Jeremiah Chapter 9 Read as one passage

Jeremiah 9:11–22

Put together from the study of each verse: what each one meant, in order, with the background, words and debates of the whole passage said once.

11“And I will make Jerusalem a heap of rubble, a haunt for jackals; and I will make the cities of Judah a desolation, without inhabitant.” 12Who is the man wise enough to understand this? To whom has the mouth of the LORD spoken, that he may explain it? Why is the land destroyed and scorched like a desert, so no one can pass through it? 13And the LORD answered, “It is because they have forsaken My law, which I set before them; they have not walked in it or obeyed My voice. 14Instead, they have followed the stubbornness of their hearts and gone after the Baals, as their fathers taught them.” 15Therefore this is what the LORD of Hosts, the God of Israel, says: “Behold, I will feed this people wormwood and give them poisoned water to drink. 16I will scatter them among the nations that neither they nor their fathers have known, and I will send a sword after them until I have finished them off.” 17This is what the LORD of Hosts says: “Take note, and summon the wailing women; send for the most skillful among them. 18Let them come quickly and take up a lament over us, that our eyes may overflow with tears, and our eyelids may gush with water. 19For the sound of wailing is heard from Zion: ‘How devastated we are! How great is our shame! For we have abandoned the land because our dwellings have been torn down.’” 20Now, O women, hear the word of the LORD. Open your ears to the word of His mouth. Teach your daughters to wail, and one another to lament. 21For death has climbed in through our windows; it has entered our fortresses to cut off the children from the streets, the young men from the town squares. 22Declare that this is what the LORD says: “The corpses of men will fall like dung upon the open field, like newly cut grain behind the reaper, with no one to gather it.”

What the first hearers heard

To Judeans in the last decades before 587 BC, this verse directly contradicted what they were sure of. Jerusalem was the city God had chosen, the place of his temple and his "dwelling," and many believed it could not fall. Here God himself says he will turn it into a rubble mound where jackals den.

Hearers would have recognised several things at once:

  • The form of a covenant curse. Cities becoming wastes and haunts of wild animals was the familiar penalty for breaking a treaty. With Leviticus 26 in the background, the message was that Israel had broken its covenant and its own sanctions were now in force.
  • God as the one acting. The verb "I will make" is repeated. Babylon would carry out the destruction, but the prophet presents it as God's judgment. In the following verses (9:12–16) he gives the reason: they abandoned God's instruction (torah) and followed the Baals.
  • Total emptiness. "Without inhabitant" meant the end of the life of the land itself: no farmers, no herds (9:10), no travellers, no townspeople. In a society where identity was bound up with land, family inheritance and the temple, it was the loss of everything.

In the flow of chapter 9, the verse comes between a lament (9:10) and a challenge (9:12: "Who is wise enough to understand this?"). It was meant to make hearers grieve and also to make them ask why, so that the disaster would be understood as judgment and not dismissed as random catastrophe.

From the study of Jeremiah 9:11.

Verse by verse

  1. 11“And I will make Jerusalem a heap of rubble, a haunt for jackals; and I will make the cities of Judah a desolation, without inhabitant.”

    The LORD himself speaks: "I will turn Jerusalem into piles of rubble, mounds of tumbled stone like the ancient ruin-heaps that dot the land, and it will become a den where jackals live, their howling filling the empty streets at night. And the towns of Judah I will turn into a waste, a ruin so complete it appals anyone who sees it, with not a single person left living there."

    Both halves of the verse use the same verb, "give/make," and in both God is the one acting. This is not presented as bad luck or merely as Babylon's aggression. The capital comes first, then the country towns: the whole kingdom, from its proud centre to its villages. The "jackals" are real wild scavenger dogs, not the "dragons" of older English. They are the creatures that move into a place after people have gone. The verse ends on emptiness: "for lack of anyone dwelling." The verse before it mourns pastures with no one passing through and no cattle lowing. The verse after asks why the land lies scorched "with no one passing through." Verse 11 sits between them as God's answer: the silence is his doing.

    Full study →
  2. 12Who is the man wise enough to understand this? To whom has the mouth of the LORD spoken, that he may explain it? Why is the land destroyed and scorched like a desert, so no one can pass through it?

    Who is truly wise, wise enough to see what is behind this? Who has actually heard the LORD speak, so that he can stand up and tell the people plainly what it means? Here is what needs explaining: why has the land died? Why has it been burned and wrecked until it looks like the empty wilderness, with not even a traveller crossing it?

    The verse is a challenge. Judah had its professional sages and its prophets, the people whose job was to read events and speak for God. Jeremiah 8:8–9 has just said that these wise men rejected the LORD's word. So the question 'Who is the wise man?' is pointed, and the expected answer is close to 'no one.' Two qualifications are named. One is insight, the ability to discern causes. The other is revelation, having been spoken to by 'the mouth of the LORD.' Having received the word also means being obliged to pass it on publicly.

    The disaster is described in heavy, covenant-laden words. The land has 'perished,' the verb Deuteronomy uses when it warns that Israel will 'perish from the good land' if it forsakes the LORD. The land is 'burned' or 'laid waste' (the Hebrew allows both). It has become 'like the wilderness,' the uninhabited back-country Israel once crossed on the way into the land (2:6). And 'no one passes through': even the roads are empty. The promised land has gone back to the wilderness Israel was rescued from. The verse sets up a question that only God can answer, and in the next verse he does: 'Because they have forsaken my instruction…'

    Full study →
  3. 13And the LORD answered, “It is because they have forsaken My law, which I set before them; they have not walked in it or obeyed My voice.

    The prophet has just asked a question nobody wants to answer: Who is wise enough to explain why the land lies ruined, burnt like a wilderness that no one passes through? Now the LORD answers it himself, and the verse could be expanded like this:

    "Here is the reason. They walked out on my teaching, the instruction I personally gave them and set right in front of their eyes. They would not listen when I spoke to them, and they would not walk the road that teaching laid out."

    There are three charges, and each one makes the others worse:

    • Desertion. The verb is the one used for abandoning a partner or ally. Leaving God's torah is the same thing as leaving God (as in Jer 2:13).
    • A gift refused. "My torah, which I gave, before their faces." "Torah" is broader than a legal code. It is a teacher's or parent's instruction, a whole way of living, and it was offered openly, the way Deuteronomy says God "set before" Israel life and death.
    • A voice ignored and a road not taken. In Hebrew, "listening to someone's voice" means heeding it, and "walking in" a teaching means living by it. The next verse finishes the picture. Israel kept walking, but after their own stubborn hearts and after the Baals. They didn't stop following; they changed masters.

    The ruin of the land is therefore not presented as bad luck or a Babylonian victory alone. It is what happens when a people breaks faith with the covenant partner who taught them how to live in that land.

    Full study →
  4. 14Instead, they have followed the stubbornness of their hearts and gone after the Baals, as their fathers taught them.”

    God set His law in front of them like a path to walk on, and they would not walk in it (verse 13). Instead, they fell in behind other masters. First, they followed the hardness of their own heart: a mind made up and set firm against Him, which in Hebrew is about will and decision, not emotion. That hardened will became their guide. Second, and as part of the same disloyalty, they fell in behind the Baals: the many local 'lords' of storm, rain and harvest, whose name also meant 'master' and 'husband'. This was not a new mistake. It was the lesson their ancestors had carefully taught them. The verb is the same one Deuteronomy uses for parents teaching God's words to their children, so the family teaching that was supposed to carry the covenant down the generations had carried down Baal worship instead. 'Walked after' is the language of loyalty, of servants following their lord. So the charge is that Judah changed lords: it chose its own stubborn will and the gods of the land over the God who had given it torah.

    Full study →
  5. 15Therefore this is what the LORD of Hosts, the God of Israel, says: “Behold, I will feed this people wormwood and give them poisoned water to drink.

    "So then, this is the word of YHWH, commander of armies, Israel's own God: Look, I am already setting the table. I am feeding them, this people, on wormwood, and I will make them drink water laced with poison."

    The verse is the sentence that follows the charge in v. 14: they walked after their own stubborn hearts and after the Baals. The language of feeding and giving drink is the language of Israel's founding story, when God fed them manna and gave them drink from the rock in the wilderness. Here the same caring host serves a meal of punishment. The food is wormwood, a desert shrub known for its sharp bitterness. The drink is "water of rosh", water made toxic by a poisonous plant. Together the two words climb from bitter to deadly. A hearer who knew Deuteronomy would also catch the fit: Moses had warned that anyone who turned to other gods would be "a root bearing poison and wormwood" (Deut 29:18). Now the people are made to eat what they themselves planted.

    "Look, I am…" with the ongoing verb form makes the threat immediate: the action is on its way, not far off. Calling them "this people" rather than "my people" adds a cold distance. The picture would also have had a hard literal edge for a city facing Babylonian siege, where food runs out and water turns foul. The poison-meal leads straight into v. 16: scattering among the nations and the sword.

