque · v7

    'And the necklace': a word borrowed from Persian for a gold collar or torque, a typical Persian royal gift of honour.

  22. דַהֲבָא֙

    dahăbā' · H1722

    gold · v7

    'Gold'. Ironically, the same gold that fills the feast's sacrilegious vessels (vv. 2–4).

  23. עַֽל־

    'al- · H5922

    on, upon, over · v7

    'On': the chain will sit on his neck where everyone can see it.

  24. צַוְּארֵ֔הּ

    ṣawwə'rēh · H6676

    neck · v7

    'His neck'.

  25. וְתַלְתִּ֥י

    wətaltî · H8523A

    third; a 'third' (an official title?) · v7

    'And as third': either third in rank in the kingdom or an official title meaning something like 'triumvir' or 'chief officer'. See the studies and debates.

  26. בְמַלְכוּתָ֖א

    bəmalkûtā' · H4437

    kingdom, kingship, reign · v7

    'In the kingdom': the realm of Babylon. This is the kingdom that, by the end of the chapter, will be 'numbered', 'weighed' and handed over (vv. 26–28, 30).

  27. יִשְׁלַֽט׃

    yišlaṭ · H7981

    to rule, have authority · v7

    'He shall rule' or 'exercise authority': real governing power, not only an honorary title. The promise is hollow, because the kingdom falls that night.

  28. אֱדַ֙יִן֙

    ʾĕḏayin · H0116

    then · v8

    Daniel's Aramaic chapters use this word over and over to move the story along: 'then…'. It ties the experts' arrival straight to the king's frantic shout in verse 7.

  29. וְלָֽא־

    wəlāʾ · H3809

    and not · v8

    'And not'. The plain 'and' sets their arrival right beside their failure. In English it is naturally rendered 'but'.

  30. כָהֲלִ֤ין

    ḵāhălîn · H3546

    to be able · v8

    Another participle: '[they were] not able'. This was a lack of ability, not a lack of willingness. The same verb comes back in 5:15 for the same failure and in 5:16 for Daniel's reputed ability.

  31. לְהוֹדָעָ֥ה

    ləhôḏāʿâ · H3046

    to make known · v8

    'To make known', a causative form of 'know'. In Daniel this verb belongs to revelation. In chapter 2 it is the God of heaven who 'makes known' what is hidden (2:23, 28–29, 45).

The world behind it

The night Babylon fell (October 539 BC). Belshazzar (Akkadian Bēl-šarra-uṣur, "Bel, protect the king") was the son of Nabonidus, Babylon's last king. Babylonian sources (the Nabonidus Chronicle and the Verse Account of Nabonidus) report that Nabonidus stayed about ten years at the oasis of Tayma in Arabia and "entrusted the kingship" to Belshazzar in Babylon. So Belshazzar ruled in practice but was not the senior king. Many scholars think this explains why the highest honour he could offer was to be "third" in the kingdom.

Babylon's experts. Babylonian kings kept a large staff of scholar-diviners. Exorcists (āšipu) recited spells against evil. Diviners read the organs of sacrificed animals. Astronomer-astrologers watched the sky for omens. Huge reference collections of omens ("if X happens, then Y will follow") were their working library. An unexplained sign written by a disembodied hand on the palace wall was exactly the kind of crisis they existed to handle. Their failure in v. 8 is therefore a failure of the whole system.

Rewards of investiture. Purple dye made from murex shellfish was among the most expensive goods in the ancient world. A purple robe marked someone as belonging to the king's inner circle. Gold neck-torques and robes were classic Persian royal gifts (Herodotus 3.20; Xenophon, Anabasis 1.2.27). The pattern of robe, gold chain and promotion is the same one Pharaoh uses for Joseph in Genesis 41:42, and that Ahasuerus echoes for Mordecai (Esther 6:8–11; 8:15). Jewish listeners would hear Daniel's story as another Joseph story: an exile honoured at a foreign court for interpreting what its own wise men could not.

Why Aramaic? Daniel 2:4b–7:28 is written in Aramaic, the international language of the Babylonian and Persian empires. The court tales are told in the court's own language.

From the study of Daniel 5:7.

Where scholars differ

in v7

What does 'third' (taltî) in the kingdom mean?

  • Third in rank: after Nabonidus (the absent senior king) and Belshazzar (acting king), the highest place Belshazzar could give.

    The Nabonidus Chronicle and the Verse Account of Nabonidus show Nabonidus absent at Tayma for years, having 'entrusted the kingship' to Belshazzar. The phrase is the same in 5:16 and 5:29. Many commentators see it as an accurate historical memory.