    Full study →
  6. 16I will scatter them among the nations that neither they nor their fathers have known, and I will send a sword after them until I have finished them off.”

    "And I myself will scatter them, breaking them up like a flock with no shepherd, among foreign peoples they have never had anything to do with. Neither they nor any generation of their ancestors had ties with those peoples. And I will let the sword loose to chase them there and follow at their heels, until I have brought them to their end and used them up."

    The verse finishes the sentence God began in verse 15: having fed this people bitter wormwood and poisoned water, he now uproots and pursues them. Each phrase comes from the covenant curses of Leviticus 26 and Deuteronomy 28, so a Judean who knew those texts would recognise that the treaty penalties were being carried out. Leviticus 26:33 reads "I will scatter you among the nations and draw out the sword after you." Deuteronomy 28:36 and 64 speak of "a nation that neither you nor your fathers have known".

    There is a bitter fit to it. The chapter has charged that the people "do not know" the LORD (9:3, 6). Now they will be sent to peoples they do not know. Exile itself gives no safety, because the sword goes along behind them. The verse is a threat of judgment spoken at its harshest. It is followed at once by God's summons to the professional mourning women (v. 17).

    Full study →
  7. 17This is what the LORD of Hosts says: “Take note, and summon the wailing women; send for the most skillful among them.

    This is the word of YHWH, commander of the armies: "Open your eyes and understand what is happening. Send word for the women who chant the funeral dirges, and get them here. Send for the wise women, the true experts in lament, and get them here."

    The verse comes straight after God's sentence in 9:16: exile and a pursuing sword "until I have finished them off." Ordinary Judeans would have known the next step. When someone dies, you send for the keening women, trained professionals who compose and chant the formal dirge (the qinah) and lead the household in weeping. God gives that order now, while Jerusalem is still standing. Judah is to hire mourners for its own funeral.

    The wording carries an edge. Just before this, God asked, "Who is the man wise enough to understand this?" (9:12), and no one answered. Here the same two words come back. The people are told to "understand" (the verb from the same root), and the people summoned are the wise women. Judah's wise men could not read the situation. The only wisdom that fits it now belongs to women skilled in grief. The doubled "let them come" sounds like a family hurrying to bring the mourners in before the body is cold, and it leads into the next verse: "Let them hurry and raise a lament over us, so our eyes run with tears" (9:18).

    Full study →
  8. 18Let them come quickly and take up a lament over us, that our eyes may overflow with tears, and our eyelids may gush with water.

    The LORD of Hosts has just ordered: send for the mourning women, the skilled ones (v. 17). This verse says what they are to do and why. Let them hurry. There is no time, because death is already at the windows (v. 21). Let them strike up the funeral lament over us, the way mourners sing over a body laid out for burial. Here the body is the nation, still breathing but already counted as dead. The purpose of their dirge is to break open the people's own grief: so that our eyes stream down with tears and our eyelids run with water. The two halves of the verse rise in stages. Tears become water, and the eyes, which in Hebrew can also mean 'springs', become a spring breaking out. The 'us' matters. The people are not watching someone else's funeral. They are mourning themselves, using the same words for weeping that Jeremiah uses for his own grief elsewhere (13:17; 14:17).

    Full study →
  9. 19For the sound of wailing is heard from Zion: ‘How devastated we are! How great is our shame! For we have abandoned the land because our dwellings have been torn down.’”

    The verse gives the reason the mourning women must hurry (vv. 17–18). The funeral cry has already started. From Zion, the hill of the temple, the city everyone believed God would never let fall, comes the noise of formal wailing for the dead. Jeremiah describes it in the past tense ('has been heard') even though Jerusalem is still standing. He speaks of the future disaster as if it has already happened, so his hearers cannot dismiss it.

    Then we hear the mourners themselves, in the clipped, broken phrases of a funeral lament:

    "How we have been ravaged! — looted and wrecked like a city sacked by an army. We are utterly disgraced — publicly humiliated, our hopes exposed as empty before the nations. For we have left the land — the land promised to our fathers. For they have thrown down our homes" (or, as some read it, "our homes have thrown us out").

    Three 'for's are piled one on another, like a sob catching in the throat. Under the grief lies a quiet echo. The verb 'we have left/forsaken' is the same verb God used a few lines earlier: 'they have forsaken my instruction' (v. 13). The people who abandoned the LORD are now forced to abandon the land. The disaster is not random. It is what their own choice of forsaking God produces, though the mourners only voice the pain, not the confession.

    Full study →
  10. 20Now, O women, hear the word of the LORD. Open your ears to the word of His mouth. Teach your daughters to wail, and one another to lament.

    Yes — listen, you women, to what the LORD says. Let your ears take hold of the word that comes from his own mouth. Train your daughters in the keening cry of mourning, and let every woman teach her fellow woman the funeral song.

    The women spoken to are first of all the mourning women of verse 17: the "skilled" women whose job was to lead a community's grief at funerals with a set cry and a composed song. God does not just tell them to mourn. He gives them a word to take in (the verb pictures the ear grasping what is handed to it), and then tells them to pass the craft on. Mothers must train daughters, and each woman must train her neighbour, because the coming deaths will be too many for the existing mourners. The two words for what they teach are technical. The first is the keening wail, the same sound already heard rising from Zion in verse 19. The second is the qinah, the formal dirge with its limping rhythm, often beginning "How…!". Verse 21 ("Death has climbed in through our windows…") is the kind of dirge they are to learn. There is a bitter irony here. In Israel the thing parents were meant to "teach" their children was God's instruction. Now, because that instruction was abandoned (9:13), what mothers must teach their daughters is how to bury a city.

    Full study →
  11. 21For death has climbed in through our windows; it has entered our fortresses to cut off the children from the streets, the young men from the town squares.

    This is the dirge Jeremiah tells the professional mourning women to teach their daughters. Its first words picture Death as a burglar.

    Death has climbed up and in through our windows. It needed no door. It scaled the wall and slipped through the small, high, latticed openings, the one gap in a shut-up house. It has come into our strongholds. It got into the fortified great houses of the king and the nobles, the safest stone buildings in Jerusalem. Their walls and their wealth did not keep it out.

    It came with a purpose: to wipe out the little children from the lanes, so that none are left playing there, and the young men in their prime from the public squares, where the city traded, judged, gathered and talked.

    The verbs are in the past tense, as a lament speaks of a disaster already finished. The siege has not yet ended, but the dirge already mourns it. "Death" here likely covers everything a Babylonian siege brought: the sword, starvation, and the plague that bred in a crowded, cut-off city. Jeremiah elsewhere uses the same word for pestilence. The picture moves from the inside outward: windows, citadels, lanes, squares. No space is left untouched. The victims are the city's future: the youngest children and the young men who would have defended it and fathered the next generation.

    To Jeremiah's hearers the image may also have called up an old and familiar dread. Across the ancient Near East, deadly powers were imagined creeping in through windows to snatch children. Jeremiah's point is that this time the intruder is no demon but the judgment the Lord has announced.

    Full study →
  12. 22Declare that this is what the LORD says: “The corpses of men will fall like dung upon the open field, like newly cut grain behind the reaper, with no one to gather it.”

    God turns to the prophet in the middle of the mourning song: "Speak! This is the LORD's own declaration." What follows is stated as already settled: the dead bodies of the people will drop and lie on the open ground like clods of manure spread across a field. The word for "bodies" is the one used for animal carcasses. It is singular and covers everyone, so the image is one heap of humanity, children and young men included (v. 21). They lie on the surface of the field and not in it, out in the open where everyone can see them.

    Then a second picture: they lie like the rows of cut stalks a reaper leaves behind him as he moves down the field. Every farmer knew the next step. A worker always came behind the reaper to gather the stalks and carry them to the threshing floor. This time no one comes to gather. In Hebrew "gather" is also the word for gathering the dead to their family in burial. The final words therefore mean two things together: the harvest will be left to rot, and no one will bury the dead or mourn them.

    The verse is God's answer to the dirge the professional mourning women were called to sing. Death has climbed in through the windows (v. 21), and the field outside will be full of bodies that no one claims.

    Full study →

Where the English drifted

  • in v11

    a den of dragons (KJV); a habitation of dragons (YLT)

    meʿon tannim

    What we hear
    A lair of mythical, monstrous or demonic dragons, as if supernatural beasts will take over the city.
    What they heard
    A lair of jackals: ordinary wild scavenging dogs that live in abandoned ruins. They show that the city is empty of people, not that it has been invaded by monsters.
  • in v12

    desert

    midbar

    What we hear
    A sandy, barren desert like the Sahara.
    What they heard
    Uncultivated, unsettled open country (steppe, scrub, seasonal pasture), defined by having no towns or farms. It also recalls the wilderness of the exodus wanderings.
  • in v12

    the wise man

    ha'ish hechakham

    What we hear
    Any thoughtful, intelligent person.
    What they heard
    Includes that, but in Jeremiah 'the wise' are also a recognised class of royal counsellors and scribes (8:8–9; 18:18). The question puts their claimed expertise to the test.
  • in v13

    my law

    tôrātî

    What we hear
    A legal code or set of statutes, like criminal or civil law, enforced with penalties; often heard in contrast to 'grace'.
    What they heard
    'My instruction or teaching': the covenant guidance God gave Israel. It includes commands but has the feel of a parent's or teacher's direction, a way of life given as a gift ('which I gave before them').
  • in v14

    imagination of their own heart (KJV)

    šərirût libbām

    What we hear
    Their fantasies, daydreams or creative ideas, or perhaps 'whatever they imagined to be right'.
    What they heard
    The hardness or fixed stubbornness of their will: a mind set firm against God. In 1611 'imagination' could also mean a scheme or plot, which comes closer.
  • in v14

    heart

    lēb

    What we hear
    Emotions and feelings, as in 'follow your heart'.
    What they heard
    The place where a person thinks, plans and decides. 'Stubbornness of heart' describes a will that is set and closed, not feelings out of control.
  • in v15

    water of gall (KJV, YLT)

    mê-rōʾš

    What we hear
    Bile from the gall-bladder, or 'gall' meaning brazen nerve.
    What they heard
    Water made poisonous by a toxic plant (or venom). The point is that it is deadly, not only bitter.
  • in v15

    LORD of hosts

    YHWH ṣəbāʾôt

    What we hear
    'Host' as someone who entertains guests, or a vague sense of 'crowds'.
    What they heard
    YHWH as commander of armies, heavenly and earthly. In this passage that leads straight into the threat of the sword (v. 16).
  • in v16

    heathen (KJV)

    gôyim

    What we hear
    Uncivilised, irreligious or savage people; pagans in a contemptuous sense.
    What they heard
    "Nations": foreign peoples other than Israel, defined by land, rule and descent. The threat is foreignness and distance from YHWH's land, not barbarism.
  • in v17

    cunning women (KJV)

    chakhamot

    What we hear
    Sly, scheming or deceptive women.
    What they heard
    Skilled, expert women. Literally "wise women," masters of the craft of lament.
  • in v17

    wailing women / mourning women

    meqonenot

    What we hear
    Women overcome with grief, crying without control.
    What they heard
    Trained performers who composed and chanted formal funeral dirges (qinah) and led a community's lament: a recognised trade.
  • in v17

    LORD of Hosts

    YHWH tsevaʾot

    What we hear
    A ceremonial title, or vaguely "Lord of many things." Some hear the host of a gathering.
    What they heard
    YHWH, commander of the armies (heavenly and earthly).
  • in v18

    take up a wailing / lament (hired mourners)

    nāśāʾ nehî (by the meqônenôt)

    What we hear
    Paid mourners sound fake: put-on grief, 'crocodile tears', show without feeling.
    What they heard
    A respected, skilled public role. The trained women led the community in a recognised form of lament, and their performance was meant to draw out real tears from the bereaved (as this verse says).
  • in v19

    spoiled (KJV)

    shuddadnu (shadad)

    What we hear
    Pampered, overindulged, or gone bad.
    What they heard
    Plundered, ravaged, violently wrecked, as a city is looted by invaders.
  • in v19

    confounded (KJV, WEB)

    boshnu (bosh)

    What we hear
    Confused, puzzled.
    What they heard
    Publicly shamed and disgraced; let down by what one trusted.
  • in v19

    tabernacles (YLT)

    mishkenoteinu (mishkan)

    What we hear
    The sacred Tabernacle or worship tents.
    What they heard
    Ordinary homes and dwellings of the people.
  • in v20

    wailing / to wail

    nehi

    What we hear
    Uncontrolled, spontaneous, perhaps embarrassing crying.
    What they heard
    The ritual keening cry of a funeral: a known, patterned sound that could be taught and was led by skilled women.
  • in v20

    lamentation / to lament

    qinah

    What we hear
    General sorrow, regret, or complaint.
    What they heard
    A specific genre: the composed funeral song or dirge, with a characteristic rhythm, sung over the dead or over a fallen city.
  • in v21

    palaces

    ʾarmenot (ʾarmon)

    What we hear
    Grand, luxurious royal residences: wealth and ceremony.
    What they heard
    Fortified citadels or keeps of the king and nobility, the most defensible buildings in the city. The stress falls on strength, not luxury.
  • in v21

    death

    mavet

    What we hear
    An abstract event or medical outcome, the end of life.
    What they heard
    Here Death is a near-personified intruder that climbs and enters. In Jeremiah the word can also specifically mean plague, so siege-time pestilence is likely part of what is meant.
  • in v22

    as the handful after the harvestman (KJV)

    kəʿāmîr mēʾaḥărê haqqōṣēr

    What we hear
    "A handful" sounds like a small number, a few leftover bits behind the harvest.
    What they heard
    The cut swaths of grain the reaper drops behind him in rows as he works. The picture is of many bodies, laid out field-wide, waiting for a gatherer who never comes.
Every word
  1. וְנָתַתִּ֧י

    venatatti · H5414

    give, put, make · v11, v13

    'And I will make/turn into.' Natan with 'into' (le-) means to turn something into something else. The speaker is YHWH. The form is a promise about the future, and it carries on from the threats in the verses before.

  2. אֶת־

    et- · H0853

    object marker · v11, v12, v13, v15, v16

    This word is not translated. It marks Jerusalem as what the verb acts on.

  3. יְרוּשָׁלִַ֛ם

    yerushalaim · H3389

    Jerusalem · v11

    The capital and the temple city, the place Judah believed God would never let fall (compare Jeremiah 7:4). Naming it first makes the threat as hard-hitting as possible.

  4. לְגַלִּ֖ים

    legallim · H1530

    heap, pile (of stones) · v11

    'Into heaps.' This means mounds of rubble where a city used to stand. The word is plural, so the picture is a field of tumbled stone piles.

  5. מְע֣וֹן

    meʿon · H4583

    dwelling, lair, den · v11

    'A lair of.' The word can mean any dwelling: an animal's den, a human home, or even God's holy dwelling. Here it means a den for wild scavengers.

  6. תַּנִּ֑ים

    tannim · H8577

    jackal · v11

    'Jackals.' These are scavenging wild dogs whose howling at night was linked with abandoned ruins. They are not dragons.

  7. עָרֵ֧י

    ʿarei · H5892

    cities, towns · v11

    'The cities of.' This means the walled towns of the countryside. The judgment spreads from the capital to the whole kingdom.

  8. יְהוּדָ֛ה

    yehudah · H3063

    Judah · v11

    The southern kingdom, all that was left of Israel after Samaria fell in 722 BC.

  9. שְׁמָמָ֖ה

    shemamah · H8077

    desolation, waste · v11

    'A desolation.' This is land laid waste and emptied. The root (shamem) also means to be appalled, so the word suggests a ruin that horrifies anyone who sees it.

  10. מִבְּלִ֖י

    mibbeli · H1097

    without, for lack of · v11, v12

    'For lack of' or 'so that there is no'. The same phrase appears in 9:10 ('no one passes through') and 9:12. The three uses tie the passage together around the idea of emptiness.

  11. יוֹשֵֽׁב׃

    yoshev · H3427

    one who sits, dwells; inhabitant · v11

    'Inhabitant,' literally 'one who sits/dwells.' The towns will have no people living in them at all. Only animals will be left.

  12. מִֽי־

    mi · H4310

    who? · v12

    Opens a challenge-question. It governs both halves of the first line: who is wise, and who has received the LORD's word. In context the question is close to rhetorical: Judah's self-styled wise men have just been exposed (8:8–9).

  13. הָאִ֤ישׁ

    ha'ish · H376

    man, person · v12

    'The man.' This is the ordinary word for a person, and the definite article makes it a type: 'the sort of man who is truly wise.'

  14. הֶֽחָכָם֙

    hechakham · H2450

    wise · v12, v17

    'The wise one.' In Jeremiah this points at the recognised class of sages and counsellors (18:18). The question puts their competence to the test.

  15. וְיָבֵ֣ן

    veyaven · H995

    to understand, discern · v12, v17

    'So that he may understand.' The verb means discerning, seeing through to the real cause. Here the cause is why the catastrophe happened.

  16. זֹ֔את

    zot · H2063

    this · v12

    'This.' It means the whole devastation just announced in 9:10–11. The word is feminine, and the 'it' in 'declare it' points back to it.

  17. וַאֲשֶׁ֨ר

    va'asher · H834

    who, which · v12, v13, v14, v16

    'And [the one] whom.' This starts a second candidate, the person who has received revelation, next to the wise man.

  18. דִּבֶּ֧ר

    dibber · H1696

    to speak · v12, v22

    'Has spoken.' The tense describes completed speech: someone to whom God has actually said something.