  • An official title meaning a high officer ('the Third', like Hebrew šālîš and Akkadian šalšu/tašlīšu), with no exact numerical ranking implied.

    Hebrew šālîš ('officer') comes from 'three' but works as a title (e.g. 2 Kings 7:2). The varying forms (taltî / taltā') suggest a borrowed technical term (Montgomery; Collins, Hermeneia).

  • One of a ruling triumvirate (three top officials).

    Daniel 6:2 describes three high officials over the satraps under Darius. The Old Greek's 'third part of the kingdom' may reflect an early understanding of this kind.

in v7

Who were the 'determiners' (gāzərayyā')?

  • Astrologers who calculated fates from the stars.

    The verb 'to decree or determine' suits fixing destinies. Astrology was a major Babylonian science. ESV and others render it 'astrologers'.

  • Diviners in general, perhaps experts who read the organs of sacrificed animals.

    The root 'to cut' could point to cutting up sacrificial animals, and reading organs was the most prestigious Babylonian divination. Many versions use the neutral 'diviners' because the evidence is thin.

in v8

Why could the experts not even *read* the writing?

  • The script was ambiguous. Aramaic was written with consonants only, so the letters (mn' mn' tql prs) could be pronounced as several different words. They could see the letters but not tell which words were meant or what the string signified.

    The words Daniel reads in 5:25 are ordinary Aramaic terms for weights or measures (mina, shekel, half-mina/'divide'), as Clermont-Ganneau proposed in 1886. Daniel's interpretation exploits several possible readings of each root (counted, weighed, divided/Persia). So 'reading' here may mean choosing the right vocalization.

  • The writing was arranged or encoded in an unusual way.

    The Babylonian Talmud (Sanhedrin 22a) suggests several possibilities: the letters were written in vertical columns, or in a letter-substitution code (atbash, where the first letter of the alphabet stands for the last), or in reverse order. These are early Jewish guesses, not evidence from the text.

  • The script was supernatural or unknown, or God kept the experts from understanding it, so that only an inspired reader could decode it.

    The narrative stresses inability (kəhal) and God-given ability (5:11–16). A similar idea of withheld understanding appears in Dan 12:9–10. The text never says the script was foreign, so this view rests on how the narrative works rather than on a stated detail.

in v8

How does verse 8 relate to verse 7, where the wise men are already being addressed?

  • Verse 8 picks up the narrative again: the king's order and promise (v.7) are followed by the summary of the experts' arrival and failure.

    Hebrew and Aramaic storytelling often gives a speech first and then narrates its result. 'Then' (ʾĕḏayin) often introduces the next development in Daniel's Aramaic.

  • Verse 8 is a sign that the story was put together in stages, or it means that a wider group ('all the king's wise men') arrived after the first summons of 'the wise men of Babylon'.

    There is a slight shift from 'the wise men of Babylon' (v.7) to 'all the king's wise men' (v.8). The Old Greek of chapter 5 differs a great deal, which shows the story circulated in more than one form.

Sources
  • HALOT (Biblical Aramaic section) s.v. אָשַׁף, גְּזַר, הַמְנִיכָא, פְּשַׁר, תַּלְתִּי
  • BDB Aramaic section s.v. קְרָא, חַיִל, אַרְגְּוָן
  • J. A. Montgomery, Daniel (ICC), on 5:7
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia), on 5:7 and 5:16, 29
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (WBC), on ch. 5
  • Nabonidus Chronicle (ABC 7) and the Verse Account of Nabonidus
  • Herodotus, Histories 1.181; 3.20
  • Xenophon, Anabasis 1.2.27
  • Polybius, Histories 2.29 (maniakai, torques)
  • Genesis 41:42; Esther 6:8–11; 8:15 (investiture parallels)
  • Theodotion and Old Daniel (Greek) 5; Vulgate Daniel 5:7
  • HALOT (Aramaic section) s.v. כְּהַל, כְּתָב, פְּשַׁר, קְרָא, עֲלַל, חַכִּים
  • BDB Aramaic section s.v. פְּשַׁר, קְרָא
  • J. J. Collins, Daniel (Hermeneia), on Dan 5 and the Old Greek
  • J. E. Goldingay, Daniel (Word Biblical Commentary)
  • J. A. Montgomery, Daniel (ICC)
  • Babylonian Talmud, Sanhedrin 22a
  • Nabonidus Chronicle and Verse Account of Nabonidus (on Belshazzar)
  • C. Clermont-Ganneau (1886) on mene, tekel, peres as weights
  • Theodotion's Greek Daniel; Old Greek Daniel; Vulgate
  • Qumran Pesher Habakkuk (1QpHab) for later use of pesher

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).