  19. פִּֽי־

    pi · H6310

    mouth · v12, v20

    'The mouth of.' The idiom 'the mouth of the LORD has spoken' marks direct, authoritative speech from God (compare Isaiah 1:20; 40:5). It is the mark of a true prophet.

  20. יְהוָ֛ה

    YHWH · H3068

    the LORD (the divine name) · v12, v13, v15, v17, v20, v22

    Israel's covenant God, named personally. Only his word can explain what he himself has done to the land.

  21. אֵלָ֖יו

    elav · H413

    to, toward · v12, v17

    'To him.' It finishes the Hebrew way of saying 'whom': literally 'who … spoke to him.'

  22. וְיַגִּדָ֑הּ

    veyaggidah · H5046

    to tell, declare, make known · v12

    'So that he may declare it.' The causative form means to set something plainly in front of someone. The recipient of revelation is expected to report it publicly.

  23. עַל־

    al · H5921

    upon, on account of · v12, v13, v18, v22

    Combined with 'what,' it means 'on what grounds,' that is, 'why.' It asks for the cause.

  24. מָה֙

    mah · H4100

    what? · v12

    'What?' Together with the previous word: 'on account of what?' This is the standard form of the 'why did this happen?' question.

  25. אָבְדָ֣ה

    avedah · H6

    to perish, be lost, be ruined · v12

    'Has perished.' The land itself is pictured as dying or being lost. The word is strong enough to be used of people who die.

  26. הָאָ֔רֶץ

    ha'arets · H776

    land, earth · v12, v19

    'The land': the territory of Judah, the land promised and given under the covenant. It does not mean the whole planet.

  27. נִצְּתָ֥ה

    nitstsetah · H3341

    to be kindled, burned · v12

    'Has been burned' or 'laid waste.' Lexicons disagree about the root (see textual notes). Either way it describes a land scorched or wrecked by invasion.

  28. כַמִּדְבָּ֖ר

    khammidbar · H4057

    wilderness, steppe · v12

    'Like the wilderness.' The farmed and settled land has become like the uncultivated back-country where nobody lives.

  29. עֹבֵֽר׃

    over · H5674

    to pass over, pass through · v12

    'One passing through.' Not even travellers or caravans cross it any more. The roads are dead, which is a step beyond 'without inhabitant' in 9:11.

  30. וַיֹּ֣אמֶר

    wayyōʾmer · H0559

    and he said · v13, v15, v17

    Brings in God's own answer to the riddle of verse 12 ('Why has the land perished?'). The prophet asked who could explain it. Now the One whose mouth speaks gives the explanation himself.

  31. עָזְבָם֙

    ʿozbām · H5800A

    to leave, abandon, forsake · v13, v19

    A verb-noun with a suffix: 'their forsaking'. It names deliberate desertion, the kind of leaving one does to a partner or an ally, and it is the charge on which the whole verdict rests.

  32. תּ֣וֹרָתִ֔י

    tôrātî · H8451

    instruction, teaching, law · v13

    'My instruction': the covenant teaching God gave Israel. It holds commands, but it is framed as a teacher's or parent's guidance, a way to live. The 'my' makes it personal.

  33. לִפְנֵיהֶ֑ם

    lipnêhem · H6440G

    before (literally 'to the face of') · v13, v22

    'Before their faces': set out in plain view, the way Deuteronomy says God 'sets before' Israel life and death. No one can claim not to have known.

  34. וְלֹא־

    wəlōʾ- · H3808

    and not · v13, v16

    Starts the first of two parallel denials that spell out what 'forsaking' looked like in practice.

  35. שָׁמְע֥וּ

    šāməʿû · H8085H

    to hear, listen, heed, obey · v13, v19, v20

    'They listened.' With 'to the voice' it means listening that responds: heeding, obeying. Hebrew has no separate verb for 'obey', so to hear properly is to do.

  36. בְקוֹלִ֖י

    bəqôlî · H6963A

    voice, sound · v13, v19

    'To my voice.' The torah is not a dead text here. It is God's living voice, heard again through priests and prophets such as Jeremiah himself.

  37. הָ֥לְכוּ

    hāləkû · H1980I

    to walk, go · v13, v14

    'They walked.' Walking is the ordinary Hebrew picture for a way of life. Verse 14 turns on the same verb: they did walk, but 'after' their stubborn hearts and 'after' the Baals.

  38. בָֽהּ׃

    bāh · H9034

    in it (her) · v13

    'In it.' The suffix is feminine and points back to torah (a feminine noun). The torah is pictured as a road to walk in.

  39. אַחֲרֵ֖י

    ʾaḥărê · H310

    after, behind · v14, v16, v22

    'Walk after' means to follow someone as your master, the way a servant walks behind a lord or a worshipper follows a god in procession. Deuteronomy's warning 'do not go after other gods' uses the same words.

  40. שְׁרִר֣וּת

    šərirût · H8307

    stubbornness, hardness · v14

    It comes from a root meaning 'firm, hard'. The word describes a mind that has set itself and will not be moved. Here that hardened will is pictured as the master they follow.

  41. לִבָּ֑ם

    libbām · H3820

    their heart · v14

    In Hebrew the heart is mainly where a person thinks, plans and decides, not mainly where feelings live. 'The hardness of their heart' means a will that is closed and has made up its mind.

  42. הַבְּעָלִ֔ים

    habbəʿālîm · H1168

    the Baals · v14

    Baʿal means 'lord, owner, husband'. It was also the title of the Canaanite storm and fertility god. The plural covers the many local forms of Baal worshipped at different shrines, and perhaps foreign gods in general.

  43. לִמְּד֖וּם

    limmədûm · H3925

    they taught them · v14, v20

    This form of the verb means deliberate teaching or training. It is the same verb Deuteronomy uses for parents teaching God's words to their children. Here the teaching has been turned around: what got passed down was the Baals.

  44. אֲבוֹתָֽם׃

    ʾăbôtām · H1

    their fathers, ancestors · v14, v16

    This means the earlier generations, not only the fathers of the present generation. The guilt has built up over generations, and the present generation has taken it on and continued it.

  45. לָכֵ֗ן

    lākēn · H3651

    therefore · v15

    The standard hinge in a prophet's judgment speech. It turns from the charge (v. 14: they followed their stubborn hearts and the Baals) to the sentence. What follows is presented as the result of what came before.

  46. כֹּֽה־

    kōh · H3541

    thus, so · v15, v17, v22

    Part of the messenger formula 'thus says…'. A royal herald used the same wording to deliver a king's words exactly.

  47. צְבָאוֹת֙

    ṣəbāʾôt · H6635

    armies, hosts · v15, v17

    'Of armies': YHWH as commander of the heavenly forces, and here of the earthly ones too. In Jeremiah the title often comes before a sentence of military disaster (see v. 16, 'I will send a sword after them').

  48. אֱלֹהֵ֣י

    ʾĕlōhê · H430

    God of · v15

    'God of Israel': the speaker is the people's own covenant God, not a foreign power. That makes the sentence a judgment from inside the relationship.

  49. יִשְׂרָאֵ֔ל

    yiśrāʾēl · H3478

    Israel · v15

    The covenant people as a whole. In Jeremiah's day this means Judah and Jerusalem, the part of Israel that was left.

  50. הִנְנִ֧י

    hinnî · H2005

    behold, here I am · v15

    'Look, I…' Joined to the participle that follows, it announces an action about to happen, and it puts God in the foreground as the one doing it.

  51. מַאֲכִילָ֛ם

    maʾăkîlām · H398

    to cause to eat, feed · v15

    'Making them eat / feeding them': the action is pictured as already starting. The same verb describes God feeding Israel manna in the wilderness (Deut 8:3, 16), so the provider is now giving out bitterness.

  52. הָעָ֥ם

    hāʿām · H5971

    people · v15

    'The people': the covenant community, kin-group and nation together.

  53. הַזֶּ֖ה

    hazzeh · H2088

    this · v15

    'This people': in the prophets the phrase often sounds cold and distancing (compare Isa 6:9; Jer 6:19). God does not say 'my people' here.

  54. לַֽעֲנָ֑ה

    laʿănâ · H3939

    wormwood · v15

    A shrub of the Artemisia family, proverbial for its intense bitterness. It is the 'food' served: something unbearable to eat, a picture of bitter suffering.

  55. וְהִשְׁקִיתִ֖ים

    wəhišqîtîm · H8248

    to give drink · v15

    'And I will make them drink': the verb form carries on the future announced by 'here I am feeding'. It is the verb for watering people and flocks, and for God giving Israel water from the rock (Ps 78:15).

  56. מֵי־

    mê · H4325

    water(s) of · v15, v18

    'Water of…': drinking water, the most basic need for life, especially in a city under siege.

  57. רֹֽאשׁ׃

    rōʾš · H7219

    poison; a poisonous plant · v15

    A poisonous, bitter plant (perhaps hemlock or colocynth), and by extension venom. 'Water of rosh' is water made toxic: the drink that should keep them alive now harms them.

  58. וַהֲפִֽצוֹתִים֙

    wahăpîṣôtîm · H6327

    to scatter, disperse · v16

    Causative form: God himself will make them scatter, like a flock broken up or seed flung. The verb form looks ahead ("and I will scatter them"), continuing the sentence of judgment begun in v. 15.

  59. בַּגּוֹיִ֔ם

    baggôyim · H1471

    nation, people · v16

    "Among the nations": foreign peoples outside Israel. The point is ethnic and political foreignness, not moral savagery.

  60. יָֽדְע֔וּ

    yādəʿû · H3045

    to know · v16

    To know by experience or relationship. They have no history, ties or familiarity with these peoples. The same verb runs through the chapter: Judah "does not know" the LORD (9:3, 9:6), so exile among unknown peoples matches their refusal to know God.

  61. הֵ֖מָּה

    hēmmâ · H1992

    they · v16

    An emphatic "they themselves", paired with "and their fathers" to stress total unfamiliarity across generations.

  62. וְשִׁלַּחְתִּ֤י

    wəšillaḥtî · H7971

    send, send off, let loose · v16, v17

    An intensive form, "send off, let loose". The sword is pictured as an agent God dispatches on a mission. Distance from the homeland gives no escape.

  63. הַחֶ֔רֶב

    haḥereb · H2719

    sword · v16

    "The sword" with the definite article: the familiar covenant curse of war and violent death, one of Jeremiah's stock triad of sword, famine and plague.

  64. עַ֥ד

    ʿad · H5704

    until, up to · v16

    Sets the limit of the pursuit: it goes on until the goal is reached.

  65. כַּלּוֹתִ֖י

    kallôtî · H3615

    to finish, complete, consume, bring to an end · v16

    Literally "my finishing" (a verb used as a noun, with "my"). God brings the thing to its end, used of finishing a task and of using something up completely. Here it means to finish off the people under judgment.

  66. וְקִרְא֥וּ

    veqirʾu · H7121

    and call, summon · v17

    With the preposition "to" it means to send word for someone and hire them, the way a family called in mourners when someone died.

  67. לַמְקוֹנְנ֖וֹת

    lamqonenot · H6969

    women who chant dirges · v17

    "To the keening women": women whose job was to compose and chant the qinah, the formal funeral lament. The word names a skilled trade, not just people who happen to be crying.

  68. וּתְבוֹאֶ֑ינָה

    utevoʾenah · H0935

    and let them come · v17, v21

    A feminine plural wish or purpose form: "so that they come." It sounds urgent, like a family hurrying to get the mourners in.

  69. וּתְמַהֵ֕רְנָה

    ut'mahērnāh · H4116

    to hurry, hasten · v18

    An intensive verb form with a feminine plural ending: 'and let them (the women) hurry.' The subject is the professional mourning women summoned in v. 17. The urgency matters because the disaster is near: death is already 'climbing in through the windows' (v. 21).

  70. וְתִשֶּׂ֥נָה

    v'tissenāh · H5375

    to lift, raise, carry · v18

    'And let them lift up.' Here it is the standard Hebrew idiom for starting a formal lament: you 'lift' a dirge the way you raise your voice in song (compare Jer 7:29; Amos 5:1).

  71. נֶ֑הִי

    nehî · H5092

    wailing, lament, dirge · v18, v19, v20

    A spoken or sung lament for the dead, a recognised kind of mourning cry with its own style, not just shapeless sobbing. The same word comes back in vv. 19 and 20, and in Rachel's weeping in 31:15.

  72. וְתֵרַ֤דְנָה

    v'tērádnāh · H3381

    to go down, descend · v18

    'So that they may run down.' The 'and' here gives the purpose or result: the women's dirge is meant to set off the people's own weeping. In Hebrew the eyes themselves 'go down' in tears, a picture of streaming.

  73. עֵינֵ֙ינוּ֙

    ʿênênû · H5869

    eye (also spring, fountain) · v18

    'Our eyes' (a pair). The same Hebrew word also means 'spring' of water. This adds to the water imagery that runs from 9:1 ('my eyes a fountain of tears') to this verse.

  74. דִּמְעָ֔ה

    dimʿāh · H1832

    tears (collective) · v18

    Singular in form but collective in meaning: 'with tears.' Grammatically it describes what the eyes run down with. The same phrase recurs in Jer 13:17 and 14:17.

  75. וְעַפְעַפֵּ֖ינוּ

    v'ʿafʿappênû · H6079

    eyelid · v18

    'And our eyelids.' This is the poetic partner of 'eyes' in the second line. In Hebrew poetry eyelids can 'flutter' or 'gaze' (Prov 4:25; 6:4). Here they become the banks that the flood spills over.

  76. יִזְּלוּ־

    yizz'lû · H5140

    to flow, stream, trickle · v18

    'Let them stream.' The verb is used of running water, streams and floods (Exod 15:8; Ps 78:16). It raises the picture from tears to running water.

  77. כִּי

    ki · H3588A

    for, because · v19, v20, v21

    Links this verse to the call for mourning women in verses 17–18. It gives the reason the women must hurry: the wailing has already started.

  78. מִצִּיּוֹן

    mitsiyyon · H6726

    from Zion · v19

    Zion is Jerusalem, the hill of the temple and the city God was believed to protect. That makes the wailing coming from Zion especially shocking.

  79. אֵיךְ

    'eikh · H0349A

    how! · v19

    Not a question. It is the cry that opens a funeral lament, 'How...!' A longer form of the word opens the book of Lamentations (Eikhah).

  80. שֻׁדָּדְנוּ

    shuddadnu · H7703

    be devastated, plundered · v19

    'We have been ravaged.' The verb is used for violent destruction and looting by an invader. It is a stronger form of the verb, and the passive shows something done to them.

  81. בֹּשְׁנוּ

    boshnu · H0954

    be ashamed, put to shame · v19

    'We are disgraced.' This is public humiliation: their hopes fell apart and their standing was lost in front of everyone. It is not mainly an inner feeling of guilt.

  82. מְאֹד

    me'od · H3966

    very, exceedingly · v19

    Makes the shame stronger: 'utterly, deeply' disgraced.

  83. הִשְׁלִיכוּ

    hishlikhu · H7993

    throw, cast (down/out) · v19

    'They have thrown.' The Hebrew does not name who 'they' are. Either enemies threw down the houses, or the houses themselves 'threw out' the people (KJV).

  84. מִשְׁכְּנוֹתֵינוּ

    mishkenoteinu · H4908

    dwelling, tent, tabernacle · v19

    'Our dwellings', ordinary homes. The word comes from the verb 'to settle, dwell' and can call up tents, but here it does not mean the sacred Tabernacle.

  85. נָשִׁים֙

    nashim · H802

    women · v20

    In context these are first of all the professional and skilled mourning women summoned in verse 17, though the address widens to the women of the city generally.

  86. דְּבַר־

    devar · H1697

    word, matter, message · v20

    'The word of' — the spoken message of YHWH. The women are given a prophetic word to receive, not just a task.

  87. וְתִקַּ֥ח

    vetiqqach · H3947

    take, receive, accept · v20

    'And let [your ear] take.' The ear is pictured as a hand taking hold of something given. The verb is used in wisdom writing for accepting instruction (Proverbs 1:3; 2:1): the women must take this word in and keep it.

  88. אָזְנְכֶ֖ם

    ozenkhem · H241

    ear · v20

    'Your ear' — singular ear, plural 'your': the group listens as one. The ending is grammatically masculine although women are addressed, which is a common feature of Hebrew.

  89. בְנֽוֹתֵיכֶם֙

    venoteikhem · H1323

    daughters · v20

    'Your daughters' — the next generation must be trained because the existing mourners will not be enough for the number of dead.

  90. רְעוּתָ֖הּ

    reʿutah · H7468

    female companion, neighbor · v20

    'Her companion' — the feminine of the ordinary word for neighbour or fellow. Together with the previous word it means 'each woman to her fellow woman'.

  91. קִינָֽה׃

    qinah · H7015

    dirge, funeral song · v20

    A formal funeral song — a recognised poetic form, often in a distinctive 'limping' rhythm of a longer line followed by a shorter one. Verse 21 that follows reads like the opening of such a dirge.

  92. עָ֤לָה

    ʿalah · H5927G

    go up, climb · v21

    'Has come up'. Death climbs up to openings set high in walls, the way a burglar or a besieging soldier scales a wall. The past tense presents the disaster as already done, as a lament does.

  93. מָ֙וֶת֙

    mavet · H4194

    death · v21

    Death acting almost as a person: an intruder who climbs and enters. In Jeremiah the word can also mean plague specifically (Jer 15:2; 18:21), so siege-time disease may be in view along with the sword.

  94. בְּחַלּוֹנֵ֔ינוּ

    be-challoneinu · H2474

    window · v21

    'Into / through our windows'. These were small openings, often latticed and set high in house or city walls. They were the one gap in a closed building, and death gets through it.

  95. בְּאַרְמְנוֹתֵ֑ינוּ

    be-ʾarmenoteinu · H0759G

    citadel, fortified palace · v21

    'Into our strongholds'. These were the fortified great houses of the king and the elite, the strongest and safest buildings in the city. Even they are breached.

  96. לְהַכְרִ֤ית

    le-hakhrit · H3772I

    cut off, eliminate · v21

    'To cut off'. This states death's purpose: to wipe out a group so completely that it is gone from a place. With 'from' it means to empty the streets of their children, not to carry children indoors.

  97. עוֹלָל֙

    ʿolal · H5768

    young child, infant · v21

    'Child' (singular, standing for the whole group). Here it means small children old enough to be out of doors, the little ones who play in the street.

  98. מִח֔וּץ

    mi-chutz · H2351

    outside, street · v21

    'From the street / the outdoors'. This is the open lanes outside the houses, where children ran and played.

  99. בַּחוּרִ֖ים

    bachurim · H0970

    young men · v21

    Young men in their prime and of fighting age, the city's strength and its future.

  100. מֵרְחֹבֽוֹת׃

    me-rechovot · H7339

    broad place, plaza, square · v21

    'From the squares'. These were the wide open spaces, usually near the gate, where people traded, held trials, met and talked. That public life ends.

  101. נְאֻם־

    nəʾum · H5002

    utterance, declaration · v22

    A fixed prophetic term meaning "oracle" or "declaration of". It marks what follows as YHWH's own pronouncement and gives it the weight of a verdict.

  102. וְנָֽפְלָה֙

    wənāpəlâ · H5307

    and it will fall · v22

    "And it will fall." Grammatically this is a perfect with "and", which here points to the future as certain. The verb is used of people falling dead in battle. It is feminine singular to match the collective noun "corpse".

  103. נִבְלַ֣ת

    niblat · H5038

    corpse, carcass · v22

    A dead body, the word used for animal carcasses and for unburied human corpses that make people ritually unclean. It is singular but collective, so "the corpse-mass" or every corpse. It is a degrading word, not a respectful one.

  104. הָֽאָדָ֔ם

    hāʾādām · H120

    human being, humankind · v22

    "The human", meaning people in general and not just males. Men, women and the children of verse 21 all lie in the same field.

  105. כְּדֹ֖מֶן

    kədōmen · H1828

    like dung, manure · v22

    "Like dung." The picture is lumps of manure lying spread across a field. It is a stock phrase in Jeremiah for bodies left unburied (8:2; 16:4; 25:33) and is meant to shame.

  106. הַשָּׂדֶ֑ה

    haśśādeh · H7704

    field, open country · v22

    The open countryside or farm field outside the town. It is the place of sowing and harvest, and that sets up the harvest image that follows.

  107. וּכְעָמִ֛יר

    ûkəʿāmîr · H5995

    cut grain, swath of stalks · v22

    "And like cut stalks." These are the armfuls of grain lying where the sickle dropped them, not yet bound into sheaves. Here they are left lying in rows on the ground.

  108. הַקֹּצֵ֖ר

    haqqōṣēr · H7114

    the reaper · v22

    A participle, "the one reaping": a farm worker with a sickle. He is part of the comparison and is not a figure of death himself.

  109. וְאֵ֥ין

    wəʾên · H369

    and there is not · v22

    "And there is no one." It states flatly that something is absent: no one at all comes.

  110. מְאַסֵּֽף׃

    məʾassēp · H622

    one who gathers · v22

    "One gathering." This is the worker who follows the reaper to collect the stalks. The same verb is used for gathering the dead to burial ("gathered to his people"), so the line also means that no one will bury them.

The world behind it

When and where. Jeremiah prophesied in Judah from roughly 627 BC until after Babylon destroyed Jerusalem in 587/586 BC. Chapters 8–10 belong to his warnings before the fall. Babylon was the rising power, and Judah's leaders, priests and many prophets insisted that the city with God's temple could not fall (Jeremiah 7:4, "the temple of the LORD, the temple of the LORD").

Ruin mounds. Ancient Near Eastern towns were rebuilt again and again on the same spot, so destroyed cities became visible mounds (tells) of collapsed mudbrick and stone. Kings boasted of turning enemy cities into "mounds and ruins." A Judean hearing "Jerusalem into heaps" would picture the capital becoming one more lifeless hill like those already in the landscape.

Treaty-curse language. Ancient treaties ended with curses on whoever broke them, and a favourite curse was that the guilty city would become a ruin where wild animals live. The 8th-century Aramaic Sefire treaty curses the city of Arpad to become a mound where desert animals, gazelles, foxes and hares make their home. Israel's covenant with God has its own curse list (Leviticus 26:31–33; Deuteronomy 28), which includes "I will make your cities a waste… your land a desolation (shemamah)." Jeremiah's wording would have been heard as that covenant curse now coming into force.

Jackals. The golden jackal was common in the land. It scavenged on the edges of settlements and took over ruins, and its eerie night-time howling was proverbial (Micah 1:8). In prophetic poetry, "a lair of jackals" is shorthand for a place humans have abandoned for good.

Reversal later in the book. Jeremiah 51:37 says almost the same words about Babylon: "heaps, a lair of jackals… without inhabitant." The judgment Babylon brings on Jerusalem will in time fall on Babylon itself.

From the study of Jeremiah 9:11.

Where scholars differ

in v11

Who is speaking in the lament just before (9:10), and how does it relate to God's "I will make" in 9:11?

  • Jeremiah weeps in 9:10, and God answers in 9:11.

    The prophet laments in the first person elsewhere (8:18–9:1). The change to God's decree in 9:11 reads like a shift of speaker, which is common in Jeremiah's poetry.

  • God himself weeps in 9:10 and then announces the judgment in 9:11.

    The Hebrew has 'I will take up' with no marked change of speaker before 'I will make' in 9:11. Some scholars (e.g. Fretheim, Brueggemann) read the passage as God grieving over the very judgment he brings.

  • The original called on the people to lament (as the Greek has it).

    The Greek reads a plural command, 'Take up…'. Most see this as an adjustment to avoid God weeping or to smooth the change of speaker, but it is a real ancient witness.

in v12

Did Jeremiah himself compose verses 12–16, or were they added later by editors explaining the exile?

  • These verses are later prose by editors (often linked to the school behind Deuteronomy, the 'Deuteronomistic' editors), added after 586 BC to explain the catastrophe.

    They are prose following a poetic lament. Their wording ('forsaken my instruction,' 'not listened to my voice,' 'walked after the stubbornness of their heart') is typical of Deuteronomy-style editing. The question-and-answer form also appears in Deuteronomy 29 and 1 Kings 9 (e.g. McKane, Carroll).

  • The material goes back substantially to Jeremiah, who himself drew on Deuteronomy's language.

    Jeremiah came from a priestly family and lived through Josiah's reform, which centred on a Deuteronomy-like scroll, so that vocabulary would be natural for him. The wise-man theme ties in with 8:8–9 and 9:23–24 (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom).

in v12

Is the question a real call for an interpreter or an ironic rhetorical question?

  • Ironic: no human expert can answer, so God answers himself in 9:13.

    8:8–9 says the wise have rejected the LORD's word. In 9:13 the LORD, not a sage, supplies the answer.

  • A real summons for the true prophet and true wisdom to step forward, implicitly Jeremiah himself.

    The second qualification, being spoken to by 'the mouth of the LORD,' describes a true prophet. Jeremiah is the one who does go on to 'declare' the answer to the people.

in v13

What does 'my torah' refer to here: a written book (Deuteronomy / the Mosaic law) or God's instruction more broadly, including priestly and prophetic teaching?

  • A written covenant document, most likely some form of Deuteronomy.

    The phrasing here ('forsake', 'set before', 'walk in', 'obey my voice') matches Deuteronomy closely. Deuteronomy calls itself 'this torah'. The 'book of the torah' found under Josiah (2 Kgs 22) was recent history. Jer 8:8 mentions a written torah handled by scribes.

  • God's covenant instruction in a broader sense, handed down by priests and renewed through prophets.

    Jeremiah also uses torah for priestly teaching (18:18) and links it closely to God's living 'voice' through the prophets (7:23–26; 26:4–5). The parallel with 'my voice' in this verse points to ongoing spoken instruction, not only a fixed text.

in v13

Who wrote the prose of 9:12–16: Jeremiah himself or later editors in the style of Deuteronomy?

  • Later editing in the 'Deuteronomistic' style (the school of writers whose language matches Deuteronomy and the books of Kings).

    Many of Jeremiah's prose sermons share fixed phrases with Deuteronomy and Kings. Scholars such as Hyatt, Nicholson and Thiel attribute them to editors working around the time of the exile.

  • Basically Jeremiah's own words, in the prose style of his time.

    Others (e.g. Holladay, Bright, Weippert) argue that Deuteronomy's style was simply the common prose style of late 7th-century Judah, and that the prose sermons fit Jeremiah's situation and themes.

in v14

What exactly does šərirût mean: 'stubbornness' or 'imagination/thoughts'?

  • Firmness or hardness, so stubbornness (most modern lexicons and translations).

    The root š-r-r means 'firm, solid' in related languages (Aramaic and Syriac šrīr). The word always appears in contexts of refusing to listen (Jer 7:24; 11:8; Ps 81:11–12).

  • The heart's own thoughts or devisings (the Targum, some medieval Jewish commentators, the KJV).

    An interpretive tradition that links the word to inner musing. The context of rejecting God's word, in favour of one's own ideas, also allows this reading.

in v14

Who are 'the Baals'?

  • The local forms of the Canaanite storm god Baal, worshipped at different shrines.

    Biblical names such as Baal-Peor and Baal-Berith, place names, and the Ugaritic texts all show Baal worshipped under many local titles.

  • A dismissive general label for all foreign gods and cults.

    Deuteronomistic writing pairs 'the Baals' with 'the Ashtaroth' as a stock phrase for idolatry in general (Judg 2:11–13; 10:6). The Septuagint's 'idols' reflects this broader reading.

in v14

Is this prose section Jeremiah's own words or a later editor's?

  • A prose layer added by editors steeped in Deuteronomy, explaining the exile after it happened.

    The vocabulary and question-and-answer form closely match Deuteronomy and Kings. This is the 'prose sermon' layer identified by Mowinckel, Thiel and others.

  • Jeremiah's own preaching, drawing on Deuteronomy, which he knew.

    Jeremiah's poetry uses the same themes. Deuteronomic style was the common religious language of his time, especially after Josiah's reform.

in v15

Is the poisoned meal literal (siege famine and contaminated water) or a metaphor for bitter suffering?

  • Mainly a metaphor for the bitterness of judgment and exile.

    Laʿanah and rosh are figurative in nearly every biblical use (Amos 5:7; 6:12; Prov 5:4; Deut 29:18). The same words are aimed at the false prophets in Jer 23:15, where nothing literal is in view. Verse 16 then turns to exile and the sword.

  • A metaphor rooted in real siege conditions.

    Sieges caused famine and foul water. Lamentations 3–4, written after 587, describes the city's fall with the same plant words alongside literal starvation. Jer 8:14 sets 'water of rosh' in the context of fleeing to fortified cities.

in v15

Does 'giving them bitter water to drink' allude to the ordeal for a suspected adulteress in Numbers 5?

  • Yes, a deliberate allusion: Israel, the unfaithful 'wife', is made to drink an ordeal-drink that proves her guilt.

    Jeremiah often pictures idolatry as adultery (Jer 2–3). Numbers 5 also uses the verb 'make drink' with bitter, curse-bringing water.

  • Unlikely, or at most a loose echo.

    Numbers 5 says 'waters of bitterness' (mê hammārîm), not laʿanah or rosh. The close verbal match in Jeremiah 9:15 is with Deuteronomy 29:18, not Numbers 5.

in v15

Which plant is rosh?

  • Hemlock (Conium maculatum).

    A deadly weed of fields and ditches, which fits Hos 10:4 ('springs up like rosh in the furrows').

  • Colocynth (Citrullus colocynthis) or opium poppy.

    Colocynth is intensely bitter and toxic, and it grows in the Levant. The poppy has been suggested because of rosh's identical spelling with 'head' (the seed-head). Both rest on circumstantial arguments, and lexicons such as HALOT leave the question open.

in v16

How does "until I have finished them off" fit with Jeremiah's repeated promise "I will not make a full end" (4:27; 5:10, 18; 30:11; 46:28)?

  • The "them" is the guilty generation or group being addressed, not the whole people of Israel for all time.

    Jeremiah separates judgment on specific groups (e.g., the Egypt refugees in ch. 44, the "bad figs" in ch. 24) from a surviving remnant through whom restoration comes (24:5-7; 29:10-14). Lev 26:33 uses the same scatter-and-sword curse but then adds that God will not destroy them utterly (26:44).

  • The language is deliberately absolute covenant-curse rhetoric, meant to shock and to remove false security. It is not a precise forecast of how many will survive.

    Deut 28 uses equally total language ("until you are destroyed", 28:20-24, 45, 51), and the same book still expects return after exile (Deut 30:1-5). Treaty curses in the ancient Near East were typically worded as totally as possible.

  • The "not a full end" sayings are later qualifications added as the book was edited after the exile, softening earlier oracles of total doom.

    Some critical scholars (e.g., in the tradition of McKane and Carroll) point out that 4:27b, 5:10 and 5:18 fit awkwardly with the verses around them and may come from a later layer. Others find the tension authentic to Jeremiah himself.

in v17

Are the "wailing women" and the "wise women" one group or two?

  • One group described twice (poetic parallelism): the keeners are the "wise" ones because lament is their skill.

    Hebrew poetry regularly says the same thing twice in matching lines. Here the lines use matching verbs (call / send) and the same ending (let them come). BSB and NIV, with "most skillful of them," follow this reading.

  • A step up: first ordinary mourners, then the most expert lament-composers.

    Chakham elsewhere marks real specialist expertise (Ex 35:25; 2 Sam 14:2), and Amos 5:16 singles out "those skilled in lamentation" as a group of their own.

in v17

Is "Consider" (hitbonenu) part of the original text?

  • A secondary addition or a misplaced word.

    It appears to be missing from the Old Greek. It also makes the line metrically heavy, and the line reads smoothly without it.

  • Original and deliberate.

    It shares a root with 9:12 ("wise enough to understand"), and the verse plays on "wise" in its second half. Jeremiah uses the same imperative elsewhere (2:10). All Hebrew witnesses have it.

in v18

Whose voice is in the 'us'?

  • The community of Judah speaks. They are the ones mourned and the ones mourning.

    Verse 19 continues in the people's voice ('How we are ruined! … we have left the land'). The funeral setting makes the people both corpse and bereaved.

  • The prophet, and some argue God himself, joins the lament alongside the people.

    The surrounding unit (8:18–9:3; 9:10) mixes divine and prophetic speech in weeping. 9:10 has 'I will take up weeping and wailing' using the same idiom. Scholars who stress divine grief in Jeremiah (e.g. Heschel, Fretheim) read the voices as overlapping. Others limit 'us' in this verse to the people.

in v18

Hebrew 'us' or Greek 'you'?

  • The Hebrew first person is original.

    It fits v. 19. It is the harder and more striking reading (the people mourn themselves), and the Greek change can be explained as matching the commands of v. 17.

  • The second person may reflect a different Hebrew text behind the Greek.

    The Greek Jeremiah is known to come from a distinct, shorter Hebrew edition, so its differences cannot automatically be treated as translator's changes.

in v19

Who or what 'has thrown' in the last clause?

  • An unnamed 'they' (the invaders) threw down our dwellings.

    The most natural grammar: a third-person plural verb with no stated subject often means 'people' or 'they', with 'our dwellings' as the object. Followed by ESV, NASB, WEB, YLT, and most commentators.

  • Our dwellings have cast us out.

    KJV reading; matches the idea of the land expelling its people (Lev 18:25, 28). But it needs an implied object ('us'), and the noun is feminine plural while the verb is common plural, which is possible but not decisive.

  • The text should be read as first person: 'we have cast away / been cast from our dwellings'.

    Supported by the Septuagint's first-person verb and by the first-person verbs earlier in the lament. It requires changing the Hebrew text, which most translators avoid.

in v19

Is the lament prediction or reflection on events already happening?

  • Prophetic anticipation before 586 BC.

    Verses 17–18 call mourners to come, which suggests the disaster has not yet arrived; the past tenses describe the future as certain.

  • It reflects the deportation of 597 BC or later editing after 586.

    The specific mention of leaving the land and ruined homes fits real exile; some scholars think Jeremiah's oracles were shaped further after the fall.

in v20

Who is speaking in verses 19–21, and is verse 21 the content of the dirge?

  • Verse 20 is the prophet relaying God's word to the women, and verse 21 is the sample dirge they are to teach.

    Verse 21 opens 'For death has climbed…', reads like a funeral song, and fits the instruction to teach a qinah. Many commentators (e.g. Holladay, Lundbom) read it this way.

  • Verse 21 is the prophet's own continuing speech explaining why mourning is needed, not the quoted dirge.

    The 'for' (ki) can be read as giving a reason, and verse 22 (Hebrew 21) returns explicitly to 'Thus says the LORD', so the speaking voices are hard to separate.

in v20

How does the opening כִּי function?

  • Emphatic 'Yes / Now / Indeed', introducing a fresh command.

    It stands before an imperative, where 'because' reads awkwardly; BSB 'Now' and KJV 'Yet' reflect this.

  • Causal 'For', linking back to verses 17–19.

    The ki-clauses in verses 19 and 21 are causal, and the call for mourning women in verse 17 provides a natural antecedent.

in v21

Does the image of Death entering through the window draw on a specific ancient Near Eastern tradition?

  • It echoes the Mesopotamian child-killing demoness Lamashtu.

    Shalom Paul (Biblica 49, 1968) pointed to Akkadian incantations in which Lamashtu slips in through windows and doors and seizes infants. This matches the verse's focus on young children (ʿolal) and on entry through windows.

  • It echoes the Ugaritic myth of Baal and Mot (Death).

    Umberto Cassuto and others linked it to the Baal Cycle (KTU 1.4 v–vii), where Baal at first refuses to have a window in his palace. Some read this as a fear of hostile powers, possibly Mot, entering. Critics note that the Ugaritic text never actually says Mot comes through the window, so the link is uncertain.

  • It is simply vivid poetry drawn from siege warfare, with no specific myth behind it.

    Joel 2:9 uses the same verbs ('go up', 'come in through the windows like a thief') for an invading locust army. The siege setting, and the parallels in Lamentations and Deut 32:25, explain the image without any myth.

in v21

What kind of 'death' is meant: the sword, or plague?

  • Death in general, especially killing by the invading army.

    Verse 22 describes corpses falling like dung on the open field, which suggests slaughter. Deut 32:25 and Lam 1:20 speak of the sword bereaving 'outside'.

  • Pestilence specifically, or as a major part of it.

    In Jeremiah, mavet stands for plague in the triad with sword and famine (Jer 15:2; 18:21). Disease spreading through a besieged city would 'enter' every house regardless of its walls.

in v22

Is the opening "Speak, thus declares the LORD" original?

  • It is original. The prophet is ordered to break into the lament with a direct oracle.

    It is the Masoretic text as transmitted. Sudden changes of speaker are typical of Jeremiah's poetry, and the formula marks the shift from the women's song to YHWH's verdict.

  • It is a later addition or a corruption.

    The Septuagint seems to lack it. The pairing kōh nəʾum is almost unknown elsewhere. The verse reads smoothly as a continuation of v. 21 without it.

  • Read deber, "plague", instead of dabbēr, "speak".

    Same consonants. Jeremiah often pairs sword, famine and plague (e.g. 14:12; 21:7), and "plague" would continue "death" from v. 21. There is no manuscript that reads this way, so it remains a conjecture.

in v22

Do vv. 21–22 belong to the women's dirge or form a separate saying?

  • Verses 21–22 are the content of the lament the women are to teach (v. 20).

    "For death has climbed…" follows directly on the instruction to teach a lament. The style is that of the qînâ (funeral lament).

  • Verse 22 is a separate divine word added to the lament.

    The new speech formula and the switch from "our windows" (first person) to third-person description suggest a different voice.

Sources
  • HALOT s.v. תַּן, תַּנִּין, גַּל, מָעוֹן, שְׁמָמָה
  • BDB s.v. תַּן; גַּל; שָׁמֵם
  • Septuagint (Rahlfs) Jeremiah 9:10
  • Vulgate Jeremiah 9:11
  • Sefire Treaty I A (Aramaic treaty curses), as discussed in Hillers, Treaty-Curses and the Old Testament Prophets
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jeremiah 9
  • BDB s.v. חָכָם, בִּין, נָגַד, אָבַד, יָצַת, מִדְבָּר
  • HALOT s.v. יצת, נצה, מִדְבָּר
  • Burke O. Long, "Two Question and Answer Schemata in the Prophets," JBL 90 (1971)
  • W. McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC)
  • J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 9:11; Vulgate, Jeremiah 9:12
  • BDB s.v. תּוֹרָה, עָזַב, שָׁמַע, הָלַךְ, נָתַן
  • HALOT s.v. תּוֹרָה; עזב I
  • Moshe Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (1972): treaty background and the 'why has the land been destroyed?' question-and-answer form
  • William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia, 1986), on 9:11–15
  • J. A. Thompson, The Book of Jeremiah (NICOT, 1980)
  • Rahlfs–Hanhart Septuaginta; J. Ziegler, Ieremias (Göttingen Septuagint)
  • Biblia Sacra Vulgata, Jer 9:13
  • Supplied interlinear data (lemma, Strong's, morphology) and BSB, KJV, WEB, YLT texts
  • BDB s.v. שְׁרִירוּת, שָׁרַר
  • HALOT s.v. שְׁרִירוּת
  • HALOT s.v. בַּעַל
  • BDB s.v. לָמַד (piel)
  • Weinfeld, Deuteronomy and the Deuteronomic School (on the 'why has this happened' question form and the Ashurbanipal parallel)
  • Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia)
  • Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible)
  • Septuagint Jeremiah 9:13 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate Jeremiah 9:14
  • HALOT s.v. לַעֲנָה; s.v. רֹאשׁ II
  • BDB s.v. לַעֲנָה; s.v. רֹאשׁ
  • BDB s.v. אָכַל (Hiphil); s.v. שָׁקָה
  • Deut 29:17–18; 28:64; 8:3, 16; Lam 3:15, 19; Jer 8:14; 23:15; Amos 5:7; 6:12; Hos 10:4; Num 5
  • Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia (Jer 9:14 MT)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 9:14 (Göttingen ed. Ziegler; wording to be verified)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 9:15
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 9
  • Zohary, Plants of the Bible (identification of wormwood and rosh)
  • BDB s.v. פּוּץ, ידע, כלה, חֶרֶב, גּוֹי
  • HALOT s.v. פוץ hif.; כלה pi.
  • Leviticus 26:33, 44; Deuteronomy 4:27; 28:36, 64 (covenant-curse parallels)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 9:15 (Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 9:16
  • HALOT s.v. קין (polel), בין (hitpolel), חָכָם
  • BDB s.v. קִין, חָכָם, צָבָא
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 9:16–21
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible), on 9:16–21
  • KTU 1.19 IV (Ugaritic Aqhat epic: mourning women in Danel's house)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 9:17–21
  • Septuagint Jeremiah 9:16 (Göttingen/Rahlfs)
  • Vulgate Jeremiah 9:17
  • BDB s.v. נְהִי, נָשָׂא, נָזַל, עַפְעַף
  • HALOT s.v. נְהִי; נזל
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 9:17–21 (professional mourners)
  • Ugaritic Aqhat epic (KTU 1.19), mourning women
  • A. J. Heschel, The Prophets; T. Fretheim, The Suffering of God (on divine lament in Jeremiah)
  • BDB s.v. נְהִי, שָׁדַד, בּוֹשׁ, עָזַב, שָׁלַךְ, מִשְׁכָּן
  • HALOT s.v. שׁדד, בושׁ, שׁלך
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 9:18 (Rahlfs)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, on Jer 9:17–22
  • HALOT s.v. קִינָה, נְהִי, רְעוּת, לָקַח
  • BDB s.v. נְהִי; קִינָה; לָמַד
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia) on 9:16–21
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible) on 9:16–21
  • U. Cassuto on Jeremiah 9:20 [Eng. 9:21] and the Ugaritic Baal cycle (window episode)
  • IVP Bible Background Commentary: Old Testament, Jeremiah 9:17–21 (professional mourners)
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 9:19
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 9:20
  • BDB s.v. מָוֶת, חַלּוֹן, אַרְמוֹן, עוֹלֵל, רְחוֹב
  • HALOT s.v. אַרְמוֹן; כָּרַת (hiphil)
  • Shalom M. Paul, "Cuneiform Light on Jer 9,20", Biblica 49 (1968) 373–376
  • U. Cassuto, The Goddess Anath / Biblical and Oriental Studies (on the Baal palace window, KTU 1.4)
  • W. L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on Jer 9:16–21
  • J. R. Lundbom, Jeremiah 1–20 (Anchor Bible), on Jer 9:16–21
  • Septuagint Jer 9:20 (Rahlfs); Vulgate Jer 9:21
  • Supplied source text with lemma, Strong's and morphology data
  • HALOT s.v. עָמִיר, נְבֵלָה, דֹּמֶן
  • BDB s.v. אָסַף, נְאֻם
  • William L. Holladay, Jeremiah 1 (Hermeneia), on 9:16–21 [Heb.]
  • William McKane, Jeremiah 1–25 (ICC), on 9:21
  • Septuagint, Jeremiah 9:21 (Rahlfs-Hanhart)
  • Vulgate, Jeremiah 9:22
  • Esarhaddon's Succession Treaty (SAA 2.6), curse sections

Original-language data: STEPBible TAHOT/TAGNT (CC BY 4.0).